#boycottHajj
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 гру 2018
- In a recent article on Slate.com, the author says regarding Hajj, “Saudi Arabia has turned the holy journey into a political and moral nightmare. I don’t see how I can go.” When I googled Boycott Hajj, articles upon articles popped up about this issue - in fact, there is also a petition, now closed, on change.org calling for boycott Saudi and boycott Hajj. Given that Hajj is one of the five pillars of faith, how should we make sense of this issue? As always, let’s sit down and talk to Dr.Shabir Ally and learn more?
___
Please SUBSCRIBE to SUPPORT the show!
Questions: www.QuranSpeaks.com/Contact
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Twitter : / quran_speaks
![ОРБАН приехал к ПУТИНУ и "отчитался" о поездке в Киев 😁 [Пародия]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_0ukDovOWq8/mqdefault.jpg)
Mecca and Madinah need to be a separate country from Al Saud ul Najd. Similar to how the Vatican is not a part of Italy. That completely neutralizes the political aspect of Hajj. Reason why it's not happening is because Najdi House of Saud profits from the prophets.
This is AMAZING. LOVE IT!
We should liberate Mecca from Saudi regime not boycott.
And then we will do muharram( beat ourselfs) in makka and celibrate birtday of the prophet( pbuh) in madina.
Prophet Muhammad pbuh didn't do pilgrimage till mekka was liberated that's all we need to know
mochaman11 go read conquest of Makkah from 7th grade Islam history books.
Yes he did not the hajj but the umarah
Yeah, and this happened because they had an agreement with the mushrikoon permitting them to go. Nonetheless, they did have the intention to do Hajj anyway until Abu Suhail prevented them to do so and they signed the treaty of Hudhaybiyyah AND received the reward for Hajj.
@@rickyusuf8696 you mean suhail ibn amr
2BeStbros Jazakum Allahu Khairan for correcting me, bro! :-)
The Hijaz is under the occupation of a violent group of highway robbers that were placed there by the imperial British state. We as Muslims need to seriously consider ways of starving this imperial creation out of existence and boycotting the hajj is one possible way.
Don't do the pillars when able is disbelief.
It doesn't matter who is in control, you are going for Allah and only Allah... He is not going to ask about what they are doing....... We should be worried if he accept our hajj not about the money, politics or what others are doing..... I don't even know Allah accepted one of my prayer or any good dead I have ever done........ We don't know and we should be worried about what will happened in the dark grave... I guarantee you no one will be worried about politics or what's going..... Hajj is a piller of Islam and calling for a boycott is just like calling for not praying or not giving zika....
gaili osman what so it's acceptable that a bunch of desert gangsters should extort and create a racket out of the hajj?
Where exactly does your zakah go as poverty is rampant in Saudi Arabia? Do you think that the Alsaud mafia fairly distribute the wealth generated by the ummah or the oil trade?
The hijj belongs to Allah regardless of political issues all muslims from around the world have the right to go to it.
Go to Hajj / Umarah when ever you can. This is religious Muslim do.
Don't use this as a political issue.
Most of us muslims couldn‘t even boycot coca-cola you really think we will boycot a holy place? That would be a really bad joke.
boycott the al saud
MD.Muzahidul Islam Samrat *Ahl saud
Who told you to boycott??? your ownself or you have a true based on quran n sunnah to boycott one of the 5 pillars of islam
What hajj has to do with al saud
@@dawnrise761 actually that would be less degrading as we don't have to deal with the zio-slaves rather we will deal with the slave master directly
It is Allah's test...
Whether you will go for Hajj with your money or will you buy iPhone...?
Boycott the Sufis more like.
No Muslim should make such a statement: "Boycut Hajj" just as they wouldn't say "Boycut the Prayer, Fast, Zakat, Shahaadah"
Abdullah ibn Umar (ra) narrated that he saw the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) making tawaf of the Ka’bah and saying, “How delightful you are, and how great is your scent! How magnificent you are, and how great is your sanctity! But by the one in whose hand is the soul of Muhammad, the sanctity of a believer, his wealth and his blood, is greater in the sight of Allah than your sanctity, and we do not think of him except good.” (Ibn Majah)
Mekka and medina should be international cities with ambassadors from every muslim country.
