I really want to thank you for your channel. I live in a very small remote part of California and there are no mosque in my area. During Covid I reverted to his Islam by myself in my house. Best thing I’ve done for myself since I quit drink 12 years ago. . Since then I’ve been watching your channel on the regular. You’re like my mosque it’s like my virtual mosque. My virtual Islamic center. Thank you so much for all you do.
Im glad that you have made this great decission about your life. And also that you have chosen to listen to Shabir Ally. You can also choose to listen to Nouman Ali Khan and Hamza Yusuf. Try listening to themn you wont regret. I wish you all the best my brother
@@anonymous2150 I think instead of moving away. I’m going to build a mosque. I’m going to pray to Allah and use all of my fundraising skills and hopefully Inshallah Allah will bless this community with a mosque.
Masyaallah! Welcome to islam brother! Congratulation for a great decision that u have made in your life. May Allah make us steadfast on the religion of Islam.
I commend Dr Shabir Ally for his continuous service to Islam and pray to Allah for strength and blessings to Dr Ally and the sister in their untiring efforts in the service of Islam. May Allah reward us all with Jannatul Firdaus, Ameen.
@@hammadmirza3253 Thanks for your comment. I was referring to the sister as sister in Islam, not actual sister to the dr. Yes, he's his daughter. Again thanks for the comment Thanks
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
Assalamu alaikum Beautiful conclusion. We should not separate as Muslims and should respect and tolerate eachother for the sake of unity. And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it. Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you may be guided. Qur'an 3.103
Is like what the Quran say about the ahli kitab : they separate into many sect, and each of them think they are better from the other's . This is exactly what i feel when talking to a harsh people who call them self follower of salafi
Quran says only the party of Allah will be successful and the messenger said only 1 group out of 73 will be in paradise and that group is following Quran and Sunnah of the messenger and following his companions and 2 generations after them in goodness
Well not quite. We cannot accept obvious deviation such as the Ahmadiyya movement or these modernist quranist groups. Religion reaches us in a historical fashion so we must follow the original group and that group hss always been the main body of Muslims who follow the 4.schools. The Shia and Ibaadi were among the first group to separate themselves from the main body of Muslims and others did likewise at various stages in history. These Wahabis/salafist types are just more of the same as are the quranists.
@@kirkp-ko8hk Assalamu alaikum. There is no point bringing such deviations as Ahmadiyyah into the conversation or any other clear deviations that are not even in Islam. This video is not about such groups. We have a bigger enemy we should worry about more than Muslims with a different viewpoint. The kafiroon and shayateen have got us arguing about salafi, deobandi, barelvi, etc, whilst they do what they want and enjoy the fruits of the Muslim lands.
Really enlightened by the discourse. A born muslim,but found none who could answer some of my queries. No biasness openness to truth keeping in line with the Quaran and hadith. Thank you and thank you Allhumdulillah.
This interview is inconclusive. He mentions about bad and good in every group, but fails to mention them.That leaves so many unanswered questions. Did Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahaab introduced Salafism or did he revived the Aqida?As far as the hadeeth goes regarding the term Salafi. The prophet saws taught his daughter Fatima before his death, advising her,"Fear Allah, be patient, and I am the best Salaf for you ".This hadeeth is in Bukhari.Also what he fails to make mention off,is the fact that the Muslims at the time were known as,Ahlul Athaar, Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamaa'a, Ahlul Hadeeth, Asalaful Saaligh.The Great Hambali Scholar,Imam Aghmad Ibn Hambal had advised the people in his time, not to take from Shaafi'e, Abu Ghaneefa, or Maaliek, AL Awzaaie but take where they took from, which was where? The first generation which is the Salaf of this ummah.The muslim brotherhood is not upon the way of the Salaf, but rather they have Gawaariej mentality. To revolt where as the Salaf practice what the prophet saws had ordered with, and that is not to revolt against your leader.So in essence the Salafies are adhering to the best of their ability to obey the prophet saws had ordered with.So this interview is short of the actual truth of who the Salafi follow. Surah Waqi'a verse 13 Allah makes mention of a multitude of people who will follow in the beginning and a few in last days which we find ourselves in.In my opinion, each muslim is by nature a Salafi if he claims to follow the prophet saws and his companions.
yes..you said it...you are right 👍...he didn't mention the terrorist side of Ibn Abdul wahhab. In history it's mentioned he killed thousands of aalims and sayyed's and thousands of innocent muslims because they did not follow his aqeeda...
@@hashimaachi2517 that's the part where i dont like from Muhammad bin Abdul Wahhab, they destroying old historical sites of Islam in Saudi Arabia, calling them some sort of bid'a or something..... And from that thing, Nahdlatul Ulama was born in Indoneisa, to protest about puritanistic movement and protect old Sufi and old Habib practicing their own old practice that inherited from scholars before them....
@@haiderzeb91 yes Akhi I have question since ur a fellow salafi is Sadl allowed did abukhadeeja answer this I saw imam Malik say it’s the way of Salaf to so Sadl is it ok to take that position,jazakAllah khairan
The schools of jurisprudence are all from the original majority body of Muslims. It was the Shia and Ibaadi who broke away from the main body ot Muslims because of their disagreement concerning various rashidun caliphs.
@@Randomhandlename False akhi. The theology of the religion (core of any religion) is same and easy to follow in the Quran and does not change with any school of thought. The Messenger and his hadiths are what are interpreted by the schools of thoughts, not the Quran. Example: Some school of thoughts might raise the finger during Athaiyat and then rest it where is another might simply keep it pointed up at all times. This is further discussed by Dr. Ally in one of his videos. Allah knows best.
Salaf سلف means "predecessor". If we add صلح "righteous" to it then we are speaking about the pios predecessors that include the first 3 generations of this Ummah, the Sahaba, those who learn from them and followed them and those who learned from them and followed them. 3 generations in total. Basically these 3 generations made sure everything was gathered, documented and they are the best for a reason. To follow them is to follow the correct understanding of the Quran and Sunnah. Note: people might claim to follow the Salaf and yet they don't. Alhamdulillaah most of those who claim do so, but then we have exeptions and those who dislike the Salaf Al Salih in general will take this opportunity to generalize abd slander everyone. Then we have the "Wahabi". Not only is this a invented slander by some deviants that did not like لا إله إلا الله, they made up a non existing sect all based on the Name and Attribute of Allah, Al Wahhaab. If we break it down, Wahhab is Allah. So who are they referring to? They say: "Abd Al Wahhab" . Mkay..But that is still the wrong person. Then they will finally tell you: "We mean Muhammad". Okey, now it makes sense. So you had issues with Muhammad, why not then call this non existing sect "Muhammadis"? Its because that is too obvious. Every Muslim is a Muhammadi i.e a follow of Muhammad ﷺ. So even the way they formunalted the name is a deception. Anyways, they accuse Sheikh Ul Islam رحمه الله of fighting people who worshipped other than Allah and *that it is wrong* as if the Prophet ﷺ didn"/ fight shirk in the same land of Arabia. They claim he fought in a war that happened in a diffefent century than the century he lived in. They accuse him of rebelling against the Ottomans in his own home town that wasn't even occupued by the Ottomans. And when you ask the evidences then there is never any. Even worse, the Imam is known for his books in Aqeedah and his view on rebelling against the Muslim leader and yet they claim the opposite, clear evidence that these people slander. Best part, the non Muslims who wrote a Wikipedia article on "Wahhabism" state that *no one actually uses this name nor calls themselves by this name* . So clearly this is a slander and the worst kind since its Allah's name and attribute that is being used to spread lies.
What do you say about his brother Shaykh sulaiman Ibn Abdul wahab letters in regards to the Shaykh ul Islam? I suggest you watch some bro Haji videos .... He shows clear proof going against your claims.
@@bharatmodi6712 It was invented by Sufi's and it has nothing to do with Muhammad, but its entirely a name and a attribute of Allah that is used to slander people.
Allah has called is Muslims and period. No word is above the word of Allah. Whatever you are, you are a Muslim and this is what Allah calls you in the Quran.
Al-Bukhari narrated from 'Ubadah ibn as-Samit [radhiyallahu 'anhu] that he said: "The Prophet (Peace be upon him) called us and we gave him the bay'ah that we would listen and obey whether we were active or tired, in difficulty or in ease, and even if others were preferred over us. And that we were not to rebel against those in command, unless you see open kufr [kufran bawahan] for which you have a clear proof from Allah." (Sahih Bukhari)
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
A broad and non-sectarian approach in the discussion, which is what we muslims need, as Dr.Shabir wisely stated that "there's good and bad in all movements ."
Sunnah is The Way of the Last Prophet (peace be upon him), when The Creator in the Quran says follow the Sunnah, and following it means ''sunni''. How can one say they are ''not sunni'' yet be able to make claims on Islam? it's oxymoron. And it is bizarre how this contradiction is becoming normalized due to masses been ''religious'' with The Knowledge been taken away, we have began the resemblence of the previous people of the books. Some go to different extremes of the Khawarij way, some go to the different extremes and branches of the opposite end, be they mystecism, philosophy, and other scisms. As muslims we are instructed to be on the middle-way, with knowledge based on evidence and faith. Please understand the importance of the Quran, Sunnah and the Example of the Companions (as in the Hadiths).
And people are having a hard time distinguishing the acts of the Khawarij or groups resembling them and labelling them as part of the Salaf. This it self is a big mistake and shows lack of knowledge and what some circles (both in the western and easter cultures, some who even consider themselves muslim but in belief are not) who oppose Islam want done so misrepresent Islam and close the channels of Islam been understood in purity by the masses. We need to increase our understanding of issue and do sound research, not through comments on the internet but through proper scholars and literature on the subjects by those who really are representatives of the issues and topics.
1 The Prophet P.B.U.H did ➡️ N0T ⬅️ instruct us to follow any Imam. 2 Allah Did ➡️ N0T ⬅️ Instruct us to follow any imam. 3 The imams did ➡️ N0T ⬅️ instruct us to follow them. 4 The ➡️ complete & perfect ⬅️ Islam existed before the arrival of all the Imams. 5 All the four great imams said, if you find a hadith which contradicts what we have taught you then ➡️ REJECT ⬅️ what we taught you & follow the teachings of Prophet P.B.U.H. 6 Are you ready to follow an imam if it means ➡️ REJECTING ⬅️ a Hadith 🤦🏻♂️❓
Your explanations on such topics are highly beneficial to both reverts and other Muslims. I urge you to continue on the excellent work of enlightenment and service to Islam, and for all of us Muslims to contribute what we can, in the work of da'wah.
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
قال رسول الله ﷺ : إِنَّ أُمَّتِي لَا تَجْتَمِعُ عَلَى ضَلَالَةٍ، فَإِذَا رَأَيْتُمُ اخْتِلَافًا فَعَلَيْكُمْ بِالسَّوَادِ الْأَعْظَمِ The Prophet (PBUH) said: “Surely my people will not agree on error. So if you see enmity, it is obligatory for you to follow the group with the most (majority).” (Narrated by Ibn Majah: 3950). So who is the majority of Muslims? they are Sunnis (Ahlussunah wal Jama'ah). And Wahhabism-Salafi are not part of Sunni (Ahlussunah wal Jamaah)
Does he have any good stuff on the child brides? That one is always tough for me. That said - I am increasingly convinced (and pray!) Muhammad is not a historical figure - but never the less - how do we fear God and honor such a man?
Ex-Muslims are the best role model for every Muslim brothers and sisters. As a Christian (Street Preacher), I learned Muhammed and Quran from the Ex-Muslims. Today when I ask a simple question to Muslims 👉 they run, run, run 🏃 away from me. May the living God Jesus Christ bless all Ex-Muslims forever and ever. Amen, Hallelujah 🙏✌️♥️
I'm not a Muslim but I've been interested in learning about different cultures and religions for decades. Recently, my curiosity began to turn sour due to a certain online community that cares more about hating on lgbt people, ex-Muslims, liberal Muslims, etc. rather than contributing something positive to the world. I've only seen a few of Dr. Shabir Ally's videos but he has gained my admiration.
