I was wrong when i said Muzammil is ray of hope for Pakistani society. He is the LIGHT HOUSE,a real bright one . It takes lot of courage to speak in the toxic society. My respect for you grows with every video of yours. More courage and strength, respect to you. Thank you.
Sabse acchi baat: Black hole me itni presence pahle nahi dekhi, wo bhi aaj Pakistan ka cricket match bhi hai. All credit goes to Mr Muzammil. Ek aur khas baat: Pakistan ke youth me badlaw aa raha hai, wo facts ke sath JINA pasand kar rahi hai. Salute to Mr Muzammil and listeners.
Through this kind of podcast.. First time as a Indian i am getting to know pakistan deeply.. Otherwise mainstream media just focus on warmongering when it comes to Pakistan...
Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high Where knowledge is free Where the world has not been broken up into fragments By narrow domestic walls Where words come out from the depth of truth Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit Where the mind is led forward by thee Into ever-widening thought and action Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake.
Nowadays almost all are commoners have hot debate of boycott of certain products. And if you ever dare to share any information or give any rational opinion on that you have no idea what replies you get.... absolute happiness to listen to you man .
As an Indian, I am immensely inspired by Muzzamil. His discourses are so interesting as not only do you learn geo politics but also philosophy of great minds like Nietzsche. I wish that Pakistanis and Indians bridge our gaps in the years to come and overcome our differences.
00:07 Current challenges in modernization in Pakistan 02:18 The transition to modernity in Pakistan and its impact on economy and society. 06:29 Individual autonomy is the key to modernity. 08:36 Lack of clarity in Pakistan's social contract 13:02 The impact of lack of modernization on scientific inquiry 15:11 Challenges in education and societal progress in Pakistan. 19:22 Challenges in privatization and corruption in Pakistan 21:19 Pakistan needs to practice foreign policy isolation for development and growth. 25:10 Focus on maintaining a moral society through upbringing and social order. 26:50 Modernization in Pakistan: Challenges and Progress 30:31 Impact of social attitudes on the economy 32:32 Challenges in modernizing Pakistan 36:28 Support for modernization in Pakistan is crucial for progress 38:22 Challenges of women's freedom to work and exercise in Pakistan 42:09 Democracy requires individual empowerment and philosophical change 44:09 Understanding the impact of philosophical dialogues on creating public consent 47:38 Concerns about corruption and wealth sources in institutions 49:34 Challenges in Pakistan's modernization 53:14 Discussion on political landscape in Pakistan 54:52 Challenges in appreciating art and culture in Pakistan 58:26 The need to modernize Pakistan's mindset and approach towards progress. 1:00:25 Discussing challenges of modernization in Pakistan. 1:04:08 Challenges and solutions for modernization in Pakistan 1:06:13 Challenges in Pakistani modernization due to government and military influence 1:09:50 Impact of extreme violence on social order 1:11:38 Discussion on sacrifices made for education and societal advancement 1:15:41 Discussion on discourse created by Pakistan 1:17:53 Importance of evolving identity in Pakistan 1:21:44 Pakistan's historical support for Islamist regimes 1:23:28 The industry has earned 35 billion dollars 1:27:27 Challenges in governing Pakistan 1:29:18 Land reform in Pakistan 1:32:51 Importance of questioning and discourse in education system 1:34:35 Challenges of education system in Pakistan 1:38:27 Challenges in Pakistan's modernization 1:40:16 Challenges in career choices in Pakistan 1:44:09 Challenges of Radicalization in Pakistan 1:46:06 The need for change in Parliament and its impact on society 1:49:45 Discussion on the legacy and conflict in Pakistan 1:51:26 Discussion on the impact of modernization on education in Pakistan 1:56:34 Importance of journalism and alternative media 1:58:43 Challenges in Pakistani citizenship process 2:02:11 Challenges in political ideologies and power dynamics 2:04:03 Challenges faced by common people in Pakistan 2:07:50 Discussion on modernization in various regions of Pakistan 2:09:45 Challenges in achieving autonomy in Southern Punjab 2:13:17 Revolution in True Nature Thunk
Sir you are truely inspiration of young boys and girls of pakistan.pakistan needs man like you then pakistan bring changes.love from india best wishes.
