Must be his years of experience combined with extraordinary intelligence, honesty and decency to be so patient and humble in his explanation that even a layperson like myself could understand. I actually taped him as I couldn't see it all day. It was very educational to listen to him. And yes, he is so spoken and articulate. Lord, I hope there are more like him out there.
Not so fast. Dr. Langenfeld, the ER doctor, said the blood gas level was tested and showed a Carbon DIOXIDE level at 100%. NOT an oxygen level at 98%. So one of these doctors is either lying or totally incompetent. And how did the prosecution not notice this huge contradiction?
There is a huge discrepancy in Dr Tobin's testimony. Here is a another direct quote from him in the testimony: “Chauvin kept his knee on Floyd’s neck for 3 minutes, 2 seconds, after Floyd took his last breath, Tobin said. After that last breath, Floyd’s oxygen levels went down to zero and Floyd “reached the point where there was not one ounce of oxygen left in the body,” In other words, Floyd had been dead at least 3 minutes and 2 sends before they took him away in the ambulance. With the lungs not working and the heart stopped, how could the oxygen saturation go up to 98%? To re-oxygenate blood from 0% to 98% is impossible without the lungs working and the heart pumping blood through the lungs. Some have said that CPR in the ambulance is the reason. While it's easy to charge the lungs with breathing-like action, without great heart action pumping blood through the lungs, it can't recharge the hemoglobin with oxygen. Yes, CPR moves a some amount of blood through the lungs, it's not like normal heart action. Not enough to recharge a dead man's hemoglobin up to an extremely healthy level of 98%. I've been in the hospital many times with non-respiratory issues, and sometimes had oxygen saturations lower than 98%. This dog just doesn't hunt.
@@noob3dprinter Yes that's right. Someone cleared this up for me. Landenfeld did say his carbon dioxide level was 100, not 100%. Also, this was a different blood draw from the one Dr. Tobin was referring to, but the testimony didn't make that clear. It got very confusing, especially when the prosecution brought him back for rebuttal. But none of it matters now, the jurors apparently had their minds made up for them all along by public pressure. Chauvin got over charged in this case and over convicted.
@@optoms1178 1. If you know anything about trials, ANY AND ALL expert witnesses can be contradicted. These people are testifying for their own gain (like Tobin did this for free to help him get clients in civil cases who pay $500 per hour). 2. As you could see, Chavin had a shoestring budget ... while the state spent millions ... unfair fight for sure. 3. There was no sour grapes about my comment. I pointed out Tobin was biased. He was.
He "oozes" corruption. They were told prior to this he can not ask this question because they purposefully did this knowingly the defenses expert had already left the state. They are lucky its not a mistress. Besides, the protection has already been debunked and destroyed. False and cherry picked edited questions and clips. This isn't a trial, it's an embarrassment to the justice system.
@@christophervincent8420 Corruption, huh? Seemed like a pretty solid medical take to me. I think you just don't like what he has to say and feel that George Floyd's killing was justified. Also any potential corruption in a case like this would favor the killer cop and not the victim so that's a ridiculous statement you made. Just admit you think it was ok for George Floyd to be executed.
@@jmaguire2232 guess you only pay attention to the "prosecution" and refuse to hear the the rest of the people talking. Baaaa baaaa sheep.like a good little boy
Dr Tobin you are absolutely the most honest, open, and intelligent witness in this entire trial. It was a pleasure to learn from you. 😘 RIP George Floyd 🕊🕊🕊♥️
Um Nelson probably has an IQ around 120 to 150.......I think you are mistaken. Im no advocate for him, but he is extremely smart. He accomplished every single legal proof he was able to in this circumstance.
He's a paid liar. Dr. Langenfeld, the ER doctor, said the blood gas level was tested and showed a Carbon DIOXIDE level at 100. NOT an oxygen level at 98%. So one of these doctors is either lying or totally incompetent. And how did the prosecution not notice this huge contradiction?
@@wtaleteller9248 He may or may not, but he knows his clients is guilty, and is tried, unsuccessfully, to manipulate scientific facts, he embarrassed himself and his client.
Dr. Tobin! Is inspiring people to study! Listen to this guy I have no clue of anything on his field of study.. And yet he's explaining it in a way so digestible.
IM IN LOVE WITH THIS DOCTOR TOBIN, WE SHOULD HAVE MORE DOCTORS LIKE HIM WHO ARE HONEST , HAVE PASSION FOR THER PROFESSION- HELPING HIS PATIENTS , DEDICATING THEIR LIVES TO RESEARCH, IMPROVING THEIR KNOWLEDGE AND THE MOST IMPORTANT SHARING THAT KNOWLEDGE WITH OTHERS.
Didn't you hear his testimony? He testified that George Floyd's blood gas was 98 percent oxygen which is very normal for someone who is living and not asphyxiated. Meaning, his heart stopped for a different reason such as drug overdose. I hope you really do appreciate his dedication to truth and facts even when they don't align with your worldview.
@An Capall Mór I am white & love myself. I’m horrified at the police brutality we’re witnessing these days being perpetrated on citizens, mostly black men.
@@mollybolton8425 He actually didn't receive payment for his testimony. He felt the case was of such importance he refused payment. If you had paid attention you would have seen this.
hahahaha. keep telling yourself that. the prosecution gave the defense their case cause you do not even know what an argument is nor have any idea what a burden of proof is
Where is the logic here? If you resist then murder is ok? I mean yes he resisted to a point but what about after he was unconscious? That is the line between controlling a suspect and killing him, not to mention not allowing anyone to give him medical attention like the fire fighter. Guilty all day long.
Sadly this doctor and the prosecution just admitted mr Floyd had 98% oxygen which proves he was not strangled or died of a lack of oxygen, this proves the defense was correct, mr Floyd died of a heart attack and the officer had nothing to do with his death. With all stupid jokes like m&ms aside, the state prosecutor just proved beyond reasonable doubt the officer is innocent, I honestly can’t believe the prosecution was that fucking stupid.
@@monica62888 no problem because apparently I have more common sense then you which is why you resort to sarcasm as a rebuttal, if you had a lick of common sense I’m sure you can prove me wrong.... please take you time I’ll wait.... no... can’t provide facts to prove me wrong? Then go be a idiot someone else.
Our Irish brother Martin Tobin made bits of that dirty cop and his fake witness ,god bless him for telling the truth and being excellent in relation to the way he expressed it to the jury in simple terms
@big andy lol don't worry you haven't solved the case in relation to Oxygen in his blood and dying from asphyxia , Believe me this was common knowledge to all the experts that had received a copy of the blood tests and and had months to prepare ,if it had been some kind of ureka moment they would have brought it up ,iam sure there was a reason why they didn't ,that's why they are experts in their field ,try CPR and recieving oxygen ,but could not get the heart started again because the brain had been starved for too long and no electrical pulse for the heart but was still being artificially pumped
@big andy yes he was a late addition ? but the judge wouldn't allow the new evidence because the defence hadn't had time to prepare ,that's what would have caused a mistrial ,he just went over blood oxygen levels to rule out carbon monoxide being a cause of death ,as far as the blood oxygen levels were concerned they had known that information for months it wasn't anything new ,he just stated because of the high oxygen levels carbon monoxide was not a factor in his death and the jury had a right to know that information obviously or the judge wouldn't have allowed it
Knowledgeable without being pretentious, puts things in layman’s terms and is absolutely self-assured about what happened and not wavering for even a moment when pressed.
@@laurafedora5385 Sounds like you just described someone with a god complex. Not very scientific because with true science, there must always be some doubt. To be without any doubt is to be a god which this doctor certainly is not.
Also respect to Jerry Blackwell, he is a superstar in this as well. Super intelligent charming man who knows how to bring the best out of people. Yeah I love him too! ❤
The defense opened the door to blood gases when they mentioned carbon monoxide. The nurse on the jury will already know about blood gases and can infer from Dr. Tobin's testimony it wasn't high without the actual lab results.
