Borderlands 3 - The Review
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 вер 2019
- Between Epic, Randy, SupMatto and a shady review process, you'd think that BL3 was shit and that 2k had something to hide. Turns out the game is great and that 2k are just muppets.
--
Thanks for watching. If you enjoyed the video, be sure to hit the like and subscribe buttons, and if you REALLY liked the video, consider supporting me on Patreon. You get a fancy script every time I do one of my big 'The Review' reviews: / skillupyt
--
You can watch me streaming on Twitch here: / skillupyt
You can find my second channel here;
• Playlist
Skill Up Gaming Facebook Page!
/ 2029370630658327
Twitter: SkillUpYT?lang=en (@skillupyt)
Join us on the community Discord:
/ discord
--
Greedfall review:
• Greedfall - The Review
Gears 5 Review:
• Gears 5 Is So Damn Goo...
Control Review:
• Control Feels Like It'...
Remnant: From The Ashes Review
• Remnant: From The Ashe...
Wolfenstein: Youngblood Review
• Wolfenstein Youngblood...
Warhammer: Chaosbane Review:
• Warhammer: Chaosbane -...
Blood and Truth (PSVR) Review:
• A VERY Serious Review ...
A Plague Tale: Innocence Review:
• A Plague Tale: Innocen...
My Rage 2 review:
• Rage 2 - A Brief Revie...
My Days Gone Review:
• Days Gone - The Review...
My Far Cry New Dawn review:
• ...Shame It Was Sold A...
The Division 2 Review:
• Tom Clancy's The Divis...
My Days Gone impressions:
• Days Gone Is Nailing S...
My Metro Exodus Review:
• Metro Exodus - The Rev...
My Anthem Review:
• Anthem - The Review (2...
My Division 2 Impressions video:
• The Division 2 Beta Re...
My Apex Legends review:
• Apex Legends - A Brief...
My Anthem Impressions:
• Anthem has too many is...
Please don't skip The Hong Kong Massacre:
• The Hong Kong Massacre...
My Far Cry: New Dawn Preview
• Far Cry: New Dawn's Co...
My Resident Evil 2 review:
• Resident Evil 2 - A Br...
Ace Combat 7 Review:
• Ace Combat 7: Skies Un...
Metro: Exodus Hands-On Impressions
• I Played Metro: Exodus...
My reaction to the Bungie/Activision split:
• My Reaction To The Bun...
Ashen- The Review:
• Ashen - A Brief Review...
Why I Deleted My CoD: Bo4 Review:
• Why I Deleted My (Posi...
Hades Early Access Review:
• Hades - The Early Acce...
GRIS Review:
• GRIS - A Brief Review ...
Darksiders III Review:
• Darksiders 3 - A Brief...
My Fallout 76 Review:
• Fallout 76 - The Revie...
My Red Dead Redemption 2 Review:
• Red Dead Redemption 2 ...
Diablo 3 Switch Review:
• Diablo 3 Eternal Colle...
Assassin's Creed Odyssey: The Review
• Assassin's Creed: Odys...
Destiny 2: Forsaken Review
• Destiny 2: Forsaken - ...
Destiny 2: Warmind DLC:
• Destiny 2: Warmind - T...
Destiny 2 - Curse of Osiris Review (I'm Done With Destiny 2):
• Destiny 2 - The Curse ...
My Destiny 2 Review:
• Destiny 2 | An In-Dept...
No Man's Sky - The Review
• No Man's Sky - The Rev...
Warframe: The Sacrifice - The Review
• Warframe: The Sacrific...
My Detroit: Become Human Review:
• Detroit: Become Human ...
My God of War review:
• God of War | A Brief R...
Final Fantasy XV Royal Edition Review
• Final Fantasy XV Royal...
My Kingdom Come: Deliverance Review:
• Kingdom Come: Delivera...
My Monster Hunter World Review:
• Monster Hunter World -...
The Division Review (2018)
• Tom Clancy's The Divis...
Warframe: The Plains of Eidolon Review:
• Warframe | The Plains ...
My Warframe Review (2017)
• Warframe | The Review - Ігри
Thanks to Displate for sponsoring this video. They make high-quality metal posters, so you can switch them around whenever you please. You can find the full range of stuff I recommend here: displate.com/codeskillup Be sure to use offer code 'skillup' for a 15% discount!
@@nicholasnajibi3082 Shut the fuck up
I don't know dude, Balex was one of the most hilarious characters I've seen in a long time. The streamers are very cringe but I feel like this game has quite a few well written moments that made me laugh.
@@MrAustyn88 dud its his opinion dont go snowflake
There is no need to be offended
Skillup tnx for the review its was fun and gave me new vigor to keep playing it keep what you doing
@@petarpan100 I could say the same thing that you said to him, ya snowflake. But, unsurprisingly, you're wrong in that it is just his opinion. He is making a claim about the bias of SkillUp towards the franchise effecting this review, which isn't an opinion, it is either true or false. And as far as I'm concerned, something not bitching/commenting about when you have no proof
The writing actually made me wince multiple times. I couldn't believe some of it was real.
"Cuz you eat butts... Skag butts"
HOW DO U DO FELLOW KIDS
yeah i just wanted to shoot myself whenever vaughn, the calypsos, or ava talked. atleast the rest of the characters were fine tho
the tiny tina game went even HARDER in this direction, which was baffling to me
@@homicidalgeorge Ellie became kinda annoying
Handsome Jack telling the story about the guy with the spoon shows more character than The Twins in the entire game...
Stop it the more people keep proping Handsome Jack the more it feels bland. Like yes he was good villian bit was not great as people make him out to be.
TheBlakamon15 He is one of the most memorable villains in modern video games. I am not saying the should bring back HJ, (they shouldn’t) but The Twins felt like side villains that complement the true villain.