Islam in general doesn't approve of LGBTQ relationships and views them as damaging and destructive. Same goes for those who like to not only leave Islam, but go around telling others to follow them i.e. exmuslims. Leaving is one thing, leaving while making effort to have others follow is another. As for liberal Muslims, there is no such thing in reality. You can't toss Allah's speech to the side and pick up liberal values and still pretend as you hold Allah's speech above everything else. I'm not even that positive that either of these group get that much attention from Muslims. Seems to still be mostly Christians and atheists that they engage with and talk with the most.
Im not Muslim, but I have been watching your videos out of curiosity. It's very nice to see what your beliefs are outside of what people in america believe Islam is. I am not an athiest at all but I follow no particular religion. I am actually in the middle east now and I have met alot of muslim people who are very kind, so I thought I should do my due diligence and learn a little about their beliefs. I really do think Islam is great though. As you would say, Peace be upon you.
And Peace be upon you. Welcome to submission to the One and Only dear. You will find that the entirety of the universe is submitted to His will, as should we be. May Allah guide us to the straight path.
Unfortunately, a lot of wrong information The Salafi movement follows the first generations, not Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab. The books of creed, most of the books that are taught are the books of Ibn Taymiyyah. In the doctrines, the books of Ahmad ibn Hanbal are studied, and these are older than Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab, who has only about three books. Hasan al-Banna is said to have been an Ash'ari Sufi in the Shadhili way The Brotherhood is not based on Salafism, but rather a political thought and a mixture of Ash’ari, Sufi and other sects and religions. It has nothing to do with Salafism and seeks to unite Muslims to their rule for a political, not religious, goal. She says monotheism is something that is common to Muslims, so you will see Sufis building shrines, And he pleads with the righteous saints at the shrines, and this contradicts Islamic monotheism, which is the message of all the prophets. He lied assuming that the Salafis say that God has a hand like a human being And he lied when he said that the Salafis say that God has a king like man Nobody says that. He lied that 9/11 was linked to the Salafists, because 9/11 was orchestrated by the leaders of Al-Qaeda and everyone knows that Osama bin Laden and Al-Zawahiri were from the Muslim Brotherhood and had nothing to do with the Salafists, rather they were insulting the Salafi scholars in Saudi Arabia. Rather, they are fighting the rulers of Saudi Arabia who adopt the Salafi ideology, and their outbursts in Saudi Arabia are many. Unfortunately, Shabeer made a mistake and lied in this meeting. We are waiting for a response from the Salafi Muslim sheikhs He admitted with shame that he read the chains of hadith from the predecessors because they are the people of hadith and they are the ones who know this science without the other Islamic schools of thought that strayed from the approach of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh
They don't follow sahaba. They do wild interpretations and then say it is what sahaba did. But they are coo far. They follow nothing in Sunnah and Quran.
@@cowsmuggler1646 They say what the early scholars of Islam said, and this annoys the Sufis, Ash’aris and Shiites, because they invented new sayings that the companions of the Prophet Muhammad did not say.
@@tkhassan8415 It is a series of followers of the early ones, the scholars of the four imams were following the companions of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh, and Ibn Taymiyyah was imitating Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal in doctrine and jurisprudence, And Sheikh Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab was an imitator of Imam Ibn Taymiyyah, and so is the inheritance of religious science transmitted from one generation to another, and they were committed to the sayings of the first generation. In this time, many Muslims invent rituals and inventions in Islam and then say: I follow Imam Ibn Hanifa in jurisprudence.. The question is why not follow him Also in faith Following in the belief is the most important and it is the path to paradise because the companions of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh did not innovate in religion but rather followed the sayings of their prophet pbuh This is what we must do
I have the impression that Shabir and Safiyyah conflated the topic on schools of thought (madhahib) and aqeeda. Those who adhere to the aqeeda salafiya do follow madhahib. In Saudi Arabia, many people follow the Maliki madhab and Hanbali madhab as well, and others follow Shafi'ee and Hanafi madhabs. Hence, following a salafi aqeeda does not mean against any school of thought. The conflict is between those who are fanatics of a certain school of thought and those who are salafis because salafis, even though they follow a school of thought, they reject the ruling of their madhab if it is repugnant/contradictory to an established Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w because the Prophet is infallible on all matters of the religion while the Imams of the madhahib were not. As a matter of fact, all those famous Imams of the madhahib made a disclaimer that people should reject their (Imam's) opinion or rulings if it is against a sahih hadith. As for me, to be a salafi, it means that you strive to follow the Sunnah according to the understanding of the salafus-saleh (first 3 generations), follow any of the madhab because the madhab provides the details on how to perform all acts of worship but you should not be a fanatic to any madhab because the Imams of the madhahib were not infallible people.
So what exactly is the difference between all these schools of thoughts brother mean do they pray differently cuz tbh im scared i just came to know about this and im now confused as yo which madhab is the correct one.
@@justice1872 The schools of thought in Islam came later, approximately in the 3rd century after Hijra, there are at least 4 of them which are famous but there are more than 4 . None of the imams of these schools of though claimed to be infallible, in fact all of them basically said that if any of their statements or rulings go against an authentic tradition (hadith) of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w., their statement should be discarded. Imam Abu Hanifah: “If a hadith is found to be authentic, then it is my madhab.” Imam Malik: “Everyone after the Prophet will have their statements accepted or rejected except the Prophet.” Imam Shafi: “Every hadith of the Prophet is my position even if you did not hear it from me.” Imam Ahmad: “If one rejects a hadith of the Messenger of Allah, they will be at the brink of destruction.” So my advice is you can follow any of these schools of thought but you should not be fanatical towards it to the extent that you would reject the clear evidence from the sunnah that contradicts the madhab's ruling. As for me, I follow the Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (Handbali) madhab because I have read his books but I also take other madhabs' position over the Hanbali position after comparing their positions to the authentic sunnah of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. May Allah guide us all, ameen!
As Salaamu Alaykum ALHUMDULLI ALLAAH ! WELL SAID ! As a Muslimah ( 72 , Muslim 42 years, from Michigan , Now in Boston, MA. ! ) I visit whatever masjid I am near and taught my Son , the same ( He has Family ) ! I have seen the EXTREMES, CULTS , SECTS, etc… and IT is confusing and SAD ! I Embraced ISLAM at Univ. of Michigan , 1980 & was taught MALKI Madhab, but we learned about the other 3 or 4 (?)! We have GOT TO PREPARED /UNITED for the TRAILS that are coming ! IT is BAD ENOUGH the Saudi Arabia Mafia Fam. is OFF THEE STRAIGHT PATH for ___ years or Centuries & OTHER Muslim Nations ( Used to be 1 UMMAH) are FOLLOWING them !
@@orthodoxmuslim it could be applied on the opposite. Many brothers that called themselves salafi are so fanatic, radical, on their views about the madhabs.
Middle path is suratal mustaqeem as long basic tenets of Islam such as Tawheed and Hazarat Muhammad ❤️ ﷺ seal of all prophets ( No prophet will come after him) are not compromised we must consider them as part of islamic body and there should be no doubt on their sincerity. Following aqeeda of Salaf saleheen is right way definitely they followed Prophet Muhammad ❤️ ﷺ and were sincere . May ALLAH swt guide everyone towards it . Ameen
The four 'schools' of Sunni are based NOT on 'Aqeeda' but on 'Fiqh' which are completely different !!! Please, look for the meanings of the for-mentioned terms !!! Wahabizm is of different Aqeeda !!!
qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed.
A small correction regarding the part where the shaykh talks about the attributes of Allah and the Salafi interpretation. It is not true that they literally say it is a hand like a human hand, but that they believe that Allah has a hand, and what it is like, the believer does not enter into it or think about it. Big difference.
Without doubt the clear, manifest, distinguished, evident proof of this title and ascription, which is to say: I am a Muslim upon the Book and the Sunnah and upon the methodology of our Salaf as-Salih, and that is to summarise it by saying: ‘I am a Salafi’.
You're not from the Salaf hence you're not a Salafi, you're being delusional know what you are a Wahabi!!! Abdul Wahab claimed that anyone who disagress with him is a Kaafir & since no Sahabi ever claimed this then it's clear as daylight that Abdul Wahab was a fraud & a munafiq!!!
@@comparativereligiondailynews if you are a Muslim that means you are a Salafi by extension because salaf follow the prophetic teaching with the understanding of the companions and the followers.
“As for those who divide their religion and break up into sects you have no part in the least, their affair is with Allah. He will in the end tell them what they used to do.”(Quran 6:159) So we should not call ourselves as of any Mazhab, instead we should call ourselves as Muslims.
Absolutely right Islam is not like any other religions it is unique and it is true making sects and different beliefs makes it no different than Hinduism and Christinanity
@Humanity Insaniyat see my friend the one doesn't believe in Quran and Sunnah and doesn't follow the commandments of Allah Al Wahid given in Quran and try to add up something extra which is not authentic and follow those things that person is not considered as muslim because he or she is not following the clear and simple statements of Allah SWT and doing something of their own will
I wish to ask is there a specific reason why Dr. Shabir groomed his beard the way he did, I mean I heard mustache is to be shaved and beard to remain as a Sunnah following, however Dr. Shabir has shaved almost all of it from the face, even the chin, leaving only the part of beard which is on the neck area. Please educate me if this is the exact sunnah of the prophet? Thanks.
Alhamdulillah . What is called in our time “Salafiyyah” are the Sunnis, or Ahl al-Hadith wa al-Athar, in short, who follow Islam as stated if they want to define the interpretation of Surat Nadhrun in what the Companions, the Successors, and their followers said, and our scholars and sheikhs have a Mutawatir chain of transmission in this regard. We are not like Al-Ash'ari, Al-Maturidi, Ibadi, and Rafidah. If they want to interpret a verse, they turn to philosophy. If they see a hadith that contradicts their opinions, they say it is weak, or they change its meaning and philosophize based on it. As for whoever denies the attributes of God Almighty, such as His being leveled above the heavens, or His face, or His hand, or His leg, or who says that the Qur’an is created and that God does not speak, then they are Al-Jahm bin Safwan, the Mu’tazilites, Abdullah Al-Ibadi, the Rafidite Shiites, the Zaidis, the Kalabiyya, the Ash’aris, the Maturidis, and all of these people do not have a prophetic hadith or a saying of a companion. To prove the validity of their religion. The Muslim Brotherhood are not Salafis, but rather they are Ash'ari Sufis. Your conclusion reminds me of the Indian Emperor Akbar, who invented a new religion
What is rational, what is logical, what is humane, what is spiritual and what is true faith in God.. Once i was in Madina visiting the beloved Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) grave.. i was passing by waiving my hand and scaff along the barricaded pathway.. just trying to express my love.. surprisingly i was shouted syirik! syirik! syirik sheikh! by one of the guard.. sadly as i recalled if someone accuse you of disassociation in Allah and if Allah judge otherwise the blame will be upon the accuser.. i'm surprise people could be so quick in judging others.. that may lead to disunity, quarrels, disputes and conflicts.. i remember a hadith the Sahabat Bilal(RA) would roll his bare body at the prophet grave in tears of his longing.. is it a bidaah not ride camels to work or use toothpaste instead of siwak.. some would be so dogmatic, narrow or shallow in their insistence.. that they forget to apply other tens or hundreds of hadiths to smile, to be peaceful, to be kind and loving to one another in the true faith of Allah.. just my humble opinion, may Allah forgive, guide and bless us all.. Ameen..
