Or any supervisors in the chain of command who were aware of this incident? This is yet another example of why police reform is needed. Body cams should be required for EVERY police dept in the country and any officer who shuts off their body cam while on an incident should be terminated no questions asked. In addition, every police dept should have a civilian oversight board who is required to review any arrest where an injury has occurred, including reviewing body cam footage.
Because the "buck stops at the top" no longer applies. One term, twice impeached Trump said it the loudest, "no I don't assume any responsibility" for anything negatively impacted by my incompetency.
Exactly.Even for shooting. There are situations where they put bystanders, and fellow officers in more danger than the criminal does. If it is justified and doesn’t put others in danger, they don’t need immunity. Same with physical injuries. They shouldn’t be using so much more force than the criminal that they end up with more than bruises or cuts, or accidental injuries from falling against something which the officer has no ability to control. They also should face at least monetary punishment for turning their cameras or audio off without being able to give clear evidence of malfunction which would be sustained and not coincidentally convenient for a small period of time. There also needs to be independent oversight above them so commanding officers or chiefs, or anyone related to law enforcement are not able to sweep it under the rug. The whole system, as it is, is a mess. Even unions fight for bad cops. I get the need for unions on the one hand, fighting for benefits…but on the other, no one is ensuring that the bad cops, or workers in any professions, don’t get to hold positions in the unions and work to cover their own butts and buddies.
In the state of Ohio, there is a separate charge for doing harm to golden agers that adds extra time to your sentence. So, why should cops be above that (laws are different from state to state)?
@@theodoreroberts3407 This one will be looked at very closely due to the Police Accountability Act in Colorado. I can not understand how one officer can stand by and do NOTHING but watch, while another police officer misbehaves. Same as the other three officers in the George Floyd case. I support our Police 100% BUT I do not support 100% of the officers that get hired.
@@rosegeaber7533 its not a generalization its the truth. Good cops either quit because they are expected to protect psycho bullies or they succumb to the culture and comply.
@@dannymayo3236 No Sir, that is not the case. They may be few, and they may be a minority in the system, but they do exist. You are making a blanket statement that is comparable to saying that everyone of a certain race are evil. That is what gets us all in trouble. Remember we are all different and absolutely yes, police reform needs to happen on a grand scale! And ASAP! Take care.
@@BrokefishN More, or less in their policy. They love to sometimes yell out to you, I'm just following policy. Which we all know, Policy is not Law. The Policy stays the same, due to the victim takes the money the city offers without Trial. In most cases the city sets the terms to which you take the money. They admit to no fault, but find the persons behavior in bad taste. Trial = policy change for sure.
exACTly!!! as they beLIEve their brethren are all as they are crEATures from CAIN's roots$ who LIE LIE and LIE to cover up their demon side on the 'left'.. Look at the last sUPper TABle.. who wears green RObEs on the left SHOULDer and BLUE on the RIGHT is GOoD's ear to jOHn. who is the 1st plACe SETting ..... is just-*ICE* that melts under *FIRE* = makes sTEAM work!!! Fire the TOP down in uniFORM as they are the LEAderS w/o the H = transMISSION ...H = the 8th # = GOoD and the 8th plACe SETting is for MATtHew = wet math is the 1st and the last science of for and by the GOoD of the REPublic... the GOoD reps of We the People = JUST-US 'served' on *ICE* lol.
Nah, they're prefect..they have a hard job...if all that woman did was not resist....she shoulda made better choices.....the police officers will be exonerated....🤦🏿
I try not to knowing from personal experience it gets far worse when money is involved. The police in Hawaii tried to kill my girlfriend in 1994 after she was hit by a drunk driver by taking her to the wrong hospital that doesn't do major surgery and providing misinformation that put her in observation. They also filled out a false police report so impossible her medical records listed police corruption connected to her auto insurance was affecting her recovery. Then there's what happened on June 9, 2009 and what followed... this is the equation for the Fine Structure Constant: (e{a})/t=E and that's just a fancy way to spell busted. It's just a matter of time...
@@nettejohnson7492 Is your keyboard broken? WhAts wiTh alL the wIErd caPitalizaTION? Also are you high because that shit makes no sense. Funny as heck though.
@karen bevis Yes... and this is not the only video of the police turning off the cameras to beat a defenseless woman as officer Wiley Willis did to Angela Garbarino where almost half a million dollars in a payoff was used to silence what officer Willis did to her after turning off the camera and leaving Angela in a pool of her own blood. Officer Wiley Willis says she tripped and fell. Officer Willis who is white was fired but never charged for the felony crime of disfiguring Angela who is also white and I think it's important to point out the violent police culture in America once generally accepted and (mostly) applied to black Americans allowing this violent behavior is growing almost exponentially often unrelated to racial prejudice. Too many videos show police officers enjoy disfiguring women as it's not just an act of violence... it's a way some men enjoy having sex. This fact is seldom mentioned but expressing hate and rape go together as both past and current History shows. Some police enjoy "leaving their mark" on the faces of women they chose to hate and violently slam down on their face breaking teeth. In the case of Officer Wiley Willis after the show was over a year and half later with the News media no longer paying attention the Shreveport Municipal Fire and Police Civil Service Board voted to reinstate Officer Willis on the police force with full back pay and benefits for the year-and-a-half he was "fired" using a "technicality" which I believe due to being obvious was put in place by the police using forethought gained from past experience working with their attorneys. His discipline was just a fake show IMO created to deceive the American Public the police now regard as a threat out to get them as well as a piggy bank full of cash tax dollars filled up annually allowing the onslaught of violent criminal behavior to continue and therefore grow unrestrained. So here we are again years later hearing the police laugh at torturing a small mentally disabled 73 yr old woman who was being nice and no threat to them whatsoever. Time is exposing what happens when unrestrained blind hate put out by the police is allowed to continue by not only supporting police violence, but funding it as well as if pretending to put out a fire with water and then switching over to use gasoline.
Until those who allow this ie the chief, DA's, the city council, mayor and especially the police unions start to be impacted on personal levels, this behavior will only escalate. Loveland for instance, is a small town where it would be quite easy to bump into any of these assholes, start the purge!
@@SmittyAZ there is no excuse. This was a year ago. And as far as that goes he is negligent if he didn’t know the truth of his officers. It’s only when the public found out about this vicious mauling of this frail sick person who was obviously confused. This poor lady
@@buhdahto This is why a friend of mine who is an activist against cops tends to be lenient on female cops because he recognized that they are discriminated against and often are selected as Patsy's.
They are immune to laws. I like to refer to it as corruption. They are judging the publics ire to decide if anymore charges will apply. They may no longer work in Colorado if convicted. This means they will work elsewhere. Systemic issues.!! COPS love to change the narrative. She weighs 80lbs. This is not training please this is common sense. All Police need extensive psychological testing to ensure the right-wing authoritarian and social dominant orientation type personalities cannot work in LE. These are the rogue officers with abusive backgrounds, abused, bullied, and or the bullies. Often abuse animals, children, and women. The worst personality types for LE are 80-85% of LE. Law Enforcement specifically attracts these personality types that enjoy control and power over others. Nothing knew its been like this for hundreds maybe even thousands of years. Austin Hopp and Daria Jailia. are barley children who gave them this much power and authority to begin with?
We all watched them laughing at the violence they committed on an elderly woman with dementia then refusing her treatment after admitting to what they did makes them some of the worst cops out there. Around the same time this dept settled a suit for beating and charging another elderly person who was a witness for not wanting to talk to them. This chief needs to be fired.
As another commenter suggested start taking lawsuit payments out of the whole dept's pensions. Like the Army, maybe the others in the dept will start changing attitudes of their comrades if they all get penalized.
@@АнтонПреображенский-ю3и I don’t trust the Republicans either , and I are one . I did not understand how bad police were until all these video,s were posted online
Innocent until proven guilty. Charges are like throwing spaghetti against the wall and see which one sticks, or which ones they can try and plead out / get money for. I'm not saying anyone did anything wrong. Or that anyone did. Conviction without reasonable doubt is what makes this country great. Without it, everything falls apart. I'm not saying you have lost sight of that, but most people have. It's more about public opinion than fact. And if, what people hear or see on tv is taken as fact, we've come to a scary place as Americans. It's all fun and games, until it's you on the other end. And the long arm of the law, with endless resources, and prosecutors on salary, and you needing a pay lawyer...... We are all screwed.
I work at a popular retail store, I can't say the name (but you know) and a woman with dementia approached me the other day, obviously confused, I sought out the right care, spoke with her, remained calm, didn't accuse her of a crime or stealing, got her son (who was grateful) to come to pick her up, things don't have to be this way, it's the mindset of the police in this country. It is NOT a small minority, it is the MAJORITY in control of the system itself. No one had to train me to be a human being when dealing with someone like that. If you're a good person, it should be natural. The fact the officers acted the way they did speaks to two things, either you're training MAKES you a monster because the pound in your head, "everyone you run into is a criminal" or it attracts the kind of psychopathic people who lack that natural tendency. Either way, things have to be changed, and changed on a VERY high level.
