Edifier MR4 on Amazon: amzn.to/3zeJyD1 Edifier MR4 on eBay: ebay.us/P1I8JX Edifier MR4 on Edifier: edifier-usa.myshopify.com/products/edifier-mr4-ref?sca_ref=2950905.Bg8N4HhErK PreSonus Eris E3.5 on Amazon: amzn.to/3zfGlTN PreSonus Eris E3.5 on eBay: ebay.us/jVYb1Z Amazon tech deals: amzn.to/3VgqUU8 Links are affiliate links. I gain a small percentage at no cost to you if you make a purchase. This will help my channel. Thank you.
It has been done already in different channels, to save you the time, people are coming back to the 1st Gen, apparently 2nd ruined the sound for the sake of Bluetooth.
@@prodbyrt1956 I have both pairs right here, and what I can tell you is that it depends on your needs. If you want a little bit more flatness to your overall sound MR4 is the way to go, you can feel their frequency range is just bigger and better. E3.5 is definitely a multimedia/monitor speaker with a very pronounced bass/mid curve and they are, of course, way louder than MR4. Im using MR4 now, and to be honest Im not coming back. Bass is just so much better in MR4
@@fractalized3 that’s very interesting.. well I’m looking for monitors for reference mixing and music production mainly.. my room isn’t treated so I’m not very picky about the frequency response but yes it is important.. anyways it’s surprising because Eris e3.5 r more popular as a “studio monitors” and ah u say they r not as flat as MR4?? In that case ig I have to stick with MR4
@@prodbyrt1956 My man, take it from someone who has both pairs connected and active at the moment of writing this comment. MR4 are way better for flatness and studio monitoring overall, 3.5 are nice, very very nice actually, but they do indeed have a boost curve, they will serve well as monitors too, I used them for 4 years in a previous workstation. MR4 also have better stereo imaging which is quite relevant when mixing. Also take into account the 2 modes MR4 offers, "Music" which has a boost curve around the mids and "Monitor" mode which is as flat as the speakers can get. MR4 also have DPS protection, which some people like some don't, the speakers will compress or even suppress low frequencies beyond the supported threshold to prevent damage to the cone. ALSO, and very important! 3.5 have an expiry date, believe or not, everyone I know that has had them report 4 years of good use, before getting huge noises and hisses. You can also verify this through different reviews out there and reddit post of people reporting the same for some reason. I know this is too much but I also know how important and frustrating the process of picking a pair of speakers can be. Cheers! Hope this is helpful!
Well done demo. I prefer the Edifier, they would be a good choice to use connected as an output monitor for the Fractal FX3 guitar processor while recording or simply practicing.
I have the Eris 3.5 and caps bloated on 3rd year and now is not turning on. Come to find that this is common for the Eris, they fail and some pretty early on. ill be buying the Mr4 or the 1280DB from now on.
I was quite blown away by the quality of the Eris 3.5 for such a small speaker and price. Now I wish I had bought the Edifer.....anyhow, no weeping because soon I will go into much higher prices. Thanks for your clear report!
The Eris 3.5 are a piece of shit. Me and two of my friends buyed them the same week. 3 years later, my speakers and my friends ones died nearly at the same time.
@@TOON.MUSIC.503 Maybe it's because it's not built the same way, but when i compare to standard 100€ hifi speaker that can last 15 year, those ones kinda felt like a scam
i Got the Edifier mr4, i had the chance to testem back to back and i prefer MR4. it ddoesnt comparee to Yamaha hs8 that i use, but they are verry good for 30% of 1 HS8. nice video
Creo que a edilfier mr4 le hacen mucha propaganda, yo lo compre 2 veces y las 2 veces me salieron defectuosos los tuve que regresar ya no puedo confiar en edilfier 😢 quisiera haber tenido la misma buena experiencia que otras personas
If you want to choose between these 2 speakers, the MR4 is better sound wise. If you want the best sound and still a relatively affordable price, go with the Edifier R1700BTs. It is amazing. Here's a video about it here: ua-cam.com/video/EM08vN1sCM4/v-deo.html
Thanks for your review man! I will probably go for the MR4s to save money for a decent subwoofer! Since I want a 2.1 setup for more bass frequencies, I am thinking of choosing between Edifier T5 and Presonus Eris Sub 8 for my subwoofer. I'll be using my setup for listening to music from classical to very modern stuff and also for music production. Keep in mind that Eris Sub 8 is about 89usd more expensive than T5 in my country. Which one do you recommend? I appreciate your help!
