DSAUDIO.review || Edifier MR4 vs Presonus Eris E3.5 || sound.DEMO
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 лип 2024
- If you like my content than please consider supporting the channel here: www.buymeacoffee.com/dsaudio....
----------------------------
Follow me on:
Instagram - / digitalstereophony
Facebook - / digitalstereophony
-----------------------------
Contact me at:
digitalstereophony@gmail.com
----------------------------
Timestamps:
0:00 - Intro
0:17 - Long Night
1:16 - Man On Fire
2:25 - Deep
3:29 - Retro Wave
4:23 - Inspiring Middle East
5:37 - Mortals
6:53 - Jazz Con Cajon
7:57 - Bellissimo
9:00 - Return To The Wild
----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
-Sound recorded using pair of SE Electronics SE8 mics and Zoom H6 recorder
-Frequency measurements done in semi treated room using UMIK-1 microphone
-Levels matched using SPL meter
-All tone controls set to neutral - Наука та технологія
Buy me a coffe: www.buymeacoffee.com/dsaudio.review
Instagram - instagram.com/digitalstereophony/
Facebook - facebook.com/DigitalStereophony/
Hi there. Bro, what's sound's better in your opinion?
The one we've been all waiting for!!
DSAUDIO makes the only reliable test comparisons Ive heard. Truly professional. Thanks a lot.
Edifier MR4 sounds fuller & less harsh
I think this channel reads our minds, today I discovered these new Edifier and I was wondering how they would sound. Where can you hear a comparison? neither more nor less than in this wonderfully useful channel. Thanks for all the effort. Much appreciated.
I am surprised by the MR4, as monitors they are quite flat, although they sound a bit boxy. I understand that they have a function like normal speakers, being able to alternate between the two. That idea of being able to change the type of transduction is fantastic. I think that at the performance / flexibility / price level, the MR4 are clear winners.
I don't know MSRP of MR4 bu twhere i live right now i can find them a bit cheaper than Eris 3.5. But MR4 sounds much better to me. I have monitors at least a class better than those, but a friend of mine looking for a nice setup 2.0 for a small room on tight budget. And i guess i have a winner.
This channel is truly amazing. I bought the MR4 less than a month ago and I think it's fantastic, I'm already very fond of it since I never even owned cheap speakers.I make music and the truth is that to produce they are very clear, transparent and reliable. I want to thank you for the work you do and the contribution to the community. I also wanted to ask you what you think about on combining the MR4 with the T5 subwoofer to complete the audio spectrum. Thanks!
I doubt if that is possible. Looking for the same arrangement.
good line diagram and Impressive sound (in this price)
Holyyyyyy MR4 Another levelllllll
I bought some MR4s for black friday deals, finally got a chance yesterday to put them through their paces, wow I am really impressed with them. I've never heard the PreSonus Eris 3.5 so can't compare, but the MR4s are much better than I was expecting. Paired with a decent software EQ it's incredible how they respond across their dynamic range, so much detail in the mids, i struggle a little to get the high end sounding balanced without too much and then fatiguing my ears a little and the bass doesn't hit hard below 30hz, but I threw all different EQ profiles at them and they just do exactly what they need to. i should mention I'm only using them at a workstation and I'm using them for multimedia not sound mixing, and as they are intended for sort of near-field I don't imagine you could fill a room nicely with them, however sitting at my desk with some Norah Jones and it sounds like she's right in front of me live.
Wow, Thank you so much!!😊
I would definitely choose MR4 of the two, it's just more pleasant to listen to. The Presonus' mid-high emphasis is very annoying and unnatural, although you might get used to it quickly and not even notice it because there's nothing to compare it to. In any case, I avoid such a high-pitched sound because it is very tiring. Very cool channel!
Damn good channel. You deserve at least 1M subscribers.
such awesome channel .. hope that he will continue some day
Oh that MR4 is interesting. Wonder how the will battle with Edifier R1280T
마지막 곡에서 확 느껴지네요. 위쪽 소리는 3.5가 좋은거 같고, 낮을쪽은 mr4가 좋은거 같네요. 호불호가 워낙 갈리는 분야라 선택은 각자의 몫일듯..
Not even a fair fight. The Edifier is so much better.