Our poor muslim countries feed aal e yahud billions of dollars in the name of hajj and umrah every year. Like for example pakistan, we always don't have much dollars in our trade account but we'll feed all the remaining dollars to saudis who are already the richest people right now. And what they do for us? Nothing, just nothing to give push to our economy. This shows how much arabs care for their so called "brothers and sisters".
I agree we cannot boycott Hajj but opt not to select a package that has accommodation in the clock towers for example. Those calling for a boycott of hajj I'd question their level of Eeman
You don't like the custodians of the 2 holy sanctuaries so boycott 1 of the 5 pillars that you'll personally be held accountable for ? What lost people. These people have ulterior motives, this is just a smokescreen.
The custodians are trying to destroy the religion.
Anab Keenadiid 😂😂😂😂 political Muslims on the brinks of disbelief
Boycott the criminal Zionist regime of Saud protected by the west
How can someone even think this way, fix your conviction and dont mix up Gods commandment and todays political issues, which will come and go. You stay firm to Allah's command till your last breath. This is a devils action and may be someone who wants to divide muslims is doing this. Stay united brother and sisters.
This is crazy !!! Hajj will and should never never be boycotted its a pillar of Islam. Anyone who can afford should go or fund someone to go.
hajj supposed to be free no visa
First visa is free. Check your fakts.
Also there are a billion people,
If someone cannot do hajj or omrah he is not forced to do it. As long as you can you go.
Some pwople go there yearly, thats why the charge is added for people who go there alot.
I liked it
Did you hear about the recent Enrique Iglesias music concert in Riyadh?
Granted it was not in Mecca or Medina but it was in KSA
Those Muslims at the concert were jiving to the music
What’s your take on this ???
If boycott will save one life. Then it's our duty to boycott. How does one go if Saudi government threatened them. Because they spoke up against the injustice. And if you go your life may be in danger. It's not as if the Saudi government won't kill you.
Study the story when Mecca was governed by Hajjaj, the cruel governer, of what the pious scholars did during that time, to answer this question.
As a Saudi I support boycott the hajj please stop coming here. What my government give billions over the years and if we charged the real cost of coming to Saudi and live there for weeks then you won't be able to ever come here. Again don't talk my word just boycott hajj.
Just amazed and astonished at the number of people taking up the role of “All Mighty “ in passing judgments regarding whether a person is (Muslim or not) or who is kafar.
Be afraid of what you do?
I say boycott the whole kingdom let’s take them down!!
Don't forget the other gulf states too
Question: Apparently there is a "season" associated with Hajj. Is it required that people attend Hajj only during the State designated period, or can people go when they choose? Speaking for myself I think the experience would be more moving without the press of the crowds.
@mochaman11 Thanks. Is that by Islamic tradition or is that a Management decision by the Saude government?What I am working to ask is whether I as Muslim could buy a plane ti cket to Arabia and then travel to Mecca on my own to circle the Kaaba seven times? Thoughts?
@Bruce Sims. You may visit the Kaaba outside of the days of hajj. This is called umrah. It however only includes visiting the Kaaba and not the rites of hajj in the places of Mina and Arafah
@@zaheeressop8270 Thanks so much. I have watched a few programs on the Hajj but believed that the many activities associated with the event were embellishments added over time.My bad. So the Quoran and the Prophet (pbuh) had laid out a particular number of experiences that an individual was expected to engage in over and above simply traveling to Mecca. I'm guessing that there must be some recording of ones participation in these activities, like a certificate or something, right?
@@brucesims3228 Hajj is a pilgrimage that takes place in the month of Dhul Hijjah. It is compulsory for Muslims to perform the Hajj at least once in their lifetime if they are financially and physically able to. There are various practices and rituals that are attached to the Hajj.
