The Most In-Depth Catan Analysis I've Ever Done

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
  • ➡️ Start Playing Catan FOR FREE: bit.ly/Colonis...
    ⭐️Follow Me If You Are Awesome:
    ➡️ Play in Tournaments HERE: / discord
    ➡️ TWITCH: / dylighted_catan
    ➡️ DyLighted Discord: / discord

КОМЕНТАРІ • 166

  • @Ther3tr0
    @Ther3tr0 Рік тому +265

    I understand it's a tournament setting, but if I played like this with my friends, I probably would not have enough friends after for another game. Still interesting to see Catan being played at such a level.

    • @boardgametotears
      @boardgametotears Рік тому +3

      My friends would just need to get better to keep up with me 😂.

    • @DyLightedCatan
      @DyLightedCatan  Рік тому +51

      Haha yea I wouldn’t do this with friends. This is just a cash tournament so everyone is trying to win

    • @CeilingPanda
      @CeilingPanda Рік тому +6

      Even so at some point you might get good enough to understand most situations and look at it from a more objective standpoint and not an emotional one

  • @AdamLighter1
    @AdamLighter1 Рік тому +107

    The most impressive win I have ever seen. From such an abismal position in the early game, you put yourself in the best position to get lucky with every action you did. And you did get lucky, many times. But thats what it takes to win from positions that would be abandoned by other players. You got a mono, you had a great opportunity to use it, you got those 2 VPs that you needed. Anyway, huge huge props to you man, it is DyLightful to watch you play the game

  • @Dminuspictures
    @Dminuspictures Рік тому +20

    The first time a 12 block has ever paid off.

  • @hehexdhehexd
    @hehexdhehexd Рік тому +36

    I was playing as Blue this game as my first Catan tournament ever, and somehow made it to the semifinals vs DyLighted with only a month or two of Catan experience. He table talked us really well and played good! In the end, I really didn't like my position, hopefully, I'll have a chance for that rematch!

    • @clementdenis4212
      @clementdenis4212 Рік тому +5

      I think cooperating with him still gave you your best shot at winning the game anyway. He gave some pretty generous trades.

  • @QYXP
    @QYXP Рік тому +52

    Your table talk remains completey unmatched, absolute master! I hope I can be that good one day

  • @thomasonsi2198
    @thomasonsi2198 Рік тому +20

    That was the greatest Catan game i've ever seen. I know you also talked on stream about ways to improve4 your commentary, and this was night and day better. Pacing, detail, truly a Gotham chess worthy commentary. Great Win

  • @clonerzzz
    @clonerzzz Рік тому +64

    you're killing it with these uploads, really helping me trough my exams

    • @lucasharder4511
      @lucasharder4511 Рік тому

      Yeaa, im in midterms as well.... sucks

    • @clementdenis4212
      @clementdenis4212 Рік тому

      Well some of us are teachers who have exams subject to write so overall he is keeping balance between students a d teachers.

  • @TheNoobsterForever
    @TheNoobsterForever Рік тому +45

    That was awesome! Great to see the table work together, and that awesome pull at the end

  • @AP-dc1ks
    @AP-dc1ks Рік тому +22

    I think Dylan somewhat overestimated his trading power using wheat. Because whatever he does, black does too (and eventually double). So he can't really set a monopoly price for wheat until black is embargoed by the table.

  • @dandydrew
    @dandydrew Рік тому +8

    Awesome video Dylan. I love how you raise the bar for the community. Let’s go! 🎉

  • @jondonjr
    @jondonjr Рік тому +7

    Wow you literally commanded red and blue like a sensei.. absolute miracles being worked here lol... Insane game. Best I've ever seen I think, it had everything!