& much cheaper
For video editing purpose which one is better? Edifier MR4 or Presonus Studio Monitor 0 Erise3.5
You were absolutely right, the MR4s sound a lot better. I feel that the presonus are more medium, while the MR4 sound much more complete despite the fact that there is not much difference in size. I would like to see the Edifier against the presonus 4.5 to see what happens. Greetings! 🇨🇱
I would love to see that too
Presonus much better
really>
That's a HUGE difference
Great comparison :). Im standing on choosing between MR4, E4.5, CR4/5 and tbh I don't know what to choose (unless there is a better set of monitors that I didn't hear yet). Im waiting for more comparisons in the future.
E4.5 and CR4X vs MR4 are coming soon
@@DSAUDIOreview still waiting on it
Definitely take a look at Monoprice Sv25 monitors!
Best monitors in 100-200 dll price range! And both are active
If it's within your budget range, go for Eris E5
@@postmortemritual Hey, thanks for recommendation. I was thinking about E5 but sadly the space is my issue. E4.5 is already touching the limit of how big of a monitor I can buy, sadly. Tbh I would need need more good multimedia speakers than monitors....I though that monitors is the way to go 'cuz I was thinking about creating some "home made" music and if it wouldn't work out I would be left with at least decent speakers. I was thinking about MR4, because of that switching mode(I know it wouldn't be much, but its something I guess?). So if you have Any recommendations for smaller speakers/monitors I'm all ears :)
@DSAUDIO.review Do you have plans to test the Vanatoo transparent one encore and transparent zero speakers?
Hey you should do Kali LP-6 vs RCF Ayra Pro 6
The Edifier's definitely sound clearer and deeper, overall sound quality is just almost great. The presonus sound a bit hollow, its lacking that kick of bass in every music tested.
becouse of the mic
Excellent
3.5 sounds like a tweeter that produces a little midrange
A comparison of Eris 3.5 2nd generation and Edifier MR4 would be interesting! Please present such a video
2nd gen sounds way better
Edifier more muffled, but more pleasing bass (at least on my headphones).
Are Edifiers in Monitor or music mode? As I understand from the homepage you can switch that.
Monitor mode
9:11 lmao, that beautiful ambience just disappeared when it turns to eris e3.5 haha.. Okay Edifier is my choice:)
but i think the original mix is between the 2 .... :/
Having e3.5... Thay sound very harsh on video, but in reality it's not that bad at all. They're decent enough at telling you about problems in upper mids and highs. Not in lows, but what you want from that size... however mid-bass is plesantly tight. So, trying translating what I'm hearing here... seems that edifiers are very muddy and not really a monitors by any means.
The MR4 sounds "muddy" in comparison because it has frequencies in the 200Hz - 1kHz range and high highs that's pretty much missing with the Eris 3.5. I have the Eris 4.5 as secondary monitors because it has similar problems and my mixes translate poorly as a result. It's good for multimedia listening but not for real production work. Upgraded to Genelec 8040As as my main monitors and I immediately realized how much I was missing with the Eris 4.5. PreSonus' real professional monitors starts from Eris E5 and above, I think they'd be great value monitors.
@@raykrislianggi i tried both .... i like the 3.5, i like the 4.5 ..... but i hate the sound of the Eris 5. I returned them.
I'm not really into mixing and recording. But am looking for good and clear speakers, as I listen to jazz music and play guitar, I need something clear so I can learn songs by ear. I will also sometimes record guitar and need the speakers to listen to my recordings. Nothin professional. Whats your opinion on that? And the lack o bass? Thanks!
exactly what I was thinking when I was listening to this. That the Edifiers were so muddy vs Eris.
Thank you for this
Im waiting for "Vault C6 vs Presonus E4.5"
Would like to see these against KEF LS50s
The Kef speakers (€1500,-) will blow these €100,- speakers out of the water.
I would love to hear a E3.5 with subwoofer comparison
you got the e3.5 huh? Well, the mr4 could have a subwoofer too if im not mistaken
@@santiagoberto7178 I'm thinking on getting one. The thing is they say E3.5 is good but lacks bass so it would be interesting imo
@@rodrigorocharsr3721 may i recommend you the edifier s350db? Check them out. I got them and like them a lot. The catch is that they are not studio monitors... But on the other hand they offer nice connectivity.