Outside that month, for the other 11 months of the year, Muslims can visit Makkah as often as they want to perform the lesser pilgrimage, the umrah. The umrah is not compulsory upon Muslims but there is great reward for it. Muslims can also visit Makkah and just pray at the Kaabah, in the Grand Mosque, or even just attend classes, or simply to contemplate and spend time away from the hustle bustle of this world.
There is no certificate to prove that you have done the Hajj or umrah as you dont do it for worldly benefit, you do it to obey God.
Alhamdulliah, this is great information. The brother gives a well-balanced answer. Charles Shabazz
I think we should go back to the way hajj was INITIALLY intended by Allah. Its not a 10 day period. Hajj is a 4 month period. People cram into the short window out of ignorance and laziness if I can be honest. Not lazy physically but mentally. Most muslims dont read Quran enough to understand what actual rights/freedoms they truly have. With that said i can damn sure understand why people want to boycott. Idk if that will change the saudi gov't devilish mindset but its a start.
I think we should do as prophet Muhammad pbuh did he didn't do hajj till he liberated Mekka
I'm not sure how some Muslims can think that Allah is waiting for them in Makkah while many of their countries, families, and countrymen in need, in poverty, and are dying due to the lack of health care and nutrition, then they go spend huge sums to just feel psyched-up and be amused with the holy sites, and maybe shed a tear or two, thousands and thousands of miles away from those who are in urgent need of any help available.
Let me put it simply in this example, if one of our neighbours is in urgent need of a medicine and we only have 5 dollars, should we spend those 5 dollars to get to the masjid and pray in congregation and get "phsyced-up" or should we think it's a must and more of a priority and obligation from Allah to help our neighbor?
Some Muslims have lost any kind of common sense. Allah is free of need, he doesn't need us to be at places, he commands us to worship Him alone with every single step we take. Rituals are just a part of the recipe, but all the rituals in the world can't save a selfish arrogant spirit. It baffles me when I see some Syrians are paying thousands of dollars to travel to hajj while other Syrians have nothing nutritious to eat, their underaged kids are working and have left education, and have no shelter, what kind of destruction is waiting such an Ummah? I think we are witnessing the results but more is yet to come unless we wake up and believe in the one True God, Allah, and disbelieve in the god that our history and culture have created!
This is disbelief at its core. Just as a group of people boycotted zakat at the time of Abu Bakr, they were declared as disbelievers!
Balance is the way to go indeed
I have a question:
Who are Yazidis and were there Sunnis when the battle.of.karbala happened I'm confused are Yazidis Muslim or Sunni so confusing who killed hussain? Was it Yazidi or Sunni Muslim? And why do we hate the Yazidi please help me out someone.thx! *please dont skip this if u know I'm a confused person*
That's our holy land no one can stop us from going anyone trying to stop us. Boycott the boycott
No one's stopping you btw
Oh really? So you don’t need a visa to go there? Not just any visa, a special visa just for that.
Jafar Khan that would be the Muslim thing to do does anyone believe in the qudrulllah anymore? Allah wil expel whoever he needs to expel in so time.
How do you boycott a commandment of Allah swt? No worldly affairs should come in between your relationship with Allah swt right?
wonderful video
May Allah bless you
Why not boycott the price, instead of hajj itself
A very sofisticated talk about a religion that denies the divinity of Christ and yet came 600 years after.
I can't help but looking at his beard. It's fecking mesmerizing.
I agree to this boycott movement until the sacred cities are freed from the occupation of the Najd ( AKA - head of satan or Qarn al shaytan )
The music makes it hard to hear what you sayin
The scholar is trying to be diplomatic and should give solid straight answers.
Do not boycott hajj. You only have to perform once in your life. That's it once only. Other than that do not go anymore. There were many muslims went to mecca over and over again. This got to stop.
Rarely do I see an America-Muslim broadcast without thinking that the further one travels away from Madeenah, the more innovative people's practice of the religion generally becomes.