@@TheBlakamon15 your argument is making my head hurt. People’s reverence for Jack makes him bland? The fuck?
Handsome Jack eating pretzels has more character than the twins in the entire game.
"the moral of the story is.. Your a total bitch"
When Claptrap is the least anoying character you know something is wrong with your story
Why do you care about story? Remember Face Mcshooty? This series is a joke
@@kageakiminato8536 Because you can't even skip these? lol
@@kageakiminato8536 Most people who play games care about the story. The fuck you on about?
My gun yells yeet when i throw it. 10/10 would loot again.
Deluxe baby maker?
It also yells "HERE COMES DAT BOI" before shooting out 4 copies of itself with legs that act as turrets.
God I love this game.
I got a tediore that says yeet too
@@clutchbleach2057 my brother got that gun while we were playing and i was like 'hey is your gun saying yeet?!' a minute or 2 later he said 'hey i think it is!'
@@zebur4170 pretty much the only good thing a Tediore gun can do lmao
It’s crazy how dated this game now feels. I genuinely cringed when I read this. Just shows how you probably shouldn’t write things based around internet lingo.
Bruh what are you doing to your cornflakes?
Knew I could not have been the only one lmao.
Lol. Right
I want you to review my life and tear it apart
Too much palm hair and blurry vision 9/10 -IGN
You're a male: 0.5/10 IGN
'Treat me bad daddy' 4-10, "Felt like the game enjoyed the abuse too much"
oh god, my review would be so depressing.
Seeing all your personal reviews being negative I decided to write my own review about you all.
- Underrated and could do with some polish but ultimately a gem of a game with hidden depth :)
Being a human before a dev, I want to thank you for your kind worlds on my bosses/level designs (Carnivora/A9k). I'm doing this job trying to make that kind of impact, so knowing it succeeded for even a few is ... surreal. Thank you.
You made a fantastic game man, I'm still playing it to date
Everyone on the internet is saying the same thing: writing is awful but gameplay is awesome. Just get rid of Borderlands 3's writers cause it's a shame that their work would tarnish yours!
Are all these BL2 comparison clips from a dusty generation 1 ps3? even without the HD texture pack installed the game doesn't look remotely that bad
It looks pretty bad now,textures are blurry as heck even with hd texture pack and don't get me started on the terrain it looked good back then,but BL 3 is miles better in every way except story
I have to set it to low on my Radeon 7 since the game crashes my PC every 5 minutes. Talking BL2.
And yeah, after playing BL3, BL2 just feels outdated.
@@aniruddhadas1011 bl2 definitely doesn't look great anymore, but compared to high settings on PC, the footage in this video looks like a 2013 phone game, idk what's up with it here
I don't think using the HD texture pack is a fair comparison, because that's not how the game originally was. That being said, even with the HD texture pack it still looks like shit.
Looks like some kind of shitty Switch version. I'm replaying Borderlands 2 right now actually and it looks WAY better than what SkillUp is showing. Pretty disingenuous if you ask me.
The biggest thing for me was instanced loot, now we don't gotta fight over who gets what.
Greatest thing to ever happen to looter shooters, that and the lost loot machine!
i didnt have to sucker punch my brother for that blue drop :P
You can still do it so you can still ruin friendship
That mode is also great for co-op. Means friends can keep playing apart from each other if timing doesn't line up, and don't need specific characters they only use to play together. A buddy of mine picked it up late and I was able to bring my level 18 char into his new game, still have a challenge and still make meaningful progress.
And this makes loot pools even bigger as you can trade stuff to those who want them
Split screen borderlands with my son is literally what life is about...
Damn thats wholesome
I too enjoy borderlands with this guy's son
Just don't both open your inventory at the same time lol
This warmed my heart up. I want to raise a lil gamer.
@@voltiacccc yeah my son makes me feel like I hit the lottery on parent teacher night. SO we dont recognize rating systems in my house; violent vidja games dont make bad kids, shit parents make shit kids
Personally, I think the writing was too soft and trying to not offend a living soul. Also the new characters just annoy me, looking at you Ava
Got to agree plus the In your face "only women can save the world" feminist agenda is just a little old. Seriously, every male character in this game is an IDIOT.
Writing? In borderlands? Fuck off, you sound like a game of thrones baby
Clay and Mainwright tho?
@@InvaderG Those two and Balex are the exceptions, but I give Wainwright a gold star
the characters are plain shit. gameplay is great but the vibe is more like fortnite than borderlands
Honestly, people keep saying that there are other looter-shooters, but Borderlands is the only series that gets it for me.
Same
I don't know. I feel other Looter Shooters outdo Borderlands in many more aspects. Destiny gets social elements, Exotic Quests and far more interesting worlds and events. Division Gets more tactical gameplay. Warframe gets sheer depth from so many systems. Borderlands feels like is playing same tricks and hoping they still work.
Some people like it simple and same. While also prefering things to stay the same.
@@FraserSouris I mean you point out what the others do better but miss the things that all the others do work which make borderlands superior. Destiny is held back by its overeliance on pure engrams and trying to force people to pay real money, its pvp element that hurts its pve, its story and characters which are worse than all 3 borderlands games, and it's worse mission design and enemy variety.
@@FraserSouris also as he says himself in this video, destiny and other games in this genre feel like work. Destiny has gotten ridiculous with its grind. I dont like playing games that feel like work. Borderlands never feels like work. You dont have to do 60 public events for a certain weapon or do this many strikes etc.
Imagine the gameplay of borderlands 3 combined with the writing and optimization of borderlands 2
@Grym wait so why "fuck no" you just agreed with him (ps handsome jack was a great villain the writing was really good)
Jonah Thoennes optimization was bad for borderlands 2 what are you talking about? I feel like some people are literally talking about shit they don’t even know but don’t get me wrong bl3 is fucking amazing
Ehh I gives fuck about the story I’m in for the gameplay
Julio Hernandez Then go play call of duty, some of us have brains and would like a decent story
What's all the hate for the writing in bl3? Honestly amazing for me as someone who's cared about these characters for years now.
