Can The Mercedes AMG ONE Beat A GT3 At The NORDSCHLEIFE?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 161

  • @THEWINDTUNNEL
    @THEWINDTUNNEL  2 місяці тому +46

    Would you rather own the AMG One or the GT3?

    • @Kierenstanden-qz7eu
      @Kierenstanden-qz7eu 2 місяці тому +23

      GT3 engine will last longer

    • @3h415t0ph
      @3h415t0ph 2 місяці тому +6

      Clearly GT3

    • @Ilovecars-wd6xu
      @Ilovecars-wd6xu 2 місяці тому +5

      Amy one
      Cause it has a formula 1 engine

    • @michaellarkin6158
      @michaellarkin6158 2 місяці тому

      hich one doesnt come with a shitty AI voiceover?

    • @tstraw48
      @tstraw48 2 місяці тому +9

      AMG One, then I'd sell it immediately. $$$$$

  • @jidearojo
    @jidearojo 2 місяці тому +264

    Beating a car that was specifically tuned for a track is extremely challenging. It's like racing a private jet with an f18 hornet when we all know the victor

    • @akaDOOD
      @akaDOOD 2 місяці тому +19

      The tires are the main problem

    • @vauxcorsa
      @vauxcorsa 2 місяці тому +1

      a private jet could probably win that

    • @jidearojo
      @jidearojo 2 місяці тому

      @@akaDOOD I can agree but I'm also pretty sure that windtunnel would create a fair game and give them both racing tyres

    • @jidearojo
      @jidearojo 2 місяці тому +5

      @@vauxcorsa private jets enter mach 1.18?!

    • @toonverbruggen7351
      @toonverbruggen7351 2 місяці тому +5

      @@jidearojo I'm not a jet expert but I'm pretty sure the hornet can only go supersonic for a short period of time. Over longer distances a private jet could actually have a chance.
      Same thing with the tornado and condorde, yes the fighter aircraft was faster but had to give up because it's not built to sustain those speeds.

  • @melegattie4116
    @melegattie4116 2 місяці тому +142

    In real life the AMG ONE did lack battery on the straight, "only" topping at 325km/h and 310 while passing bridge, here the AMG ONE did +337km/h at bridge.. so the GT3 will beat the AMG ONE in a more realistic condition

    • @joelrodriguez9611
      @joelrodriguez9611 2 місяці тому +1

      At most, that would slow down the laptime. It'd be enough for an overtake nevertheless. GT3 wouldn't be able to regain the lead on the remaining corners without divebombing.
      If we're comparing only laptimes then the simulation is futile. Just pair the record vs a GT3 qualyfying lap and call it a day.

    • @ErwinLiszkowicz
      @ErwinLiszkowicz 2 місяці тому +17

      This is why as much as I like watching videos on this channel, they have zero merit.
      Most of these AC1 mods are just skins shoved onto a random physics model with some basic values tweaked. You just can't treat it seriously.

    • @xnotasweatx
      @xnotasweatx 2 місяці тому +4

      @@ErwinLiszkowiczfrr most of these mods suck

    • @nicolasoliveira4903
      @nicolasoliveira4903 Місяць тому

      ​@@ErwinLiszkowiczThis is why I'm not a mod lover. It never is good as the vanilla version. Maybe paid mods are better, but they cost more than the whole game+dlcs.

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      ​@joelrodriguez9611 I'd like to see a GT3 car doing a clean qualification lap around the ring without any other car interference. I'd like to, because i never did, and im watching the N24h since 2000. So the true potential of a quali lap for any GT3 car, we haven't even seen.

  • @AloneRacecar
    @AloneRacecar 2 місяці тому +83

    To be honest I’m a little impressed how the GT car was able to hold up itself against the supercar for most of this Nürburgring race. 👍

    • @jidearojo
      @jidearojo 2 місяці тому +5

      @@AloneRacecar with 1000hp, I think you should know that the AMG ONE is a hypercar. Supercars are between 650-900hp cars.

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      Well, the issue with these simulations is that they do not take into consideration that the battery will deplete like it did IRL, the downforce also being always there, wind is at constant speed and trajectory. You can't take this simulation serious. IRL, the GT3 cars wouldn't be passed by any road car on the ring. I mean, when have we ever seen a clean qualifying lap with a GT3 car around the ring. No inference from other cars... i have never seen one tbh

  • @eamonahern7495
    @eamonahern7495 2 місяці тому +52

    2:03 Hello rebel tree! 👋

    • @Jejking
      @Jejking 2 місяці тому +3

      Lol :D

  • @bigtime9597
    @bigtime9597 2 місяці тому +39

    Why is the AMG One not in track mode? That's where its best performance is.