Whilst i admire dr shabir ali , i really cant see how he can encourage people to go hajj and pay money into a country that is not only embarassing islam, but murderous and blood sucking, and they very openly support the state of israel today. This must be boycotted and it will be. You cant close your eyes and ears to this trouble and go and do a religious pilgrimage.
We Muslim's will go to Hajj, but it's an atrocity what's happening in Yemen and more by the Saud's.
@@Ahmed-ef3bg many people will boycott it temporarily until the govt falls. This is a necessity. I cant go their and feel religious and spiritual whilst there are humans killed and massacred by the govt im going to be indirectly helping during the pilgrimage
@@just2comment-295 they want to destroy the worth of the sacred sites.
You can sanction them etc. Muslims don't do this to other countries but now want to do this to the Hajj 🙅😬
@@jbaron8120 al saud are the only ones that destroy the sacredness of the holy cites. Stop calling everyone that opposes ur beliefs as 'they' and focus on the critism itself. Not all people are ill willed
@@just2comment-295 but you will feel ok buying your iphones and stuffs that goes to western governments who sponsor people and resources to fight your religion?
The same government that sells the weapons to Saudi are now turning to you and whispering, dont go to one of the obligation of your religion, youre making them rich.
What state we Muslims are in?
The sauds also banned millions of Palestinian from doing hajj too. So yes, BoycottHajj. Boycotting haj doesn't mean that you abandon your beliefs in doing hajj but this a rather a political pressure or pressure from muslim ummah worldwide.
You haven't been burdened with politics why force yourself into it ? People baffle me.
@@anabkeenadiid8279 Why people always make complicated, it baffle me too. I am not forcing anything. It's very simple form of protest. It's actually more of solidarity rather than politics with fellow muslims who are denied hajj by the Sauds.
You are pure filth. Where is your proof? And what reason?
My mom was trying to go and she is Canadian and they refused to give her a visa because of the Canadian and Saudi issues.
@@yunischanel9389 really? She was trying to go hajj or umrah?
Sister looks tired!!May Allah give her strength and bless her!!
Let be Muslims not because of the Saudi royal family.They are accountable to their actions. Their actions doesn't prevent u from going to Hajj.Are we going to hajj to please the Saudi royal family?Do your deeds for the sake of Allah. Weather hajj or any other good deeds,do it for sake of Allah.Will u leave Islam because some people leave Islam?Go to hajj not to please Saudi royal family but to please Allah.Let leave buy the teachings of Islam.
Next the same people will say boycott the Salah (Pray), Zakat, Ramadan and at the end boycott Muslim. Whoever said that boycott Hajj is not the Muslim. A foolish can do that.
This was a great video with great explanation on why it is not smart to boycott Hajj. First of all it is one of the five pillars, meaning it is 100% necessary to complete before we leave this world, no matter what, and since Hajj is seasonal people have to go as soon as they can and not put it off till Saudi changes, or for any other reason because as he said in the video "life is short", we don't know what could happen to us to make us incapable of going or unable to do so. Second, boycotting Hajj as a weapon to use against the rulers of Saudi will not make any difference, the majority of people who go to Hajj don't really know much about Saudi politics and are really devote muslims, so they would perform the hajj no matter what Saudi does, because their intention is to do it for Allah not to put money in the pockets of the Saudi royals, it just happens to work out that way. Third, in order for a boycott of Hajj to actually have an affect to have the Saudi royals change its behavior, it must be a massive boycott that lowers the number of people going by the millions. Lastly, Saudi is a really rich country I'm not sure anyone knows howe much Hajj makes up for their GDP. For all we know Hajj is only a small fraction of its overall wealth and boycotting the Hajj will not hurt them in the slightest. So in conclusion I believe if people want to make Saudi suffer for their human rights violation, they should maybe fight political in their country. For example, apply pressure on law makers to cut Saudi trade and support, or push for governments to sanction the royals. They are multiple ways to punish Saudi for their actions, but boycotting Hajj one of the five pillars of out great religion is not one of them.
