THE HERD | Colin Cowherd DEFENDS Caleb Williams, He's Clearly GREAT, Chicago Bears Are Just BAD

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 180

  • @ahastar1141
    @ahastar1141 15 годин тому +7

    I think analysts are giving way to much credit with the interceptions thing. In the game Monday he threw a pass that Harrison smith of the vikings just flat out dropped, and threw up a bad cross field lollipop jump ball that was fortunately dropped in a jump ball. It's he is not throwing picks, but he also isn't pushing the football down the field and attacking defense. Taking sacks and incompletions in lieu of interceptions while having bad passing stats isnt a positive

    • @johnwickonspeed7701
      @johnwickonspeed7701 14 годин тому +2

      He went 4 of those 8 games without throwing a TD either.

    • @Secretarynotsure89
      @Secretarynotsure89 14 годин тому +1

      It’s easy to not throw interceptions if you just sit in the pocket and wait to get sacked. I could do that for millions of dollars .

    • @ahastar1141
      @ahastar1141 14 годин тому +3

      @ I think part of it might be he’s scared to throw a pick as it’s the one stat that is really being pushed positively for him. While he doesn’t need to be a gun slinger good QBs are going to throw picks. I think he’s not being aggressive enough but it in some ways also being careless in that he’s throwing up bad balls that just are getting dropped or are so off the mark no one can catch it.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 14 годин тому

      @@ahastar1141 yeah, and you're one of those who would be the first in line to criticize him for too many interceptions. Quarterback for the Bears is damned if you do and damned if you don't proposition.

    • @Secretarynotsure89
      @Secretarynotsure89 14 годин тому +1

      @@Harold-w2yor you could just act like a number one overall pick/ generational prospect and both throw the ball AND not be intercepted. That's too much to ask from the pocket princess?

  • @Dom2.0
    @Dom2.0 9 годин тому +1

    Just watch the film breakdowns... He's missing wide open guys, missing easy throws, and holding the ball forever taking sacks... he got his coaches fired because the organization is watching film and seeing that it's him failing the team. You don't add all these weapons to last years 7 win team and get WORSE...

  • @VinnyP47
    @VinnyP47 16 годин тому +1

    I was gonna ask if I was the only one whose audio was cutting out but I guess not. I like your videos a lot boss and I'm going to continue to watch them, but the audio does tend to cut out pretty regularly. Keep up the great work man!

  • @Jo3Mama235
    @Jo3Mama235 14 годин тому +2

    Caleb has a good arm, but the guy looks like he's playing with a blindfold on. The amount of open receivers he misses downfield because he doesn't go through his reads is insane

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 11 годин тому +1

      @@Jo3Mama235 and yet he's still way better than Fields

    • @tiffanygregory2091
      @tiffanygregory2091 3 години тому

      ​@Harold-w2y
      But he's not. Thats the problem. Team is getting less yards. Less points and CW through 14 games has accounted for less tds than JF last year in 13. Line was worse last year. Skills were worse last year. 4 yds in a half against SF? 1 first down against Minn? His bad pass % is just that! Bad. His pressure to sack ratio is worse than anything you saw with JF. And again, the roster CW is working with is waaaaay better!

  • @JackSapeon-y9d
    @JackSapeon-y9d 14 годин тому +1

    Understandment is a word.

    • @JWLSports
      @JWLSports  13 годин тому +1

      It is not. But I make up words all the time. But still funny to hear.

  • @williamjames648
    @williamjames648 14 годин тому +1

    I dont think you can properly grade Caleb on this season based on the level of dysfunction, that being said, when u score 0 points in the first half 4 weeks in a row, it can't be all the coaches. Merrill hodge said it best last year on Colins podcast, he doesn't see it neither have I. Ive seen this for years with the bears organization they blame the coach and want them fired then they get worse,. They haven't found anyone successful since lovie smith and it aint going to change, they will screw it up. There is literally no evidence that calebe has anything else but the wow plays and when you make them when they're down 20 and the defense is playing soft then its not really a wow game changing play