Subḥana’llāh How is an average person supposed to decide between what is good and bad without having broad knowledge of Islam, since one have to follow the explanation of Quran and Sunna from someone, isn’t it better to follow a school of thought another word view of group of scholars of early generations. Despite of so many different opinions in gray space between the school of thought, there is no hatred or arrogance between the followers. Sadly the Wahabi and the Salafi brothers are far away from this quality. It is absolutely wrong statement to say that all schools have good and bad, because opinion of all schools of thought are base in authentic sources which one might disagree with, actually it’s the individual followers of schools of thought have good and bad in them which is understandable. Finally I like to advise the interviewer to have some manners not to call someone (ie dr Shibbir) by name who’s way older then her in age and much knowledge then her in Islamic knowledge. May Allah Subhanahu wa ta’ala grant me and you all beneficial knowledge and understanding of Islam.
Muhammad is mentioned only four times in the Koran and that too all in the past. The Koran describes Muhammad as someone who lived in the past. So which Muhammad are Muslims referring to as thei prophet
Alhamdulillah I got Tohid from Salafi! The Abdul Wahab was the one who focus the follow only authentic source only. Now Saudi Arabia is the only one nation who holding Tohid without mixing it.
I'm a muslim. as far as i seen, many people tend to think that this kinda movement as a sect. It isn't. I think it's a compulsory for muslims to follow the early generations/Shahabah (salaaf), especially on aqidah subject and their way of thinking. Because they learned the quran and hadith and its tafseer directly from Rasulullah peace be upon him. As explained in the video, people often try to interpret (takweel) the attributes of Allah, that Allah himself mentions in the Quran. But as far as the Shahaabah do, this clearly PROHIBITED. You CAN'T intrepret (for example) Allah's hand as a kind of "power". But just explain it literally as Allah intrepret himself in the quran. BUT we DON'T think how and what his 'hand' is look like, especially compared to human hands or his creation type of hand. This is how the salaaf tafseer, and the aqidah of the salaaf. And as muslim who follow their teaching, we are automatically a salafy by definition. I see nothing wrong with that. And the way they learn today is also the most scientific afaik. This makes the new generation more interested in studying Islam at its purest.
10:23 bruh Salaf never ever interpreted those verses by saying that they r metaphorical they never distorted the meaning of the Qur'an they used to believe in the understanding of the companions of the Prophet peace be upon him and the companions used to believe in those verses literally without using the word "how" because they r the part of unseen and the knower of unseen is ALLAH SWT
Despite the fact that I do not follow the same school of thought with the sheikh, I believe he is amazing. He deserves the title "Allamah" which is a status above "Aalim"; both derived from "ilm" meaning knowledge. On top of that he is "Mujtahid". He reads, evaluates then draws his own conclusion "qawl". Most Indian scholars are distinctive and exemplary.
@@nishiayad You mean like libraries? Libraries carry knowledge..lots of knowledge, but we can't describe them as "knowledgeable". BTW, forget about this "joke", how much do YOU know?
first. You will not find anyone identifying themselves as a Wahhabi, this is the fallacy of the straw man. secondly. Salafism or Ahl al-Athar is a matter related to the doctrine, meaning that you are a Muslim who understands your religion in the same way that the first three generations understood it, especially the understanding of the Prophet (PBUH) and his companions. He mixes between fiqh and belief. The four schools are schools of fiqh, but when the question is about Salafism, the comparison is, for example, about Ash’ari or Maturidi (like the Taliban, many think that they are Salafis and this is not true), the Mu’tazilites (like Shabir Ally himself, but with a liberal touch), Kulabi, Jahmi and even Shias or Ibadites ... (doctrinal schools, the difference between them is doctrinal not just a difference in fiqh) I think he does it on purpose or he is speaking out of ignorance.
Slmalkm everyone, could someone please tell me why have saudi arabia kept only sheikh abdul wahabs teachings for arabia, and not any other sheikhs, scholars, alims, men of knowledge. Etc, etc..im very confused here, can some one explain please, would help me a great deal and ease my confusion aswell as many others like me could also benefit from some one with knowledge to explain and clear and refresh our misty minds, thankyou will appreciate it. ♥️🙏❤️..
Saudi Arabia didn’t keep only his teachings but the teachings of the salaf. It’s sh Mohammad ibn abdelwahhab Who followed the salaf. If you want to know the real and true Islam go to al madrasatu al umariyyah channel
Before talking about the difference between Salafi and Wahabi, the question is where is the starting common reference? The answer is once the common starting point is having faith on the five pillars or basic Isamic fundamantal believes which is being the: 1. Faith in the only one Allah. 2. Believing that Moahmed is the final messenger from Allah. 3. Practicing prayer performance as a duty. 4. Observing the Zakat Almis giving. 5. Obeying once in life time the Haj Pilgrimage by giving visit tribute to Mecca. If a Moslem take the pledge to do whole heartedly the above mention five obligations he or she is on the right track and can play rugby or steep chase, let alone becoming a member of a group as long as there is a Soveriegn country with goverance. What is not acceptable in Islam is lack of law and order or anarchy.
Muslim narrated from Hudhayfah ibn al-Yaman [radhiyallahu 'anhu] that he said: "I said: "O Messenger of Allah, we were in a state of evil, then Allah brought us this good that we are in now. Will there be evil after this good?" He said: "Yes." I said: "Will there be good after this evil?" He said: "Yes." I said: "Will there be evil after this good?" He said: "Yes." I said: "How?" He said: "There will be after me leaders who do not adhere to my guidance, and who do not follow my Sunnah. " (Sahih Muslim) Note: The best examples of the consequence after the Caliphs are overthrown : Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan.
@@dandiaz19934 Khalifa means the head of the state of a country or a tribe etc. Netanyahu is the Khalifa of Israel , Biden is the Khalifa of America, Modi is the Khalifa of India, King Salman is the Khalifa of Saudi Arabia. Khelafa on Earth is given to a nation by Allah. It is absolute power on earth. Khalifa of the earth is that Nation or that individual of the nation who have the absolute power and authority on earth. Khalifa is a Arabic word. There are another type of Khalifa i.e. Khalifa ala Mihajun Nabua = Khalifa upon the way of the prophet hood. These Khalifas are rightly guided by Allah. Adam, King Solomon King David, The first four Muslim Khalifa etc were rightly guided Khalifa. Other Khalifas can be good or bad. Such as The Aaad and Thamud nation (Referred in the Quran) were the Khalifa of the Earth who were not rightly guided.
Some Muslims who claim them self as salafissm they are not pleasent to be around they are very pushy about religion and how to be in it especially for women if they are not covered like them I mean fully covered it seems never is good enough how much you do.
Actually ibnu Abdul Wahab misinterpreted the ideology of salafusswaliheen and make fake claim that he follows them. Actually that man represented some of deviant ideology of ibn taymiyyah who is controversial figure Muslim Scholars.
I was watching your channel for sometime now, and I hope you will pose my question to Mr shabir ally because I watched a lot of his debates and very much enjoyed it. And I would really happy if you will notice and answer my question which I was wondering for quite sometime. So my question is a little bit related to your today's topic. I would like to know about other great yearly scholars of islam who were very reputable and respected also in the first three generation but who's were not lucky to be survived or later embraced or joint with classical four schools. I would like to Mr shabir ally will elaborate who were they at least just names and I could read their biography because it's so interesting for a lot of ordinary people. I'm not sure I guess Sufian as Sauri was one of them. I hope you won't ignore my message. Thank you very much and good luck in your job. Truly yours Akimkhan from Kazakhstan.
Brother you can just Google the answers to your questions and you will find plenty of credible information that will satisfy your needs. If you have such a need for real answers please pursue a more expedited approach. Mr. Shabbir Ally will more than likely not be able to answer a UA-cam question in the comments. It's just not realistic.
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
Let me explain it to you more clearly there are two main sects shows I’m and Sunnis now Sunnis have four madahb Maliki Shafi Hanafi Hanbali Salafi are Hanbali now some salafis follow the teachings of Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab and some don’t but don’t separate them those who follow his teachings are still salafis just like how I can follow the teachings of a certain scholar but I will still stay Salafi also all people who follow Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab are Muslim Sunnis Hanbali Salafi but not all Salafi follow the teachings of Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab For documentation purposes: who wrote this was a Muslim Sunni Hanbali Salafi and a follower of the teachings of Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab.
Bother true salafis are the Ahle Sunnah waljamaah ie those who follow the experts in jurisprudence who were from the salaf asaalihun and earlier generations (khair al quroon) - Hanafi, Shafie, Maliki and Hambali. In my opinion the new groups such as 'Salafis' have caused massive confusion. While they happily hail and strict rigidly to their recent scholars viz Albaani, they don't shy away from labelling the majority of the Ahle sunnah as 'blind followers'. May Allah taala grant us true understanding and protect our imaan. AMEEN!
I asked one Rabbi did he read the Surah Al Qahf do they study the Quran to have knowledge what the Quran says ? He said yes I did. So I asked do you have the same story in the Torah about Moses traveling with Khidr Aleyhisalaam? He said there is not such an event in the live of Prophet Moses . If there was such an event we Jews must have it recorded in our records. And I said then why it is in the Quran ? He said I have no idea .
He has beard goat. He is eb lease worship. That is why he calls himself Quran. Quran is not speaking. He is speaking. Only Mohammed can claim he is Quran speaking. Because he was the Quran walking. So he is saying he is like Mohammed. He is coo far.
What is your problemet it is normal if a man have beard Jesus peace be upon him had beard. Have some respect to other peoples I see in many off your comments you have personal problem against us Muslims. May Allah guide you and remove the hate frome your heart my advice to you is read about Islam frome our Islamic books and leave the hate media they will never show you the correct information. Peace
We proud to be folowing salafisom as much we can . We try to folow the sunna of Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him . We refuse to folow the innovation in islam .... The people who are innovating new to islam the get ready to reserve seat to hellfire ..
@@Randomhandlename Not as empty as Salafi's heart and brains. Salafis are just white washing the current sheikhs in the throne and their acts. Please prove: 1) Music Concert in Saudi. 2) Saudi National Day 3) Bombarding Muslim countries or supporting the oppressor. 4) The Saudi Clock Tower (I can list things which Salafis won't dare to speak against)
You are koofar. You put a clock tower in Mecca. In the West clock tower is symbol of shaytan. He is known as father time. The Burj Khalifa is designed like the Tower of Babel. You put moons on your mosques. And you destroy the tombs of the prophets and hurt Muslims. You are shaytan worshipers. Koofar. Know them by their fruit. You can say whatever you want. That don't mean nothing.
@@cowsmuggler1646 we proud to be follower of true islam. Not like Fruit salad mixing all fruits then branded as single fruite juice . Study islam properly by authentic hadhees ... avoide the punishment from Allah by doing unislamic way ...
Thank you for your message, to understand Islam we have the Quran, to understand the Quran we have the Sunnah (Hadiths) to understand the Sunnah we have the Companions (the Salaf). Simply put, each need to be in correlation with the other and thus the Quran. We have people here who are arguing and making statements with words/sentences on the face that may seem correct and/or nice, but remember (this part isn't directed at you, but generally to all who may read) some of the people here reject the Hadiths in entirety, thus negating the Sunnah. However, we find God in the Quran clear tell us to follow the Sunnah, thus true Hadiths and our sources of the Hadiths are the Companions and naturally the Salah that follow. It is unfortunate that there are so many misunderstandings, confusions and paradigms flawed by politics and/or misconceptions. Yet it is by the Will of Allah that these occur. May Allah give us deeper sincerity, a better understanding and a sharper capacity to distinguish matters and not fall into traps of misinterpreting what comes our way as a trial, ameen.
@@KenanTurkiye Do not forget to follows the uelamas who follow the teachings of the prophet (ulama warosatul anbiya),.which they took knowledge from their teachers, the teachers.of their teachers up to the Salaf (isnad). This is the Sunni Ahlussunnah wal Jamaah's way. Anyone who claimed following the Quran & Sunnah without having isnad would be on the wrong path for sure as mentioned in Hadith "anyone who learned Quran and Sunnah by his self understanding (bi Ro'yi) will be put on ashtray" HR Tirmidzi وَمَنْ قَالَ فِى الْقُرْآنِ بِرَأْيِهِ فَلْيَتَبَوَّأْ مَقْعَدَهُ مِنَ النَّارِ Allahu a'lam...
