Can we TRUST HIM anymore?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
  • Funny, random, epic, fails, easter eggs, hidden details, and Star Wars clips and shorts from Bombastic.
    🕶 FOLLOW ME 🕶
    Instagram: / staybombastic
    Twitter: / staybombastic
    Discord: / discord
    Facebook: / bombasticgamerfilms
    TikTok: / staybombastic
    #shorts #StarWars
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 361

  • @TaraCicora
    @TaraCicora 16 днів тому +288

    Yes, I just understand that he isn't a savior, just a man.

    • @Milothemighty10
      @Milothemighty10 16 днів тому +25

      I appreciate a lo of the things he’s been involved with over his time at lucasfilm clone wars, rebels, bad batch the character of Ahsoka but yeah, he’s definitely not flawless…

    • @durrantmiller8810
      @durrantmiller8810 15 днів тому +7

      @@Milothemighty10 no one is. George wasn't.

    • @Milothemighty10
      @Milothemighty10 15 днів тому +5

      @@durrantmiller8810 as someone who loves the prequels I say fair enough…

  • @tedscheett9420
    @tedscheett9420 15 днів тому +134

    Let's not forget that Filoni is a second season behemoth. Clone Wars and Rebels started out rough, but once they got going, they hit the ground running.

    • @nexy12
      @nexy12 15 днів тому +14

      You've got a point, Ashoka S1 had a couple of rough patches, but overall, it was pretty good. So I can't imagine what S2 is gonna hold.

    • @TheArcher101
      @TheArcher101 15 днів тому +6

      Ahsoka season 1 felt like season 2 to me though, with everything that happened offscreen between Rebels and it
      But yeah, here's hoping it really picks up going forward

    • @TheHazmate
      @TheHazmate 14 днів тому +6

      Lmao. Those shows where good despite of him, not because of him.

    • @Retrouno
      @Retrouno 13 днів тому +2

      You do realise it was a whole team right?

    • @tedscheett9420
      @tedscheett9420 8 днів тому +1

      @@Retrouno Okay, sure. But I'm trying to stay positive here. This whole debacle with Acolyte has been a clear attack against fans and I'm trying to see some reason and sense. Say he did okay the Witches. I'm certain that he did believe that a coven of Force Sensitive witches appealed to him because the Nightsisters went over pretty well. I highly doubt that his intention was to butcher canon. And I allude to his direction when I say he's better with a second act. I'm not an idiot, I know directors have teams. One without the other, however, isn't much more than idle hands and an idea man. So if you're trying to hit me with the "Um, actually..." card, know this: I am as floored about this series as anyone else, but I am trying my best to see sense rather that be blinded by the bait that is in front of me. They WANT us to be angry. Want us to tear each other apart so they can look at it as proof that we are a toxic little fanbase and churn out more garbage. THAT'S the game plan.

  • @zestyfg
    @zestyfg 16 днів тому +258

    Everything after Mando season 2 has shown that Filoni and Favreau need each other.

    • @troy5400
      @troy5400 16 днів тому +23

      Bad Batch is fire

    • @lightningleopard8877
      @lightningleopard8877 16 днів тому +12

      @@troy5400but wasn’t Filoni or at least fully him😅

    • @davidm4566
      @davidm4566 15 днів тому +17

      @@troy5400BB is just ok. It never really filled it's potential.

    • @Atamatchstix
      @Atamatchstix 15 днів тому +4

      @@troy5400It really is great but it had so much potential

    • @xsiphone2570
      @xsiphone2570 15 днів тому +1

      BB is the best in the past 7 years

  • @h4roldproductions148
    @h4roldproductions148 16 днів тому +205

    He sometimes screws up but he can also cook

    • @OivaJuhani-bv6zn
      @OivaJuhani-bv6zn 16 днів тому +14

      Let him cook!

    • @Kriv-kj6lk
      @Kriv-kj6lk 15 днів тому +3

      Very true

    • @tedscheett9420
      @tedscheett9420 15 днів тому +14

      This is the same guy who okayed Jar Jar canonically having a love interest and the Umbara arc. He's a bit clumsy at times, but he's got heart.

    • @h4roldproductions148
      @h4roldproductions148 15 днів тому +12

      @@tedscheett9420 to add on to this, Filoni also made the poopy Martez sister arc, and made masterpiece known as the siege of Mandalore

    • @tedscheett9420
      @tedscheett9420 15 днів тому +6

      @@h4roldproductions148 The most important part of the Martinez sisters arc was setting up Maul's involvement in Mandalore. And that could have been done literally any other way. But Siege of Mandalore had me on the edge of my seat the entire time.

  • @jacobs1834
    @jacobs1834 16 днів тому +388

    I still trust him more than the creator of the acolyte.

    • @ImTheDudeGames
      @ImTheDudeGames 16 днів тому

      I still trust him more than Kathleen's false-feminist ass

    • @Qoobon_
      @Qoobon_ 16 днів тому +44

      Well guess who he is and what he co-made

    • @Lilac-and-Gooseberries
      @Lilac-and-Gooseberries 16 днів тому +53

      Actually apparently the witches in the Acolyte were his idea.

    • @jacobs1834
      @jacobs1834 16 днів тому +3

      @@Qoobon_ don’t care

    • @andreababcock2622
      @andreababcock2622 16 днів тому +16

      Leslie Hedyland is a fairly low bar.