    • @CArl3n-c3ln
      @CArl3n-c3ln 2 місяці тому +4

      Yea I agree in track mode it should absolutely obliterate the gt3

    • @andyw3152
      @andyw3152 2 місяці тому +7

      @@CArl3n-c3ln 🤣

    • @6digits
      @6digits 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@CArl3n-c3lnmaybe, until you do multiple laps. The AMG one eats tires and the GT car will be able to use them lap after lap. Same goes for fuel.

    • @thr3x658
      @thr3x658 Місяць тому +7

      Because its assetto corsa and the track mode is either not avalible or only visual changes, as the car is not officially in the game

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому +1

      ​@@CArl3n-c3ln you know that no road legal car is able to beat a real GT3 car around this track irl? The sheer amount of downforce they have around there is something no road legal car has. IRL, the AMG ONE ran out of battery on the Döttinger so it did not hit 337 kph like in the video. The GT3 do not rely on this stuff so they always have the same amount of power. And again, the amount of downforce and grip they have, no street legal road car can touch...

  • @maxxillion1760
    @maxxillion1760 2 місяці тому +28

    How about which of the holy trinity would be fasteat around the ring?

    • @chikmnunget
      @chikmnunget Місяць тому +1

      We already know that answer in real life, it was the 918

  • @sniperyt445
    @sniperyt445 2 місяці тому +50

    amg one is not in full downforce spec or the mode is like that

    • @1000roentgens
      @1000roentgens 2 місяці тому +6

      Theres a lot wrong with this VS video, each car did bot have the track to themselves etc.

    • @kristianangeloni
      @kristianangeloni 2 місяці тому +1

      Well, this mod doesn't have the issue with the battery that the real one had during the lap neither

    • @redvivid
      @redvivid 2 місяці тому +1

      Even in full downforce mode the weight makes it slow through the corners.

  • @matheusbastos6429
    @matheusbastos6429 2 місяці тому +15

    That amg one mod is so bad, it comes with wrong downforce, powerband and a lot more pretty sure.

  • @Hardys-Mods
    @Hardys-Mods 2 місяці тому +21

    3:40 AMG One needs a driver mod for sure

    • @DamarFadlan25
      @DamarFadlan25 2 місяці тому

      Maybe Asuna Yuuki could be the one on Driver Mod in AMG ONE.

    • @AlainSALLE
      @AlainSALLE 2 місяці тому

      Just give the steering wheel to Kevin Estre...ua-cam.com/video/THvkwbi1qFc/v-deo.htmlsi=-GTu7FXlFE0M3BY1

  • @mogelkaiser1876
    @mogelkaiser1876 2 місяці тому +3

    video idea: a 1 lap race around the nordschleife with all the safety cars of the current major motorsport serieses.
    F1: AMG GTR PRO and AM Vantage
    NLS: BMW M4
    WEC: 911 Turbo
    Indycar: C8 Corvette
    Nascar: Modified Camaro
    Super GT: Nissan Z
    DTM: Cupra Formentor VZ5
    GT Masters: Audi R8 and RS Etron
    Formula E: Taycan Turbo S

  • @RallyXsings05
    @RallyXsings05 2 місяці тому +4

    Goodness me that drone moment spooked me a little!! 😅

  • @carkid9831
    @carkid9831 2 місяці тому +21

    the one had to pass and the gt3 blocked like hell

    • @lordracer7743
      @lordracer7743 2 місяці тому +9

      the ai is too stupid to pass.

    • @Teddiebear4
      @Teddiebear4 2 місяці тому

      @@lordracer7743not ai driving, that’s a real person

    • @DeanzCarz
      @DeanzCarz 2 місяці тому +4

      @@Teddiebear4 no it's not wtf

  • @castlesii2916
    @castlesii2916 2 місяці тому +2

    Nice shots! Would be nice to see lateral Gs comparsion

  • @FlowMichael
    @FlowMichael 2 місяці тому +2

    And this is why tires are important

  • @jasons2562
    @jasons2562 2 місяці тому +9

    The GT3 car has only 520 horsepower and tons of drag, it would never be that fast in the longer fast sections

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  2 місяці тому +2

      GT3s reach 300 km/h at Le Mans

    • @stardustb390
      @stardustb390 2 місяці тому +1

      it's 300kgs lighter, it wouldn't have that same top end but it would be more than quick enough around corners to beat a hypercar.