بہت اعلی اس طرح کی مکالمہ کوشش مثبت تبدیلی کی طرف پہلا قدم ہے میں آپ تمام دوستوں کے لئے دعا گو ہوں آپ کی کامیابی نسل کی کامیابی تصور کرتا ہوں سلامت رہیں
Academics in India should learn from the concept of "The Black Hole" and thinkers, specially those who don't get space in the establishment of Social Studies department of our Arts & Humanities Universities, should arrange quality discussion on this forum.
एक बार फिर से ... बहुत शानदार अनुभव! You are Hero, as one boy said, "You are Shahrukh Khan of Baloch youth." कभी भारत आने का प्रोग्राम हो तो बताना, मैं जरूर मिलने आऊंगा। Best of Luck bro.
Yeh Muzammal sahab ki mohabbat hay k sawalat khatam honay ka name ni le rahay kyunkeh he is among the young fresh blood beings as fresh n flexible beings
Great to hear M Z Shah about how to bring Modrenity in Pakistan., which I hope brings real change there in their idealogy! One point raised by one student - Abdul Kalam Azad (guided by Mr Nehru) first Education Minister of India to promote I.I.T's helped development in Indi but he also played down the true history of Ancient India by not including ancient learning Centres like Taxila and Nalanda universities and their role to promote and seek knowledge in school history course books which fanatised great progress made under Islamic and British rulers.
Dear Muzammil, I suggest you create a group of people like yourself, Pervez Hoodboy and other rational people and run a focused campaign across Pakistan among youth. I hope and pray that you guys succeed in inculcating the desire to pursue rational and progressive path , which helps Pakistan to stand on own feet and make progress.
The lack of individuals as a roadblock to enlightenment reminds Immanuel Kant’s saying that ‘Enlightenment is man’s emergence from his self-imposed immaturity. Immaturity is the inability to use one’s understanding without guidance from another’.
Several years ago a person wanted me to invest in education in Pakistan , I told her I don’t believe Pakistani education is viable as people lack critical thinking , and intolerance can not coexist with education 😊
This is certainly a ray of hope from “across the border”. Wonder how much momentum such discussions can generate so as to effect a fundamental change in this disaster called “Pakistan”, and how long it will take it will take to get them out of the black hole that they have gotten into since the madness of August 1947?
Muzamil mentions all the ethnicities except the Punjabis. No one knows about the massacre of the Punjabis in 1947. Millions were butchered and about 10 million were displaced. Hundreds of thousands of women were abducted raped and killed. Children lost their parents and never met their families again.
There are many indian critical thinkers like Muzammil bhai. 🇮🇳 But people don't want there delusions and favours to be criticized. *Watch kanhaiya kumar's old videos, Jignesh mewani, ravish kumar, Abhijeet banerjee, Meera Nanda, shashi tharoor, raghuram rajan, Arundhati roy, sonam Wangchuk, P. Sainath, Ashok kumar pandey, OSHO and many more.*
From where you are, man 🎉 Excellent dear From where you got the education. First person I have heard talking sensible and human Bravo, Pak needs more like you, keep growing
Actual hero of Pakistan was khan Abdul Gaffar khan, Keizer Hayat Tiwana, Allah Bux soomru etc but you have rejected them adopting Jinnah , British, feudalism, communalism .over all your debate is in positive direction.
All Pakistani, this guy is a gem. Protect him and listen to him.
Beauty is that most of the viewers of this video are from India 🙂
Protect this man at any cost!!!!
Our students from rural areas seem more enlightened and rational then ones residing in Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad.
شہروں کے بچے اب سارے برگر ہیں
I was wrong when i said Muzammil is ray of hope for Pakistani society.
He is the LIGHT HOUSE,a real bright one .
It takes lot of courage to speak in the toxic society.
My respect for you grows with every video of yours.
More courage and strength, respect to you.
Thank you.
Muzammil is a future ... He is such a excellent person .. Pakistan need such people .. stay blessed..
Most intellectual person I have ever seen ❤ hats off from pune Maharashtra india 🇮🇳
I am from India & I religiously follow both - The Black Hole & Syed Muzammil - Both are Great in their own aspects 👏👏
I am a Hindu Indian eagerly listen muzammil a rising philosopher of Pak who critically analise the pak society issues, best wishes
Pakistan needs more people like him. Only Pakistani youths can bring changes in Pakistan.