  • @the8thknight178
    @the8thknight178 16 днів тому +61

    I trust him. Come on the guy brought us the Clone Wars...

    • @connordorman117
      @connordorman117 15 днів тому +4

      One of many and he seldom wrote ir directed yet he is credited for everything.

  • @patatebanine4278
    @patatebanine4278 13 днів тому +5

    Basically, Filoni is just an animator and artistic director, not a sci-fi director or live action director. This is a guy who has been running his whole life to get a contract to compete with his old friends Michael Dante DiMartino and Bryan Konietzko (creator of Avatar). He didn't have a contract to do his own animation so he decided to stay with Lucasfilm because he knows that it's a big, renowned franchise and that it brings in money. He went too far doing live action because it's not his job.

  • @Alexanderbuilds2001
    @Alexanderbuilds2001 16 днів тому +45

    I enjoy clone wars, rebels, bad batch, tales of the Jedi. So yes I do.

  • @johnwscarpenter
    @johnwscarpenter 15 днів тому +10

    Filoni did a fantastic job with the Clone Wars. His creation of the Ashoka character brought forth one of the most beloved characters in the SW universe.
    But under Disney something about the SW stories and writing went sideways. We can’t read Filoni’s mind. But it seems like he has bent to the will of unseen higher-ups who do not appear to care a great deal about SW. It’s a damn shame.

  • @IgnisNatus
    @IgnisNatus 15 днів тому +6

    No that much... He put the idea of witches and force thread in the acolyte...

    • @UnimaFilms
      @UnimaFilms 11 днів тому +2

      Who gave you this information ???

    • @IgnisNatus
      @IgnisNatus 11 днів тому

      ​@@UnimaFilmsit's written in star wars website. Let me find it...

    • @gig9499
      @gig9499 5 днів тому +1

      Imo, povs are ok. Witches have been around for the clone wars, and the force can be seen *like* a thread in the grand span of things. Writing the thread as if its the only accepted way of seeing the force isnt the best way to write it. In fact, the ideas couldve served as a skeleton for the development of a new culture and people, like how the nightsisters were introduced, but the show just left it like that

  • @fazbrogaming7776
    @fazbrogaming7776 16 днів тому +75

    Dave Filloni is the best writer we have in Star Wars rn, closest thing to George Lucas, my only issue with Dave is that he chooses to mostly ignore anything related to the books and comics, then retcons them in his tv shows.

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 16 днів тому +3

      Boycott him. Don't watch his shit. Money is the only thing that matters

    • @scrrin
      @scrrin 16 днів тому +18

      That's not how you spell Tony Gilroy (and the rest of the Andor writers).

    • @Retrouno
      @Retrouno 16 днів тому +2

      Christ it’s that bad?

    • @JohnDman2020
      @JohnDman2020 16 днів тому

      Lol

    • @Retrouno
      @Retrouno 16 днів тому

      @@JohnDman2020 Star Wars shill

  • @JainaSoloB312
    @JainaSoloB312 15 днів тому +15

    Dave is literally George's apprentice and they're still super good friends, he's literally the closest thing to having George still telling SW stories. That is to say, yeah I trust him but I don't deify him and he does his best work with many creative minds helping him

    • @ryanmussell739
      @ryanmussell739 15 днів тому +2

      I like Dave more when he is working with favreau.

  • @spartadragonrider
    @spartadragonrider 15 днів тому +4

    Hot take, you never could trust Filoni, hes got a certain way of writing things that would probably work best in non-cannon continuities like infinities. only a handful of clone wars episodes were actually good, rebels was worse and it only went downhill from there. He was never a "savior" he was the begining of the end.

  • @TheTrueMorse64
    @TheTrueMorse64 16 днів тому +7

    Harvey Dent… can we trust him!?

  • @ArtinPanda
    @ArtinPanda 16 днів тому +56

    Help me Dave Filoni, you're my only hope.

    • @kenechukwueze6217
      @kenechukwueze6217 16 днів тому +3

      🤣🤣🤣 filoni os trash

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 16 днів тому +1

      George Lucas*

    • @madwibble
      @madwibble 15 днів тому

      Dave Feloni? Now that's a name I haven't heard in a long time.

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 15 днів тому

      @@madwibble this fool believes in Dave Filoni. How sad....

  • @hotfroganimations
    @hotfroganimations 12 днів тому +2

    Dude just doesnt want to be fired. Chief creative officer is clearly a meaningless title.

  • @EduardN6448
    @EduardN6448 11 днів тому +1

    All was looking good... then "The Acolyte" dropped, and so did my hopes for Star Wars

  • @CaptainphoenixofficialYT
    @CaptainphoenixofficialYT 16 днів тому +2

    I trust Filoni. Yes, I know he isn't perfect but he's done great projects in the past and understands the core of Star Wars. I think it's great that he's overseeing multiple projects as Star Wars does need a unified direction and I'm glad he's at least planned both Ahsoka season 2 and chunks of the movie (that's WAY more than I can say for the sequel trilogy).
    Overall, I'm somewhat optimistic with Filoni at the helm.

