if theres an issue of central issues overshadowing state ones....why theres no single platform/site that displays every detail about the state and the central issues and what each party has contributed to resolve an issue and what issues that are not solved yet in an organised way. Such a platform would be very helpful for many people (90s and 2k most who dont care about them). I feel like the digital presence of India's governance is very low.
@ThinkSchool Bro you are biased, you are preferring north india politicians for your video clip and politicians who spoke about one nation and one election, also you are using the pictures of only noth India politicians. Why there is a discrimination??
Bhai in matters related to nation politics suppressing state politics in ONOE is not correct. U should have given example of odisa and andhra how people vote differently for both state and central gov. Mainly odisa voting in 2019 how could u miss that.
State elections need to happen together at once and general election separately. That makes sure the local issues are not neglected and also we make it a point to get done with them at once.
Then what's the point on even implementing this law cause as per your instructions it wouldn't be economically feasible 💲at all 😮🙄 Instead they should just pass it anyway don't you think the people will slowly get used to it as the political parties addresses this issue so the people will stillvote for state differently than the central election What's your opinion I really wanna know 😅
Being a resident of Odisha i completely support ONOE as in my state we cast our vote once for both lok shaba and state assembly without any problem and we are doing this from decades.
My analysis - INC will oppose anything that the BJP is doing (literally that's their stance after 2014) so no hopes from them to do critical thinking , but I have hopes from other regional parties , JPC was a good choice
If you jump on drainage don't expect everyone to jump we have our power to show atleast once in a year and you are trying to get away that also🤦♂️ once come to south states to see our development.. we are not saying we are 100% developed atleast we know where we lack .. now also BJP is majority why can't they improve anything?
Yes The indian voter are enough mature that they can differentiate b/w state and lok sabha election which we seen multiple times that voters voted for a different part in central and other in state assembly
Being member of Andhra who also votes for both Lok Sabha and state assembly at the same time, I don't spport ONOE as I want to protect my state specific narratives if given a chance and in case of a political turmoil and no confidence, I wouldn’t want to incentivise the new government to give freebies or clear large amount of farmer debts just to please them. As it take a long term (5-10 years) to bring some plans to fruition.
See USA, they also do all election (House, Senate and Presedent) in one go. Also we have seen that Odisha, Andhra Pradesh where state election happen with Lok Sabha, people had voted differently.
They compare what ever they like.. become like USA in every way then, if u want to compare. 😂 Also the candidates talk to people on talks shows n stay in touch with people unlike politicians in India who actually like kings.
It boils down to one simple argument that if people are smart enough to vote for different parties when elections are happening at different times ( lets say 6 months apart ) then they are also smart enough to vote for different parties when elections are happening at the same time.
that's the problem. people are not smart. people vote for lot of shit reasons... lot of people don't even have basic knowledge of how economy works. short term benefits wins over log term goals!
There is already enough proof in history of indian election to prove ppl are much smarter..! My state karnatka ( other states too ) is an example where ppl have voted for different government on same day ..! Multiple time since 80s
@@Gowtham91mn"not smart" is just being unfair on our voters, we can say that the Centre (who ever is in power)might bank on this confusion and see a majority of people choosing one particular party..
The opposition is called pappusition these days, just wasting parliamentary session time and not having a constructive opposing view. What a bunch of duds have opposition become
Looking at One party system like China , and how far ahead they are , seems it was the way to go but alas not possible , we will always be backwards as compared to them
@@prajwalparaskar2047 if dictatorship=development I don't really have any problem with that. What democracy has given us? Politicians who loot tax payers🤡🤡
I am from odisha and bjd is ruling odisha for more than 20 years He were frustrated with their corrupted party and government so we decided to change@@mthanos259
Frequent elections keep governments accountable. When a state election is due, ruling parties are pressured to deliver tangible results or face the consequences. This cycle ensures continuous governance rather than a focus solely on the general election years.
I can't comment on other parties or states. But, how TMC can question any party be it bjp, congress on matters of democracy, governance, economy, job, corruption and last not but the least patriotism ? 🤔
The logical thing in my opinion is to implement the second phase first .. instead of aligning state and centre elections together...make panchayat, muncipal and state elections together...since the same parties are in the panchayat and state....
Modi and BJP has very deep n innovative thinking who never thought one nation one election... Congress and opposition parties should atleast think 1% of nation growth..
Keep up the good work! I love your editing and your style of presenting the topic. It’s straight to the point and easy to understand. Looking forward to a million subscribers!
Those who think that one election will lead to people(both politicians and voters) not considering local issues while voting have a lot to learn about Indian democracy and the voters.
I can't speak for other states, but in Andhra Pradesh, where assembly elections are held simultaneously with parliamentary elections, regional parties have won 5 out of 6 times in the past 30 years. This clearly shows that "One Nation, One Election" won't necessarily diminish the presence of regional parties. It ultimately depends on the party's ideology and its connection with the people. I also disagree with your claim that most Indians prioritize national issues over state issues-it's actually the opposite. However, I do agree with your point that mid-term elections for short-term governments tend to undermine long-term issues.
I am BJP supporter from Maharashtra. I remember Maharashtra elections were postponed because EC couldn’t conduct Haryana and Maharashtra (two big states) elections together. Now they wanna conduct whole nation’s elections & all states together 😂 I am BJP supporter but can’t understand BJPs logic
Bro don't act like fool it's was not necessity to do both election at same time that's why arrangements are not made but if onoe become reality EC will prepare keeping these things in mind.
Major reform will be needed to do this. It is definitely possible though, but BJP needs to do a ton of work for it to happen. Everything from logistics to EVM will need change and reform. Overall, I think it's good for the unity of the country, but it will be a bit of a problem initially.
Basically story of each and every sector in india. We can improve so much if only we can make effecient use of our resources, human resources in this case
Do you think it will be successful ? Our media house is sleeping have you seen previous interview of Amit shah what questions they have asked teachers used to ask a class 2 grade students they want one nation one election but they will force media @@AbhAsh-w5g
Voters are smart and well-informed; they understand the distinction between national and state issues. Until 1967, India followed the system of “One Nation, One Election.” How can implementing this system again be considered the death of democracy? By that logic, is the Congress suggesting there was no democracy in India until 1967?
@@tanmaynarang2193 The Congress-led central government's use of Article 356 to dismiss state governments disrupted synchronized elections in some states. However, it was Indira Gandhi's decision in 1970 that ultimately ended synchronized elections in India.
What a good explanation! Hatts off you have covered this completely unbiased by mentioning advantages and disadvantages without letting your self opinion comming in between . This is what todays media lacks. Kudos 👏
I don't think so he missed the most important point, the political environment of India where hate and toxicity is increasing day by day because of this frequent election.