Are we not going to mention the music? The music was so damn good
Love the music that plays at Sanctuary III
My mate saw a reddit post saying turn down the gun volume so you could listen to the music, after we'd completed the game. man my game has basically been muted except for the music and its so nice. also closed captions are amazing. ""x" barrel ignites" is something to fear now.
Music and sound quality in general.
The type of music that plays in devils razor and other Pandora maps, but devils razor is my favourite rn, combined with the borderlands Pandora desert theme is what I love most about borderlands, the atmosphere.
I love metal and electronic, and there are times where it blends them together perfectly!
I'm still loving the game with the hope that they realize what they have done wrong and fix it
Probably not they've made far to much money on it
you cant fix the writing
Some Guy Hopefully they just retcon it
Why is the Borderlands 2 footage in a 800x600 resolution?? O_o
I noticed it, the hand is in really low resolution, exaggerating the difference?
It is xbox 360
To feed hits narrative
@@Shane-mr4fe borderlands 3 is better graphically. Look up comparison videos.
@@Hal03Rat Does the game look this bad on Xbox 360 ?
It looks nothing like that on PCs of that time or even on the PS3.
Don't let this distract you from the fact that he said ketchup on cornflakes
Tastes better than a used diaper filled with indian food.
@@Corusame but thats just indian food
@@skimrizzle9598 Alright, I don't usually reply to hateful comments but you baited the fuck out of me.
Have you ever HAD Indian food? There's a lot to unpack when talking about India, sure, but their food is not one of them. It's fucking delicious. Change my mind.
ph0e You’re spot on. Indian food is spectacular
Dude, i really hate to be that guy, but PLEASE post your review of Sekiro even if people disagree with you. I really believe that the skill-up fanbase can handle a controversial opinion without things going shit crazy. Furthermore, even if you believe you have an unpopular opinion that everyone will disagree with, I subscribed to your channel to hear your opinion for better or worse, you always have a different outlook on games that reviewers usually do not offer. I played the game and finished it, but i still want to hear your opinion, so please if you may sir, present to us your sekiro review..
This needs to be higher
One day mate. One day :)
No that game is universally loved. He made it clear he didn't care for it and his review will reflect that. Why post a video you know is gonna get ratio'd and a bunch of posts shitting on him?
@@mindsouljah Would you guys care to explain? I am out of the loop
@@720pchannel he didn't like sekiro. And it wouldn't be a wise move to post a video about a game that got universal praise just to say you didn't like it for whatever reason. He literally will get git gud messages a million times
They ruined the amazing gameplay with the absolutely disgusting and aggravating story. I waited until it was on Steam and got it for $30. They ruined half of the game so I'm willing to pay half of the price.
im holding out until GOTY is under 20$, the story offends me that bad
@@bradhaines3142 I just got it for 10$ :D
@@WiblWibl988 yeah i lied to myself, bought the goty for 50$ because i loved 1 and 2 so much. not gonna lie the gameplay alone was worth it. the new DLC for the 4th skill tree, ehh. its definitely different but without a higher level cap its pretty meh. especially if you use moze or zane, not great. moze is OP but the skill is no better, zane is still painfully niche
@@WiblWibl988 where did you buy it? I need that too AHHAH
@@Rex-he9nj Amazon black friday sales
“Nothing but more borderlands, a glorified dlc, borderlands 2.5” have these critics even seen the pre sequel?
@Scitch2781
It is, but at the same time it doesn't have any longevity after the campaign.
Like Wilhelm is my favourite vaulter, but damn I don't want to farm two bosses until the end of days so I can run through a couple of maps for run.
@@knavenformed9436 I've heard the dlc is really good, give it a try
@@infectedanimal9830
It has the same exact problems as the main campaign, and it's a bore when all your weapons are glitched as I don't like the neon look, but bis is bis.
Bold of you to assume I haven't played it though.
Infected Animal this is an aside but I hate dlc. Let me buy the “good” version first. Charge me more sure, but let me have a good game with my first purchase
@@havenprice i hate all these large day one patches. funny how for ps1, ps2, and much of the ps3 era, games released quicker and had no need for large patches, yet now it's nearly impossible for any company to release a game without the need for a large patch. either they hire idiots now that can't make games right the way they used to, or it's intentional. either way it makes it more difficult for your console to be fully playable 20 or 30 years from now. for people who like to collect all the consoles and games, these newer consoles will be complete junk in the future unless they have everything they need (patches, dlc, etc.) saved when the online services for that console get shut down. even then i hear the ps4 has some kind of battery in it that will die after 25 years or so and even though it's possible to replace it, you'll lose everything anyhow. i really can't stand the weasel direction the gaming industry continues to head in.
I appreciate your unbiased review where you can enjoy it for what it brings to the table while holding it accountable for what it doesn’t.
This. Skill up is one of the very few reviewers that does this, and that's why he's one of the very few reviewers I am subbed to.
When it comes to AAA he does that, but when its AA, A, or low budget games, then the issues are heavier than the game being great and fun.
WHY ARE YOU APPLYING KETCHUP TO YOUR CORN FLAKES AT ALL?!
He probably had the ketchup next to the corn flakes and accidently knocked it over... That's the only explanation I can think of lol
KETCHUP ON CORN FLAKES?
DISGUSTING!... TRY RANCH WITH FROOT LOOPS!
He’s channeling his inner Psycho
Say what you want about the characters but BALEX is amazing
agree
That's what pisses me off the most is we get good characters like balex but they come and go in 1 mission where as characters like ava are for some reason the focal point.
He is.
Him being Ice-T made him even more hilarious
Zanes dialogue is fun too
I really like the new map and have no trouble with it, especially helps figuring out when you have to go underground because you can easily find the spot where it leads down.