    • @ErwinLiszkowicz
      @ErwinLiszkowicz 2 місяці тому

      @@THEWINDTUNNEL They did not. Even with draft the fastest car did 294.

    • @kirre_motion3437
      @kirre_motion3437 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@THEWINDTUNNELonly 270 on Nordschleife...... Watch 24 hrs race for example

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      But the AMG ONE wouldn't either since it's battery would have been drained a lot faster. There is a reason it did "only" a 6.29. It ran out of juice and didn't make the 337 kph at the Dötringer... No battery left

  • @enzoracer5323
    @enzoracer5323 2 місяці тому +14

    This amg one is not accurate, the handling is too much wrong...

    • @cargx44
      @cargx44 2 місяці тому

      This mod is not really good when I try.

  • @cryptichaste2270
    @cryptichaste2270 2 місяці тому +1

    i am yet to see a good amg one mod out there

  • @ramadhanisme7
    @ramadhanisme7 2 місяці тому +3

    Beating gt3 only because it has a higher top speed, but corner per corner the gt3 is faster

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      Only possible in a game. IRL, not a chance. Tires overheating, lack of downforce and therefore grip, the battery ran out of juice at the end of the track irl. There is so much wrong with this video. Just like the one with the RB19 doing a faster time with the GP and Nordschleife track than a GT3 doing the Nordschleife alone. F1 cars up until 2021 could maybe do it, but not the current ones...

  • @GabrielleJohnDomangcas
    @GabrielleJohnDomangcas 2 місяці тому +1

    AMG 1: Chasing the Gt3 around. 😂
    Gt3: Running for his goddamn life. 😢

  • @shrapnut7612
    @shrapnut7612 2 місяці тому +1

    Wow, I’ve never seen aieral footage of that track, I’ve only seen early versions of the track from the default views.
    The first section of banked concrete (round a bout,?) never new it was so circular. Nice viddy, thanks.

    • @THEWINDTUNNEL
      @THEWINDTUNNEL  2 місяці тому

      The Nordschleife is such a beautiful track

    • @mr8I7
      @mr8I7 2 місяці тому

      There's old footage of an F1 race there in the early 70s. Most of it is filmed from the sky in a helicopter due to the sheer scale of the circuit. It's pretty amazing footage.

  • @jt_obey_714
    @jt_obey_714 2 місяці тому +19

    I didn't know that the AMG One sounds like an F1 car

    • @baguettedepain3975
      @baguettedepain3975 2 місяці тому +52

      It has a F1 engine.

    • @Skibidigokyllyourself
      @Skibidigokyllyourself 2 місяці тому +25

      it literally has an f1 engine, that was the whole point

    • @KitKitChanIsaac
      @KitKitChanIsaac 2 місяці тому +4

      It literally has an F1 engine bruh 💀 ofc it's going to sound like an F1 car😭😭😭

    • @diamondjebgold9906
      @diamondjebgold9906 2 місяці тому

      It’s pretty much a formula 1 car for the road ofc it sounds like a f1 car

    • @EvanNyameyeTachie-Menson
      @EvanNyameyeTachie-Menson 2 місяці тому +1

      Bro thinks it has a Mercedes V8

  • @tylerduffin7656
    @tylerduffin7656 24 дні тому

    This whole video could have been done by looking at the lap record for a gt3 car and the lap record of the AMG one.

  • @GraveUypo
    @GraveUypo Місяць тому

    i don't like that they're not driven by the same person and one can hold up the other

  • @sir_kala
    @sir_kala 2 місяці тому +1

    Racing both side-by-side doesn't make it accurate or at least close
    You should make one lap from each other and show up the difference
    PS: No hate, just an advice, you have my like

  • @kirre_motion3437
    @kirre_motion3437 2 місяці тому

    To have a better idea of how it would be in RL compare the AMG s lap record with the qualifying laps of GT3 cars

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      You can't. The GTR's never have a clean lap to themselves. It's always trafic. There are almost 200 cars on the track. At least 100 at the same time with most of them being a lost slower than the GT3. You can't do it like that...

  • @kirre_motion3437
    @kirre_motion3437 2 місяці тому

    This sim might be not perfect, but the times in rl show that it would exactly happen this way. Amg one needs 6.29 for a lap. A gt3 racecar needs 6.30 from exit of gp track to the last corner of nordschleife during qualify of the 24hrs track. So you have to add few seconds for hole lap of isolated nordschleife. Laptimes are nearly the same.