Why not go to Jeruzalem instad?
Let the Quran Speak
Moses (PBUH) said to Pharaoh Let my people go for Hajj. Exodus 5:1
The Al Saud family have also destroyed historical and archaeological Islamic heritage and history to build Hilton and Swiss Hotel on E.g houses of sahabas etc. This alone makes them unfit to look after makkah and madinah. The sites should be looked after by an international council of Muslims.
This is a sign to the Final Hour. At a time of pilgrimage no one will go.
And I always thought of this.. and it’s people and organisations like this who are going to achieve this.
May Allah destroy them.
Aameen!
That's after it gets destroyed and that won't be before the time of nabi isa because he's going to perform pilgrimage. And allah knows best
Hajj is NOT compulsory , only if you can afford you can do it. Before Hajj the obligation upon us is calling people towards Islam. Spend your time , money & energy to gain knowledge in comparative religions + science & history & preach Islam to the mankind & that should be the prior to the Hajj.
You are so beautiful, innocent and inteligent!
Thank you Dr. Shabir Ally! As always enlightened!
There are other countries where people are blabbering officials to get a chance to years before. I think we should apply direct to Saudi hajji Web site than the country official. This is mostly in Africa and Asia countries.
I wish i could go but finding halal money in the uk is extremely hard as Bengali and Pakistani people all own businesses via haram Means. May Allah protect us.
Assalam walaikum brothers and sister s. Do your hajj don’t avoid it. It’s only going to be your loss. Don’t boycott hajj. To do evil things by saudis they don’t need hajj money. If you really understand there economy then you see that they keeping America float with buying billions of dollars of weapons.
It’s only my view. I am not a scholar. Love you all
If people want to boycott Hajj to hurt Alsaud financially that they depend heavily on then it's their choice and you are not their judge. They will be at sin and will hold your burden for not doing Hajj because Allah does not accept you putting yourself in harms way and 1 drop of a Muslims blood is more precious than the Kaaba. Once these mufsidene are removed then we can continue.
I am not surprised that there is a American Muslim movement to boycott Hajj .
The US has a very strong and organised Shia presence which is loyal to Iran. Who believe that Najf is more important than Makkah.
BTW Hajj generates around 2 billion dollars to the whole Saudi economy. Government coffers lose money.
Do Hajj if you can afford it. Do it while you can afford it, while you have life and health. If any of these are missing, you will regret not performing Hajj while you could have.
Also, why is it a mandatory Pilar to make Hajj, doesn’t that mean it’s making it a black mail and burden for Muslims to perform Hajj, guaranteeing money for the host nation I.e. (Saudi Arabia)? How do people not see this? Just because God says if you don’t do it you’re going to hell or lower level of heaven and bad deeds not wiped out? Someone please explain other than saying Allah ordered you to do it and made it a Pillar of the faith.
those calling for this boycott are people who are bored, have empty lives, and are attention seeking. Had I the finances to perform the Hajj, I'd be there in a flash. InshaAllah one day.
I have a very bad problem,i don't have bad medical problems. I know Because my minde is stable enough I can't boycott The Haj..😔 😔 😔 😔.
Salam
Please review a book published recently
The curse of God
Shoutout to sheikh ibrahim 👌
Where this fatwa came from that you do hajj if you have money? The land was given to the Muslim so they can do hajj, why it's costing now? Hajj was always free, but now they change everything, they put 5 star hotel,visa fee, and you name it. So no matter what,you can't do hajj without money. This is corruption, if you can't talk against it than you have problem
As a Saudi, I say to the muslims boycotting Hajj, Makkah is welcoming every muslims want to come, but involving politics in this will hurt only youre relation with Allah.
So, think twice before anything.
Rasullallah said help the zaleemun...then Sahabah said how can we help Zaleemun...Zaleemun are killing the people.and helping him? .. Rasullallah said help him by stopping and preventing him from doing zaleem...if boycotting hajj is helping zaleemun stopping the zaleem...why not?
