Dreamcast vs PlayStation 2 (Alone in the Dark The New Nightmare) Gameplay Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 кві 2024
- A side-by-side comparison between Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare for Dreamcast and PS2 (PlayStation 2).
Dreamcast Version = Left Side
PlayStation 2 Version = Right Side - Ігри
![Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare [2001] PS vs PS2 vs DC vs PC vs GBC (Graphics Comparison)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RCYVZdNH0rU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare [2001] PS vs PS2 vs DC vs PC vs GBC (Graphics Comparison)](/img/tr.png)
It gets me so impressed to see how Dreamcast was faster than other systems. This is not the first comparison that DC needs to "wait" the other version reach it in time during comparison.
a Shen Mue comparison with Xbox would be great.
the read speed from the GD are more fast that the first dvd playstation 2 models
Dreamcast is my favorite console of all time….i was the odd kid that had one, while all my friends had a ps2 but they were always impressed with how it ran cross platform games
Dreamcast was a powerhouse, in some ways it was like having a Model 3 arcade at home. In 1999 it was mind blowing to have true arcade quality graphics at home.
No. It was more like having a Naomi at home, as that was the arcade board it was based on.
It's niomi not m3 it's exactly the same as niomi just half the ram and a disc instead of a drive
Naomi > Model 3
@@wordsshackles441 no. Naomi was much cheaper, and that's the reason it took the place of Model 3 as the board of choice for that generation of games.
@@timkasansky2528 You are incompetent.
Toda mi vida jugué la versión de PS2. Pero ahora que veo esta comparativa, la versión de Dreamcast tiene mejor sombreado, iluminación y resolución... ¡Necesito jugar Alone In The Dark 4 en Dreamcast! 💯
Dreamcast: better resolution, better hair textures and faster load times
PS2: moving mouths
It’s the Dreamcast that has better in game loading. He’s pausing the Dreamcast screen so the ps2 catches up. Remember the ps2 dvd takes longer the read.
@@systematicallyshocked oh yes you're right, I just woke up when I saw the video I must have inverted them when I compared in-game loading times.
This PS2 port has always been known to be shitty anyway. Except for the moving mouths of course.
Pretty much, @31:20 the room with the mirror, the PS2 frame rate tanks and has missing shadows too.
@@Kazeira you just woke up so you were actually inverted and saw the video upside down 😁
@@systematicallyshocked O DVD do PS2 não é mais lento que o GD do dreamcast, provavelmente por ser um jogo do inicio do PS2 não deve estar bem programado, ainda mais pelo PS2 ser o console mais difícil de programar daquela geração.
Man, this game really was ahead of its time in many aspects, wasn't it? It was using mapping like REmake's a year before that game came out.
Mapping? What do you mean ?
@@wordsshackles441 How light interacts with 2D backgrounds as if though they were 3D textures.
this game walked so REmake could run
@@yourmommasuqsdik918A most accurate analogy!
@marianoyuba3736 The PS1 version was already doing so if I remember right.
SEGA Dreamcast wins!
Always
Dreamcast making the best games. Ask Chad Warden.
@@fatboymachinegun That would be the PS Triple.
The DC came out 4 year after the PS1, so anything else would be weird
Edit, I have appearently no idea what I'm talking about, it's vs the ps2 so much more impressive
@@ThePsychoticWombat The comparison is with the PS2 which came out AFTER the Dreamcast
Hey, the production and interfacing of this video is awesome. Keep up the great work!
Go on the Dreamcast!!
excellent comparison, as always
I'm very impressed on how fast the loading is on Dreamcast, i was not aware of this. 21:35 almost had time to make a tea :)
Good job on having to sync the footage on this 50min gameplay.
Superior Dreamcast!
Dreamcast venceu essa disputa!
E em quase todas também, coitado do ps2.
I still have this game but never finished because disc 1 got scratched I was pissed since it was one of the few games that released when Dreamcast was being discontinued
Dreamcast melhor concerteza 🤩😍 Upiiiiiiiiii 🌀 Vitória SEMPRE 🌀
A versão do Dreamcast ficou muito melhor, inclusive nos cenários em alta resolução!