    • @brownie3454
      @brownie3454 Рік тому +1

      Straight up Jedi shit. Dylan was the bright spot on an otherwise cringe af table

    • @Mateilenberg
      @Mateilenberg Рік тому +3

      Well, yeah. But essentially he made the table even with him, black and red. Blue was out, but red was very close as well.
      Pulling a VP was his only shot for the next rounds.
      While black and red had multiple ways to win

  • @pramodhsrihari493
    @pramodhsrihari493 Рік тому +13

    Watching Dylighted play is a true pleasure, loved the players working together this game.

  • @armaosk
    @armaosk Рік тому +3

    wow, that was an amazing demonstration of epic table talk. Dylan, you could esily be a member of the council in the game of thrones!

  • @smallsizedperson
    @smallsizedperson Рік тому +5

    This was the most impressive game I've seen you play! I was a bit concerned you were being too friendly with your trades with Red and Blue but it paid off!

    • @AquaCoalaNest
      @AquaCoalaNest Рік тому

      Lol, he ripped them off, that is the power of framing :)

  • @danthemaninapan
    @danthemaninapan Рік тому +3

    Fantastic video - a perfect combination of in-game discussion and post-game interjections to go into more depth. It provides entertainment and helps us viewers improve at the same time

  • @caseyvaughn4471
    @caseyvaughn4471 Рік тому +3

    Amazing game. You hustled a win out of the gutter, truly an inspiration!

  • @joshholder359
    @joshholder359 6 місяців тому

    i barely play catan but even I can appreciate that this was nuts from start to finish. tabletalk + strategy was so impressive

  • @adamwolyn9859
    @adamwolyn9859 Рік тому +1

    I’ve watched all your videos and this has to be the game with the best execution so far. Incredible gameplay!

  • @chrisnorwood0211
    @chrisnorwood0211 Рік тому +1

    honestly stunned you won that game. Shows that table talk is the way people win.

  • @elitecpudoc329
    @elitecpudoc329 Рік тому +7

    Dylan's table talk game is next level. What a win.

  • @acepie413
    @acepie413 Рік тому +3

    Looking forward to this video - Dylan always makes the greatest Catan content on the platform!
    One small critique off the bat; please leave a couple more seconds for us to pause the video during those 'What Would You Do?' segments before you tell us your answer.

  • @mohamedsalad2081
    @mohamedsalad2081 Рік тому +3

    have not watched it all yet but in DyLighted we trust

  • @jasonlavalleur
    @jasonlavalleur Рік тому

    Glad to see you're making content again. Hope it is still enjoyable for you. Liked the tip of using your own hand to easily track opponent cards better I hadn't heard that one before.

  • @apuroopkapavarapu8248
    @apuroopkapavarapu8248 Рік тому

    I watch every video of yours Dylighted. This was one of your best games ever!!
    You hustled like a boss. Well played!!

  • @gordogo912
    @gordogo912 Рік тому +2

    31:45 you had the least production. They had 35, you had 33. Red miscounted

  • @Goofygoobatron
    @Goofygoobatron Рік тому +1

    You’re literally a monster at coming back when the game is all but lost through table cooperation. Just nuts haha

  • @Ikosaeder11
    @Ikosaeder11 Рік тому

    Omg. I just rewatched your video about your first visit today. What a coincidence :D

  • @PikachuPlays
    @PikachuPlays Рік тому

    The synchronized scream and mic echo at 40:30 had me cackling

  • @dimitaranastasov1448
    @dimitaranastasov1448 Рік тому +1

    As soon as you start doing complicated trades with Delyghted you know it's over 😂

  • @LofiLofy
    @LofiLofy Рік тому

    Fantastic comeback, the ending was cinematic. The editing is excellent as well

  • @assanassa5985
    @assanassa5985 Рік тому +1

    I really thought you had no chance

  • @Tranzekno
    @Tranzekno Рік тому

    This has to be one of the most goated games I've seen

  • @Rombik97
    @Rombik97 6 місяців тому

    17:25 taxi driver xD

  • @kartikeyapandey1951
    @kartikeyapandey1951 Рік тому +1

    One of the best games I've seen.

