PMLA Threatens the Basis of Indian Jurisprudence.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 236

  • @mahendratiwary3689
    @mahendratiwary3689 8 місяців тому +42

    Last but not the least thanks so much Kapil Sibbal sir ….. you are great. Lots of love ❤ and respect.

  • @JumgeSora
    @JumgeSora 8 місяців тому +14

    Learned lot about difference between PMLA & CRPC. Thank you Kapil sir for this discussion. Really a very draconian law, banaya tha terror funding & black money ko rokhne but iska kuch nahi kar k kuch aur hi kar raha hai ED is kanoon ka.

  • @salmansharieff3261
    @salmansharieff3261 8 місяців тому +6

    Sir, pls broadcast this video in many platforms....as much as possible. Very useful information. Great sir

  • @RuturajThorat
    @RuturajThorat 8 місяців тому +13

    Very interesting and very helpful discussion Kapil sir and Team

  • @SandeepSingh-ey4ih
    @SandeepSingh-ey4ih 8 місяців тому +12

    Sibal sb
    Lawyers with spine like you only can save our democracy and constitution

  • @basurao8503
    @basurao8503 8 місяців тому +23

    Kapil paaji we need many more of such interactions, discussions to be aired by U Sirji & your erstwhile team. 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @danishbiochem
    @danishbiochem 8 місяців тому +28

    Indian law and constitution has been reduced to a joke. "Presumption of guilt till innocence is proved" is considered an archaic, outdated principle in most of the civilized world, unthinkable, in any society that values due process and rule of law. Yet in India - perhaps owing to our unique knowledge and wisdom as Vishwagurus - we have decided the opposite. God save this country.

    • @pbghosh5305
      @pbghosh5305 8 місяців тому +1

      🎉

    • @ivyjacob8025
      @ivyjacob8025 8 місяців тому +2

      God will bless the INC party & the INDIA alliance with success in the LS Elections!!!

    • @jayendrashah2358
      @jayendrashah2358 8 місяців тому

      I don't understand why
      you have asserted that "Presumption of Guilt till innocence is proved is considered an archaic, outdated principle in most of the civilized world, unthinkable in any society that values due process and rule of law" unless this is your tongue-in-cheek comment.
      Innocent until proven guilty is universal and neither archaic not outdated and still applied in most countries and societies, which values in due process and rule of law.
      It is up to the accused or their representative to prove that they are innocent and the prosecution to prove that they guilty.
      If Kejriwal & co can't get release on bail, then that's SC's ruling based on the evidence it holds.
      Why should you blame Modiji, his Government and BJP?
      Also note that PMLA was enacted in 2002 and not in 2014 or thereafter.

    • @danishbiochem
      @danishbiochem 8 місяців тому

      @@jayendrashah2358 The presumption of innocence wasn't a single moment of change, but rather developed over centuries and is now considered archaic. Here's a breakdown:
      Roots in Ancient Law: The idea of a presumption of innocence has roots in ancient legal systems, but it wasn't always universally applied.
      Development in Medieval Europe: By the 13th century, the principle gained traction in Europe's common law tradition. However, there were exceptions, particularly for serious crimes such as murders and rapes, not corruption scams that come under civil laws.
      Formalization and Modernization: The concept wasn't codified in a single document, but gained prominence through court rulings and legal philosophies. The 18th and 19th centuries saw a stronger emphasis on fairness and due process, solidifying the presumption of innocence.
      While the exact date is hard to pinpoint, it's safe to say the presumption of innocence became a well-established principle in Western legal systems by the late 18th to early 19th centuries. India inherited these systems and thus it is fundamental to the Indian system that you be deemed innocent until proven guilty. These laws just inverse that fundamental principle.

    • @KVR8527
      @KVR8527 8 місяців тому

      Constitution says " every citizen is equal" Why so many privileges for minorities? Constitution has provided for reservation and benefits for deserving people
      Why amend constitution, to give reservation for Muslims?
      Constitution says there is no discrimination on the basis of caste or religion but Hindus are discriminated against by several acts .
      Why Wakth Board is required? Why Madrasa are required? Why triple talak minor wedding 4 weddings are required
      Why Hindu temples and temple funds are in the custody of govt
      Why diversity is not accepted by minorities by claiming that their God and their religion is only right so others should be converted?