It's a humble request, please provide CC as well.. it will help us to understand the topic with more clarity.. Thank you for the information.. I highly appreciate ur efforts..❤
Hey Really love your videos, extremely informative and specially unbiased. Just a quick typo you can probably fix. At 15:34 under MLA it says Center, it should be saying state. Thanks for doing great work
Even without ONOE, freebies are given today and ending states like Karnataka in bankruptcy so stating that as a point against ONOE does not make sense!, also if you see Karnataka, People have voted to Congress for state govt and BJP for Central Govt, so the voter is definitely intelligent enough to vote to whom he wants! I am all in for ONOE! Lets GO!
Have been constant viewer of your channel for the last 2 years. But since last 2 months I've not watched a single video of urs because now I get full summary in text via AI, IMO saves a lot of time...
I love your videos . China has progressed so well because of their government policies cause they treat themselves as one nation. We as Indian should think in same way . I fully support the government policy. Lets strive towards growth and make India an economical superpower .
You really summarised the video very well....why we need 1 nation and 1 election when we can achieve that with little tweak in modal code of conduct 👍🏼👏🏼
if theres an issue of central issues overshadowing state ones....why theres no single platform/site that displays every detail about the state and the central issues and what each party has contributed to resolve an issue and what issues that are not solved yet in an organised way. Such a platform would be very helpful for many people (90s and 2k most who dont care about them). I feel like the digital presence of India's governance is very low
Well the point about mid-term elections where party will only focus on freebies to remain in power for the next elections after completing this shorter mid-term is insignificant and invalid. As parties are still spending so much amount of money on freebies to remain in power for 5 years. Take example of Delhi where Kejriwaal is promising even more freebies. Freebies will be always used by parties until there is no demand from public side, which will eventually happen. At least ONOE will be more efficient and stable than the current system despite the freebies. And as more people become educated and oppose spending tax money on freebies as its our own money, the freebie culture will end. I have understood that ONOE may seem much chaotic today but it has a long vision and promising results/growth in long term. It will definitely benefit the country a lot. And also...don't underestimate a voter, they know very well whom to vote on central issues and on state issues and this wisdom will only increase with time. Whoever agrees can like this :)
We actually started our democratic path under One Nation One Election,then in different states due to political instability governments started falling apart and now we are here that every year in some part or the other of the country election is happening
5 years is the least time that should be given to prove the points, it is a nation with the largest population, takes time to get the wheels to turn, it is about time Indians understand that state and local issues are what result in National issues.
Its simple really. Conduct Lok Sabha elections as they are. Then conduct state elections for all states on one day, which is exactly 2.5 yrs after Lok Sabha elections and a weekend. People can express their satisfaction, state parties are happy, just one day when entire nation will be closed.
It should be implemented ASAP ❤. It will save advertisement cost , 500 500 ke note wali freebies , manpower , and most importantly TIME (which is more important than money).❤
1. Unexpired term (lets say 2 years as taken in video) us time me koi party development ka kaam nhi kregi. It will just do some PR activities in the name of development and wait for next elections to be held after 2 years. 2. Jaise ye kaha ja rhaa hai ki 2014 me 7 mahine model code laga tha par kya poore desh me laga tha. NHI. 3 months poore desh me which was Lok sabha. Baaki 4 states me only 2 months more tha. Total 5 months in 4 states and only 3 months in whole of India. 3. Is new plan ke hisaab se atleast 6-7 months ka model code of conduct lagega. Firstlly 3 months for lok sabha vidhan sabha and then next 100 days (3.5 months) for local body. 4. The most important reason as also explained in this video: Local voices will totally go unheard. Ek hi kamre me 2 EVM hogi. Just think. Aap jaoge. Ek party ki achi image hogi. Dono evm pe same party ka button dabake aaoge. Its true for most of the people. 5. Then accountability khatam ho jayegi as explained with UP example. 6. Ye constitution me articles change, sab ko synchronise krna to 2029. Ye sab choti cheeze hai and one time hai. Real challenges jo upar bataye vo hai jin vajah se ONOE should not be passed. Instead One Nation 2 elections could be there. It will be best. Every 2.5 years me with only 1 month of model code of conduct every time.
I think 1 nation 2 election is better... Jahan pe election year mein hi central govt waala election year ke start mein ho aur doosra year ke end mein... + model code of conduct 1 month ka... Seems fair... Aur hamne Maharashtra elections se dekh hi liya hai.. ki 6 mahine baad bhi public ka opinion alag hota dikha hai...
In reviewing the challenges and concerns raised regarding the parliament bill, it is evident that while the highlighted issues merit consideration, their overall weight is significantly lower than the potential benefits the bill promises to deliver. The broader advantages, including long-term national progress, far outweigh the identified drawbacks, making this bill a step in the right direction.
What india actually needs is giving every state equal role for choosing the ruling party. Like in united States, thus every state will equally valued by central government after winning election. Then states of north east etc will be more developed, more efficient whole country projects etc etc. It will be beautiful. But the ruling govt never do that coz they won with influence of states like up etc😢
I think that's a flawed argument.. in America not all states get equal seats.. its done in accordance to population just like in India.. even in America high population states such as California Texas Florida and New York have a lot of seats compared to other states... And wake up dude.. bjp not only wins UP they literally win seats from every state except Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Punjab and Andhra (if no alliance)..even in northeast bjp is strong.
@harishmr6371 bro that's not what I meant. Remember the first time Trump wins the election? He was approx 2 lakhs vote behind hilary Clinton. But he won. It's not about America bro. But this change is essential for india. Also Don't get offended as every BJP bhakths . I'm telling any party don't dare to do that. Both BJP and congress. Also there are lots of incidents of BJP not caring much about states which they don't have rule 😂
Atleast theres a person who thinks reasonable, first we need to give the states the power they needed to develop the other cities not only their capitals apart from that india does not need any election reforms and stuff after developing cities then we need to change educational and labour reforms and after that employment
The argument that the local issues may get silenced, in my opinion is vague. Because local problem still gets overseen even with the current system we have. No political party truly cares about farmers and daily wage earners anyways.
BJP plan is to take whole country for granted for 5 years... People should keep quite for 5 long years... Whether it is congress or BJP in power, people will loose their voice... Very BAD IDEA of modi....