  • @ahastar1141
    @ahastar1141 15 годин тому +1

    I think blaming the bears organization is the easy part. The hard conversation is saying that Caleb has under performed as a good player on a bad team. Even in the vikings game he made very poor throwing decisions ( which weren't but should have been picked off) and missed wide open receivers ( not seeing them or overthrowing them).
    Probably the play that encapsolates this was at the the end of the game where caleb was scrambling left out of the pocket then came back right, and instead of hitting Cole K short across the middle, he throws an off balance on the move throw from the left side of the field to the right front endzone leading to a jump ball between the receiver and DB that ultimately got knocked down. No coach is going want their QB to make that throw and no NFL QB is going to make that throw.
    While his coaching and development haven't been good, some of his performances are just bad. If he's a generational talent, even he should be able to complete some passes in the first half of a game and not put up these disaterous first half numbers. We see flashes of talent, but just the inconsistency on routine throws and some of the decision making is not what you'd expect from a talent of his caliber

    • @Roger-hs1dl
      @Roger-hs1dl 4 години тому

      But he's not really under performing. It's playing exactly like a rookie. Better!! For some reason, you all just need become to want him to fail like you to. The new age sports fans are like transgenders, weirdos.

  • @electric8668
    @electric8668 Годину тому

    Question for Caleb Williams doubters..........Do you believe Caleb Williams would be playing better, the same or worse if he was QB for Detroit, Kansas City or Chargers?

  • @rachelnicholshusband8487
    @rachelnicholshusband8487 17 годин тому +2

    Understandment

  • @sammysam2615
    @sammysam2615 4 години тому +1

    He's not great. He has a better OLine, more weapons and essentially the same Dline. Yet both Trubisky and Fields had less and sports media attacked them but won't can't criticize Williams. It makes zero sense

  • @waynesonneman7343
    @waynesonneman7343 4 години тому

    Fields and Williams have one very important thing in common when it comes to the bears neither can do the most important thing and win games. End of story.

  • @scat_in_da_hat6648
    @scat_in_da_hat6648 12 годин тому +3

    His no interception stat really isn’t that impressive when you consider he isn’t even putting up points and is taking way more sacks because he’s holding the ball.. he just doesn’t have that “understandment” 😅

  • @allcalibasketball3029
    @allcalibasketball3029 12 годин тому

    This is what you get wheb Colin goes to lunch with the talent 😂

  • @Ekbird
    @Ekbird 9 годин тому

    What are the last three years a rookie quarterback went to the playoffs when inside the best division in football?

  • @Bearsgamepodcast
    @Bearsgamepodcast 16 годин тому

    Great video, man, but your audio keeps cutting out the entire thing...

  • @Secretarynotsure89
    @Secretarynotsure89 14 годин тому

    Reasons Poles should be fired: 1) he picked the Princess Bust; 2) He could have picked her AND kept Justin since he only got a sixth round pick and they could have battled for the position. If she can't win the job she doesn't deserve it. They didn't want to hurt her feelings, but there are no feelings in football; 3) They didn't even bring Jayden Daniels into Halas hall and he's the far better qb, not to mention Caleb could wind up being the worst qb prospect picked in the first round of the FIVE that were picked. 4) The team won 7 games last year and that #1 overall pick and the 9th pick could have allowed this team to add multiple pieces to that 7 win team and continue the upward trajectory.
    Poles is the problem. He gambled on the pocket princess and this organization is going backwards quickly. #ZackWilson2.0

    • @Roger-hs1dl
      @Roger-hs1dl 4 години тому

      Lol! You said you're not a Caleb hater! But you're literally in the multiple comment sections making long ridiculous comments talking about Caleb. You're sick with it😂.. You're having to much fun dog.
      You just need people too talk to huh?

    • @derekheerman9575
      @derekheerman9575 4 години тому

      Awful take 😂

  • @raprevenue1922
    @raprevenue1922 14 годин тому

    I said from the beginning Bagent should’ve been the until Caleb was ready. Caleb and the bears wanted to go through the growing pains so they equally share the blame for the record. The falcons for example will thrive with penix because they made sure he was ready. Now the bears have to hope this dysfunctional season doesn’t impact the future.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 10 годин тому

      @@raprevenue1922 Penix hasn't even taken a snap yet and you're crowning his ass. Just remarkable.

    • @raprevenue1922
      @raprevenue1922 10 годин тому

      @ I’m more so crowning the organization for waiting until they did to let their quarterback takeover. Get that jealousy out your blood.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 10 годин тому

      @@raprevenue1922 okay so tell me how you know Penix will be any good? Just sitting on your ass doesn't make you good.

  • @paulhester489
    @paulhester489 17 годин тому +10

    Why has Caleb has such a negative impact on Chicago Bears? Teammates do not like him. Despite having playbook since February he still runs around. Both OC and HC fired because of Caleb excuses. Media will not stop the excuse parade for Williams.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 16 годин тому +2

      You could have a play book for 5 years but you need time to execute the plays. How do you know players don't like him? Do you have friends in there or are you just hating?