Chief of Police needs to be fired and charged as well. How many of these cases have been swept under the rug? Chief of police needs to go he knew about this and did nothing.
The press conference by the chief was laughable where he had the gall to say this wasn’t the Loveland pd , this isn’t the Loveland pd even though the people who committed these crimes were in Loveland pd uniform and it turns out this isn’t an isolated incident by this dept Loveland ! I think they should change the towns name to Loveland as long as your a cop . Cops are never going to change because the problem is most people think this issue is a new issue but in truth the crimes LEOs commit has been happening for a very very long time and the high ups don’t care what crimes are committed as long as they can hush them up because their main goal is preserve the integrity of the polices image in the interests of self preservation . The corruption is real and anyone who thinks that this cooperation isn’t corrupt is in denial , the blue line backers usually have members of law enforcement in their families and won’t accept that they have a POS psycho in their family .
I live in Loveland and I know about 3 other cases similar to this one with officers trampling over the people who live in Loveland. And absolutely nothing being done about it. As a matter of fact my mother’s restaurant in downtown Loveland had its front window shot out by a random driver and Officer Austin Hopp was the one who was sent to the restaurant to investigate and months went by with nothing from the LPD or the officer who responded. Now I’m not saying every cop in Loveland is crap, there are some “good ones” but a lot are power hungry douchebags that forget the basics like reading you your rights before placing you under arrest.
Let's put it simply: You do not need any training to learn not to use aggressive force against an old confused woman. You need (evil) training to think using such force is OK.
The chief says he didn't know about this until a few days ago when the federal lawsuit was filed. How could he not know? The FOIA requests, the woman's defense attorney demanding discovery, the viral videos, the media asking questions? Gross incompetence or a failed coverup, either way, he needs to go.
@Ron K Hell yes he knew, this isn't the first rodeo for this police department, look them up, they have been doing the same sadistic crap for years and worse.
don't forget that the bystander (you can see/hear him on one of the body cam videos) who witnessed Garner's treatment by the road apparently filed a formal complaint..... who knows where that ended up. Obviously the "chief" didn't hear anything. Smells like a cover up to me (or gross incompetence/negligence at all levels). Only reason anyone is hearing about this now is because of the lawsuit. I guess that's too big to hide or ignore.
Yes I'm tired of hearing how dangerous there jobs are, the biggest threat to a police officer is there aactions of control over the person they are speaking too. And there attitude of showing there supposedly power over the people. It's not a few bad apples, it is the complete tree. You will never see me on the side of the road when the funeral passes of a fallen police officer. My thoughts will be was he one of the bad apples, and how many lives has been ruined.
This isn't a thing because it was video taped. It's a thing because we SAW the video tape. Police departments still have way too much control over how and when FOIA requests are processed. Over a year for this to come out? Gee, I wonder why.
When there is no Swift Justice, I repeat when there is no Swift Justice, to a Bad (Act or Deed) the heart ❤️ of people becomes embolden, to practice the bad (Acts & Deeds) that,there has been & still is (normally) on Swift Justice to.
They knew it was wrong but they didn’t think they would ever get caught. Most of the time they don’t. A lot of these cops are not mentally stable at all. They have severe control issues.
A year? They collaborated in writing their report, he stated he threw her to the ground several times and then spoke of “controlled manner” for report. So happy they’ve been fired and charged.
String them up in the center of the city & then let the poor lady they brutalized & humiliated, take swings at them with a Louisville slugger like they were pinatas! When she gets tired let her family & friends have a go! FTP
@@siamsamblue30041 ideally Iraqi's deserve to be treated with humane decency, but sure hammers can be used to tenderize meat, its not like these killers have souls.
A police captain once seen me speak at a youth event and he invited me to apply. I made a statement that policing is alot of social work, he disagreed said its more enforcement. Needless to say i didnt apply....
It was so awful seeing how far they pushed her arm up behind her back. It made me sick to my stomach when I saw it and you could almost see when her shoulder dislocated. They knew what they were doing, arms don't bend that way naturally unless you're double jointed or something. It was so blatant that you don't even need a trained professional to tell you that bending it the way they did would cause it to dislocate, anyone with an iota of common sense knows that arms aren't made to bend that way. Bless her heart
2 other officers should also be charged...the sergeant who was on scene and helped to hogtie her , and the idiot who watched the body cam video with these two and laughed it up. then there is the issue of the line of supervisors who saw no problem with the use of force. go get them all.
Disrespectful toward a senior citizen; you'd think to show compassion, what if it were your parent or family member? Injury inflicted and failure to disclose is in other words termed Liar/what is the world becoming? Tragic🤔
Won't happen unfortunately. Convicted cops never get put in gp. Corrections officers protect their own. & the corrections guards are the worst of them all.
What puzzled me in this case was the fact she didn't have any stolen items in her possession. The were taken by the store. I think she even tried to pay for them. There was no reason to even approach her when they saw she was only carrying dandlions.
The system of controlling the public is the problem. They do not serve. The police only want to hold power over the citizens. The courts support this violence, too.
10 Months? Why is the Mayor of Loveland Jackie Marsh, DA Gordon McLaughlin and the Police Chief Robert Ticer still in office? What else are they hiding?
The mayor, the DA and the governor also deserve to be sued because they have the power to do something about it, thereby a fiduciary duty, and have done nothing.
Very interesting story. I do believe the elderly woman who was arrested and hog tied by the police officer because she was “not listening” due to her dementia only weighed 80 pounds, however, not 120 pounds. She is extremely frail. Great story and thankful for this update.
@@briangriffith4574 she offered to pay. She had her debit card in her hand when she was thrown down. This story gets me upset Everytime I hear something about it
@@briangriffith4574 Right! And, in fact, she offered to pay by that time, as she did have that one credit card on her, but by that time, the store staff would not allow her. Perhaps because she was outside the store by then. But still??
And these two were having a romantic relationship at the time. Isn’t that just precious. Two cops abusing a 73 year old with dementia. Your parents must be so proud of the felons they raised.
Needs to be more than just those 2 held accountable and they knew they had hurt her shoulder and arm that is why they left her cuffed to intentionally cause her even more pain while they all laughed and joked
It is a shame what they did to that woman with no empathy ,and then laughing and fist bumping about it, they broke her arm.well they’re not laughing now.
What about the family for leaving Karen Garner all alone so she could wonder off? Shouldn’t they be charged as well and put in jail as well and they are still in charge of Karen Garner with no supervision as to how they are treating Mrs. Garner.
If these loose their police certification in CO and don't serve jail time, they'll still be hired in another state because they stick together protecting fellow brothers in blue.
Naw, put them in the national database so all 50 states will have the information. Any state or county who knowingly hires former corrupt cops. will answer to the government and be levied with heavy fines for each day that corrupt cop is on their payroll
That guy was a legend. He should be decorated for intervening in that situation. His testimony is so important too because it did indeed appear to him that the cops were roughing up a child. That's how disturbing that scene is.
And the attitude of the offending cop telling him that knowing she whole story from Wal-Mart and now he knows the whole story. The cop did not know the whole story. He could have followed her in his cop car , there was no threat with this lady.
Training won’t help. It’s the entire culture and who they hire. Until they hire a more educated, less aggressive, racist, sadistic type of person then nothing will change.
I love the mug shots, and I’m loving the consequences they are facing. Dude you guys are in there because you injured and scared the hell out of a 73 year old lady who weigh probably 80 pounds! Then you watch the video and laugh and think you did an amazing for our community!
It's honestly such a joke that the response to every case of police misconduct is "better training". Umm, how about accountability and justice instead?
@Stu Bonner I am not trained in the use of force and will never be involved with so-called "law-enforcement".. but from an early age i knew, in my gut, that little kids....the elderly and challenged people...animals..needed to be dealt with gently..! I was in the military for years and saw bad things happen in a dirty colonial war..BUT remember that elders, mothers, children were usually treated fairly...! The GESTAPO thugs are violent because they like violence and they love to inflict pain..! They did it to this 73 year old lady and will do the same...again and again. ! Jail time needed and probation for a long time after. !
I saw the video from the jail where they are watching the bodycam footage and laughing and making comments on their assault on this poor old lady. It was so disgusting 😡 they had no regrets for what they did to her. It's definitely a systemic problem, absolutely!!! These problems with police are not training issues, well it is a part of it but a small part, it's the one one training that they're getting from other bad cops after the academy.
Just imagine a few years ago when people had cameras, but didn't know how much difference it would make. I don't see a problem taking vids of police activities, if they're not doing what they should be, now it becomes a problem. Mr. DeMill, their ready for their close up.