  • @brittanyjtaylor2638
    @brittanyjtaylor2638 16 днів тому +19

    I will trust him when we see Thrawn fight the Grysk

    • @Vihaan-hl3lp
      @Vihaan-hl3lp 14 днів тому +1

      Fr dude I can't believe thrawn is being done so dirty and if he loses to the rebellion again I'll never trust him

    • @LoganMcBride325
      @LoganMcBride325 14 днів тому

      I agree. The best part about Thrawn is the Chiss Ascendancy. They were easily the best Thrawn books that Zahn wrote. Although I have my doubts about the Ascendancy playing a large role.

  • @Painful_Production
    @Painful_Production 16 днів тому +2

    He can be one with the force, but we should be worried should the dark side find him.

  • @CometTangoOfficial
    @CometTangoOfficial 16 днів тому +3

    If he has oversight of all star wars projects... then why on earth didn't he push harder to stop the Acolyte Episode 3 from happening?

    • @Kriv-kj6lk
      @Kriv-kj6lk 15 днів тому +2

      Not his show, he mainly provides guidance to do with lore for the other creators. He approved the idea of the witches, but they weren’t under his creative control.

  • @octosalias5785
    @octosalias5785 13 днів тому

    I would say his only weakness is the 'Star Wars Brand Chase Scene' which are often wacky cartoonish and usually a different tone than the show. This Acolyte thing was clearly planned since at least The Last Jedi

  • @mkhud50n
    @mkhud50n 16 днів тому +6

    Let’s not judge it till it’s over. I’m already noticing deeper layers to it that I missed the first time. It’s growing on me.

    • @Bane520
      @Bane520 15 днів тому +1

      From what... The Acolyte???

    • @ForceMaximus84
      @ForceMaximus84 13 днів тому

      Dude, Acolyte betrays everything Lucas set up about the force in the name of a sick agenda.

    • @mkhud50n
      @mkhud50n 13 днів тому

      @@ForceMaximus84 wrong, people saying that are too lazy to figure it out or they don’t understand Star Wars themselves. Look up a diagram of the yin yang symbol. It’s that. That’s balance. Been that way for thousands of years and always will be. It’s what Star Wars is based on. So is Acolyte.

    • @ForceMaximus84
      @ForceMaximus84 13 днів тому

      @@mkhud50n Lucas would never have gone for this. Filloni got cornered, so he played along. This should not be considered cannon.

    • @mkhud50n
      @mkhud50n 13 днів тому

      @@ForceMaximus84 lol what about it bothers you. Be specific.

  • @dragonblaster-vu8wz
    @dragonblaster-vu8wz 15 днів тому

    I think Dave will bring something that's majorly needed to Star Wars: consistency. Story ideas have gone all over the place, so it'll be nice to have someone that can piece everything together so the lore makes sense

  • @oliversherman2414
    @oliversherman2414 16 днів тому +8

    This man saved Star Wars with the Clone Wars!

    • @willyzsafe-roomu9435
      @willyzsafe-roomu9435 16 днів тому +6

      by changing the entire personality of the characters, retconning lots of stuff, and making Ahsoka one of the main characters in Star Wars... Yeah...nope

    • @oliversherman2414
      @oliversherman2414 16 днів тому +6

      @@willyzsafe-roomu9435 Ahsoka's one of my favourite characters, so I don't see the problem there. And I say he improved the characters, especially the clones

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 16 днів тому +4

      Star wars never needed saving......what horseshit is that?

    • @willyzsafe-roomu9435
      @willyzsafe-roomu9435 16 днів тому +1

      @@Amp661 exactly, like, prequels are actually pretty okay movies to watch, and they got some info in there, like in Attack of the Clones there's mentioned that Clones are very obedient and will follow every order. Or in Revenge of the Sith where Palpatine says "The time has come" which meant the Clones knew about Order 66 before and TCW just pretends that line doesn't exist and makes some inhibitor chips so that way some of the clones will just refuse to do Order 66 and or will feel guilty

    • @Emoji_Smiles
      @Emoji_Smiles 16 днів тому +1

      GEORGE did. Stop giving filoni all the credit.

  • @DanTVonYouTube
    @DanTVonYouTube 16 днів тому +32

    Yes I think that he could SAVE star wars

  • @dirtpirate36
    @dirtpirate36 16 днів тому +8

    I think we can. I think he gave some token deference here and there to Kennedy so that he would be in position to take over the whole thing, or the very least have total creative control over his projects, when they finally kick her out.

  • @user-yr5ky4nt4x
    @user-yr5ky4nt4x 16 днів тому +3

    I hope we can trust him he might be the only director we have left.😮🤔

  • @wojti225
    @wojti225 16 днів тому +9

    I mean...he deleted the "Ahsoka" novel from the canon and disrespected "Dark Disciple" by bringing Asajj back.

    • @ultrabrian8151
      @ultrabrian8151 16 днів тому +4

      Actually he didn’t.

    • @wojti225
      @wojti225 16 днів тому

      @@ultrabrian8151 Could you say something more?

    • @Sultan_Vader_VI
      @Sultan_Vader_VI 16 днів тому

      I’m assuming they are gonna go back and discuss it but the creators of TBB specifically stated ventress’s return would be done in such a way that dark disciple isn’t retconned.

    • @wojti225
      @wojti225 16 днів тому

      @@Sultan_Vader_VI That's why I said it disrespected the book, not that it deleted it from the canon. Most of the emotions from a characters death comes from not being able to see them later. That's why I don't care how are they gonna explain how Asajj returned. What mostly matters to me is that she returned.