Mr4 are lacking in mids while the Presonus tweeter gives a bit of clarity in mids but lacks on bass, which only subwoofer can solve the problem on presonus. In the end of the day, Mr4 are also great in terms in sound and aesthetics. We all have personal preference and use your ears. Whatever you choose between these two, still a win. Specially if you’re upgrading on a normal/generic speakers.
Lol you need to clean your ears, the mids are definitely better on the MR4 or you have no idea how to properly assess the sound. The presonus is more inclined towards the treble.
Are you serious? The Presonus is muddy in the mids at best, they aren't even comparable! This isn't even about personal preference it's about actual clarity!
Bro U do mix ur own music right any producer would tell that the mr4 has the better bass and mid range frequency while the PreSonus sounds like it has less bass and to much treble or high eq
My presonus after 3 years are done Propably i will choose now the MR4 Especialy cause i can see 2 modes Cause i mainly using them for guitar playing Do you recommend them for this usage ?
I had the R1280T so I know how it sounds. For music listening, you're better off with the R1280T, for music production, the Eris E3.5. That being said, if you can put $10 more, get the R1280TS. It is much better then both the Eris and the R1280T
Nice review sir 👍 I'm wondering if you can also do a "vs" or give feedback between the R1700xxx and the MR4. I'm really confused on which one to pick since there's no test unit in any of the stores i went to
Edifier MR4 on Amazon: amzn.to/3zeJyD1
Edifier MR4 on eBay: ebay.us/P1I8JX
Edifier MR4 on Edifier: edifier-usa.myshopify.com/products/edifier-mr4-ref?sca_ref=2950905.Bg8N4HhErK
PreSonus Eris E3.5 on Amazon: amzn.to/3zfGlTN
PreSonus Eris E3.5 on eBay: ebay.us/jVYb1Z
Amazon tech deals: amzn.to/3VgqUU8
Links are affiliate links. I gain a small percentage at no cost to you if you make a purchase. This will help my channel. Thank you.
are speakers like this a good choice for a TV instead of a sound bar?
@@spiloFTW It's better to go with the R1280 series for a TV because they have a Remote
I am so happy to have found this. I decided on these two online- and was hoping I would find a video comparing them. Thanks!
You are so welcome!
me too !
Edifiers MR4 sound so much better it's not even a competition IMO
Great review, thank you!!!
My pleasure!
Thanks I think Ill go with the Edifier MR4 I think my Fiio k3 will give it a nutch up
A comparison of Eris 3.5 2nd generation and Edifier MR4 would be interesting! Please present such a video
It has been done already in different channels, to save you the time, people are coming back to the 1st Gen, apparently 2nd ruined the sound for the sake of Bluetooth.
@@fractalized3 can u pls tell me which is better edifier mr4 or pre sonus eris e3.5 1st gen??
@@prodbyrt1956 I have both pairs right here, and what I can tell you is that it depends on your needs. If you want a little bit more flatness to your overall sound MR4 is the way to go, you can feel their frequency range is just bigger and better. E3.5 is definitely a multimedia/monitor speaker with a very pronounced bass/mid curve and they are, of course, way louder than MR4. Im using MR4 now, and to be honest Im not coming back. Bass is just so much better in MR4
@@fractalized3 that’s very interesting.. well I’m looking for monitors for reference mixing and music production mainly.. my room isn’t treated so I’m not very picky about the frequency response but yes it is important.. anyways it’s surprising because Eris e3.5 r more popular as a “studio monitors” and ah u say they r not as flat as MR4?? In that case ig I have to stick with MR4
@@prodbyrt1956 My man, take it from someone who has both pairs connected and active at the moment of writing this comment. MR4 are way better for flatness and studio monitoring overall, 3.5 are nice, very very nice actually, but they do indeed have a boost curve, they will serve well as monitors too, I used them for 4 years in a previous workstation. MR4 also have better stereo imaging which is quite relevant when mixing. Also take into account the 2 modes MR4 offers, "Music" which has a boost curve around the mids and "Monitor" mode which is as flat as the speakers can get. MR4 also have DPS protection, which some people like some don't, the speakers will compress or even suppress low frequencies beyond the supported threshold to prevent damage to the cone. ALSO, and very important! 3.5 have an expiry date, believe or not, everyone I know that has had them report 4 years of good use, before getting huge noises and hisses. You can also verify this through different reviews out there and reddit post of people reporting the same for some reason. I know this is too much but I also know how important and frustrating the process of picking a pair of speakers can be. Cheers! Hope this is helpful!