@@Liitebulb I do. I lived through an amount of it. I have memory of events, I didn't read it in a book (which usually only reflect one or two aspects). Question: have you ever been to a fire before reporters arrive. Later, you watch the report and it looks and sounds like a different fire?
@@crispyblack8779 I have repeatedly edited in an attempt at getting past the UA-cam censorship algorithm to post a list of primarily *_black people murdered by white police._* If you care to see the list, click "Read more" as by adding text I have managed to put the list up. I have had great difficulty in doing so. It is far from complete, with the last name on the list being of special note. He was an innocent unarmed white 26-year-old husband and father of two little girls, clearly terrorized and senselessly murdered by police on camera. TYT has the only unedited version of the video that I know of. Racism is a huge factor in all this, but this deadly behavior goes far beyond racism. George Floyd And Andrew Brown Jr. And Daunte Wright And Ronald Greene And Philando Castille And Eric Garner And Shawn Bell, _(on his wedding day)_ And Anthony McClain And Ousmane Zongo And Amadou Diallo And LaQuan McDonald And Anthony Lamar Smith And Casey Goodson Jr. And Marvin Scott III And Freddie Gray And Terence Crutcher And Sandra Bland And Ronnell Foster And Willie McCoy And Michael Brown And Rayshard Brooks And Atatiana Jefferson And Davinian Darnell Willuams And Tony Terrell Robinson Jr. And Nimali Henry And Marcus Smith And Corey Jones And Tyrell Wilson And Botham Jean And Terence Walker And Alton Sterling And Walter Scott And Treyh Webster And Akai Gurley And Andre Hill And Breonna Taylor And Kurt Andras Reinhold And Ahmaud Arbery And Elijah McClain And Tamir Rice And John Crawford III And Eric Harris And Fred Hampton And Adam Toledo, _Latino_ And Mario Gonzales, _Latino_ And Christian Hall, _who was Asian._ And Christopher Roupe, white, age 17 And Eugene Mallory, white, age 80 _(machine gunned in his bed)_ And *Daniel Shaver,* _who was also white, unarmed and innocent._ _And more than we could ever count._ *_"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable."_* ~~ John F. Kennedy
The most damning evidence that this was a straight up assault is the video of them reviewing the body cam and laughing. The officer admitting he heard this poor elderly woman’s shoulder pop is truly disgraceful.
Wow wow wow, calm down there buddy. this is nothing some Training wont be able to fix. Always remember the popo are here to abuse and degrade...uhhh I mean serve and protect. Serve and Protect !!
The chief acts like he is a mushroom. Someone is keeping him in the dark, and feeding him bullshit. The whole command staff needs to go. That department is rotten from top to bottom and back to the top.
100 years in jail wouldn't be enough for what they did to that frail, disoriented woman. And then they laughed about it. Unbelievable, and unforgivable.
And before they assaulted her she was smiling with flowers in her hand it's so sad. To make it worse she didn't do anything wrong they said she shoplifted but she didn't . those demons were not smart enough to ask where the stuff they thought she stole was when she walking with nothing but flowers on her.
I don't know what they deserve but they certainly are the most hatable people. Charles Manson seems more likeable. Even the clutter murderers. No doubt they're worse criminals though.
Out of all the cases that have hit UA-cam in the last year or so this one sticks in the mind. It might be because my late mother had dementia but it’s more likely to be because they behaved in such an egregious way. I find the smirk on her face particularly irksome.
@@rjlchristie they are seen giggling and laughing while they review the body camera footage as if they were a couple of teenagers watching a 'pranking video'. So disgusting to watch.
Get rid of that entire shift, they were all laughing and fist pumping each other after they beat that lady. Give them all Jail time and let them enjoy some fist pumps behind bars!
Of course he knew about the injured shoulder. He was bragging about it on camera "Wait for the POP". He is nothing but a spineless coward. She is no better.
How disturbing. I can feel her pain bc I had a dislocated shoulder after neck surgery that went untreated and I still have pain in my shoulder. I’m glad he got prison time to think about what he did.
Get rid of qualified immunity, make lawsuits come out of the pension of the police. Also put these two away for a long damn time, disband that department and rebuild it from the ground up
My solution is that the city pays the officer a reasonable amount for liability insurance just like they do for uniforms, that amount is based on a new officer who has no claims. If the officer's insurance pays claims and their insurance rate goes up they eat the increase just like someone with a shit driving record has to deal with higher insurance premiums. Police abuse investigations should be done by an outside entity not tied to the police and the police union pays the cop's salary during this time while the cop sits on their ass. As we all know these investigations drag out forever and in most of them the cop collects full pay during that time. If the cop wins the city reimburses the police union, if the cop loses and then too bad for the union they can try to recover the money from the cop.
@@bruce2357 the tax payer shouldn’t pay for their insurance. They already make more then enough with their bloated overtime and let’s not forget all the benefits of cheap auto and home insurance because of being a civil employee. Or what about their amazing health insurance gifted to them. The cops pay for their own insurance to “protect them” when they royally screw up. How many other professions out there will let you resign after discovery of criminal conduct, yet there are no repercussions for the actions taken.
I agree... But Qualified Immunity is the backbone...the anchor stone...of the US Police and Prosecution at the local and State and Federal District levels. While SCOTUS will throw out a few bones for the public to cheer... It will NEVER seriously limit it.
This video also shows that it's not only poc that get treated bad by cops. Allot of them are just bullies. They have been under the impression that they can do whatever they want for a long time. Glad to see that they're starting to be held accountable
That is true. Not only POC but not all these people gave a damn when it was them. They had to deserve it. Disease spreads. Doesn't just stay with any set of people. If something had been done about this before, this case wouldn't have happened.
@@ydcee3123 so you think it used to be only poc who got treated that way by cops and now it's spread to white people? It's always been all colors. I'm 45 and white and I've had problems with cops most of my life. My son has had several bad encounters with cops too. It seems to be more of a " have/ have not" issue than a race issue.
Its "To Abuse and Degrade" that is the real motto of the Popo. Some new officers follow yours but to be part of the Blue Gang you need to follow the latter.
They were like two cats who caught a mouse, and would pick it up and drop it, then swatting it across the room , with pure joy on their faces, and why not they had the power of the State on their side, or so they thought.
@@cabinbills6743 Yeah. Amber Guyger got ten years for murdering Botham Jean in his own living room eating ice cream while watching tv. At the time she worried to her supervisor/married lover about possibly losing her job, not Jean's possible survival or her possible arrest. So, ten years was ten more than I expected. And the judge gave her (Amber) her (judge's) personal Bible.
Kathryn Geeslin what would the sentence have been if she wasn’t a cop ? Wonder how many of those personal bibles the judge has given to other murderers . That case got so much publicity judge had no choice kinda like the Chauvin case . How long did it take for her to file an appeal ?
Any "officer" who feels it is necessary to rough up an elderly person with dementia has NO BUSINESS being an "officer". Plain and simple. This is criminal behavior.
The love is gone out of Loveland those 2 aren’t fit to work with my dog the problem is what about the rest involved and the rest that new about it and the ones that covered it up. This is far from settled
And her family, why was she alone if her family knew she had dementia, should they not be held accountable as well? The family didn’t even care about Karen Garner until they realized they could get rich off of what happened, then they all of a sudden cared.
They thought they had gotten away with hurting a frail, helpless 73 year old lady, but the world has spoken! But, in jail they will pay for their crime!
The people in administration who's job it is to oversee these issues are a part of the bigger problem that the media is not talking about. They need to go up the ladder and expose these people and the amount of incidents they are mishandling.
As of May 2022, one year after this video was posted. The elderly Ms. Garner has been awarded a 3 Million dollar settlement. She suffered a broken arm and dislocated shoulder in the incident. The male cop was just sentenced to 5 years in prison and 3 years of parole for his egregious behavior. and attempt to cover up his personal malfeasance.
I'm glad both cops are facing the music especially for blatantly lying that she was not injured. As a resident of Colorado, I'm grateful this new law will be applied to this case.
Until Aurora CO cops who murdered Elijah McClain are INDICTED AND ARRESTED...I don't believe the white supremacists on Colorado police forces and other states will be purged out of the force .
Why is it that these police are arrested when they assaulted someone yet one of the police involved in the mcclain murder quit and is probably a cop in some other state or probably inglewood or littleton. So its racism. Why isnt the wokism hard left media talking?
So her crime was “not stealing something”. Her dementia led to her walking out of Walmart with some stuff, she was stopped, surprised she forgot, offered to pay. Walmart called the cops out of concern and said there was no crime. This thug cop told her to stop, she kept walking, he beat her up. Hope he goes to jail and gets a daily beat down himself. Serve and protect???