  • @444thatssevenfours4
    @444thatssevenfours4 Рік тому

    Dylan this recent stream of videos has been awesome, thank you man!

  • @blueshell0
    @blueshell0 Рік тому

    Really thrilling content, also huge respect for keeping the up the fight against black!
    PS: cool, that you used Vivaldi - Winter at the end, some music is too good not to be used

  • @88ongbak
    @88ongbak Рік тому

    Ha ha that was crazy! Nicely done

  • @afroheaddudeful
    @afroheaddudeful 8 місяців тому

    Main character plot armor on the last pull bruv

  • @secondengineer9814
    @secondengineer9814 Рік тому +1

    Could you give another second or two between when you say "pause the video and try to figure X out"? I end up getting spoiled before I can hit the pause button

  • @cjShmoo
    @cjShmoo Рік тому

    This was the most incredible win I think I've ever seen in a Catan game

  • @niklas8470
    @niklas8470 Рік тому

    Please bring more videos, I love watching them

  • @philipeick-vocalmusic
    @philipeick-vocalmusic Рік тому

    Crazy how you managed to win this in the end!

  • @armadocardelon1006
    @armadocardelon1006 Рік тому

    On the turn you monopoly. After building a city (8 VP). You could have road built and traded the ores 3 for 1 twice for a road. road build (2) + 2 roads on board + 1 road is 5 roads getting longest road +2 VP and winning

  • @talmagejones
    @talmagejones Рік тому

    So cool to see the games with faster and more nuanced table talk

  • @rudyroker3
    @rudyroker3 Рік тому +1

    What an awesome video!

  • @slates7713
    @slates7713 Рік тому +4

    What about the 9-10 wood for the second pick? Get the 3:1 immediately and can expand over to the sheep

  • @davey645
    @davey645 Рік тому

    10:03 the future is now, old man

  • @dallasdeneve3540
    @dallasdeneve3540 Рік тому +1

    That was actually so insane

  • @felixdaubner3361
    @felixdaubner3361 Рік тому

    Let’s go wish you luck in the finals 💥🔥

  • @chaboki
    @chaboki Рік тому

    That was the most hype pull. I got way too into it 😂

  • @jamesmoens1455
    @jamesmoens1455 Рік тому

    I WENT OFF SO HARD WHEN YOU PULLED IT

  • @maxmustermann4337
    @maxmustermann4337 Рік тому +1

    can you not build road past other players settlements? Is this why he didn't finish with road?

  • @shoe7525
    @shoe7525 Рік тому

    God damn this is a great video

  • @calebshort2169
    @calebshort2169 Рік тому

    Freaking amazing game. I think when Dylighted plays better players. We tend to get the full Dylighted in these games. Though I do love more content.

  • @oliveguardian7757
    @oliveguardian7757 Рік тому

    would love to see more of this

  • @AquaCoalaNest
    @AquaCoalaNest Рік тому

    Episode name: "How can I justify my selfish motives as generous" :D

  • @DRFOP
    @DRFOP Рік тому

    Love the Vivaldi finish!

  • @shawnpretzel6182
    @shawnpretzel6182 Рік тому

    No one in that game deserved the win more than delighted. He had a good position at the start but got screwed almost out of the game till he got everyone to work together to stop black from winning. Ggs

  • @edwardmorris5977
    @edwardmorris5977 Рік тому

    You could’ve 1 at 38.16. You needed to build 1 city to get to 8. Then port 6 ore for 1wood,1brick to build a road+ road building to take road

    • @DyLightedCatan
      @DyLightedCatan  Рік тому

      you can't play dev cards the same turn you buy it and you can only play 1 dev card per turn

    • @edwardmorris5977
      @edwardmorris5977 Рік тому

      @@DyLightedCatan ohhhh you’re right! Oops!

  • @tengYT
    @tengYT Рік тому

    What a finish..