Edifier MR4 Win
@@Ares-yc8wf я русский но это точно.
Yes, MR 4 winners
Well done demo. I prefer the Edifier, they would be a good choice to use connected as an output monitor for the Fractal FX3 guitar processor while recording or simply practicing.
may i know how do you connect your mr4 to your guitar processor? is it direct via fx3 output to mr4? thanks!
@@kebsukristo5098from the outputs on my AXe FX3
Great comparison , i liked the edifiers more 💨
Presunos is better for music production flat sound
This man read my mind, I was just looking at both of these monitors, and I now know which one I will buy.
Which one you chose?
@@KnowledgeSharingTech Edifier.
Thank you very much. I was thinking about buying the presonus ones, and this video opened my eyes! Now I know better speakers at the same price! 🖤
Mr4 is better than the presonus eris e3.5 because i have used both these two in my home studio☺️☺️
Extremely informative. Thanks a lot my good sir you just made this decision way easier. MR4 it is.
Good choice
Many thanks for your review I’m looking for monitors for a small studio setup. I never considered the Edifier MR 4 until watching this
Glad I could help!
Does these speakers have Bluetooth? If not, what do I need to purchase to get them to have Bluetooth??
The eris 3.5 has bt. But I absolutely can't recommend it. It's sbc codec only
I have the Eris 3.5 and caps bloated on 3rd year and now is not turning on. Come to find that this is common for the Eris, they fail and some pretty early on. ill be buying the Mr4 or the 1280DB from now on.
Yes, much better Edifier MR 4 !
cool stuff bro, thanks for the review
You bet
Edifier MR4 are better!!
Thank you man, this is the exact comparison I was looking for. MR4 takes it handily!
Glad I could help!
Very good video. thx!
Unless I have tin for ears, the Edifier MR4 are "clearly" the winner! :)
How does the Eris E3.5 2nd gen compare to the MR4?
I was quite blown away by the quality of the Eris 3.5 for such a small speaker and price. Now I wish I had bought the Edifer.....anyhow, no weeping because soon I will go into much higher prices. Thanks for your clear report!
Then you can start aiming at Adams
The Eris 3.5 are a piece of shit. Me and two of my friends buyed them the same week. 3 years later, my speakers and my friends ones died nearly at the same time.
@@yanthetrooper67 3 years for 100 dollar speakers is amazing
@@TOON.MUSIC.503 Maybe it's because it's not built the same way, but when i compare to standard 100€ hifi speaker that can last 15 year, those ones kinda felt like a scam
@@yanthetrooper67 I just watch this video because my Eris just died after 3.5 years as well. But I really liked them 😞
i Got the Edifier mr4, i had the chance to testem back to back and i prefer MR4. it ddoesnt comparee to Yamaha hs8 that i use, but they are verry good for 30% of 1 HS8. nice video
Thanks for sharing!
DUDE! I have a pair of $800 Yammy HS8s for my recording studio, these are for a glorified kitchen, apples to orangutangs...
Excellent review.
Very indepth, great explanations that were easy to follow.
I have purchased the Edifier MR4 in white.
Thank you for sharing.
Thanks and enjoy your new speakers!
Ls edifier suenan espectaculares en el video 😮
Creo que a edilfier mr4 le hacen mucha propaganda, yo lo compre 2 veces y las 2 veces me salieron defectuosos los tuve que regresar ya no puedo confiar en edilfier 😢 quisiera haber tenido la misma buena experiencia que otras personas
Edifier of course. It doesn't hiss like presonus
yeah by a mile
as someone who listens to all kinds of music (also classical), which one would you recommend me?
If you want to choose between these 2 speakers, the MR4 is better sound wise. If you want the best sound and still a relatively affordable price, go with the Edifier R1700BTs. It is amazing. Here's a video about it here: ua-cam.com/video/EM08vN1sCM4/v-deo.html
thanks for this you just made my mind up!!