@@ibnadam9606 then you are either an ignorant Muslim influenced by secularism (if that's the case then fear Allah ) or you are a clear disbeliever which makes your options useless and not of importance when it comes to Islam and it's adherents
The Wahhabism is a movement founded by Abd al-Wahhab ibn Rustam al-Ibadi in 171 AH, and it is a group of Kharijites that originated in Morocco, where its founder declared all Muslims to be infidels and disrupted the Hajj. When the call for monotheism was established in the Arabian Peninsula at the hands of Imam Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab, may God have mercy on him, at the beginning of the twelfth century of migration, and Imam Muhammad ibn Saud supported him, the Ottoman Empire at that time called their call Wahhabism to alienate Muslims from them. They overwhelmed the ignorant people because the names are similar, but history has revealed them. The Arabized Standard in the Fatwas of the People of Morocco (1/168) quotation: Noor Muhammad bin Fayd Ahmad Al-Arkani
qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed.
@Maths PC qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed.
@PC Maths you think the sky can fall on earth like allah says? (qurans 22;65) sky is a gas resting on earthsurface/ light shines through it.....people in 7th century believed sky was up there....this was a very COMMON POPULAR BELIEF.....now what do think about 22;65?
I also know 2 or 3 hadtih ,, Muhammad (pbuh) said I fear most of one thing in our islamic age that at end time , a group of follower will come to existence and they will claim they are true Muslim (extremist) ,but they were far from Islam is like an arrow will separate from his bow,,whenever you see them killed them and that reward will grant you on day of judgment.. 2. A man will come from najd who cause greatest fitna amongst the whole Muslim world ,they will call themselves true follower but there back is always in front of true teaching. .. So nice try to defend deviants,,, 3. Whenever u find difficult to follow the true teaching of Islam in end time,,,,follow largest group of Islam,,, Now which group have largest group of Islam in current time it's Sunni sect( hanfi,shafi,hanbali,Maliki).. And a nice try to defend Medina university who is established in 1900 century,,,,
Pls share sources for these hadeeth. Especially the second hadeeth you mentioned about a prophecy of a man coming from najd who would cause great fitnah.
@@rehanasyed8831 the horns of the devil will come from najdn and najd is Ryadh. Some people in order to escape this, they try to say that najd is Iraq and not Ryad. But it is well established that najd is Ryad and when the prohet a.s. blessed Sham and Yemen, some people said bless z nejd as well, but the prophet a.s. refused to do so and here he mentioned the horns of the devil will come from there
Just a food of thought for my Sunni brothers and sisters: This Hadith is from Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) and I'm sure everybody is familiar with but nobody take it seriously. My ummah will be divided into 73 sects. All of them will be in the Hell Fire except one. (Sahih Moslem) The DAY when We shall call together all human beings with their (respective) Imam. Quran 17:71 Personally I TAKE my religion from the one who was appointed by Allah, the one who was the first accepted Islam. The one who was raised by Prophet himself and the one who was married the daughter of the Prophet. Off course there are so many other proofs to support my believes but that I just leave it to this for now.
Sunan Ibn Majah Hadith 3950 36 Tribulations (8) Chapter: The great majority Anas bin Malik said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’”
@Farhan Salaam brother first of all learn some Manners then the guidance will follow Insha’Allah. If you want to discuss this hadith and anything else in a civilised manner then I'm here
DR Shabir is avoiding the question that the four schools of thought developed after the first generation of the Salaf. And Salafism did not developed in the 20th Century, nor did the medhhab of Wahabism developed in the 18th century. Both Salafism and Wahabism is the medhhab of Muhammad ibn 'Abdullah. And the Muslim brotherhood are not considered Salafee.
🩸🩸🩸If you go around the world many incorrect teachings have crept into Islamic practice ( especially in South Asian part of the world). I believe Islamic teachings have to be understood the way earlier generations of Muslim understood from prophet and for that you need proper extensive education from Islamic universities. Imagine every Tom, Dick and Harry read Islamic scriptures and give their own interpretation then even none Muslims can read Islamic scriptures and give their own understanding. I think that would be disastrous. We should always strive to understand Islamic teachings the way prophet taught and I think that earlier generations of Muslims were the best at this. FYI, Salaf is not a sect. Peace ✌️
@@mumtaz4327 He did quality control by following the earlier generations of Muslim that is the proper ways the Islamic teachings has to be understood from prophet Mohammed (pbuh). Peace ✌️
How can someone so cruel and harsh with words claim they are among people of the sunnah , salafi is some of the most harsh peoples with words ive met in the comment,
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
@@altappomaktappo7060 you could be right but I know for a fact madhabs had their own area years back. Arabs are known for creating issues and my religion Islam is perfect. Arabs the imperfect creed of shaitan
@@hassendelft3907 They agree with the Khawarij in denying the attributes of Allah, they claim the Quran is created and allow rebellion against the Muslim ruler. Also 45% Omanis are Sunni so we can't claim Omani is mostly ru, governed,influenced by Ibadis.
@@hassendelft3907 That goes against the Ijma (consensus) of the Sahaba and the tabien and tabu tabien. In fact, the majority of the Ummah do not allow this because of the Authentic hadith of Prophet ﷺ where he forbids rebelling against the Muslim leader. I don't think anyone who is a deviant would go against this consensus. This is exactly the nonsense Khawarij wanted and that is why Uthman ibn Affan رضي الله عنه was killed.
As a Muslim from the Shia school of thought this man speaks truth unlike a lot of others like him who spread false lies and who destroyed the shrine of imam Hussein.
The only truth is in following the Quran and the sunnah with the understanding of the 3 favored generations. Anyone who goes against that is the one who divided and ran away from true Islam
@@sisoshsasa some people that ascribe themselves to the way of the salaf don't truly follow it and go extreme in refutations. But in general salafis forbidding evil and not uniting with other deviant groups is a good thing. How can the muslims unite upon different beliefs? We'll unite when all the groups with false beliefs return to the quran and the sunnah
@@xhalo_4137 problem is that many “salafis” have opinions that are often subjective at best. in every community i have ever been salafis divide, start drama and feel totally justified for all the chaos they create. we are what like 1,500 years removed from the best generation that that ever lived? we’re too weak as Ummah right now to be divided. i take solace in knowing that the Sahabah didn’t behave ANYTHING like most “salafis” today
Subhaanallah, the status of our ummah. "And glad tidings to the strangers". When i saw the scarf and the line of questioning i know some ignorance is about to go down.
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
Need to emphasize here that despite of factions among Muslims worldwide, we are being confronted with some ideologies that have brought down Islam as a way of life. To some extent that LGBT and One World Religion are on the rise while ulama' are stunned with worldly matters and wealth. Don't get involved with mazhabs and perceptive thinking as means and ways to conclude which one is right because we still have alQur'an and Hadiths for reference.
Sincerely, You either read and learn a lot to know or you don't read and you don't know. Dr. Shabir Ally is mistaken in his definitions of salafi and "wahhabi". Salafism is Aqeedah not a school of jurisprudence (madhab). All 4 major schools of jurisprudence are salafi. Sheikh AbdulWahhab is of the Hanbali school of jurispudence. As for the phrase "Wahhabi",,,, accusing a man with that phrase ( one of the 99 names of Allah) is linguistically the equivalent of calling him godly. As for its use as an insult or term of derision, well,,,,, after you meet God, tell us how it went. Would love to learn what you know about God's names and their use(s) that the rest of the Ummah does not know. As an interesting observation,,, in general I have noticed that those who comment on the opposing side of the salafi/"wahhabi" videos online are on the whole the rudest and most insulting. If you have no manners, you have no Deen. Regardless of which side you are on.
You are very correct this is not right time to talk about religion we need to unite and save our brother from the country like india sri lanka and mianmar
Sure shabir debates Christians and debates western preachers, I have not yet seen a sunni preacher coming out and telling sunnis that sunnis have no evidence that Rasulallah appointed abu baker to be Khalifa, and abu baker lied to Rasullallah and banned the writing of hadith.
Rasullallah Said " I am leaving among you two successors: * The Book of Allah, is a rope stretched between the heavens and the earth, and عترتي اهل بيتي Ahllulbeity, and they will not be separated until they come back to me at alhawd.* Al-Suyuti's graduation (Hamm Tabb) on the authority of Zaid bin Thabit. Al-Albani's investigation (Sahih) See Hadith No.: 2457 in Sahih Al-Jami’. According to this hadith, unless you follow Ahlullbeit, you will lead yourself astray.
We have Qura'n now...!! Where are ahl e byt now to guide us (after Hassan Askari died without leaving any heir/or when his non existant son went into hiding).?
@@zahidfareed3218 (we have Quran now) that's what omar said in (razia khamis) . omar was exposed by Rasulallah as fasik munafik. Second point about the Mahdi, nore that 65 sunni scholars confirmed his birth on the ( 15th of Chabaan.) So, sunna is also Quran and the Mahdi, son of Imam Askhari, is the 12 successor of Rasulallah.
@@zahidfareed3218 You just went in a circle, did you read what my reply? More than 65 sunni scholars in thir books conformed the birth of Imam Mahdi on the 15 of Chabaan. If you are sunni then you have to believe in hadith same as you believe in the Quran, that's why yiu have bukhari muslim and other hadith books. Rasullah said in ghadir khum اني تارك فيكم خليفتين كتاب الله وعترتي أهل بيتي، لن يفترقا حتى يردا علي الحوض (الصواعق المحرقة) Rasulallah also said لاىتقوم الساعة حتى يبعث الله رجلا من اهل بيتي يملا الأرض قسطا وعدلا كما ملات ظلما وجورا Rasulallah is telling that the Mahdi is the last Khalifa, and his absence is ordained b Allah, and your guidance is to verify taken from Imams of Ahlullbeit during the absence of thr Mahdi (as)
I don't see no Quran speaking. I see some man speaking. The man is koofar. He is claiming to be Quran. He is a wasabi himself. The goat beard is their thing. The bafomet goat.
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba 1 Firka Shia 2 Bohri 3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers 4 Jamat e Islami 5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers 6 Najdi Saudi's Followers 7 Devbandi 8 Tabligki Jamat 9 Zhikri Kadyani Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
They can dress it up all they want but schools, wahabis, salafis etc are all sects forbidden within Quran. There is only submission to one God. The Quran warms against sects but man can't help following other men.
You are confusing sincere efforts to strive to understand and share Islam with secterianistic polarization (which is not allowed in Islam), yet bundling the sincere efforts to investigate, learn and propagate Islam with such secterianism is an orientalist ambition in order to curb the spread of Islam. In another message in this video, you clearly detailed how you reject Hadiths and only Quran is enough, whereas in the Quran Allah says follow the Sunnah and the source of Sunnah is the true Hadiths. Again, your complete rejection of Hadiths is another orientalist/western ideological attempt to cause a breakup of the Muslim unity. I request you reevaluate your standing, but obviously you are free to choose as you wish as this life is a life of trial and I wish you the best that you deserve in both worlds.
@@KenanTurkiye And this is nothing to do with western "orientalists". It's to do with those who do what Quran tells us, to think. It was sent to a people who are capable of thought and to seek knowledge, not follow dogma or imams or pirs or schools or sects. That is why Islam flourished in the early days when it came to science and progress as Europe was in the dark ages. Over time we reverted to backwardness with a focus on rituals and style over substance, choosing outward appearance over heart. Hadiths are merely allegations, they are alleged saying of the prophet according to third parties and therefore hearsay. Imagine if no one collected them, where would you be today? Because God certainly never told anyone to write anything else. The Quran is huge and before you start if Prayer is essentially the key to heaven why is each "namaz" and wudu steps not categorically listed step by step in its current from today? If Iblis prayed so much like nonother and had so much knowledge how was that still not enough to save him for simply refusing to bow to Adam AS? If prayer was proscribed to Jews and Christians why aren't they doing it today either, the Jews at least because they preserved their books better apart from adding in Talmud and Mishna. It is because just like other "sects" of monotheism we created our own based on man made books too. Doesn't Quran warn to follow in the footsteps of our forefathers? What do you think that means? To me it's the mainstream today.
