Dido and Æneas - Henry Purcell (Dido's Lament) + Fr lyrics

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лип 2014
  • Dido and Æneas - Henry Purcell 1689
    Dido : Malena Ernman (sublime performance)
    Acte III
    Movt. 37. Aria, "Thy hand Belinda, darkness shades me"
    Movt. 38. Ground, Aria and Ritornello, "When I am laid in earth"
    Movt. 39. Chorus, "With drooping wings"
    Movt. 40. Epilogue, strings "All that we know the angels do above" ## Unfortunately no epilogue ##

КОМЕНТАРІ • 464

  • @AndromedaCripps
    @AndromedaCripps 2 роки тому +304

    Still coming back to this recording and still crying every time. It’s not just the stellar acting, the incredibly evocative musical choices which portray a story beyond the manuscript without sacrificing the music, it’s also the staging.
    I’ve always appreciated the carefully selected and beautiful portrait-like poses the three characters take on the stage, but it wasn’t until this, my 30th or so viewing, that I realized at that thought that even the lighting plays an integral role in this performance. The actors ARE a portrait- in their dramatic pose, they are brightly lit but juxtaposed by an all-encompassing black background. This is one of the most prevalent styles of Baroque painting, a technique called tenebrism, in which dramatically lit characters in the foreground pop in front of a dark black background.
    The music, dresses, and yes, even the AESTHETIC of the STAGING ITSELF are ALL **historically informed**. This blew my mind when I realized. I am utterly stunned again and again, at the complexity of passionate dedication put into this piece of art.
    It’s a little crazy to think that Purcell wrote this opera to be simple enough for a young girls school to perform, when I see a mature and emotionally deep performance such as this, that still feels miraculously as though it would not be the slightest out of place in front of Purcell and his contemporaneous audience. I really can’t express how good this is. I think this is one of those performances that you spend the rest of your life wishing you could have been there to see. Damn.

    • @Occams-Razor
      @Occams-Razor 2 роки тому +4

      This recording prompted me to buy the Blu Ray of the same production. Everything is done so well including the support actors who never look at the camera compared to Malena Ernman, and the minimalist stage and lighting.

    • @adsones
      @adsones Рік тому +7

      So beautifully put. I too come back to this constantly and I'm always moved by the sheer perfection achieved by all the people involved in this, because everything works sublimely. The staging and lighting are so evocative it's like a painting coming to life, like Kubrick's Barry Lyndon. I even took a screenshot of it and made it my desktop wallpaper. The perfect synchrony between the ladies' dramatic expressions/body language and Dido's voice fading as she finally succumbs and is embraced by death is so moving. And then the final act comes in and I just can't hold my tears as I'm embraced by the angelical voices of the chorus singing the most poetic/soul-fulfilling lyrics:
      "With drooping wings you Cupids come,
      And scatter roses on her tomb.
      Soft and gentle as her heart
      Keep here your watch, and never part."
      Virgil and Purcell, a match made in heaven.

    • @aliciarealp
      @aliciarealp Рік тому +1

      De acuerdo en todo. Excelentes palabras para calificar esta hermosísima composición y puesta en escena ¡Muchas gracias!

    • @psycholoog-denhaag
      @psycholoog-denhaag Рік тому +5

      Me too

    • @Knonnynonny
      @Knonnynonny 8 місяців тому +5

      Thank you for that PLEASURE!!! of a reading. An uncommon grace at all times, especially in our time of such want of civility and civilization.

  • @Ahsoka_Hyrule
    @Ahsoka_Hyrule 5 років тому +488

    I just want to take a moment and applaud the two actresses playing Dido's handmaidens, they're fantastic at what they do and their performance adds so much to the scene.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  5 років тому +13

      Yes' yes

    • @andreaellis5202
      @andreaellis5202 4 роки тому +6

      Absolutely

    • @vazioli
      @vazioli 4 роки тому +8

      YES!! absolutely!! Marvellous performance!!