Cops are under no obligation to protect you this is already been ruled on by the United States supreme Court if you are under the impression they're here to protect you you're a dumbass
No. Her crime was stealing. She stole. They RECOVERED it. She was being arrested and charged with a criminal activity. She was combative, non compliant, and admitted she stole. This was not her first offense. She did not get beaten. She was fighting against restraining officers. They never struck her or use more force than necessary to arrest her. The only thug, is the old lady. Whether she had dementia or not, is irrelevant at the time of her arrest and not information the officer could have reasonably known. It’s the masses persecuting them for doing their jobs well.
@@stumpbumpers No, the Walmart manager told the police no crime was committed and called in that he was worried for her safety. The police had no right to stop her, no probable cause, she does not have to comply. They are fucking thugs and should go to jail, I’m sure they will. Let the courts decide. So if a cop comes up to you and wants to talk, you must? Maybe in the USSR. Not here. You should learn your rights.
What would be the penalty for shoplifting? A. "cite release" ( A ticket). Not a broken arm, or a dislocated shoulder. She was an old woman, a hundred and twenty pounds. Police have a hard job, and have to assert their control quickly. But common sense should have kicked in. There was no reason to manhandle her.
There needs to be a state hotline to turn behavior like this in! And a safe way for other LE to turn in this type of behavior. GOOD COPS DO NOT WANT TO WORK WITH COPS LIKE THIS! OPEN A HOTLINE COLORADO!
I'm almost 40 and I've rarely seen any police in public so much as following basic traffic laws. Majority drive like azzholes park in fire lanes for non emergency reasons, handicap parking you name it. I watched a state cop almost sideswipe the car next to him because he was looking at his phone on the freeway, I threw my hands up on my way by and he flipped me off.......
The video of the office with the cells feet away was by far worse. Them laughing and watching the body cams of the male officer striking and wrestling with the woman. Him saying hear the pop! So excitedly, of course they knew she was injured.
When we can’t expect cops to be decent, rational human beings, we’re beyond the issue of “retraining”...That’s when it’s time to gut the department and start all over again.
The chief of police needs to be charged to for covering up this crime and anyone else involved.
Where are the city leader why are they not firing the chief of police.
Don’t worry nothing will happen to these two brave heroes .
plus the DA who saw the video, he needs to go.
I agree
@Shelly Fresh the citizens of Loveland need to clean house next election. Start removing city officials that are not doing their jobs.
Why is the chief of police still in office, is the question I have....
Or any supervisors in the chain of command who were aware of this incident? This is yet another example of why police reform is needed. Body cams should be required for EVERY police dept in the country and any officer who shuts off their body cam while on an incident should be terminated no questions asked. In addition, every police dept should have a civilian oversight board who is required to review any arrest where an injury has occurred, including reviewing body cam footage.
I am confident he will resign or fired. Also Mayor and city council members.
I wrote the city manager an email offering to take the job.
No response.
Because the "buck stops at the top" no longer applies. One term, twice impeached Trump said it the loudest, "no I don't assume any responsibility" for anything negatively impacted by my incompetency.
@@babydriver8134 How good are you at writing "incomplete " reports? To get hired you gotta be up there with the worst of them.
This is why we need to end Qualified immunity once and for all.
Exactly.Even for shooting. There are situations where they put bystanders, and fellow officers in more danger than the criminal does. If it is justified and doesn’t put others in danger, they don’t need immunity. Same with physical injuries. They shouldn’t be using so much more force than the criminal that they end up with more than bruises or cuts, or accidental injuries from falling against something which the officer has no ability to control. They also should face at least monetary punishment for turning their cameras or audio off without being able to give clear evidence of malfunction which would be sustained and not coincidentally convenient for a small period of time. There also needs to be independent oversight above them so commanding officers or chiefs, or anyone related to law enforcement are not able to sweep it under the rug. The whole system, as it is, is a mess. Even unions fight for bad cops. I get the need for unions on the one hand, fighting for benefits…but on the other, no one is ensuring that the bad cops, or workers in any professions, don’t get to hold positions in the unions and work to cover their own butts and buddies.
This was not excessive force. This was a vicious assault on an elderly woman.
In the state of Ohio, there is a separate charge for doing harm to golden agers that adds extra time to your sentence. So, why should cops be above that (laws are different from state to state)?
Yes!!
This is the kinda thing we're all going to face if we don't reform the police. Period.
@@theodoreroberts3407 This one will be looked at very closely due to the Police Accountability Act in Colorado. I can not understand how one officer can stand by and do NOTHING but watch, while another police officer misbehaves. Same as the other three officers in the George Floyd case.
I support our Police 100% BUT I do not support 100% of the officers that get hired.
Former DA that colluded to NOT charge, should be charged.
People without a 'moral compass' should never be authorized to wear badges.
Thats All of the Police force! They are either Sociopaths or protect Sociopaths.
@@dannymayo3236 Making generalizations like that doesn't help the cause. If you want to help stop abusive police , it will take good cops to help.
@@rosegeaber7533 its not a generalization its the truth. Good cops either quit because they are expected to protect psycho bullies or they succumb to the culture and comply.
This society has no moral compass. This starts with the fear of God. They dont have THAT
@@dannymayo3236 No Sir, that is not the case. They may be few, and they may be a minority in the system, but they do exist. You are making a blanket statement that is comparable to saying that everyone of a certain race are evil. That is what gets us all in trouble. Remember we are all different and absolutely yes, police reform needs to happen on a grand scale! And ASAP! Take care.
Abuse of the elderly is a felony charge in it self.
My dad past away from the disease it us very horrible disease 😔.
@@ferrotulysse3426 my sincere condolence for your loss
Even a bystander, who’s not trained, could see they were using excessive force.
Yeah and the sgt. intimidated him , but was not charged with anything...smdh
A blind horse at a mile distance could see that :-)
@karen bevis her mind is becoming close to one... And her body is just as frail...
And he got threatened by Sargent. this is in there training
.
@@BrokefishN More, or less in their policy. They love to sometimes yell out to you, I'm just following policy. Which we all know, Policy is not Law. The Policy stays the same, due to the victim takes the money the city offers without Trial. In most cases the city sets the terms to which you take the money. They admit to no fault, but find the persons behavior in bad taste. Trial = policy change for sure.
This is the shit they did while they knew they were being filmed. Imagine what they do when they aren't being filmed or off duty.
exACTly!!! as they beLIEve their brethren are all as they are crEATures from CAIN's roots$ who LIE LIE and LIE to cover up their demon side on the 'left'.. Look at the last sUPper TABle.. who wears green RObEs on the left SHOULDer and BLUE on the RIGHT is GOoD's ear to jOHn. who is the 1st plACe SETting ..... is just-*ICE* that melts under *FIRE* = makes sTEAM work!!! Fire the TOP down in uniFORM as they are the LEAderS w/o the H = transMISSION ...H = the 8th # = GOoD and the 8th plACe SETting is for MATtHew = wet math is the 1st and the last science of for and by the GOoD of the REPublic... the GOoD reps of We the People = JUST-US 'served' on *ICE* lol.
Nah, they're prefect..they have a hard job...if all that woman did was not resist....she shoulda made better choices.....the police officers will be exonerated....🤦🏿
I try not to knowing from personal experience it gets far worse when money is involved. The police in Hawaii tried to kill my girlfriend in 1994 after she was hit by a drunk driver by taking her to the wrong hospital that doesn't do major surgery and providing misinformation that put her in observation. They also filled out a false police report so impossible her medical records listed police corruption connected to her auto insurance was affecting her recovery. Then there's what happened on June 9, 2009 and what followed... this is the equation for the Fine Structure Constant: (e{a})/t=E and that's just a fancy way to spell busted. It's just a matter of time...
@@nettejohnson7492 Is your keyboard broken?
WhAts wiTh alL the wIErd caPitalizaTION? Also are you high because that shit makes no sense. Funny as heck though.
@karen bevis Yes... and this is not the only video of the police turning off the cameras to beat a defenseless woman as officer Wiley Willis did to Angela Garbarino where almost half a million dollars in a payoff was used to silence what officer Willis did to her after turning off the camera and leaving Angela in a pool of her own blood. Officer Wiley Willis says she tripped and fell.
Officer Willis who is white was fired but never charged for the felony crime of disfiguring Angela who is also white and I think it's important to point out the violent police culture in America once generally accepted and (mostly) applied to black Americans allowing this violent behavior is growing almost exponentially often unrelated to racial prejudice. Too many videos show police officers enjoy disfiguring women as it's not just an act of violence... it's a way some men enjoy having sex. This fact is seldom mentioned but expressing hate and rape go together as both past and current History shows. Some police enjoy "leaving their mark" on the faces of women they chose to hate and violently slam down on their face breaking teeth.