    • @paulhester489
      @paulhester489 16 годин тому +1

      @Harold-w2y DJ Moore said last year Caleb and Drake were not better than Fields. Jaylon Johnson said Caleb better not bring that Diva drama to Chicago. Caleb told his teammates to clean up their areas. Caleb is toxic. Perhaps you are too.

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому +2

      Dude!!! I'm so tired of ppl saying that He got the HC and OC fired like they were something to lose!!! They were garbage and nvr should of been a choice to begin with. Who else needs to go is Poles!!! He made this mess and now they have to find someone else to clean up his buma## mess. 🙄

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому

      ​@@paulhester489How someone toxic, bcus they want a clean spot? That says more about you than anything. And he is better than Fields and quit bringing him up!!! Get off here crying about The Bears and go be a Steelers fan. You on here whining like a chick!

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому

      ​@@paulhester489How someone toxic, bcus they want a clean spot? That says more about you than anything. And he is better than Fields and quit bringing him up!!! Get off here crying about The Bears and go be a Steelers fan. You on here whining like a chick!

  • @cochisechicago
    @cochisechicago 14 годин тому

    Should have went the Eli route when he had the leverage.

  • @martykehoe8510
    @martykehoe8510 13 годин тому

    Any Bears fan that is putting blame on this kid doesn't have a clue of what they're talking about. the coaching is atrocious, the offensive line is simply offensive.

    • @allcalibasketball3029
      @allcalibasketball3029 12 годин тому

      You're definitely not a Bears fan. 43 out of his 58 sacks came after 4 seconds. His pressure to sack ratio is more than double percentage of the next QB in the league. That's not on the line. It's a coincidence. They blame the line at USC as well. Whatever happened to accountability?

    • @mattL---
      @mattL--- 11 годин тому

      @@allcalibasketball3029that could definitely be a coaching issue too…as an eagles fan, I was hard on hurts last year. He looked terrible. While he did have trouble reading the field, the coaches calling long developing plays also adds to the struggles. Recipe for disaster. If Caleb truly has all these weapons, getting them out in space and letting them work should be the play. They’re not doing that

    • @Dom2.0
      @Dom2.0 9 годин тому +1

      Just watch the film breakdowns... He's missing wide open guys, missing easy throws, and holding the ball forever taking sacks... he got his coaches fired because the organization is watching film and seeing that it's him failing the team. You don't add all these weapons to last years 7 win team and get WORSE...

  • @brandonromero6806
    @brandonromero6806 16 годин тому +3

    There is no evidence that Caleb is great. Its hard to be great in NFL. He doesn’t have the ability to read defenses or keep up with speed of game. Coaching could fix that. But that takes right coach and some winning to build confidence. And unfortunately his team is by far the worst in that division. Detroit has at least 2 years before they have to pay everyone. Vikings are just getting going and so are packers so not sure when he will have a chance to shine even if he magically becomes twice as good.
    I don’t think you can ignore that his numbers are all coming in garbage time. That’s concerning. I can handle picks and bad decisions. Not being able to keep up is concerning. Yes his oline is bad but honestly only like 10 teams have good ones.

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому

      Well go out and do better, since you on here acting like you can do better. I'm tired of couch potatoes, like you think they can do something or better!!

    • @brandonromero6806
      @brandonromero6806 16 годин тому

      @ thats got to be the dumbest comment I have ever seen. The guy is being paid millions of dollars to be one of 32 people on the planet who can do his job. He will be evaluated as such.

    • @Roger-hs1dl
      @Roger-hs1dl 4 години тому

      ​@@brandonromero6806Naw, your new era comment section fans have become pompous, overly critical jealous men. It's like you all get off trying to demoralize other fans. Strait weirdos..

  • @7nawt7
    @7nawt7 18 годин тому +8

    Nothing to work with, a stretch. He has three number one wide receivers

    • @big04marsh19
      @big04marsh19 17 годин тому

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @big04marsh19
      @big04marsh19 17 годин тому +1

      You forgot a good te and 1000 yard back

    • @bluemilk6057
      @bluemilk6057 17 годин тому +1

      None of that matters if the offensive line can't block

    • @orlandobaldwin1717
      @orlandobaldwin1717 16 годин тому +2

      @@bluemilk6057dawg what? did u forget what burrow did? he made a sb and 2 afc championships. im not even a bengals fan but u cant blame the line.