    • @catherinescott562
      @catherinescott562 4 роки тому +7

      Ahsoka Hyrule I second that - I’ve watched this a few times; they are wonderful

    • @jamestrimbath
      @jamestrimbath 4 роки тому +2

      And also dido

  • @BangkokVoiceCoach
    @BangkokVoiceCoach Рік тому +74

    A moment of directorial genius that Dido is instantly struck blind by the poison. It makes so much sense of the opening lines of the recit, “thy hand Belinda, darkness shades me.”

    • @tohokugirl8144
      @tohokugirl8144 11 місяців тому +4

      And the closing of her eyes by handmaid.

  • @johannesrotter5125
    @johannesrotter5125 2 роки тому +40

    A vivid Caravaggio Painting. Outstanding Performance. OMG. No more words.

    • @frankverstappen2853
      @frankverstappen2853 4 місяці тому +2

      I saw the opera live in Amsterdam. So, for me it was like a Rembrandt painting.

  • @MushishiLivi
    @MushishiLivi 6 років тому +308

    Purcell is underrated. The raw emotion in this is so strong. It takes a lot to bring me to tears, but this piece has no trouble doing so. You can feel absolutely everything the singers feel and it's powerful.

    • @ElasticReality
      @ElasticReality 5 років тому +4

      And she's just a few cents flat which makes her feel even lower than the music, like its a life raft thrown to her soul she cant reach.

    • @timsmarr2781
      @timsmarr2781 5 років тому

      Vivaldi's music still better .

    • @elenikiroy
      @elenikiroy 5 років тому +10

      @@timsmarr2781 oh please

    • @domainofthesun4400
      @domainofthesun4400 4 роки тому

      @@ElasticReality brilliantly put

    • @MushishiLivi
      @MushishiLivi 4 роки тому +7

      @@timsmarr2781 Literally has nothing to do with what I said, but go off queen.

  • @gabrielesaudelli7154
    @gabrielesaudelli7154 Рік тому +7

    A vision like Caravaggio. Colors, lights... And the music of the stars.

  • @vazioli
    @vazioli 4 роки тому +69

    The settings, figures, shapes, colors, shadows and light remind of Rembrandt's paintings! Beautiful!

  • @emilegrou
    @emilegrou 2 роки тому +50

    One of the saddest, if not the saddest, song in the classical repertoire in my opinion!

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  2 роки тому +8

      Beautiful sadness

  • @Ranggalih
    @Ranggalih 5 років тому +217

    Perhaps the best rendition of the opera I've ever seen. This scene in particular is beauty at its peak. Malena Ernman's technique is very appropriate, her mordents, her dynamics,... and I would like to point out a moment specifically during the second climax of "remember me, but ah! forget my fate..."; which in the first climax was executed with strength, but as Dido weakens - the second one sounded more softer, delicate, yet 'tearing' in which it perfectly reflects Dido's lamentation. And could we have a moment to applaud on how well the production team was? Each frame of this particular scene resembles a painting in which its quality is equivalent to those hanged in the Louvre... Truly, a beautiful masterpiece by Purcell executed well in this particular production....

    • @ericwallbruch2767
      @ericwallbruch2767 4 роки тому +8

      @ranggalih-- I love what you said!! when i saw this (and immediately re-shared on facebook), one of my remarks was that the friezes before and after the aria-proper could be Caravaggio's!

    • @tvaripo5038
      @tvaripo5038 2 роки тому

      We all see the same my friends
      This is incredible 🙏🙏🙏

    • @tanyadixon3479
      @tanyadixon3479 Рік тому

      A vocal tapestry.

  • @stairfall12345678900
    @stairfall12345678900 4 роки тому +35

    This is one of the only versions I can find where the singer doesn’t overuse vibrato during the final phrase. The ‘slipping away’ deaths are always more convincing than dramatic deaths for me...

  • @londonlass1000
    @londonlass1000 Рік тому +16

    My cousin had this sung at his funeral it was heart rending. Such a sad song and he died too young. This is beautifully sung.