In the case of Officer Wiley Willis after the show was over a year and half later with the News media no longer paying attention the Shreveport Municipal Fire and Police Civil Service Board voted to reinstate Officer Willis on the police force with full back pay and benefits for the year-and-a-half he was "fired" using a "technicality" which I believe due to being obvious was put in place by the police using forethought gained from past experience working with their attorneys. His discipline was just a fake show IMO created to deceive the American Public the police now regard as a threat out to get them as well as a piggy bank full of cash tax dollars filled up annually allowing the onslaught of violent criminal behavior to continue and therefore grow unrestrained.
So here we are again years later hearing the police laugh at torturing a small mentally disabled 73 yr old woman who was being nice and no threat to them whatsoever. Time is exposing what happens when unrestrained blind hate put out by the police is allowed to continue by not only supporting police violence, but funding it as well as if pretending to put out a fire with water and then switching over to use gasoline.
How about the good samaritan that walked up and them how wrong they were, we need more brave people like him.
Great Scott
Sure do and hats off too this India Samaritan here too tell the Police too leave her along!
The Good Samaritan law can have a large impact if the prosecutors see that the officers ignored anyone trying to prevent the crime.
It took a year to get it out. The chief is the one who covered it up. Fire them all and put them in jail
I'm tired of commenting on this shit lock the police chief and all up throw away the keys shameful monsters and demons walk among us everywhere
💯
Until those who allow this ie the chief, DA's, the city council, mayor and especially the police unions start to be impacted on personal levels, this behavior will only escalate. Loveland for instance, is a small town where it would be quite easy to bump into any of these assholes, start the purge!
If he really didn't know, then he should be fired for stupidity!
@@SmittyAZ there is no excuse. This was a year ago. And as far as that goes he is negligent if he didn’t know the truth of his officers. It’s only when the public found out about this vicious mauling of this frail sick person who was obviously confused. This poor lady
The female police officer has been charged with not reporting it. What about all those who reviewed the tape and did nothing.
@networkbike543 That is a very good question.
That's what I'd like to know.
Not just watched the video. They sat and watched it joking and laughing about the use of force. The video shows several watching
@@buhdahto This is why a friend of mine who is an activist against cops tends to be lenient on female cops because he recognized that they are discriminated against and often are selected as Patsy's.
They are immune to laws. I like to refer to it as corruption. They are judging the publics ire to decide if anymore charges will apply. They may no longer work in Colorado if convicted. This means they will work elsewhere. Systemic issues.!! COPS love to change the narrative. She weighs 80lbs. This is not training please this is common sense. All Police need extensive psychological testing to ensure the right-wing authoritarian and social dominant orientation type personalities cannot work in LE. These are the rogue officers with abusive backgrounds, abused, bullied, and or the bullies. Often abuse animals, children, and women. The worst personality types for LE are 80-85% of LE. Law Enforcement specifically attracts these personality types that enjoy control and power over others. Nothing knew its been like this for hundreds maybe even thousands of years. Austin Hopp and Daria Jailia. are barley children who gave them this much power and authority to begin with?
Sad part is they weren't fired n charged for their wrongdoing. They were fired and charged for the backlash from the community and media
We all watched them laughing at the violence they committed on an elderly woman with dementia then refusing her treatment after admitting to what they did makes them some of the worst cops out there. Around the same time this dept settled a suit for beating and charging another elderly person who was a witness for not wanting to talk to them. This chief needs to be fired.
...and prosecuted. This chief needs to be fired and prosecuted.
As another commenter suggested start taking lawsuit payments out of the whole dept's pensions. Like the Army, maybe the others in the dept will start changing attitudes of their comrades if they all get penalized.
@@BoltRM Senate needs to get on this, the Democratic side needs to. I don't trust republicunt side
@@АнтонПреображенский-ю3и I don’t trust the Republicans either , and I are one . I did not understand how bad police were until all these video,s were posted online
@@richardmorrison2686 For instances, Derek Chauvin
Read the lawsuit, 2 supervisors covered up, it's not a one off.
is it ever. ever hear of the thin blue line?
Innocent until proven guilty. Charges are like throwing spaghetti against the wall and see which one sticks, or which ones they can try and
plead out / get money for. I'm not saying anyone did anything wrong. Or that anyone did. Conviction without reasonable doubt is what makes this country great. Without it, everything falls apart. I'm not saying you have lost sight of that, but most people have. It's more about public opinion than fact. And if, what people hear or see on tv is taken as fact, we've come to a scary place as Americans. It's all fun and games, until it's you on the other end. And the long arm of the law, with endless resources, and prosecutors on salary, and you needing a pay lawyer...... We are all screwed.
I work at a popular retail store, I can't say the name (but you know) and a woman with dementia approached me the other day, obviously confused, I sought out the right care, spoke with her, remained calm, didn't accuse her of a crime or stealing, got her son (who was grateful) to come to pick her up, things don't have to be this way, it's the mindset of the police in this country. It is NOT a small minority, it is the MAJORITY in control of the system itself. No one had to train me to be a human being when dealing with someone like that. If you're a good person, it should be natural. The fact the officers acted the way they did speaks to two things, either you're training MAKES you a monster because the pound in your head, "everyone you run into is a criminal" or it attracts the kind of psychopathic people who lack that natural tendency. Either way, things have to be changed, and changed on a VERY high level.
Its a shame but police depts test for this type of behavior. They want officers who will do violent acts on people.
Common sense and critical thinking
Chief of Police needs to be fired and charged as well. How many of these cases have been swept under the rug? Chief of police needs to go he knew about this and did nothing.
And if he didn't know, why didn't he know?
It just shows who the cops really serve. To them, the public is beneath them and like cattle.
The press conference by the chief was laughable where he had the gall to say this wasn’t the Loveland pd , this isn’t the Loveland pd even though the people who committed these crimes were in Loveland pd uniform and it turns out this isn’t an isolated incident by this dept
Loveland ! I think they should change the towns name to Loveland as long as your a cop .
Cops are never going to change because the problem is most people think this issue is a new issue but in truth the crimes LEOs commit has been happening for a very very long time and the high ups don’t care what crimes are committed as long as they can hush them up because their main goal is preserve the integrity of the polices image in the interests of self preservation .
The corruption is real and anyone who thinks that this cooperation isn’t corrupt is in denial , the blue line backers usually have members of law enforcement in their families and won’t accept that they have a POS psycho in their family .
I live in Loveland and I know about 3 other cases similar to this one with officers trampling over the people who live in Loveland. And absolutely nothing being done about it. As a matter of fact my mother’s restaurant in downtown Loveland had its front window shot out by a random driver and Officer Austin Hopp was the one who was sent to the restaurant to investigate and months went by with nothing from the LPD or the officer who responded. Now I’m not saying every cop in Loveland is crap, there are some “good ones” but a lot are power hungry douchebags that forget the basics like reading you your rights before placing you under arrest.
Correct if she's also guilty for knowing then so should be the chief
Land of the free again
Stop it
They weren't the only ones laughing at that video. Everyone involved should be fired. Take their pensions. These two need to be in jail.
Let's put it simply: You do not need any training to learn not to use aggressive force against an old confused woman. You need (evil) training to think using such force is OK.
Assholes!!!!!
The chief says he didn't know about this until a few days ago when the federal lawsuit was filed.
How could he not know?
The FOIA requests, the woman's defense attorney demanding discovery, the viral videos, the media asking questions?
Gross incompetence or a failed coverup, either way, he needs to go.
@Ron K Hell yes he knew, this isn't the first rodeo for this police department, look them up, they have been doing the same sadistic crap for years and worse.
As citizens, we can FOIA without any cause. Do it. YOU can find bad cops daily...
don't forget that the bystander (you can see/hear him on one of the body cam videos) who witnessed Garner's treatment by the road apparently filed a formal complaint..... who knows where that ended up. Obviously the "chief" didn't hear anything. Smells like a cover up to me (or gross incompetence/negligence at all levels). Only reason anyone is hearing about this now is because of the lawsuit. I guess that's too big to hide or ignore.
Piece of SHIT!
God bless them police chiefs, hope they can sleep at nights..they ent got relatives..lol
Her gaze looks sadistic. 3 other criminals are still on the loose. The
Chief and the sergeant still haven’t been arrested for their cover up.
I love it it turns me on
Yes these encounters can escalate quickly. But who’s doing the escalating? Is anyone else tired of hearing how dangerous their job is ?
Yes I'm tired of hearing how dangerous there jobs are, the biggest threat to a police officer is there aactions of control over the person they are speaking too. And there attitude of showing there supposedly power over the people. It's not a few bad apples, it is the complete tree. You will never see me on the side of the road when the funeral passes of a fallen police officer. My thoughts will be was he one of the bad apples, and how many lives has been ruined.
It's only because the video went viral that they got in any trouble. This stuff happens everyday
Unfortunately
Yep...only because the lawyers got involved.
The power of....social media!! Yes!