@@santiagoberto7178 truuuuue, the s350,360 I think a lot about them too, nice
@@rodrigorocharsr3721 mids lack not bass
Интересно послушать Edifier MR4 против Mackie mr524. Спасибо за твой труд. Мне показалось или у Edifier присутствует шум?
its actually i can mix music on any set of speaker.. and i will make it sound good on any device any platform any module out there you name it 😎
why now lots of speakers have this hollow after 8kHz ????
Man for a bedroom producer as with 130€ what would you raccomend?
Would anyone know how these presonus' perform as a soundbar alternative for watching TV?
Would any of these two good for karaoke?
May i ask you which is better in mixing/monitoring vocals and creating music between these two? I'm planning to buy a budget flat sounding monitor.Thank you in advance
Just pass by passenger here....I will opt for Presonus for mixing or creativity work because it is made for studio, Edifier have to keep music in style so they are not as focus on monitor as Presonus does.
^^+1 for Presonus as it has neutral- brighter sound sig (most professional studio mixing monitors have brighter sound sig idk why), imaging is also better in presonus.
The difference was so big that even hearing this from my iPhone I’m still able to notice a difference
Hey, so which one you recommend? I want to use for mixing
Between these two MR4 wins hands down
Pioneer DM-50d vs VM 50 maybe?
Hello, I am looking for some information or review, reviews on: Samson RXA5, RXA6, Swisonic A305, A306, Prodipe Pro 5 v3 and ESI Active 05 but there is not much on the web maybe someone has such monitors what can tell me about nixh, or maybe some comparison ?? by the way, good material, greetings.
Cant believe the timing of this video for me ^_^
Same, choosing between these 2. What would you get?
@@MackoyStudio i would get the MR4. I think they are pretty tough to beat at their pricepoint, and even a little more.
Im in a tough spot, since i already own the s350db, but those arent studio monitors.
Between the MR4 and the presonus, to me its pretty clear that the edifiers sound better. (the whites looks awesome). But as always, trust your ears.
@@santiagoberto7178 thanks man.
@@MackoyStudio no problem. Hey, if you get them, please share your experience
@@santiagoberto7178 i have two choice now, used e3.4 for half price, an mr4 new set, i can buy both, so which one do you recommend?
I prefer Pre Sonus. But Edifier is very good too.
MR4 vs R1700bt or bts plssss...
I had my eyes on the PreSonus for a long time, but then I found out about these Edifier, that are cheaper here where I live. Still can't decide.
MR4 is clearly the winner here.
more bass the better.. go for mr4
These Edifiers are excellent in terms of sound... Unfortunately, they have a little bit of a connection, but for the price, it's something that can be overlooked.
Would it be possible to make a comparison between the Presonus E4.5 vs Edifier MR4 vs Micca PB42X? Not necessarily with all three at the same time.
I agree, i just purchased them, looked at so many options and for some reason I thought these had their own DAC and a USB connection. Every other speaker I've used on the 3.5mm jack on my workstation just never sounded as nice as when they run on usb and do their own conversion, however these MR4s sound amazing even on the 3.5mm output. I have an audio interface at my other place and when i get around to bringing it back home i intend to try out the balanced inputs, I suspect will sound even cleaner if possible
a mix of the 2, would be the good rendering. Edit : a kind of proof compared to better monitors : ua-cam.com/video/YftZtzD9Wyc/v-deo.html
Presonus has grittier bass but it seems edifier has more thump but less definition. Edifier seems like there's a veil over the higher frequencies too. But the presonus seems to have no life with the jazz voices.
Will there be a iloud micro monitor vs MR4?
iloud is better
Hi, which would you recommend just to listen music?
Mr4
Weird. I can hear a small amount of hiss on the MR4 in this vid. (on Deep)
The worst is at 9:05, do they really sound that bad ?! If that is so it's is a big no go for me.
Edifier Mr4 vs Edifier s880
mr4가 약간 묵직하고 e3.5가 약간 가벼운 소리가 나네.. 왜 mr4가 더 싼거지?
TLDR: Edifier MR4
The edifiers sound amore coloured than the presonus so people here seem to think that's better but for mixing less colour equals more accurate translation. Am I wrong?
Having heard the Presonus Eris E3.5 live I would NOT recommend them to anyone, really bad sounding with no balance plus they have zero low end.