@@SK991dvdhd Do you realize Hadiths are the source of the Sunnah of the Last Prophet (peace be upon him)? Do you realize the Creator in the Quran, explicity informs the reader that the previous 'people of the book' lost their religion because they did not follow the Sunnah of the Prophets that were sent to them (peace be upon them all)? The realities of fabricated Hadiths is in no means an excuse to reject ALL Hadiths, as you reminded us, in the Quran The Creator calls on us readers to contemplate, reason and evaluate the evidences in existance, so rejecting ALL the Hadiths goes even against that. Orientalist/enemies of Islam want ALL Hadiths to be rejected by muslims, because they did the same with other peole of the book (their ancestors in disbelief did) hence why the previous people of the book became ''those who are astray or those who gained ''His'' anger''. Muslim community is under attack by the same disbelievers who want to take Sunnah away from the Muslims and leave them with the Quran (sounds so nice, but the Quran says don't leave the Sunnah), that's how word play fools some people into thinking that they are right. Islam is understood with Quran, Sunnah and the Example of The Companions. And yes Allah in the Quran says, follow the Sunnah and brings to us the The Companions as examples. So you trying to dismantle this does not do harm to Islam, but to your own knowledge and faith.
@@SK991dvdhd With your last message you are again making a confused mistake. The Quran is complete, anyone who doubts that is in the wrong. That is not the point I brought across, nor should that be your anchor to continue your confused statements. We are talking of the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace be upon him), his Sunnah was observed by the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, and they took His Way as an example in their lives. The Way of the Prophet (peace be upon him) is collected in the Hadiths, some original, some fabricated, and these have been deduced and cleared by Islamic scientist and scholars. So you claim to completely reject ALL Hadiths is rejecting the Prophet, who's Way is pointed out to us in many verses in the Quran and we are commanded by The Creator to follow his path (peace be upon him). Of course as muslims, we take the Prophets Way (peace be upon him). I hope you understand how you are confusing two issue, The Quran is complete, the Sunnah/The Way of the Last Prophet (peace be upon him) is in the Hadiths. Disbelievers want to shoot the muslims by claiming The Quran is perfect yet reject the Sunnah, I hope you wont fall for that trap anymore.
The tv program should invite the right alim ulama who really understands what is salafy, so the world not miss took about salafy, in our country Indonesia Masya Allah and Alhamdulillah spread really fast.. Salafy teachs us back to the right path to the way Rosulullah alaihi sholatu wassalam and the sahabat from the wrong traditions that we follows over years and years..
@@modoulaminsanyang1324 right ulama means right Schølar , people who teaches the Quran and Sunnah according to the understanding of the three earlier generations
Assalamu AAalaykum: I am keenly following you a lots and endlessly loves for both of you. Can you kindly sends me 30 different recitations of Glorious Qur' an...
I am a irreligious person and even I can say, this man is very good. He makes a very informative and clean explanations. He never do any propaganda. A value resource for Muslims and an irreligious person myself. Regardless of your beliefs and ideologies, it is very important for self to gain information, make and understanding of things, and keep your self objective. As long as you keep your objectivity and senses, ideologies, beliefs keep you from extremist and very subjective thinking. This will result with non-hate and harmony between different groups of people. I personally find it stupid to see any Muslim or Cristian, etc. person to be bad just because I am irreligious, I believe religious people should do the same against people like me. It is of course applicable as long as red lines are not crossed, in which it is very important where those red lines are drawn. It is very important to judge a person by his/her character and not by only by his/her beliefs and ideologies.
Why didn't dr. Shabeer mention the reson as to why Mohammed bin abdullwahab start the movement? The biddah in the Arabian peninsula and the Islamic world was spreading very much and people started to do shirk as to worship trees or rocks or Graves. It was a dark time . Thank Allah that people like Mohammed bin Abdul wahab were there to teach people the right way .
You baffoon, they didnt worship trees. Or rocks. Bidah doesnt mean you mass takfir the entire Arabian peninsula. Abdul Wahaab declared everyone in Mecca and Medina kafirs, he even declared his own teacher a kafir. His own brother and father opposed him citing he was a lunatic
@@abdulhaseeb6091 you're the ignorant one and bluntly lie don't spread false claims . He didn't said that to the scholars of Islam he fought against those who do shirk like worshipping Graves and Jin and rocks . I am a Saudi and I know the history of my country.
@@abdulhaseeb6091 also I'm sure you didn't read any of his books. If you did you'll know that you've wrongly accused him. You just repeat what his haters say and lie about without researching.
What is the right way? The teaching of Muhammad abdullwahab who says Allah sits on arsh c'mon man I'm not a scholar but we need to pray for a better guidance political power and religion doesn't mix and Muhammad Abdullah was using religion to gain political power! May Allah guide us towards the right path inshallah
The mind boggling thing is Quran and bukhari-Hadith both say “DONT BE DIVIDED INTO SECTS” Yet we have plenty And yet we like to identify with one or the other So confusing
Just follow Quran. And read authentic Hadith for certain explanations and authentic narrations. Disagreements happen everywhere all the time among people, it happened even among Sahabas. Just don't let this be a cause of division among ummah.
The Salafis or Wahabis are more accurate and follows references from Quran and Sahi Hadith but others just follow their Mulllah and Maulavi without accurate references
@@Mu5tyLaghmani Brother there isn't such a thing as a Wahabis. These terms don't exist it's a derogatory form to describe those who follow the pious predecessor.
In the name of Allah, the most gracious, the merciful. Is Calling Oneself As AHLUL HADEES or a SALAFI Justified when Allah Named us as Muslims: And who is better in speech than one who invites to Allah and does righteousness and says, "Indeed, I am of the Muslims." (Quran 41:33) The verses in which Allah the Lord almighty called us as Muslims were revealed at the time where there were no sects in Islam, The Whole Muslim Ummah was One body, By the Passing of time unfortunately the Muslim Ummah was divided into several sects, Khawarij , Shia, Qadiyani, Baha'i, Parvezi, Barelvi (Grave worshippers), Deobandi and many more sects, Every sect call themselves to be Muslims. All these Sects seperated from the main body (Rasoolallah ﷺ and his Sahaba) follow their dignitaries blindly even if they contradict in the vital issues of Aqeedah (Belief) hence they are deviated. The way of Understanding Quran and Sunnah (Hadees) according to the understanding of Rasoolallah ﷺ and his Sahaba is Called MANHAJ E SALAF, people those who follow this understanding are the part of that Main body, called as Salafi's or AHLUL HADEES. This is the only Rightly guided Sect. Sunan Ibn Majah 3992 It was narrated from 'Awf bin Malik that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “The Jews split into seventy-one sects, one of which will be in Paradise and seventy in Hell. The Christians split into seventy-two sects, seventy-one of which will be in Hell and one in Paradise. I swear by the One Whose Hand is the soul of Muhammad, my nation will split into seventy-three sects, one of which will be in Paradise and seventy-two in Hell.” It was said: “O Messenger of Allah, who are they?” He said: "The main body." ("What I am upon and my Companions." Jami` at- Tirmidhi 2641). 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 JAZAKALLAH KHAIR 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Shabir Ally's face is seperate from his beard it's mind boggling...it's like two different things in one. I wonder what led him to do that the need behind it and why he did not do it in his past years. I feel as if it's showing his facial features just like a modern day hijabis who wear hijab while showing everything.
So if the hadith doesn’t agree with science today then we reject it but tomorrow if the science agree with hadith we go back and accept the hadith ?? Is my understanding correct??
The first place he should have started was to rectify the question. The 4 schools is not a branch of Islam. It is a school of jurisprudence (fiqh). It is not a branch nor a sect in Islam. These 4 imams rhm all had the same understanding of aqeedah. Aqeedah is essentially an understanding of Allah from Revelation ie Qur'an and Sunnah. Wagabi is a derogatory term for Muslims that really want to strive to learn tawheed as understood from the Qur'an and Sunnah. We should refrain from using these derogatory terms as Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahab has done great work contrary to what some Muslims may say.
I like how Dr Shabir Ally tried his best to be neutral but still had to admit that salafism is a politicised movement that developed later and took things like Allah's throne and hand literally
it is called anthropomorphism (mojasimaet ) it is well known facts in some of their ageeda ... listen to yasir qahdi and bro Hajj and books of al barbahari
@@zahinelahi2655 Did the salafist tell Allah has two right hands, even human wouldnt have two right hands right? Did the salafist tell Allah sit, how's Allah sit in your opinion?
To quote just one Hadith : 'Stay with the Majority of my Ummah for the Majority of you will never go astray " The Salafi movement is a very small minority. Just think about that for a moment. Thank you
Brother Shabbir, I used to listen you in past, but since you displayed very weak knowledge and weak faith when discussing with Christians regarding some important faith and beliefs like Israa and Meraj. I pray to Almighty give you wisdom and strength to understand and defend our beliefs without giving up in pressure from others, Aameen.
Thank you for the informative topics. I would like to ask a question which you may consider answering in a future video if possible. Considering that the differences between Shia Islam and Sunni Islam is based on which hadeeth the two decided to follow and also the way they interpret respective hadeeth and Sunna. Also taking into account that the 4 main Sunni schools of thought also differ in the sunna and hadeeth they follow. Question is why the Shia isn't considered another school of thought, if they base their core agreed authentic hadeeth also? Thank you
Do they follow the salaf? I doubt ,the followers of salaf are follower of Madh hab in this case neo salafi don't follow Madh hab nor they follow salaf ,they follow Ibn Taymiyya and MUHAMMAD ABDULWAHAB and they are not salaf s they are khalafs
@@sadofaraji5999 I have been leveled as THIEF for not doing man made innovated worship also I belong from a village of India with a tomb where people are drawn to the grave and not to mosques, where people are drawn to Milad not to obligatory prayers. No one speaks about keeping beard
Salafi are those adhere to the creed and methodology to the best generation of the salaf and sunnah, they follow the teachings firmly and practices according to the pious predecessors(salaf) and sunnah who were granted paradise that’s the main goal. They’re salafis that are too harsh and water down the aqeedah nowadays. Stay with the jamaah who are upon the truth ie Abu khadeejah, Abu hakeem, Abu idris etc
Lol 😂 finally met some one from salafi masjid lol though I was the only one nice to see salafi Manhaj growing also shout out to abukhadeeja Abu Hakim Bilal David and Abu iyad
11:34 I guess Imam malik, The founder of the Maliki madhab was was a salafi then? As he said: Abdullah ibn Nafi’ reported: Malik, may Allah have mercy on him, was asked about the saying of Allah Almighty, “The Most Merciful rose above the Throne,” (20:5). The man said, “How is his rising?” Malik said, “The rising is acknowledged, its modality is unknown, and asking about it is an innovation (Bidah). I see you are a man who intended evil with this question.” Source: al-Istidhkār 2/529 Ibn Abdul Barr said, “The people of the Sunnah agreed upon affirming the divine attributes as related in the Book and the Sunnah, interpreting them as reality and not as a metaphor, except that they do not ask ‘how’ is the modality of any of that.” Source: al-‘Ulūw lil-‘Alī al-Ghaffār 1/250 عَنْ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ نَافِعٍ قَالَ سُئِلَ مَالِكٌ رحمه الله عَنْ قَوْلِ اللَّهِ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ الرَّحْمَنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَى قَالَ كَيْفَ اسْتَوَى فَقَالَ اسْتِوَاؤُهُ مَعْلُومٌ وَكَيْفِيَّتُهُ مَجْهُولَةٌ وَسُؤَالُكُ عَنْ هَذَا بِدْعَةٌ وَأَرَاكَ رَجُلَ سُوءٍ 2/529 الاستذكار قال ابن عبد البر أهل السّنة مجمعون على الْإِقْرَار بِالصِّفَاتِ الورادة فِي الْكتاب وَالسّنة وَحملهَا على الْحَقِيقَة لَا على الْمجَاز إِلَّا أَنهم لم يكيفوا شَيْئا من ذَلِك
@@ShahJee101 He literally denies ahadith based on opinion and his degree in Islamic studies is from a Canadian University. Maybe do some digging first jahil. Allah is Al Wahhab and I am his slave. So I am a Wahhabi lol
I really want to thank you for your channel. I live in a very small remote part of California and there are no mosque in my area. During Covid I reverted to his Islam by myself in my house. Best thing I’ve done for myself since I quit drink 12 years ago. . Since then I’ve been watching your channel on the regular. You’re like my mosque it’s like my virtual mosque. My virtual Islamic center. Thank you so much for all you do.
