PMS vs Mutual Fund: Is Portfolio Management Services Worth It? Why I Invested with PMS Fund?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 35

  • @saikatmukherjee8683
    @saikatmukherjee8683 23 дні тому +4

    You mentioned your PMS investment has same risk as a large cap or index fund. This sounds highly improbable if that PMS promises 25% conservative and 40% optimistic return. Can you share the source of such research?

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  23 дні тому +2

      that is a great question. I will try to make video where i might share some screenshots, numbers etc.
      All PMSs are supposed to share there performance data with SEBI. You can check that data here www.apmiindia.org/apmi/welcomeiaperformance.htm?action=PMS and compare it with benchmarks on a month on month basis for last 18 months. You might see that good PMSs have done better than benchmark in the red zone as well.
      Apart from this, PMSs shared their own data with me, which I might be able to share in a video someday.
      Despite all this, I am as sceptic as you are. Previous numbers don't indicate future results. I will try to share monthly update on my PMS performance so that it might be more helpful.

  • @AceHunley
    @AceHunley 24 дні тому +2

    great video explaining the intricacies of portfolio management services. keep it up. subbed!

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  24 дні тому +1

      Thank you so much.

    • @AceHunley
      @AceHunley 24 дні тому +1

      @ no problem Brishma! Always good to hear the knowledge of others. I post financial videos and inspiring interviews. Trying to grow my channel too!

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  23 дні тому +1

      @@AceHunley that is great. my best wishes for your journey.

  • @SKCtripple0
    @SKCtripple0 23 дні тому +2

    Thanks for a wonderful video giving details of a new investment vertical called PMS. the details of money invested thru PMS that you said is 30 lakh crore is mind boggling and the high return are very tempting. you rightly mentioned that big surplus money comes to a person once in a while and it becomes a big onus to utilize this corpus judiciously. In general, Selling a property provides one a big corpus of funds. Govt allows citizens to utilize the capital gains for 2 years and if the money is reinvested in property the tax on capital gains are waved off. PMS provides a very good opportunity to utilize property capital gains for two years. Does Govt allow to use Property capital gains to reinvest in PMS or in stock market without any tax liability?

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  23 дні тому

      that is a great question. Never checked if property gains tax can be saved via stocks or PMS. Will check and update.

    • @loganandhan
      @loganandhan 22 дні тому +1

      @@Bhishma.Choudhary I was told by my auditor, if that gain is invested in some FD, its waived off. Otherwise investing in equity - not. However, please check.

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  21 день тому

      Thats interesting info. Will have to confirm with auditor on this.

  • @AzaeZel-r4u
    @AzaeZel-r4u 22 дні тому +1

    Look into strategic indices that use factors like momentum, quality, value, alpha, low volatility etc
    All will beat nifty50( largecap)

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  22 дні тому

      good point. never came across this. maybe, i will try to start investing some amount in these, to compare how things fare compared to PMS and professionally managed MF portfolio. Thanks for the suggestion.

  • @pankajrane2004
    @pankajrane2004 9 днів тому +1

    Sir, can your share.. what are the important questions you have discussed with PMS service in during your PMS service selection?

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  9 днів тому +1

      Here are the few things I had asked (1) TARGET RETURNS: What are their realistic & aspirational target returns in next 5 years. (2) RISK: How do they minimise risk. Their strategy. (3) TAX: How much tax should I expect to pay annually (also linked to Churn Ratio or Annual Turnover of the fund) (4) LIQUIDITY: How quickly can I withdraw funds when needed (5) FEE Structure (6) System dependency on fund manager in case manager is unwell (PMS is mostly run by fund manager) (7) Their Team Size (8) Any Data they can provide to corroborate their claims

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  5 днів тому +1

      ua-cam.com/video/PGyvojtJ47w/v-deo.html Here is the follow up video where I have tried to answer all the queries here. I hope this would be helpful.

  • @linuxbee
    @linuxbee 23 дні тому +2

    Which pms did you go with ?

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  23 дні тому +1

      I will share the details once I have more data around the performance. Then I can review the PMS with more insights from my own experience.

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  5 днів тому

      ua-cam.com/video/PGyvojtJ47w/v-deo.html Here is the follow up video where I have tried to answer all the queries here. I hope this would be helpful.

  • @malakondaiahkonda6307
    @malakondaiahkonda6307 20 днів тому +1

    Pls let us jnow what kind PMS fund u choosed....I am also planning for PMS..as currently investing in Mutual funds and direct shares....but i am having currently high risk and high reward...as of now acchived same...but going further need to rduce the risk....I am also thinking which PMS is better..my expectations returns 18 to 20%...

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  20 днів тому

      @@malakondaiahkonda6307 I will share the PMS fund details soon with updates on performance as well. I can completely understand it can be very confusing to choose whether PMS is a good option or not, and if yes, them which PMS to go for.

    • @rakeshpandey9730
      @rakeshpandey9730 10 днів тому +1

      Still waiting , please share your pms research and which pms you invested

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  5 днів тому

      ua-cam.com/video/PGyvojtJ47w/v-deo.html Here is the follow up video where I have tried to answer all the queries here. I hope this would be helpful.

  • @umavidyadhar6770
    @umavidyadhar6770 23 дні тому +2

    Can you please name ur PMS which you invested so tat it will help someone?

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  23 дні тому +2

      Sure, I will do that. I will name the fund in the upcoming videos. I wish to name the fund only when I have some performance numbers at my hand. That is the whole purpose of my videos that I can share my honest experience with these funds & platforms. Do stay tuned.

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  5 днів тому

      ua-cam.com/video/PGyvojtJ47w/v-deo.html Here is the follow up video where I have tried to answer all the queries here. I hope this would be helpful.

  • @chirathenaveen5562
    @chirathenaveen5562 25 днів тому +1

    Bro in grip as per schedule date interest and principal will come ha if Sunday or govt holidays??

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  25 днів тому

      In my experience with all the platforms, payments are not received processed on Sunday & Govt Holidays. I receive them next day. Just 2 days back, i had 2 payments scheduled for Sunday, but I received both of them on Monday.

    • @chirathenaveen5562
      @chirathenaveen5562 22 дні тому +1

      @@Bhishma.Choudhary Grip on time payment ha

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  22 дні тому +1

      @@chirathenaveen5562 for me, till now, it has been on time.

  • @rakeshpandey9730
    @rakeshpandey9730 10 днів тому +1

    Which pms service to choose ?

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  10 днів тому

      Seriously, I did not expect so many viewers interested in PMS. I am so happy that you want to know more. Working on the next video for this. Will upload PMS details & performance update for 15 days.

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  5 днів тому

      ua-cam.com/video/PGyvojtJ47w/v-deo.html Here is the follow up video where I have tried to answer all the queries here. I hope this would be helpful.

  • @gyanukumar9633
    @gyanukumar9633 23 дні тому +1

    Sir plz make a video on good PMS services

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  23 дні тому +1

      Sure. I will keep on updating performance & insights from my PMS fund for sure. I will also try to share how finalised my PMS from the shortlisted funds. I avoid commenting on funds whose service I have not taken.

    • @Bhishma.Choudhary
      @Bhishma.Choudhary  5 днів тому

      ua-cam.com/video/PGyvojtJ47w/v-deo.html Here is the follow up video where I have tried to answer all the queries here. I hope this would be helpful.