Great testimony from Dr.Tobin! He is definitely an expert in his field! Chauvin doesnt have a chance in hell to get off without jail time! Chauvin it’s time to pay up for your cruelty and disregard for human life!
Dr.Tobin is like the Sherlock Holmes of the mystery of the inner body workings. His voice is smooth and calming. When someone respeates a correct answer in their own way. He's like "Percisley"
When I comment.... it is always according to exactly what I am seeing and hearing.... with full understanding that I don't know any of these people..... nor the whole story.... I was speaking to what was said about what he's done for the amount of years and listening to him speak and explain.... @bilo Z.... thanks but, I'm cool on seeking out all your other comments for a You Tube WHO'S RIGHT WHO'S WRONG back and forth.... Again I commented about what was presented in this video....smh
Just a clarification for the journalist speaking on this video. The doctor is an internal medical specialist in pulmonology's Which consists of: The respiratory system; Which includes the lungs.
*my edit is... did some of you not hear that the police interceptor was actually a Hybrid yesterday? Tobin is a true expert witness. He doesn't care about being compensated. The man is basically a scientist, he knows what he knows and you're not going to be able to twist him up or make him change his mind. He is giving facts as he knows them. All expert witnesses- for either side should be like this.
I guess you are not a medical expert. Dr Tobin testimony was full of mambojambo. There are a lot of studies made about positional asphyxia and this guy denies them all. And his calculations about the force Chauvin used in knee pressing is total garbage. It cant be calculated. I understand why state called him, they didnt like medical examiners testimonies. This guy is not qualified for speculate a cause of death or elements around it. I must admit he was a good speaker, especially about bull shit.
@@Raimond799 Interesting that the defense couldn't find a single expert witness to can confirm with what you're saying. I'm surprised they didn't hire a blue collar guy like yourself to refute medical science.
Speak to the nurse and chemist on the jury. They will know about blood gases without them being introduced. Why did the defense open the door to blood gases but, not present the results to prove their point? They will wonder.
@E walker The defence was not provided with the blood gases report before. Hence they asked it to be excluded out of the prosecutor testimony today... But the judge did allow to include the oxigen saturation levels taken during the EMR which was fair enough
And also a bird was flying by and the feathers blew into his airway.Derek was trying to keep the bird away.That so called ex officer is a cruel sadistic demon.God sees and knows everything.His day is coming.Galatians 6vs9
@Doogie rj That's 98% when he arrived at ER, which is after the paramedics performed CPR, which typically results in a rise in oxygen saturation levels to 94-98%. All that is proof of is that the paramedics performed CPR. This study (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6072928/) states an ‘...SaO2 (oxygen saturation) between 94-98% is a dedicated treatment goal in current guidelines’. Meaning doctors aim for 94-98% oxygen after a cardiac arrest, during CPR. I know its easy to see +90% oxygen and think "We breathe oxygen, that means he was breathing" but that's simply not the case.
Jerry blackwell is not being paid for his services "pro bono basis". He wants justice for FLOYD. Amazing how GOD uses ppl without allowing them to accept money.. blessing to lawyer Jerry blackwell ✊🏿
@CrazyMikey4Life one the stupidest comment I've ever seen.. this doesn't mean put your knee on his neck while he's begging for help.. you seen in the video that he was no resisting arrest. He didn't want to be in the back of the seat. . He asked them to put him in the front. So don't come at me with this bull shit.. when we comply it's still a death sentence.. , example>>Philando Castile, a 32-year-old African shot by police in his car should I go on and on? 🤔🤔
He's lying. Dr. Langenfeld, the ER doctor, said the blood gas level was tested and showed a Carbon DIOXIDE level at 100%. NOT an oxygen level at 98%. So one of these doctors is either lying or totally incompetent.
@@ytsm bs Tobin didn't charge a fee for one reason ,so nobody could claim he was being paid off by any side ,and tell us how he nearly caused a mix trial ? ,,it was claimed before he took the stand that the new evidence would cause a mistrial if he has mentioned it , obviously he didn't bring in the new evidence ,at the very least know what is actually going on
I think the jury will see this so far I haven’t seen 1 good witness for defence the one I thought had a say has just been outed for not telling the truth
Bless Dr Tobin. Behind his calm, poised exterior you could sense his anger at the blatant lies from Dr Fowler. I can't help but feel the prosecution should have had Dr Tobin deliver his testimony near the end, so it was fresher in the minds of the jurors. Also, did anyone see Chauvin leaning over looking at Mr Nelson's notes? I'm sure that's not appropriate behaviour for a defendant, he's acting like he's Mr Nelson's colleague or something. He should be in orange and in handcuffs!
You know. I was thinking the same thing. Like let’s do a live demonstration right and have people come in and have a knee placed on their neck and have two others hold you down behind a supposed car that’s on for almost 10 minutes. All jurors must participate. I wonder HOW this would play out.
@@mr.duanesharpe Steven crowder did it for the same amount of time and he has a heart condition also. Not saying it's definitive, but if you want an example
They’re now asking for test to be allowed as newly discovered evidence! I didn’t get to hear if the judge said yes or no, just the request and rebuttal.
@@clairepaterson2374 It wasn't newly discovered, the defense asked for these test results 2 months ago and the prosecution claimed none were ever done. But now they mysteriously appear, and the judge even said it's shady and not allowed. The judge stopped short of calling the prosecution dirty scumbags.
@None of your business you understand there’s literally rules to subdue someone who is resisting, there’s rules to even subduing someone you think is on drugs and potentially a danger, and guess what it’s not just kill them, you are clearly a very sad ignorant man who has no idea what they are talking about
@None of your business u should move to Brazil or something since u think the cops should do whatever they want when they catch a criminal I guess lol America’s the best cuz we’re not barbaric. Doesn’t matter if a criminal doesn’t present a deadly threat u can’t kill him
@None of your business the point that they are making is perception is often reality for people. If Chauven would have left his ego and pride at home the world would’ve possibly seen an overdose. Because he wanted to play billy bad ass he’s in the position he’s in now. Not sure if you’d be as quick to point these things out if it was someone close to you that received the officers sense of justice. 🤷🏾♂️
@@robrandolph9463 No, he sounds Irish. Educated there and then earned a British Thoracic Association Fellowship at King's College, London under Philip Hugh-Jones, a pioneering lung and diabetes researcher.His credentials are impeccable.
Dr Toblin make me feel like I want to become a doctor, he explains technical things in such simple ways, he is by far the most influential person in this case
Nelson and Chauvin are INSTANTLY worried the minute they hear Dr Tobin's name. During the delay before he takes the stand watch their body language, Nelson continuously adjusts his glasses, fiddles with his mask, his hands are fidgeting. Chauvin struggles to keep his fingers from drumming the table and his eyes dart nervously around the room. It's so different from their arrogant, impassive demeanour the rest of the time. They're rattled. Gooo onnnnn Dr Tobin!
The defense is dirty to bring this up at the last moment after all their other theories have been Factually disproven. Dr Tobin disproves this as well♥️.
I hate to tell you this is a last minute dirty trick by the prosecution. They knew what the defenses legitimate medical pathologist was going to say from his report months ago. They had plenty of time to rebut it. They did nothing then try to slip in their expert to deny it and why at the last minute. Pay attention. The prosecution has 100% of the burden to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. If they miss something, it cannot be brought in at a disadvantage to the defence without adequate chance for them to bring back their expert. Easy? Yes, it's the law. Nice try though.
The prosecution experts said that Floyd succumbed to a lack of oxygen while pinned to the ground yet a pulmonologist testifying for the prosecution said that records show Floyd’s body was saturated with 98 percent oxygen?
@@ryanb8719 his arterial blood was. That is proof that he didn't have an excess of carbon monoxide in his body/blood. The defense was trying to say the carbon monoxide from the tailpipe of the running car contributed to his death.