All elections at once is not possible Maybe Lok Sabha Elections+Assemblies of AP, Odisha, Maharashtra, Rajasthan, MP, Chattisgarh, Telangana, Arunachal Pradesh, Haryana, Jharkhand and Sikkim might be held at once. And during second cycle remaining all states would be held along with UP which can be held during midterm. I say One Nation One Election is very much needed because: 1) Party Central leadership's focus would be more on elections than on main issue which we saw during second wave of COVID when lockdown was purposefully delayed till May 6th 2021 I Guess when cases were rising from 1st week off April itself we saw what was the end result of that delay. Here all parties should be blamed mainly BJP which is in power. 2)More promising of unfesible non merit freebies or cross subsidies would happen frequently which can lead to disastrous State finances. 3)ECI's official cost of conducting those many elections is rising too fast. For 2019 General Elections itself ECI's cost was close to a billion USD. 4) Even Parties funding rallies cost would be too high which eventually will be recovered through corruption in contracts. Here Iam not saying that One Nation One Election would completely eradicate this but atleast it will remain unchanged or same because spending would be only for one time. Lastly its not that ECI can't organise such a big election ECI can. Infact during the times which date back to post Independence times till 1967 elections were held at one time for all. Do remember that time we had an unreliable logistics system and despite that ECI printed ballot papers then transported it till last polling booth and again taking back them to the counting stations everything was very difficult with unreliable logistics system back then. But still ECI did well. Then to conduct One Nation One Election now India needs around 4 million EVMs for all states and center combined. But we currently have around 2 milllion EVMs as said by Ex ECI chairman. I believe in manufacturing potential of India if we could assemble over a 10 million Mobile phones then we can pretty much assemble 2 million EVMs with considerable Local Value Addition. But the main challenge would be to deploy those many central forces for safe conduct of elections. I support this One Nation One Election
Arguments against the cons: 2. Overlapping Nation and State Issue: Facts, Let's talk about Modi (biggest 353 seats) wave in 2019, 4-5 months before lok sabha BJP lost Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh and Madhya Pradesh Vidhan sabha, but voters gave full majority to BJP in Lok sabha. Another in 2019 with Lok sabha election (parallel) there was elections in Orissa (Biju janta Dal: Full majority) and Andhra Pradesh (YSR Party). Voters are educated they know whom to vote and where. 3. Frequent elections, even though costly ensures that gov remain accountable to the people throughout their term: Context of Mid term crisis: Freebies are unstoppable until supreme court or election commission intervenes. ----------------- Add this point to Pros: 1. Elections damages the social fabric of India, How ?: Politician divide India into vote banks of Community (Hindu, Muslim), Castes , Regions (Bengali Identity, Kannada Identity, Marati Identity) which reach peak at the times of election. Polarization at Peak. USA is also an example where Black vs White happens. 2. Voters turnout will be more Every one will join the election, Every one can come home and join the election festival (This make democracy stronger) ------------------- Additioal Point: India is not new to one nation one election is not new to world, USA 2-8 Nov every 2 year, UK also does it. I don't think the democratics structure is damaged there.
This bill will revolutionize India. This is the most important bill brought by Govt. This is a huge relief to people. This will eliminate urban naxals, anti-India regional parties and unite India on one single day to vote for progress.
Lol real development by taxing people to the MAX. Broken judiciary and police. When something happens any case we file takes 10+ years to resolve. What development did Modi do ?
I believe it's great idea to have ONOP. It was like that before and the Congress changed it in 70s. However, it should be implemented and in few years after the implementation, everything will settle down. Jus imagine apart from saving thousands of crores, thousands of hours will be saved for those officials, police, teachers, etc. It improves voters turnout as well.
Maturity is , opposition should take note of this case study and argue in house, they are running baseless points in parliament. You should suggest according to your case study it should be implement or not, what is best in the interest of country. Everything comes with some pros and cons.
Earlier when I was a child, I never saw central govt campaign for local body or panchayat or state. Now this govt is in election mode 24×7 . So it's problem of BJP party not India's
@vofficial170 kisne bola ak hi party tha, saab party the, Janta party 1948 se thi. Congress kaam karta tha isliye baar baar jita, abhi 10 saal se BJP ne kiya achieve kiya 100 smart city bola tha, mujhe gin ke 5 dikha do baas, Inflation, Unemployment, Vikas ye saab mudda tha BJP ka 2014 mein, abhi Hindu Muslim, Mandir, Mutton, Machli pe ah gaya
@srvdass LOL smart city pata hai lekin aaj tak search bhi nhi hoga iske regarding news kyu ? FYI - 7,380 out of 8,075 projects, with an investment of ₹1,47,704 crore are done . 17 cities completed 100% of the work. 34% cities ne 90% projects complete kiya hai aur approx 75 cities aise hai jaha 74-75% projects complete hue hai . Aur before you start ranting about these stats first understand what smart city mission was , it was about area based development not some high-rise buildings and skyscrapers which I don't know where people get the information from. You can also watch the powertrain video on that .
Though it attracts hell lot of controversies it also reduces the burden on resources and election workers. Having the one nation and one election policy is a blessing but it should not be implemented in the blink of an eye. Centre should listen to all state legislatures and implement it in such a way that it should not be seen as their weapon against democracy.
It’s not a blessing at all why would I want the government to be able to do what ever it wants for four years and whitewash it in last year by freebies or by polarising the people
First, I thank Think School to come up with a very clear explanation. Here's my thought, - ONOE sounds good but a country like India do not need them. - Phase 1 should synchronize state elections on a single day. If MP elections occur in 2024, MLA elections should be in 2026. These are two separate elections, One spent by the Union government and the other spent by the State government. - This Bill gives itself the power to actually change how the State elections are conducted altering the balance of power between state and central governments in India. This should not happen as India is a Union of States and it will create Chaos - Assuming Tamil Nadu spends 600 crore, its annual budget is 4.5 lakh crore, totaling approximately 20 lakh crore over five years. This means that 600 crore represents only about 0.03% of the five-year budget, and less than 0.1% of Tamil Nadu's total budget. - People's voices and protest will only be heard at the time of elections (once in 5 years), Prices will reduce only at the time of elections (once in 5 years), Politicians will meet public only at the time of elections (once in 5 years) and so on. Price reductions, including for gas and petrol, are used as political tools solely in the final year of a term. ONEC will destroy the State's power of individuality. So Personally I stand against the Bill.
But bro after onoe the party can shift the focus from election to actual work and it will save thousands of crores which are wasted each year in elections. Also rewdi politics might also start decreasing because no party would offer freebies in all state at the same time
@@dhairyamittal1313 - India has the annual budget around 2023-2024: ₹47.13 lakh crore 2022-2023: ₹46.03 lakh crore 2021-2022: ₹34.83 lakh crore 2020-2021: ₹30.42 lakh crore 2019-2020: ₹26.99 lakh crore From 2019 to 2024 - In five years India has 185 lakh crore budget. The Amount cost for conducting the Lok Sabha election is around 10K crore - 15K crore. It's just 0.5 percent of the 5 Year budget. (But the amount that each party spend is totally depends upon how bad they want to win the election) In FY 2020 - 21 Govt is lost 1 lakh crore in taxes due to corporate tax cut. My question is if the govt is ready to bear 1 lakh crore for the corporate, why can't they spent 10K crore on people who chose the govt for the next 5 years? India is leaking money through various forms and that should be fixed first if they want to save money. - States like TN are prone to natural disaster. Modi was able to visit TN numerous times during the elections and never bothered to visit not even once during back to back record-breaking natural disasters. And imagine the case for Manipur. This is how the national parties are. They only engage with the public during election season, and people's anger is expressed solely through their votes. This is a key reason why the BJP lost all 40 seats in states like Tamil Nadu. - The limitations for spending in Elections should be monitored and should take serious actions. - IIndia's vast size means that many states have populations larger than some European countries. ONOE will pose significant challenges in this diverse nation. Even if 10 percent population opposes it, that means for India it's more than 100 million people and it will create a destruction in Democracy.