Yup
This isn't a thing because it was video taped. It's a thing because we SAW the video tape. Police departments still have way too much control over how and when FOIA requests are processed.
Over a year for this to come out? Gee, I wonder why.
The burning question has to be "what made them think this was ok?" Even if she did not have dementia it was wrong.
Give people power and they will show you who they are‼️ Made me remember The Stanford Prison experiment‼️
Evil . Some people are just evil
Thin blue line gang is why...blame these two.. collateral damage. 💯❤🇺🇸
When there is no Swift Justice, I repeat when there is no Swift Justice, to a Bad (Act or Deed) the heart ❤️ of people becomes embolden, to practice the bad (Acts & Deeds) that,there has been & still is (normally) on Swift Justice to.
They knew it was wrong but they didn’t think they would ever get caught. Most of the time they don’t. A lot of these cops are not mentally stable at all. They have severe control issues.
A dislocated shoulder is one of the most excruciating injuries you can experience. Unreal
She sat in jail for hours.
you've obviously never experienced the severe cop butthurt when a citizen exercises their rights
A year? They collaborated in writing their report, he stated he threw her to the ground several times and then spoke of “controlled manner” for report. So happy they’ve been fired and charged.
Yep , finally we see some accountability
String them up in the center of the city & then let the poor lady they brutalized & humiliated, take swings at them with a Louisville slugger like they were pinatas! When she gets tired let her family & friends have a go! FTP
They were not fired. They resigned. The Chief let them resign.
@@mcahill135 Exactly so they can go and work at another department with no professional consequences.
How do you train a policeman to exercise empathy and common sense. And add maturity
You can't train someone to have empathy and common sense,if your a normal person your born with that,it does seem a lot of the police aren't...
How do you train animals to be humans?
@@siamsamblue30041 ideally Iraqi's deserve to be treated with humane decency, but sure hammers can be used to tenderize meat, its not like these killers have souls.
A police captain once seen me speak at a youth event and he invited me to apply. I made a statement that policing is alot of social work, he disagreed said its more enforcement. Needless to say i didnt apply....
Most cops are test tube babies.
It was so awful seeing how far they pushed her arm up behind her back. It made me sick to my stomach when I saw it and you could almost see when her shoulder dislocated. They knew what they were doing, arms don't bend that way naturally unless you're double jointed or something. It was so blatant that you don't even need a trained professional to tell you that bending it the way they did would cause it to dislocate, anyone with an iota of common sense knows that arms aren't made to bend that way. Bless her heart
2 other officers should also be charged...the sergeant who was on scene and helped to hogtie her , and the idiot who watched the body cam video with these two and laughed it up. then there is the issue of the line of supervisors who saw no problem with the use of force. go get them all.
Please put him in gen-pop. There are some lifers who will show him what it feels like to have joints popped.
I hope they have long lives filled with every torture imaginable.
I Pray Badly for that all the Time hopefully one day. These Coward's will be put in General Population 🙏 🙏🙏🙏👮😭
Disrespectful toward a senior citizen; you'd think to show compassion, what if it were your parent or family member?
Injury inflicted and failure to disclose is in other words termed Liar/what is the world becoming? Tragic🤔
Did you hear that? No, pop him again.
Won't happen unfortunately. Convicted cops never get put in gp. Corrections officers protect their own. & the corrections guards are the worst of them all.
What puzzled me in this case was the fact she didn't have any stolen items in her possession. The were taken by the store. I think she even tried to pay for them. There was no reason to even approach her when they saw she was only carrying dandlions.
Wal Mart should bear some responsibility.They called the cops in the first place.
@tomcooley3778, hopefully, the family will sue Walmart.
So many "Bad Apples" it's almost like the entire Tree has been poisoned.
It starts from the roots and spreads to each limb.
Exactly
Bad Apple's are knocking off the good ones it's so many of them oh my.
The whole orchard is poisoned, it’s not just a few trees.
The system of controlling the public is the problem. They do not serve. The police only want to hold power over the citizens. The courts support this violence, too.
10 Months? Why is the Mayor of Loveland Jackie Marsh, DA Gordon McLaughlin and the Police Chief Robert Ticer still in office? What else are they hiding?
Excellent question, corruption has absolutely no boundaries when it comes to taking advantage of your fellow humans.
A whole lot hopefully they'll look in to other arrest.
This department has several other law suits pending right now
The mayor, the DA and the governor also deserve to be sued because they have the power to do something about it, thereby a fiduciary duty, and have done nothing.
I'd say their still in office, because they were elected by people who share the same view.
The chief of this department stated they didn't know about this arrest for almost a year. While two or more sergeants were involved in the booking
Give someone power and you’ll see who they really are.
Good point🎯💯👍🏼❣️
So true!
@carla beckford they? Who’s they? These two didn’t murder anyone.
these two don't belong dealing with people in any way. these two will hurt people and try to cover it up.
They both belong in prison!
For the safety of all humans.
Show the video of the officers watching the violent arrest and laughing. "Listen for the pop".
Very interesting story. I do believe the elderly woman who was arrested and hog tied by the police officer because she was “not listening” due to her dementia only weighed 80 pounds, however, not 120 pounds. She is extremely frail. Great story and thankful for this update.
And she didnt even steal anything! The employee took it from her before she left.
@@briangriffith4574 she offered to pay. She had her debit card in her hand when she was thrown down. This story gets me upset Everytime I hear something about it
@@briangriffith4574 Right! And, in fact, she offered to pay by that time, as she did have that one credit card on her, but by that time, the store staff would not allow her. Perhaps because she was outside the store by then. But still??
Honestly. Bet the females he lives with suffer the same. In fact, positive he hits at home.
@rebeccaberry4764 Walmart wanted to find her to make money. They have a handbook procedure on how to handle them so they can get a fine
You shouldn’t need training to be a decent human. She was in no way a threat to them.
This inhumane behaviour made me think of The Stanford Prison experiment‼️‼️‼️
Fealings police
Decent humans do not become pigs!
And these two were having a romantic relationship at the time. Isn’t that just precious. Two cops abusing a 73 year old with dementia. Your parents must be so proud of the felons they raised.
Sadistic monsters, all of them.
Needs to be more than just those 2 held accountable and they knew they had hurt her shoulder and arm that is why they left her cuffed to intentionally cause her even more pain while they all laughed and joked
You could see her bones pop out.
He did say wait for the pop while watching the bodycam footage with the female cop so he knew she was injured.
These were terrible people. Great breakdown and explanation of the case!
It is a shame what they did to that woman with no empathy ,and then laughing and fist bumping about it, they broke her arm.well they’re not laughing now.
I hope they laugh all the way to jail. They'll be in a cell alone. Not in general population.
FIRE THE CHIEF!!! AND CHARGE HIM WITH WITH ACCESSORY TO ALL THESE CHARGES
What about the family for leaving Karen Garner all alone so she could wonder off? Shouldn’t they be charged as well and put in jail as well and they are still in charge of Karen Garner with no supervision as to how they are treating Mrs. Garner.
@@lylarose2696 not taking care of someone with a disability may be a mistake but it’s not a crime
@@lylarose2696 what about... what about... what about.. what about... what about... shut up
It's not a training issue, its cop culture issue.
You are absolutely correct.
If these loose their police certification in CO and don't serve jail time, they'll still be hired in another state because they stick together protecting fellow brothers in blue.
REPSDirect, " protecting fellow THUGS in blue ".
Not if the public expose them wherever they go. And new law on accountability may change things.
Which is why all the other states need to follow Colorado's lead and together we need to create a central database.
Naw, put them in the national database so all 50 states will have the information. Any state or county who knowingly hires former corrupt cops. will answer to the government and be levied with heavy fines for each day that corrupt cop is on their payroll
That needs to change too..their record should follow them and say do not hire them.
She was so small and frail the guy who intervened thought he was roughing up a small child
That guy was a legend. He should be decorated for intervening in that situation. His testimony is so important too because it did indeed appear to him that the cops were roughing up a child. That's how disturbing that scene is.
That man is braver than you know to stand up like that. I pray that I could rise to that level when needed.
And the attitude of the offending cop telling him that knowing she whole story from Wal-Mart and now he knows the whole story. The cop did not know the whole story. He could have followed her in his cop car , there was no threat with this lady.
Training won’t help. It’s the entire culture and who they hire. Until they hire a more educated, less aggressive, racist, sadistic type of person then nothing will change.
She and the third officer aided and abided, need to add charges. If this was a citizen they would throw what ever they could
Sometimes monsters, look like people.
Yup. reminds me of the movie The Thing (1982).
I love the mug shots, and I’m loving the consequences they are facing. Dude you guys are in there because you injured and scared the hell out of a 73 year old lady who weigh probably 80 pounds! Then you watch the video and laugh and think you did an amazing for our community!