And if the US would educate _its_ population on the Constitution and the law, then we wouldn't have a bunch of people already making up their minds about this _trial._
This doctor is so intelligent..i wanna take notes..i learned so much about carbohemoglobin something something hyper pharynx something something..yes all of that
Put that monster way! He killed a man in cold blood by not letting him gasp for air for almost ten minutes! We don’t pay cops to kill subjects, cops job is to arrest subjects and bring them to jail.
It’s amazing to me that they play with our intelligence like we don’t know we can’t breathe if our neck was being sat on. And for nine minutes, nine!!!!...
That’s great but it wasn’t his neck and Chauvin moves his position several times during that time while George died from an OD and a bad heart made worse by the stressful situation.
@@JaggersLips R u kidding me. Did you hear the entire LIVE, OR were you LISTENING.. His death was initiated by that MURDERER, as if he had permission.. He didn’t give life. Therefore, he can’t take life.. #staywokeppl✌️
@@audrafolkes5978 sorry what ? I’ve watched the entire 14 days of court proceedings, the evidence is there for all to see. I watched with a neutral mindset, it only seems that people that are biased are only hearing what they want to. There is far too much doubt in this case and they will never prove murder. Too many other factors caused Mr Floyds death.
@@audrafolkes5978.. Don’t mind the fool. People will know the truth and still believe a lie. I would like for someone to apply a pressure to their neck and let’s see what happened.
Oh... I bet the defense wasn’t happy to see this guy back as a rebuttal witness. Looks like a major mistake by the defense to introduce the whole CO gambit...lol
So Fowler's bizarre claim the CO was a factor in Floyd's death is totally refuted. The test showed it was 1.5%, which is normal. Although that was not allowed in, the fact is it could not have been over 2%, which is also normal. So no, he wasn't sucking on the tail pipe of the police car. Fowler was a total joke, a paid witness. Unlike Dr. Tobin - who was not paid. Fowler did not realize that the data that WAS available precluded what he postulated. Pretty basic stuff here. A high school biology student could have refuted Fowler on this point.
@@TexboyGamer The blood gas test was after he got to the hospital and was being resuscitated. Oxygen levels go up instantly. CO levels take an hour or two to go down.
spotless???? im not even in the camp of the defense and I can clearly see that the prosecution is horribly unprepared... there are so many holes in their case... thats why they were trying to go for the mistrial by ignoring the judges direct orders NOT to speak on this new evidence.... they want the mistrial so they can come back better prepared next time... The prosecution hasnt proved anything beyond a reasonable doubt... no where near. The put a whole bunch of hypotheticals and their witnesses have all be contradicting eachother... I think the dude is going to walk on a hung jury.
@@redeyespyone Tobin a world renown expert in his field. Just proved that what Fowler testified to........was basically a lie. I’m white and 60 years old. Am sick to death of any form of racism/discrimination. All my life nothing has really changed. We ALL start off the same (conceived) and end up the same way (dead). We should all get treated the same and enjoy the same opportunities in life. It’s about time that started to happen. If someone does wrong. They should face the consequences. Coppers, politicians..........everybody and anybody. Chauvin is guilty in my mind (having watched this case daily. Through jury selection and the trial). I sincerely hope that he gets what he deserves (In my opinion a long jail term that will wreck his life). This racism shite is evil and there needs to be a change. Banging Chauvin up............(same for the other three involved in his arrest/death). Will hopefully be the start. It’s up to the 12 jurors now and I hope that they do the ‘right’ thing. Stay safe, stay healthy........to you and yours.
Dr. Tobin right from the beginning showed how he knows his stuff and I wish you was my dad because I bet you I would be way farther in life than what I am now he is so intelligent you rock dr. Tobin best in the West
It is so horrible to see George Floyd being killed by cops kneeling on him until he dies without remorse, very inhuman punishment! Justice for George Floyd!
From what I see in comments I think people forget that when you’re in custody of officers your well-being is their responsibility. If you’re high on drugs and can’t breathe it’s their responsibility to get you medical care and perform any first aid needed. Kneeling on your neck and restricting airflow doesn’t follow those rules. Hence the sentences given.
The problem is that he was not kneeling on his neck. The autopsy showed no damage to his neck. They showed another view and it was on his shoulder. Also, he was saying he could not breath before he got into the vehicle.
This is getting embarrassing for the defense, but I wouldn’t have any doubts of him walking. Cops are immune to most repercussions in America, you do see them once in a blue moon, I’m not saying you NEVER see a cop held accountable. But it seems in this day and age that it rarely happens.
@@SliceofBread123 unfortunately, although I think Chauvin is guilty - that’s just my opinion, people are all entitled to their own opinions. I believe we are still a long way away from accountability being a normal thing.
@@DaRealBigRif the fact that people think, “if you can talk you can breathe” is hilarious and shows how uneducated they are - take a moment to look up Kyle Plush and how he died, how the 911 operator botched calls and how he was on the phone via Siri and clearly talking while slowly suffocating due to the tragic situation he found himself in that day. No disrespect to Kyle’s family, either. I just think his case is solid evidence that you can suffocate via limited inspiration. Also, John Jones’ death can be a counter argument as to him dying via blood to his brain from an upside down position, as John lived for several hours upside down and Kyle died with an hour, or so. (Which proves it was asphyxiation due to the chest being compressed and a limited amount of oxygen being able to reach his lungs). Rip to John Jones, too. And my condolences to his family as well.
GENIUS! using this dr. Tobin for there Rebuttal. He was awesome in this trial. I keep coming back just to listen to this Brilliant man. I learned alot from his testimony. 👍💗
Did you check what he said against the body cam. Like him saying that the officer was pushing on the handcuffs when you can clearly seeing him pulling the handcuffs?
That's pathetic considering you probably don't know anything about him. He could be a horrible human being or... A... Racist!! He is white. It's ok, some people don't need much evidence of people's characters in order to worship them. Of course this is tongue in cheek, but so true for some. Looking for one thing, no matter what the cost.
Putting pressure on someone neck causes pain and restricts breathing. What is so hard about that. The neck is sensitive, and can be damaged with putting pressure on it.
whats hard about that is the fact that its not true. putting pressure on the back or side of the neck doesnt restrict breathing, thats why cops do it every fucking day all around the world. i understand why you and people like you would feel that way, especially after watching the video, but the media knew better and they lied to you on purpose.
@@missrubyred1515 you can believe what you want to believe, but this is a commonly used police restraint hold, listed in the milwaukee police departments officer training hand book as a CONSCIOUS hold, as opposed to an UNCONSCIOUS hold, like a choke hold, which believe it or not they are also allowed to use in some circumstances. the reason this went to court is because the media turned it into a race issue.
They’re doing everything in their power to try to say this man is not guilty BUT HE IS!!!! This is why the judge is threatening to consider it a mistrial because now they’re just doing the most! NO the exhaust from the vehicle didn’t kill him. Like come on now …
I would love to hear Dr. Tobin in a medical lecture!
He’s incredibly gifted 💜
Me too! Such a gentle humble man! Would love to meet him and I could listen to his accent all day everyday!
Totally agree with you
@Dillird Q Thurman what did he lie about?
Gifted at what?? Are you a patient of his??
I was thinking the same thing..seems like a master class worthy discussion...actually interesting
Must be his years of experience combined with extraordinary intelligence, honesty and decency to be so patient and humble in his explanation that even a layperson like myself could understand.
I actually taped him as I couldn't see it all day.
It was very educational to listen to him. And yes, he is so spoken and articulate.
Lord, I hope there are more like him out there.
I totally agree. He is just brilliant and explains it so the jury will understand and layperson like me as well can understand.
