Quote from Carey on clicks: “It's a sad thing when almost every band you see isn't playing doing that, it's the clicks and backing tracks that are keeping time. I've never played to a click on stage in my life. You have to put yourself in this environment that's vulnerable and just fucking go off in the moment.”
Mmm, I'm of the mind that it's not necessary to throw shade at bands who play to clicks. It CAN be a crutch if bands let it, but I think sometimes we let ourselves think that using it is "cheating" when it really isn't. If you can't play, a click isn't gonna make you that much better. Actually, it takes certain amount of skill to play to one and not sound dull and robotic. That said, I 1000% agree that if you can play this tight at this level of complexity without a click track, that definitely deserves monumental praise.
I enjoy your comments. You clearly know drums. To hear you say I have no idea on his time signature is very honest. People cannot truly understand the level of skill to triple one hand, double the other hand, high hat in 4’s and last but not least the length of that run is absolutely ridiculous. You are watching GOAT level mastery. This dude is just on a different planet.
The only other drummer I'd put on Danny's technical skill level is Peart (RIP). Also, the reason he's so tough to count is due to Poly-rhythms. It's often much easier to count off of Justin (bass), since Danny's often using the drums as almost a backing vocal track at times.
Thanks, I'm always looking for an excuse to watch ath vic firth video again. Appreciate you appreciating what has been know by the tool army since the early 90's. Danny Carey is on some other shit and evolving constantly. Cheers mate, no worries, you will evolve too. Become Pneuma!
Danny must have played on the snare line for Lawrence KS marching band while I marched and played Triples for Shawnee Mission Northwest (Shawnee, KS) as we would’ve competed in State! That would be so rad!!!!! I’m also 59!!!!
It would be a feat for a machine to be able to figure out the click to play for this song. Which one do they play? When do they play it? AI isn't complex enough to understand Danny Cary or Tool yet!
@Thomas Grey Yeah, technically there is a regular timing that is maintained for most of it, but the difficulty of using a regular click with those meter changes means it would probably be harder than not using one at all, not to mention the points where beats are deliberately way off-time. It's like some Frank Zappa shit except it still actually sounds like music. Incredible.
He is not recognized as so due to politics but he is by far one of the best. The latest tool album has put him clearly ahead of Neil at this point. Give it 10 years and rolling stone may recognize it but doubt it.
I love Neil, and Danny (credit Bruford), but I don't know there's a "best", maybe your favorite. To just mention one other with 4 limb independence, stamina, multiple time signs and genius: Tomas Haake of Meshuggah.
I think you're forgetting about the Atomic Clock Gene Hoglan, as well as Tomas Haake, among many others. Each have their own particular styles, and are grandmasters at what they do. There really isn't a single "best" drummer, considering we aren't even touching in the realm of the speed tech death drummers showcase that are almost inhuman. Love Danny Carey. It's just impossible to label a single drummer as "the best" overall.
I don't think people understand how hard it is to replicate what you do in the studio and bring that to the live stage, play perfectly for 11: 23ish seconds....this man is a legend
Even drummers that watch this video are amazed at Danny’s ability to play off beat, switch time signatures, how easy he makes it look, his fills, his knowledge of music. The man is truly a master of his craft. 💪🏻💪🏻
"The metronome has to ask permission to danny on what time to play" lol love it. the hi-hat is in front to prevent collisions on the cross over since he is such a hard hitter. The Grudge is also a masterpiece, if you gonna do the whole discography just start at the beginning and listen to them grow through out 30 years, good job mate you earned my sub.
This is exactly what happened to me. Not a fan, watched pneuma drum video, became Tool fan. Listened to Fear Inoculum just about every day for the last 7 months
Through that extended solo in the middle, I just keep marveling at all the layered complexity going on with his hands, all over the kit. And yet that one F-ing cymbal (is that the thing called the high hat?) just keeps ticking along at it's own separate rhythm, with mechanical precision, coming from one of his feet. Like each limb has its own set of ears and its own brain. Insanity.
I like this guys' humbleness, he's not shy at stating his opinion and admitting later that he might be wrong. I like honest and sensitive reaction, I think we all do
“I now understand the hype around Danny Carey. I fully fully understand.” That was one of my favorite moments of someone realizing that! Always makes me happy when someone sees the talent
“You’ve now made me feel as if I know absolutely nothing about drums, and I’m gonna have to start learning about drums all over again” I hear that! I’m a professional chef. I started in 1993 as a pastry chef, and worked that for twelve years. Then I jumped over to the other side and had been going on that for another 8 years. Having knowledge of both pastry and hot food, I thought I was pretty well versed. I had basically fallen into repetition... I sort of accidentally ended up eating at a 3 star Michelin restaurant (Manresa) and was fretting about how much it was costing me before I got there. I was maybe three courses (out of 17 total) into my experience when I realized I no longer thought that over $300 for just me was too much $. I was flattened, and I felt like I’d been gut punched. I was in the same exact place there as you were hearing/watching this mastery, which is the audio version of three star Michelin dining for progressive metal. Tool as a band is in the same place as the best restaurants in the world. Many people don’t know about that kind of food, actual or audio, and are “satisfied” with blue box Mac and Cheese (pop?!)! Anyway, count yourself blessed man! I was after going to that meal, it changed my life, and my career... I was sooo complacent! It’s awesome when we can be inspired to the next level by the hard win talents of people who have been able to push past the norm to something special! An excellent reaction video sir, I echo everyone else, and you got my sub. I’d also love to hear what you think about Invincible!