Just look at the smirk on that mean girls face! Cannot wait to see them both in court.
Ju Win, Jail .
@@sydneyevans2637 oh totally! I just want to see their stupid faces leading up to it!!
@@juwin9437 Bet the smirk turns into a frown quickly.
She look like she taking a selfie not a mugshot
She looking so proud of herself...loser with absolutely no heart or common sense.
"Training" does not fix those that enjoy sadist behaviour.
It's honestly such a joke that the response to every case of police misconduct is "better training". Umm, how about accountability and justice instead?
@Stu Bonner
I am not trained in the use of force and will never be involved with so-called "law-enforcement".. but from an early age i knew, in my gut,
that little kids....the elderly and challenged people...animals..needed to be dealt with gently..!
I was in the military for years and saw bad things happen in a dirty colonial war..BUT remember that elders, mothers, children
were usually treated fairly...!
The GESTAPO thugs are violent because they like violence and they love to inflict pain..!
They did it to this 73 year old lady and will do the same...again and again. !
Jail time needed and probation for a long time after. !
I saw the video from the jail where they are watching the bodycam footage and laughing and making comments on their assault on this poor old lady. It was so disgusting 😡 they had no regrets for what they did to her. It's definitely a systemic problem, absolutely!!! These problems with police are not training issues, well it is a part of it but a small part, it's the one one training that they're getting from other bad cops after the academy.
It's sad that nothing happened until the tapes were released to the public.
Black folks have been saying for YEARS that nothing happens when the police see the tapes. Action only happens when WE see the tapes.
Just imagine a few years ago when people had cameras, but didn't know how much difference it would make.
I don't see a problem taking vids of police activities, if they're not doing what they should be, now it becomes a problem.
Mr. DeMill, their ready for their close up.
You know how much it happened throughout history
@@Liitebulb I do. I lived through an amount of it. I have memory of events, I didn't read it in a book (which usually only reflect one or two aspects).
Question: have you ever been to a fire before reporters arrive. Later, you watch the report and it looks and sounds like a different fire?
@@crispyblack8779 I have repeatedly edited in an attempt at getting past the UA-cam censorship algorithm to post a list of primarily *_black people murdered by white police._* If you care to see the list, click "Read more" as by adding text I have managed to put the list up. I have had great difficulty in doing so. It is far from complete, with the last name on the list being of special note. He was an innocent unarmed white 26-year-old husband and father of two little girls, clearly terrorized and senselessly murdered by police on camera. TYT has the only unedited version of the video that I know of.
Racism is a huge factor in all this, but this deadly behavior goes far beyond racism.
George Floyd
And Andrew Brown Jr.
And Daunte Wright
And Ronald Greene
And Philando Castille
And Eric Garner
And Shawn Bell, _(on his wedding day)_
And Anthony McClain
And Ousmane Zongo
And Amadou Diallo
And LaQuan McDonald
And Anthony Lamar Smith
And Casey Goodson Jr.
And Marvin Scott III
And Freddie Gray
And Terence Crutcher
And Sandra Bland
And Ronnell Foster
And Willie McCoy
And Michael Brown
And Rayshard Brooks
And Atatiana Jefferson
And Davinian Darnell Willuams
And Tony Terrell Robinson Jr.
And Nimali Henry
And Marcus Smith
And Corey Jones
And Tyrell Wilson
And Botham Jean
And Terence Walker
And Alton Sterling
And Walter Scott
And Treyh Webster
And Akai Gurley
And Andre Hill
And Breonna Taylor
And Kurt Andras Reinhold
And Ahmaud Arbery
And Elijah McClain
And Tamir Rice
And John Crawford III
And Eric Harris
And Fred Hampton
And Adam Toledo, _Latino_
And Mario Gonzales, _Latino_
And Christian Hall, _who was Asian._
And Christopher Roupe, white, age 17
And Eugene Mallory, white, age 80 _(machine gunned in his bed)_
And *Daniel Shaver,* _who was also white, unarmed and innocent._
_And more than we could ever count._
*_"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable."_*
~~ John F. Kennedy
The most damning evidence that this was a straight up assault is the video of them reviewing the body cam and laughing. The officer admitting he heard this poor elderly woman’s shoulder pop is truly disgraceful.
Wow wow wow, calm down there buddy. this is nothing some Training wont be able to fix. Always remember the popo are here to abuse and degrade...uhhh I mean serve and protect. Serve and Protect !!
They're all liable for not protecting that poor, sweet woman. Is this a systemic issue? In Loveland, it is!
The chief acts like he is a mushroom. Someone is keeping him in the dark, and feeding him bullshit. The whole command staff needs to go. That department is rotten from top to bottom and back to the top.
The chief knew and covered it up. The D.A. is in the good old boys network too.
Ticer, A total failure in leadership
See how tuff they are without that badge to hide behind!
Not tough at all, majority of them need plus size bullet proof vests which I'm sure cost more than standard.
Badge & backup of the chief as well as fellow officers ..."the thin blue shame"
Don’t drop the soap.
@@tonycampbell9626
Hear the Pop?
Thank goodness I can now sleep peacefully knowing that the world is safe from 73 year old people with dementia
I'm glad that the "authorities" are finally starting to at least partly starting to see legal charges for doing bad cr@p! No more protecting them!
They beat up grandma, they couldn’t just let it go. If it was you or me, we still be sitting in jail and those cops would still be on the streets.
rhe Rapture of the Believers in Jesus Christ will happen before anything is fixed
They still only move when it becomes public. Otherwise it's cover-up-as-usual.
100 years in jail wouldn't be enough for what they did to that frail, disoriented woman. And then they laughed about it. Unbelievable, and unforgivable.
And before they assaulted her she was smiling with flowers in her hand it's so sad. To make it worse she didn't do anything wrong they said she shoplifted but she didn't . those demons were not smart enough to ask where the stuff they thought she stole was when she walking with nothing but flowers on her.
I don't know what they deserve but they certainly are the most hatable people. Charles Manson seems more likeable. Even the clutter murderers. No doubt they're worse criminals though.
They need to be put under the jail.
Out of all the cases that have hit UA-cam in the last year or so this one sticks in the mind. It might be because my late mother had dementia but it’s more likely to be because they behaved in such an egregious way. I find the smirk on her face particularly irksome.
It’s not about training. Accountability is the issue.
It is also about hiring. Quit hiring psychopaths!
"It’s not about training."
Correct, their behaviour after the fact in reviewing the arrest video effectively demolishes that excuse.
@@rjlchristie they are seen giggling and laughing while they review the body camera footage as if they were a couple of teenagers watching a 'pranking video'. So disgusting to watch.
Its both. Train pigs to de escalate situations instead of seeing everyone as the enemy and revenue.
Get rid of that entire shift, they were all laughing and fist pumping each other after they beat that lady. Give them all Jail time and let them enjoy some fist pumps behind bars!
I am waiting for Hopp to say he feared for his life because he has allergies and the flowers she was picking was a deadly weapon.
now the public needs to keep tabs on these two because other State / County law enforcement agencies won't do their due diligence when hiring
Hopp is back in Key West, where he grew up. He will be working on his Daddy's charter boat, the "Reel Deal".
@@JohnLockesReflection OH...this info needs to go viral down in the Fla Keys#
Of course he knew about the injured shoulder.
He was bragging about it on camera "Wait for the POP".
He is nothing but a spineless coward.
She is no better.
These people are evil.
How disturbing. I can feel her pain bc I had a dislocated shoulder after neck surgery that went untreated and I still have pain in my shoulder. I’m glad he got prison time to think about what he did.
Get rid of qualified immunity, make lawsuits come out of the pension of the police. Also put these two away for a long damn time, disband that department and rebuild it from the ground up
My solution is that the city pays the officer a reasonable amount for liability insurance just like they do for uniforms, that amount is based on a new officer who has no claims.
If the officer's insurance pays claims and their insurance rate goes up they eat the increase just like someone with a shit driving record has to deal with higher insurance premiums.
Police abuse investigations should be done by an outside entity not tied to the police and the police union pays the cop's salary during this time while the cop sits on their ass.
As we all know these investigations drag out forever and in most of them the cop collects full pay during that time.
If the cop wins the city reimburses the police union, if the cop loses and then too bad for the union they can try to recover the money from the cop.
Force all police officers to carry insurance, like Auto insurance. Just like a bad driver, they won't be able to work as their premiums go up
@@bruce2357 the tax payer shouldn’t pay for their insurance. They already make more then enough with their bloated overtime and let’s not forget all the benefits of cheap auto and home insurance because of being a civil employee. Or what about their amazing health insurance gifted to them. The cops pay for their own insurance to “protect them” when they royally screw up. How many other professions out there will let you resign after discovery of criminal conduct, yet there are no repercussions for the actions taken.
That is the only way to stop police misconduct.