  • @alejandrogarcia9637
    @alejandrogarcia9637 Рік тому

    Amazing game! I learned a lot about extorsion, ups, I meant trading.

  • @nolannorman2006
    @nolannorman2006 Рік тому

    Best video out there

  • @Storm.999
    @Storm.999 Рік тому +1

    I would have taken 5 4 8 road right aswell, i’m getting more i to catan and i’m top 300 atm

  • @zHawkC
    @zHawkC Рік тому +1

    What's the reasoning behind not cutting off black with your first road going to the 4-3? You said red made a mistake pointing to the 3:1 port first rather than going towards the contested spot then you did the same. I know you 3:1d at the very end but with all the trades you were doing with your sheep and wheat you didn't need the 3:1 early either. Instead left the 4-3 open for black to plow for a long time and get them onto ore which you said was dangerous when they did get it. Also the weakness of your set up was low ore to pair with wheat sheep and double settling on the 4 would've helped.

    • @TP_Gillz
      @TP_Gillz 11 місяців тому

      I agree. That was the one mistake I think he made as well. But he would have to race red for it so he simply chose the safer option.

  • @BtKskul
    @BtKskul Рік тому

    I have a question
    When he had 9 points won't he had win if he hadn't made the city makes him at 8 and he saved 3 ore and 3 ore already in hand use them to 3:1 port for road and then road build and got the longest road

  • @jaxmilasincic1059
    @jaxmilasincic1059 Місяць тому

    38:15 doesn’t roadbuilding + 1 road (6 ore at 3:1) make 5 roads for the win?

  • @felske5
    @felske5 Рік тому

    wow insane comeback

  • @demetriousramirez
    @demetriousramirez Рік тому

    The psychological manipulation is crazy, it's kinda fun seeing people spot it properly though

  • @E_-_-
    @E_-_- Рік тому

    9:43 the story of my life in catan

  • @dankasaur
    @dankasaur 6 місяців тому

    i love you dylan

  • @jaimecornejo5674
    @jaimecornejo5674 Рік тому

    that was amazing

  • @chuuyanakahara4356
    @chuuyanakahara4356 Рік тому +1

    41:15 can't you just 3:1 ore and brick for wood, build 2 roads, and then road building for 6 roads and win with 11 points? You could build above black.

    • @chuuyanakahara4356
      @chuuyanakahara4356 Рік тому +1

      I don't play competitive Catan, so if settlements block the longest road, I wasn't sure. My bad if that's the case.

    • @michaelmoyer1647
      @michaelmoyer1647 Рік тому +4

      Settlements do block longest road. So pulling for the vp was his only option once black took his expansion spot

    • @roberttarlap4365
      @roberttarlap4365 Рік тому

      4 roads on 12 wheat and one road to 11-6 is 5 roads?

  • @thebossnittany
    @thebossnittany Рік тому

    This is an all timer.

  • @ggdroid
    @ggdroid Рік тому +1

    Nice game! I love it! 😊

  • @Vala7K
    @Vala7K Рік тому

    amazing video 🤩

  • @Tinskap
    @Tinskap Рік тому

    27:13 This was such an annoying moment to watch considering the alternative storyline was that neither of you have cities and black just runs away with the game, Comparing who has a better city when it's a blessing to have one in the first place.

  • @yshuttle
    @yshuttle Рік тому

    Great game and analysis

  • @mwysocz
    @mwysocz Рік тому

    I still can't believe what I just saw :)

  • @Mephisto707
    @Mephisto707 Рік тому

    3:21 I'd point my road to the right. Settling on the 9 wood early is better than the 12 wheat with port.

    • @jandjhroco
      @jandjhroco Рік тому

      You could easily get cut off by black who has much more wood and brick production

    • @Mephisto707
      @Mephisto707 Рік тому

      @@jandjhroco Black would rather go for 9 10 wood with port than plow White. Plus, if he plowed there, White could plow Black on the 8 3 Wheat on the other side.