He is trying to preserve Hindus and Bharat , what happened to Kashmiri pandits ‘ what was Hindus condition in Gujarat pre Modi era there are infinite examples please open your eyes and see we are 100 years behind Modi is trying to catch up
There are so many points regarding one election one nation 1) As an Indian ,my Chief Justice is being selected by the majority of Ruling Party which is the already killing the democracy. If not counter this point with true facts 2) One Nation One Election , the center wants to have good hold in South Indian States through this. 3) Our center media is controlled by central party and state media is controlled by state party which is a true fact . They wants to have hold in that portion 4) One Nation one election can be considered as One Leader election as our voter have no proper education and rich people don't like to vote. 5) We have seen UAPA side effects on so many innocent people such as (doctor in UP , Journalist in UP for covering Mid day Meal).
its a challenge to party in rallies cause they cant contradict thier policy in different times and also same thing cant be said by cm and pm candidate in one rally. No more jod tod ki sarkar and horsetrading. POLICY OVER POLITICS please
You missed the economics and costs of one election, like 800000 new EVMs just for comparison. Also please add a sound deadning to your Mic arm and a cage on mic to avoid the Table thumb throughout this video.
I support One Nation One Election. The pros here outweigh the cons. Yes there are challenges that we can overcome with practical experience. But there is no relationship between Cauvery water dispute, farmer distress, unemployment with ONOE.
Elections are meant to elect better leaders, not to waste money. If you're concerned about excessive spending, set a limit on how much any party can spend over five years. Additionally, stop digital ads. It's shameful that the BJP spent over 100 crore on online ads. Also, remove political party symbols and faces from government schemes. This would be a more effective way to save money.
check out Odoo ♥: www.odoo.com/r/UL2
The best brand in Business management right now and the best brand ever to work with :)♥♥
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
if theres an issue of central issues overshadowing state ones....why theres no single platform/site that displays every detail about the state and the central issues and what each party has contributed to resolve an issue and what issues that are not solved yet in an organised way. Such a platform would be very helpful for many people (90s and 2k most who dont care about them).
I feel like the digital presence of India's governance is very low.
Maa kasam nhi deta hun main😖😖 phir bhi mera koi gana nhi sunata hai🥺🥺😭 please sun lo bas ek baar😔😔70k
@ThinkSchool Bro you are biased, you are preferring north india politicians for your video clip and politicians who spoke about one nation and one election, also you are using the pictures of only noth India politicians. Why there is a discrimination??
Bhai in matters related to nation politics suppressing state politics in ONOE is not correct.
U should have given example of odisa and andhra how people vote differently for both state and central gov.
Mainly odisa voting in 2019 how could u miss that.
State elections need to happen together at once and general election separately. That makes sure the local issues are not neglected and also we make it a point to get done with them at once.
Yes one nation two election
Then what's the point on even implementing this law cause as per your instructions it wouldn't be economically feasible 💲at all 😮🙄
Instead they should just pass it anyway don't you think the people will slowly get used to it as the political parties addresses this issue so the people will stillvote for state differently than the central election
What's your opinion I really wanna know 😅
They are casting different votes for state and centre. So, it doesn't matter
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
The policy itself says for 2 separate election in the span of 100 days.
Being a resident of Odisha i completely support ONOE as in my state we cast our vote once for both lok shaba and state assembly without any problem and we are doing this from decades.
Exactly. Additionally ONOE will bring more unity to the country as a whole.
My analysis - INC will oppose anything that the BJP is doing (literally that's their stance after 2014) so no hopes from them to do critical thinking , but I have hopes from other regional parties , JPC was a good choice
If you jump on drainage don't expect everyone to jump we have our power to show atleast once in a year and you are trying to get away that also🤦♂️ once come to south states to see our development.. we are not saying we are 100% developed atleast we know where we lack .. now also BJP is majority why can't they improve anything?
Yes The indian voter are enough mature that they can differentiate b/w state and lok sabha election which we seen multiple times that voters voted for a different part in central and other in state assembly
Being member of Andhra who also votes for both Lok Sabha and state assembly at the same time, I don't spport ONOE as I want to protect my state specific narratives if given a chance and in case of a political turmoil and no confidence, I wouldn’t want to incentivise the new government to give freebies or clear large amount of farmer debts just to please them. As it take a long term (5-10 years) to bring some plans to fruition.
Best political video till date by Thinkschool. Absolutely no bias throughout the video.
common he is biased about local issues. Why didn't he mentioned about Odisha or AP?
See USA, they also do all election (House, Senate and Presedent) in one go. Also we have seen that Odisha, Andhra Pradesh where state election happen with Lok Sabha, people had voted differently.
USA WONT USE EVM’s then 😂😂
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
The thing is that they are a 2 party system (Dems and Republicans). Not comparable
They also use BALLET paper as apparatus
They compare what ever they like.. become like USA in every way then, if u want to compare. 😂 Also the candidates talk to people on talks shows n stay in touch with people unlike politicians in India who actually like kings.
It boils down to one simple argument that if people are smart enough to vote for different parties when elections are happening at different times ( lets say 6 months apart ) then they are also smart enough to vote for different parties when elections are happening at the same time.
that's the problem. people are not smart. people vote for lot of shit reasons... lot of people don't even have basic knowledge of how economy works. short term benefits wins over log term goals!
Exactly a valid point
@@Gowtham91mnbjd was in power for 5 consecutive terms irrespective of CG. WB, Raj, Karnataka, Delhi. People know whom to cast vote.
There is already enough proof in history of indian election to prove ppl are much smarter..!
My state karnatka ( other states too ) is an example where ppl have voted for different government on same day ..!
Multiple time since 80s
@@Gowtham91mn"not smart" is just being unfair on our voters, we can say that the Centre (who ever is in power)might bank on this confusion and see a majority of people choosing one particular party..
In India any decision can't get 100% Favour, there's always an Opposition. It's a great thing sometime but sometime it's also get Problematic.
The opposition is called pappusition these days, just wasting parliamentary session time and not having a constructive opposing view. What a bunch of duds have opposition become
I have yet to see a good argument against it
@@KrishVarri I know brother, but Opposition is also very important for Democracy like recent example of South Korea.