    • @organix85
      @organix85 16 годин тому +2

      Speaking of a stretch… saying he has 3 No. 1’s is a stretch.

  • @des8301
    @des8301 15 годин тому

    Lmao understandment 😂😂😂

  • @BSHEP23
    @BSHEP23 16 годин тому +4

    If the Bears had Baker Mayfield or Sam Darnold they would be in the playoffs this season.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 14 годин тому +5

      @@BSHEP23 there is no shortage of comedians commenting here.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 14 годин тому +3

      @@BSHEP23 they would both be on IR and Darnold might still be in the hospital.

    • @MarloJackson-d7k
      @MarloJackson-d7k 10 годин тому +1

      Not with this offensive line!!!

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 10 годин тому +1

      @@MarloJackson-d7k yes with this offensive line. Darnold holds the ball on average longer than Williams and with his cement feet he would already be out for the season.

    • @BSHEP23
      @BSHEP23 9 годин тому

      @@Harold-w2y Average quarterback play would have the Bears in the playoffs this season.

  • @SauceRicky88
    @SauceRicky88 17 годин тому +3

    Maybe Caleb will get better, but from what I can see, he can’t read defenses

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 16 годин тому

      I am glad you can't read defenses or do any real analysis.

    • @SauceRicky88
      @SauceRicky88 16 годин тому +1

      @ it’s obvious don’t be mad at me, Geez it is what it is yall fell in love with college highlights the nfl isn’t the Pac 12 💀😂

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому

      ​@@SauceRicky88you can go be a Steelers fan! Bcus Justin wasn't it neither!

    • @SauceRicky88
      @SauceRicky88 16 годин тому

      @@midwestkrazy83turner50 do I have to be a bears fan to comment? 😂

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 15 годин тому

      @SauceRicky88 who's your team? And yes! Bcus why do you care if you ain't? You just trolling.

  • @klohr311
    @klohr311 7 годин тому

    Don’t blame him? Lol..Qb position is the most prize position with money and fame and takes the most of the blame for the team win and loss. Even Troy on mnf says take the blame even if it’s not your fault.

  • @SteveSweetness34
    @SteveSweetness34 9 годин тому

    Under… stand…mint!

  • @fracturedsolace145
    @fracturedsolace145 17 годин тому

    Denver lost yesterday a day maybe it's me but your audio kept cutting out.

  • @angusnegrin
    @angusnegrin 3 години тому

    For me is Ben Johnson or nothing.

  • @Game-kp1zk
    @Game-kp1zk 18 годин тому

    This teams failure is poles he needs to be fire. Imagine Caleb playing behind Washington’s offensive line.

    • @big04marsh19
      @big04marsh19 17 годин тому +1

      Washington oline is middle of the pack has been bad last 3 games stop give Jayden 3 good wr and a good te

    • @Emmanuel-b5q
      @Emmanuel-b5q 17 годин тому

      They're not firing the GM that actually got the quarterback for lol

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 16 годин тому

      ​@big04marsh19 just look at the stats. When Washington can't run the ball and have to rely on Daniels to pass every down they don't score. Watch what happens Sunday when the Eagles shut down the run and Daniels has to throw.

  • @jessiehuskey40
    @jessiehuskey40 6 годин тому

    It will harden him

  • @ericstewart8508
    @ericstewart8508 14 годин тому

    Dude you was losing in college 😂

  • @allcalibasketball3029
    @allcalibasketball3029 12 годин тому +1

    This stat tells it out. 43 out of the 58 times he's been sacked came after 4 seconds. The ball should be released within at least 2.5 seconds. Stop blaming the offensive line.
    Caleb has the worst pressure to sack ratio,more than double the next QB.
    Feet are not stable in the pocket and very inaccurate throwing the ball down the field

  • @jeffortman6395
    @jeffortman6395 5 годин тому

    No run game

  • @allcalibasketball3029
    @allcalibasketball3029 12 годин тому +1

    Generational talent my ass 😂😂

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 11 годин тому

      @@allcalibasketball3029 FGB

  • @kareem9954
    @kareem9954 13 годин тому +2

    Colin is talking crazy in this segment. Caleb is not good.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 11 годин тому +1

      @@kareem9954 FGB

    • @MarloJackson-d7k
      @MarloJackson-d7k 10 годин тому +2

      Stop hating!!! This offensive line is garbage!!! 17tds and 5 ints

    • @donniereiter3646
      @donniereiter3646 2 години тому

      You don’t know football rookie

  • @jessiehuskey40
    @jessiehuskey40 6 годин тому

    Is that word?