당시엔 브라운관 티비 사용이 기본인 시절이라 해상도에 대한 개념이 적을 수 밖에 없었지만 지금은 얘기가 다르죠 대부분의 게임이 480p VGA출력에 대응하는 DC가 PS2 보다 해상도에서 앞설 수 밖에 없습니다
그래픽 메모리가 턱없이 부족한 PS2는 480i 정규 해상도도 지원하지 못한 게임이 수두룩 합니다
세로 해상도를 반으로 줄여버리는 방법(512×224)으로 급하게 땜질해 출시한 게임이 너무 많아요
They were not released in a haste. Ps2 version of games systematically benefitted from additional development time and effort.
Video memory is not the issue, the GameCube only has 3MB for video.
The PS2's Graphics Synthesizer was so weak the Emotion Engine(CPU) had to render most of the complex geometry itself, which in turn used up CPU power and held the Emotion Engine back.
The PS2 Alliasing problems are always a problem and the colors and contrast on the Dreamcast are always an advantage, good for the Dreamcast!
I don’t think anyone hates on Sega as much as PlayStation fans.
They hate on everyone.
They're savages even towards us PS Vita fans.
PlayStation fans are the worst thing about PlayStation, and I'm including the PS3 launch in that metric too.
Seems the other way around to me
XD oh the irony......you people are so pathetic....XD.....zero self reflection
I hope yall are kidding around. Cause this is pretty sad. Goodness gracious just enjoy what you have and don’t have. I still play my ps2 and Dreamcast today. They’re great systems. Along with the Xbox and GameCube since that generation is still full of amazing games I’m getting around to. AND I use my vita. But more so my PlayStation TV, I have the OLED vita but I recently hacked the pstv to play a lot of jrpgs off my tv.
PlayStation fans have a massive chip on their block. PS2 is a console with many great games, but the fact is it can only compete with Dreamcast/GCN/Xbox graphically due to rendering 40% less pixels.
Hmmmm... Ps2 version looks dreadful compared to dreamcast. The framerate, the lighting. Like damn...
Audio too, the music is glitched in PS2 version (only DC and ps1 have fixed audio)
Great comparation,great game.saludos Mundomakina
The DCHDMI mod to your Dreamcast looks fantastic comoared to the PS2 component!
Colors and effects are quite good on PS2, but DC has higher poly, sharper look + better loading.
I wonder if there are any content or gameplay differences.
Honestly, I'm surprised they bothered with a PS2 version at all, because it was a PS1 game. There was no Saturn version, so I get why they released a Dreamcast release.
The PS1 could never. It would explode.
@@mikemcnut3204 This game is literally on the PS1.
To port their engine to PS2 I guess, using an already finished game is the best way to do so.
ps1 is a better port, trust me
otro ejemplo que demuestra que dreamcast pudo ser competente si seguía su producción unos años mas
Could you make a comparison of Time Crisis 2 Arcade vs Playstation 2? There are no comparisons of the game on youtube. Great videos by the way!
todo mundo falando dos gráficos, mas um detalhe super importante é que as músicas na versão de Ps2 são totalmente bugadas nesse port (de PC tbm). As unicas versões que tem o audio corrigido são de DC e PS1.
Dreamcast wins. Credit goes to the PS2 version for being one of the few PAL PS2 games to feature a 60Hz mode.
That’s not entirely true. I wanna say that from around the middle of the PS2 cycle, more and more games offered the 60hz option until all games eventually did so natively. I remember cause I used to read a lot of gaming magazines and they all made a point about the 50hz vs 60hz issue 😅
Most of the Dreamcast games I owned had the 60Hz mode, which was great as I had a multi-system TV which had NTSC mode.
@prismatism It's still not anywhere near as good as the DC's support for 60hz. Even when a PAL DC game doesn't have the "600Hz toggle", that just means it doesn't have support for interlaced 60Hz.
Every PAL Dreamcast game that has a VGA mode runs in full-screen, full-speed progressive scan 60Hz, regardless if that same game had a toggle for interlaced 60Hz or not.
There are about 5 PAL Dreamcast games that don't support VGA mode, and also don't have a toggle for interlaced 60Hz.
Most of the PAL Dreamcast games that you think don't have a 60Hz mode actually do via VGA mode. VF3, Dynamite Cop 2, and many more.