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      And then you need to remove all the cars that are slowing down the GT3 doing the qualifications lap. I mean, im watching the N24h since 2000 and i have never seen a clean qualifying lap without interference. It will take a lot of timw till road legal cars can match the timw of GT3 cars around the ring, if ever, since as road legal cars get faster, so do all the other cars too

  • @UrijTamasov
    @UrijTamasov 2 місяці тому +6

    Gib dem AMG ONE slick reifen und gegen den über Porsche 919 WR bitte das währe cool

    • @sargublast7168
      @sargublast7168 2 місяці тому +5

      Not even close, its over 1 minute faster

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      Dude, the ONE wouldn't be able to beat a GT3 car irl. Unless i see a clean qualifying lap from a GT3 car, without trafic, i can't ever say that a mere road legan car can beat a GT3 around the ring, and im watching the N24h since 2000

  • @flavioxy
    @flavioxy 2 місяці тому

    is the one on slicks?

  • @3h415t0ph
    @3h415t0ph 2 місяці тому +2

    Next: can the amg one beat the 919evo at the norschleife with 1min ledge.

  • @marvinzhang3734
    @marvinzhang3734 Місяць тому

    why gt3 letting go in the middle of the race ??

  • @redvivid
    @redvivid 2 місяці тому

    Ultimately it comes down to weight. The AMG One couldn't keep up in the corners.

  • @F1XEditzz
    @F1XEditzz 2 місяці тому +1

    the amg one was in hypercar spec?

    • @KikuraKun
      @KikuraKun 2 місяці тому +5

      Not Le Mans HyperCar, just hypercar, like Veyron, One:1, F1, etc.

    • @F1XEditzz
      @F1XEditzz 2 місяці тому

      @@KikuraKun oh ok

  • @loxan22
    @loxan22 2 місяці тому +1

    The sheer power of the AMG One is amazing, however it lacks a little bit on the corners. In fact GT3 RS 992 have higher minimum average speed throughout the entire lap and higher minimum average speed through corners. Misha mentioned it in this video
    ua-cam.com/video/No3kcVGi3qg/v-deo.html

    • @divinasi0n
      @divinasi0n 2 місяці тому

      Because it's weighed down by gimmicks. It could have been a lot faster if they didn't need a million electric motors and batteries etc.

  • @xgoldx6582
    @xgoldx6582 2 місяці тому

    Which is the proximity radar app that you are using? I really like seeing the real model car there!

  • @brycearmstrong2891
    @brycearmstrong2891 2 місяці тому

    Gt3s need a speed boost, there is no way they should be slower than a NASCAR.

  • @DeanzCarz
    @DeanzCarz 2 місяці тому +1

    the mod got it wrong..

  • @Scintilla69
    @Scintilla69 2 місяці тому

    Can the McLaren “1” series beat its GT race cars?
    McLaren W1 VS McLaren 720S GT3X
    McLaren P1 VS McLaren 720S GT3
    McLaren F1 VS McLaren Artura GT4?

  • @joaoayala
    @joaoayala 2 місяці тому

    The drone sounds a little bit worse than the One. Just a little bit.

  • @DamarFadlan25
    @DamarFadlan25 2 місяці тому

    The AMG ONE looks very cool but its still fractionally slower than AMG LMGT3.

  • @parliache3329
    @parliache3329 Місяць тому

    NGL, after seeing the IRL lap record of AMG One at Nordschleife. The AMG One at Asetto Corsa are much slower at the high speed corners. IRL AMG one are probably much faster than the AMG GT3.

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      Yeah, but the AC model didn't have its battery drained so it compensated a lot for it. Irl, ot didn't do 337 at the Döttinger

  • @caringsnowfox
    @caringsnowfox 2 місяці тому

    Next the new xiomi car vs something

  • @andreaswalz5652
    @andreaswalz5652 2 місяці тому

    Da ist der GT3 wohl vom Gas gegangen. Wenn man die Passagen vor dem langen schnellen Streckenabschnitt anschaut wie der One am,, rudern,, ist weil die Reifen ihr Limit erreicht haben und der Abstand ziemlich groß zum GT3 war kann ich das nicht glauben das er gewonnen hat. Zumal der GT3 auf einmal recht langsam war.

  • @gurujoe75
    @gurujoe75 2 місяці тому

    I'm sure this "simulation" has no idea of the differences in braking system, chassis, internal aerodynamics, etc. So it's just child's play about top speed.

