Personal Ranking: Jasmine | Aladdin (2019)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
- -Aladdin (2019)-
Remember, it's just my opinion, my perception of Jasmine which is determined by many factors. Read more below.
Once again, this live-action was really well casted, much better than BATB, so focus on my comments, not placements themselves.
I didn't include Persian versions on purpose.
My software didn't want to cooperate and I wasn't able to correct some things.
Intro Music:
• [Music box Cover] Alad...
Feel free to share your thoughts!
Hope you enjoy,
Meliae
The editting is so cute 😍😍
Thank you!
Great ranking, my dear!
💖
I was surprised by the first place, I love it when the rankings are not so predictable hehe
And thanks for Brazilian in the top 5 😊
Brazil did a wonderful job with live-actions! 💖 Indeed, I also love when I'm not sure what to expect! 😊
What I really love about your rankings is that you don't have that "same kind" of commentary about the artists! I didn't expect at all to see Hiba Tawaji in the first place but I gotta agree with you! Amazing video!!! I'm thinking on do a jasmine Ranking too!
That was really nice, thank you! I'm glad you agree with Hiba's placement, she's rather underrated. 😊
I'm in love with this heart transition that your editor has! our bottom ranks are really similar - I put Bulgarian in top 15, but now looking back I've grown to like her less and I'd agree with your placement. For some reason knowing that Annie Rojas said she struggled with the songs makes me sympathise & like her more! so thanks for sharing that piece of 'fun fact' 😀 Meshi's Jasmine is by far my least favourite role of hers, though I guess, I do like how she brings Oriental charm to Jasmine whereas you can't say so for Moana. Interesting how you think Korean & Chinese Mandarin are mirror images, they sound totally different to me 😅 I think Ding Shuang is very similar to Norwegian (by the way, I've no idea if you'd agree or disagree, but speaking of which other dubs the Chinese Mandarin voices remind me of - Weina & Kasia!) glad to see German high, a lot of people put that low because of too much autotune, but I genuinely can't hear it 🙈 another voice I'm happy to see in the top 10 is Hindi, my fav. Your comment for Croatian 😂 I think everyone's diet has failed with being stuck at home this year, the snack cupboard is too easily in reach. But shocked at first! in a good way, I LOVE Hiba and am overjoyed to see her get the appreciation 💕
I love it, too, that's why I overuse it. 😅 Bulgarian is really decent, but as I said, it may be easily overlooked and when compared with other ladies, it's not that impressive, unfortunately. Oh, my least favourite Meshi's role is Moana, actually - I completely cannot see her and Moana as one. By that mirror image I didn't really meant vocal timbre (which is completely different), but the way they express themselves, but perhaps I should have said differently. 😅 I can hear some autotune on Julia's voice, but it doesn't bother me that much. The diet " thing" - I know, right? Yay, glad to see a Hiba fan! ❤️
znowu ten zeszyt, tyle że tym razem mamy mniej niż 2 miesiące :"DDD aniwaiz ślicznie zedytowany filmik i mega wybory, a przede wszystkim ta top piętnastka 👌 damn a Meshi jak wysoko XD AND I OOP CO TO ZA PIERWSZE MIEJSCE-
U mnie wciąż będzie zdalnie, więc ten zeszyt nie robi na mnie wrażenia. :v Dankeschõn, mimo wszystko uważam, że to jedna z lepszych ról Meshi. ;') A Hiba - naprawdę nie rozumiem, dlaczego ludzie ją tak krytykują, no ale cóż, ja mam często dziwny gust - wszyscy szaleją za Marie Galey, natomiast ja nie, itp. itd.
Yes, another ranking from you :) I'm sad to see Bulgarian so low but I understand your point of view; and quite surprised to see Malay out of the top 10. Thanks for Portuguese in 12th place :D About the big top, I'm so glad to see that Russian made it, along with Hindi, Serbian, Brazilian and English. Probably we disagree the most about the 1st place but that's your opinion. Lovely ranking as always!
As I said in description, placements aren't of the first importance when it comes to Jasmine because she has so many wonderful voices, I really love Shila. I'm glad you agree with me on Russian! Thank you! 💖
Oh my gosh it's the first time I see Hiba with the gold medal ! Thanks ! :)
She truly deserved that gold medal!