Amen
Not so fast. Dr. Langenfeld, the ER doctor, said the blood gas level was tested and showed a Carbon DIOXIDE level at 100%. NOT an oxygen level at 98%. So one of these doctors is either lying or totally incompetent. And how did the prosecution not notice this huge contradiction?
There is a huge discrepancy in Dr Tobin's testimony. Here is a another direct quote from him in the testimony: “Chauvin kept his knee on Floyd’s neck for 3 minutes, 2 seconds, after Floyd took his last breath, Tobin said. After that last breath, Floyd’s oxygen levels went down to zero and Floyd “reached the point where there was not one ounce of oxygen left in the body,” In other words, Floyd had been dead at least 3 minutes and 2 sends before they took him away in the ambulance. With the lungs not working and the heart stopped, how could the oxygen saturation go up to 98%? To re-oxygenate blood from 0% to 98% is impossible without the lungs working and the heart pumping blood through the lungs. Some have said that CPR in the ambulance is the reason. While it's easy to charge the lungs with breathing-like action, without great heart action pumping blood through the lungs, it can't recharge the hemoglobin with oxygen. Yes, CPR moves a some amount of blood through the lungs, it's not like normal heart action. Not enough to recharge a dead man's hemoglobin up to an extremely healthy level of 98%. I've been in the hospital many times with non-respiratory issues, and sometimes had oxygen saturations lower than 98%. This dog just doesn't hunt.
@@noob3dprinter Yes that's right. Someone cleared this up for me. Landenfeld did say his carbon dioxide level was 100, not 100%. Also, this was a different blood draw from the one Dr. Tobin was referring to, but the testimony didn't make that clear. It got very confusing, especially when the prosecution brought him back for rebuttal.
But none of it matters now, the jurors apparently had their minds made up for them all along by public pressure. Chauvin got over charged in this case and over convicted.
Dr. Tobin is absolutely amazing. I feel like he is kind and compassionate, extremely knowledgeable and so qualified yet exhibits such humbleness.
you forgot BIASED
@@wernerfoerster3666 lmao 😂 go cry somewhere else 🤡😂😂😆
@@Materialgirl_3
Wow, what a brilliant comment!
@@wernerfoerster3666 lol sour grapes, if the defense could contradict Dr Tobin why didn't they bring their own pulmonary specialist?
@@optoms1178
1. If you know anything about trials, ANY AND ALL expert witnesses can be contradicted. These people are testifying for their own gain (like Tobin did this for free to help him get clients in civil cases who pay $500 per hour).
2. As you could see, Chavin had a shoestring budget ... while the state spent millions ... unfair fight for sure.
3. There was no sour grapes about my comment. I pointed out Tobin was biased. He was.
This man is a dream expert. Soft spoken, intelligent, clear, detailed, and understandable.
He oozes reputability whereas the defense's witness was obviously hired to say exactly what he said. The jury will be able to discern that.
@@jmaguire2232 100% agree. You can hear a change in the tone of the voice and during cross examination
He "oozes" corruption. They were told prior to this he can not ask this question because they purposefully did this knowingly the defenses expert had already left the state. They are lucky its not a mistress. Besides, the protection has already been debunked and destroyed. False and cherry picked edited questions and clips. This isn't a trial, it's an embarrassment to the justice system.
@@christophervincent8420 Corruption, huh? Seemed like a pretty solid medical take to me. I think you just don't like what he has to say and feel that George Floyd's killing was justified. Also any potential corruption in a case like this would favor the killer cop and not the victim so that's a ridiculous statement you made. Just admit you think it was ok for George Floyd to be executed.
@@jmaguire2232 guess you only pay attention to the "prosecution" and refuse to hear the the rest of the people talking. Baaaa baaaa sheep.like a good little boy
Dr Tobin you are absolutely the most honest, open, and intelligent witness in this entire trial. It was a pleasure to learn from you. 😘 RIP George Floyd 🕊🕊🕊♥️
Rip
100% true. He explained in such details. 46 years of experience, who would dare to challenge his knowledge!
That man is loved in Ireland... he is at home answering the twisted questions...A great knowledge,a fine man.
@adrienne balboa Go play somewhere else! 🛑
Amazing Dr. but he was not the only honest one person to have spoken so good!
I could listen to him talk all day , what a revelation , at last a witness who knows his business .
If he is a medicine professor I too want to study medicine and listen to his lectures all day long
He is a good doctor.
@@mayito9100 medicine is interesting, and it never hurts to have a basic understanding. Coukd save yoyr life someday. Or yoyr loved ones.
Irish man, go on ireland
Me too, when I need something to put me to sleep. His entire testimony was completely irrelevant.
He’s wonderful at explaining things in layman’s terms, excellent witness
@Eric Crapton he just knows his shit!
@Eric Crapton he did not accept payment.
@Eric Crapton throwaway, nice
@Eric Crapton you are wrong, Dr. Tobin refused any payment
And he’s calm cool and collective. Must be from Canada we r laid back also here
Dr Tobin is in an Absolute different league to this whole court absolute class
He's the Michael Jordan of pulmonology
@An Capall Mór i do not think that word means what you think it means
I would love him to be my doctor
Let’s ignore the fact he’s probably caused a mistrial
Best witness in the entire case by an absolute mile.
What a legend is Tobin, just shy of 70, and still a frontline doctor in the ICU, Nelson couldn't mess him about.
Um Nelson probably has an IQ around 120 to 150.......I think you are mistaken. Im no advocate for him, but he is extremely smart. He accomplished every single legal proof he was able to in this circumstance.
He's a paid liar. Dr. Langenfeld, the ER doctor, said the blood gas level was tested and showed a Carbon DIOXIDE level at 100. NOT an oxygen level at 98%. So one of these doctors is either lying or totally incompetent. And how did the prosecution not notice this huge contradiction?
@@wtaleteller9248 He may or may not, but he knows his clients is guilty, and is tried, unsuccessfully, to manipulate scientific facts, he embarrassed himself and his client.
@@jonnyarmstrong6563 Nope nope nope. Nelson thinks Chauvin is innocent of wrong doing. If you can't see that then you need to learn more about people.
@@wtaleteller9248 Which is it? Nelson thinks Chauvin is not guilty or he has a high IQ? It's obvious Chauvin is guilty.
Dr. Tobin! Is inspiring people to study! Listen to this guy I have no clue of anything on his field of study.. And yet he's explaining it in a way so digestible.
I remember this from 7th grade
You're right about one thing, you really don't have a clue.
Oprah should interview ‘Dr Tobin.
I’m so in love with this Dr
Me and you both, I said in an earlier post I could listen to him talk all day
Me too I was before u thou ☺️😂😂
I'm in love with George Floyd. Such an upstanding citizen
He's definitely a star!!!
So likeable lucky staff who work with him daily.
Typical Irish man :)
Dr Tobin, you are brilliant & knowledgeable Pulmonologist. Everything you said even from the previous hearing was all based on Medical Science.
💯‼️‼️‼️🙏🏼
IM IN LOVE WITH THIS DOCTOR TOBIN, WE SHOULD HAVE MORE DOCTORS LIKE HIM WHO ARE HONEST , HAVE PASSION FOR THER PROFESSION- HELPING HIS PATIENTS , DEDICATING THEIR LIVES TO RESEARCH, IMPROVING THEIR KNOWLEDGE AND THE MOST IMPORTANT SHARING THAT KNOWLEDGE WITH OTHERS.
Deported.
I completely agree! I legitimately learned quite a bit from him! I REALLY like the way he teaches and explains what he is saying and why...
Didn't you hear his testimony? He testified that George Floyd's blood gas was 98 percent oxygen which is very normal for someone who is living and not asphyxiated. Meaning, his heart stopped for a different reason such as drug overdose. I hope you really do appreciate his dedication to truth and facts even when they don't align with your worldview.
Hes mine..he has a beautiful soul🤍🖤
@@joeking8789 he's welcome back to Ireland, go on Ireland 🇮🇪
Waoooooo just waooooooooo. This Dr. Tobin is really singing like a bird absolutely genius. Very well educating.