Micca rb 42 pls 🙏
Maybe MR4 w DSP, Eris w/o? MR4 has very flat frequency response
mr4가 승리네요 presonus는 하이가 더 드러나고 미들이 부족하지만 mr4는 전체적으로 균형잡힌 사운드로 들립니다 꽉 찬 느낌이에요
mr4 OTT 볼땐 어떤가요? 이걸로 비교해 보니 대사들이 좀 뭉게지지 않을까 걱정되네[요.
@@91j6 OTT는 안봐서 모르겠지만 음악을 들을때 가사나 악기선명도는 충분하고 넘칩니다
Can’t believe how misleading people’s opinions are here, clearly, the Edifiers sounded much more like the source tracks, even through my AirPods Pro….
Monitor mode vs music mode of edifier mr4?
Both monitor mode
Man, the Edifier sounds scooped in the middle...yes, Presonus lacks bass but a subwoofer fixes that and there's more clarity. You can't easily fix the lack of mids in most Edifiers...
Мне presonus нравится больше,у него более правильный звук на средних, больше ясности
I just bought MR4s and I think they are tuned more to music listeners than as monitors, however they are still plenty responsive in the mid-range with some minimal tweaking - they sound warm and alive with a decibal or 2 extra at 300hz and 1000hz. I was not expecting them to sound so nice in the middle (after eq'ing them a little).
Hi, bro. After testing my new Edifier MR4, I hear a very slight noise that comes only from the tweeters of each speaker, it is like white noise or interference and it increases when the volume of the monitors is turned up. The sound does not come from the other connected devices, since the noise is heard even when I only have the monitors connected, without plugging anything else. I have also tried it with several current outlets and the sound persists. My question is, is this noise normal? For what is this? Is it normal or the one I have was faulty? THANK YOU
Gee, you win the jackpot.
@@justinking5964 ??????
I've read some owners of MR4s are hearing the same "self-noise". It seems to be normal for these speakers. Presonus is better at this (I own a pair, no noise at all), but they have other cons as shown here and in other reviews.
Are you using the RCA connection?
82€ Eris 3.5 (sonovente website), 130€ MR4 (official website). By adding another 40€ more, I'm sure there are even better than the MR4...
In amazon spain the mr4 color White 90 euros
hahah in my country Eric is twice as expensive as Mr4
is it possible to compare the presonus eris e4 & the edifier mr4?
E4.5 vs MR4 is coming
@@DSAUDIOreview ohh, I mean e4.5 hahha.. Well I'm excited for that!😌
Edifier Good
Edifier invites you to be involved with the song, PreSonus just to hear well detailed music, not to immerse yourself into the experience. Imo
Presonus has more flat open sounding.
Presonus for work with music.
Edifier for simple people like bass
I thought that those edifiers would be better as monitors but they still have the commercial sound with an excess of bass, having had r1280t, I have already ruled out edifier forever, my best option is presonus, much more balance
This is false, presonus 3.5 is much worse in terms of balance compared to edifier mr4.
L take
Pero le puedes ajustar los graves al MR4 en la parte de atras , si no te gusta tanto grave le bajas y listo lol
mr4는 너무 통울림이야해야하나 그런게 심해서
오히려 깔끔한 e3.5가 저는 더 나은거 같네요.
쿵쿵 울리는거 좋아하시는분이거나 집안에 울려도 층간소음 걱정없는분들은
mr4가 때리는맛이 있기때문에 좋으실거 같네요
Yes, e3.5 is much more clean.
MR4 miles better than the "tweeter" eris
The PreSonus has more defined frequencies to my ears. The Edifier, despite the poorer quality, has a muddy sound with more bass but not necessarily great low-end tones. I’d go with the PreSonus for sure.
i want to upgrade my old dell ax210 to Presonus 3.5 do you recommend it?
Я полностью согласен с вами, почему другие не слышат этого
MR4 sounding a litle nasal in the last track??
yes i have the mr4 here .... and they miss something between 1kHz and 5kHz ....
Can always EQ.
Presonus has sharp highs, and lacks the lows. Edifier sounds flat which is what a monitor speaker is for. .
Presonus has clear and punchy sound good for instrumental music ..
Might as well get KEF LS50s.