I disagree, and find it to be one of the worst features of the game, that and the fact you cant track more then 1 mission at a time, I missed a lot of side missions due to this and when i realized they were on a different planet i was already to high a level to care and go back.
The map in Borderlands 3 absolutely sucks...it is like the map in Control, and that one sucks as well...especially given that Control wasn't even supposed to have a map in the first place.
@@LuckyLuch1 fair point I can't say I've had that trouble since I've been doing every side quest as they come up but yes not being able to mark them all is annoying considering you could do it in every other game.
Hit left or right on dpad.
Worst part of the game
I love how an ad pops up after 10:00 *WHAT'S WORSE* appears.
Same. Was it a boost ad?
The problem about making a game about topical things is that game development takes a long time. This is especially true when you base your entire main plot around it.
Tbh borderlands 2 fan wanted end end game
Kira wtf is wrong with your profile pic
@@CobaltFyrestone uhhh.... Nothing....
I agree but I wouldn't argue that the entire main plot is based around anything topical. If you're talking about streaming being the topical thing then I'd even argue that it's more topical today. But I don't think streaming had any effect on the plot at all, it was basically just a reason for the calypso twins to have such a huge following
@star burns This is true...
*I LOVED Tales from the Borderlands*
personally, i found bl2 way more memorable, 3 was good but kinda lackluster when alls said n done after you finish the game
It’s not Call of Duty. 8.9 - IGN
IGN is 2k approuved and was the place where gearbox and 2k talk so yeah they do like this pack of mone... this game
Yall act like an 8 is a bad score or something
@@SolidSnake240 unless it aint 10 these people be thinking their game just got shitted on
8 means amazing(9 being almost perfect and 10 being masterpiece) and borderlands is very good game so no fuckin way it deserves anything higher than 8.9
@@SolidSnake240 7/10 too much water -IGN
Money Singh fair response.
I think it's far better than Borderlands 2 gameplay wise
Edit: And the graphics are a world apart
no not really i have played the 2nd game without 4k update it looks nowhere as bad as the one that was shown in this video
also story wise its the worst one outside of borderlands 1
@@LTDLetsPlays
I never mentioned the story though. And you think that Borderlands 2 (without the 4K update I might add) looks better? Well, good day to you
@@robertdavidson548 "it looks nowhere as bad as the one SHOWN in this video" I SAID shown in this video you dumbass
my POINT is THIS VIDEO shows it worse than its quality is
i never said it was better than borderlands 3 or whatever the crap you wanna believe in you delusional fuck
The gameplay is better in 3. Story and writing for 2 was wayyyy better though
With a game like this, gameplay is the most important thing to me and borderlands 3 has the best gameplay out of any of the games quite easily. Typically story and writing matters a lot to me but when I’m playing a game like this with friends, I hardly even pay attention to the story.
I wholeheartedly recommend this game to anyone who is even remotely curious. You can put on some tunes and completely ignore the godawful writing if you want, but the gunplay is undeniably some of the best on the market. Only tarkov is more fun in regard to guns IMO.
I am still waiting for the game that gives me Destiny art/style with borderlands loot and Warframe fast and smooth gameplay ..
B Brescia 😔 One day my friend one day....
Oooh yes please
Anthem could have been that game.....such a shame
So, just warframe 😁
if they fix up optimization and the ui stuff i'm totally fine with it. Worthy successor to the second game.
AdrnLmao I’m with you. UI and Performance are the biggest problems right now.
All those fancy opening animations make splitscreen really suffer, not an issue on PC though :)
Turn off your Social & Network - Notifications in game, may help.
Story is trash. Gameplay is great
Too bad they cant fix the story
Most helpful, honest , informed review i've seen yet. Great work!
Tales from the Borderlands WAS pretty great! I love that Rhys and Vaughn made it into this one. Kinda wish we would have seen Fiona and Sasha somewhere...alrhpugh i believe on Rhys CEO desk is a picture of Sasha.
i watched a playthrough of tales from the borderlands on youtube, and while entertaining i don't think it would be worth playing more than once. even though you make choices, it doesn't look like those choices will make significant changes to the story like they do in other similar games. like until dawn for ps4, in that game your choices made major differences, i didn't get the feeling anything but the dialogue would usually change while watching tales of the borderlands.
I never laughed when the twins talked, but that handsome jack clip from bl2 (which i already knew about) made me burst out laughing. Now thats the kind of dark humor that i like.
Bl3 comes off as if they lost the really good writer they had for 2, hmmm.
@@umphreak9999 he did write handsome jack, as much as he is a jerkoff irl
@@gkkk2735 most of jack's lines were ad libbed
@@topdattophat were they? Thats impressive of the actor
@@topdattophat It also helps that the voice actor was charismatic and energetic as fuck. A bad voice actor would've made Jack very, very painful.
@@M21cat yes but I'm trying to say Anthony burch is not a great writer
Eden-6 missions felt like the Hammerlock DLC from Borderlands 2.
HA HE TALKS ABOUT BALANCING WHEN THEY JUST NERFED THE TORGUE SHOTGUNS! 🤣🤣
he means pvp balancing where nerfing one thing causes players to resort to another broken thing to annoy other players and get higher stats in pvp. thats just because torgue shotguns needed a nerf or smth because flakker+moze outshines the other Vh's
That aint shit dude, the balacing is all over the place. Also not trying to be mean but that doesn't mean shit, you obviously know nothing about balancing a game.
Love you skillup could you maybe review mhw iceborne?
macaroni lad that would be fantastic
He said he cant do it on twitter
Hoping to do that in Jan for the PC release :P
@@SkillUp awesome the game is in my opinion the best way to do a "live service" game the dev's have added so much content for free
@@Lonelysandman i dont wanna call it live service.. Its just selling expansion pack + free updates.