YASSSS!!!!
@An Capall Mór and you hate yourself.
@An Capall Mór I am white & love myself. I’m horrified at the police brutality we’re witnessing these days being perpetrated on citizens, mostly black men.
@@maryerichardson8302 no proof
@An Capall Mór idiot
He’s so freaking smart! I can just listen to him all day.
Prosecutor Blackman and Dr. Tobin pumonologist/ specialist did an excellent job clearing this up!!
Hello dear how are you doing?
On Yessssssssss absolutely
@@nmd298 Lol
Ummm BlackWELL not Blackman
@Jacqueline Meine *Prosecutor Blackwell. Yes, I AGREE💯
Dr. Tobin is a legend, its fascinating just listening to him.......long live Dr. Tobin
☘💚☘💚☘💚☘💚☘💚☘
😂🤦🏿♂️
Legend
@@Megan43210 💕🍀💕🍀💕🍀💕🍀💕
Chauvin thinks so too as he’s probably caused a mistrial
Dr. TOBIN IS NOT ONLY A GENIUS BUT VERY SKILLFUL IN HIS REBUTTAL. THE DEFENCE COULD NOT ENTRAP HIM. AG
He’s terrible 😂 biggest liar in the court
@@camodude4316 evidence??
@@camodude4316 racist sob
@@camodude4316 there's always the odd one. Shame on you!!
Its ok.. people will call him terrible and useless, simply because he's that good and and highly valued
Don't mess with Dr Tobin, he comes with the facts!! I love him!!
And his receipt for $25,000,000 for his testimony
@@mollybolton8425 He actually didn't receive payment for his testimony. He felt the case was of such importance he refused payment. If you had paid attention you would have seen this.
@@annawalsh8880 Unlike the defense witness who was fired and is under investigation. - How was he approved as a witness!
@@downstream0114 Which defense witness is under investigation.
@@jonnyarmstrong6563 Dr. Fowler from Maryland
If there was any way to clone Dr Tobin's intelligence with permission of God, I would.
intelligence abounds on our beautiful Island.
@Laika24102007 damn... wats wrong with u
I like the prosecutions pulmonary doctor he explains things so well. I can understand what he is talking about.
But he is completely wrong about ABG and carboxyhemoglobin.
@@williambowling8211 how so? He’s a pulmonologist - I’m going with him.
@@50toinfinityatleast Me also.................He is a world renown expert in his field
@@williambowling8211 you should have taken the stand instead of Dr, Tobin, you imposter!
Oxygen in hemoglobin at 98%. So his blood had plenty of oxygen?
The prosecutors have legit and qualified testimonies and the defense have paid crocks to lie.
Absolutely
98% oxygen saturation
hahahaha. keep telling yourself that. the prosecution gave the defense their case cause you do not even know what an argument is nor have any idea what a burden of proof is
You're insane.
Bro the entire 1st week of testimony was witnesses saying how they personally felt about the incident. How is that any better?
BOOM! Defense busted lying! Excellent job prosecution!
What's lying in court called......oh ya...perjury!
I know,right? What a great witness!
I loved all of the prosecution's doctors... This one did not come to play! You can't twist his words and Nelson tried!
♥ ♥ Way to Go DOC!! We love You
Tobin is the star of the show followed by Blackwell and Schleicher. Kudos to making logic great again!
Thank you Mr. Blackwell.
this doctor is a legend bruh
Yes he is.
Dude needs his own chapter in future books on civil rights.
I agree
Yes he is 🇮🇪 only the best from our Country
All Chauvin had to do was arrest the man, and bring him into custody. End of story.
All floyd had to do was go with him
@@stephenlaw9886 if it was one of your own you wouldn’t be saying that specially treating a humanbeen likes this and killing him there’s no excuses 🤔
Where is the logic here? If you resist then murder is ok? I mean yes he resisted to a point but what about after he was unconscious? That is the line between controlling a suspect and killing him, not to mention not allowing anyone to give him medical attention like the fire fighter. Guilty all day long.
@@saezrosario2730 so your telling me that you two were closely related?
@@saezrosario2730 He resisted arrest. Again. Shit happens.
Carbon monoxide fumes? I'm waiting for them to say he choked on an M&M next.
honestly wouldn't be surprised.
Sadly this doctor and the prosecution just admitted mr Floyd had 98% oxygen which proves he was not strangled or died of a lack of oxygen, this proves the defense was correct, mr Floyd died of a heart attack and the officer had nothing to do with his death.
With all stupid jokes like m&ms aside, the state prosecutor just proved beyond reasonable doubt the officer is innocent, I honestly can’t believe the prosecution was that fucking stupid.
@@funkmonkeyfun OMG UR RIGHT!!!!
@@funkmonkeyfun okay UA-cam Doctor! Thanks for your medical opinion, you've solved everything. 🙄
@@monica62888 no problem because apparently I have more common sense then you which is why you resort to sarcasm as a rebuttal, if you had a lick of common sense I’m sure you can prove me wrong.... please take you time I’ll wait.... no... can’t provide facts to prove me wrong? Then go be a idiot someone else.
God bless you, Dr. Tobin. You helped put this monster away!
I would love to attend any medical conferences that Dr Tobin is speaking at . I would absolutely LOVE to learn from him!
Our Irish brother Martin Tobin made bits of that dirty cop and his fake witness ,god bless him for telling the truth and being excellent in relation to the way he expressed it to the jury in simple terms
@big andy lol don't worry you haven't solved the case in relation to Oxygen in his blood and dying from asphyxia , Believe me this was common knowledge to all the experts that had received a copy of the blood tests and and had months to prepare ,if it had been some kind of ureka moment they would have brought it up ,iam sure there was a reason why they didn't ,that's why they are experts in their field ,try CPR and recieving oxygen ,but could not get the heart started again because the brain had been starved for too long and no electrical pulse for the heart but was still being artificially pumped
@big andy yes he was a late addition ? but the judge wouldn't allow the new evidence because the defence hadn't had time to prepare ,that's what would have caused a mistrial ,he just went over blood oxygen levels to rule out carbon monoxide being a cause of death ,as far as the blood oxygen levels were concerned they had known that information for months it wasn't anything new ,he just stated because of the high oxygen levels carbon monoxide was not a factor in his death and the jury had a right to know that information obviously or the judge wouldn't have allowed it
GOD BLESS, doctor Tobin. He won't have Mr Floyd Blood on his hand. 🙏🙏🙏
They should use this in law schools to show what an ideal expert witness should be like.
Knowledgeable without being pretentious, puts things in layman’s terms and is absolutely self-assured about what happened and not wavering for even a moment when pressed.
🤣🤣🤣 yep, use a witness like this to fool the dim
He nearly caused a mistrial. Yeah he's definitely a bad example.
@@duanelocke5892 no he did not.
@@laurafedora5385 Sounds like you just described someone with a god complex. Not very scientific because with true science, there must always be some doubt. To be without any doubt is to be a god which this doctor certainly is not.
Even here in Mars, we do acknowledge Dr Tobin is simply a genius!! Thank you Dr Tobin. RIP George Floyd!
Lol so Zimbabwe is called Mars now??
Hello Mars dweller.👋🏾
@@optoms1178 i have no idea why you think "here" means Zimbabwe in this instance? i can see you misunderstood the point, it aint about location lol.
@@rosalynw.otieno1994 lol, how you doing?
This Doctor is so awesome
Dr Tobin need his own medical show! I would definitely watch it!!
Also respect to Jerry Blackwell, he is a superstar in this as well. Super intelligent charming man who knows how to bring the best out of people. Yeah I love him too! ❤
I'm with you! It's been a pleasure watching him. He did a wonderful, wonderful job.
@CrazyMikey4Life Troll
I love Jerry Blackwell too !