  • @kpvdnber
    @kpvdnber 8 років тому +186

    Wow. Just wow. The poison makes it so much more intimate and compelling, in many ways better than the original. And this must be the greatest piece of acting I've ever seen in opera. Beautiful.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  8 років тому +5

      it's quite that, all agree ; )

    • @walkernick86
      @walkernick86 3 роки тому +5

      I totally agree. This is essentially a suicide scene. An overdose if you will, and her aria is her suicide note. Her friends want to help... alas it's too late! So poignant in these modern times!

    • @helenacorreia7613
      @helenacorreia7613 3 роки тому

      What do you mean with "the original" ?

    • @alanandrade2083
      @alanandrade2083 3 роки тому +5

      @@helenacorreia7613 Based on the Baroque art, I think that the original was based on Dido suiciding with a self-impaled blade like how Juliet died.

    • @ptat_worldz4751
      @ptat_worldz4751 2 роки тому +1

      @@alanandrade2083 I thought it was jumping into fire? Idk just saying from my history ten book

  • @destroybot3000
    @destroybot3000 3 роки тому +26

    3 things. This is undoubtedly one of the greatest vocal performances I've ever seen. This is also one of the greatest stage acting performances I've ever seen. Also, I didn't know that I could shoot tears for distance, but apparently I can.

  • @saranaushin2599
    @saranaushin2599 9 років тому +137

    “When I am laid in earth
    May my wrongs create
    No trouble in thy breast;
    Remember me, but ah, forget my fate.”

  • @AndromedaCripps
    @AndromedaCripps 6 років тому +114

    This is absolutely the best version of this aria you can find on UA-cam. Emotionally, musically, and authentically, this performance is spot on and beyond exemplary. It's simply phenomenal and I get chills every time I watch it. Thanks so much for sharing this amazing music with us all.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  6 років тому +1

      Texadon the Blue Kitty You welcome

    • @jaymiebriscoe3026
      @jaymiebriscoe3026 Рік тому +2

      I agree ! I come to UA-cam only to hear this particular version ! I love her voice, the music, and accompaniment!

    • @user-gh3it9fm4x
      @user-gh3it9fm4x Рік тому

      Есть ещё лучшая версия этой арии, когда исполняет контртенор и сопранист Давид Хансен, певица эта уже старая на вид и у нее дрожащий голос, а мужчина певец исполняет очень хорошо

    • @MikolinkoJansen
      @MikolinkoJansen 10 місяців тому

      But have you heard Jeff Buckley's version

  • @vallyunchained
    @vallyunchained Місяць тому +2

    Splendida, nello stile, nella tecnica, nei filati improvvisi, nella tenuta di fiato. WOW.

  • @leporello7
    @leporello7 7 років тому +601

    I am stunned. This is not only the most credible death scene I witnessed in four decades, but overwhelmingly plausibly bound to the music and words. Could opera get any more meaningful? A giant "thank you" to Malena Ernman and the director! If I shall ever need to show someone what opera is all about and what it can achieve in its best moments, I will show them this eternally beautiful snippet.

    • @franciscocamara233
      @franciscocamara233 7 років тому +9

      you are absolultly right.Sometimes( if not always )lyrical teather because of his musicality tends to get apart from reality.

    • @claim2game027
      @claim2game027 7 років тому +14

      Perfectly stated! THIS is what opera is all about.
      If only there were more productions with this sensibility, artistry and good taste, we would enjoy more beautiful pieces like this, and not make some aberrations we see nowadays... Many thanks to Ernman, Christie, Deborah Warner and all those involved in this production.

    • @xandercorp6175
      @xandercorp6175 6 років тому +2

      You may appreciate Janet Baker in this role: ua-cam.com/video/D_50zj7J50U/v-deo.html
      The recording quality cannot of course compare with this modern 1080p HD video, but I consider the performance in my link to be well worth forgiveness for this flaw.