Great review. I just have an issue with you bringing up open worlds changing like destiny and war frame (Public Events etc). You fail to mention that BL3 can actual be played offline unlike those games that have changing worlds.
I personally would sacrifice a lame public event and have the ability to play game when I want where I want.
Warframe can be played solo, but yea you need internet for em.
you don't really need to forfeit a changing world to have offline though - the world can still be doing things around you, you just need to simulate what might happen if there were other people in the world then change the events accordingly.
CyanPhoenix it actually does in this game.
Rare world spawns occur and im sure there is a secret raid boss tucked in.
I think some maps are just too big and that is the real issue.
Andro King™ nobody said anything about solo....
True
The writing in this game is so painfully bad that It either had me turning the volume off or stop playing entirely. Characters are one dimensional and almost every single one of them is extremely manic, which makes none of them interesting or enjoyable. Jokes often fall flat and the writing made me incredibly unmotivated do progress quests. The moment to moment gameplay is the only redeeming part of this game.
The mission structure is what's killing it for me. If it was as simple as go here, kill some dudes, pick up the McGuffin and come back like it was in the first Borderlands it wouldn't be so bad. What's killing it is the extra steps thrown into that simple formula. It's not so bad for the main story missions, but then they use that expanded formula for ALL of the side quests too. It just drags out the experience and makes the poor writing feel even worse.
I knew the word 'legendary' had lost all meaning in games when I saw some footage of a legendary enemy in Fallout 4 that was just a regular crab thing that went down in seconds. Got to wonder who was telling all the epic stories about that thing and its accomplishments.
I've always wished that you reviewed Witcher 3 under Skill Up to witness your beautiful review style. Maybe go back and review it? I can dream.
Forest D'Esposito maybe he can review the ps5 remaster that’ll inevitably come out in a couple years.
It would be a hell of a love letter to witcher, a deserved one
@@rwalker0130 Knowing CD Projekt RED they'll likely price it at $20, unlike most publishers who even sell ports at full price (like Nintendo).
@@dreamerabe The Witcher 3 PORT for the Switch is at $60 which does include the DLC. So if were going by individual pricing, that would be $40 for the base game and $20 for DLC. This is a downgraded port, not a remaster, for a 4 year old game. If they're going to Remaster it for the PS5 it's not going to cost only $20, be a bit more realistic.
Well at least im 99% sure we'll get a cyberpunk review also mentioning the witcher 3..
Your reviews are the best Ralph, I always look forward to them.
If the jokes were more similar to Borderlands 1 rather than 2, it wouldn't have been so bad.
Borderlands 1 was absolutely amazing, especially the ending.
Yes I know, most people say the ending was a buzzkill, but that was the point. They trolled the players, and it was epic.
I think I'll wait till the Epic Store Early Access is over next April.
Yeah, it sucks but I refuse to play any game on the Epic store. I'll wait till they release on a real pc store ie. Steam
That's the best thing you can do. Let the bugs get fixed in the meantime
Just play it on console, i have a PC but fuck epic and i didn't want to wait
@@Jim26D You and I both know Steam is just gonna introduce MORE bugs
@@Lenoh That doesn't make any sense at all. And alot of issues are with the launcher something steam for how many fuckin years now? A decade? Two? Yeah something steam clearly hasn't fucked up.
The main issue with BL3 is many people outgrew the writing. Many people started playing the series in middle school and the humor didn't evolve with the growing audience. Although, tales from the borderlands did a good job with improving on the writing but that's a different team.
I chuckled just as much playing this as 2, why Skill Up praises 'Shooty McShootface' and trashes the writing in 3 is beyond me. It's hit and miss, just like 2, and imo 3 has nothing as abominably cringe as Tiny Tina, and shes actually still in the game! haha.
Don't forget, a new generation is in middle/high-school who likely still can relate to the humour that the older players may have grown out of... I imagine the target audience remained the same and that is why the writing did not mature at the same rate of the original player base.
I was disappointed that this game didn't have neither the secret vault symbols achievements nor the cryptic clue achievements that made for fun engaging exploring of the maps. Instead you have predictable achievements that are already marked on the map. At least to me that was a regression form Bordelands 2.
One thing I can say about the story, I have never hated and wanted to kill the villians as much as I did in this game. The twins are basically the Paul brothers and god are they annoying.
What's up with annoying twins in games lately ? Far Cry new dawn, Wolfenstein Newblood, Borderlands 3, is this a new trend ?
That's 3 games, just 3 games
"With all that in mind, I now present to you my review of CDPR Displates."
Seriously my biggest gripe is how they continue to use the same terrible UI design. It's slow, it's ugly, it's not all that functional. Developers need to prioritize fast usable UI.
BL2 wasn't bad. But they went back to BL1 aesthetics which aren't great
Yup, and death animations. I die alot in this game, death should have no animation, just respawn me! I feel like inventory and the rest of the options should be in a separate button.
My biggest problem with the twins is that it felt like they were handed every victory.
Not buying a game because of some tweets is stupid tbh !
Not buying it because of shady review processes and strong arming youtubers...sure..i can understand that.
Randy is a certified dickhole, and those tweets aren't by far the worst he's done. Not wanting to buy the game, or at least from the Epic Store or until it's on sale for his consistently shitty behavior is justified IMO.
sucks that the people with families to feed have to suffer as a result
@@YoQ i understand it, don't condone it
@@YoQ Yep. Randy will just fuel the EGS bribe cash and royalties to his bank account, like always.
Blistering Barnacles he’s a dickhead, but he’s not some terrible person. Who cares.
Borderlands 3 looks exactly like how you remember Bordelands 2 from all these years ago
so like the best looter shooter ever?