Im glad that you have made this great decission about your life. And also that you have chosen to listen to Shabir Ally. You can also choose to listen to Nouman Ali Khan and Hamza Yusuf. Try listening to themn you wont regret. I wish you all the best my brother
Please go to a place where there is mosque and muslim community. You have to learn Islam properly through practice.
@@anonymous2150 I think instead of moving away. I’m going to build a mosque. I’m going to pray to Allah and use all of my fundraising skills and hopefully Inshallah Allah will bless this community with a mosque.
Masyaallah! Welcome to islam brother! Congratulation for a great decision that u have made in your life. May Allah make us steadfast on the religion of Islam.
God bless you and may he ease your journey ameen
I commend Dr Shabir Ally for his continuous service to Islam and pray to Allah for strength and blessings to Dr Ally and the sister in their untiring efforts in the service of Islam. May Allah reward us all with Jannatul Firdaus, Ameen.
Ameen 🧡
the sister is his daughter
@@hammadmirza3253 Thanks for your comment. I was referring to the sister as sister in Islam, not actual sister to the dr. Yes, he's his daughter. Again thanks for the comment Thanks
Avoid unnecessary division amongst the people who believe.
Too late
According to what source?
@@dinardinar2657 the Quran tells us not to divide into sects
Doesnt the Quran say : Dont be like the ahli kitab, they divide into many group and each group thinks they are better then the other..
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
Assalamu alaikum
Beautiful conclusion. We should not separate as Muslims and should respect and tolerate eachother for the sake of unity.
And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it. Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you may be guided.
Qur'an 3.103
Is like what the Quran say about the ahli kitab : they separate into many sect, and each of them think they are better from the other's . This is exactly what i feel when talking to a harsh people who call them self follower of salafi
Quran says only the party of Allah will be successful and the messenger said only 1 group out of 73 will be in paradise and that group is following Quran and Sunnah of the messenger and following his companions and 2 generations after them in goodness
@@Randomhandlename May Allah guide us to that, ameen
Well not quite. We cannot accept obvious deviation such as the Ahmadiyya movement or these modernist quranist groups. Religion reaches us in a historical fashion so we must follow the original group and that group hss always been the main body of Muslims who follow the 4.schools. The Shia and Ibaadi were among the first group to separate themselves from the main body of Muslims and others did likewise at various stages in history. These Wahabis/salafist types are just more of the same as are the quranists.
@@kirkp-ko8hk Assalamu alaikum.
There is no point bringing such deviations as Ahmadiyyah into the conversation or any other clear deviations that are not even in Islam. This video is not about such groups.
We have a bigger enemy we should worry about more than Muslims with a different viewpoint. The kafiroon and shayateen have got us arguing about salafi, deobandi, barelvi, etc, whilst they do what they want and enjoy the fruits of the Muslim lands.
Really enlightened by the discourse. A born muslim,but found none who could answer some of my queries. No biasness openness to truth keeping in line with the Quaran and hadith. Thank you and thank you Allhumdulillah.
This interview is inconclusive. He mentions about bad and good in every group, but fails to mention them.That leaves so many unanswered questions. Did Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahaab introduced Salafism or did he revived the Aqida?As far as the hadeeth goes regarding the term Salafi. The prophet saws taught his daughter Fatima before his death, advising her,"Fear Allah, be patient, and I am the best Salaf for you ".This hadeeth is in Bukhari.Also what he fails to make mention off,is the fact that the Muslims at the time were known as,Ahlul Athaar, Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamaa'a, Ahlul Hadeeth, Asalaful Saaligh.The Great Hambali Scholar,Imam Aghmad Ibn Hambal had advised the people in his time, not to take from Shaafi'e, Abu Ghaneefa, or Maaliek, AL Awzaaie but take where they took from, which was where? The first generation which is the Salaf of this ummah.The muslim brotherhood is not upon the way of the Salaf, but rather they have Gawaariej mentality. To revolt where as the Salaf practice what the prophet saws had ordered with, and that is not to revolt against your leader.So in essence the Salafies are adhering to the best of their ability to obey the prophet saws had ordered with.So this interview is short of the actual truth of who the Salafi follow. Surah Waqi'a verse 13 Allah makes mention of a multitude of people who will follow in the beginning and a few in last days which we find ourselves in.In my opinion, each muslim is by nature a Salafi if he claims to follow the prophet saws and his companions.
well said brother
Each Muslim who practices what our prophet pbuh and companions were upon they’re the salaf/is
yes..you said it...you are right 👍...he didn't mention the terrorist side of Ibn Abdul wahhab. In history it's mentioned he killed thousands of aalims and sayyed's and thousands of innocent muslims because they did not follow his aqeeda...
@@hashimaachi2517 that's the part where i dont like from Muhammad bin Abdul Wahhab, they destroying old historical sites of Islam in Saudi Arabia, calling them some sort of bid'a or something.....
And from that thing, Nahdlatul Ulama was born in Indoneisa, to protest about puritanistic movement and protect old Sufi and old Habib practicing their own old practice that inherited from scholars before them....
@@haiderzeb91 yes Akhi I have question since ur a fellow salafi is Sadl allowed did abukhadeeja answer this I saw imam Malik say it’s the way of Salaf to so Sadl is it ok to take that position,jazakAllah khairan
It should be emphasised that despite the different schools of Islamic jurisprudence, we all have one Quran🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
This is the strongest and purest "Hadeeth" of all... The Quran is more important...
Right on point!❤
Without the Sunnah Quran cannot be clarified which Quran itself mentions that it is upon the messenger to clarify Quran
The schools of jurisprudence are all from the original majority body of Muslims. It was the Shia and Ibaadi who broke away from the main body ot Muslims because of their disagreement concerning various rashidun caliphs.
@@Randomhandlename False akhi. The theology of the religion (core of any religion) is same and easy to follow in the Quran and does not change with any school of thought. The Messenger and his hadiths are what are interpreted by the schools of thoughts, not the Quran. Example: Some school of thoughts might raise the finger during Athaiyat and then rest it where is another might simply keep it pointed up at all times. This is further discussed by Dr. Ally in one of his videos. Allah knows best.
Salaf سلف means "predecessor".
If we add صلح "righteous" to it then we are speaking about the pios predecessors that include the first 3 generations of this Ummah, the Sahaba, those who learn from them and followed them and those who learned from them and followed them. 3 generations in total.
Basically these 3 generations made sure everything was gathered, documented and they are the best for a reason.
To follow them is to follow the correct understanding of the Quran and Sunnah. Note: people might claim to follow the Salaf and yet they don't. Alhamdulillaah most of those who claim do so, but then we have exeptions and those who dislike the Salaf Al Salih in general will take this opportunity to generalize abd slander everyone.
Then we have the "Wahabi". Not only is this a invented slander by some deviants that did not like لا إله إلا الله, they made up a non existing sect all based on the Name and Attribute of Allah, Al Wahhaab.
If we break it down, Wahhab is Allah. So who are they referring to?
They say: "Abd Al Wahhab" . Mkay..But that is still the wrong person.
Then they will finally tell you: "We mean Muhammad".
Okey, now it makes sense. So you had issues with Muhammad, why not then call this non existing sect "Muhammadis"?
Its because that is too obvious. Every Muslim is a Muhammadi i.e a follow of Muhammad ﷺ.
So even the way they formunalted the name is a deception.
Anyways, they accuse Sheikh Ul Islam رحمه الله of fighting people who worshipped other than Allah and *that it is wrong* as if the Prophet ﷺ didn"/ fight shirk in the same land of Arabia. They claim he fought in a war that happened in a diffefent century than the century he lived in. They accuse him of rebelling against the Ottomans in his own home town that wasn't even occupued by the Ottomans.
And when you ask the evidences then there is never any. Even worse, the Imam is known for his books in Aqeedah and his view on rebelling against the Muslim leader and yet they claim the opposite, clear evidence that these people slander.
Best part, the non Muslims who wrote a Wikipedia article on "Wahhabism" state that *no one actually uses this name nor calls themselves by this name* . So clearly this is a slander and the worst kind since its Allah's name and attribute that is being used to spread lies.
Wahabisam and salafisam are terrorists
What do you say about his brother Shaykh sulaiman Ibn Abdul wahab letters in regards to the Shaykh ul Islam? I suggest you watch some bro Haji videos .... He shows clear proof going against your claims.
Wahabi is derogatory word for people who follow strict Tawheed ones of Allah swt, the British and Iranians adopted this
@@Mu5tyLaghmani it is not a new word, been used for a long time, even before Lawrence of Arabia. Another term is Najdi
@@bharatmodi6712 It was invented by Sufi's and it has nothing to do with Muhammad, but its entirely a name and a attribute of Allah that is used to slander people.
As with many of the movements what I understand is mostly about political groups, the main thing is follow the Qur'an and Hadiths. May Allah Guide us.
This time anybady want learnt real islam u can find only in salafi manhaj
@@delux1952 you're a bukhariist
Seems like Allah left you a long time ago, and you splintered.
Allah has called is Muslims and period. No word is above the word of Allah. Whatever you are, you are a Muslim and this is what Allah calls you in the Quran.
@@exposedition6999 that's not even a word. u sectarians really don't stop
Al-Bukhari narrated from 'Ubadah ibn as-Samit [radhiyallahu 'anhu] that he said:
"The Prophet (Peace be upon him) called us and we gave him the bay'ah that we would listen and obey whether we were active or tired, in difficulty or in ease, and even if others were preferred over us. And that we were not to rebel against those in command, unless you see open kufr [kufran bawahan] for which you have a clear proof from Allah." (Sahih Bukhari)
You obey eb lease. Wild goatmen.
BarakAllahufeek
@@cowsmuggler1646 uncalled for
Allahu Akbar . Hadeeths speaks the truth..
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
A broad and non-sectarian approach
in the discussion, which is what we muslims need, as Dr.Shabir wisely stated that "there's good and bad in all movements ."
Sunnah is The Way of the Last Prophet (peace be upon him), when The Creator in the Quran says follow the Sunnah, and following it means ''sunni''. How can one say they are ''not sunni'' yet be able to make claims on Islam? it's oxymoron. And it is bizarre how this contradiction is becoming normalized due to masses been ''religious'' with The Knowledge been taken away, we have began the resemblence of the previous people of the books.
Some go to different extremes of the Khawarij way, some go to the different extremes and branches of the opposite end, be they mystecism, philosophy, and other scisms.
As muslims we are instructed to be on the middle-way, with knowledge based on evidence and faith.
Please understand the importance of the Quran, Sunnah and the Example of the Companions (as in the Hadiths).
And people are having a hard time distinguishing the acts of the Khawarij or groups resembling them and labelling them as part of the Salaf. This it self is a big mistake and shows lack of knowledge and what some circles (both in the western and easter cultures, some who even consider themselves muslim but in belief are not) who oppose Islam want done so misrepresent Islam and close the channels of Islam been understood in purity by the masses.
We need to increase our understanding of issue and do sound research, not through comments on the internet but through proper scholars and literature on the subjects by those who really are representatives of the issues and topics.