Wow I can't believe people even thought about "boycotting" a command from ALLAH. What's next "boycotting" fasting in Ramadan cause we want to send a message to the government?
I remember before the war in Yemen Muslims were complaining, why Saudi is not doing anything for other Muslim countries? now the same people are complaining, why saudi is in a war?
I am Yemeni and I support Saudi Arabia. But hypocrits will bring any excuse to attack Madina and Macca.
Good Job....
Is this sister married?
If not how am I supposed to contact her mahram?
I see Sabir wouldn't use his own words when asked how he feels about the Saudis exploiting the Hajj. Where's your spine Sabir? This guy...🙄
"We should correct them?" Really Dr Shapir? And where is the Zakat for Yemen people?
I dont agree with the high hajj prices...
can a single lady go haj by herself?
People not understand, it's not about abandoning one of Islamic pillor, hajj is the second 💰 machine for saud family they are using that 💰for evil did. Allh see and know the intention if you have plan to do hajj and you didn't do it for that purpose.
Mecca must ensure the profit from Hajj goes to poor Muslim country, it's billion dollars, they can't keep it all for their pleasure... It's Umma money and must be returned to Umma...
Allah ordered hajj and nobody has right to call for boycott. These are really brave that want to prevent what Allah ordered.
Did you all know that if you take ALL of the prayer directions from ALL the mosques from the 1st hundred years , they actually point to Petra? Not only does it fit the geological descriptions of Mecca, it has the Crescent carved there . There's even some evidence that the black stone was moved during a war. And, as it is thought to be what was referred to as Becca, it's believed to have been changed in ancient documents to Mecca. ( the arabic letters are very close and would have been very easy to change )
If anyone is interested, look up Dan Gibson introduces " The Sacred City" It's about an hour and a half documtary and very much worth the time
Deluded beyond reason.
Ahmed
Did you watch it? It gives incredibly compelling evidence.
@@flawedandbeautiful4166 so now i have to see evidence from a non muslim ? Srsly ? I will go to guys like adnan rahisd who r historians in Islamic teachings aswell
it's completely incorrect. the first qibla was jerusalem, so in the general direction of petra. this changed to mecca even in the Messenger PBUH's time, in fact he even indicated how to orient the mosque in Yemen (pretty miraculous that, it points directly to the kaaba despite the long distance). Western documentaries are rarely well-documented regarding islam (or anything else for that matter)
This brilliant idea I been Waiting this boycott so long pps of all Faith stand up against suad house . devils working brings us ....headache.go ⏰ 👀
Hajj will stop in the next year or so. We are getting to that point.
Though I am an admirer or Dr. Ally Shabir, I would very much like to point out that he made no outright effort condemning the Saudi government for their actions or offered a viable,impactful solution to the problem. The interview was a waste of time.
Love you religion Allah said you would be tested,what a test the believer go through just to be witnesses for Allah,subhanallah big rewards coming believers don't anger to much the believers does always get tested enjoy,seek Allah thru prayer and patience it's really true this our opportunity to practice enjoy smile و لله الحمد
It’s like you’re saying boycott Islam, because hajj is a pillar of Islam. Are you doing hajj for Allah or Saudi.
God will test us all.
Question: Can we get an explanation, from where the five pillars of Islam originated? Thanks :)
It has been derived from a famous hadith known as Hadith Jibreel. An occasion when Angel Jibreel met the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him in the presence of his companions, may Allah be pleased with them.
Jibreel asked the Prophet PBH what is Islam? The answer was the five pillars.
@@amansur1 Famous doesn't necessarily mean it is accurate also, anyone from the academic point would dismiss your argument. My question is to the scholar, not from the commentators. Thanks
The Quran. All the five pillars are being commanded in the Quran.
@@tuahabadar I doubt that any academic will dismiss the argument as it is in authentic hadith.
