Hiding and surviving - Growing up under National Socialism | DW Documentary

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 91

  • @Cocoa_Kalypso
    @Cocoa_Kalypso 13 днів тому +9

    No matter how many different ways these stories are told, the history repeats itself. It's presently occurring but now anyone with a smart phone can bare witness to the horrors. And nothing is being done about it.

  • @maryweavergouwens4737
    @maryweavergouwens4737 15 днів тому +25

    And it repeats...

  • @paulocarreiro5855
    @paulocarreiro5855 14 днів тому +7

    I just want to thank Charlotte for her bravery and work.

  • @sergiorivaslamas
    @sergiorivaslamas 12 днів тому +1

    Charlotte is so lucid and wise. It remembers my mom, she lives and No wonder why Charlotte is a true leader. These kind of persons always have a excellent memory and are really mature even as a childs. and their personalities are FORGED with pain and incredible strength
    My mother's name is Eva. And I know that you two could get along... jej of course she speaks spanish. We are bolivians.
    Congratulations. Charlotte. You are a ligth of wisdow

  • @TheShoe1990
    @TheShoe1990 13 днів тому +5

    Tomorrow is the 86th anniversary of 'the night of broken glass'

  • @barbararey-constantin5679
    @barbararey-constantin5679 5 днів тому +2

    I hope that people today will be able to appreciate what it meant for Frau Zenzi for whom her relationship with God was important was willing to be basically called a whore, an unmarried woman with a child. At that time, it would have been very shameful. She risked her life and threw away her good name for love of Charlotte. I am very glad that I was able to watch this interview. For those who have studied history carefully and for their whole lives, the political situation worldwide is very frightening. Most of my fellow Americans don't know any history and that is why they fall for an idiot's lies.

  • @quanglobaldocumentary
    @quanglobaldocumentary 15 днів тому +5

    I can't even imagine the fear and pain they experienced. It's so moving to hear these untold stories.

  • @MainMan7012
    @MainMan7012 15 днів тому +6

    Americans need to learn from the German experience as something like it may be in their future.

    • @diannemcbeth7428
      @diannemcbeth7428 8 днів тому

      Why? Isn’t antisemitism a danger all over the world? It’s diabolical and no nation is immune from the power of unreasonable hatred.

  • @mohammedsaysrashid3587
    @mohammedsaysrashid3587 15 днів тому +11

    Incredible documentary about Jewish ✡️ prosecution by Nazism regime before and during WW2. Jewish communities hadn't their's own political project in Europe....they didn't desired changing others religion believers. They tried internal adoption beneath host societies. Simply, it was beast and ultra cruelty embodied against innocent Jewish ✡️... I hope a time comes humanity to abandon all kinds of hatred, including ( religion hatred messages) ...

    • @Howardlifts
      @Howardlifts 15 днів тому +1

      Bs dude, read the talmud

    • @hamerful
      @hamerful 15 днів тому +1

      ​@@HowardliftsTalmud was born from their own nationalistic narcissism. The Tanakh that they were supposed to follow states other things than the Talmud.

  • @irisfiamma
    @irisfiamma 5 днів тому +1

    Thank you very much Charlotte for your resilience.

  • @annehersey9895
    @annehersey9895 12 днів тому +1

    If her father kknew from the beginning, why, especially when the Gestapo talked to Charlottes mother, didn’t the three of t 11:04 leave Germany right then and keep the family together?? That’s the question I always have: WHY DID YOU STAY??? I’m surprised that her being pregnant is why they decided TO STAY in Germany. I would think that was an even BIGGER REASON TO GO! To the US or Israel where they wouldn’t be different. Why would she think her kids would be better off going to school with kids whose parents worked in the Camps or the Gestapo or any number of Nazi jobs. She couldn’t stand to look at her neighbors after the war yet decided to raise a family among the people who treated her like dirt. To me, that doesn’t make sense. But she’s done and continues doing good work and I am not going to judge her but I sure would like to talk to her about her reasoning.

    • @sarahwestbrook4702
      @sarahwestbrook4702 8 днів тому +4

      It's quite ignorant to assume one can simply leave. Even if you're willing and able to leave, it doesn't mean that another country will allow you entry.

  • @TheStockwell
    @TheStockwell 15 днів тому +10

    I'm looking forward to reading loads of deflection, toxic innuendo, and lots of Whataboutism in the comments.
    Fingers crossed! 😺

  • @stlafg
    @stlafg 15 днів тому +38

    And yet her people are doing worst things to people of palastine ,

    • @aviram75
      @aviram75 15 днів тому +7

      Do you think so? Have you ever thought that many Jews are against what is happening in Gaza?

    • @KottonPye-vo6fe
      @KottonPye-vo6fe 15 днів тому +8

      So true. If only hamas look after Gaza children Instead of spending money on the army and their underground tonels. Gaza children will never forgive hamas for that.

    • @Lucyinthskyy
      @Lucyinthskyy 15 днів тому +3

      Not worse

    • @soulscanner66
      @soulscanner66 15 днів тому

      The Germans are doing nothing to the Palestinians. If they were, there would be no Palestinians.

    • @Willie5000
      @Willie5000 15 днів тому +1

      @@KottonPye-vo6feI can assure you they’ll resent Israel a lot more.

  • @iq-ride9329
    @iq-ride9329 15 днів тому +62

    Just imagine how Palestinians children feel

    • @patrickcooper9658
      @patrickcooper9658 15 днів тому +1

      They will be liberated from the terrorists Hamas and Hasbulla soon as the same way the Jewish children was liberated by the Americans ...

    • @fatimaperez9181
      @fatimaperez9181 15 днів тому +2

      These people learned from the best A. H.