That's a good way of putting it, true for the gameplay too
When I went back and played that free dlc they just brought out for bl2 a couple months ago it didn't feel good to play at all, because the gunplay sucked compared to more modern games and it didn't feel like I was actually firing anything. But bl3 feels exactly how I remember feeling playing bl2 which is all I wanted
I literally couldn't tell the difference when he showed the side by side clips from 3 and 2
@@IloveGorgeousGeorge The art style might be the same but the detail is almost like comparing halo 3 to halo reach, bl2 almost looks like crap comparatively (even though at the time it looked good)
Borderlands 2 was an entirely different experience for me. I was still in school, not depressed and had friends.
:)
Still one of the best looter shooters out therre, but with one of, if not, the worst stories/writing in any game. After playing this game i automatically thought, "man Tale of the Borderlands is fucking screwed", because i just imagined this game, but with only its story, and the new Tales of the Borderlands was exactly that and it was god awful, not ven laughingly so, but depressingly so.
Idk why these issues weren’t obvious to the developers. Imagine being part of the gunplay team only to see what the story writers came up with.
The last Borderlands thing I played was Tales, and that was def a shock when I went into the BL3 and found that the writing felt so “blegh” compared to that (plus no Fiona 😭). Gunplay and updates to optimization, UI, etc. might keep me around, but we’ll see.
love the engine work and new gameplay systems
hate story and characters
in short, thankfully the programming side of development compensated both the makreting and the writing team, more concerned with journalists and short term profit
waiting that sale on steam :(
8:10 lol, it's not THAT bad XD, that's low graphics ... but if BL3 on the right is low graphics too it's ok
As far as characters go, I'm not a fan of the NPCs throughout the story (with the exception of Rhys), but the Vault Hunters are pretty well-written imo. The game is extremely fun to play though. =]
"Sale on steam" thats gonna be a long while
@@kalebreid45 i'm still going to buy it eventually ... seeing so many people enjoy the gameplay gives me hope
story-wise, in short, too many characters, purposely stretched with filler, thus unfocused, false stakes/consequences/sacrifices
BL2 was a bit dated when i got into it, but thanks to the story i finished it twice all over.
@@zarodgaming1844 i like the story more then borderlands 2 bc borderlands 3 have cutscenes,its more epic and funny
Great job on the review 👍, quick side note soooo awesome you edited so the commercials synced to your segments seems insignificant but really makes the review easier to watch and follow 😁
Borderlands has the possibility of some of the best writing for villains in a game that I’ve seen in a while. If you haven’t played Tales From The Borderlands, you need to. Because I won’t spoil anything, but the beginning of episode 5 is damn near perfect.
Unpopular opinion here, but borderlands 3 made me chuckle a few times. I think the humour is pretty much the same as the BD2 and the pre sequel
I loved out loud a bunch of times. It fully embraces the stupidety and cringe and is fully aware that it's dumb af, which is rather rare these days.
thats good
borderlands takes stupid jokes, cringe or not, and still makes it funny. it could be the dumbest shit, i’ll still laugh. that’s what makes the game unique and enjoyable.
I could laugh at many of the side missions and some cringe-laughter was in there as well. I find that there are just some (or many) misplaced jokes, like one in a story mission that literally destroyed the tension of the whole scene.
Yeah I guess you're right, but I miss Jack's dark humor.
Borderlands 3 is a harsh reminder of what the looter shooter genre moved away from. It started the genre, but no one followed suit. A diverse RPG skill system, a plethora of loot that you can't help but pick and choose, a villain that is ever present (regardless of how poorly done they are), and most of all an experience that feels whole. Games in the genre release and they then promise a "whole" at a later date. Regardless if I got my money's worth, I almost never feel like I got a full game. Borderlands 3 felt complete from start to finish, and engaged me from start to finish. If they add more to the game in the future, I won't feel like they're adding it because they had something left over to give. Borderlands 3 gave everything, and anything else after this point is *more*
@Grym Can you really blame anyone for think that Borderlands invented the genre? Most people never even heard of Hellgate:London. And 2 years is not that long of time before.
Thanks for your honest review. I will purchase BL3 on Steam during a summer or winter sale.
The part about PVP is so true! I’n getting really tired of everyone obsessing over numbers and competitive pvp when we could all just be having some goddamn fun
Good point
Sometimes there are just people that have been playing FPS for 16 years and your version of "competitive" is their version of barely paying attention.
Indeed! Everything now is just based on competitive and ESPORTS! it's all so toxic, and everyone acts like they got something to prove or that they're better than someone else! It's crazy, man! I just love to chill and have fun with games!
Btw Elites do not spawn in Destiny 2 with unique loot., It's actually bordlands 3 that has that one.
Unique loot to the *boss.* The loot for the whole Borderlands 3 was still unique to whichever gun you came across.
D1 strike bosses had themed loot gear. D2 is close, but instead of bosses it counts a drop from the strike instead.
@@lejenddairy Destiny 2 does have unique strike loot... litterally what are you talking about?
You can only obtain the loot if it's Heroic that week.
Matthew Scully you mean nightfall and there is no guarantee on that loot. Also with the list of absolute horrid rolls and nightfall loot being overly outshined by pinnacle weapons and just better loot in other places
@@aczeos People only go for them for the titles.
I LOVE how they mostly kept core of borderlands the same, and just made improvements on existing content. I like the new 3d map, I don't understand why some people don't like it.I like the small visual updates to the UI in general. It still feels like borderlands to me.
Borderlands 3 is what I wanted and more. It's still the classic looter shooter that started the fps loot shoot genre, and gearbox didn't try to completely re-invent borderlands. No premium currency, no buyable lootboxes, no battle royal, instead you unlock or earn cosmetics, no always online bullshit.
I think that Borderlands 3 is better than bl2 in every way except 2.
1. Handsome Jack is very detailed antangonist. I would be shocked if gearbox managed to make a villian better than him.
2. Performance.Subjective. SOME people claim to barley be able to play the game because of stuttering, crashing, ECT ECT. I'm on PS4 pro on preformance mode and the only "problem" I've experienced is a bit of lag when opening my inventory.