What really gets me is how Carey plays small and quiet jazz gigs, then with Tool he fills entire stadiums with this unmistakable and powerful sound. Great video mate, subbed!
I think Danny is tapping into other levels of consciusness, or better, unconsciusness. He spent his entire life practicing like 6/8 hours at day mastering rudiments and odd Times, that now all these things are part of his unconscious circuits of his brain. This is how, for example, kids learn to walk or speak. He is not controlling time anymore, he is just flowing in the river of time, and this is why he seems so relaxed and he can improvises fills around the time signature and orchestrations in the middle of electronic pads part. In fact the live versions are allways different from the studio's.
That is THE BEST REACTION to this video I have seen and trust me I have seen a few. He is an absolute master of his craft. This new album is a totally different experience to their other stuff, you can really see the maturity. Invincible is on a par with this song, although totally different. I highly recommend you dive into that one. John Kew has done an amazing cover of that one if you want to see the drumming, however if you just want to hear the song for what it is, you can just listen to the studio track. It will blow you away.
Danny is an octopus God in a man's body. 2 things to note about this video are Danny's dynamic control and precision. Danny plays in tympani fashion the way he plays notes on his tuned drums. Every note is played exactly where he planned it and exactly as loud as he wanted it. Also, the part at 14:50 where you go back to marval at the polymetric section, is a 3/16 played over a 4/4 where the flat, hand switching triplet resolves back on the 1 after 3 phrases. THEN he begins introducing new elements of the kit into the rhythm until there are 5, before reducing them to 4, then 3, then 2. That build up is mathematically amazing. Being able to write and play something complicated that sounds ridiculous is one thing, but being able to write and play something so complicated that sounds so simple is on a whole other level. I love watching these reaction videos. You can usually tell by the thumbnail weather someone is going to watch this and think " that was cool, Danny is a badass" and have no idea what just happened, or weather they're going to be counting the whole time and still getting lost ending in absolute amazement at Danny, the octopus God.
I can't believe you actually called out the time signature of 33/16 on the first listen. The main riff is usually written as 5/8 + 7/4 + 7/4, which would be 33/8. That is impressive that you spotted the 33 so easily considering how unusual of a count it is.
On the other hand he counted the 4/4 part as being 19/16. But to be fair, counting Tool's time signatures at first listen is always a bit of a gamble. If I had to count the time signature for The Pot when I first heard it I'd never have guessed the whole beginning of the song till the second chorus was in 4/4.
This song is a showcase for Danny's talents. The master of polymetric time signatures. The heir to Neil Peart. What's more amazing is he is 58 yrs. old at the time of this recording. Tool is simply an experience and Danny Carey is simply one of the best drummers alive today.
I’ve been a metal head all my life. I never liked tool. My mates loved them. I wasn’t into it. My wife took me to see them live. Wow! Changed me. One of the most talented set of musicians on the planet in my lifetime
No click for TOOL, just in ear monitors for him and that’s it. Thats the way they’ve always done things. Also he had to put his high hat in front because all the pads to his left he’s incorporated in his kit. Great analysis!!
More amazing than this is going to see them in concert and watching Danny do this for over 2 hrs, and do a 10 minute solo in between while the other guys gave a break. Had a great seat where I could see everything he was doing, blown away.
Mate, this was such an awesome and honest reaction. One of the best I've seen. I absolutely love when established and experienced musicians absorb and recognise greatness. I love it! Yeah, Danny is mental! Great work mate. Legend! MIND BLOWN!
Solid reaction. I've watched dozens of reactions to this piece since it was released, and yours has to be the most honest & knowledgeable of the lot - thanks for sharing.
Welcome to the Tool Army bro.. I've seen this 30 odd times, maybe more! Which then took me into reactions and your video, it's great that Tool are finally opening a lot more eyes to their musical genius, the best reaction I've seen hands down. Definitely give this album a go it will just shine a light on every other they have put out, enjoy the journey 👍
Great video man! I’ve been playing drums for 25 years and he makes me feel like I know absolutely nothing too. He’s great and they have definitely become my favorite band as I’ve aged. I used to avoid them because of the time signatures but now I have the patience and appreciation for it.
Best part of the entire video 9:35 "I have no idea where 1 is" Great reaction by the way, love the honesty at the end. When someone can say that they feel like they know nothing about time signatures, you know they finally fell down the Tool rabbit hole.
Subbed JUST for this excellent reaction. It was very interesting to see you go from your statements at the beginning to how you were blown away at the end. Yes, you are right, Tool gets better with age. I'm Danny's age now, pushing 60, and I've been listening for decades, probably heard every song 10,000 times, and it *never* gets old, but the more *I* age, the better Tool sound and the more the message rings true. I hope you do continue your Tool journey; there's nothing like them out there. Stay safe and hope you keep going down the Tool rabbit hole.
Definitely do some more Carey. There is so much more to sink your teeth into. Drumming wise 46&2 is another good one to watch, there are plenty of pro shot live footage of that one. The ending to the song the grudge is another behemoth.
Both songs are masterpieces. Invincible is probably my favorite on Fear Inoculum, as much for the lyrics as the musicianship. We need more HD video documentation of live performances for sure.
Loved this, your reaction is brilliant and the honesty, no idea where 1 is. Subscribed because of MGLA video but this is icing on the cake. Your technical explanations on the kits and styles is great, better than a lot of reaction videos, you offer real insight so thanks.
Got a sub today. You for sure need to listen to Fear Innoculum. It's drum porn. Hell it's almost porn porn. Btw I suggest listening to Invincible next. then Descending then Chocolate Chip Trip then Fear Inoculum then make sure to save 7empest for the end. Get you self some diapers. They won a grammy for that one.
