The person in charge and the Committe responsible should resign. If TMK was according to the Academy bureaucrats, chosen by poll, we should know the details like number, target group etc. Wokism in Music Academy and tarnishing of the spotless tradition of the Academy are a strict no-no. Whether it's Jyotishs or Bharatanatyam or Carnatic music, they all derive from our Vedas, as our Mahaperiva had clearly pointed out. The Academy's bureaucrats should go. All financial support should be stopped. The bureaucrats should be forced to quit if they don't leave by themselves after such a disgraceful decision. There's NO room for "social reform" or politics in Carnatic music which is a musical extension of Tamilnadu's & Bharat's Bhakti movement.
Very well said. Shameless TM Krishna is a crypto Christian and part of Tukde Tukde gang. That's why he is backed by Hinduphobic Brahminophobic DMK Stalin
Dr.Vijayalakshmi and Ramprasad ji You put across your correct thoughts so well and effectively. The anchor has no intention of listening and when she is cornered , she says she doesn’t understand and goes for a break.
The Irony of the fact is carnatic music are sung in reverence to God and this Regime which is totally anti God is acting to be the protector of the Carnatic Music.That is the underlying Irony of the whole matter.
Wrong notion and narrative to start as Carnatic Music is always a controversy. Carnatic music is about Bhakti-Rakti-Shakti. It’s just that since a Decade TMK joined Leftist gang for his personal milage and leftist media’s highlighted for obvious reasons. It’s a foul mouth of one person versus over 10000 years of rich history with Millions of Artists and Rasikas . Keep your facts clear and bring a true Narrative .
Very difficult for this slender group to fight against mighty. Sri. N. Murali and Mr. N .Ram. keep quiet and come forward to glorify the music of T.M.K the Tansen of South India.
You oppose/fight because you feel something is not right. ‘Winning’ or ‘losing’ is not the immediate issue though in the long it is crucial. Someone has to start a battle. It might be lost. After many more battles, the war may be won or lost, on its own merit.
The anchor has lost it when she confuses herself about music in general and Carnatic music in particular. Even TMK’s main point is it is Carnatic Music that has shut its doors to others who aren’t Brahmins. Most news channels and their anchors don’t seem to understand what TMK stands for and why is he opposed and the comical (?) role of MMA that is accused and was boycotted by TMK now bending its back and hastily announcing in March the award which hitherto used to be announced in July/August!
I heard you speaking with such legends. Firstly just because u r a journalist u need not show your arrogance while speaking with them. Secondly you haven’t gone through the brahminical persecution to understand this.
Did not like the way she ended it without allowing others talk. I mean if most of the takers for it are Brahmins that's not thing to be discussed. The communities must want to come in and can we force everyone to take upto music? In that case, why madurai some did not receive Sangita kalinidhi. Is it musicians(mostly Brahmins) or listeners(mostly Brahmins) fault?
This anchor is clearly unpredictable. It's odd that she speaks softly for a moment, then raises her tone; it's unclear why she becomes so effervescent. She takes breaks at odd times, then calls on another guest after the break. Cannot subscribe to propaganda channels.
So, who is going to bell the cat ? Who is going to teach Dalits to sing, appreciate, and imbibe Carnatic music, like how T M Krishna suggests ? All this seems like a “ lot of Hot Air”. All said and done, who will have the desire, time, and energy, to create “interest and love”;for this ancient Art in these so called other sectors? Mastery in Carnatic music, like in many other accomplishments, requires specific discipline, and a like long effort and dedication, to Excel. Who will be the torch bearers to take up this “Gigantic responsibility”? Creating Diversity in the population of Carnatic community is not just hiring people randomly to fill slots (based on various castes / communities). This will merely result in disasters as those that we see today in other jobs / careers / education systems, where “Quota system” prevails. This will only end in “ Mediocrcy” ! Structural Changes such as this should occur very Slowly and Spontaneously. The desire to learn this art of Carnatic music should come from within, and Not be orchestrated by groups of people who consider it as their duty to include the entire population from various walks of life to imbibe Carnatic music. This is a serious point to ponder over, rather than get overexcited by debating and boycotting !