@CrazyMikey4Life 😂😂😂😂 you have only god to answer to for that
Defense Nelson tried his best to get a mistrial Smh But it did not work.
The defense opened the door to blood gases when they mentioned carbon monoxide. The nurse on the jury will already know about blood gases and can infer from Dr. Tobin's testimony it wasn't high without the actual lab results.
I'm happy it didn't work
@Binova Gurung youre spot on.... good thing the judge didnt mistrial this..
Actually it was the prosecution who almost caused a mistrial, the judge clearly warned the prosecution. Prosecution is corrupt.
@Binova Gurung the prosecution was hiding evidence away.... the defense asked for the tests 2 months ago.... just the usual shady prosecution ways....
Great testimony from Dr.Tobin! He is definitely an expert in his field! Chauvin doesnt have a chance in hell to get off without jail time! Chauvin it’s time to pay up for your cruelty and disregard for human life!
Yes
Yes I definitely agree with you 💯%, he should be ashamed of himself and the entire police department he represents!!
Dr.Tobin is like the Sherlock Holmes of the mystery of the inner body workings. His voice is smooth and calming. When someone respeates a correct answer in their own way. He's like "Percisley"
With his lovely accent 😍
Dr tobin should have his own show love this guy very intelligent
Dr. Tobin is going to be a SUPERSTAR after this trial is over!!🔥🔥
He's like that one teacher that you actually look forward to taking his classes
Hell yeah! 😂🔥
Yessssssss
He was debunked and made to be a biased fool
@@christophervincent8420You need to stop SMH....
Studied breathing for 46 years.... wow!!! SME for real and he is so poised, intellectually sound and methodical....
He's a bluffer !!! Plz read my other comments
@@biloz2988 no thanks
When I comment.... it is always according to exactly what I am seeing and hearing.... with full understanding that I don't know any of these people..... nor the whole story....
I was speaking to what was said about what he's done for the amount of years and listening to him speak and explain....
@bilo Z.... thanks but, I'm cool on seeking out all your other comments for a You Tube WHO'S RIGHT WHO'S WRONG back and forth....
Again I commented about what was presented in this video....smh
@@strongtribe I realized that
Just a clarification for the journalist speaking on this video. The doctor is an internal medical specialist in pulmonology's Which consists of: The respiratory system; Which includes the lungs.
*my edit is... did some of you not hear that the police interceptor was actually a Hybrid yesterday?
Tobin is a true expert witness. He doesn't care about being compensated. The man is basically a scientist, he knows what he knows and you're not going to be able to twist him up or make him change his mind. He is giving facts as he knows them. All expert witnesses- for either side should be like this.
I guess you are not a medical expert. Dr Tobin testimony was full of mambojambo. There are a lot of studies made about positional asphyxia and this guy denies them all. And his calculations about the force Chauvin used in knee pressing is total garbage. It cant be calculated. I understand why state called him, they didnt like medical examiners testimonies. This guy is not qualified for speculate a cause of death or elements around it. I must admit he was a good speaker, especially about bull shit.
The fact he doesn't want money makes him seem more politically motivated to me.
@@Raimond799 Interesting that the defense couldn't find a single expert witness to can confirm with what you're saying.
I'm surprised they didn't hire a blue collar guy like yourself to refute medical science.
@@rydude6723 They didnt need to do it. Dr Baker testimony alone made a reasonable doubt in this case and he was a state witness.
@Ari Douglas i think there's something locked on your keyboard...
I really enjoy listening to Dr Tobin's explanations....so clear...
Speak to the nurse and chemist on the jury. They will know about blood gases without them being introduced. Why did the defense open the door to blood gases but, not present the results to prove their point? They will wonder.
For a hung jury
They will wonder why the prosecuter left it out
@@lancethumel9277 they also left out the possibility of a bee sting. Didn't you see the bee buzzing around.
@E walker The defence was not provided with the blood gases report before. Hence they asked it to be excluded out of the prosecutor testimony today... But the judge did allow to include the oxigen saturation levels taken during the EMR which was fair enough
I know Right Maybe This Could Help Chauvin In An Appeal
"If the knee fit, you must convict!"
@Brad Lincoln And three guilty verdicts, gonna have to learn to deal with that too :)
@Brad Lincoln how butt hurt are you now...!?? Dummy
@Brad Lincoln pls watch the entire trial then come back and make a conclusion
I literally could take every class Dr. Tobin teaches. I needed this type of teaching in college. 🙌🏽
8th grade science. Good luck
The killer cop is guilty!
& he will be sentenced for life I pray to god!
I love Dr Tobin ❤❤❤
Woah!
Calm down chick. 🙂
@@UberSynth lol 😍😍😍
The defense might as well say air pollution killed George Floyd 😂😂 chauvin is about to have nice bed in prison!!!
And also a bird was flying by and the feathers blew into his airway.Derek was trying to keep the bird away.That so called ex officer is a cruel sadistic demon.God sees and knows everything.His day is coming.Galatians 6vs9
And I don't even think he'll really sleep well at night - well, no miracle.. after what he did.
@Doogie rj That's 98% when he arrived at ER, which is after the paramedics performed CPR, which typically results in a rise in oxygen saturation levels to 94-98%. All that is proof of is that the paramedics performed CPR.
This study (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6072928/) states an ‘...SaO2 (oxygen saturation) between 94-98% is a dedicated treatment goal in current guidelines’. Meaning doctors aim for 94-98% oxygen after a cardiac arrest, during CPR.
I know its easy to see +90% oxygen and think "We breathe oxygen, that means he was breathing" but that's simply not the case.
Jerry blackwell is not being paid for his services "pro bono basis". He wants justice for FLOYD. Amazing how GOD uses ppl without allowing them to accept money.. blessing to lawyer Jerry blackwell ✊🏿
@CrazyMikey4Life one the stupidest comment I've ever seen.. this doesn't mean put your knee on his neck while he's begging for help.. you seen in the video that he was no resisting arrest. He didn't want to be in the back of the seat. . He asked them to put him in the front. So don't come at me with this bull shit.. when we comply it's still a death sentence.. , example>>Philando Castile, a 32-year-old African shot by police in his car should I go on and on? 🤔🤔
I can listen to Dr. Tobin all day and understand what he’s actually talking about long live Dr Tobin
He's lying. Dr. Langenfeld, the ER doctor, said the blood gas level was tested and showed a Carbon DIOXIDE level at 100%. NOT an oxygen level at 98%. So one of these doctors is either lying or totally incompetent.
Legend has it that Dr. Tobin’s beard has master’s degree
Dr Tobin is the real hero here. Hope his testimony wiped the smirk off this villain Chauvin's face.
@@Alwaysindys Sarcasm is the lowest form of wit unless it comes out of an intelligent person's mouth. Your comment fell flat.
Dr Tobin makes me want to get my notebook out and start taking notes...completely unbiased just straight facts. Thank you DR TOBIN!!!! 🙏🏾
Everything is based of some level of bias
A: He offered his expertise for free, so unbiased he is not.
B: Make sure your notes contain the fact ThatcHer Tobin nearly caused a mistrial.
I liked him as well!
Can you imagine having this man as your doctor!!?
@@ytsm bs Tobin didn't charge a fee for one reason ,so nobody could claim he was being paid off by any side ,and tell us how he nearly caused a mix trial ? ,,it was claimed before he took the stand that the new evidence would cause a mistrial if he has mentioned it , obviously he didn't bring in the new evidence ,at the very least know what is actually going on
Dr Tobin won't say what you want him to say Mr Nelson 😅
As much credit is due to Dr Tobin, great job by the prosecution on preparing him for the cross examination.