I agree... But Qualified Immunity is the backbone...the anchor stone...of the US Police and Prosecution at the local and State and Federal District levels. While SCOTUS will throw out a few bones for the public to cheer... It will NEVER seriously limit it.
This video also shows that it's not only poc that get treated bad by cops. Allot of them are just bullies. They have been under the impression that they can do whatever they want for a long time. Glad to see that they're starting to be held accountable
That is true. Not only POC but not all these people gave a damn when it was them. They had to deserve it.
Disease spreads. Doesn't just stay with any set of people. If something had been done about this before, this case wouldn't have happened.
@@ydcee3123 so you think it used to be only poc who got treated that way by cops and now it's spread to white people? It's always been all colors. I'm 45 and white and I've had problems with cops most of my life. My son has had several bad encounters with cops too. It seems to be more of a " have/ have not" issue than a race issue.
“To Serve and to Protect” officers should think about this whenever they are in doubt.
Its "To Abuse and Degrade" that is the real motto of the Popo. Some new officers follow yours but to be part of the Blue Gang you need to follow the latter.
They were like two cats who caught a mouse, and would pick it up and drop it, then swatting it across the room , with pure joy on their faces, and why not they had the power of the State on their side, or so they thought.
Don’t worry nothing will happen to these brave heroes
@@cabinbills6743 That's what I am afraid of. But we got a conviction here recently. Maybe things are changing. We'll see.
Kathryn Geeslin even if you get a conviction the sentencing usually is a joke .
@@cabinbills6743 Yeah. Amber Guyger got ten years for murdering Botham Jean in his own living room eating ice cream while watching tv. At the time she worried to her supervisor/married lover about possibly losing her job, not Jean's possible survival or her possible arrest. So, ten years was ten more than I expected. And the judge gave her (Amber) her (judge's) personal Bible.
Kathryn Geeslin what would the sentence have been if she wasn’t a cop ? Wonder how many of those personal bibles the judge has given to other murderers . That case got so much publicity judge had no choice kinda like the Chauvin case . How long did it take for her to file an appeal ?
He knew he hurt her shoulder, he said in the video that he heard it pop and though "that's gonna be bad" and then they all laughed about it.
they are not laughing now are they
Cruelty to your elders.shocking to see footage
The abuse by police is an isolated issue. It only happens in areas that have police.
Good one! Lol
🤣🤣🤣
Excellent ..should be quoted.
CLEVER ☠️
You're a legend
Where's the police chief's mugshot?
No matter what excuse you give, no amount of training can compensate for common sense.
I just saw the Karen garner video it was so heartbreaking to watch I’m glad they gave him 5 years
Hearing this attorney talk, it gives me hope.
he is just a talking head, he has no skin in the game
@@BaBa-gq4lw all black people have skin in the game when it come to this topic .
@@trusarmor4957 even if the guy is a Tom
This guy is amazing stop bringing people down this guy did amazing like dude keep it to yourself
@@VV-qi5fg like I said he is nothing but a talking head, sounds good but really says nothing, inaccurate misleading, fake news
Any "officer" who feels it is necessary to rough up an elderly person with dementia has NO BUSINESS being an "officer". Plain and simple. This is criminal behavior.
Wow WOW there buddy!! Every city would be left without a police force if we follow your litmus test.
For a person to be this cruel and inhumane, no training will change that, it's a character issue.
The love is gone out of Loveland those 2 aren’t fit to work with my dog the problem is what about the rest involved and the rest that new about it and the ones that covered it up. This is far from settled
Assaulting and hurting an elder woman who suffers from dementia. The level of sadism...
You know what makes me sick. Not only did that Chief cover it up. But their mugshots? She does not look remorseful whatsoever.
The only person in danger was Karen from these officers.
And her family, why was she alone if her family knew she had dementia, should they not be held accountable as well? The family didn’t even care about Karen Garner until they realized they could get rich off of what happened, then they all of a sudden cared.
She was smiling in her mug shot. Wow, if that doesn’t show you she cares less.......
she is kinda hot.
@YupIt'sMe💕 Is someone jealous? : )
Maybe the female inmates will pet and brush her hair?
@@LeadMe2TheBliss lmao she is not hot you must be desperate for anything that breathes on you.
@@brandonp2211 Sounds like you're jealous. Also, I clearly said she was "kinda hot" not hot.
They thought they had gotten away with hurting a frail, helpless 73 year old lady, but the world has spoken! But, in jail they will pay for their crime!
The people in administration who's job it is to oversee these issues are a part of the bigger problem that the media is not talking about.
They need to go up the ladder and expose these people and the amount of incidents they are mishandling.
Culture of depraved indifference to life
Glad I found this follow up report.
Made me cry how can they be so cruel
You can't train compassion!!!! The frail old woman was not a threat that warranted such force.
She wasn't a threat AT ALL! They should have seen her safely home, made her a cup of tea/coffee and contacted a family member to come and comfort her.
It's a NEW police accountability law, that police are required to tell the _whole_ truth?? 🤯
As of May 2022, one year after this video was posted. The elderly Ms. Garner has been awarded a 3 Million dollar settlement. She suffered a broken arm and dislocated shoulder in the incident. The male cop was just sentenced to 5 years in prison and 3 years of parole for his egregious behavior. and attempt to cover up his personal malfeasance.
I'm glad both cops are facing the music especially for blatantly lying that she was not injured. As a resident of Colorado, I'm grateful this new law will be applied to this case.
Until Aurora CO cops who murdered Elijah McClain are INDICTED AND ARRESTED...I don't believe the white supremacists on Colorado police forces and other states will be purged out of the force .
Why is it that these police are arrested when they assaulted someone yet one of the police involved in the mcclain murder quit and is probably a cop in some other state or probably inglewood or littleton. So its racism. Why isnt the wokism hard left media talking?
So her crime was “not stealing something”. Her dementia led to her walking out of Walmart with some stuff, she was stopped, surprised she forgot, offered to pay. Walmart called the cops out of concern and said there was no crime. This thug cop told her to stop, she kept walking, he beat her up. Hope he goes to jail and gets a daily beat down himself. Serve and protect???
Put him in the cage with Mr. BEND OVER !!!
what was dispatched to the responding squad?....dispatchers should also be held to very high standards regarding the wording of their calls.
Cops are under no obligation to protect you this is already been ruled on by the United States supreme Court if you are under the impression they're here to protect you you're a dumbass
No. Her crime was stealing. She stole. They RECOVERED it. She was being arrested and charged with a criminal activity. She was combative, non compliant, and admitted she stole. This was not her first offense. She did not get beaten. She was fighting against restraining officers. They never struck her or use more force than necessary to arrest her. The only thug, is the old lady. Whether she had dementia or not, is irrelevant at the time of her arrest and not information the officer could have reasonably known. It’s the masses persecuting them for doing their jobs well.
@@stumpbumpers No, the Walmart manager told the police no crime was committed and called in that he was worried for her safety. The police had no right to stop her, no probable cause, she does not have to comply. They are fucking thugs and should go to jail, I’m sure they will. Let the courts decide. So if a cop comes up to you and wants to talk, you must? Maybe in the USSR. Not here. You should learn your rights.
What would be the penalty for shoplifting? A. "cite release" ( A ticket). Not a broken arm, or a dislocated shoulder. She was an old woman, a hundred and twenty pounds. Police have a hard job, and have to assert their control quickly. But common sense should have kicked in. There was no reason to manhandle her.
There needs to be a state hotline to turn behavior like this in! And a safe way for other LE to turn in this type of behavior. GOOD COPS DO NOT WANT TO WORK WITH COPS LIKE THIS! OPEN A HOTLINE COLORADO!
if there are 1000 good cops and 10 bad cops and the 1000 good cops don't turn in the 10 bad cops, you have 1010 bad cops. Good cops? show me one.
I'm almost 40 and I've rarely seen any police in public so much as following basic traffic laws. Majority drive like azzholes park in fire lanes for non emergency reasons, handicap parking you name it. I watched a state cop almost sideswipe the car next to him because he was looking at his phone on the freeway, I threw my hands up on my way by and he flipped me off.......
@@williamhickock1203 Exactly. If half the cops were doing their jobs, the other half would be in jail.
Okay. Then why don’t the “good cops” speak up?!? Are they afraid of little old ladies, too?
@Ron K thank you for the phone number.
The video of the office with the cells feet away was by far worse. Them laughing and watching the body cams of the male officer striking and wrestling with the woman. Him saying hear the pop! So excitedly, of course they knew she was injured.
This isn’t new. They’ve been getting away with this for over a hundred years.
I’m very angry about what these demons done to this poor lady. It’s so sick and evil!!! You’re certainly right about it!!
When we can’t expect cops to be decent, rational human beings, we’re beyond the issue of “retraining”...That’s when it’s time to gut the department and start all over again.