    • @Kriv-kj6lk
      @Kriv-kj6lk 15 днів тому +2

      From how I see it there seems to be an unsaid rule that lucasfilm is the only creative which can make canon, anything done by other authors are subject to change.

  • @fazbrogaming7776
    @fazbrogaming7776 16 днів тому +5

    I’m hoping Abaoloth will play a massive role in season 2 of Ahsoka since it seems that’s who Bayland is after. I’m also hoping it will be revealed that Anakin is the next ruler of Mortis. He is the chosen one after all so it makes sense.

    • @TDF-34212
      @TDF-34212 16 днів тому +1

      How do we know that it's Abeloth, or that's who its presumed to be? There weren't any references of her.

    • @TheTrollingMaster-xr9el
      @TheTrollingMaster-xr9el 16 днів тому +2

      @@TDF-34212he’s after something involving the mortis gods so Abeloth might be a factor though I personally don’t think so

    • @TDF-34212
      @TDF-34212 16 днів тому

      @@TheTrollingMaster-xr9el Ah, okay.

  • @Dobbythecat123
    @Dobbythecat123 15 днів тому

    “Yes, yes I do I’m very good at staying awake” 💀

  • @TGerreGT
    @TGerreGT 16 днів тому +2

    The guy is like a career-backup. Definitely knows the lore better than everybody, but it doesn't make him a good filmmaker, and at this point, he's more interested in telling stories of extras on his previous shows, than taking care of the big picture. Satisfying the nerdiest nerds won't get the franchise back on track, unfortunately.

    • @maineloon1515
      @maineloon1515 16 днів тому

      If only that were the case lol, I love when Star Wars gets weird. But I understand causal viewers want to see Yoda, Anakin etc… weird Star Wars is some of the best and people don’t know what they’re missing!

    • @TGerreGT
      @TGerreGT 16 днів тому

      @@maineloon1515 That's not what I meant. I'm actually happy, that the so-called "Skywalker saga" is not in the main focus anymore, it was already worn down for quiet a while. I've spoken to some younger fans around the time when Disney decanonized the old extended universe, and created the "Legends" category, and they were actually welcoming to the idea, because they though that all the old material was way too chaotic, like authors were allowed to release whatever, with next to no supervision at all, and they wanted to have at least some sort of a structure. I accepted that argument, but it was only some novels, and comics, consumed by only a small fraction of the most hardcore fanbase, so it didn't cause any major problems anyway. When we only had to deal with Lucas contradicting himself with some storylines in the prequels, it was way easier to say, "OK, whatever". But right now, SW has like dozens of cooks in the kitchen, and it's not just for the 1% any more, it's for everybody. Filoni could be the one who stops this, but he doesn't. I don't know why, I don't know what's going on behind the scenes, maybe he doesn't have the jurisdiction to say this or that, but the stuff he actually works on is not helping either. It's filler content.
      I think we need more stuff like Rogue One. It was a perfect fit for SW. There was plenty of room for it, it didn't break canon, and it was executed nicely. The Kenobi show could've been the same, or even better, but they completely wasted the potential. The Book of Boba Fett was at least mostly harmless. If you don't like it, you can skip it, and nothing changes. But The Acolyte for example will go down as a "try to pretend it never happened" kind of thing, and right after an actually promising thing, which is Andor, so we still never know what comes next. We can't really trust them to learn from either failure and success as we move on. Remember, that the Skeleton Crew supposed to come out first this year? I wonder what happened...

    • @maineloon1515
      @maineloon1515 16 днів тому

      @@TGerreGT I agree that they can't learn from failure. I did not mind Obi-Wan but they really missed the mark there, Book of Boba also was not bad but again, missed the mark. So far I am enjoying the Acolyte and I hope its sticks the landing. I would really love to go to the Old Republic era, so much room for expansion and such! I'm not a big book reader to be honest, the weird I was referring to was more directed at the Nightsisters, Mortis, Force origin such (Yoda's adventure arc in CW season 6) and that stuff. I think a lot of people are hating on the Acolyte for political reasons and such and simply trying to stir stuff up rather than let the show run its season and then make the rants and stuff. I would say Dave isn't stopping some of the stuff we would like him to for 2 reasons, 1) he enjoys what he reads, so he supports it and it doesn't turn out how he thought. 2) Kathleen Kennedy simply says what's going to happen and he has to go along with it. But yeah wonder where Skeleton Crew is???

    • @TGerreGT
      @TGerreGT 15 днів тому

      @@maineloon1515 Okay, I can respect that. I'm actually not a big fan of the animated series, because it's responsable for a lot of the problems that effect the writing to this day, like bringing people back from the dead, and undoing things that supposed to be permanent, otherwise it can't be taken seriously. Some of the characters introduced there are cool, but breaking continuity with things like presenting Ahsoka as Anakin's padawan, while she's nowhere around in the movies, is just dumb, and annoys the hell out of me.
      I agree that The Acolyte didn't get it's fair chance from the fans, but I can't help myself thinking that what we have seen so far, is bad. And the showrunner lady talking shit to the fanbase during her press tour...man...I honestly don't understand how it supposed to help her cause, whatever it may be. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to ruin it for You, I'm glad that at least somebody is having a good time.

