Recording Your Acoustic Guitar | SM57 vs. AT2020 vs. Loudbox Mini
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 сер 2024
- Hey Everybody!
I'm changing it up this week! No deep dive into pedals or amps and no guitar mods. This week I'm going to try to answer the question - "Which of my recording methods is best for acoustic guitar?". The options compared are a Shure SM57 dynamic microphone, an Audio-Technica AT2020 condenser microphone, and using the XLR output from my Fishman Loudbox Mini. I run through flatpicking, finger-picking, and strumming to see which one I think is best!
Enjoy!
#presonus #fishman #shure
I’ve been using an SM57 for vocals, acoustic guitar and amped guitars. I’ve been thinking about gettin the AT2020 and your video sold me on it. The biggest issue I have with the SM57 is having to significantly increase the gain when recording vocals/acoustic. I noticed you (probably) did too. In your clips both the amp samples and SM57 samples have a noticeable hiss in between the notes. The only one that didn’t was the AT2020. The AT2020 also sounded a lot more balanced. The SM57 definitely captures more low-end (which isn’t really a bad thing!). But Thank you for this video! Very helpful!
AT2020 seems to capture more guitar sound, was thinking of purchasing of Zoom H2 for the mobility, but now thinking of AT2020 for home recordings. Thx for the review!
Excellent video. I'm now sold on the AT2020...very quiet, really brings out the best in your Taylor. I also have the Loudbox mini so it will be great to try out the same experiment.
His g string was raping my ears. What is it with players who never get better after a year? I'm 45 an have a 2 hour warm up to a metronome before I even consider noodling. Discipline guys.
The sm57 is the classic mic if you are not reamping like normal people.
I agree with your thought and also was surprised at the better quality recordings with the dynamic Shure...thanks for the time to go through the experiment and sharing, very well done
Thanks! Glad it helped
Your video is what I was looking for, because I wanted to do a similar setup because I already have an sm57 but I was thinking in buy the at2020 to compliment my recordings. This weekend i will buy my at2020.
Good compare. Try out the Audio-Technical ATR2100x-USB and see how you feel it compares to the SM57. Both XLR and USB of the ATR2100x-USB are near identical sound based on my tests and sound really good.
Will put it on the list
Great video! I don't have any of the equipment you used, but for what I heard, I agree with you. Mics are usually better sounding in my opinion, although there are good counter examples. It would be good to see a video with you try to use the taylor system with the eq in the amp to make it sound more like a microphone.
My guitar has a built-in mic with a control in the preamp that allows me to blend the piezo with the mic, I always try to mix as much mic as I can, it makes the guitar sound a lot more natural.
Great idea! I will add it to the list!
Liked that you played Colters song!
Yep. He has some great tunes
Is it possible to not getting the terrible hiss sound with the SM57? The tone itself is not as bad and I do like it, but the hiss is terrible and AT2020 sounded a lot better. I'm actually considering to pick up either the SM57 or AT2020, pairing up with my Scarlett 2i2. Thoughts?
You could try using an expander plug in on the recorded audio. An expander is the opposite of a compressor and you can use it to make quiet sounds quieter. You'll probably loose the micro-detail along with the noise but you can play with it to get a balance that is acceptable to you.
why does the sm57 have a hissing sound in the background?
What's the difference between AT2020- USB vs XLR cable?
Nice playing. Is that some Clay Pigeons I hear?
Yessir
Apparently UA-cam thinks it's thank you by dido. They copyright claimed my video
@@pougnetpedals Aw man, that sucks!! And not even for the right song :/
@@pougnetpedals lol. that sucks.
Yep. I disputed it and it got lifted last week. Glad to share revenue, but not with dido haha
How to connect condenser and dynamic microphones at the same time I have phantom but I can chose if the two inputs are phantom or not not separately
From what I understand, most newer dynamic mics aren't affected by the phantom power
Hey man! I'm stuck between the two mikes, but only have the money for one at the moment. I've got the mike that's with the studio pack in the focusrite 2i2 (a large condenser), but it's just really freaking bassy, so I'm looking for something that's got a better accent on mids and highs, and from what I hear, the sm57 seems like the kind of mike I'd want. Could you give me your thoughts? I'd run a dual mike setup using both the condenser and either one I'd pick
Can't go wrong with an SM57. Great all around and something that can be used in many applications.
How do you record the fishman? DI out XLR to XLR to interface??? If I do that will it work and give me the same sound that comes thru amp?? Thx
Yes
Hey, I tried using the SM57 but it turned out really soft on my DAW, any idea how you do it?
Got preamp?
i had no issue running it through my presonus audiobox? maybe the gain levels aren't set high enough?
@@pougnetpedals Probably
1 year late but you need to buy a cloud lifter
My sm57 doesn’t sound like that at all
Skip to 3:30
Thanks
Is it possible that sm57 has more hiss than at2020?
Yes, but I think that is due to the audiobox interface I'm using. The Shure requires more gain then the at2020 and thus you get more noise. I'm thinking of upgrading to one of their new usb Interfaces with better noise suppression and more gain.
@@pougnetpedals I have an Audiobox itwo. Which one do you have?
Usb 96
I noticed that as well. Hiss seems obvious on both the sm57 and the loudbox when doing fingerstyle.
Youre the dude who sees a guitar at a party and has to let everyone know you can play at a novice level? Ehh? I used to be that guy