Yep, you got it. I got it in '93. I've been trying to drum like him ever since. (Jonkew) does drum covers of many of TOOLs songs. Exact to the sheet music. I've learned a lot from him.
Great, great reaction!! You got me into Tool know (as well)!! I am a big fan of Porcupine Tree, esp. with drummer Gavin Harrison. I'm not sure if you already reacted to him. But if you didn't, please watch the song Anesthetize, live from Tilburg!!! Another Porcipine Tree song that might be interesting from a drummer point of view is Bonnie The Cat.
I appreciate the honest assessment of the drum playing! I will clue you in on a recent interview with Maynard. He has said that he doesn’t write in 4/4, more in the 6/8 area, because he doesn’t breathe in a 4/4. He referenced Joni Mitchell because she didn’t write in 4/4. Tool sound is different because they are.
I'm really glad you appreciate Danny Carey's talent. He's absolutely in another dimension when it comes to drumming. He plays things that no one on earth is capable of playing which makes him my favorite drummer of all time.
Great video brother. Im a happy subscriber now. 👍 I’m impressed that you identified the 33/16 time sig. You’re the only one I’ve seen that was able to pick up on it. It’s also impressing that you noticed how intricate his polymeter is during the instrumental. In the last section check out his right hand. All double strokes throughout the entire instrumental with the right hand is hard enough, but in the last section he goes from playing 5 drums with the right to 4, then 3, then 2 to create a walls are closing in/tightening/tension building affect, and then boom! Any and all drummers out there can learn a ton from that part alone. You CAN in fact create these types of moods with percussion. Also, he never plays to a click. It would foul them up! 😂 Great video!
Love your reaction. Thank you for listening to this amazing band. Danny is, in my opinion, the greatest of all time. It brings me great joy to know the younger generation is open and willing to listen to, and appreciate this great music!
That was some good respect you gave Danny and the band there, it was a good watch. I get it with the "not a huge Tool fan" thing. They can be a bit tedious for me sometimes, but they do so many things really well, especially stylistically. I'll try to listen to an album and get a little bored, but then I'll go see them live and loose my s**t over em again. I dunno, but one things for sure, my drumming and songwriting style is laced with their influence
I love this I love it when, especially a musician, hears tool after years of seeing their shirts and knowing about them but never really knowing, love it when they see, and realize. Tool and especially Danny are on another level
Danny has some very delicate and creative drumming, whenever I see his passion and creativity it leaves me nothing less but inspired and very calm inside. It's a bit meditative, trance like. He surely has a style that is very unique to him, I could listen to probably a lot of drummers blindly and I would hear out DC simply because of his unique drumming. Maybe you could call it DC'esque, he deserves it. There are really great drummers out there, he for sure can be considered one of them. You do not have to react, but I ask of you to watch two other drumcams: Triad and Lateralus (first one for this meditative experience and crazy creativity; later one for his absolutely mindboggling climax) Both these Drumcams are shit qualitywise, but that still is not able to ruin the experience watching him drum and learn from. Keep it up. And no worries if Tool has never been your thing, that's the thing with art, I never got much out of Mozart, yet I like Beethovens more "chaotic" pieces or Handel's baroque. Lateralus: ua-cam.com/video/dfwhSuyumz4/v-deo.html Triad: ua-cam.com/video/2dwxTd5JZ50/v-deo.html
Different strokes for different folks. I will mention however, that there does exist a handful of chaotic/dark pieces among Mozart's oeuvre -- of which inspired Beethoven -- that you might enjoy if you haven't heard them already.
@@olly8453 exactly, it's not even the prowess, they are all fantastic musical geniuses, but some just don't cling with you, you still respect it for the musicianship though. I'd never argue Beethoven is the better componist, just that I like his style more. ^^ I love Mozarts Requiem though.
@@Spasstiful Absolutely. Taste in Art is as diverse as there are individuals; it really comes down to what resonates with one personally. For me Mozart takes the cake -- very closely followed by Bach and Beethoven. Mozart was more restricted than Beethoven was during his lifetime, but even so Mozart was constantly pushing new ground, which paved the way for Beethoven to take music to where he ultimately did. Here's a couple of pieces you might not have heard from Mozart that are more "Beethovian" in their style: This is a prelude and fugue (the fugue has four independent melodies constantly interweaving though one another at once that a achieve a sort of chaotic fusion). Beethoven personally copied this work out by hand and studied it, as he did with many of Mozart's works. ua-cam.com/video/NDKdrQgp_q0/v-deo.html One of two "dark" outlier piano concerto Mozart wrote. Mozart hardily ever wrote works in a minor key, but when he did...he left an indelible mark. This piano concerto heavily inspired Beethoven. When Beethoven first heard this piece, at the end of it he remarked to his colleague: "we shall never be able to do anything like that." ua-cam.com/video/Mz-KGTZ0vrs/v-deo.html Cheers!
@@olly8453 Thank you for the pieces, I am indeed not too experienced in pieces of Mozart as it requires a lot of work getting into the works of great componists. Just never really got into Mozart, and when I tried, I just couldn't really deal with it, so I stuck more to the old baroque componists which Bach of course is another great one even though I find myself listening to Handel more. Beethoven I can only really enjoy or not even consider to put it on. Pretty mooddependend. I will give your suggestions a look, for the sake of discovering that I am missing out something I would regret. 🙏
@@Spasstiful What composer/band I listen to very much depends on my mood as well; anything from Beethoven, Bach, Handel, Dvorak, Chopin, Shostakovich, or Tool :P -- as well as many more. Happy to share :) Hope you find something appealing out of it -- but if not! Tis all good as well. I know a lot of people who say they just can't get into Tool, but that doesn't stop me from trying every gateway angle possible to see if I can get them interested :P Even so, there are just some people that it just isn't their thing -- never hurts exploring though!