PS2 on the other hand is not great for this. To say that a quarter of the PAL PS2 library had a 60Hz mode would be generous. To say that over 95% of the PAL DC library supports 60Hz one way or another is a fact.
@@n64fan60 Dreamcast gave the most 60Hz games, GameCube was close behind it(albeit with limited progressive scan support because Nintendo decided "screw PAL regions specifically" for some reason) Then Xbox and PS2 come in last with 60Hz support, Xbox is slightly ahead of PS2 in this regard, but behind SEGA and Nintendo.
I though it was using the Retrofighters Dreamcast controllers but it's a mock-up
Really great game i play one when released on ps1. Back then this game had 9/10 score
PS2 has lip synching and show's Carnby's breath. Control is better on PS2 due to 2 analogue sticks. However, on the Dreamcast the higher resolution makes for a beautiful game over the muddy visuals of the PS2. Playing the game via GSM in progressive scan on the PS2 helps enormously with the visuals, but still not up to the Dreamcast standard..IMHO
Plus the music is much better on the Dreamcast version. On the PlayStation 2 it's downgraded, not as much as on the PC version where it's completely ruined, but still of worse quality compared to the PlayStation and Dreamcast versions.
At the time, I thought Code Veronica and Ecco also looked better on the Dreamcast, more vibrant colours and sharper image.
Better game than the 2024 version.
damn, dreamcast was such a impressive effort from sega... Wish sega was still on the market...
Lo único bueno en la versión de ps2 son las expresiones faciales y que todo está en un disco, por lo demás la dreamcast lo barre
One little clarification I think might be relevant.
240p is actually a slightly higher native vertical resolution per frame than Ps2's traditional 448i output.
The actual native vertical resolution of a 448i output is 224px (per field), and NOT 448px.
Dreamcast. 😍😍😍
excelente juego lo jugué en Dreamcast hace 24 años 😀
Foi um dia desses.
Dreamcast is better overall, but in PS" the character moves his mouth. This one is like comparing N64 to Dreamcast due to different resolutions.
Check out the Gameboy Colour version of this game, it's amazing
@@Haywood-Jablomie it’s the same one on the Nintendo Switch online app right? I played it abit, it’s pretty interesting. For what it is.
Playstation 2
@@Haywood-Jablomie That version was very ambitious. It's not a great game, but I appreciate what they managed to do.
My Childhood 😍 Still waiting for a remake 🤲
Interesting the Dreamcast version seems to look superior to the PS2. Its not stated in the video description but I assume the Dreamcast is VGA and the PS2 is Component?
That would be interesting to know but perhaps it’s more to do with the Dreamcast being 480p and the PS2 being 480i? Component video can handle 480p if the software can deliver the signal
Dreamcast had more vram than the PS2.
Dreamcast has double or twice as much video ram 8 MB / PS2 4 MB
@@waynetemplar2183The Ps2 version of the game outputs a 240p frame buffer. That’s all you get, no magic cable can change that.
Ps2’s was memory limited and throughout its very long life span has consistently output much lower pixel counts, IQ, and/or texture definition.
@@wordsshackles441some would say the ps2 actually held back that era of gaming open world. GameCube and Xbox were both vastly superior but every game had to be made with ps2 in mind.
I will never understand how the dreamcast lost to playstation2 every single game that was released on both consoles the DC version it's superior in graphics and load times but in the end sega killed the dreamcast before it could reach its full potential, I still have my sega dreamcast maybe I could grab this game and give it a go.
Dc wins 🎉
PC Version was nice in high res as well. Was awesome. One of the first games that had proper game pad support on PC then.
PC wasn't being compared here.
PC was being commented on, here.
@@Jammet The video is about the Dreamcast and Playstation. Yeah, people get off topic.
It just goes to show that Sega Dreamcast had it going on when it not only outperformed the PS1, but even the PS2.
Apparently it couldn't outperform the PS2 in the one area it needed to most.
@@SomeOrangeCat in sales, yep
@@SomeOrangeCat True, but remember at launch people bought the PS2 for DVDs, in Japan it sold at 10:1 systems to games for the first few years.
Dreamcast was bought purely by people who wanted to play.