Praying for a prosperous and cultural tolerant Pakistan.
Tha jiska intizar wo Intellectual aagaya. Great to see him again ❤🎉
پاکستان کے ہر نوجوان کو مزمل شاہ کے لیکچرز سننے چاہئیں ۔
Sabse acchi baat:
Black hole me itni presence pahle nahi dekhi, wo bhi aaj Pakistan ka cricket match bhi hai. All credit goes to Mr Muzammil.
Ek aur khas baat:
Pakistan ke youth me badlaw aa raha hai, wo facts ke sath JINA pasand kar rahi hai.
Salute to Mr Muzammil and listeners.
سید مزمل کی گفتگو ہمیشہ حقائق کے قریب تر ہوتی ہے وجوہات سے لے کر مسائل کے حل تک ۔
Good to see so many Pakistanis coming out to hear Muzammil. He is one of the very few sensible voices of Pakistan.
I don't believe that pakistan has intellectual like syed Muzammil.... Love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Oh shut up. Love ❤️from Pakistan. 😊
I never thought I would listen to a Pakistani for more than half hour. I hope his spark ushers Pakistan into new mental attitude.
This guy is a GEM indeed , really love this MAN.
Respect Syed muzzamil shah 🗿💯
Through this kind of podcast.. First time as a Indian i am getting to know pakistan deeply.. Otherwise mainstream media just focus on warmongering when it comes to Pakistan...
Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high
Where knowledge is free
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments
By narrow domestic walls
Where words come out from the depth of truth
Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection
Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit
Where the mind is led forward by thee
Into ever-widening thought and action
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake.
Glad to see full house first time in Black Hole.
Congratulations Muzzamil Bhai.
Youths of Pakistan want to open their minds.
Good sign.
All the Best.
Nowadays almost all are commoners have hot debate of boycott of certain products. And if you ever dare to share any information or give any rational opinion on that you have no idea what replies you get....
absolute happiness to listen to you man .
Wow it's revolutionary speech sir love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏🙏
As an Indian, I am immensely inspired by Muzzamil.
His discourses are so interesting as not only do you learn geo politics but also philosophy of great minds like Nietzsche.
I wish that Pakistanis and Indians bridge our gaps in the years to come and overcome our differences.
bro he have read sociology, philosophy, political science, international relations , science . take a bow
My favourite political commentator/analyst.I could listen to this guy for hours!
00:07 Current challenges in modernization in Pakistan
02:18 The transition to modernity in Pakistan and its impact on economy and society.
06:29 Individual autonomy is the key to modernity.
08:36 Lack of clarity in Pakistan's social contract
13:02 The impact of lack of modernization on scientific inquiry
15:11 Challenges in education and societal progress in Pakistan.
19:22 Challenges in privatization and corruption in Pakistan
21:19 Pakistan needs to practice foreign policy isolation for development and growth.
25:10 Focus on maintaining a moral society through upbringing and social order.
26:50 Modernization in Pakistan: Challenges and Progress
30:31 Impact of social attitudes on the economy
32:32 Challenges in modernizing Pakistan
36:28 Support for modernization in Pakistan is crucial for progress
38:22 Challenges of women's freedom to work and exercise in Pakistan
42:09 Democracy requires individual empowerment and philosophical change
44:09 Understanding the impact of philosophical dialogues on creating public consent
47:38 Concerns about corruption and wealth sources in institutions
49:34 Challenges in Pakistan's modernization
53:14 Discussion on political landscape in Pakistan
54:52 Challenges in appreciating art and culture in Pakistan
58:26 The need to modernize Pakistan's mindset and approach towards progress.
1:00:25 Discussing challenges of modernization in Pakistan.