I love seeing an accomplished drummer humbled by Danny, and I mean that in the best way possible. You're the ones that have a chance to follow in his footsteps, not the ones that think they can already pull it off. I love playing and I can't even air drum to his simplest stuff.
No click around here. Lol. They don’t use it. The man isn’t human. You nailed it. There’s unbelievable musicality in his compositional style. Everything blends with the other instruments and vocals so beautifully. He’s not providing beats as a base for the other instruments. It’s a dance
I am glad to see Tool finally making an impact on the greater musical world. They are worth the effort to listen to. I have been on board since Lateralus. I first saw them in 2006. They do soemthing no other band does. And it is soooooo good.
The thing is about trying to get Danny's timing down is that exactly in this song and many others you can't count the total beats. This because of his polyrhythm he is playing a 4/4 a 7/8 and a11/16 all at the same time. I'm not completely sure about those times but I do know that, that is why us fans call him the octopus.
“I wonder if the metronome asks Danny Carey for permission what time signature to play?” I lost it 😂😂😂😂
Not sure about metronomes, but atomic clocks seek his accuracy.
That made me lol too
😂
4:04
This metronome comment is an insanely humorous observation .
Totally lost it too! One of the best quotes I’ve heard on these react vids!
Once you realise tool has a lead drummer and rhythm vocals, it makes a lot more sense
They’re all geniuses
This is a fantastic way of putting it that made me smile
@@adamjosiah123 True...
Exactly...
THEY ARE ALL 4 AMAZING MUSICIANS AND ARTISTS. AS GOOD AS DANNY IS AT DRUMMING THE OTHER 3 ARE EQUALLY AS AMAZING. MAKE NO MISTAKE ABOUT THEM.
Quote from Carey on clicks:
“It's a sad thing when almost every band you see isn't playing doing that, it's the clicks and backing tracks that are keeping time. I've never played to a click on stage in my life. You have to put yourself in this environment that's vulnerable and just fucking go off in the moment.”
Clicks wish they could play to Danny Carey.
Dam I just posted the same thing 🤣
Mmm, I'm of the mind that it's not necessary to throw shade at bands who play to clicks. It CAN be a crutch if bands let it, but I think sometimes we let ourselves think that using it is "cheating" when it really isn't. If you can't play, a click isn't gonna make you that much better. Actually, it takes certain amount of skill to play to one and not sound dull and robotic.
That said, I 1000% agree that if you can play this tight at this level of complexity without a click track, that definitely deserves monumental praise.
literally scrolled down during the video to post something really similar about Danny's thoughts on clicks.
That's a very dumb statement, so many bands have light shows, orchestra as backing track or whatever that require you to be exactly on time.
Carey likes to play 4 different timings at once.
He can do 5. But not with his pants on.
☠️
OK I LOST IT
🤣
Bahahaha
Lmao!
"I feel like.... I now know nothing.... about TIME."
And that's Tool.
I enjoy your comments. You clearly know drums. To hear you say I have no idea on his time signature is very honest. People cannot truly understand the level of skill to triple one hand, double the other hand, high hat in 4’s and last but not least the length of that run is absolutely ridiculous. You are watching GOAT level mastery. This dude is just on a different planet.
Thanks for all the nice comments people! I’m slowly making my way down this endless Tool hole...
The only other drummer I'd put on Danny's technical skill level is Peart (RIP). Also, the reason he's so tough to count is due to Poly-rhythms. It's often much easier to count off of Justin (bass), since Danny's often using the drums as almost a backing vocal track at times.
welcome to the rabbit hole...
One of us... One of us...
Thanks, I'm always looking for an excuse to watch ath vic firth video again. Appreciate you appreciating what has been know by the tool army since the early 90's. Danny Carey is on some other shit and evolving constantly. Cheers mate, no worries, you will evolve too. Become Pneuma!
An endless spiral hole..
59 yrs old, at the top of his game. No click. Other worldly. 🤘
Danny must have played on the snare line for Lawrence KS marching band while I marched and played Triples for Shawnee Mission Northwest (Shawnee, KS) as we would’ve competed in State! That would be so rad!!!!! I’m also 59!!!!
@@CutandShoot5x5 wouldn't that had been an awesome experience!!
John Whittle I know John! I was thinking about that possibility & it blew me away! We won State in 78’!
But but 54yo Lars can't be expected to play the crappy shit he played 20 years ago the same crappy, that's why it's worse crappy now.
"FINALLY" someone who understands the technical abilities Danny has...
No kidding!
😂
Neil Peart can't tell anymore
"Is he playing to a click?"
It would be a feat for a machine to be able to figure out the click to play for this song. Which one do they play? When do they play it? AI isn't complex enough to understand Danny Cary or Tool yet!
Lol spot on.
@Thomas Grey Yeah, technically there is a regular timing that is maintained for most of it, but the difficulty of using a regular click with those meter changes means it would probably be harder than not using one at all, not to mention the points where beats are deliberately way off-time.
It's like some Frank Zappa shit except it still actually sounds like music. Incredible.
Visual queues. You know, the way bands did it decades ago.
"Just a normal day at the office, yeah, playing 33/16". lol
Danny Carey ladies and gentlemen, The man will go down in history as one of the very very best.