    • @leporello7
      @leporello7 5 років тому +1

      xandercorp Oh, thank you very much for that link! Janet Baker is outstanding. What projection even in the piano passage! And above all her technique she not only sings, but really transports the message.

    • @xandercorp6175
      @xandercorp6175 5 років тому

      +leporello7 My pleasure, sir.

  • @martinfitzgerald6705
    @martinfitzgerald6705 Рік тому +10

    Amazing staging, it looks like an intimate Vermeer painting, lit from the left, or possibly a painting by Rembrandt.

    • @alext7268
      @alext7268 11 місяців тому +2

      Not Rembrandt. Vermeer or Caravaggio.

  • @nasduro
    @nasduro Рік тому +7

    Unbelievably wholesome performance by a truely dedicated artist. Such a joy to witness.

  • @jasonkim5503
    @jasonkim5503 4 роки тому +61

    This is PERFECTION. Dido has been consistently well sung by countless sopranos and mezzos, but it has never been THIS PERFECTLY SUNG AND PERFECTLY ACTED. A true lyric wonder we are witnessing here.

    • @Dremons7
      @Dremons7 Рік тому +2

      My eyes will never not water seeing Dido grasping blindly at the handmaiden

    • @MikolinkoJansen
      @MikolinkoJansen 10 місяців тому

      But have you heard Jeff Buckley's version

  • @cmelodynick
    @cmelodynick 7 років тому +118

    Remember Purcell. A life sadly cut short. What could he have written if he had lived longer. Remember Henry Purcell.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  7 років тому +1

      nick cmelody Probably two or three masterpieces like this one ; )

    • @error.418
      @error.418 6 років тому

      Who?

    • @alioffe4321
      @alioffe4321 5 років тому

      A tragic loss for the world of music. Much like Bellini

    • @FergusJohnston
      @FergusJohnston 4 роки тому +1

      What are you talking about? He wrote TONS!

    • @FergusJohnston
      @FergusJohnston 4 роки тому

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_compositions_by_Henry_Purcell

  • @ernshaw78
    @ernshaw78 7 років тому +38

    This is a brilliant woman, she can properly and authentically re-animate these works.

  • @ZicraVEVO
    @ZicraVEVO 2 роки тому +23

    I’d like to showcase as well the exquisite staging on this scene, very baroque too. The violent contrast of the lighting reminds me of Caravaggio’s tenebrism and the composition looks exactly like a mythological/hagiographical works’ painting. Very well done!

  • @mothman.3001
    @mothman.3001 3 роки тому +72

    To think she sang that, while lying down in a corset
    It’s stunning

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  3 роки тому +1

      it's her job 😉

    • @musicloverlondon6070
      @musicloverlondon6070 3 роки тому +12

      Was thinking the exact same thing; not the easiest circumstances in which to project your voice in a difficult aria! Wonderful performance.

  • @yaelehrlichslushny48
    @yaelehrlichslushny48 3 місяці тому +1

    It is far the best interpretation I have ever seen. Of course, William Christie is always so good but I must admit that Malena Ernman is absolutely sublime. I studied musicology, especially early music but the life took me away from it, so that I didn't know what had happened in the last 20 years. I just discovered the dido's lament on you tube yesterday and cried...
    I decided to buy the DVD, as I couldn't miss it. It is no words to describe this unique performance!

  • @oriolpicasriera3344
    @oriolpicasriera3344 5 років тому +13

    I have seen the version of Didonato and now I have seen Ernman's version ... I have no words. It is the most complete and current scene of a death I've seen... The scenic interpretation and sung are terribly sincere, extraordinarily beautiful, but without sweetening it. The opera is still a complete show.

  • @cameronkelsall7085
    @cameronkelsall7085 8 років тому +63

    Her musicality is exquisite, but she also brings very fine attention to detail in the text and great enunciation. A complete performance on all levels.

  • @KingBuddha84
    @KingBuddha84 Рік тому +11

    Art. This woman’s voice is art.