MetalheadRob Redbar spot on for me too man. The performance on my high end PC is terrible though. It’s easily a 10 for me. I just hope they fix the performance issues asap
@@j.kol3491 I hope so to dude. I feel bad for us fans of the series and wish I could help somehow. At least on PC a hotfix or patch won't take as long to push through as it does on console. Certification can take quiet a while.
Well then you're lucky, I play on Xbox One X, it has crashed my Xbox twice and froze itself 3 times. A lot of FPS drop and lagging when trying to switch between 'inventory' and 'skills'
The problem is that they said that this map will help is to find things, but it didn't. Nothing changed, sometimes you still can't understand how to get to some places. They should make a system like in GTA V.
@@BooguyTheAdept You can rotate the map to see the elevation of levels and see what bridges or pathways lead up and down. A big improvement over bl2s map. Do you mean claptrap spare parts or the kiosk that talk about the first vault hunters?
7:59 I seriously had a good laugh 😂
Gotta be honest, I loved this review. Personally, yeah, I thought the writing was garbage, but that wasn't really what I got the game for. If I wanted good writing, I'd play Tales again. No, I bought it for insane loot and creative and fun class diversity, and that's exactly what I got. I'm totally satisfied.
I agree telltale is a narrative studio and did better with the lore and story better than gearbox ever has. At least we hav both for different reasons. I'm still goin to wait this game out cuz I don't think it's worth 60 yet.
Borderlands 3 Story and Villians were dissapointing yet everything else is an improvement.
I can't believe Im going to say this:
But I miss Anthony Burch.
DanDraco What’s up with em?
@@puddles2967 that's not Anthony Burch. Anthony Burch did not voice scooter, he is the lead writer of Borderlands 2.
@@PKDeviluke25 You know what? I'm stupid. Sorry.
Was the much better writer. These guys are pretty bad in comparison
@@puddles2967 nah you're good. scooter voice actor is still alive and has a channel called film joy.
you can switch between quests without entering the menus. you can even see the currently assigned keys next to the quest name
This was a life-saver for me once I realized it.
I would've liked that option on the map itself, so I don't have to scroll left, change mission, go back onto the map, check location, repeat.
The thing that I really love about borderlands 3 is when I join my buddy's game, and the enemy stay my level even though he's 10 levels above me, but they'll stay his level on his side it's a nice touch.
Scaling, ladies and gentlemen. More and more games are doing it, and it's such a good feature.
Definitely useful, brought some things to light I didnt even think about for my soon to come review. As always, great video.
Thank you for mentioning Tales Of The Borderlands, such a great game
I will name my first born loader bot.
I dont always agree with you but you're thorough. 1 like for you. Plz consider reviewing shadowkeep.
He definitely is. He's said he would be reviewing the new Destiny expansion a few times
It's gonna be garbage, D2 sucks
@@cartoonvideos5 that's your opinion, at least they aren't sucking epic dick or choosing insane people as their CEO lmao
@@cartoonvideos5 im guessing if you have ever played the game you have only played the base game
He’s a huge destiny fan so he’s 200% doing that
The game just takes you out of the flow way too much. Like, all the times you have to "talk to Lilith" and travel back and forth from Sanctuary with excessive load times especially on consoles between different areas, and also the unskippable in-game cutscenes... The game just gets in its own way way too often. Just let me kill stuff. Everytime I get in the flow, another terrible forced vehicle mission or have to travel somewhere else for more boring exposition.
And yes, I think they need to stop playing it so safe and try doing some new things. Don't change the core gameplay loop, just try some new things.
Song at the end is 'Rembrance' by Purple Dive. Love me some vaporwave.
BL2: Tiny Tina > Claptrap.
Just saying.
BL3: Cl4ptrap> Tiny Tina
I love the thought that Tina will probably be playable in the next game.
K
Also Krieg > all.
Corvidae nah cos then she’ll have no part in the story
Refuse to support 2k or epic so I'll be waiting on this one. Looks like more Borderlands though which is pretty cool with me.
Sawyer have fun with that. I’ll enjoy the hell out of this in your place 😁
Steam relaese all the way.
It will be patched up by then.lol.
gamers: vote with ur dollar because capitalism lol
also gamers: buys game eventually anyway
@@mr.dreampants8095 yeah and ? You tell them to not put their ego before customer but also (after a some time) to make good game before some quick cash grab
@@mr.dreampants8095 I remember when I believed in capitalism... Dark days
You're the only reviewer to point out how crippling pvp balance is to a team based game design, thank you!
Sounds like this'll be one of those games to catch up on audiobooks while playing, lol.
Bob Ross streams are relaxing. Just listening to Mr.Ross talk is wonderful
I feel like you should seperate the Online Loot Shooters like Destiny, Division and Warframe from a offline or coop focused Loot Shooter Borderlands.
The online ones have gotten the term MMO lites because what drives them are the same reasons why MMO RPG like WoW, FFXIV, GW2, BDO are driven by.
These games requires world bosses, events, recurring enemies and whatnot because they are built on the idea that they can always be played.
Borderlands isn't. You choose when to play it.
I agree with your video but the comparisons between the other loot shooters and Borderlands feel like comparing Skyrim to ESO.
Tripl3M but comparing Skyrim to eso is also a fair comparison because there are a lot of similarities, or you want to compare eso with destiny?
RonixEnclave no he didn’t, he was just explaining how restricting it is, because it is
@@fatbroccoli8 having a strong online pvp element in these types of games is super restrictive in other ways too. They dont have to worry about guns being unfair for pvp or abilities being too crazy. That's what I dislike about destiny nothing is ever super cool because everything has to be fair in pvp.