Looking at One party system like China , and how far ahead they are , seems it was the way to go but alas not possible , we will always be backwards as compared to them
@@prajwalparaskar2047 if dictatorship=development I don't really have any problem with that. What democracy has given us? Politicians who loot tax payers🤡🤡
How did the BJD win in Odissa when the BJP won the lok sabha seats I'm 2019?
What about 2024 sir?...
FYI: go to Odisha and see the billboards. If you don't understand Odia read about the shubhadra scheme. If that's not freebies idk what is.
I am from odisha and bjd is ruling odisha for more than 20 years
He were frustrated with their corrupted party and government so we decided to change@@mthanos259
@@mthanos259😂true bjp is promoting freebies too
But they hav to because other parties are promoting if they don't then they won't get vote
Sir go to reality and check again.in ground level voters are not understanding this vote going to centre or state. Confusion about mp and mla vote.
Frequent elections keep governments accountable. When a state election is due, ruling parties are pressured to deliver tangible results or face the consequences. This cycle ensures continuous governance rather than a focus solely on the general election years.
Yes that's why one party ruled for 60 years plus and delivered non stop 😂
I can't comment on other parties or states. But, how TMC can question any party be it bjp, congress on matters of democracy, governance, economy, job, corruption and last not but the least patriotism ? 🤔
At least people can protest in Bengal not like other states which clearly shows how democracy work in Bengal
@@gauravdas5000 the CM herself protests there over 😂😂
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
I feels funny when someone says that Bengal democracy 🤣 ,
Economy has become dead in last 15 yr
The logical thing in my opinion is to implement the second phase first .. instead of aligning state and centre elections together...make panchayat, muncipal and state elections together...since the same parties are in the panchayat and state....
It cannot happen parties usually assess ground reality through local elections....and then state elections happen....
Yes sensible
Yes
Very Satisfied by the Quality.
Thank You
Modi and BJP has very deep n innovative thinking who never thought one nation one election... Congress and opposition parties should atleast think 1% of nation growth..
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
Kuch zyaada hi soch liya modi ji ne , baksh do please mat socho itna
@@Harchatur14real
Nation will grow more if dicatorship come. You will support that? Democracy = accountability
I.M.O. congress just want to sell India to other powerful countries and never think of growth of their own country
Not one in the opposition have the capability to be a visionary. So don’t mind them, we just keep moving with what we should do.
@@KrishVarri kuch bhi
@@VizorfamTu bhi kuch mat bol, facts ke upar baat kiya kar
@@Vizorfam Name one, just one who has the capacity to be a visionary in opposition
People who you really need in the country to grow are migrating out. So good luck
Because they are shutting their voice
Keep up the good work! I love your editing and your style of presenting the topic. It’s straight to the point and easy to understand. Looking forward to a million subscribers!
If they can pull this off, it'll be truly revolutionary as you said❤
Those who think that one election will lead to people(both politicians and voters) not considering local issues while voting have a lot to learn about Indian democracy and the voters.
We want No more freebies.😊
Check his video on freebies and comment
Maharashtra ladli behen yojna
@@mansoofalamansari8716 haj subsidies should be stopped immediately to do haj there should be no subsidies or freebies.
I can't speak for other states, but in Andhra Pradesh, where assembly elections are held simultaneously with parliamentary elections, regional parties have won 5 out of 6 times in the past 30 years. This clearly shows that "One Nation, One Election" won't necessarily diminish the presence of regional parties. It ultimately depends on the party's ideology and its connection with the people. I also disagree with your claim that most Indians prioritize national issues over state issues-it's actually the opposite. However, I do agree with your point that mid-term elections for short-term governments tend to undermine long-term issues.
I am BJP supporter from Maharashtra. I remember Maharashtra elections were postponed because EC couldn’t conduct Haryana and Maharashtra (two big states) elections together. Now they wanna conduct whole nation’s elections & all states together 😂 I am BJP supporter but can’t understand BJPs logic
Bro don't act like fool it's was not necessity to do both election at same time that's why arrangements are not made but if onoe become reality EC will prepare keeping these things in mind.
Major reform will be needed to do this. It is definitely possible though, but BJP needs to do a ton of work for it to happen. Everything from logistics to EVM will need change and reform. Overall, I think it's good for the unity of the country, but it will be a bit of a problem initially.
Basically story of each and every sector in india. We can improve so much if only we can make effecient use of our resources, human resources in this case
You're thinking of present while the BJP is thinking of the future .....
Do you think it will be successful ? Our media house is sleeping have you seen previous interview of Amit shah what questions they have asked teachers used to ask a class 2 grade students they want one nation one election but they will force media @@AbhAsh-w5g
This bill should overwhelmingly pass in both houses of parliament.
It wouldn't cause it's a bad idea
Voters are smart and well-informed; they understand the distinction between national and state issues. Until 1967, India followed the system of “One Nation, One Election.” How can implementing this system again be considered the death of democracy? By that logic, is the Congress suggesting there was no democracy in India until 1967?
What do you think might've been the reason to bring this change in 1967 in the first place ?
Voters are not smart and they r misinformed most of the time... Or why else political parties r throwing freebies to them..
@@tanmaynarang2193 The Congress-led central government's use of Article 356 to dismiss state governments disrupted synchronized elections in some states. However, it was Indira Gandhi's decision in 1970 that ultimately ended synchronized elections in India.
Kejriwal saying "are humko kya" is the most henious act of democracy
What a good explanation! Hatts off you have covered this completely unbiased by mentioning advantages and disadvantages without letting your self opinion comming in between .
This is what todays media lacks. Kudos 👏
Hey, ganesh and team this is by far the best video i've seen on this topic with perfect balance of all the pros and cons ,u nailed it very well.
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
I disagree. some examples were deliberately not shown, like Odisha.
@vishalvdhumal i didn't get that
I don't think so he missed the most important point, the political environment of India where hate and toxicity is increasing day by day because of this frequent election.
So good in narration, loved hearing it!
SO EASY TO UNDERSTAND
Excellent Ganesh Sir...😊
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
It's a humble request, please provide CC as well.. it will help us to understand the topic with more clarity..
Thank you for the information.. I highly appreciate ur efforts..❤
They are showing up
such a great video, o was unable to think the disadvantages of one nation election, but now everything is clear.
Hey Really love your videos, extremely informative and specially unbiased.
Just a quick typo you can probably fix. At 15:34 under MLA it says Center, it should be saying state.
Thanks for doing great work
We must remember democracy is not about efficiency it's about accountability.