For me it seems that Edifier is closer to the source
i'm agree with you, a lot of people think presonus better and clearer because they add more treble there, people forget to compare to the original track in the video .. the treble on presonus is far from the original track :D
The sound of the MR4 is much moure pronounced. The Eris 3.5 sounds a bit muffled :(
Presonus sounded clearer because of neutralish-brigter sound sig(prob. better for mixing); bass is faster and controlled; imaging is a bit better. Edifier bass is boomy and a bit loose , muffled behind the curtain sound, darker sound sig (better for just watching movies,entertainment). the thing with Edifier speakers is the poor quality control, often you loose sound of one of the either speakers because of bad quality wires, resoldering can temporarily fix it and will reoccur. Presonus would be the better choice IMO. i stay out of edifier because of its poor inconsistent quality control.
This is the reason I am buying Presonus. Quality of the materials seems better in Presonus. I also prefer the normal power switch, that MR4's long press to shut down is pain. I can get Presonus from the local store and MR4 i should order from Amazon. So many mixed reviews about these speakers, so I don't trust them and also Amazon quality varies a lot. Much less risky to get them from a local store and return them if they are not working properly. Presonus also has bluetooth option for little bit more money. I am buying these as desktop speakers and if I get annoyed of them, I can use them elsewhere because of bluetooth. At first I thought I don't need bluetooth, but actually that is a big plus when I am rethinking it. Although, I cannot say that MR4 wouldn't sound better in this video. The sound is more colorful, but at some parts I preferred Presonus. I was looking for MR4, because it was available in white color, which would be great for my setup. Then I read some Amazon reviews and someone pointed out that front of the monitor is different material and different white than sides of the speaker. That is not a good thing to begin with and discoloration is probably becoming stronger with age, because sides looked like ones which may become more yellow over time. That will be one ugly speaker. Comparing looks of this black MR4 to Presonus, I highly prefer Presonus. It has little blue details, which makes it look more unique and expensive compared to MR4.
I was confused by so many comments saying the MR4 sound better. To me, the PreSonus sound clearer and would benefit from adding the subwoofer.
@Joe Castellon true I agree with you
@@JoeCastellon true
Have you listened to both in person? I just bought the MR4s and agree they are probably better for (and intended for) multimedia and music listening rather then as a pure studio setup - on a flat EQ with the bass/treble dials in the middle they sounds a little muddy and not all that bright. However with very minimal adjustment in EQ I'm blown away with the imaging, depth and sound quality possible on them, at least for near field listening (which probably goes for the Eris' too) and they seem to be capable of reaching down nicely for a 4" driver (they supposedly have a 60hz cutoff but if I boost the eq at 30hz or even 20hz there is almost a hint of sub-bass.
presonus win
love presonus, has a more natural sound
에디파이어가 나은듯
3.5 doesn't sound like this in real life
Yep. It sounds better, though admitedly the bass is lacking. But it has a 3.5 inch speakers, so that is to be expected.
presonus win e3.5 has good resoultion in high mid
copium
I feel like the clear winner is the PreSonus but you need to add the subwoofer to make it sound as full as the MR4.
MR4 is muddy. Presonus is crispy. snare sound is much better on Presonus.
As expectet. Edifier Bass heavy with not even a touch of separation and Eris clear separation and no Bass. Now CR4 and both get roasted
Altough i liked the mr4 a lot, i find your comment pretty accurate.
MR4 1 dollar I will pay
Presonus sounded better to me
They both sound pretty shitty, but the Edifier is slightly less shitty
I guess you dont know many shitty speakers
эдифаер абсалютный мусор, если у эрисов компактный и четкий звук, а также присутствует плотность и обьема, то у пукалок эдифаер и размазанный и раздутый одновременно
edifier won, more bass
Bass is not important at all.
Presonus win !
你腦子壞了
Mr4 COPY THE ERIS 🤮🤮🤮🤮
They both sound pretty bad.
3.5가 훨좋게들리는데 mr4 좋다는 사람들 개많네 둥둥거리는게 좋은건가
e3.5는 mr4의 비교 대상이 아님.
e4.5는 데리고 와야 비교 가능.
모니터링 스피커의 역할은 소스 성향을 그대로 출력하는건데,
e3.5는 약v 성향이라서 듣기 재밌는 스피커지
모니터링 역할을 수행하기엔 역부족입니다.
presonus win