Of all time, 100%! I think each of his limbs would go down for that individually. ;)
The sad part is that there are People in this world who don't know Tool
He is not recognized as so due to politics but he is by far one of the best. The latest tool album has put him clearly ahead of Neil at this point. Give it 10 years and rolling stone may recognize it but doubt it.
Indeed, he is definitely one of the best ever.
@@adamjankowski7679 Neil Peart? LOL he's not better than Danny IMO. But then again opinions are like Assholes everyone has one lol...
“Aww, here we go ... I now fully understand the hype around Danny Carey ... fully, fully understand..”
I know, right!!!
That's a 58 year old man a master of the craft in his prime arguably the best drummer of all time a technical genius
He’s now sixty and probably won’t slow down until he’s dead.
Fun fact: TOOL indeed does not play to a click
I'm not sure such a sophisticated device exists yet
@@randygarbrecht3185 you just watched it perform 😄
@@randygarbrecht3185 It's called Danny
Danny is the click!
Tool is the click
I’ve watched 20+ reactions to this, and Your’s has been the most knowledgeable and entertaining, even amongst other drummers. 👍.
This is one of my new favorite things to watch on UA-cam, drummers reacting to Danny
Couldn't agree more cornucopia of musical knowledge
yup
@@Zerostar369 Same.
Agree 100%.
Love this response. I wish more people could witness his genius. With Peart gone, Carey is the best drummer in the world bar none.
Damn straight. Peace.
some tech death drummers giving you the glare rn 😂
I love Neil, and Danny (credit Bruford), but I don't know there's a "best", maybe your favorite. To just mention one other with 4 limb independence, stamina, multiple time signs and genius: Tomas Haake of Meshuggah.
Vinnie Colaiuta is still alive....
I think you're forgetting about the Atomic Clock Gene Hoglan, as well as Tomas Haake, among many others. Each have their own particular styles, and are grandmasters at what they do. There really isn't a single "best" drummer, considering we aren't even touching in the realm of the speed tech death drummers showcase that are almost inhuman. Love Danny Carey. It's just impossible to label a single drummer as "the best" overall.
I don't think people understand how hard it is to replicate what you do in the studio and bring that to the live stage, play perfectly for 11: 23ish seconds....this man is a legend
Danny Carrey makes drummers want to practice and quit at the same time
"1,2,3,4,5,6..." muttering, counting, then stops and stares with a perplexed look ;)
Even drummers that watch this video are amazed at Danny’s ability to play off beat, switch time signatures, how easy he makes it look, his fills, his knowledge of music. The man is truly a master of his craft. 💪🏻💪🏻
"The metronome has to ask permission to danny on what time to play" lol love it. the hi-hat is in front to prevent collisions on the cross over since he is such a hard hitter. The Grudge is also a masterpiece, if you gonna do the whole discography just start at the beginning and listen to them grow through out 30 years, good job mate you earned my sub.
I had to pause I laughed so hard. I have seen a lot of reactions and heard some funny things but that was my favorite. xD
On point, on both... The shows that lead with "the grudge" are my fav...
Where's the 1? Ask the Hi-hat. Easy to follow.
We should do a DANNY CARRY FACTS GENERATOR like chuck norris lol
ua-cam.com/users/shortswZftHsSgGwM
"I feel like I now know nothing about time."
Best reaction yet.
Those polyrhythms, the triplets, and the way he just seamlessly slaps that far right cymbal gets me every time🔥
Yes! I've not seen anyone else comment on that before and I couldn't agree more. He's so good you can't even air drum to his stuff.
Yes!!!
This is exactly what happened to me.
Not a fan, watched pneuma drum video, became Tool fan.
Listened to Fear Inoculum just about every day for the last 7 months
Through that extended solo in the middle, I just keep marveling at all the layered complexity going on with his hands, all over the kit. And yet that one F-ing cymbal (is that the thing called the high hat?) just keeps ticking along at it's own separate rhythm, with mechanical precision, coming from one of his feet. Like each limb has its own set of ears and its own brain. Insanity.
All four of his limbs are doing different things…it’s outrageously good!
lmao fr the cymbal casually reminding me that time moves forward and im not j hypnotized in a drum loop
Watching drummers try to count time while Danny plays is a lovely recreational activity.
I like this guys' humbleness, he's not shy at stating his opinion and admitting later that he might be wrong. I like honest and sensitive reaction, I think we all do
“Is he playing to a click” - no, he IS the click
“I now understand the hype around Danny Carey. I fully fully understand.” That was one of my favorite moments of someone realizing that! Always makes me happy when someone sees the talent
“Is he playing to a click?”
Danny is the click lol
Fear Inoculum is definitely a showcasing of Danny's talents
Except 7empest. ;)
Fear Inoculum is Danny playing with the rest of the band! No one can get even close! He's not human!
5:19, but I have no idea what's going on
It's alright brother, nobody but Carey knows what's going on.
“Q: What’s the time signature?
A: Um..the Tool time signature.
Q: What’s that?
A: Yes!
Q: Huh?
A: EXACTLY! “
Lmao.....that's great!!
“You’ve now made me feel as if I know absolutely nothing about drums, and I’m gonna have to start learning about drums all over again”
I hear that! I’m a professional chef. I started in 1993 as a pastry chef, and worked that for twelve years. Then I jumped over to the other side and had been going on that for another 8 years. Having knowledge of both pastry and hot food, I thought I was pretty well versed. I had basically fallen into repetition... I sort of accidentally ended up eating at a 3 star Michelin restaurant (Manresa) and was fretting about how much it was costing me before I got there. I was maybe three courses (out of 17 total) into my experience when I realized I no longer thought that over $300 for just me was too much $. I was flattened, and I felt like I’d been gut punched. I was in the same exact place there as you were hearing/watching this mastery, which is the audio version of three star Michelin dining for progressive metal. Tool as a band is in the same place as the best restaurants in the world. Many people don’t know about that kind of food, actual or audio, and are “satisfied” with blue box Mac and Cheese (pop?!)!