I think the jury will see this so far I haven’t seen 1 good witness for defence the one I thought had a say has just been outed for not telling the truth
@@caroleallen888 true...the defense team is crushed
@@caroleallen888 I concur
@@veezienhamoruhwande99 I concur
Bless Dr Tobin. Behind his calm, poised exterior you could sense his anger at the blatant lies from Dr Fowler. I can't help but feel the prosecution should have had Dr Tobin deliver his testimony near the end, so it was fresher in the minds of the jurors. Also, did anyone see Chauvin leaning over looking at Mr Nelson's notes? I'm sure that's not appropriate behaviour for a defendant, he's acting like he's Mr Nelson's colleague or something. He should be in orange and in handcuffs!
What a great Doctor.
May god give him paradise and guide him to the straight path he has a good heart😍
I just hope those jurors will ask their friends to put a knee on their neck for just few seconds to get the decisions that they need!
Remember its "neck area" now since it has been shown to be his back in videos with a clearer angle.
@@M3NDVX because floyd was moving trying to breathe, their position would change but by the time he died his knee was definitely on his neck
You know. I was thinking the same thing. Like let’s do a live demonstration right and have people come in and have a knee placed on their neck and have two others hold you down behind a supposed car that’s on for almost 10 minutes. All jurors must participate. I wonder HOW this would play out.
@@mr.duanesharpe Steven crowder did it for the same amount of time and he has a heart condition also. Not saying it's definitive, but if you want an example
Unsurprising that someone with your name is dumb enough to make that suggestion thinking it would help the prosecution's case.
Blackwell + Tobin = Dream Team
Judge: Prosecution cannot mention Carboxyhaemoglobin blood test results, or else this is a mistrial
Dr Tobin: And I took that personally
They’re now asking for test to be allowed as newly discovered evidence! I didn’t get to hear if the judge said yes or no, just the request and rebuttal.
@@clairepaterson2374
It wasn't newly discovered, the defense asked for these test results 2 months ago and the prosecution claimed none were ever done. But now they mysteriously appear, and the judge even said it's shady and not allowed. The judge stopped short of calling the prosecution dirty scumbags.
@@clairepaterson2374 the prosecution was hiding evidence.... it wasn’t new evidence or new tests...they just committed a federal felony....
Lmao
Literally starts to testify about it....😂
@@camodude4316 he clearly told the judge both sides been had a copy
Even if Mr Floyd would not have died, it is still wrong to knee on someones neck.
They need to teach this in Kindergarten and Police school.
@None of your business you understand there’s literally rules to subdue someone who is resisting, there’s rules to even subduing someone you think is on drugs and potentially a danger, and guess what it’s not just kill them, you are clearly a very sad ignorant man who has no idea what they are talking about
@None of your business u should move to Brazil or something since u think the cops should do whatever they want when they catch a criminal I guess lol America’s the best cuz we’re not barbaric. Doesn’t matter if a criminal doesn’t present a deadly threat u can’t kill him
@None of your business the point that they are making is perception is often reality for people. If Chauven would have left his ego and pride at home the world would’ve possibly seen an overdose. Because he wanted to play billy bad ass he’s in the position he’s in now. Not sure if you’d be as quick to point these things out if it was someone close to you that received the officers sense of justice. 🤷🏾♂️
@None of your business blimey you talk some rubbish. Floyd did not die of an overdose they already proved that! Keep up
@None of your business lmao
Gwan Kilkenny...doing Ireland proud 🇮🇪🇮🇪😊
Absolutely.
I second that ,god bless that doctor
he sounds Danish to me ...
@@robrandolph9463 No, he sounds Irish. Educated there and then earned a British Thoracic Association Fellowship at King's College, London under Philip Hugh-Jones, a pioneering lung and diabetes researcher.His credentials are impeccable.
@@robrandolph9463 he's from co Kilkenny Ireland started his medical education in Dublin university
I love this Dr, so calm, professional and straight to the point... The defense team is crushed...We are waiting for the verdict...
No justice
No peace
You are gross
@@joeking8789 No Justiiiiiice No Peace.
@@ouubet What does that even mean
@@joeking8789 Meaning??
@@veezienhamoruhwande99 No Justice No peace? You burn down innocent peoples shit cause you dont get your way?
Dr Toblin make me feel like I want to become a doctor, he explains technical things in such simple ways, he is by far the most influential person in this case
Oh Dr Tobin, such a beautiful soul🤍🖤
Nelson and Chauvin are INSTANTLY worried the minute they hear Dr Tobin's name. During the delay before he takes the stand watch their body language, Nelson continuously adjusts his glasses, fiddles with his mask, his hands are fidgeting. Chauvin struggles to keep his fingers from drumming the table and his eyes dart nervously around the room. It's so different from their arrogant, impassive demeanour the rest of the time. They're rattled. Gooo onnnnn Dr Tobin!
@CrazyMikey4Life I love watching people squirm. Like Nelson and Chauvin here.
@CrazyMikey4Life Find me a foetus that can run and I'll tell you.
Maybe it could have had to do with this fake ass testimony with evidence that wasn’t disclosed to the defense
@@johnfunderburk1128 glad you agree they look worried.
@@speakertreatz good, you agree a mistrial should have been ruled (as the judge stated).
Team Tobin 💪
He’s from Ireland 🇮🇪 respect to this dr 👍🏽
@@haniya_5600
✌
@@haniya_5600 ☘💚☘💚☘💚☘💚☘👍👍👍👍
Do everything you can to never ever end up in a court room. It is a circus.
Dr.Tobin is the real deal.
I truly love this man I could listen to him all day long.
The defense is dirty to bring this up at the last moment after all their other theories have been Factually disproven.
Dr Tobin disproves this as well♥️.
I hate to tell you this is a last minute dirty trick by the prosecution. They knew what the defenses legitimate medical pathologist was going to say from his report months ago. They had plenty of time to rebut it. They did nothing then try to slip in their expert to deny it and why at the last minute. Pay attention. The prosecution has 100% of the burden to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. If they miss something, it cannot be brought in at a disadvantage to the defence without adequate chance for them to bring back their expert. Easy? Yes, it's the law. Nice try though.
@@julesmisty dirty trick?? The Carbon Monoxide had nothing to do with the defense trying to persuade the jury. This defense is hilarious
The prosecution experts said that Floyd succumbed to a lack of oxygen while pinned to the ground yet a pulmonologist testifying for the prosecution said that records show Floyd’s body was saturated with 98 percent oxygen?
@@ryanb8719 his arterial blood was. That is proof that he didn't have an excess of carbon monoxide in his body/blood. The defense was trying to say the carbon monoxide from the tailpipe of the running car contributed to his death.
@@ryanb8719 yup !
I absolutely love Dr. Tobin!
I love Dr Tobin , he says it straight off the bat it's his word or nothing !!!!
I envy Dr Tobin's Students, he is such a great teacher... so simple and clear in his explanations.
If the USA would just train it's population in science instead of believes and entertainment, this trail would be shorter.
Says the dip$hit who can't differentiate between trail, and trial...🤣
And if the US would educate _its_ population on the Constitution and the law, then we wouldn't have a bunch of people already making up their minds about this _trial._
Dr Tobin was phenomenal, he nailed the defense! I was glued to the screen when he was testifying! Brilliant
The could have put Dr Suess up there ... that jury was convicting across the board no matter what
@@wernerfoerster3666 sour grapes... Lol
@@optoms1178
if you think Tobin was phenomenal and "brilliant", it just goes to illustrate how easy it is to dupe the general public.
This doctor is so intelligent..i wanna take notes..i learned so much about carbohemoglobin something something hyper pharynx something something..yes all of that
Put that monster way! He killed a man in cold blood by not letting him gasp for air for almost ten minutes! We don’t pay cops to kill subjects, cops job is to arrest subjects and bring them to jail.
It’s amazing to me that they play with our intelligence like we don’t know we can’t breathe if our neck was being sat on. And for nine minutes, nine!!!!...
That’s great but it wasn’t his neck and Chauvin moves his position several times during that time while George died from an OD and a bad heart made worse by the stressful situation.