I didn't AT ALL expect Hiba at the first place, can't say I agree but a real surprise anyway! Stunning editing as always, glad for Romanian, Russian, Norwegian, Brazilian and English especially 😊
I know, but I really DO have different preferences regarding French voices. I've never understood why people would criticise Hiba so much! Glad you like these versions, too.😊
What a beautiful ranking once again! I can say as always that we both agree and disagree with some, but I won't tell you more cause I'm planning to make a Jasmine ranking... But I have to say, even though Hiba is not my number 1, I was soooo happy to see she's on the first spot for you, because I lover her too! She really breaths the character, and every nuance in her voice feels so genuine and authentic! Also, thank you for 13th place :)
Thank you! Such a coincidence that they're both named Naomi, love that. Hiba definitely needs more spotlight, agree with everything you've said. And I'm looking forward to your ranking! ☺️
The editing is soooo pretty! I'm not familiar with Jasmine 2019 voices, but I think we quite agree. Thanks for Dutch, she's not pretty popular but I really love her (though I might be a little biased). Glad to see English at #2. I think she's really great
Thanks! I've been familiarizing with these voices for a few months before making it, actually. Indeed, Desi isn't that popular, but I really like her!
Love the transitions and editing, good job👌
Well, we kinda agree on almost every voice here, starting from your top 17 I share the same opinion as yours, only in a different order (both Jasmine and Aladdin have been well-cast anyways, just like in the animation).
BTW the singers who stand out the most are Greek, Norwegian, Brazilian, Malay, Croatian (what you said about Franka lmao), English (I'm so pissed off at Disney for covering her with all that autotune in the pop version, I honestly can't listen to it, while in the movie she really belts Speechless like a Broadway star).
My biggest disagreement would be Hiba - whom I'd still place in my top 20/15 - who yells a little too much during Speechless IMO, but maybe she will grow on me, who knows. All I can say is that I prefer her in the Canadian version, where her voice sounds more controlled
Thank you! I kinda agree with you about Hiba, she should have tried to adjust her singing to Naomi's lips movements better, it may seem too powerful sometimes, but I still maintain that she sounds extremely realistic & heartfelt. ❤️
Your videos are always such a treat! The editing is beautiful as always and your comments are a joy to read ❤ Our rankings seem to be rather similar - from what I can recall from mine 😂 - except for a few exceptions. I would've wished to see Thai (my favorite) a little higher, but I appreciate your comment on her :) Seeing your placements of Serbian, Romanian and Brazilian definitely made me reflect on my own list - You really brought up great points with them 😊 Thanks for 2nd place! I was not expecting your #1 AT ALL hahah, but it's nice to see some appreciation toward her!
Aw, thanks! As much as I recall your ranking, we have similar taste, indeed. Glad to see an Irina fan. 😊 I honestly hesitated about my #1, I was torn between Naomi and Hiba, I love them both so much!
Oh wow...I'm very touched that you choose the French version for the 1st position, I always get goosebumps when i listen to her performance, it's so beautiful💜
More than a year has passed and she still holds that position! 💙🌟
@@meliae. yesss it makes me feel very proud 😊
1:09
Nincy Vincent ♥️ chechi ur voice 🔥
Singing voice behind Disney princesses 😍 in Tamil and Telugu 🔥 proud to be ur fanboy and brother to ♥️
¡Yaayy! Hiba it's in 1th place. Really THANX by do that. I just don't understand when people put her lower than the 15th place. Her voice it's so beautiful and powerfull. You can feel her pain when she's singing Speechless part 2 and I admit that she's got so much strange high notes, like when she says the second "Parler" she sounds shaky but I still love her with that. I'd put Shila higher, she don't fit but her voice it's so beautiful that I can't put her lower. She sounds really young when she's older than Naomi, that's funny. So thanks by 25th place, this time I liked my dub and I think that when people says dislike Annie they doesn't say coherent stuffs. 💖
@EvelynMedranoARMYLanguageGirl Why do you have a profile picture of the Soviet Union?
Dzięki za 10 :D Gratki dla trochę niespodziewanej zwyciężczyni! :)
Oh finally my Hiba gets the love she deserves 😍😍😍😍
Thank you so much for that, I actually think she's the most amazing French voice since Nathalie Fauran (Melody) with the others new female voices of 2019 (Anne Sila as Nala 2019 and Charlotte Hervieux as Elsa in Frozen 2) 🤩
Well I'm French and I want Hiba to be the voice of Jasmine since her participation in the Voice in 2015 and then her cover of Arabian Nights 😃
I think it's one of the Jasmine's rankings I agree the most and I love your editing 🙂
I'm *speechless*, we have the same favourites when it comes to French voices! Nathalie, Charlotte, Hiba & Laura are true jewels!