Anyway, count yourself blessed man! I was after going to that meal, it changed my life, and my career... I was sooo complacent! It’s awesome when we can be inspired to the next level by the hard win talents of people who have been able to push past the norm to something special!
An excellent reaction video sir, I echo everyone else, and you got my sub. I’d also love to hear what you think about Invincible!
I appreciate this comment immensely.
I also appreciate this… that was likely one of the best comments, not for hilarity but for genuine content, that ive read on the ole utube
What really gets me is how Carey plays small and quiet jazz gigs, then with Tool he fills entire stadiums with this unmistakable and powerful sound.
Great video mate, subbed!
A birthing of a TOOL fan. 30 years of excellence!
He recorded the entire album without a metronome & on analog tape. He is the best of all time.
FUN FACT: Every Tool song is actually in the same time signature: squirrel/infinity. ;-)
Squirrel/infinity love it!!!
Squirrel/infinity is the best description
I think Danny is tapping into other levels of consciusness, or better, unconsciusness. He spent his entire life practicing like 6/8 hours at day mastering rudiments and odd Times, that now all these things are part of his unconscious circuits of his brain. This is how, for example, kids learn to walk or speak. He is not controlling time anymore, he is just flowing in the river of time, and this is why he seems so relaxed and he can improvises fills around the time signature and orchestrations in the middle of electronic pads part. In fact the live versions are allways different from the studio's.
That is THE BEST REACTION to this video I have seen and trust me I have seen a few. He is an absolute master of his craft. This new album is a totally different experience to their other stuff, you can really see the maturity. Invincible is on a par with this song, although totally different. I highly recommend you dive into that one. John Kew has done an amazing cover of that one if you want to see the drumming, however if you just want to hear the song for what it is, you can just listen to the studio track. It will blow you away.
If you want more tool, especially from a drum perspective, the grudge. The ending of that song is GODLY from Danny Carey
The grudge is my jam out song that I get angry and shoot people in CS: Source to...it's my stress reliever. I approve your comment! ;)
Danny is a master for sure. Completely underrated. Possibly the greatest drummer of all time. This is one of their simple songs.
Danny is an octopus God in a man's body. 2 things to note about this video are Danny's dynamic control and precision. Danny plays in tympani fashion the way he plays notes on his tuned drums. Every note is played exactly where he planned it and exactly as loud as he wanted it. Also, the part at 14:50 where you go back to marval at the polymetric section, is a 3/16 played over a 4/4 where the flat, hand switching triplet resolves back on the 1 after 3 phrases. THEN he begins introducing new elements of the kit into the rhythm until there are 5, before reducing them to 4, then 3, then 2. That build up is mathematically amazing. Being able to write and play something complicated that sounds ridiculous is one thing, but being able to write and play something so complicated that sounds so simple is on a whole other level. I love watching these reaction videos. You can usually tell by the thumbnail weather someone is going to watch this and think " that was cool, Danny is a badass" and have no idea what just happened, or weather they're going to be counting the whole time and still getting lost ending in absolute amazement at Danny, the octopus God.
I can't believe you actually called out the time signature of 33/16 on the first listen. The main riff is usually written as 5/8 + 7/4 + 7/4, which would be 33/8. That is impressive that you spotted the 33 so easily considering how unusual of a count it is.
Well ... No ... It's from the very very start to 2:35 4/4 9/8 4/4 5/8 4/4 . 5/4 2/8 14/8 5/8 14/8 5/8 14/8 5/8 14/8 5/8 12/8 8/8. ...
It’s easy to spot “33” in this video. Dude gives it away right there on the jersey.
@@nawulajchiwu A bird in the seat is worth 33 in the beat...
On the other hand he counted the 4/4 part as being 19/16. But to be fair, counting Tool's time signatures at first listen is always a bit of a gamble. If I had to count the time signature for The Pot when I first heard it I'd never have guessed the whole beginning of the song till the second chorus was in 4/4.
"I have no idea where one is" - no truer words were ever spoken regarding a Tool song.
Scary thing, though, because that section was 4/4😬
This song is a showcase for Danny's talents. The master of polymetric time signatures. The heir to Neil Peart. What's more amazing is he is 58 yrs. old at the time of this recording. Tool is simply an experience and Danny Carey is simply one of the best drummers alive today.
Maybe the best reaction to this video I’ve seen.
I’ve been a metal head all my life. I never liked tool. My mates loved them. I wasn’t into it. My wife took me to see them live. Wow! Changed me. One of the most talented set of musicians on the planet in my lifetime
No click for TOOL, just in ear monitors for him and that’s it. Thats the way they’ve always done things. Also he had to put his high hat in front because all the pads to his left he’s incorporated in his kit. Great analysis!!
I never tire of this composition
Danny's hi-hat gives you the beat of the song. He really is an octopus.
I never realized how impressive Danny’s dynamics & timing are until you reviewed this song!
More amazing than this is going to see them in concert and watching Danny do this for over 2 hrs, and do a 10 minute solo in between while the other guys gave a break. Had a great seat where I could see everything he was doing, blown away.
Mate, this was such an awesome and honest reaction. One of the best I've seen. I absolutely love when established and experienced musicians absorb and recognise greatness. I love it! Yeah, Danny is mental! Great work mate. Legend! MIND BLOWN!