Still, not like any of the 6th gen systems was a bad one to be on if you wanted a good time(or STILL want in regards to Dreamcast and Xbox, to a lesser extent GameCube and their independent releases these days)
Quando eu olho essas comparações e fico imaginando "e se o Dreamcast tivesse dado certo, qual seria o seu poder real?", porque tipo, sabemos que o Dreamcast tem o Shenmue que é um jogo lindo, só que ele é de 99. Muita agua rolou entre 2001 (ano de descontinuação do Dreamcast) e 2008 (ano da descontinuação do Xbox e GC) e os programadores saberiam trabalhar bem melhor com o Dreamcast se ele fosse encerrado em 2008 como seus concorrentes.
Queria VCdecide comparece DOA2 SD Remaster, contra o port porco do PS2, nossa, iria dar choro.
Eu tenho Dreamcast e PlayStation 2 e liguei o Dreamcast com VGA box e o PlayStation 2 com Cabo vídeo componente junto com conversor que faz upscaler de 720p /1080p e mesmo assim a versão de Dreamcast leva vantagem.
As texturas e cenários pré renderizados tem resolução maior, os efeitos de luz também são melhores e ao apontar a lanterna a luz passa suavemente pelos objetos dos cenários além das cores mais vivas.
O jogo não sofre de tantos Slowdowns com no PlayStation 2
Já no PlayStation 2 o jogo está com a resolução mais baixa no geral e a lanterna não passa a luz suavemente pelos objetos no cenário e dependendo do lugar causa slowdowns em algumas partes do jogo principalmente quando aparece muitos inimigos.
Mas os personagens parece ter mais polígonos e a boca tem movimentos na versão de Dreamcast os personagens não tem expressão dos lábios.
O Dreamcast NTSC americano e Japonês tem a imagem com cores, brilho e contraste melhores do que o Dreamcast brasileiro PAL-M
A versão PAL-M tem a imagem com cores, contrastes e brilho muito escuro e acaba ocultando as texturas dos jogos.
Great game
Joguei muito a versão de DC. Depois de muito tempo, quis jogar novamente, mas meu DC está com defeito, daí fui jogar no PS2. Assim q o jogo começou, eu pensei q meu PS2 estava ligado com cabo av, e não o componente. Q imagem ruim! A impressão q dá é q pegaram a versão de PS1, gravaram em um dvd e relançaram no PS2.
Tem cara mesmo de ser apenas um port direto de PS1 pra PS2
Sega needs to make a Dreamcast 2
Why would they? There's no financial reason to do so.
@@SomeOrangeCat because the original one was awesome 😎
@@PrettyBoyx69x From a business standpoint that's not a compelling reason. Sega has made more money as a third party publisher than they ever did as a console manufacturer. They finally found the success that eluded them during the "vs Nintendo" years. Why throw that away?
@@SomeOrangeCat thanks for destroying my dream lol
@@PrettyBoyx69x hehehe Dreamcast never dies
The Dreamcast is much better in the PS2 graphics, where it probably failed cleanly due to the fact that it didn't have a DVD. I used to play Dreamcast with my cousin and admired the graphics, and when I bought a PS2 with anticipation, I was extremely puzzled by the terrible graphics, which were worse than the Dreamcast.
Dude the same thing happened to me too, sorta. My brother bought the Dreamcast and we’d always admire the graphics. Especially Shenmue, that was the “can’t get any better than this” moment. My cousin had a ps2 and whenever we’d go to his house and play I was in shock how much worse everything looked.
Of course then I saw final fantasy 10 later after it released and thought, now I’m sold and got myself a ps2. Love both systems.
The Dreamcast was going to die early no matter what Sony released. Sega had sealed it's fate with all the blunders they made with the previous generations.
Sony always "embellished" when it came to specs during the Kutaragi days (of ps2 and ps3).
Sony lied about ps2's so-called "emotion engine" having graphics on par with the Toy Story motion picture back then. In reality, the machine came out and had almost nothing impressive available for it.
I vividly recall waiting 3+ years for anything noteworthy to become available for mine... and by then, the superior GameCube hardware (and Xbox) were out. I had four different consoles during Sixth gen and it was quite interesting.
The ps2 game I played most during those first 3 years was Devil May Cry... and I remember having to go plug my Dreamcast back in, as it had a stacked game library for my tastes. By the time ps2 got going, Xbox and GameCube were in full swing too.