  • @JackSapeon-y9d
    @JackSapeon-y9d 14 годин тому +1

    Stat padding . All those yards , TDs happen during garbage time

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 14 годин тому

      @@JackSapeon-y9d of course they did, those 340 yards against the Vikings were all during garbage time.

    • @Dom2.0
      @Dom2.0 9 годин тому

      Exactly.. he plays good when the defense knows the game is basically over and get soft.. he doesn't put together even 3 qtrs of football

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 8 годин тому

      @@Dom2.0 apparently you don't watch much football and are just a casual observer. So, give a a specific example of what you consider garbage time. Score / Deficit / time remaining. Before you do keep in mind many teams have rallied from large deficits to win.

    • @Dom2.0
      @Dom2.0 8 годин тому

      @Harold-w2y actually I know way more than you casuals in these comments sections because I actually been around teams for work and I watch film breakdowns, I speak from TAPE not feeling and opinions, maybe you should try it before looking stupid to the public.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 7 годин тому

      @Dom2.0 if you

  • @PukeyMcDork
    @PukeyMcDork 13 годин тому

    Caleb is a bust. He was simply overhyped and so many people got sucked into the circus. It's hard for people to look past the garbage time stats and just say This Guy Is Not That Good. In a way, he was doomed from the start because he is so much more like Manziel than Mahomes. And we were promised Day One Greatness. DAY ONE!

    • @JWLSports
      @JWLSports  13 годин тому

      lol a “bust”

    • @PukeyMcDork
      @PukeyMcDork 13 годин тому

      He did not meet expectations. Ergo, bust

  • @1848revolt
    @1848revolt 8 годин тому

    He is so great at holding on to the ball.

  • @trvaron
    @trvaron 14 годин тому

    I blame the Bears. Quarterbacks go there to die. What I blame Caleb for is deciding not to go back for his senior year KNOWING that he'd go to the Bears. I'm hoping that the Bears CAN'T figure things out and that Caleb can be traded to a legit team that can properly develop him. We'll see what happens.

  • @CapPTanMcKringleBerries
    @CapPTanMcKringleBerries 17 годин тому +3

    Next year he will wear a different shade of nail polish and lipstick and we'll have a better year

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 17 годин тому +1

      Ha ha ha!! You're so funny you should be doing stand up somewhere.

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому +1

      STOP IT 🛑. Go find something constructive to do with ur life.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 14 годин тому

      @midwestkrazy83turner50 thanks father.

    • @Harold-w2y
      @Harold-w2y 14 годин тому

      @@midwestkrazy83turner50 your comment is constructive?

    • @Secretarynotsure89
      @Secretarynotsure89 14 годин тому

      She’s just trying to make it to the end of the season so she can go shopping for dresses and makeup. 💄 her mind is far from the football field

  • @tmac3549
    @tmac3549 16 годин тому

    The Bears fans are the problem. Bitching and blaming everyone but themselves for supporting this crap. Chicago fans always blame a player from each team every season. The owners got you sprung and they know you will keep coming back for more pain. Going into 2025 I’m blaming the fans. It’s your turn to take criticism. Stop going to the games and watch shit change.

    • @montezzz8721
      @montezzz8721 16 годин тому +1

      Blaming the fans is a lukeworm iq level take lol. Chicago has the third highest population and one singular team this isn’t Florida/LA/New York/Pennsylvania/Texas where if one team is dogshit we can jump ship across town. Chicago owners are across all sports the cheapest, blaming the fans makes no sense. You don’t think we’re waiting for Virginia to kick the bucket or Reinsdorf to sell the Bulls and Sox?

    • @midwestkrazy83turner50
      @midwestkrazy83turner50 16 годин тому +1

      ​@@montezzz8721yea. Dude had no clue what he was talking about? Just saying something to be noticed. How you blame fans? Like We have say so in the moves they make! LMAO, SMH

    • @montezzz8721
      @montezzz8721 16 годин тому

      @@midwestkrazy83turner50 Exactly such a loser ass mentality lmao. “Leave the team when they suck then just come back when they’re good it’s that simple” guaranteed he’s a Cowboys/Lakers/Yankees fan as well. His whole solution for a city that big is for everyone to stop watching football like it’s Jacksonville or some shit

    • @s6xafterse7en
      @s6xafterse7en 9 годин тому

      Agreed, Bears fans are dumb as fuck.