    • @maineloon1515
      @maineloon1515 15 днів тому +1

      @@TGerreGT I completely understand your perspective, if I read books and comics and then shows came a long and completely upended them I would hold a grudge too. Don't get me wrong I have not loved or even liked a lot of what the show runner has said but even though she has spearheaded doesn't mean there isn't merit to the story nor does it mean that everything in the show is bad. But I would like to thank you for being civil in this discourse and not being demeaning or anything such as that, unfortunately that happens too much in comment sections like this. :)

  • @hellstrom4209
    @hellstrom4209 16 днів тому +2

    I'd say he is like George Lucas in where he has great ideas, but needs help with the execution of those ideas. People bashed Lucas for the prequels, which were all directed and written by him, in contrast to ANH and ESB.
    I think Filoni should have a writters room to help better execute his ideas like with TCW and Rebels.

    • @bathsaltvendor
      @bathsaltvendor 15 днів тому +1

      Yeah, his ideas actually come from someone who loves Star Wars. I hope he gets some of the old writing team from TCW to help him out with ironing out season 2 of Ahsoka because there were quite a few writing issues in season 1.

    • @Kriv-kj6lk
      @Kriv-kj6lk 15 днів тому +1

      This is exactly right, he retains, for better or worse, some of the flaws and strengths of George Lucas. My best suggestion moving forward would be to get Timothy Zahn to help him write Ahsoka season 2.

    • @bathsaltvendor
      @bathsaltvendor 15 днів тому

      @@Kriv-kj6lk Agreed! He gets the vibe of Thrawn right, but actually showing Thrawn getting down to brass tacks is where he's weakest. A Timothy Zahn consultation would be perfect!

  • @SraMacaco
    @SraMacaco 14 днів тому

    Absolutely, but I admire more than his creativity; I admire his soul. He is kind, open-minded, inclusive, funny, conscientious, hard-working, willing to learn and grow - all qualities that I admire in a person and that come out in his work. I love everything he’s done, then I watch the analyses done by people smarter than I am and love it even more for the deeper stuff I missed. He is not perfect; no one is, but I don’t care - Dave Filoni is my hero.

  • @fazbrogaming7776
    @fazbrogaming7776 16 днів тому +6

    I’m probably alone on this boat but I don’t really see much of an issue with Alolye ep 3, the whole force string thing is just the way these witches perceive the force, no different to how the Zeffo from fallen order see it as The Life Wind or the nightsisters as magic.
    Just another religion that has a different view in the force than the Jedi.

    • @maineloon1515
      @maineloon1515 16 днів тому +1

      Thank you so much for saying this! I 100% agree, just like in real life with religion, Islam, Christianity, and Judaism are basically different interpretations of the same idea and the Force has this same concept. I love world building and while the episode and series isn’t perfect I’m enjoying it and can’t wait to see where it goes. Thanks for not being so negative like so many other people!

  • @wickdaline8668
    @wickdaline8668 16 днів тому +20

    He's about to ship Wolfwren 😳

    • @AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk
      @AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk 16 днів тому +6

      Bruh
      That ship is so dumb

    • @noah-os5ev
      @noah-os5ev 15 днів тому +2

      ​@@AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk I agree that ships ass.

    • @AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk
      @AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk 15 днів тому +2

      Fr set up Ezra and sabine for seasons make them siblings just so u can make Sabine Mary Sue and in love with her rival.

    • @noah-os5ev
      @noah-os5ev 15 днів тому

      @@AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk Sabine should be with space Moses.

    • @AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk
      @AnakinSkywalker-qe2rk 15 днів тому

      Fr

  • @RealMilester1
    @RealMilester1 14 днів тому

    The only bad thing he has done that makes kinda no sense in the timeline is killing off Darth Maul, since it is weird that he is at the end of Solo but then he dies to Kenobi after being stranded in that weird sith ruins

  • @Raichiro
    @Raichiro 16 днів тому +20

    After 3 misses back to back? Nah. Think he has too much on his plate

  • @Invalidcookie-bv4cx
    @Invalidcookie-bv4cx 15 днів тому +1

    No. ONE PERSON without any input from someone else is never a good idea.
    George had his wife. then Spielberg. You need someone to go "This is a stupid idea" sometimes.
    Even Filoni had that when he did Clone Wars. Henry Gilroy wrote most of the episodes. If you want Star wars to start heading
    in the right direction he needs someone to knows how to tell a story. Henry Gilroy was a Cartoon writer in the 80s/90s.
    So Gilroy had the knowledge to build a story around Filoni's ideas.

  • @spikefishnetwork1118
    @spikefishnetwork1118 15 днів тому

    Denile is on of the stages of grief. Filioni is a boloni

  • @GiovanniAlckmimRusso
    @GiovanniAlckmimRusso 16 днів тому +1

    Is Dave Filoni better than woman from Acolyte? Yes. Is he great? No. With Favreau he did great as seen in Mandalorian seasons 1 and 2. By himself he is hit or miss

  • @LtDavidB312
    @LtDavidB312 13 днів тому +1

    He wasn’t actually trustworthy before, so no.

  • @Vilgax00
    @Vilgax00 16 днів тому +4

    He is the only one who has actuall understanding of the starwars lore. He is not perfect. But he is the best option we have so far.