  • @daankoster4265
    @daankoster4265 Рік тому +10

    Truely amazing...so very very emotional. Dido's Lament is obviously well known, but the choir that follows it is brilliant as well. What a performance!!

    • @aci1970
      @aci1970 2 місяці тому

      I actually prefer the choir in this aria. And by "I prefer" I mean ❤×1000000+1 instead of ❤×1000000

  • @iliyakhramov4381
    @iliyakhramov4381 2 роки тому +5

    Drama, Art, wow. Glorious and powerful theater and opera.

  • @orochet
    @orochet 9 років тому +17

    ¡Madre mía! ¡Las veces que he llorado viendo esta interpretación!

    • @caliostra
      @caliostra 4 роки тому

      😚😚😚😚😍😍

  • @megancastleauthor
    @megancastleauthor 6 років тому +16

    Incredible blend of both emotion and vocals. Wow! Bravo!!!!!!! What a grand performance!

    • @ElasticReality
      @ElasticReality 5 років тому

      And acting! I mean, wow. I was little stunned, I didn't know they were planning on letting someone actually die on stage tonight. Management will be getting a very stern call.

  • @dmitryk9676
    @dmitryk9676 Рік тому +14

    Recitative
    Thy hand, Belinda, darkness shades me,
    On thy bosom let me rest,
    More I would, but Death invades me;
    Death is now a welcome guest.
    Aria
    When I am laid, am laid in earth, May my wrongs create
    No trouble, no trouble in thy breast;
    Remember me, but ah! forget my fate,
    Remember me, remember me, but ah! forget my fate.

  • @onlinesinginglesson
    @onlinesinginglesson Рік тому +4

    Wow.the acting of the one behind adds soooo much!!! Lead singer- Brava. Super hard especially that she sung "ahhhh forgeeeeeet" instead of "ahhhhhh" , "forget". 👏👏👏

  • @iliyakhramov4381
    @iliyakhramov4381 3 роки тому +7

    Greatness. Acting is very strong, terrifyingly emotional, full out, matching words and music and emotions and actions. Extremely well done.

  • @keepthefaith6171
    @keepthefaith6171 6 років тому +63

    I cant be the only one who is crying...

  • @queenofunderland
    @queenofunderland 6 років тому +10

    It is one of the production that makes me crying. Especially by thepart of dido's end of aria and cupid's scene.

  • @fabianyefe2099
    @fabianyefe2099 5 років тому +9

    Esto es el todo! Me parece muy difícil que esta interpretación en vivo pueda ser superada por un sinfín de cosas: la escenografía, la iluminación, el vestuario, el coro, la puesta en escena, la música pero por sobre todo la voz de ella. Impresionante! No puedo dejar de escuchar esto todo el tiempo! Me parece que la palabra en español que mejor podría interpretar esto sería: SUBLIME!

  • @sophiabright8371
    @sophiabright8371 7 місяців тому +3

    Her voice is pure crystalline bliss!

  • @evanjones9602
    @evanjones9602 Рік тому +6

    If any of you have seen the Guardians of the Galaxy movie, that lament is in it. And that is quite a tear jerking rendition.

  • @citronellasch.1647
    @citronellasch.1647 5 років тому +5

    Stunning...no more words needed. Every particular emotional moment is getting into my heart. Such a wonderful performance in stage! Artists like her may bei able to touch your soul just in black clothes on an empty stage! The greatest moment in opera I've eher seen! Thank you from the depth of my heart!

  • @musicadebodayeventos3478
    @musicadebodayeventos3478 7 років тому +6

    I am in tears. How much talent! Ms Ernman is soberb

  • @idilbursa2939
    @idilbursa2939 2 роки тому +6

    this is the first time I watched this... I had tears in my eyes, it's magnificent really

  • @blekkmark
    @blekkmark 4 роки тому +8

    I am speechless. Pure art, beautiful; timeless ...

  • @umrasangus
    @umrasangus Рік тому +3

    I came here to hear the bassline because someone mentioned it, so I closed my eyes and started hearing/analyzing the piece but I ended up crying. This is raw.