  • @dylanknight4752
    @dylanknight4752 2 місяці тому

    On calling bS on the times in the video. They ran about 6:50 in the video game lap. Not 6:30. And you can tell by in car driving the video game came do what the real life driver did.

    • @GraveUypo
      @GraveUypo Місяць тому

      hmm, true. it starts at 0:16 and ends at about 7:06. that's 6:50

  • @mikebadcossi2583
    @mikebadcossi2583 2 місяці тому +1

    The only quation f me IS ....can all your 'hypercars which chasing the Others run 24h on full throttle?😂😂😂😂😂

  • @Prasannashinde365
    @Prasannashinde365 2 місяці тому

    this is not real amg one model

  • @stark3855
    @stark3855 2 місяці тому

    The mod you used for the AMG ONE is terribly bad.

  • @Success-go5vr
    @Success-go5vr 2 місяці тому

    This is a video game, there is no point on the race because is not real.

  • @nelisvanwieren9508
    @nelisvanwieren9508 2 місяці тому

    I think GT3 will take this. Yes it's less powerfull but lighter

    • @biljancanin
      @biljancanin Місяць тому

      Of course it would take it. IRL the AMG ONE ran out of juice so this one had all the battery advantages, and irl the GT3 never have a clean qualifying lap. It's always trafic out there for them. They still do approximately 6.30 with trafic around the Nordschleife section...

  • @BlackSoul_Hunter
    @BlackSoul_Hunter Місяць тому

    That's a stupid comparison. First of all the AMG One is build with F1 technology. It has over 1000HP and active aerodynamics (it helps with breaking). The GT3 hasn't an active aero and has only 680HP. This is why the GT3 could stay ahead in the challenging first part with lots of corners. The Aerodynamic of an GT3 beats the AMG One in these fast and slow turns. But in the Highspeed parts over 1000HP can not be beaten by 680HP. The aerodynamic of the GT3 (often driven with more aero at the nordschleife) makes the car slower at highspeed. I don't see any sense behind such a comparison.

  • @ralfhtg1056
    @ralfhtg1056 2 місяці тому

    The AMG One is such a farce! 1,6 l V6... combined with elctric engines... Yuck! If I had the money for such a car I'd have it revamped completely: kick out these electric engines and the 1,6 l V6 and have it replaced with a V8 or V12 engine! And the cockpit.... I'd throw out all the digital displays and install a classic cockpit, with analog displays and physical buttons!

  • @n00g75
    @n00g75 2 місяці тому

    sorry .. but the video seems kinda fake. especially in the beginning when the amg one is behind the gt3 car!
    the power to weight ration of the GT is like double to the amg 1! its 1.66 for the amg1 to 2.3 for the GT3!
    and yes sure .. aero is equally important .. but
    at least at the beginning the amg1 should have got the pole!
    and most important .. at the beginning of the race .. when the aero and the air aint at the proper temparature it doesnt work well! lol

  • @ZedNinetySix_
    @ZedNinetySix_ 2 місяці тому +3

    That AMG ONE has no reason to be 1800kg, let's be honest.
    How do these manufacturers still not learn weight makes you slower and less efficient...

    • @1000roentgens
      @1000roentgens 2 місяці тому +1

      Weight also gives you traction and balance

    • @tudytudy3316
      @tudytudy3316 2 місяці тому +5

      Mate, you dont know how to make a better car than mercedes.

    • @GraveUypo
      @GraveUypo Місяць тому

      @@1000roentgens the traction it gives is proportionally lower than the increase in momentum so effectively you have higher tire wear and worse grip at corners

  • @StaticFalconar
    @StaticFalconar 2 місяці тому

    The AMG ONE is literally faster in real life than what this funky model can do in the sim.

    • @Teddiebear4
      @Teddiebear4 2 місяці тому +3

      Statistically speaking the amg one should be fast on paper but because of the gt3s downforce it makes it a lot closer

    • @Alejandro_BoniIIa
      @Alejandro_BoniIIa 2 місяці тому +3

      Both the sim and the real car did a 6:29

  • @mrink9818
    @mrink9818 2 місяці тому

    pfffff boringgggggg. Show me real cars. In a game I win this match with 200+ roadcars in grand tourismo and I am not even a professional

    • @mrink9818
      @mrink9818 2 місяці тому

      ohhh, and its about 1minute 30 away from a time you should have driven with these cars.

  • @pikachustar8260
    @pikachustar8260 2 місяці тому

    Amg has double power

  • @sashaklik4283
    @sashaklik4283 2 місяці тому

    a gt3 without bop should definitely be quicker