Even without ONOE, freebies are given today and ending states like Karnataka in bankruptcy so stating that as a point against ONOE does not make sense!, also if you see Karnataka, People have voted to Congress for state govt and BJP for Central Govt, so the voter is definitely intelligent enough to vote to whom he wants! I am all in for ONOE! Lets GO!
Have been constant viewer of your channel for the last 2 years. But since last 2 months I've not watched a single video of urs because now I get full summary in text via AI, IMO saves a lot of time...
I love your videos . China has progressed so well because of their government policies cause they treat themselves as one nation. We as Indian should think in same way . I fully support the government policy. Lets strive towards growth and make India an economical superpower .
Very good narrative. Clear picture on the topic. Like your work.
best Video on ONE NATION ONE ELECTION topic
Very well explained and detailed video
You really summarised the video very well....why we need 1 nation and 1 election when we can achieve that with little tweak in modal code of conduct 👍🏼👏🏼
Thank you for putting forward the pros and cons of OMOE without any bias. Now it's easier for me to form my opinion. 😄
if theres an issue of central issues overshadowing state ones....why theres no single platform/site that displays every detail about the state and the central issues and what each party has contributed to resolve an issue and what issues that are not solved yet in an organised way. Such a platform would be very helpful for many people (90s and 2k most who dont care about them).
I feel like the digital presence of India's governance is very low
Nice said and analysed!!!
Well the point about mid-term elections where party will only focus on freebies to remain in power for the next elections after completing this shorter mid-term is insignificant and invalid. As parties are still spending so much amount of money on freebies to remain in power for 5 years. Take example of Delhi where Kejriwaal is promising even more freebies. Freebies will be always used by parties until there is no demand from public side, which will eventually happen. At least ONOE will be more efficient and stable than the current system despite the freebies. And as more people become educated and oppose spending tax money on freebies as its our own money, the freebie culture will end.
I have understood that ONOE may seem much chaotic today but it has a long vision and promising results/growth in long term. It will definitely benefit the country a lot. And also...don't underestimate a voter, they know very well whom to vote on central issues and on state issues and this wisdom will only increase with time.
Whoever agrees can like this :)
We actually started our democratic path under One Nation One Election,then in different states due to political instability governments started falling apart and now we are here that every year in some part or the other of the country election is happening
i think the school hired a new editor so that's why the editing style changed for this video
I think school fans will notice this😁😁❤❤
Most important and most hot topic at the same time
Against ONOP.
1. National issues overshadowing state & local.
2. No accountability for 5 years.
3. If reforming MCC works what is need of all this.
5 years is the least time that should be given to prove the points, it is a nation with the largest population, takes time to get the wheels to turn, it is about time Indians understand that state and local issues are what result in National issues.
any govt or reform needs 10 years to show actual results
2 point is absolutely rubbish
really, how can people believe in this bs?
Its simple really. Conduct Lok Sabha elections as they are. Then conduct state elections for all states on one day, which is exactly 2.5 yrs after Lok Sabha elections and a weekend. People can express their satisfaction, state parties are happy, just one day when entire nation will be closed.
One day, really, ek din me chunaav hote kahaan dekhaa hai tumne.
It should be implemented ASAP ❤. It will save advertisement cost , 500 500 ke note wali freebies , manpower , and most importantly TIME (which is more important than money).❤
very minor problem in this video : table sounds while u move ur hand
not very major but noticable sound
Nice video and feedback Ganesh ✌🏻
But, still shocked to see only a 5.5k likes over a span of 75k views..
Qiute pathetic that was! 😒
1. Unexpired term (lets say 2 years as taken in video) us time me koi party development ka kaam nhi kregi. It will just do some PR activities in the name of development and wait for next elections to be held after 2 years.
2. Jaise ye kaha ja rhaa hai ki 2014 me 7 mahine model code laga tha par kya poore desh me laga tha. NHI. 3 months poore desh me which was Lok sabha. Baaki 4 states me only 2 months more tha. Total 5 months in 4 states and only 3 months in whole of India.
3. Is new plan ke hisaab se atleast 6-7 months ka model code of conduct lagega. Firstlly 3 months for lok sabha vidhan sabha and then next 100 days (3.5 months) for local body.
4. The most important reason as also explained in this video: Local voices will totally go unheard. Ek hi kamre me 2 EVM hogi. Just think. Aap jaoge. Ek party ki achi image hogi. Dono evm pe same party ka button dabake aaoge. Its true for most of the people.
5. Then accountability khatam ho jayegi as explained with UP example.
6. Ye constitution me articles change, sab ko synchronise krna to 2029. Ye sab choti cheeze hai and one time hai. Real challenges jo upar bataye vo hai jin vajah se ONOE should not be passed. Instead One Nation 2 elections could be there. It will be best. Every 2.5 years me with only 1 month of model code of conduct every time.
Unexpired terms mein like 2 year video mein liya gya hai
Party 2 saal scam karte karte hn nikal degi agle election mein Paisa lagane ke liye 😂😂😂
I think 1 nation 2 election is better... Jahan pe election year mein hi central govt waala election year ke start mein ho aur doosra year ke end mein...
+ model code of conduct 1 month ka... Seems fair...
Aur hamne Maharashtra elections se dekh hi liya hai.. ki 6 mahine baad bhi public ka opinion alag hota dikha hai...
Very well presented with food for thought. Good research and good work
In reviewing the challenges and concerns raised regarding the parliament bill, it is evident that while the highlighted issues merit consideration, their overall weight is significantly lower than the potential benefits the bill promises to deliver. The broader advantages, including long-term national progress, far outweigh the identified drawbacks, making this bill a step in the right direction.
What india actually needs is giving every state equal role for choosing the ruling party.
Like in united States, thus every state will equally valued by central government after winning election.
Then states of north east etc will be more developed, more efficient whole country projects etc etc. It will be beautiful.
But the ruling govt never do that coz they won with influence of states like up etc😢
I think that's a flawed argument.. in America not all states get equal seats.. its done in accordance to population just like in India.. even in America high population states such as California Texas Florida and New York have a lot of seats compared to other states... And wake up dude.. bjp not only wins UP they literally win seats from every state except Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Punjab and Andhra (if no alliance)..even in northeast bjp is strong.
@harishmr6371 bro that's not what I meant. Remember the first time Trump wins the election? He was approx 2 lakhs vote behind hilary Clinton. But he won.
It's not about America bro. But this change is essential for india.
Also Don't get offended as every BJP bhakths . I'm telling any party don't dare to do that. Both BJP and congress.
Also there are lots of incidents of BJP not caring much about states which they don't have rule 😂
In USA all states have equal number of seats in
Senate regardless of their population.
Get your facts checked bro.
@@harishmr6371
Atleast theres a person who thinks reasonable, first we need to give the states the power they needed to develop the other cities not only their capitals apart from that india does not need any election reforms and stuff after developing cities then we need to change educational and labour reforms and after that employment
at 15:45 the text below mp and mla stayed the same for both but it should be different , also great video
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
waah foofaji very observative!!