1:04:08 Challenges and solutions for modernization in Pakistan
1:06:13 Challenges in Pakistani modernization due to government and military influence
1:09:50 Impact of extreme violence on social order
1:11:38 Discussion on sacrifices made for education and societal advancement
1:15:41 Discussion on discourse created by Pakistan
1:17:53 Importance of evolving identity in Pakistan
1:21:44 Pakistan's historical support for Islamist regimes
1:23:28 The industry has earned 35 billion dollars
1:27:27 Challenges in governing Pakistan
1:29:18 Land reform in Pakistan
1:32:51 Importance of questioning and discourse in education system
1:34:35 Challenges of education system in Pakistan
1:38:27 Challenges in Pakistan's modernization
1:40:16 Challenges in career choices in Pakistan
1:44:09 Challenges of Radicalization in Pakistan
1:46:06 The need for change in Parliament and its impact on society
1:49:45 Discussion on the legacy and conflict in Pakistan
1:51:26 Discussion on the impact of modernization on education in Pakistan
1:56:34 Importance of journalism and alternative media
1:58:43 Challenges in Pakistani citizenship process
2:02:11 Challenges in political ideologies and power dynamics
2:04:03 Challenges faced by common people in Pakistan
2:07:50 Discussion on modernization in various regions of Pakistan
2:09:45 Challenges in achieving autonomy in Southern Punjab
2:13:17 Revolution in True Nature Thunk
I am Indian. I am libral. I can make pakistan great. I am harvard law student. I appreciate you 🎉🎉
Thanks for coming on the second time.
Very thought provoking. May you continue to spread this wisdom.
Lovely syed muzmmil shah.
Your a great teacher❤❤❤
I am from a very rural area of Punjab .I like his videos..
Sir you are truely inspiration of young boys and girls of pakistan.pakistan needs man like you then pakistan bring changes.love from india best wishes.
Awesome session. Eye opener about what’s happening in Pakistan.
Best session for progressive peoples in Pakistan.
بہت اعلی اس طرح کی مکالمہ کوشش مثبت تبدیلی کی طرف پہلا قدم ہے میں آپ تمام دوستوں کے لئے دعا گو ہوں آپ کی کامیابی نسل کی کامیابی تصور کرتا ہوں سلامت رہیں
Academics in India should learn from the concept of "The Black Hole" and thinkers, specially those who don't get space in the establishment of Social Studies department of our Arts & Humanities Universities, should arrange quality discussion on this forum.
I too clapped for you, ( India). You are also telling the truth for my country..
Syed Muzammil should be made the Prime Minister of Pakistan
एक बार फिर से ... बहुत शानदार अनुभव! You are Hero, as one boy said, "You are Shahrukh Khan of Baloch youth." कभी भारत आने का प्रोग्राम हो तो बताना, मैं जरूर मिलने आऊंगा।
Best of Luck bro.
Woooww Yar!.....This type of mentality people should be in our India too😊
Ability to influence people mentally and physically ❤
Yeh Muzammal sahab ki mohabbat hay k sawalat khatam honay ka name ni le rahay kyunkeh he is among the young fresh blood beings as fresh n flexible beings
Always a delight to see a houseful at The Black Hole. Fresh wave of thoughts and insights by Muzammil.❤
Each n every word of the speech is very thoughtful n intereting. Kudos to the audience. Huge respect and love to you Sir from J&K!🇮🇳❤️ TYSM!
Great to hear M Z Shah about how to bring Modrenity in Pakistan., which I hope brings real change there in their idealogy! One point raised by one student - Abdul Kalam Azad (guided by Mr Nehru) first Education Minister of India to promote I.I.T's helped development in Indi but he also played down the true history of Ancient India by not including ancient learning Centres like Taxila and Nalanda universities and their role to promote and seek knowledge in school history course books which fanatised great progress made under Islamic and British rulers.
This is what I pay my Internet Bills for.
I think i am the one nepali 🇳🇵 watching your video 📷❤
Excellent informed and balanced analysis. Thank you.
Outstanding speaker and hats off to TBH.🤩
Syed bhai you are very courageous. Please be safe in the land of Talibaan controlled by Pakistan army
Amazing, love from India ❤
God bless Syed Muzammil Shah and other free thinkers.
I am so glad that you can use this platform for putting your point of view across!👍🏼👏🙏
All time my favourite syed muzamil shah and parvez hoodboy
Played for family during our long drive home, up to 1:12:59
Dear Muzammil, I suggest you create a group of people like yourself, Pervez Hoodboy and other rational people and run a focused campaign across Pakistan among youth. I hope and pray that you guys succeed in inculcating the desire to pursue rational and progressive path , which helps Pakistan to stand on own feet and make progress.