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 16 днів тому

      So do i, yet i dont want the job. Only Lucas.

  • @xbradx75
    @xbradx75 15 днів тому +1

    umm, his job is literally to take Star Wars in the direction he feels is best for Star Wars, not what some whiny youtube grifters pushing their own hate-fueled agendas for clicks and cash. He's long earned my trust in handling the franchise's direction.

  • @piotrziemba2257
    @piotrziemba2257 16 днів тому +8

    will all of this we shall see

  • @bulghar_the_grey
    @bulghar_the_grey 13 днів тому

    It is true that Dave defended The Acolite series, but I think he did it more than anything to demonstrate a certain unity among the great producers of Lucasfilm. His projects have shown a certain maturity, so I think we can trust him...

  • @Well-Hello-There
    @Well-Hello-There 16 днів тому +1

    Give us George, Brice, and Fav and full autonomy from Disney then we have a new hope.

  • @patatebanine4278
    @patatebanine4278 13 днів тому

    George Lucas wanted an awesome animated film like Avatar in 2008 so he tried to hire Bryan and Michel, the creators of Avatar, the Last Airbender in the first place but they refused because they were working. So Lucas wanted to take someone who worked on some episode of Avatar and that was Dave Filoni.

  • @JjAnteros
    @JjAnteros 15 днів тому +1

    Well, it sounds to me like he is not even in the writing phase yet, or if he is that he has only written the 1st few major scenes, according to what was said here, so i think 2027 would be generous to assume is when we get this film tbh, writing a movie usually takes atleast a few months, casting a couple months, pre production a few months, etc, if the movie is set to come out let's say the end of 2027 then they should already atleast have the writing for the movie half way done by now, this just seems like it is going to be too rushed to even make the 2027 deadline now tbh, or if it does make the 2027 deadline i hope that he atleast knows how he is going to end the movie by now tbh lol

  • @ALEXACEDEATH
    @ALEXACEDEATH 15 днів тому

    Man has more Ws than Ls, he loves and respects the franchise, has a crazy worth ethic and is just a straight up SW geek. I’d rather give him the keys to the SW kingdom than whatever the hell is happening on the Acolyte side of the company. When Dave fails, the product is passable at worst, when the Acolyte/sequels fail it seems like franchise suicide at best.

  • @coopermoore1867
    @coopermoore1867 16 днів тому +1

    How could u even say that he will be the savour of Star Wars

  • @LukeJamesActor
    @LukeJamesActor 6 днів тому

    He’s never gone give us R-rated. 😢

  • @ForceMaximus84
    @ForceMaximus84 13 днів тому

    I think he’s in a position where, since Kennedy is still in charge, if he doesn’t play ball, he’ll lose his job, and that would make things worse overall for Star Wars because there would be no one left to safeguard what Lucas created. Having said that, between Acolyte and his spearheading his Ahsoka character, he’s not doing a very good job of it.
    Lucas’ VII-IX or Nothing.

  • @Lilac-and-Gooseberries
    @Lilac-and-Gooseberries 16 днів тому +11

    According to Headland he’s the one responsible for the Acolyte witches.

    • @john90392
      @john90392 16 днів тому +9

      Doubtful. I'd take anything she says with a mountain of salt.

    • @Shredow2
      @Shredow2 16 днів тому +4

      "Filoni said my idea was fine" That in no way makes him responsible for anything, he just didn't feel the need to micro manage someone else's project when it's in a time period that doesn't affect the "main" time period. You guys need to relax and stop worrying so much. You can just ignore acolyte and nothing about the rest of the series changes too much.

    • @Deuteromis
      @Deuteromis 15 днів тому +2

      I think she's just trying to shift blame.

    • @pabloj.garcia2559
      @pabloj.garcia2559 15 днів тому

      ​@@john90392What is the diferencie between that witches from Acolyte and the nightsisters that make you dislike only one?

    • @LukiKruki
      @LukiKruki 15 днів тому +1

      @@pabloj.garcia2559 Both witch groups call Force under different name with different interpretation, both do crazy Force techniques, both do uncomfortable cult rituals. All Filoni did for Headland is telling her "Yes, you can create witch group seperate from Nightsisters. Yes, you can make them not use green liquid. Yes, you can make them include humans and non-Nightsister aliens. Yes, you can make Zyggerian Jedi". All he did is saying what can and cannot be done within Star Wars lore. Going by this logic Anakin Skywalker is still unique from twin sisters.

  • @brounjerghd6450
    @brounjerghd6450 15 днів тому +1

    He is good at doing animated shows, keep him doing that instead

  • @arbknight12
    @arbknight12 16 днів тому +4

    So he screws up once and that's it?
    We shun him?!
    No.
    In Dave we trust!

  • @bigestofthesmallbrains3307
    @bigestofthesmallbrains3307 16 днів тому +6

    He mainly does animated things. His animated stuff is really good. Ashoka was his first attempt at a live action show. I have a feeling once he gets the gang of love action stuff it will be great. I definitely have hope.

    • @ProtoArrow
      @ProtoArrow 16 днів тому

      Technically Mando was his first

  • @roycehuepers4325
    @roycehuepers4325 14 днів тому

    Considering even though KK had her fongers in s3 of Mandalorian and it was at least good over all because of Filoni, yeah, i do.