    • @miriushaefliger5412
      @miriushaefliger5412 10 місяців тому

      @@Mephisto707 three for one port offers way more flexibility, and the chances are dylan will only need one expansion spot.

  • @danieljulia948
    @danieljulia948 Рік тому

    what a game broooo!!!

  • @josim650
    @josim650 Рік тому

    New to the game, but production at 32:08 . You are far behind everyone, it isnt 33-33 ?! Or how to count it ?

  • @itioticginger9520
    @itioticginger9520 Рік тому +7

    I know what the rules say, but it is definitely log, mud, rock, seeds, meat

    • @richbros1
      @richbros1 Рік тому +1

      I can agree with everything except sheep is always sheep

    • @itioticginger9520
      @itioticginger9520 Рік тому

      @@richbros1 What I think is crazy is that the official terms for the resources are lumber, brick, ore, grain, wool... who in the world says lumber ew

  • @alexanderklevangeikholm2625
    @alexanderklevangeikholm2625 Місяць тому

    Couldn’t he just take road in the end
    ?

  • @SnIR337
    @SnIR337 Рік тому

    I would've put the 2nd settlement on the 9 10 wood, get the 3:1 port, and build to the 2:1 wood port

    • @claudiusnero5025
      @claudiusnero5025 Рік тому

      I think that basically locks you out of sheep in am OWS-setup, as both blue and black are faster to the only sheep settling spot for you. Blue could easily get to the 11/6/3, and black would be one road faster to the 12/11/6. However, I admit it would probably no be their priority.

  • @burnt41
    @burnt41 Рік тому

    were sick? or a tired voice in the live video? I felt so bad watching this

  • @nigulh
    @nigulh Рік тому

    I thought longest road instead of the the third city would have been a better option.

  • @dustysageroutdoors
    @dustysageroutdoors Рік тому

    killing us with the ads.... too many

  • @mcsizzlitz1142
    @mcsizzlitz1142 Рік тому

    LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @turel528
    @turel528 Рік тому

    That's crazy :O

  • @kwikstah
    @kwikstah Рік тому

    Can you give some more tips for tracking? I can never remember what people have.

    • @DyLightedCatan
      @DyLightedCatan  Рік тому

      Play 1000 games and you’ll naturally develop it.

    • @kwikstah
      @kwikstah Рік тому

      @@DyLightedCatan How about playing fewer than 1000 games to develop it? :)

  • @reecei6425
    @reecei6425 Рік тому +1

    Think you were too nice with red and he even pushed back on the 2 future ores he owed

    • @ZeroTolerence0
      @ZeroTolerence0 Рік тому

      He did said not to get emotional about the game. It paid off at the end, since he won.

  • @hanneskr97
    @hanneskr97 Рік тому +1

    as constructive critisism
    You should try to speak slower and make less pauses. Maybe you make the pauses behind every word to slow yourself down but it feels a little bit like stumbling through your text.
    still like your content though

  • @prettyprinesspanda7
    @prettyprinesspanda7 Рік тому +1

    Could you give more time to pause so I can think of where is the best placement of initial settlements? I wanna guess before u talk through it to test my intuition.

  • @baselgersma5752
    @baselgersma5752 Рік тому

    Epic game, that was great

  • @butuzamihai6057
    @butuzamihai6057 Рік тому

    Can someone pls help me understand what does Pop mean? (I know when the term should be use in game but not what it means word for word)

  • @Justin-xz5gb
    @Justin-xz5gb Рік тому

    LETS GOOOOOOOOOO WHAT A DUB

  • @tylerhannah0215
    @tylerhannah0215 Рік тому

    incredible game
    perfect devs

  • @Maxtorch33
    @Maxtorch33 Рік тому

    This is hype

  • @Sunbeatle707
    @Sunbeatle707 Рік тому

    Beautiful game

  • @DrHeinzDoofenshmirtz
    @DrHeinzDoofenshmirtz Рік тому

    Awesome game!