  • @abhishekkumar-xn8vv
    @abhishekkumar-xn8vv 8 місяців тому +2

    Thank you for this discussion. This draconian law should be amended.

  • @mahendratiwary3689
    @mahendratiwary3689 8 місяців тому +12

    I am appalled to see the powers given to ED and to what extent they can misuse it. What is Supreme Court doing sitting on this draconian law for so long. They should suo-moto take cognisance of this and review it with immediate affect as it affects personal liberty. Or else only god can save India. Jai Sri Ram and Happy Hindu new Year to those who celebrate.

  • @sunandadavid4372
    @sunandadavid4372 8 місяців тому +20

    There is a gap between ED and Judiciary - but Judiciary is higher than ED - Judiciary needs to work this out!

  • @SaddamHusain-sk6my
    @SaddamHusain-sk6my 8 місяців тому +12

    Thankyou So Much Kapil Sir.... For Taking Very Good initiative to Understand Such Complicated Laws in Simple Language... Video is Very Informative

  • @hassobhatia2885
    @hassobhatia2885 8 місяців тому +3

    I watch Dil Se regularly. This was by far the best episode. It was eye opener how PMLA is such a draconian law that is used with ferocity, not against terrorsts or drug dealers but rather against ordinary citizens, opposition politicians, etc. Bringing in the day to day practicing lawyers to narrate their experience and legal minefields was truly great..my question is can Supreme Court do something to restore sanity in the PMLA implementation.?

  • @dineshb7002
    @dineshb7002 8 місяців тому +8

    Based on what I have listened, this law is being used to settle political scores rather than to tackle corruption.

  • @Realchap
    @Realchap 8 місяців тому +7

    Excellent discussion with brilliant panellists

  • @IM_NO_BODY_
    @IM_NO_BODY_ 8 місяців тому +7

    Most a waiting show, thank you sir...👍

  • @Siddhantsaini1
    @Siddhantsaini1 8 місяців тому

    Thankyou Mr Kapil Sibal for imparting this knowledge to common people
    Now we know how opposition leaders are being jailed for indefinite time without being prosecuted

  • @kr.manishpratapsinghchauha1837
    @kr.manishpratapsinghchauha1837 8 місяців тому

    @ Kapil Sibbal Sir, Sir, you have achieved every possible milestone in the field of law. I am also a lawyer and use to look forward to hear your arguments earlier from 2000 to 2004 till you became a minister in UPA. We all know you have always been a genius and more knowledable even than the Judges. But then there was an arrogance of superiority. This is your second innings for us . Now in this era of undeclared emergency I am seeing a new Kapil Sibbal , a super genius who has nothing to prove to anyone and who is emerging as a warrior fighting for the victims and a champion of law and justice, a self less crusader like Mr Prashant Bhushan but your canvas is bigger than him in a different way ( only lawyers can understand the difference and it goes without saying that I have tremendous, unparallel respect for Prashant Bhushan Sir, and I don't intend to compare the two legends in there own right) Its a great service you are doing for the people and for the nation. Now you are the torch bearer, unelected leader of the Bar. Consider me as your soldier in your fight to save the, constitution, and the Democracy and the people's fundamental rights. All the episodes of Dil say... are enlighting and this one is also wonderful as people know very little about the Draconian PMLA and its misuse by the govt. This episode needs to be viewed by maximum no of people to understand the realities of the dark era we are in. The people need to be enlightened and awakened, and its high time the Constitution beech should clear the anamolies of the act.

  • @BipinKumar-bo7hu
    @BipinKumar-bo7hu 7 місяців тому

    आम लोगों को पीएमएलए के प्रावधान के बारे में इतने विस्तार से बताने के लिए धन्यवाद। आगे और इसी तरह अलग अलग मुद्दे पे बात होनी चाहिए जिससे आमलोग भी कानूनी पहलुओं के बारे में जान सके।

  • @sunandadavid4372
    @sunandadavid4372 8 місяців тому +5

    The judiciary should do something about this - otherwise unfair to person being prosecuted.