  • @user-cu8zf5ln1i
    @user-cu8zf5ln1i 13 днів тому

    In the grand scheme of things, people really seem to forget how small his rate of error is. Mando season 3 is the only majority ‘bad’ project he ever did, and even then the one well-rated episode of that season was the one he was involved in the most. The closest from that would be bad batch and Ashoka, which are mixed in quality and audience review but are still positive in both regards. Bobs Fett is a bit harder to trace cause it was clusterfuck of directors and writers, so it seems unfair to blame it on any one person . Everything else he’s done has been top class. Clone wars and Rebels and Mando 1-2 are all masterworks. Comparing to the others, the guy writing Andor is clearly very talented, but also currently has only that to his name. Outside of Andor and Filoni’s work, Disney has yet to produce a single successful Star Wars project. Even Lucas fumbled the bag with a sub-par third entry to his original trilogy, and a prequel trilogy which is objectively garbage and only made good because of the supporting projects that filoni did.

  • @ozziecomedian1786
    @ozziecomedian1786 13 днів тому

    George Lucas, Dave Filoni, Jon Favreau, and Tony Gilroy are the ones we can trust the most with Star Wars.

  • @treytucker7404
    @treytucker7404 15 днів тому

    The way I see it Leslye Headland needs to take notes from him instead of trying to convince the world that you can have your cake and eat it too.

  • @ahpierce1
    @ahpierce1 12 днів тому

    In Dave we trust

  • @Maikigai
    @Maikigai 16 днів тому

    Filoni is the only one we actually can trust

  • @dennisbuckley3749
    @dennisbuckley3749 15 днів тому

    I trust him. In my opinion Dave is more about quality of a show rather than quantity. He’s got this.

  • @jesusa.adorno6933
    @jesusa.adorno6933 16 днів тому

    As a Dave Filoni fan, I think it’s hyperbole to call him a savior, when he’s done some fumbles along the way & his style can be different at times. He has fumbled before, but it’s shown that he cares about Star Wars & wants to honor George’s legacy.
    From what I’ve seen, I’ve been enjoying Ahsoka, & I sincerely hope the Mando movie is solid & up to the quality of the first two seasons of Mando, from what I’ve heard.
    I’d take him instead of someone with no plan at all.

  • @brockcarter8748
    @brockcarter8748 16 днів тому +2

    ahsoka season one proved he is failing

  • @zacswicord4496
    @zacswicord4496 15 днів тому

    My policy is to never trust anyone too much in regards for directing Star Wars. Don’t forget that it was George Lucas being given full creative control which got us the prequels compared to his work with the original trilogy where there were people who helped him refine his project.

  • @KananJarrus-vs7ig
    @KananJarrus-vs7ig 16 днів тому

    He is still Star Wars savior I trust him I grew up with rebels and his shows so I trust him.

  • @Spider_Variant96
    @Spider_Variant96 14 днів тому

    The idea of putting faith in one person to "save" Star Wars has and always will be DUMB.

  • @brickempire9664
    @brickempire9664 14 днів тому

    I do belive he is doing his best especially eith Kathleen Kennedy watching him but his star animation shows are incredible so we can rely on him for those.

  • @idontdovarioustasks
    @idontdovarioustasks День тому

    Well he seems to be about the best that we've ... got?

  • @kuribayashi84
    @kuribayashi84 15 днів тому

    How far does the leash go KK keeps him on? That’s how far I trust him.

  • @TheArcher101
    @TheArcher101 15 днів тому

    I think the higher up he goes in the company, the closer he gets to Kennedy and the other like-minded execs
    This probably means the pressure to do things their way or lose his position and career traction is going to be higher
    Everything with him and the projects under his name mighty not be going the way we want, especially compared to his earlier work - but I don't really blame him for it, and it's still easily better than some other recent Disney SW projects regardless

  • @kaboose111
    @kaboose111 15 днів тому

    I think Dave works best when providing ideas to better directors.

  • @daltonbalusek
    @daltonbalusek 14 днів тому

    I think we can, but he needs someone to sometimes simply tell him no, or to reel back ideas. As much as I love Ahsoka Tano I think it is time Dave let her go and focus on other new characters.

  • @gandalfthewhite.5245
    @gandalfthewhite.5245 14 днів тому

    Let him cook.

  • @chaosthegod
    @chaosthegod 15 днів тому

    Filoni isn't trust worthy since TCW. I'm really surprised that most of the disney era fandom likes him, since he couldn't care less for a cohesive timeline. But I guess the new gen of fans don't care about it. They didn't care when a whole timeline was discontinued, they sure don't care by book authors being smashed needlessly so he can put out an action packed tv show.

  • @Deuteromis
    @Deuteromis 15 днів тому

    I still need to watch Ashoka, but I plan on watching Rebels first though. If he does Season 2 might be interesting if Barass shows up yeah she got stabbed in Tales of the Empire but we didn't see her exactly die.

  • @kamixakadio2441
    @kamixakadio2441 16 днів тому +1

    He does make some mistakes, some poor writing decisions, but currently, he is the only writer that on any remote level, cares about writing. I'd rewatch Ahsoka season one 100 times before I'd rewatch Acolyte once.