Fast forward to 2005/2006ish and 'ol Kutaragi did the same thing when referring to "The Cell" during the seventh gen. He went for the usual antics again and Sony fanboys ate it up... only for us to see ps3 get outperformed (and quite frequently) by a console that was released a year earlier than it. Krazy Ken just wanted us all to pay $599 for the funsies. 😄
Sales figures and lies... er, "marketing hype" do *not* reflect (nor yield) the overall quality of any product. The usual Sony fanboys like to bring up sales related nonsense in every case when Sony falls short, but unfortunately those sales figures don't increase tangible game performance in any way. It's laughable every time, as it's such a juvenile manner of defense mechanics.
For a gamer who just wanted to play the most optimal version of a game, the answer was often *not* a Sony platform, contrary to what a few sensitive fanatics hate to accept. After all of these years, it's rather pathetic to see 😄 but I suppose it falls in line with expectations.
more detail on the back of the jacket on ps2
I was wondering ... where can I buy this game ? 😮
Life is always alone in the dark,if u don't let your dark memory go away.
The Dreamcast version has faster loading times, faster transitions between pre-rendered backgrounds, brighter lighting. Unfortunately, the Dreamcast's controller's lack of enough buttons and a single analog stick were a problem. The only aspects in which the PS2 version was better were the controls (due to the Dual Shock 2's double analog sticks and more buttons) and characters with moving lips. What BOTH versions are completely lacking is the MUSIC, which was very distorsioned; a problem also shared with the PC version. In this aspect, the PLAYSTATION1 Version was the only one to get it right, being the best one in this department.
I remember I played this game in DC and ps1 and both have fixed audio.
nunca me han gustado los colores de la ps2... les falta vida...
Dreamcast them like a 4K Machine, and Ps2 like a HD Ready Machine.
Dreamcast 👍
En Dreamcast se ve🤤🤤y mas rapido la carga de cambio de cámaras
Neste caso fico com a versão para Windows 98 devido a excelente dublagem em português da Brasoft, infelizmente a tectoy cagou no pau ao não trazer jogos em português para o Dream.
Me extraña que a estas alturas nadie se haya molestado en llevar el doblaje portugués a la versión Dreamcast. En el caso del doblaje castellano, la versión Dreamcast tampoco lo tenía de lanzamiento, pero hay un parche que lo añade a partir de las versiones PC y/o PS2 que sí lo tienen de serie.
La dreamcast era muy potente mejor que play 2 y muchos juegos lo hacen ver
Dreamcast: se nao fosse a sega imcompetente, muito possivelmente estariamos diante do melhor videogame ja lançado na historia da humanidade. Lástima
dreamcast version looks great :3
How I love Dreamcast ❤
The 6th gen versions of this game should have been rebuilt from the ground up like RE1make
The Dreamcast keep dream
Like all Dreamcast games PS2 conversions. Dreamcast Wins !!!
Its a pretty hollow victory, when its a pretty poor game to begin with.
There are a few games with a 480p mode on PS2, Alone in the Dark is obviously not one of them.
Is it just me or does the Dreamcast seem more fluid, even without the constant 1-second pauses?... The Dreamcast is the most underrated video game console ever, and as the years go by, it's only been more obvious. The GameCube is second on that list (that list being made up of my personal opinions and nothing else).
Those pauses were because DC had to wait for PS2 to finish loading. In real time there are no pauses while playing the game, only for this comparison.
The Dreamcast might win with Graphics but the PlayStation 2 definitely had better controls I had this on both consoles
I love ps2 but honestly it looked blurry then the other one, the other one had more crisp
Sega wins hands down
SEGA
I see squares popping up on the Dreamcast version now and again, but the Dreamcast version is much clearer.
Ken Kutaragi was right. The PS2 looks identical to a live action film. Good thing most people waited 2 years for his gift to mankind.
Yes, a good old VHS low resolution -footage on year 2001.
Games like GT4 and The Getaway look pretty realistic, shame the architecture was so bloody complex. It was still superior to Dreamcast imo when it comes to graphical complexity, but it should've been given it was released 18 months later.
DC still my favourite console though, for 1998 tech it was amazing
is it weird the ps1 version looks more crisp?
SEGA Dreamcast sempre a frente do seu tempo 💪🏼
240p please!