  • @dranuragdeepiliindianlawin1168
    @dranuragdeepiliindianlawin1168 8 місяців тому

    हिन्दी या मिश्रित भाषा में इतनी बेहतरीन जानकारी वो भी सरल तरीके से, कमाल है, सिब्बल जी, आपके इस काम को और आपकी टीम के प्रति आभारी हैं, क्योंकि श्रेष्ठतम जानकारी आमतौर पर अंगरेजी में ही उपलब्ध है, आगे भी ऐसी जानकारी की प्रतीक्षा रहेगी, यद्यपि कि मैं PMLA के सख्त प्रावधानों के पक्ष में हूँ, और विजय मदनलाल चौधरी निर्णय को सही समझता हूँ, सादर

  • @shrikantc56
    @shrikantc56 8 місяців тому +1

    I am terrified by the power given to ED and the way they can misuse it in investigation. If a man is said that even his family will also be called for interogation that man knows that he can't do anything to avoid ED from doing this and as a last resort he says them what they want from him. Once again it's very terrifying just by the taught of it.
    Now i know why so many political party people are changing they parties. Its not because of money but because of the fear. And i have a huge respect for the people who are actually fighing for it because it needs a lot of mental strength.

  • @Divinenikhil17
    @Divinenikhil17 8 місяців тому +6

    Thank you Kapil sir ❤

  • @virinderdogra6086
    @virinderdogra6086 8 місяців тому

    Very articulated viewpoints,india must keep aloft its democracy. Jaihind.

  • @swapnilkadu639
    @swapnilkadu639 8 місяців тому +2

    Thank you so much for your great initiative...

  • @Nitin_Killawala
    @Nitin_Killawala 8 місяців тому +5

    VERY VERY ENLIGHTENING DEBATE….EVEN MODI BHAKTAS SHOULD KNOW THEY ARE ALSO VULNERABLE UNDER DRACONIAN PMLA!!!

  • @farhatkhan5905
    @farhatkhan5905 8 місяців тому +4

    You are really doing great work 💯💯💯 we proud of you, aap phir se congress join karna chahiye because we miss .....

  • @abhayjeetsinghrao5020
    @abhayjeetsinghrao5020 8 місяців тому

    I love how this panel is moderated and the clarity of procedural law Mr. Sibal's office helps us attain.
    Kind Regards
    Abhayjeet Singh Rao
    Counsel
    India and Ireland

  • @SnehaA-z9g
    @SnehaA-z9g 8 місяців тому +5

    What the All Agencies are doing now, trillions worth of Electoral Bond's case is exposed, no Investigation and arrest? Sitill Nadda ji, Modiji, Amit Shah ji and more peoples rooming around for Election process, what is going on? Why supreme court is not talking any action?

  • @anurodhbarnwal3852
    @anurodhbarnwal3852 8 місяців тому

    Thank you Sir for showing the truth in our country. This has chaged our view towards the present government.

  • @aviangami9496
    @aviangami9496 8 місяців тому +1

    very true facts and much needed topic to be debated ,analysis and put to action..sir kapil a renowned judge who knows pros and cons without any debate..this PMLA is more than a draconian law.

  • @sunandadavid4372
    @sunandadavid4372 8 місяців тому +4

    I like the fact that you are giving exposure to the younger generation! Thankyou🙏🏼

  • @K_Vjay
    @K_Vjay 8 місяців тому +1

    Mr. Sibbal Saab is great personality...and also very intelligent

  • @meditation8409
    @meditation8409 8 місяців тому

    Great enlightenment about PMLA. Have faith upon Supreme court of India who should definitely look into fault if any in PMLA.

  • @shivkumarsingh4425
    @shivkumarsingh4425 8 місяців тому +3

    Lucknow sir ji Namaste thanks for hindi programs

  • @KVR8527
    @KVR8527 8 місяців тому +1

    Constitution says " every citizen is equal" Why so many privileges for minorities? Constitution has provided for reservation and benefits for deserving people
    Why amend constitution, to give reservation for Muslims?
    Constitution says there is no discrimination on the basis of caste or religion but Hindus are discriminated against by several acts .
    Why Wakth Board is required? Why Madrasa are required? Why triple talak minor wedding 4 weddings are required
    Why Hindu temples and temple funds are in the custody of govt
    Why diversity is not accepted by minorities by claiming that their God and their religion is only right so others should be converted?