  • @gpt.answers
    @gpt.answers 15 днів тому

    i just want to see hayden christensen

  • @JazzMaster01
    @JazzMaster01 15 днів тому

    I really hope Filoni does in fact take the criticisms of ahsoka season 2 and improves. I still trust him and Favreau more than other writer and stuff. I just feel like KK got involved too much with Mando season 3 and that's why it flopped. And I think Filoni just wasn't as experienced doing live action with Ahsoka. He's a master at animated SW stuff obviously with CW and Rebels, but he just needs to practice and focus more to improve his live action skills. I still trust him with SW. I think he understand the story and lore as much(or very close) to George. He's even admitted multiple time that if he's working on a story and doesn't know where to take the story or what to do with certain characters, he'll call up George and ask what he thinks should be done. Idk I think he still loves and respects the franchise enough to make good SW. That's just my opinion at least

  • @onvogmasaj
    @onvogmasaj 16 днів тому +1

    never could never did

  • @MasterofMonkeys16
    @MasterofMonkeys16 15 днів тому +1

    I feel like most star wras hate comes from nowhere, i think people forgot what Star Wars really is. The only really bad projects that should have been better nad were major let downs, were the seuqels

  • @valmid5069
    @valmid5069 15 днів тому

    Viewers: man UA-cam rec is lame
    Star Wars Content: *Hello There!!!!*

  • @phoenixr6811
    @phoenixr6811 16 днів тому

    I’m good with the direction Dave Filoni is going with Stars Wars. Stars Wars is a sci fi and fictional universe that is continuously evolving and needs to evolve if it is to be around for the next 50 years.😊

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 16 днів тому

      Somethings don't need to be kept going for 50 years......

  • @crocdoctor7581
    @crocdoctor7581 13 днів тому

    everything he's been involved in has been a lot closer to George's vision than almost anything else made without either of them not to bring down everything else that has been made by other creators cause some of it isn't half bad but me personally the rest is hit or terribly miss and crash

  • @anotheronebitesthedust-fs6wr
    @anotheronebitesthedust-fs6wr 16 днів тому

    Obviously we can trust him he still apparently talks to george lucas

  • @Obiwancatnobi006
    @Obiwancatnobi006 16 днів тому +6

    Dave Felony "I love the EU, so much that I will constantly steal and destroy it's legacy"

  • @themcabbages77
    @themcabbages77 16 днів тому

    He is The Chosen One

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 16 днів тому

      Lol!!!!! Please.....

  • @Max.R674
    @Max.R674 15 днів тому

    At the moment I think Star Wars needs everything it can get. I mean Acolyte is really not doing well and when it's finished in the middle of next month Star Wars will need success to fix the series' flaws.

  • @breakupgoogle
    @breakupgoogle 16 днів тому +1

    Never could

  • @nathanskywalker1536
    @nathanskywalker1536 16 днів тому

    The guy is making a movie which takes time and I trust Dave he worked with George Lucas this movie could take up to 2 or 3 years to make you need to write a script preproduction production filming especially a movie like star Wars

  • @barkley8285
    @barkley8285 14 днів тому

    Never could trust Dave phony

  • @longarrowthegreat5230
    @longarrowthegreat5230 12 днів тому

    People who hate on Filoni are the same people who support the Acolyte.
    I had a conversation with my friend. He was talking about how much Dave sucked and that he should be kicked out of Star Wars. Bro wasn’t letting me get a single word out. So I asked him to let me say one sentence without interruption. He agreed.
    “You would prefer The Acolyte over Clone Wars?”
    Bro shut up and changed his mind REAL quick.

  • @sophieamandaleitontoomey9343
    @sophieamandaleitontoomey9343 16 днів тому +1

    Dave is too much of a hit or miss for me. I think with animation, he always delivers. But when it comes to the latest live action stuff, I think he helped nail the first season of Mando but that that was it.

    • @maineloon1515
      @maineloon1515 16 днів тому

      Ahsoka should’ve been animated. I loved seeing Hayden back and Rosario did a good job I think. However, I think that the animated characters should largely stay animated for no better reason really than just… because lol

  • @austin62halo
    @austin62halo 16 днів тому +1

    No, everyone’s got an agenda to push

  • @SimplyStopMotionActionFigureFu
    @SimplyStopMotionActionFigureFu 15 днів тому

    Not sure he's the issue. Seems? They sidelined the Men on this one! Including?! George Lucas! Who was 'Banned' from this one shows sets! Where? Every other show?! Welcomed his notes and hopeful 'praise' (pics of G.luc cuddling Grogu on the Mando set❤️) so.. yeah. Not sure he Had anything to do w this.

  • @Gingerbred_Hed
    @Gingerbred_Hed 16 днів тому

    Still better than johnson or whoever made acolyte.

  • @fatimafahad2493
    @fatimafahad2493 14 днів тому

    Ahsoka was so bad man 😔

  • @charliehaigh8161
    @charliehaigh8161 16 днів тому

    I find it strange that people love him so much. I dont hate him I just dont like the Ashoka Show. I wish disney would make more shows like visions. I am also quite dissapointed in the Star Wars fan base.
    Star Wars as a franchise was always political. The original triology touched on (for the time ) recent events like vietnam and nixon and stuff. Instead of complaining about disney dumbing down star wars people cry about trans and gay people appearing in shows (as if a galaxy far far away would even share the same values as us).
    Sorry for rambling :(