Solid reaction. I've watched dozens of reactions to this piece since it was released, and yours has to be the most honest & knowledgeable of the lot - thanks for sharing.
Welcome to the Tool Army bro.. I've seen this 30 odd times, maybe more! Which then took me into reactions and your video, it's great that Tool are finally opening a lot more eyes to their musical genius, the best reaction I've seen hands down. Definitely give this album a go it will just shine a light on every other they have put out, enjoy the journey 👍
Great video man! I’ve been playing drums for 25 years and he makes me feel like I know absolutely nothing too. He’s great and they have definitely become my favorite band as I’ve aged. I used to avoid them because of the time signatures but now I have the patience and appreciation for it.
Great react vid, thx for your honesty and reactions! Welcome to the Tool Army!
Tool doesn't play to a click. Danny Carey IS the click.
Best part of the entire video 9:35 "I have no idea where 1 is"
Great reaction by the way, love the honesty at the end. When someone can say that they feel like they know nothing about time signatures, you know they finally fell down the Tool rabbit hole.
I've seen Tool 7 times over the years,and hes just grown so much as a percussionist!!
Brilliant. Watching reactions to this Danny playing makes 2020 nearly worthwhile.
This might be the best Pneuma reaction I’ve seen! 🙏🏻
Subbed JUST for this excellent reaction. It was very interesting to see you go from your statements at the beginning to how you were blown away at the end. Yes, you are right, Tool gets better with age. I'm Danny's age now, pushing 60, and I've been listening for decades, probably heard every song 10,000 times, and it *never* gets old, but the more *I* age, the better Tool sound and the more the message rings true. I hope you do continue your Tool journey; there's nothing like them out there. Stay safe and hope you keep going down the Tool rabbit hole.
Same
Still digesting, years and year later.
Definitely do some more Carey. There is so much more to sink your teeth into. Drumming wise 46&2 is another good one to watch, there are plenty of pro shot live footage of that one. The ending to the song the grudge is another behemoth.
Tool is a music you listen to each instrument firstly then all together to understand the magic behind.
Best reaction video. Made my morning. Thanks.
He's like 2 drummers in one. Incredible work.
Listen to The Grudge, craziest drumming I've ever heard at the end. Also Invincible
Wish there was a HD video of that drum cam..
@@Itsunclegabby right! There are some good covers on youtube, prob the closest we'll get
That scream at the end of grudge is otherworldly!!!
Both songs are masterpieces. Invincible is probably my favorite on Fear Inoculum, as much for the lyrics as the musicianship. We need more HD video documentation of live performances for sure.
7empest is sick too.
Amazing
Loved this, your reaction is brilliant and the honesty, no idea where 1 is. Subscribed because of MGLA video but this is icing on the cake. Your technical explanations on the kits and styles is great, better than a lot of reaction videos, you offer real insight so thanks.
Got a sub today. You for sure need to listen to Fear Innoculum. It's drum porn. Hell it's almost porn porn. Btw I suggest listening to Invincible next. then Descending then Chocolate Chip Trip then Fear Inoculum then make sure to save 7empest for the end. Get you self some diapers. They won a grammy for that one.
TOOL porn
The drum cover guy John Kew does a deconstruction video of Tool’s Rosetta Stone. Am sure you would love it .....
Rosetta... stoned
Great review. Glad you appreciate Danny's insane talent. I can't think of anyone else being on the same level.
You are great in reviewing.. I love your amazingness, you know so much! And you get confusioned. I love your video, totally love it!
Spoken mature for a 26 year old ... in terms of appreciation of the creativity
Yep, you got it. I got it in '93. I've been trying to drum like him ever since. (Jonkew) does drum covers of many of TOOLs songs. Exact to the sheet music. I've learned a lot from him.
Agreed! John kew taught me stinkfist, working on more..
Best analysis of this I've seen. Love it. This guy is a robot
Great, great reaction!! You got me into Tool know (as well)!!
I am a big fan of Porcupine Tree, esp. with drummer Gavin Harrison. I'm not sure if you already reacted to him. But if you didn't, please watch the song Anesthetize, live from Tilburg!!!
Another Porcipine Tree song that might be interesting from a drummer point of view is Bonnie The Cat.
I appreciate the honest assessment of the drum playing! I will clue you in on a recent interview with Maynard. He has said that he doesn’t write in 4/4, more in the 6/8 area, because he doesn’t breathe in a 4/4. He referenced Joni Mitchell because she didn’t write in 4/4. Tool sound is different because they are.
I'm really glad you appreciate Danny Carey's talent. He's absolutely in another dimension when it comes to drumming. He plays things that no one on earth is capable of playing which makes him my favorite drummer of all time.
The best reaction, i watching this many times
Great video brother. Im a happy subscriber now. 👍
I’m impressed that you identified the 33/16 time sig. You’re the only one I’ve seen that was able to pick up on it.
It’s also impressing that you noticed how intricate his polymeter is during the instrumental.
In the last section check out his right hand. All double strokes throughout the entire instrumental with the right hand is hard enough, but in the last section he goes from playing 5 drums with the right to 4, then 3, then 2 to create a walls are closing in/tightening/tension building affect, and then boom!
Any and all drummers out there can learn a ton from that part alone. You CAN in fact create these types of moods with percussion.
Also, he never plays to a click. It would foul them up! 😂
Great video!
I genuinely said 33/16 as a joke, Hilarious that it actually turned out to be the time signature hahah!
There’s no alive like DC. The great Neil Peart was an inspiration for Danny.