  • @AyanshPaul-e6f
    @AyanshPaul-e6f 8 місяців тому

    Superb quality of discussion ! Most important thing about this debate is explaining sections for common people's knowledge.

  • @nlchomal1131
    @nlchomal1131 8 місяців тому

    Kudos ...
    Kapil Sir...
    You are doing a valuable service to the Countrymen -- by enlightening them of legal system thru such video programs.

  • @trendyinsta42
    @trendyinsta42 8 місяців тому

    Beautiful ❤️❤️❤️ keep making such empowering content....🎉🎉🎉

  • @ramasatyanarayan9887
    @ramasatyanarayan9887 8 місяців тому

    Sir, you are great. Unfortunately several people are facing problems.

  • @nalininayak7830
    @nalininayak7830 8 місяців тому

    This was extremely informative but so unjust and frightening too. Thanks Sibalji

  • @umaprabhakar6435
    @umaprabhakar6435 8 місяців тому

    Excellent. Kapil Sibal. This time it was the men on the ground who are interviewed or discussion held. Hence it was real , practical and very very useful knowledge.

  • @deepaurora3
    @deepaurora3 8 місяців тому +1

    Very informative talk. An eye opener !!

  • @omarpeerzada1721
    @omarpeerzada1721 8 місяців тому

    PMLA is the Challenge to Rule of Rule & Role of LAW ...Very Informative discussion ❤

  • @brijbhushansinghrawat719
    @brijbhushansinghrawat719 8 місяців тому

    काफी कुछ नहीं बहुत मिल रहा है वैचारिक ऊंचाई साधुवाद

  • @RaviRanjan-vf9sf
    @RaviRanjan-vf9sf 8 місяців тому

    Thanks a lot Kapil Sir, one of the most informative discussions I have ever watched on UA-cam, Kindly bring more of such interactive discussions on different legal topics..
    Personally request you sir ,to bring 1, 2 interactive sessions on Election laws in india.....

  • @anjanamalhotra7593
    @anjanamalhotra7593 8 місяців тому

    Imagine what one can face, grounds of arrest are so frightening. The mental games the pressures could breakdown anyone

  • @Aayush8504
    @Aayush8504 7 місяців тому

    Every second of the discussion is worth it . 👍

  • @ajaywadhwa2185
    @ajaywadhwa2185 8 місяців тому

    Extremely educative! A must see for all students of law.

  • @KabirKhan-fr3fx
    @KabirKhan-fr3fx 8 місяців тому

    Wow....4 sharp minds..
    Amazing interection
    Hour of the week for me...
    Thank you Kapil sir

  • @rajanbhatia4890
    @rajanbhatia4890 8 місяців тому +1

    PMLA act should be amended so that Investigations which are deliberatly done not to give bail to accused.
    Who will return their lock up days if he is innocent after verdict.

  • @VaibhavMishraIN
    @VaibhavMishraIN 8 місяців тому

    What an explanation Sir.... Thank you...

  • @AniXedit
    @AniXedit 8 місяців тому +2

    I prefer Modi's dictatorship over Mamta's democracy.

  • @yashjain7035
    @yashjain7035 8 місяців тому +1

    Hats off to this initiative ❤

  • @jaroorisawal
    @jaroorisawal 8 місяців тому

    शानदार चर्चा. शुक्रिया.

  • @pencilpaper2949
    @pencilpaper2949 8 місяців тому

    We got to learn so much from this series, A big thanks to you sir for doing this. 💚 I WISH IF YOU COULD INCREASE THE FREQUENCY OF EPISODES.

  • @vinay.ambhore
    @vinay.ambhore 8 місяців тому

    Sir bahut dhanyavad Hindi me dil se lane ko.😊😊

  • @AMIRkHAN-vk1je
    @AMIRkHAN-vk1je 8 місяців тому

    Sir, Thank u for this important discussion.Whatever you do,you do from "Dil Se."