@@JaggersLips R u kidding me. Did you hear the entire LIVE, OR were you LISTENING.. His death was initiated by that MURDERER, as if he had permission.. He didn’t give life. Therefore, he can’t take life.. #staywokeppl✌️
@@audrafolkes5978 sorry what ? I’ve watched the entire 14 days of court proceedings, the evidence is there for all to see. I watched with a neutral mindset, it only seems that people that are biased are only hearing what they want to. There is far too much doubt in this case and they will never prove murder. Too many other factors caused Mr Floyds death.
@@audrafolkes5978.. Don’t mind the fool. People will know the truth and still believe a lie. I would like for someone to apply a pressure to their neck and let’s see what happened.
@@JaggersLips How you feeling about it now?
Oh... I bet the defense wasn’t happy to see this guy back as a rebuttal witness. Looks like a major mistake by the defense to introduce the whole CO gambit...lol
@Doogie rj I'll stick with the actual doctors opinion - thanks
I would love to take all my studies with this doctor 👩⚕️
So Fowler's bizarre claim the CO was a factor in Floyd's death is totally refuted. The test showed it was 1.5%, which is normal. Although that was not allowed in, the fact is it could not have been over 2%, which is also normal. So no, he wasn't sucking on the tail pipe of the police car. Fowler was a total joke, a paid witness. Unlike Dr. Tobin - who was not paid. Fowler did not realize that the data that WAS available precluded what he postulated. Pretty basic stuff here. A high school biology student could have refuted Fowler on this point.
98% oxygen saturation. He could breathe
@@TexboyGamer The blood gas test was after he got to the hospital and was being resuscitated. Oxygen levels go up instantly. CO levels take an hour or two to go down.
I would love for Dr. Tobin to be my instructor! 😊
Long live Dr. Martin Tobin!
Prosecution's case: spotless
Dr. Tobin's testimony: priceless
spotless???? im not even in the camp of the defense and I can clearly see that the prosecution is horribly unprepared... there are so many holes in their case... thats why they were trying to go for the mistrial by ignoring the judges direct orders NOT to speak on this new evidence.... they want the mistrial so they can come back better prepared next time... The prosecution hasnt proved anything beyond a reasonable doubt... no where near. The put a whole bunch of hypotheticals and their witnesses have all be contradicting eachother... I think the dude is going to walk on a hung jury.
100% agree with you Red Eye
@@LockStoppageSandwich thank you, kindly.
@@ethanhughes2943 OK
@@redeyespyone Tobin a world renown expert in his field. Just proved that what Fowler testified to........was basically a lie. I’m white and 60 years old. Am sick to death of any form of racism/discrimination. All my life nothing has really changed. We ALL start off the same (conceived) and end up the same way (dead). We should all get treated the same and enjoy the same opportunities in life. It’s about time that started to happen. If someone does wrong. They should face the consequences. Coppers, politicians..........everybody and anybody. Chauvin is guilty in my mind (having watched this case daily. Through jury selection and the trial). I sincerely hope that he gets what he deserves (In my opinion a long jail term that will wreck his life). This racism shite is evil and there needs to be a change. Banging Chauvin up............(same for the other three involved in his arrest/death). Will hopefully be the start. It’s up to the 12 jurors now and I hope that they do the ‘right’ thing. Stay safe, stay healthy........to you and yours.
Dr. Tobin right from the beginning showed how he knows his stuff and I wish you was my dad because I bet you I would be way farther in life than what I am now he is so intelligent you rock dr. Tobin best in the West
Word
Agree
It is so horrible to see George Floyd being killed by cops kneeling on him until he dies without remorse, very inhuman punishment! Justice for George Floyd!
From what I see in comments I think people forget that when you’re in custody of officers your well-being is their responsibility. If you’re high on drugs and can’t breathe it’s their responsibility to get you medical care and perform any first aid needed. Kneeling on your neck and restricting airflow doesn’t follow those rules. Hence the sentences given.
The problem is that he was not kneeling on his neck. The autopsy showed no damage to his neck. They showed another view and it was on his shoulder. Also, he was saying he could not breath before he got into the vehicle.
This is getting embarrassing for the defense, but I wouldn’t have any doubts of him walking. Cops are immune to most repercussions in America, you do see them once in a blue moon, I’m not saying you NEVER see a cop held accountable. But it seems in this day and age that it rarely happens.
I’ve been saying that all along. Dr Tobin’s testimony was damning and he was clearly well prepared but I still think it’s 50/50 Chauvin walks.
@@SliceofBread123 unfortunately, although I think Chauvin is guilty - that’s just my opinion, people are all entitled to their own opinions. I believe we are still a long way away from accountability being a normal thing.
ua-cam.com/video/s3L5Lju2zCE/v-deo.html
@@DaRealBigRif the fact that people think, “if you can talk you can breathe” is hilarious and shows how uneducated they are - take a moment to look up Kyle Plush and how he died, how the 911 operator botched calls and how he was on the phone via Siri and clearly talking while slowly suffocating due to the tragic situation he found himself in that day.
No disrespect to Kyle’s family, either. I just think his case is solid evidence that you can suffocate via limited inspiration. Also, John Jones’ death can be a counter argument as to him dying via blood to his brain from an upside down position, as John lived for several hours upside down and Kyle died with an hour, or so. (Which proves it was asphyxiation due to the chest being compressed and a limited amount of oxygen being able to reach his lungs). Rip to John Jones, too. And my condolences to his family as well.
@@CapsFan Guilty of what......watching Floyd commit suicide
GENIUS! using this dr. Tobin for there Rebuttal. He was awesome in this trial. I keep coming back just to listen to this Brilliant man. I learned alot from his testimony. 👍💗
Did you check what he said against the body cam. Like him saying that the officer was pushing on the handcuffs when you can clearly seeing him pulling the handcuffs?
Dr. Martin Tobin, my hero.
That's pathetic considering you probably don't know anything about him. He could be a horrible human being or... A... Racist!! He is white. It's ok, some people don't need much evidence of people's characters in order to worship them. Of course this is tongue in cheek, but so true for some. Looking for one thing, no matter what the cost.
Doctor tobin doesn’t know anything he said u don’t die from fantanyl he should goggle Vacouver overdose 7000 people die from fentanyl in 5 years
This Dr is just another in a long line of attention seeking, virtue signalling, manipulative vultures.
Dr Tobin, you have done a great job in answering your question from the prosecutor it's was 💯truth.
Putting pressure on someone neck causes pain and restricts breathing. What is so hard about that. The neck is sensitive, and can be damaged with putting pressure on it.
whats hard about that is the fact that its not true. putting pressure on the back or side of the neck doesnt restrict breathing, thats why cops do it every fucking day all around the world. i understand why you and people like you would feel that way, especially after watching the video, but the media knew better and they lied to you on purpose.
@@AFHSpike so if Chauvin hadn't shown up George Floyd would have died as soon as he (George) tried to drive off in his car?
@@AFHSpike and yet here we are in court, because it happens every day. I don’t think so!
@@tapiwakay Yes he was overdosing on a combination of meth and fentanyl, the people in the car with him attested to that, as did his toxicology report
@@missrubyred1515 you can believe what you want to believe, but this is a commonly used police restraint hold, listed in the milwaukee police departments officer training hand book as a CONSCIOUS hold, as opposed to an UNCONSCIOUS hold, like a choke hold, which believe it or not they are also allowed to use in some circumstances. the reason this went to court is because the media turned it into a race issue.
Dr comes across as genuinely sincere, honest and knowledgeable. Great witness!
They’re doing everything in their power to try to say this man is not guilty BUT HE IS!!!! This is why the judge is threatening to consider it a mistrial because now they’re just doing the most! NO the exhaust from the vehicle didn’t kill him. Like come on now …
Dr tobin thank you so much love you 😘