Thanks for your review man! I will probably go for the MR4s to save money for a decent subwoofer!
Since I want a 2.1 setup for more bass frequencies, I am thinking of choosing between Edifier T5 and Presonus Eris Sub 8 for my subwoofer. I'll be using my setup for listening to music from classical to very modern stuff and also for music production. Keep in mind that Eris Sub 8 is about 89usd more expensive than T5 in my country. Which one do you recommend?
I appreciate your help!
Look at the specs and choose the one that suits you. I didn't try any of these subwoofers
@@KnowledgeSharingTech Nevermind! Thanks👍🏻
i'm looking for the best studio monitors with bluetooth and additional sub ...any idea?
Why my mr4 at cutting my sounds ??
When i mix it distort my bass sounds
bro should i but it or not, i want budget monitor for production and a bit of mixing
Does they have HISS sound?
No
Great
Wich has better sound?? Edifier MR4 or Edifier g5000, any one????
G5000 is much better sounding than the MR4. Here's a review of them: ua-cam.com/video/QraPm2yd5h4/v-deo.html
Mr4 are lacking in mids while the Presonus tweeter gives a bit of clarity in mids but lacks on bass, which only subwoofer can solve the problem on presonus. In the end of the day, Mr4 are also great in terms in sound and aesthetics. We all have personal preference and use your ears. Whatever you choose between these two, still a win. Specially if you’re upgrading on a normal/generic speakers.
Lol you need to clean your ears, the mids are definitely better on the MR4 or you have no idea how to properly assess the sound. The presonus is more inclined towards the treble.
Are you serious? The Presonus is muddy in the mids at best, they aren't even comparable! This isn't even about personal preference it's about actual clarity!
Bro U do mix ur own music right any producer would tell that the mr4 has the better bass and mid range frequency while the PreSonus sounds like it has less bass and to much treble or high eq
What about m-audio av40
Hi, is the Edifier MR4 a good speaker for a home studio, considering it to produce and record singing with a mic+interface?
Yes
Bom trabalho , gostei da maneira direta de fazer as observações. Parabéns.
Obrigada
Such a good video thank you
Glad you enjoyed it!
Fading in and out makes no sense to me for comparison.
Nice 👍
My presonus after 3 years are done
Propably i will choose now the MR4
Especialy cause i can see 2 modes Cause i mainly using them for guitar playing
Do you recommend them for this usage ?
Yes
same with me bro my presonus 4.5 cant be turned on after 3 years
@@hagemaru96 just buy new one , no one can fix this problem.. i have asked everyone here.. i just bought krk rokitt g4 7 and i am happy with it
@@KnowledgeSharingTech mr4 active Eris passive speakers right?
No, both active @@pa1kumarbhukya
MR4 for me
How does the Presonus Eris compare to Edifier 1280T ? iam try to decide between the two but noone has a direct comp
I had the R1280T so I know how it sounds. For music listening, you're better off with the R1280T, for music production, the Eris E3.5. That being said, if you can put $10 more, get the R1280TS. It is much better then both the Eris and the R1280T
Mr4 vs r100t4
They don't sell the R1000T4 in North America
Nice review sir 👍 I'm wondering if you can also do a "vs" or give feedback between the R1700xxx and the MR4. I'm really confused on which one to pick since there's no test unit in any of the stores i went to
Hello, if you want to produce music and you don't need BT and a remote, pick the MR4. Otherwise, go with the R1700BTS, they sound much better
@@KnowledgeSharingTech thanks sir! BTW, can you tell which one produces a cleaner and more audible male and female voice?
@@randomfenrir451 мне очень нравится вокал на мр4 ,но не слышал на 1700
R1700BTs
Frequency response of both please. As I know the Eris has a flatter frequency response.
Hi, I cover this in the specs chapter of the video.
Erins audio corner has both them measured with Klippel NFS.
Hi wonderful review! I am a guitar player, who plays a lot of classic rock music, AC/DC, Beatles, Zeppelin. Which in your opinion sounds better?
Hello, thanks for your message, the MR4 is better sound wise.
@@KnowledgeSharingTech Thank you so so Much! I'm going to order them today. Have you ever tried the iLoud Micro Monitors?
@@AngelMartinez-qs3cf Welcome, no, I didn't try the iLoud Micro Monitors.
I think both are horrible
R1700BTs The sound is clamped