    • @NicolasHaufe
      @NicolasHaufe 15 днів тому +4

      The Same as the German Hilter Jügend felt

    • @Hongaars1969
      @Hongaars1969 14 днів тому +1

      Please provide proof of intentional, systematic, planned, organised extermination of Palestinians. Where are the concentration camps? The extermination camps? The shallow graves? The sorting of people on the side of a railcar? The mass herding of people into showers where they were murdered by the thousands…..every single day?

    • @hamerful
      @hamerful 14 днів тому +1

      @Hongaars1969
      Good points

  • @firefox2402
    @firefox2402 День тому

    Thank you for this wonderful, moving testament of a wonderful human being.

    • @DWDocumentary
      @DWDocumentary  День тому

      Thanks for watching and sharing your thoughts!

  • @amara6656
    @amara6656 8 днів тому

    what happened to Charlottes mother? did they ever meet again?

  • @joshuatimothy2966
    @joshuatimothy2966 12 днів тому +2

    The germans did to them what they're doing to the Palestinians. But i am happy that she could share what human nature is like

    • @diannemcbeth7428
      @diannemcbeth7428 8 днів тому

      Your analogy is false. Hamas committed genocide on Oct 7 and Israel has a sovereign right to protect its people. Hamas, an Iran proxy is “doing it” to the people of Gaza. If you start a war, there’s no guarantee you’ll win it. Therefore don’t attack your neighbours.

  • @Peter-b8l6o
    @Peter-b8l6o 6 днів тому

    history is slowly repeating itself for the third time

  • @Bitingsherbertlemons
    @Bitingsherbertlemons 15 днів тому +3

    Charlotte,God bless you and yours.❤

  • @sdttilidie
    @sdttilidie 15 днів тому +14

    Would you have released this today if kamala had won? I wonder

    • @TheEsseboy
      @TheEsseboy 15 днів тому

      Hmm, maybe Trump is fascist?

    • @Kim-Berly200
      @Kim-Berly200 15 днів тому +9

      What difference does it make?

    • @mattmccallum2007
      @mattmccallum2007 15 днів тому +2

      This channel is quickly becoming a propaganda outlet

    • @TheEsseboy
      @TheEsseboy 15 днів тому +10

      @@mattmccallum2007 Wait, so in your mind, propaganda are things that are true, but you don't like it so you deny that it is true?

    • @mattmccallum2007
      @mattmccallum2007 15 днів тому +1

      @ what’s true here?

  • @somerandomfella
    @somerandomfella 15 днів тому +5

    There's never any information on why they've been persecuted for centuries. The focus is usually on what but not why.

    • @soulscanner66
      @soulscanner66 15 днів тому

      Hitler's antisemitism is well documented and his reasons for doing so is well known. He considered Jews and Slav's racially inferior to Germans, and hence enemies of Germans.

    • @hamerful
      @hamerful 15 днів тому +3

      DW has made a 4 part documentary about antisemitism

    • @somerandomfella
      @somerandomfella 15 днів тому

      @hamerful i've seen it. It still doesn't really say why apart from religious reasons.

    • @hamerful
      @hamerful 15 днів тому +1

      @@somerandomfella
      In my life I have noticed people getting spiteful and sometimes even angry on christian religious communities (why not buddhist or muslim, etc. I don't know).
      We should ask people why there is such an attitude in the first place. Maybe that would explain antisemitism as well?

    • @Hongaars1969
      @Hongaars1969 14 днів тому +1

      Read some in depth history books and you shall find out why.

  • @moshing4christ754
    @moshing4christ754 15 днів тому +1

    My 106 year old great-grandfather died of 'Covid-19', recently.
    We all need to 'Neal & Bob' for Israel! Regardless of Democrat or Republican.
    I stand with Ukraine, etc.

    • @hamerful
      @hamerful 15 днів тому

      Maybe Trump will stop sending money to Ukraine and the war will cease

  • @Whiskersforme
    @Whiskersforme 15 днів тому +19

    Free Palestine!

  • @TallyRocky
    @TallyRocky 15 днів тому +2

    Here we go amerikkka!

  • @sedatramadani1818
    @sedatramadani1818 14 днів тому +4

    And record an interview about genocide that is done upun Pelstine and view of Palestinians please

    • @diannemcbeth7428
      @diannemcbeth7428 8 днів тому +2

      The population of Palestine continues to increase so that fact alone defies your understanding of genocide. Don’t use words or accusations flippantly for deceptive reasons. If mom doesn’t serve dinner on time, is she starving her children? Get the point?

    • @sedatramadani1818
      @sedatramadani1818 8 днів тому

      You are out of understanding my words I wanted to say that the same thing is Done on Palestinians as jiwish people are suffered on that time That's all

  • @LEK-0000
    @LEK-0000 15 днів тому +2

    Childhood in hiding?? Never hided anything on my childhood

  • @johnnywadd7960
    @johnnywadd7960 15 днів тому +4

    Bye bye Gaza.....

  • @FredoTheMan1
    @FredoTheMan1 15 днів тому +1

    Welcome to Amerika

  • @khemrajrairaikirat4230
    @khemrajrairaikirat4230 15 днів тому +1

    🙏

  • @lotus-chain
    @lotus-chain 15 днів тому

    Did her living on us, when democrats on the chair? they are same as your title!

    • @TallyRocky
      @TallyRocky 15 днів тому

      Wtf?

    • @TheStockwell
      @TheStockwell 15 днів тому +3

      Could you please your comments using coherent English? 🤔

  • @zebronshorts2257
    @zebronshorts2257 15 днів тому

    From the toilet to the sea...