Best reaction I have seen to this clip.
Love your reaction. Thank you for listening to this amazing band. Danny is, in my opinion, the greatest of all time. It brings me great joy to know the younger generation is open and willing to listen to, and appreciate this great music!
Danny is big into sacred geometry. I’d imagine numbers and rhythms are especially easy for him. As it shows.
That was some good respect you gave Danny and the band there, it was a good watch. I get it with the "not a huge Tool fan" thing. They can be a bit tedious for me sometimes, but they do so many things really well, especially stylistically. I'll try to listen to an album and get a little bored, but then I'll go see them live and loose my s**t over em again. I dunno, but one things for sure, my drumming and songwriting style is laced with their influence
I love this I love it when, especially a musician, hears tool after years of seeing their shirts and knowing about them but never really knowing, love it when they see, and realize. Tool and especially Danny are on another level
Such an honest statement. Congrats!
new album is another masterpiece. would suggest 7empest or Invincible were stand out tracks for me.
Danny has some very delicate and creative drumming, whenever I see his passion and creativity it leaves me nothing less but inspired and very calm inside. It's a bit meditative, trance like. He surely has a style that is very unique to him, I could listen to probably a lot of drummers blindly and I would hear out DC simply because of his unique drumming. Maybe you could call it DC'esque, he deserves it. There are really great drummers out there, he for sure can be considered one of them.
You do not have to react, but I ask of you to watch two other drumcams:
Triad and Lateralus (first one for this meditative experience and crazy creativity; later one for his absolutely mindboggling climax)
Both these Drumcams are shit qualitywise, but that still is not able to ruin the experience watching him drum and learn from. Keep it up.
And no worries if Tool has never been your thing, that's the thing with art, I never got much out of Mozart, yet I like Beethovens more "chaotic" pieces or Handel's baroque.
Lateralus: ua-cam.com/video/dfwhSuyumz4/v-deo.html
Triad:
ua-cam.com/video/2dwxTd5JZ50/v-deo.html
Different strokes for different folks. I will mention however, that there does exist a handful of chaotic/dark pieces among Mozart's oeuvre -- of which inspired Beethoven -- that you might enjoy if you haven't heard them already.
@@olly8453 exactly, it's not even the prowess, they are all fantastic musical geniuses, but some just don't cling with you, you still respect it for the musicianship though. I'd never argue Beethoven is the better componist, just that I like his style more. ^^
I love Mozarts Requiem though.
@@Spasstiful Absolutely. Taste in Art is as diverse as there are individuals; it really comes down to what resonates with one personally. For me Mozart takes the cake -- very closely followed by Bach and Beethoven. Mozart was more restricted than Beethoven was during his lifetime, but even so Mozart was constantly pushing new ground, which paved the way for Beethoven to take music to where he ultimately did.
Here's a couple of pieces you might not have heard from Mozart that are more "Beethovian" in their style:
This is a prelude and fugue (the fugue has four independent melodies constantly interweaving though one another at once that a achieve a sort of chaotic fusion). Beethoven personally copied this work out by hand and studied it, as he did with many of Mozart's works.
ua-cam.com/video/NDKdrQgp_q0/v-deo.html
One of two "dark" outlier piano concerto Mozart wrote. Mozart hardily ever wrote works in a minor key, but when he did...he left an indelible mark. This piano concerto heavily inspired Beethoven. When Beethoven first heard this piece, at the end of it he remarked to his colleague: "we shall never be able to do anything like that."
ua-cam.com/video/Mz-KGTZ0vrs/v-deo.html
Cheers!
@@olly8453 Thank you for the pieces, I am indeed not too experienced in pieces of Mozart as it requires a lot of work getting into the works of great componists. Just never really got into Mozart, and when I tried, I just couldn't really deal with it, so I stuck more to the old baroque componists which Bach of course is another great one even though I find myself listening to Handel more. Beethoven I can only really enjoy or not even consider to put it on. Pretty mooddependend.
I will give your suggestions a look, for the sake of discovering that I am missing out something I would regret. 🙏
@@Spasstiful What composer/band I listen to very much depends on my mood as well; anything from Beethoven, Bach, Handel, Dvorak, Chopin, Shostakovich, or Tool :P -- as well as many more.
Happy to share :) Hope you find something appealing out of it -- but if not! Tis all good as well. I know a lot of people who say they just can't get into Tool, but that doesn't stop me from trying every gateway angle possible to see if I can get them interested :P Even so, there are just some people that it just isn't their thing -- never hurts exploring though!
Thank you for this reaction. Well said
I love seeing an accomplished drummer humbled by Danny, and I mean that in the best way possible. You're the ones that have a chance to follow in his footsteps, not the ones that think they can already pull it off. I love playing and I can't even air drum to his simplest stuff.
No click around here. Lol. They don’t use it. The man isn’t human. You nailed it. There’s unbelievable musicality in his compositional style. Everything blends with the other instruments and vocals so beautifully. He’s not providing beats as a base for the other instruments. It’s a dance
Tool is the best
I am glad to see Tool finally making an impact on the greater musical world. They are worth the effort to listen to. I have been on board since Lateralus. I first saw them in 2006. They do soemthing no other band does. And it is soooooo good.
thank You so much for Your reaaction, analyse it! it was a honor for me t see You! thank You!
The thing is about trying to get Danny's timing down is that exactly in this song and many others you can't count the total beats. This because of his polyrhythm he is playing a 4/4 a 7/8 and a11/16 all at the same time. I'm not completely sure about those times but I do know that, that is why us fans call him the octopus.