The reputation of the prestigious Music Academy has been brought down by awarding TM Krishna the Sangeetha Kalanidhi award. That shameless person has Christianised Carnatic music and insulted great legends like MS Subbulakshmi. That's why he is backed by DMK for their agenda. There is no bhava and bhakti in his music. He doesn't deserve it
He infact appreciated her in the beginning.. The anchor was just annoying and yelling and not allowing the guest to talk.. what do you expect? Why even invite someone if you are not gonna allow them to talk?
Painting it as hegemony, it being clustered is uttrrly baseless and should not be a permit fir anyone, least being a pro in this field to question the core values of the art. TMK is arrogant and the academy which chose him is even more in accepting fact that carnatic music is clustered which simply is not. As a mop I condemn TMK and support those who showed some spine in opposing to this outright hypocrisy and impertinance.
Dr Son you are not even 40 years old. Give all these dissucussions to others who are older than you. You have the future in front of you. Shut up and start singing
Host does not need any guest… she put forth questions and answers herself only with no consideration of views from guest…. Seems to be doing solo act with no respect to difference of opinion … good actor n modulation of voice but pathetic host… talking to herself
I want you to sing this again and embed this holy meaning in your Dentate gyrus region. ManasA eTulOrtunE nA manavini cEkonavE Dinakara kula bhUSaNi dInuDavai bhajana cEsi, dinamu gaDupu manina nIvu vinavadEla guNavihIna kalilO rAjasa tAmasa guNamula galavAri celimi galasi melasi tiruguchu mari kAlamu gaDapaka nivu Vadu painga neeku ela ee veruppu kanna sulabhamugA kaDatEranu thoova sudu sUcanalanu teliya jEyu ilanu adiyen Ee Partha septhadu bidda
2 cats fight over a piece of cake. Go to a monkey.asking for justice. The monkey ultimately eats the cake and disappointed cats watch. This story is getting enacted on the music accademy stage now. 🤔😊
Why did the host invite a guest, if she was not going to let him talk and just wants to make her points?
The person in charge and the Committe responsible should resign.
If TMK was according to the Academy bureaucrats, chosen by poll, we should know the details like number, target group etc.
Wokism in Music Academy and tarnishing of the spotless tradition of the Academy are a strict no-no.
Whether it's Jyotishs or Bharatanatyam or Carnatic music, they all derive from our Vedas, as our Mahaperiva had clearly pointed out.
The Academy's bureaucrats should go. All financial support should be stopped.
The bureaucrats should be forced to quit if they don't leave by themselves after such a disgraceful decision.
There's NO room for "social reform" or politics in Carnatic music which is a musical extension of Tamilnadu's & Bharat's Bhakti movement.
🙏
Very well said. Shameless TM Krishna is a crypto Christian and part of Tukde Tukde gang. That's why he is backed by Hinduphobic Brahminophobic DMK Stalin
Dr.Vijayalakshmi and Ramprasad ji
You put across your correct thoughts so well and effectively.
The anchor has no intention of listening and when she is cornered , she says she doesn’t understand and goes for a break.
The Irony of the fact is carnatic music are sung in reverence to God and this Regime which is totally anti God is acting to be the protector of the Carnatic Music.That is the underlying Irony of the whole matter.
Wrong notion and narrative to start as Carnatic Music is always a controversy.
Carnatic music is about Bhakti-Rakti-Shakti.
It’s just that since a Decade TMK joined
Leftist gang for his personal milage and leftist media’s highlighted for obvious reasons.
It’s a foul mouth of one person versus over 10000 years of rich history with Millions of Artists and Rasikas .
Keep your facts clear and bring a true Narrative .
Very difficult for this slender group to fight against mighty. Sri. N. Murali and Mr. N .Ram. keep quiet and come forward to glorify the music of T.M.K the Tansen of South India.
You oppose/fight because you feel something is not right. ‘Winning’ or ‘losing’ is not the immediate issue though in the long it is crucial.
Someone has to start a battle. It might be lost. After many more battles, the war may be won or lost, on its own merit.
Anchor clearly has an agenda.
Boycott her and this channel.
The anchor has lost it when she confuses herself about music in general and Carnatic music in particular. Even TMK’s main point is it is Carnatic Music that has shut its doors to others who aren’t Brahmins.
Most news channels and their anchors don’t seem to understand what TMK stands for and why is he opposed and the comical (?) role of MMA that is accused and was boycotted by TMK now bending its back and hastily announcing in March the award which hitherto used to be announced in July/August!