1 The Prophet P.B.U.H did ➡️ N0T ⬅️ instruct us to follow any Imam.
2 Allah Did ➡️ N0T ⬅️ Instruct us to follow any imam.
3 The imams did ➡️ N0T ⬅️ instruct us to follow them.
4 The ➡️ complete & perfect ⬅️ Islam existed before the arrival of all the Imams.
5 All the four great imams said, if you find a hadith which contradicts what we have taught you then ➡️ REJECT ⬅️ what we taught you & follow the teachings of Prophet P.B.U.H.
6 Are you ready to follow an imam if it means ➡️ REJECTING ⬅️ a Hadith 🤦🏻♂️❓
@@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45 I read what you put but what’s your point?
I love Dr shabir but that sort of statement isn't so wise, there are some things that must be unilaterally condemned...
Your explanations on such topics are highly beneficial to both reverts and other Muslims. I urge you to continue on the excellent work of enlightenment and service to Islam, and for all of us Muslims to contribute what we can, in the work of da'wah.
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
قال رسول الله ﷺ : إِنَّ أُمَّتِي لَا تَجْتَمِعُ عَلَى ضَلَالَةٍ، فَإِذَا رَأَيْتُمُ اخْتِلَافًا فَعَلَيْكُمْ بِالسَّوَادِ الْأَعْظَمِ
The Prophet (PBUH) said: “Surely my people will not agree on error. So if you see enmity, it is obligatory for you to follow the group with the most (majority).” (Narrated by Ibn Majah: 3950).
So who is the majority of Muslims? they are Sunnis (Ahlussunah wal Jama'ah). And Wahhabism-Salafi are not part of Sunni (Ahlussunah wal Jamaah)
Does he have any good stuff on the child brides? That one is always tough for me. That said - I am increasingly convinced (and pray!) Muhammad is not a historical figure - but never the less - how do we fear God and honor such a man?
@@paulhallett1452
Why you accept the prophecy of issac who had child bride Rebecca?
Ex-Muslims are the best role model for every Muslim brothers and sisters.
As a Christian (Street Preacher), I learned Muhammed and Quran from the Ex-Muslims. Today when I ask a simple question to Muslims 👉 they run, run, run 🏃 away from me.
May the living God Jesus Christ bless all Ex-Muslims forever and ever. Amen, Hallelujah 🙏✌️♥️
I'm not a Muslim but I've been interested in learning about different cultures and religions for decades. Recently, my curiosity began to turn sour due to a certain online community that cares more about hating on lgbt people, ex-Muslims, liberal Muslims, etc. rather than contributing something positive to the world. I've only seen a few of Dr. Shabir Ally's videos but he has gained my admiration.
Check my play list
Islam in general doesn't approve of LGBTQ relationships and views them as damaging and destructive. Same goes for those who like to not only leave Islam, but go around telling others to follow them i.e. exmuslims. Leaving is one thing, leaving while making effort to have others follow is another.
As for liberal Muslims, there is no such thing in reality. You can't toss Allah's speech to the side and pick up liberal values and still pretend as you hold Allah's speech above everything else.
I'm not even that positive that either of these group get that much attention from Muslims. Seems to still be mostly Christians and atheists that they engage with and talk with the most.
Thankfully we don't run on your admiration.
@@shafinrahman2199 Certainly, because there's nothing to admire. I was referring to Dr. Shabir Ally.
@@Bestlivexg why?
I love the open-minded conclusion of the Sheikh Masha Allah 🥰
Im not Muslim, but I have been watching your videos out of curiosity. It's very nice to see what your beliefs are outside of what people in america believe Islam is. I am not an athiest at all but I follow no particular religion.
I am actually in the middle east now and I have met alot of muslim people who are very kind, so I thought I should do my due diligence and learn a little about their beliefs.
I really do think Islam is great though.
As you would say, Peace be upon you.
And Peace be upon you.
Welcome to submission to the One and Only dear.
You will find that the entirety of the universe is submitted to His will, as should we be.
May Allah guide us to the straight path.
Peace be upon you too ❤
hi.. thanks for learning about our beautiful religion and i hope you continue to learn it :)
May you have peace in your life.
Unfortunately, a lot of wrong information
The Salafi movement follows the first generations, not Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab. The books of creed, most of the books that are taught are the books of Ibn Taymiyyah. In the doctrines, the books of Ahmad ibn Hanbal are studied, and these are older than Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab, who has only about three books.
Hasan al-Banna is said to have been an Ash'ari Sufi in the Shadhili way
The Brotherhood is not based on Salafism, but rather a political thought and a mixture of Ash’ari, Sufi and other sects and religions. It has nothing to do with Salafism and seeks to unite Muslims to their rule for a political, not religious, goal.
She says monotheism is something that is common to Muslims, so you will see Sufis building shrines, And he pleads with the righteous saints at the shrines, and this contradicts Islamic monotheism, which is the message of all the prophets.
He lied assuming that the Salafis say that God has a hand like a human being
And he lied when he said that the Salafis say that God has a king like man
Nobody says that.
He lied that 9/11 was linked to the Salafists, because 9/11 was orchestrated by the leaders of Al-Qaeda and everyone knows that Osama bin Laden and Al-Zawahiri were from the Muslim Brotherhood and had nothing to do with the Salafists, rather they were insulting the Salafi scholars in Saudi Arabia.
Rather, they are fighting the rulers of Saudi Arabia who adopt the Salafi ideology, and their outbursts in Saudi Arabia are many.
Unfortunately, Shabeer made a mistake and lied in this meeting.
We are waiting for a response from the Salafi Muslim sheikhs
He admitted with shame that he read the chains of hadith from the predecessors because they are the people of hadith and they are the ones who know this science without the other Islamic schools of thought that strayed from the approach of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh
From where they got the 1st generation.. only madhabs are available to understand about 1st generation.
They don't follow sahaba. They do wild interpretations and then say it is what sahaba did. But they are coo far. They follow nothing in Sunnah and Quran.
You’re incorrect
@@cowsmuggler1646 They say what the early scholars of Islam said, and this annoys the Sufis, Ash’aris and Shiites, because they invented new sayings that the companions of the Prophet Muhammad did not say.
@@tkhassan8415 It is a series of followers of the early ones, the scholars of the four imams were following the companions of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh, and Ibn Taymiyyah was imitating Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal in doctrine and jurisprudence,
And Sheikh Muhammad Abd al-Wahhab was an imitator of Imam Ibn Taymiyyah, and so is the inheritance of religious science transmitted from one generation to another, and they were committed to the sayings of the first generation. In this time, many Muslims invent rituals and inventions in Islam and then say: I follow Imam Ibn Hanifa in jurisprudence.. The question is why not follow him Also in faith
Following in the belief is the most important and it is the path to paradise because the companions of the Prophet Muhammad pbuh did not innovate in religion but rather followed the sayings of their prophet pbuh
This is what we must do
I have the impression that Shabir and Safiyyah conflated the topic on schools of thought (madhahib) and aqeeda. Those who adhere to the aqeeda salafiya do follow madhahib. In Saudi Arabia, many people follow the Maliki madhab and Hanbali madhab as well, and others follow Shafi'ee and Hanafi madhabs. Hence, following a salafi aqeeda does not mean against any school of thought. The conflict is between those who are fanatics of a certain school of thought and those who are salafis because salafis, even though they follow a school of thought, they reject the ruling of their madhab if it is repugnant/contradictory to an established Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w because the Prophet is infallible on all matters of the religion while the Imams of the madhahib were not. As a matter of fact, all those famous Imams of the madhahib made a disclaimer that people should reject their (Imam's) opinion or rulings if it is against a sahih hadith. As for me, to be a salafi, it means that you strive to follow the Sunnah according to the understanding of the salafus-saleh (first 3 generations), follow any of the madhab because the madhab provides the details on how to perform all acts of worship but you should not be a fanatic to any madhab because the Imams of the madhahib were not infallible people.
So what exactly is the difference between all these schools of thoughts brother mean do they pray differently cuz tbh im scared i just came to know about this and im now confused as yo which madhab is the correct one.
@@justice1872 The schools of thought in Islam came later, approximately in the 3rd century after Hijra, there are at least 4 of them which are famous but there are more than 4 . None of the imams of these schools of though claimed to be infallible, in fact all of them basically said that if any of their statements or rulings go against an authentic tradition (hadith) of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w., their statement should be discarded.
Imam Abu Hanifah: “If a hadith is found to be authentic, then it is my madhab.”
Imam Malik: “Everyone after the Prophet will have their statements accepted or rejected
except the Prophet.”
Imam Shafi: “Every hadith of the Prophet is my position even if you did not hear it from me.”
Imam Ahmad: “If one rejects a hadith of the Messenger of Allah, they will be at the brink of destruction.”
So my advice is you can follow any of these schools of thought but you should not be fanatical towards it to the extent that you would reject the clear evidence from the sunnah that contradicts the madhab's ruling. As for me, I follow the Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (Handbali) madhab because I have read his books but I also take other madhabs' position over the Hanbali position after comparing their positions to the authentic sunnah of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w.
May Allah guide us all, ameen!
As Salaamu Alaykum
ALHUMDULLI ALLAAH ! WELL SAID ! As a Muslimah ( 72 , Muslim 42 years, from Michigan , Now in Boston, MA. ! ) I visit whatever masjid I am near and taught my Son , the same ( He has Family ) !
I have seen the EXTREMES, CULTS , SECTS, etc… and IT is confusing and SAD !
I Embraced ISLAM at Univ. of Michigan , 1980 & was taught MALKI Madhab, but we learned about the other 3 or 4 (?)!
We have GOT TO PREPARED /UNITED for the TRAILS that are coming ! IT is BAD ENOUGH the Saudi Arabia Mafia Fam. is OFF THEE STRAIGHT PATH for ___ years or Centuries & OTHER Muslim Nations ( Used to be 1 UMMAH) are FOLLOWING them !
@@orthodoxmuslim it could be applied on the opposite. Many brothers that called themselves salafi are so fanatic, radical, on their views about the madhabs.
@@muadja1 it's not about calling yourself a salafi, it's about whether or not you are following the way of the as-salafus-saleh
Middle path is suratal mustaqeem as long basic tenets of Islam such as Tawheed and Hazarat Muhammad ❤️ ﷺ seal of all prophets ( No prophet will come after him) are not compromised we must consider them as part of islamic body and there should be no doubt on their sincerity. Following aqeeda of Salaf saleheen is right way definitely they followed Prophet Muhammad ❤️ ﷺ and were sincere . May ALLAH swt guide everyone towards it . Ameen
Are you sure they follow the original Salafism or corrected one ???
Reply please.
The four 'schools' of Sunni are based NOT on 'Aqeeda' but on 'Fiqh' which are completely different !!!
Please, look for the meanings of the for-mentioned terms !!!
Wahabizm is of different Aqeeda !!!
I don’t think there much love when you try to destroy the Prophet’s peace be upon mosque and the tomb.
@@zabsar3615But that incident if you recall was dealt with in a 'flash' so to speak.
Thanks!
Sincerely explained everything, mashallah, glad to discover ur channel Sheikh.❤️ Mashallah
Assalamualaikum! Jazak Allahu Khayran. Excellent massages. From Malaysia.
I am a proud catholic who studies theology of different religions, this is a good discourse, I have some knowledge of Islam as well.
qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed.
That cool dude
Join Islam, for that’s the religion of Abraham, Moses and Jesus Christ ( peace be upon them all)
@@ayilaramutmaheen6779 I respect islam, but I believe in Christianity.
Want to know about Muslim, Amish or pentecostal let me know. I have questions for you about Catholic though that may be you could address for me
Quran is the Guide , Only to Allah (God) we need to submit and believe in all his Scriptures, all Prophets and Angles.
A small correction regarding the part where the shaykh talks about the attributes of Allah and the Salafi interpretation. It is not true that they literally say it is a hand like a human hand, but that they believe that Allah has a hand, and what it is like, the believer does not enter into it or think about it. Big difference.