Thank you for the video
Another great video from think school
🎯💎🏆 Great insightful & fruitful video 🏆💎🎯
लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु
( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )
Accountability that comes with multiple elections is very important. ONOE is not good for democracy
Most unbiased youtuber when it comes to politics.
The argument that the local issues may get silenced, in my opinion is vague. Because local problem still gets overseen even with the current system we have.
No political party truly cares about farmers and daily wage earners anyways.
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
I just waited for your video, without watching any other video on YT to understand it clearly
BJP plan is to take whole country for granted for 5 years...
People should keep quite for 5 long years...
Whether it is congress or BJP in power, people will loose their voice...
Very BAD IDEA of modi....
What a useless argument.
People still troll government and carry out strikes.
Atleast they will focus on development rather than elections.
I support one nation one election. Much Much needed for saving resources and development.
What does it have to do with "death of democracy" please don't use such clickbait titles
You are amazing.
All elections at once is not possible
Maybe Lok Sabha Elections+Assemblies of AP, Odisha, Maharashtra, Rajasthan, MP, Chattisgarh, Telangana, Arunachal Pradesh, Haryana, Jharkhand and Sikkim might be held at once.
And during second cycle remaining all states would be held along with UP which can be held during midterm.
I say One Nation One Election is very much needed because:
1) Party Central leadership's focus would be more on elections than on main issue which we saw during second wave of COVID when lockdown was purposefully delayed till May 6th 2021 I Guess when cases were rising from 1st week off April itself we saw what was the end result of that delay. Here all parties should be blamed mainly BJP which is in power.
2)More promising of unfesible non merit freebies or cross subsidies would happen frequently which can lead to disastrous State finances.
3)ECI's official cost of conducting those many elections is rising too fast. For 2019 General Elections itself ECI's cost was close to a billion USD.
4) Even Parties funding rallies cost would be too high which eventually will be recovered through corruption in contracts. Here Iam not saying that One Nation One Election would completely eradicate this but atleast it will remain unchanged or same because spending would be only for one time.
Lastly its not that ECI can't organise such a big election ECI can. Infact during the times which date back to post Independence times till 1967 elections were held at one time for all. Do remember that time we had an unreliable logistics system and despite that ECI printed ballot papers then transported it till last polling booth and again taking back them to the counting stations everything was very difficult with unreliable logistics system back then. But still ECI did well.
Then to conduct One Nation One Election now India needs around 4 million EVMs for all states and center combined. But we currently have around 2 milllion EVMs as said by Ex ECI chairman.
I believe in manufacturing potential of India if we could assemble over a 10 million Mobile phones then we can pretty much assemble 2 million EVMs with considerable Local Value Addition.
But the main challenge would be to deploy those many central forces for safe conduct of elections.
I support this One Nation One Election
Brother,demolishing 370 was also impossible at one time.
@@mitulrana1138 everything is possible except dictatorship which some people claim as
Arguments against the cons:
2. Overlapping Nation and State Issue:
Facts, Let's talk about Modi (biggest 353 seats) wave in 2019, 4-5 months before lok sabha BJP lost Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh and Madhya Pradesh Vidhan sabha, but voters gave full majority to BJP in Lok sabha.
Another in 2019 with Lok sabha election (parallel) there was elections in Orissa (Biju janta Dal: Full majority) and Andhra Pradesh (YSR Party). Voters are educated they know whom to vote and where.
3. Frequent elections, even though costly ensures that gov remain accountable to the people throughout their term:
Context of Mid term crisis:
Freebies are unstoppable until supreme court or election commission intervenes.
-----------------
Add this point to Pros:
1. Elections damages the social fabric of India, How ?:
Politician divide India into vote banks of Community (Hindu, Muslim), Castes , Regions (Bengali Identity, Kannada Identity, Marati Identity) which reach peak at the times of election. Polarization at Peak.
USA is also an example where Black vs White happens.
2. Voters turnout will be more
Every one will join the election, Every one can come home and join the election festival (This make democracy stronger)
-------------------
Additioal Point:
India is not new to one nation one election is not new to world, USA 2-8 Nov every 2 year, UK also does it. I don't think the democratics structure is damaged there.
Great Must Read points, last Elections damages the social fabric of India, is the best one
Great Arguments
admin Pin the points
@@desilaziz9235 Great points
Atleast someone gets it
This bill will revolutionize India. This is the most important bill brought by Govt. This is a huge relief to people. This will eliminate urban naxals, anti-India regional parties and unite India on one single day to vote for progress.
One nation One party.
muslim league
@@PEGASIS_PLAZ Brahmins league
We Want Justice. We Demand Justice. Justice for RG Kar 🔥🔥🔥
Khatm hogya bhai ab kuch nhi hoskta iss desh mai😮💨
It's very sad that BJP is the only party which focuses on real development of India 🇮🇳😔
Really ???
Then you got fooled😂
Lol real development by taxing people to the MAX. Broken judiciary and police. When something happens any case we file takes 10+ years to resolve. What development did Modi do ?
LOL developing billions in net worth of their rich friends, if that's what u mean
The findemental theme of government is to serve people and solve their problems , so it doesn't matter how many days you are in power 🇮🇳
If you do right things for society ,you will win next term also
I believe it's great idea to have ONOP. It was like that before and the Congress changed it in 70s. However, it should be implemented and in few years after the implementation, everything will settle down. Jus imagine apart from saving thousands of crores, thousands of hours will be saved for those officials, police, teachers, etc. It improves voters turnout as well.
Wouldn't the same officials be employed for the same durations for the elections ?
Good analysis. Thanks for this. Just was my thought as well. Why not refine model code of conduct. 🙏
Maturity is , opposition should take note of this case study and argue in house, they are running baseless points in parliament.
You should suggest according to your case study it should be implement or not, what is best in the interest of country.
Everything comes with some pros and cons.
Excellent idea of One nation One election
Earlier when I was a child, I never saw central govt campaign for local body or panchayat or state. Now this govt is in election mode 24×7 . So it's problem of BJP party not India's
Kaise dekhte bro ek hi option tha uss samay congress warna 60+ years kaise rule karte ye log.
@vofficial170 kisne bola ak hi party tha, saab party the, Janta party 1948 se thi. Congress kaam karta tha isliye baar baar jita, abhi 10 saal se BJP ne kiya achieve kiya 100 smart city bola tha, mujhe gin ke 5 dikha do baas, Inflation, Unemployment, Vikas ye saab mudda tha BJP ka 2014 mein, abhi Hindu Muslim, Mandir, Mutton, Machli pe ah gaya
@srvdass LOL smart city pata hai lekin aaj tak search bhi nhi hoga iske regarding news kyu ?