PS2 has better lighting , but I'll pick the Dreamcast version 😓
Esse jogo também tem pro PlayStation 1 e PC.
I loved this game on PS1, Keep em guessing.
Lol. According to one of the Sega fanboys who replied to me, this game would not run on the OG Playstation, not realize that was the original version.
The Dreamcast could look beter in specific games, but the Ps2 just got better with time with most of it's games being impossible on DC.
Ps2 was always blurry
I like this game for the ps2 even tho u play with the direction buttons,wouldve been better with the thumbsticks but u cant have everything lol
Incredible how bad the rain effect looks on ps2
Why is the ps2 version on 240p only. Even resident evil 2 on ps1 had better graphics.
O Dreamcast sempre teve as melhores versões
Leon ???
Dremcast vs ps2 vs wii👍
I think the Dreamcast looks sharper and has better color, but the PS loads faster. Of the two, I would definitely prefer the Dreamcast version, but I can see the possible argument that the softer visuals might smooth over some of the clunkier graphics in general.
O tempo todo no vídeo o cara pausou o dreamcast para esperar o carregamento no ps2, onde foi que viu que te fez concluir que no ps2 carrega mais rápido? Do que exatamente tu tá falando?
if PS2 games were on 4.7 GB or 8.5 GB DVD disc i imagine they would’ve loaded slower than a Dreamcast disc game 1.2 GB
The Dreamcast is actually the one who loads faster on this video. It gets paused on the editing so that the PS2 can catch up.
Is this game any good?
It's "aight" nothing special, but can be fun.
Wait...this games is dont only from PS1?
It's on DC - PS1 - PS2 and PC
Dreamcast vence, mas o do PS2 é a única versão que os personagens movimentam a boca nas cut scenes ! Nem a versão do PC tem isso! Não sei o motivo, mas poderiam ter colocado na versão do Dreamcast
Dreamcast melhor aqui
Tenho a versão Dreamcast aqui original. Bem melhor.
It didn't matter. %90 of people bought PS2 version.
I can’t really tell the difference
yo creo que este juego lo juge para ps1
DC absolutely slamdunked ps2 here....Again! What were the specs for Dreamcast and Playstation 2?
PS2 had a superior processing and RAM technical specification, but the DC has more video memory, sound channels and VGA digital video output, while the PS2 had the most it had was a component analog image.
O Dreamcast tem um boa saída de vídeo mesmo em composto em crt. e ótimo som. Já o PS2 em vídeo composto mesmo em crt é um show de horrores, o que salva é o cabo componente e conversores HDMI.
Mas o PS2 tem mais hardware, fato.
o pessoal se apega aos 8mb de vídeo do Power VR para falar que o DC era mais capaz .
PS2 - 6.2 gflops
DC - 1.4 gflops
@@Ychigo100 One thing to note is that the PS2 runs internally at 512 x 448i(2x224P) upscaled to 640 x 480i in 480i/P games, while Dreamcast GameCube and Xbox can do full 720 x 480P, 576P(GameCube) and native 1080i(Xbox)
Resolution is a BIG factor in performance, it can make the difference between playable and slideshow.
Dreamcast foi o melhor console da Sega que nem os Seguista, ou melhor, os meguistas compraram, uma pena.
Cara sou seguista...mas a sega tinha um hábito horrível...tentar compensar bons jogos em plataformas seguintes ... exemplo: ao invés de sair resident evil 2 pro Saturn, ele saiu pra Dreamcast, e se tivesse um outro port melhor em um console concorrente ela não lançaria no Dreamcast, ela faria outro vídeo game.
Isso quebra qualquer fã base.😢
@@carloshr2638 Resident Evil não é da Sega, pode ter sido escolha da Capcom não lançar nele pois na época, pois dizem que era difícil programar para o Saturno.
@@dougs408 eu sei ...falo no sentido de que ...ao invés da sega ter investido mais tempo e em mais jogos pro seus consoles, ela já ia lançando um outro console pra bater de frente com a concorrência... é até é um milagre por exemplo, o Saturn ter mega man x , aliens 3 etc ... Ao contrário das concorrentes a sega era péssima em portar jogos pros seus consoles ...mas em matéria de arcade ! Ela era nota mil .