  • @dqthegreatist
    @dqthegreatist 4 роки тому +12

    This is absolutely marvellous!! It's actually one of the few Classical pieces that really moved me personally and got me soaked in tears!! The word paintings on "laid on earth" and "remember me" are absolutely gorgeous!! Thank you so much of the upload!!!

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  4 роки тому

      You welcome, with pleasure

    • @Dremons7
      @Dremons7 Рік тому +1

      "Remember me, but oh, forget my fate"

  • @Marie-ClaireBAure
    @Marie-ClaireBAure 9 місяців тому +1

    Un moment de grâce pure. La scène évoque une toile du Caravage et l'interprétation est magnifique. Merci ! ✨💗

  • @zaszlosj
    @zaszlosj 3 роки тому +5

    каждый раз смотрю и чувства переполняют сердце. Браво!

  • @AndreasWolfBass
    @AndreasWolfBass 5 років тому +6

    Malena!!! Come on.... This is overwhelming. Beautiful. Amazing. Really. Wow. Judith played along so well. I am sure they where really taken away by the emotions. I am stunned. Thank you guys.

  • @shanneek4545
    @shanneek4545 5 років тому +8

    Beautiful! I just learned about this in in my Music Appreciation class, I can't get enough of it!!

  • @isabs8616
    @isabs8616 5 років тому +6

    Stage Director Deborah Warner , musical director William Christie for " l'Orchestre Les Arts Florisants " , choir " Les Arts Florissants "

  • @dqthegreatist
    @dqthegreatist 4 роки тому +5

    I greatly adore how Ms. Ernman interpret this masterpiece as well! Thank you for the performance!

  • @Joggelschorsch
    @Joggelschorsch 5 років тому +8

    That's frickin live... awesome that they went all in on forte for the first "remember me"

  • @jeffhenigarprisonchap2287
    @jeffhenigarprisonchap2287 6 місяців тому +2

    IMO this goes beyond acting. I'm feeling the vibe that these actresses have experienced death in their families and are catharthisizing themselves onstage. It doesn't vibe like acting to me. IMO this is why we're feeling it so heavy. Still an amazing performance. I felt it in my soul.

  • @zoefang4563
    @zoefang4563 6 років тому +4

    I need to watch a stunning masterpiece like this in person!!! Definitely one of my favorite operas

  • @deltadawnize
    @deltadawnize 5 років тому +6

    Brings tears to my eyes. Absolutely moving!

  • @kastrafior1487
    @kastrafior1487 5 років тому +6

    L'opéra en feu ! Sublime et magnétique performance. Les deux choristes sont merveilleuses et de grandes tragédiennes, elles contribuent à un très haut niveau à cette scène où correspondent miraculeusement ligne vocale, jeu théâtral, musique, direction, interprétation et jusqu'aux sublimes costumes et éclairages. Malena Ernman (qui est la maman de Greta Thunberg) est phénoménale. L'opéra en feu !

  • @jazzman1626
    @jazzman1626 Рік тому +4

    I was just looking for the music but this whole performance by everybody involved, including the lighting and anyone else involved in the production, is absolutely exquisite! Thank you so much for uploading it.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  Рік тому +2

      I agree, you welcome

  • @fabiancancellara1
    @fabiancancellara1 2 роки тому +4

    The lighting in this scene... Wow

  • @Sarah-oj7bh
    @Sarah-oj7bh Рік тому +4

    The repetition of the climax gave me goosebumps.

  • @aliciaprince619
    @aliciaprince619 4 роки тому +5

    Everyone on this set was stunning !

  • @njlillycline
    @njlillycline 4 роки тому +7

    Brings me to tears every time

  • @Jazzcaz15
    @Jazzcaz15 6 років тому +5

    Wow! That’s the best rendition I have heard of that since Janet Baker sang it. Perfect!