FYI - 7,380 out of 8,075 projects, with an investment of ₹1,47,704 crore are done .
17 cities completed 100% of the work. 34% cities ne 90% projects complete kiya hai aur approx 75 cities aise hai jaha 74-75% projects complete hue hai . Aur before you start ranting about these stats first understand what smart city mission was , it was about area based development not some high-rise buildings and skyscrapers which I don't know where people get the information from.
You can also watch the powertrain video on that .
One of the best videos I have ever seen
Great bill, hope it passes and becomes law
It is not
dream on
We need this to increase productivity of nation
Though it attracts hell lot of controversies it also reduces the burden on resources and election workers. Having the one nation and one election policy is a blessing but it should not be implemented in the blink of an eye. Centre should listen to all state legislatures and implement it in such a way that it should not be seen as their weapon against democracy.
It’s not a blessing at all why would I want the government to be able to do what ever it wants for four years and whitewash it in last year by freebies or by polarising the people
@@ShubhamGupta-xv6np waste of bill
@@Vizorfam ???
@ShubhamGupta-xv6np You are he only one inthis chat actually talking something senses full and not a blind fan base of any party
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
One nation one election has lots of benefits for India and its people.. little pain in few bums shouldn't matter at all..
First, I thank Think School to come up with a very clear explanation. Here's my thought,
- ONOE sounds good but a country like India do not need them.
- Phase 1 should synchronize state elections on a single day. If MP elections occur in 2024, MLA elections should be in 2026. These are two separate elections, One spent by the Union government and the other spent by the State government.
- This Bill gives itself the power to actually change how the State elections are conducted altering the balance of power between state and central governments in India. This should not happen as India is a Union of States and it will create Chaos
- Assuming Tamil Nadu spends 600 crore, its annual budget is 4.5 lakh crore, totaling approximately 20 lakh crore over five years. This means that 600 crore represents only about 0.03% of the five-year budget, and less than 0.1% of Tamil Nadu's total budget.
- People's voices and protest will only be heard at the time of elections (once in 5 years), Prices will reduce only at the time of elections (once in 5 years), Politicians will meet public only at the time of elections (once in 5 years) and so on. Price reductions, including for gas and petrol, are used as political tools solely in the final year of a term.
ONEC will destroy the State's power of individuality. So Personally I stand against the Bill.
But bro after onoe the party can shift the focus from election to actual work and it will save thousands of crores which are wasted each year in elections. Also rewdi politics might also start decreasing because no party would offer freebies in all state at the same time
@@dhairyamittal1313
- India has the annual budget around
2023-2024: ₹47.13 lakh crore
2022-2023: ₹46.03 lakh crore
2021-2022: ₹34.83 lakh crore
2020-2021: ₹30.42 lakh crore
2019-2020: ₹26.99 lakh crore
From 2019 to 2024 - In five years India has 185 lakh crore budget.
The Amount cost for conducting the Lok Sabha election is around 10K crore - 15K crore. It's just 0.5 percent of the 5 Year budget. (But the amount that each party spend is totally depends upon how bad they want to win the election)
In FY 2020 - 21 Govt is lost 1 lakh crore in taxes due to corporate tax cut.
My question is if the govt is ready to bear 1 lakh crore for the corporate, why can't they spent 10K crore on people who chose the govt for the next 5 years? India is leaking money through various forms and that should be fixed first if they want to save money.
- States like TN are prone to natural disaster. Modi was able to visit TN numerous times during the elections and never bothered to visit not even once during back to back record-breaking natural disasters. And imagine the case for Manipur. This is how the national parties are. They only engage with the public during election season, and people's anger is expressed solely through their votes. This is a key reason why the BJP lost all 40 seats in states like Tamil Nadu.
- The limitations for spending in Elections should be monitored and should take serious actions.
- IIndia's vast size means that many states have populations larger than some European countries. ONOE will pose significant challenges in this diverse nation. Even if 10 percent population opposes it, that means for India it's more than 100 million people and it will create a destruction in Democracy.
One nation one election is a master stroke towards development of the country 👍🏻
State and Central election should be saperated by 2.5 year. This preserves democracy. Dont trust Modi blindly, he is trying hard to preserve his power
He is trying to preserve Hindus and Bharat , what happened to Kashmiri pandits ‘ what was Hindus condition in Gujarat pre Modi era there are infinite examples please open your eyes and see we are 100 years behind Modi is trying to catch up
Great video
There are so many points regarding one election one nation
1) As an Indian ,my Chief Justice is being selected by the majority of Ruling Party which is the already killing the democracy.
If not counter this point with true facts
2) One Nation One Election , the center wants to have good hold in South Indian States through this.
3) Our center media is controlled by central party and state media is controlled by state party which is a true fact .
They wants to have hold in that portion
4) One Nation one election can be considered as One Leader election as our voter have no proper education and rich people don't like to vote.
5) We have seen UAPA side effects on so many innocent people such as (doctor in UP , Journalist in UP for covering Mid day Meal).
Very well summmerised 22:24
its a challenge to party in rallies cause they cant contradict thier policy in different times and also same thing cant be said by cm and pm candidate in one rally. No more jod tod ki sarkar and horsetrading. POLICY OVER POLITICS please
I hope Democracy ends. It is our greatest weakness and prevents our growth.
Maturity when you realise opposition doesn't think like how this youtuber think, bjp is best
No when corrupt opposition leaders like Ajit pawar and hemanta vishvsharma got in NDA I lost hope.
I Support #ONOE, I am associated with electorial process and personally experience the hectic schedule.
You missed the economics and costs of one election, like 800000 new EVMs just for comparison.
Also please add a sound deadning to your Mic arm and a cage on mic to avoid the Table thumb throughout this video.
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY
I support One Nation One Election. The pros here outweigh the cons. Yes there are challenges that we can overcome with practical experience. But there is no relationship between Cauvery water dispute, farmer distress, unemployment with ONOE.
I love case study + political influence in business
Very well presented ❤
No dictatorship only democracy.
We don't want permanent leader.
Dictatorship kaha se aagyi yha election bnd thodi horhe hai
Your thumbnail 😂 loved it 😅 by the way great video with clear cut explanation
Elections are meant to elect better leaders, not to waste money. If you're concerned about excessive spending, set a limit on how much any party can spend over five years. Additionally, stop digital ads. It's shameful that the BJP spent over 100 crore on online ads. Also, remove political party symbols and faces from government schemes. This would be a more effective way to save money.
Every party spend crores on ads it cells and what not.
Looks like your views don't align with BJP that's the only argument you got😅
YOU FORGOT TO MENTION MAKARWADI EVM SCAM AND CURRENT GOVT REFUSE TO TAKE REELECTION ON BALLOT PAPER >>>> DEATH OF DEMOCRACY