  • @mgpatilvijayapur1343
    @mgpatilvijayapur1343 8 місяців тому

    Excellent presentation by legal experts.

  • @pushpendergusain4262
    @pushpendergusain4262 8 місяців тому

    कार्यक्रम को हिंदी में देखकर अच्छा लगा। इससे कार्यक्रम की लोकप्रियता और पहुंच बढ़ेगी।

  • @ritwiksekhri1729
    @ritwiksekhri1729 8 місяців тому

    Such a bliss to listen to Kapil sir

  • @syedshahmohammed9050
    @syedshahmohammed9050 8 місяців тому +1

    Sir your all series are superb I really appreciate the way of expressions so elite & informative thanks

  • @arunsrivastava7804
    @arunsrivastava7804 8 місяців тому

    Excellent programme. Highly informative.

  • @sandeepnag1714
    @sandeepnag1714 8 місяців тому +1

    very appropriate headline !

  • @elvisambrose4461
    @elvisambrose4461 8 місяців тому +9

    Does Mr Modi have any shame, I doubt it. Even if a common man was shamed in so many ways, he would have stepped down immediately. What sort of skin does he have to be so thick skinned.

  • @nitishasthana03
    @nitishasthana03 8 місяців тому +1

    Very informative 👍

  • @urbanmonk6841
    @urbanmonk6841 8 місяців тому +1

    Interesting topic sirji! If English subtitles can be provided as well it would be nice for non Hindi speakers.

  • @sridharancr1542
    @sridharancr1542 8 місяців тому

    By this every law throughly debate & passed by the parliament can be nullified by a handful of people called judges. Great👌👌👌👌

  • @avtarsingh-hf4to
    @avtarsingh-hf4to 8 місяців тому +1

    Good job sir

  • @avinashsanil8165
    @avinashsanil8165 8 місяців тому

    The same law should be used against the current establishment.

  • @duvvuridp
    @duvvuridp 8 місяців тому +2

    The interesting point is PMLAA was enacted in 2005 when UPA 1 was in power. Mr. Sibal has much to answer this!

  • @Learn320
    @Learn320 8 місяців тому +1

    Sir you can teach us with board and marker because we are beginner's in law field

  • @roopashrisinha8378
    @roopashrisinha8378 8 місяців тому

    It's time for India Alliance to raise the PMCares funds issue in front of the people. This emtional issue of corruption by Modi Shah government during COVID will shake people's faith in Modi as an efficient leader

  • @kamalkannan36
    @kamalkannan36 8 місяців тому +2

    Hello Kapil sir its very breezy in current political scenario to listen your shows to have deep understanding about pressing issues with healthy conversation without any toxicity. Is it possible to add English subtitles to this kind of episode so that we (who dunno Hondi) can also view this.

  • @BadeBhai-v7p
    @BadeBhai-v7p 2 місяці тому

    You are real God sir. You are My hero Kapil sir.

  • @koshyvarghese9174
    @koshyvarghese9174 8 місяців тому

    Very good and informative discussion.

  • @rajnishgautam4572
    @rajnishgautam4572 8 місяців тому

    Superb discussion.
    Actually it's the media work to explain/discuss the normal people like me to know about PMLA... But they are godi/lapdog for a reason.
    Undeclared emergency.

  • @mukeshrathod5573
    @mukeshrathod5573 8 місяців тому +1

    This man is once was member of most corrupt party
    What happened to
    Chidambaram, do you think that it is justice to
    People of india
    Here discussion is only for big politician, they never debate for ordinary
    Law profile criminal or
    Ordinary person

  • @ManishPatel-pg1sw
    @ManishPatel-pg1sw 8 місяців тому

    Manav ta ko khatm karne ki baat hai thanks thanks Kapil sar ji

  • @hassobhatia2885
    @hassobhatia2885 8 місяців тому +1

    Why there’s no PIL against the practice of PMLA abuse by ED.?