Sectric exactly, that’s what Shill up was saying
@@TheSectric Striker Titans with One-Eyed Mask is fair? Bruh... Mountaintop/Recluse is fair? Bruh... Short examples of things that ARENT fair and extremely powerful/broken. So, it leaves me to believe you haven't played it recent times.
You didn't mention auto-loot from chests, which is a game changer
Playing this game from four years in the future. Very glad to hear I wasn't alone in finding the writing grating. It's my first Borderlands game and I keep thinking "are they always written like this? This is bad"
Too many people are defending the writing in this comment section. The writing in 2 wasn’t amazing / I definitely was a lot younger and have rose tinted glasses. But the writing in 3 is SO FUCKING TERRIBLE THE WHOLE TIME I CANT STAND IT
Of course it wasn't ready to ship. That's why we got the Beta on Epic Store
And yet I've had a nearly flawless experience outside of 1 crash, running between 80-120 FPS @ 1440p depending on the area with just a few settings turned down/off (volumetric fog off, reflections medium).
The game has a fuckton of content out of the box compared to most modern games. Some unfortunate performance issues (which seem a bit random and hardware driven) doesn't equal "not ready to ship".
@@JWiLL0255 Its just a redicilous circlejerk at this point. The ''boycotters'' want to play this game so bad, so they try to feel better about themselves by saying ''lol its still in beta enjoy testing it xD!'' in the mean time, here we are, enjoying the hell out of this game.
I agree with you man. Performance is pretty much acceptable (flawed, but acceptable) and the game is crazy fun.
@Bill Gates TIL buying games on epic games makes you a worthless piece of shit. Thank you Bill Gates Very Cool!!!
@Bill Gates Lmfao what a ridiculous reply. I'm supporting the devs of Borderlands 3 because it's a fantastic game. The Epic Launcher might suck but I couldn't care less once I'm in game.
Newsflash: People hated Steam back in the day too. None of these corporations are your friend. Support devs who make great games - that's literally it.
Any particular reason why you're showing ps vita gameplay of borderlands 2 for comparison?
Dr. disrespect and shroud would have made a great villains as the twins who would be the toughest fps bosses in history.
Lol the game would literally just have programmed in auto aim for both of them
I think it’s funny how the villains are a satirical take on actual youtubers and streamers, showing off how fake and self obsessed a lot of them are. Also they are very easy to hate which was probably what they intended
Agree that 3 is a big step up visually but it looks like you're on the non remastered version of 2 with all the settings turned down in the comparison.
compulsive jaywalker apples to apples though. It’s what both games look like on release. I get what you mean, I play BL2 with the remastered graphics on and it looks passable but BL3 is still far better.
@@gloryioustyrone6428 But that's not how the game looked like on release unless you played it on a potato.
I noticed that as well. I played Borderlands 2 back when it was released and with the texture pack this year again. In both terms it looked way better than the footage shown in this review. The comparison shines a bad light on this review.
@@LeSangDuTigre The BL2 footage was from either the xbox or ps3. I played the hell out of Borderlands 2 on PS3 so you can trust me on the claim.
Why the fuck would you compare it to the remaster...
.Rid of Denuvo and DRM and game should run 2x better. but it 2k probably 0 chance
I’ve played about 5 hours of the game and I’ve had a lot of fun. Gameplay is what I look for and here the combat and shooting mechanics are very good. Some of the weapons look so bloody good and feel great to use. 🙂
7:40 balance with the troll faces I was dying 🤣🤣🤣
RaW Chief Ah yes, random word with troll face. Hilarious.
@@momodnoorful well yea with context its pretty funny this comment is a year old lmao
Amazing review. I only really disagreed with the subjective stuff like the story and characters, but as you mentioned its subjective in nature and I have a pro borderlands bias. That being said, if there was one thing I think should be mentioned, is that bl3 does have "event" like quests, in the form of map based challenges that reward players for exploring the new ginormous maps, and rare spawn enemies. These rare spawns are probably the closest to world bosses that bl3 has, and they can be encountered rarely in certain places in certain maps, and if you kill them they can drop good loot and they even unlock a kill quest for people on ur friends list. An example of this is in the moon map, you can come across "Dinklebot" in a certain spot, who drops a legendary Loot-o-gram that you can farm and turn into crazy earl for white rarity gear as a joke. Or Borman Nates on promethea who drops a pistol that shoots knives. They are pretty fun and a good addition in my book
Either way, another great review from Skillup. Im glad you reviewed this as ive seen a lot of people who brushed the game off entirely because of the epic and 2k stuff, and im happy you gave this gem of a game the gameplay recognition it deserves
Everything is subjective, except performance issues.
snark567 well yeah but comedy and story telling are much more subjective then most. MOST people will agree that floaty weapons that feel like nerf guns are bad but there are surly some people out there that prefer it.
@@Postpar A lot of people liking something doesn't make it objectively good, you can still have people who dislike that thing, it's all based on personal preference regardless of how popular or unpopular it is.
Saying the game has good gameplay is subjective because it depends on what the person values, saying the game has performance issues is objective because those issues exist regardless of what your opinions are.
@@snark567 Which can be fixed with patches and usually don't leave a lasting impression on those who wait.
@@crazy13alex So?
6:47-7:54 and that is why Borderlands is THE looter shooter. Everything else is just a shitty-paying part-time job disguised as a game.
*cough* Warframe *cough*
@@kevinlim7265 Warframe doesn't have a loot shooting system at all.
Being free only gets you so much. The insane grind spends that good will really quickly.
I disagree on the live-streamer overtones of the story's main villains. The exhausting "if you like my video and want to support my channel, smash that like button and don't forget to subscribe and hit that bell!" crap was ripe for mockery.
To help some people decide wether they want to buy or not: I didn’t like any of the other games, but I LOVE this one. I thought that the other games had kinda boring gameplay, but this one feels amazing to play. BUY IT BUY IT BUY IT!