Below is an example which is very straight to the point:
“Islam is built upon five [pillars]: the testimony that there is no god but Allaah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allaah; establishing regular prayer (salaah); paying the zakaah; Hajj (pilgrimage) and fasting Ramadaan.” (Al-Bukhaari, no. 8)
@@amansur1 Again, perhaps I wasn't straightforward enough to express myself that your argument is not compelling, thanks for sharing what you know, but I am not interested in your point of view, as i am asking from the Scholars not the commentators, unless you are a scholar yourself, have written books that have been peered review and you hold a PhD in either of the relevant field such as history, anthropology, psychology, human behaviour, etymology and religion. Which i believe you clearly don't and that is why you are presenting me the references of Bukhari hadith which was collected after two centuries from oral tradition to written, and no the prayer doesn't mean salah, the salah means establishing a connection (you can review any Arabic etymology for Hijazi dialect). Hajj, on the other hand, was done way before there was any Islam (you can read Arab history).
I hope it satisfies your urges to keep responding with references. Since my question is not for you, I would clearly not be satisfied with your make belief education.
Very balanced views! Thankful to have found your channel.
Why do you go and kiss a black stone? This would make it an idol.
I read that the sins of “Adam” turned it black from white so why would you kiss something sinful ? Strange!
Yes Boycott Mecca. I have been feeling like this and sends a message to the whole world
Siding on the side of weakness as expected
we wait a lifetime for hajj accreditation and permission to go. if you are able to go and have permission, you are invited by Allah and you are His guest. no political stance can change that. if the saudis are getting away with it financially, they will answer to Allah for their crimes
I think saudi arabia is only care taker or service provider
Nabi Karim SWS was born in Mecca,Allah Subhana Watala could raised him in another country,now when he made an agreement with Ansar & non Muslim return to Mecca he never ever utter the word"Be a Muslim & Becaming as Muslim" he said Let it be peace among you and Live in Peace,He narrated I am born in Arabia,does not mean one is superior to me all are equal in The Eyes of The creator/Allah,he never ver politicalize or involve in religious into politics.Now we have to come into analyzing present situation.The revenue earned dos not gave safety to the pilgrimage 2.There should must be a shelter made out of the earning of the revenue for the pilgrimage 3.There should be cheapest food delivery must b available for all Muslims around the world.4.Mecca & Madinah & other holy places places belongs to Muslims,
all over the world.These places should must be an autonomy Govern by 65 Muslim countries vn more elected by vote to control these ares.Example vatican city.Every country must send Five member army with Latest equipment to protect these ares.The Governor is a sovereign who will control these areas.The revenue collected from Pilgrimage should be spend to different countries for their development for economy.
I cant seem to understand something, can someone help me out? If Islam has the same god as jews and christians why is it that the torah and bible does not mention the kaaba if its so important to islam? Yet it was so important to the pagans where islam began...
Because the early Muslims, after the death of the Prophet, conspired to change the real location of the Sacred Temple from Jerusalem to Mecca. There are many many many evidences that today's Mecca is not the location of the _Masjid al Haram_ that the Quran talks about. If you are really interested you can read the free e-book _The Natural Republic_ by The Monotheist Group.
(I say this as a muslim submitted to God, believer in the Quran and in the prophethood of Mohammed)
Well, the Biblical account strictly circulates around the story of the nation of Israel.
@@sal_strazzullo What utter rubbish. You are so deluded its not even funny.
Tbh I would rather go to the Al Aqsa Masjid
Behind this boycott is Iranian majoos regime...
I am Yemeni and I went to Hajj last month, Just to let people know that Yemen is in civil war and we don't want Shia to conquer us and forcing us to insult prophet PBUH wife and his Sahaba and do Hajj in Karbala.
If you people don't want to go Hajj, then don't go but don't drag us to your excuse.
Correct analysis... Alhamdulilah Dr sabir..may Allah bless you
As much as I agree with boycot Saudi , I love abd sish to go to the place I prostrate towards