  • @walkernick86
    @walkernick86 3 роки тому +9

    So emotional! I love the modern twist on this. This is essentially a suicide scene. An overdose if you will, and her aria is her suicide note. Her friends want to help, but alas it is too late! So poignant and relatable in these modern times!

    • @domainofthesun4400
      @domainofthesun4400 3 роки тому +1

      indeed :-(

    • @Dremons7
      @Dremons7 Рік тому

      It's always been a suicide. Dido kills herself over the grief of losing Aeneas. It's not an overdose, it's poison, but yes, seeing how she quickly goes blind from its effects is chilling

  • @robinavalyn9513
    @robinavalyn9513 3 роки тому +5

    So amazing! Have become obsessed with this piece...

  • @adsones
    @adsones 6 років тому +46

    Continuous shivers down my spine. This has to be the ultimate rendition to this aria, which is something I never thought I would say, considering I'm deeply intimate with the Dame Janet Baker one (saw first in Pina Bausch's Café Müller). I am SPEECHLESS. Besides the fact she made this aria her own (the acting, the tone, the voice slowly fadind away when death fatally overpowers her), the presentation is drop dead gorgeous. Almost like a painting. Tremendous and superb from start to finish. And my god, the silent support from the other ladies on stage almost put me into tears. Thank you very much for this!

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  6 років тому +1

      Adson Rocha With my pleasure

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  6 років тому +2

      Adson Rocha y en a qui ne comprennent rien à rien.. l'expression de douleur et de profonde tristesse sur le visage en gros plan de l'actrice muette en arrière plan.. et la cantatrice qui parvient à garder un super jeu d'acteur tout en délivrant une sublime performance vocale! .. ils croient que c'est facile peut-être!? 😄

    • @catherinescott562
      @catherinescott562 4 роки тому +1

      Adson Rocha this is excellent; Dame Janet Baker’s version, without as modern recording equipment is superb as well

    • @eliskaprochy4679
      @eliskaprochy4679 4 роки тому +1

      Adson Rocha Thank you for expressing my own experience of this - I couldn’t describe it in better words

  • @ameliawright6947
    @ameliawright6947 2 роки тому +5

    Heartwrenchingly beautiful.

  • @nhtn91
    @nhtn91 8 років тому +23

    This is the best version i've heard... so glad i took music 101 back in college hahahha

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  8 років тому

      The best or nothing ; )

  • @nattie-k8380
    @nattie-k8380 4 роки тому +8

    It’s just unbelievable how certain and beautiful she is...

  • @glennewell2436
    @glennewell2436 3 роки тому +3

    Astonishing performance. Wish I had seen it live - what a treasured memory!

  • @richardhaugnes4083
    @richardhaugnes4083 3 роки тому

    Etter å ha hørt et hundretalls versjoner av nettopp denne vidunderlige arien,så vil jeg fremheve denne versjonen som det mest fantastiske jeg har hørt. TAKK tilMalene Emman og orkester. Tårene formelig fløt.

  • @MusyaGriboedova
    @MusyaGriboedova 2 роки тому +4

    Исполнение и постановка потрясающие. Поражает ум и сердце

  • @corvuscorone7735
    @corvuscorone7735 4 роки тому +5

    Nice. Perfect singing and great acting.

  • @fredobatista4367
    @fredobatista4367 2 роки тому +3

    A very sentimental and poetic set of aria and choruses.💚✨

  • @kastrafior1487
    @kastrafior1487 5 років тому +3

    L'opéra en feu ! Sublime et magnétique.

  • @iagus100
    @iagus100 6 місяців тому +2

    Every time I end up in tears as if I were dying myself.

  • @tenorschofield
    @tenorschofield 7 років тому +9

    Marvelous!!!,superb voice and wonderful singing, all with a deep extraordinary interpretation sentiment...BRAVISSIMA!!!

  • @donnaharrison1992
    @donnaharrison1992 2 місяці тому +1

    Great performance. I love her red dress

  • @BangkokVoiceCoach
    @BangkokVoiceCoach Рік тому +4

    THAT is vocal acting, right there!