Survival of this intellectual man in Islamic radicals of Pakistan is very difficult 😥 😢😢
Muzammal bhai ❤ from france 🇫🇷
Eye opening predictions for Pakistan is 13 predictions in 1947 by Maulana Abul Kalam Azad first education minister of India.
Congratulations, the first time it seems the hall is full of youth.
💐🌷🌹🙏
To listen the ground reality .
Muzamil shah is in one of the best rational thinkers ❤❤❤
For the first time I listened and watched the whole session so attentionally.
Shah ji love you
U live in our hearts and u merged in our enlightened brain u give us path
We are lucky to have you
The lack of individuals as a roadblock to enlightenment reminds Immanuel Kant’s saying that ‘Enlightenment is man’s emergence from his self-imposed immaturity.
Immaturity is the inability to use one’s understanding without guidance from another’.
This guy is always a delight to listen to.
You are a gem to be mentored ( Retired Prof )
Several years ago a person wanted me to invest in education in Pakistan , I told her I don’t believe Pakistani education is viable as people lack critical thinking , and intolerance can not coexist with education 😊
great muzammil sahb,,,,my hero
Amazing intellect Muzamil. Pakistan is lucky to have you.
Yes true shah sb, we lack rationalism , deeply rooted in radicalization.
❤❤❤
For The Black Hole & Dr. Parvez Hoodhbhoy
👍👍👍
&
👏👏👏
For Syed Muzammil: keep shining & enlightening all of us young man.
We watch it from India. What a great discussion from Pakistan .
The black hole is simply👌
Good Luck mujjamil Bhai 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏May God bless you for helping Pakistani people spreading Wisdom ❤️🙏❤️
Excellent discussion! ❤️🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩❤️
Lots of ❤ from India
The people of Pakistan cannot be blamed for anything. The issues lies on the top.
i am rightist but learned a lot from brother muzammil.
The only sane voice to hear in Pakistan. Knowledge is glazingly abundant in you. muzamil.
So good
This is certainly a ray of hope from “across the border”. Wonder how much momentum such discussions can generate so as to effect a fundamental change in this disaster called “Pakistan”, and how long it will take it will take to get them out of the black hole that they have gotten into since the madness of August 1947?
With Syed Muzammil around, there's still hope for South East Asia
Muzamil you are most welcome to India. The Indian Muslims can learn a lot from you
Love you muzammil from USA. My salute to your parents
Muzamil mentions all the ethnicities except the Punjabis. No one knows about the massacre of the Punjabis in 1947. Millions were butchered and about 10 million were displaced. Hundreds of thousands of women were abducted raped and killed. Children lost their parents and never met their families again.
There are many indian critical thinkers like Muzammil bhai. 🇮🇳
But people don't want there delusions and favours to be criticized.
*Watch kanhaiya kumar's old videos, Jignesh mewani, ravish kumar, Abhijeet banerjee, Meera Nanda, shashi tharoor, raghuram rajan, Arundhati roy, sonam Wangchuk, P. Sainath, Ashok kumar pandey, OSHO and many more.*
the real hero of pakistan.
Is there any one University in Pakistan where a secular atmosphere is allowed to breed ? Where minority rights are protected?
Pakistan does not deserve this man.Syed Muzammil is a rare individual.
From where you are, man 🎉
Excellent dear
From where you got the education.
First person I have heard talking sensible and human
Bravo, Pak needs more like you, keep growing
The strong do what they can, they weak suffer what they must.
How a man can b so intelligent & non aligned to islamic ideologies in a couple like Pakistan.
No one match her energy level to change the society hads off to sayad 👍👍👍
Very happy to see jam packed hall. Deserving speaker.
we need more people like him
I don't know Why nobody has invited Sayyed muzamil in India yet despite the fact indians loves listening him....
Actual hero of Pakistan was khan Abdul Gaffar khan, Keizer Hayat Tiwana, Allah Bux soomru etc but you have rejected them adopting Jinnah , British, feudalism, communalism .over all your debate is in positive direction.
It was Martin Luthdr NOT Martin Luthsr King who played a big role in European reformation.
Martinuther Ki g waa a Black leader in USA.