Yep, the same anchor who did not allow invitees to make their points when it was not in agreement of her points.
I heard you speaking with such legends. Firstly just because u r a journalist u need not show your arrogance while speaking with them.
Secondly you haven’t gone through the brahminical persecution to understand this.
What is Brahminical persecution? Who has experienced this?
Did not like the way she ended it without allowing others talk. I mean if most of the takers for it are Brahmins that's not thing to be discussed. The communities must want to come in and can we force everyone to take upto music? In that case, why madurai some did not receive Sangita kalinidhi. Is it musicians(mostly Brahmins) or listeners(mostly Brahmins) fault?
This anchor is clearly unpredictable. It's odd that she speaks softly for a moment, then raises her tone; it's unclear why she becomes so effervescent. She takes breaks at odd times, then calls on another guest after the break.
Cannot subscribe to propaganda channels.
Does the anchor know what ‘stonewalling’ means?!
The host should allow them to talk and not conclud without allowing them to answer those questions.
So, who is going to bell the cat ? Who is going to teach Dalits to sing, appreciate, and imbibe Carnatic music, like how T M Krishna suggests ? All this seems like a “ lot of Hot Air”. All said and done, who will have the desire, time, and energy, to create “interest and love”;for this ancient Art in these so called other sectors? Mastery in Carnatic music, like in many other accomplishments, requires specific discipline, and a like long effort and dedication, to Excel. Who will be the torch bearers to take up this “Gigantic responsibility”?
Creating Diversity in the population of Carnatic community is not just hiring people randomly to fill slots (based on various castes / communities). This will merely result in disasters as those that we see today in other jobs / careers / education systems, where “Quota system” prevails.
This will only end in “ Mediocrcy” !
Structural Changes such as this should occur very Slowly and Spontaneously. The desire to learn this art of Carnatic music should come from within, and Not be orchestrated by groups of people who consider it as their duty to include the entire population from various walks of life to imbibe Carnatic music.
This is a serious point to ponder over, rather than get overexcited by debating and boycotting !
The reputation of the prestigious Music Academy has been brought down by awarding TM Krishna the Sangeetha Kalanidhi award. That shameless person has Christianised Carnatic music and insulted great legends like MS Subbulakshmi. That's why he is backed by DMK for their agenda. There is no bhava and bhakti in his music. He doesn't deserve it
This "doctor" isn't answering any questions. He is just bent on being condescending to the anchor.
He infact appreciated her in the beginning.. The anchor was just annoying and yelling and not allowing the guest to talk.. what do you expect? Why even invite someone if you are not gonna allow them to talk?
He was perfectly respectful. The anchor is irritating.
Painting it as hegemony, it being clustered is uttrrly baseless and should not be a permit fir anyone, least being a pro in this field to question the core values of the art. TMK is arrogant and the academy which chose him is even more in accepting fact that carnatic music is clustered which simply is not. As a mop I condemn TMK and support those who showed some spine in opposing to this outright hypocrisy and impertinance.
Dr Son you are not even 40 years old. Give all these dissucussions to others who are older than you. You have the future in front of you. Shut up and start singing
Host does not need any guest… she put forth questions and answers herself only with no consideration of views from guest…. Seems to be doing solo act with no respect to difference of opinion … good actor n modulation of voice but pathetic host… talking to herself
I want you to sing this again and embed this holy meaning in your Dentate gyrus region. ManasA eTulOrtunE nA manavini cEkonavE
Dinakara kula bhUSaNi dInuDavai bhajana cEsi, dinamu gaDupu manina nIvu vinavadEla guNavihIna
kalilO rAjasa tAmasa guNamula galavAri celimi
galasi melasi tiruguchu mari kAlamu gaDapaka nivu
Vadu painga neeku ela ee veruppu kanna
sulabhamugA kaDatEranu thoova sudu sUcanalanu teliya jEyu
ilanu adiyen Ee Partha septhadu bidda
2 cats fight over a piece of cake.
Go to a monkey.asking for justice.
The monkey ultimately eats the cake and disappointed cats watch.
This story is getting enacted on the music accademy stage now. 🤔😊
So sad music stalwarts are compared to cats and monkeys