  • @fish-d6488
    @fish-d6488 2 роки тому +10

    i know skill in performance does not always translate to strong morality, but its hard not to imagine that malena ernman's supreme empathy on stage, dedication to her craft, and flair for the dramatic didnt seriously influence the incredible person greta thunberg has become. what a family. goddamn

  • @catherineb.7461
    @catherineb.7461 4 роки тому +48

    To even consider that Malena is Greta Thunberg is her mother is quite interesting. What a small world!

  • @woody000007
    @woody000007 5 місяців тому +1

    Sublime interprétation de Malena Ernman ; Que dire qui n'a pas encore été dit ? C'est la plus belle interprétation de ce Lament, même celle de Janet Baker qui était déjà au sommet ! Tout est réussi dans cet œuvre : les deux suivantes qui souffrent avec leur Maîtresse.
    Les chœurs, dans leurs habits de notre époque alors que les protagonistes portent de belles robes du 17ème siècle. Grâce à superbe extrait, j'ai en plus fait la connaissance de cette admirable chanteuse qu'est Malena Ernman.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  5 місяців тому

      La synthèse est faite, merci.

  • @svukicmusic3854
    @svukicmusic3854 8 років тому +20

    Heartbreaking - as it should be.

  • @poliaw6202
    @poliaw6202 7 років тому +3

    Merci à Mme Ernman et à M. Christie! Exquis souvenirs de la salle Favart...

  • @PlatPaysQuiEstLemien
    @PlatPaysQuiEstLemien 5 років тому +3

    I wept
    beautiful voice
    incredible acting
    I so much would like to see THIS production with Malena

  • @barbaranorthwood
    @barbaranorthwood Рік тому +2

    Yes, it is a sublime performance. Thank you very much.

  • @sigutestonyte8679
    @sigutestonyte8679 3 місяці тому +1

    Wonderful Malena Emmman!

  • @PaulusLXXX
    @PaulusLXXX 6 років тому +3

    EXCELENTE!!! MAGNIFICA!! EXTRAORDINARIA INTERPRETACIÓN!! realmente difícil de ser superada. Muchas gracias por compartir.

  • @mengkaotseng8105
    @mengkaotseng8105 Рік тому +2

    haunting !
    thx so much for this posting
    mxncb

  • @MrPrestoconfuocco
    @MrPrestoconfuocco 5 років тому +2

    Without words......Marveilleux

  • @msandreyevskikh
    @msandreyevskikh 3 роки тому +4

    this is the best performance I've seen. thank you so much, thank you!

  • @luisrueda7672
    @luisrueda7672 3 роки тому +3

    Impresionante puesta de una magnífica Opera, sublime.

  • @maliamonique
    @maliamonique 9 місяців тому

    my teacher in school showed our class this video in middle school. After some time has gone by I now see it in a much more mature and meaningful light than I had before. Bravo 👏

  • @citronellasch.1647
    @citronellasch.1647 4 місяці тому +1

    Wonderful performance. Most beautiful scene i've ever seen. ❤

  • @ChocolateCurls317
    @ChocolateCurls317 4 роки тому +4

    This song is so beautiful.

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  4 роки тому

      You re Beautiful too

  • @margaritisskg
    @margaritisskg 7 років тому +12

    Incredible singing, acting and direction! The best ! bravo!

  • @Krisztike45
    @Krisztike45 10 місяців тому +2

    Pure genius ❤️

  • @anniabuhl5991
    @anniabuhl5991 3 роки тому +1

    Long lives are sad, a life "cut" short is blessed.

  • @jeanmauricedennery4868
    @jeanmauricedennery4868 7 років тому +4

    Beatyful!I have une larme a l'œil chaque fois que je l'ecoute!

    • @zencoos
      @zencoos  7 років тому +1

      Jean Maurice Dennery you have so raison ; )

  • @sewatan
    @sewatan 3 роки тому +3

    Un lamento que se queda y florece en un rincón oscuro del alma...