  • @manojrai9562
    @manojrai9562 8 місяців тому

    आप बहुत अच्छे हैं।❤🌹🌹🙏🙏🇮🇳

  • @khanyariduja1070
    @khanyariduja1070 6 місяців тому

    Bright fellows. Due to them democracy is still in hope

  • @mahinderkumar1013
    @mahinderkumar1013 8 місяців тому +1

    Sibal lawyer hai. Now he has started extra - legal work of bringing various elements,including some polititicians on a portal to enlighten(?) or to pressurise😅 Iss new dukan kholne ka purpose kya hai😂

  • @duvvuridp
    @duvvuridp 8 місяців тому

    every party in power would love to have this law as it is "a lawless Law".

  • @Indus65
    @Indus65 8 місяців тому

    In an interesting hearing before DHC, an ED official was seeking anticipatory bail for himself upon receipt of summons from his office. It was opposed by ED saying that it was only calling the concerned official for obtaining information and had not decided whether as an accused or a witness. After the matter had been heard for nearly two hours,, the counsel for ED agreed to inform the petitioner before impending arrest to enable him to apply for anticipatory bail. If ED can be so strict against its own officer, its stand against others can be imagined. The apex court should examine the PMLA so strike a balance between the needs of the investigators and rights of people being summoned by them.

  • @rahulaggarwal8422
    @rahulaggarwal8422 6 місяців тому

    Thanks for information

  • @gitasen7689
    @gitasen7689 8 місяців тому +1

    A totally Brave New World world!

  • @duvvuridp
    @duvvuridp 8 місяців тому

    Rule of Law and due process! What are we trying to prove in the nation.

  • @pany167
    @pany167 8 місяців тому

    PMLA is undeclared Emergency in this country

  • @SureshKumar-xc8up
    @SureshKumar-xc8up 8 місяців тому

    True,must do something

  • @ojoao5237
    @ojoao5237 8 місяців тому

    Sir you are a Prime ministerial material in today's politics of India

  • @madhumadhusudan494
    @madhumadhusudan494 8 місяців тому

    Do you have an english version of this program

  • @tobiasjulian
    @tobiasjulian 8 місяців тому

    Is this available in English?

  • @surenm4981
    @surenm4981 8 місяців тому

    This kind of discussions bring out the draconian sides of our legal system. Matter of great concern when the like of current BJP govt misuses them for their undemocratic agendas.. Sibal Sir, your efforts are much appreciated.

  • @fizani.husain.advocate5623
    @fizani.husain.advocate5623 8 місяців тому

    Urgent PIL shud be filed in Supreme Court to get ths Act repealed...

  • @theophilusdsilva8531
    @theophilusdsilva8531 8 місяців тому

    Citizens have every right to know the any case against them. This is fundamental right and should be rightly worded incase of wrongly worded against citizens. All courts have the right and duty to correct this draconian law.

  • @gilbertdsouza7752
    @gilbertdsouza7752 8 місяців тому +1

    Why none has contested PMLA in SC ?

  • @tusharpotdar5762
    @tusharpotdar5762 8 місяців тому +1

    @2:51 ... जो कलंकित पैसा हो, उसको अगर वैधानिक, जायज आय बताकर सफेद करनेका काम करेंगे तो उस करतूत को मनी लाॅडरिंग money laundering बोला जाएगा
    तब फिर
    जो कलंकित व्यक्ति हैं, उसे वैधानिक, माने अच्छे आचरण वाला व्यक्ति, सतपूरुष, बताने के प्रयास को क्या कहना चाहिए?
    Human laundering, or Human Trafficking
    😁😁😁
    सर तो मोदि तो फिर दलाल कहलाए जाने चाहिए, नहीं!!

  • @cooffe2nik
    @cooffe2nik 8 місяців тому

    Courts have participated in ending democracy in India. Not a lawyer, but why this PMLA law has not been already scrapped by the Supreme Court. It's completely against basic principles of the constitution.

  • @subhesuranjan5482
    @subhesuranjan5482 8 місяців тому

    ❤❤❤PIL should be filed against anti defection law 10 th schedule.. Otherewise a party having 6000+ cores can buy any mp mla, Do something sir to stop horse trading , Do something it's the high time ...❤

  • @satyendramishra4051
    @satyendramishra4051 8 місяців тому

    You are great