@@meliae. and anais and emmylou
thanks for the brazilian portuguese😍
Yes! Another Hiba lover! I don't get why she isn't liked, I think she brings Jasmine's feelings across. My favourite is Maria (Norwegian) I love her but also Franka, Julia & Irina are great many more actually. I always sing my lungs out when I hear the German and Norwegian versions know those lyrics pretty well lol.
I know, right? I felt like an outsider with my love for Hiba, but I’m glad you’re a fan of her, too! I feel the same about the French lyrics. x)
Amazing ranking as always ❤️❤️❤️❤️Thank you soo much for Croatian and Serbian ❤️❤️❤️🥰🥰🥰🥰
CroSerb Queen Elsa they both really deserve it! 🥰
In Korean Min is her surname no her name
Surprises are everywhere on your channel when it comes to rankings:) Disagree? Yes. Agree? Yes. But to he fair your ranking is great and from I what I can see, you put English 2nd!She definitely deserves to be in the top 3 imo. Not to mention your no. 1 as well.
My taste may seem peculiar sometimes, I have to admit that. But I’m glad we agree at least partially! ☺️
Thank you for Kseniya!! 😍
You’re welcome, she’s amazing! ☺️
The italian Jasmine reminds me the italian Elsa
Annie's admitted that the songs were challenging? Well yeah, indeed audible lol. Unbelievable how much we agree overall though, well, Czech would be higher with me, but I can clearly see why she's down there. Vietnamese is definitely unique but her movie performance is such a downhill imo 😔
I long to hear what makes people find appealing about Julia, because I really fail to feel it. Your 1st place is such a surprise but I definitely dig it, maybe not as perfect as I expected but OH WELL she's great anyway! Beautiful ranking as always ❤
In a sense that she struggled with them and that was audible to me because she focused on that struggle too much, imo. Hiba on the other hand, despite imperfect vocals, shaped a wonderful portrait of Jasmine’s emotions. 💞Having seen your ranking some time ago, I knew you weren't a fan of Julia, but as much her Belle was decent to me, she improved a lot in those two years. I’ve loved Hiba since the very beginning, thank you! 🥰 Looking forward to your Elsa ranking!
I was looking forward to see a Jasmine's ranking from you!! I am not so familiar with the character's voices. I wouldn't describe her as my favourite nor beloved to me.
Thank you for Greek place, to be honest Jasmine is the only role in which I like Alexandra! I only disagree with the first place, I like Hiba as a singer, but her performance as Jasmine isn't actually my cup of tea.
I love your editing!!
I knew Hiba would be a huge surprise, but I sincerely love her. I think I like Alexandra's Belle slightly more, but her Jasmine is amazing as well. Thanks! 🥰
Thank you for 10th! uwu
You’ee welcome! ❣️
Mirka Gális Partlová
Sunitha Sarathy
Maja Van Honsté
Cài Yong-Chún
Nincy Vincent
Shehnaza Qyzyhanova
Nikki García
Martina Placrová
Olha Zhmurina
Annelie Saemala
Nevena Tsoneva
Nihan Omuz
Annie Rojas
Marsha Songcome
Meshi Kleinstein
Natthaphatson Simasathian
Phan Lê Ái Phuong
Desi van Doeveren
Jenes Kitti
Kinoshita Haruka
Anni Kajos
Shila Amzah
Alexándra Lérta
Dīng Shuang
Min Kyung-ah
Naomi Rivieccio
Teresa Queirós
Julia Milena Scheeser
Kseniya Rassomakhina
Natalia Piotrowska
Monali Thakur
Irina Arsenijević
Alexandra Craescu
Maria Haukaas Mittet
Lara Suleiman
Franka Batelić
Naomi Scott
Hiba Tawaji
Mirka Gális Partlová
Sunitha Sarathy
Maja Van Honsté
Cài Yong-Chún
Nincy Vincent
Shehnaza Qyzyhanova
Nikki García
Martina Placrová
Olha Zhmurina
Annelie Saemala
Nevena Tsoneva
Nihan Omuz
Annie Rojas
Marsha Songcome
Meshi Kleinstein
Natthaphatson Simasathian
Phan Lê Ái Phuong
Desi van Doeveren
Jenes Kitti
Kinoshita Haruka
Anni Kajos
Shila Amzah
Alexándra Lérta
Dīng Shuăng
Min Kyung-ah
Naomi Rivieccio
Teresa Queirós
Julia Milena Scheeser
Kseniya Rassomakhina
Natalia Piotrowska
Monali Thakur
Irina Arsenijević
Alexandra Crăescu
Maria Haukaas Mittet
Lara Suleiman
Franka Batelić
Naomi Scott
Hiba Tawaji