No, some made that mistake in the beginning.
Islam has so many divisions. I like how this man acknowledges that it is no different than the various schools of thought in Christianity.
Without doubt the clear, manifest, distinguished, evident proof of this title and ascription, which is to say: I am a Muslim upon the Book and the Sunnah and upon the methodology of our Salaf as-Salih, and that is to summarise it by saying: ‘I am a Salafi’.
I am a Muslim...
Not a Fake Sufi nor Fake Salafi...
You're not from the Salaf hence you're not a Salafi, you're being delusional know what you are a Wahabi!!!
Abdul Wahab claimed that anyone who disagress with him is a Kaafir & since no Sahabi ever claimed this then it's clear as daylight that Abdul Wahab was a fraud & a munafiq!!!
@@comparativereligiondailynews if you are a Muslim that means you are a Salafi by extension because salaf follow the prophetic teaching with the understanding of the companions and the followers.
@@comparativereligiondailynewsMuslim upon who’s understanding?
“As for those who divide their religion and break up into sects you have no part in the least, their affair is with Allah. He will in the end tell them what they used to do.”(Quran 6:159)
So we should not call ourselves as of any Mazhab, instead we should call ourselves as Muslims.
Absolutely right Islam is not like any other religions it is unique and it is true making sects and different beliefs makes it no different than Hinduism and Christinanity
Sunni is the right path
@Humanity Insaniyat no they're not
@Humanity Insaniyat see my friend the one doesn't believe in Quran and Sunnah and doesn't follow the commandments of Allah Al Wahid given in Quran and try to add up something extra which is not authentic and follow those things that person is not considered as muslim because he or she is not following the clear and simple statements of Allah SWT and doing something of their own will
@@loftilhan4868 You can’t call you Sunni, Shia or any other sect according to Quran.
This was really interesting to listen to. Thank you!
I wish to ask is there a specific reason why Dr. Shabir groomed his beard the way he did, I mean I heard mustache is to be shaved and beard to remain as a Sunnah following, however Dr. Shabir has shaved almost all of it from the face, even the chin, leaving only the part of beard which is on the neck area. Please educate me if this is the exact sunnah of the prophet? Thanks.
Trim your moustache and grow your beard. Mormons and others shave their moustaches whilst keeping a beard.
Alhamdulillah
. What is called in our time “Salafiyyah” are the Sunnis, or Ahl al-Hadith wa al-Athar, in short, who follow Islam as stated if they want to define the interpretation of Surat Nadhrun in what the Companions, the Successors, and their followers said, and our scholars and sheikhs have a Mutawatir chain of transmission in this regard. We are not like Al-Ash'ari, Al-Maturidi, Ibadi, and Rafidah. If they want to interpret a verse, they turn to philosophy. If they see a hadith that contradicts their opinions, they say it is weak, or they change its meaning and philosophize based on it. As for whoever denies the attributes of God Almighty, such as His being leveled above the heavens, or His face, or His hand, or His leg, or who says that the Qur’an is created and that God does not speak, then they are Al-Jahm bin Safwan, the Mu’tazilites, Abdullah Al-Ibadi, the Rafidite Shiites, the Zaidis, the Kalabiyya, the Ash’aris, the Maturidis, and all of these people do not have a prophetic hadith or a saying of a companion.
To prove the validity of their religion. The Muslim Brotherhood are not Salafis, but rather they are Ash'ari Sufis. Your conclusion reminds me of the Indian Emperor Akbar, who invented a new religion
What is rational, what is logical, what is humane, what is spiritual and what is true faith in God..
Once i was in Madina visiting the beloved Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) grave.. i was passing by waiving my hand and scaff along the barricaded pathway.. just trying to express my love.. surprisingly i was shouted syirik! syirik! syirik sheikh! by one of the guard.. sadly as i recalled if someone accuse you of disassociation in Allah and if Allah judge otherwise the blame will be upon the accuser.. i'm surprise people could be so quick in judging others.. that may lead to disunity, quarrels, disputes and conflicts.. i remember a hadith the Sahabat Bilal(RA) would roll his bare body at the prophet grave in tears of his longing.. is it a bidaah not ride camels to work or use toothpaste instead of siwak.. some would be so dogmatic, narrow or shallow in their insistence.. that they forget to apply other tens or hundreds of hadiths to smile, to be peaceful, to be kind and loving to one another in the true faith of Allah.. just my humble opinion, may Allah forgive, guide and bless us all.. Ameen..
Subḥana’llāh
How is an average person supposed to decide between what is good and bad without having broad knowledge of Islam, since one have to follow the explanation of Quran and Sunna from someone, isn’t it better to follow a school of thought another word view of group of scholars of early generations. Despite of so many different opinions in gray space between the school of thought, there is no hatred or arrogance between the followers. Sadly the Wahabi and the Salafi brothers are far away from this quality. It is absolutely wrong statement to say that all schools have good and bad, because opinion of all schools of thought are base in authentic sources which one might disagree with, actually it’s the individual followers of schools of thought have good and bad in them which is understandable. Finally I like to advise the interviewer to have some manners not to call someone (ie dr Shibbir) by name who’s way older then her in age and much knowledge then her in Islamic knowledge.
May Allah Subhanahu wa ta’ala grant me and you all beneficial knowledge and understanding of Islam.
Muhammad is mentioned only four times in the Koran and that too all in the past. The Koran describes Muhammad as someone who lived in the past. So which Muhammad are Muslims referring to as thei prophet
If he had a problem with her addressing him that way he would say so...also he is her dad. 🤦🏾♀️
Alhamdulillah I got Tohid from Salafi!
The Abdul Wahab was the one who focus the follow only authentic source only.
Now Saudi Arabia is the only one nation who holding Tohid without mixing it.
Alhamdulillah
Salfai and wahhabisam terrarist group
Subhanallah
Bro, you are being used by zionists. Salafism is a zionist project to divide muslims
Estagfirullah, may Allah guide you all
Is the term "Salafi" found in the Qur'an?
bad argument. neither worshipping Ali As Allah like iranian shias do
The word Salaf is found in the Quran
I'm a muslim. as far as i seen, many people tend to think that this kinda movement as a sect. It isn't.
I think it's a compulsory for muslims to follow the early generations/Shahabah (salaaf), especially on aqidah subject and their way of thinking. Because they learned the quran and hadith and its tafseer directly from Rasulullah peace be upon him.
As explained in the video, people often try to interpret (takweel) the attributes of Allah, that Allah himself mentions in the Quran.
But as far as the Shahaabah do, this clearly PROHIBITED.
You CAN'T intrepret (for example) Allah's hand as a kind of "power". But just explain it literally as Allah intrepret himself in the quran. BUT we DON'T think how and what his 'hand' is look like, especially compared to human hands or his creation type of hand. This is how the salaaf tafseer, and the aqidah of the salaaf.
And as muslim who follow their teaching, we are automatically a salafy by definition. I see nothing wrong with that.
And the way they learn today is also the most scientific afaik. This makes the new generation more interested in studying Islam at its purest.
10:23
bruh
Salaf never ever interpreted those verses by saying that
they r metaphorical
they never distorted the meaning of the Qur'an
they used to believe in the understanding of the companions of the Prophet peace be upon him
and the companions used to believe in those verses literally without using the word
"how"
because they r the part of unseen
and the knower of unseen is ALLAH SWT
Despite the fact that I do not follow the same school of thought with the sheikh, I believe he is amazing. He deserves the title "Allamah" which is a status above "Aalim"; both derived from "ilm" meaning knowledge. On top of that he is "Mujtahid". He reads, evaluates then draws his own conclusion "qawl".
Most Indian scholars are distinctive and exemplary.
i feel sorry for you
@@At-tibyaan101 Thank you
Allamah!!!! I knw 15 yearolds who are more knowledgeable than this joke. May Allah guide him
@@nishiayad You mean like libraries?
Libraries carry knowledge..lots of knowledge, but we can't describe them as "knowledgeable". BTW, forget about this "joke", how much do YOU know?
@@ALI2IZZ you don't have to be Alim to know who is Alim akhi.
first. You will not find anyone identifying themselves as a Wahhabi, this is the fallacy of the straw man.
secondly. Salafism or Ahl al-Athar is a matter related to the doctrine, meaning that you are a Muslim who understands your religion in the same way that the first three generations understood it, especially the understanding of the Prophet (PBUH) and his companions.
He mixes between fiqh and belief.
The four schools are schools of fiqh, but when the question is about Salafism, the comparison is, for example, about Ash’ari or Maturidi (like the Taliban, many think that they are Salafis and this is not true), the Mu’tazilites (like Shabir Ally himself, but with a liberal touch), Kulabi, Jahmi and even Shias or Ibadites ... (doctrinal schools, the difference between them is doctrinal not just a difference in fiqh)
I think he does it on purpose or he is speaking out of ignorance.
U said the truth, Coz even shk. Muhammad Ibn Abdulwahab he was not around in 700yrs as he as said shk. Is from 1000
Slmalkm everyone, could someone please tell me why have saudi arabia kept only sheikh abdul wahabs teachings for arabia, and not any other sheikhs, scholars, alims, men of knowledge. Etc, etc..im very confused here, can some one explain please, would help me a great deal and ease my confusion aswell as many others like me could also benefit from some one with knowledge to explain and clear and refresh our misty minds, thankyou will appreciate it. ♥️🙏❤️..
Saudi Arabia didn’t keep only his teachings but the teachings of the salaf. It’s sh Mohammad ibn abdelwahhab Who followed the salaf. If you want to know the real and true Islam go to al madrasatu al umariyyah channel
alaykum salam
Before talking about the difference between Salafi and Wahabi, the question is where is the starting common reference? The answer is once the common starting point is having faith on the five pillars or basic Isamic fundamantal believes which is being the:
1. Faith in the only one Allah.
2. Believing that Moahmed is the final messenger from Allah.
3. Practicing prayer performance as a duty.
4. Observing the Zakat Almis giving.
5. Obeying once in life time the Haj Pilgrimage by giving visit tribute to Mecca.
If a Moslem take the pledge to do whole heartedly the above mention five obligations he or she is on the right track and can play rugby or steep chase, let alone becoming a member of a group as long as there is a Soveriegn country with goverance. What is not acceptable in Islam is lack of law and order or anarchy.
17:13 I got my answer Thank you!
Muslim narrated from Hudhayfah ibn al-Yaman [radhiyallahu 'anhu] that he said:
"I said: "O Messenger of Allah, we were in a state of evil, then Allah brought us this good that we are in now. Will there be evil after this good?" He said: "Yes."
I said: "Will there be good after this evil?" He said: "Yes."
I said: "Will there be evil after this good?" He said: "Yes."
I said: "How?" He said: "There will be after me leaders who do not adhere to my guidance, and who do not follow my Sunnah.
" (Sahih Muslim)
Note: The best examples of the consequence after the Caliphs are overthrown : Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan.
This is idiotic. What do the caliphs have to do with modern nation-states?
@@dandiaz19934
Khalifa means the head of the state of a country or a tribe etc. Netanyahu is the Khalifa of Israel , Biden is the Khalifa of America, Modi is the Khalifa of India, King Salman is the Khalifa of Saudi Arabia. Khelafa on Earth is given to a nation by Allah. It is absolute power on earth. Khalifa of the earth is that Nation or that individual of the nation who have the absolute power and authority on earth. Khalifa is a Arabic word. There are another type of Khalifa i.e. Khalifa ala Mihajun Nabua = Khalifa upon the way of the prophet hood. These Khalifas are rightly guided by Allah. Adam, King Solomon King David, The first four Muslim Khalifa etc were rightly guided Khalifa. Other Khalifas can be good or bad. Such as The Aaad and Thamud nation (Referred in the Quran) were the Khalifa of the Earth who were not rightly guided.
They don't follow Sunnah. They do wild interpretations. And that is not Sunnah.
@@cowsmuggler1646
Who are they?
@@khalidibnwalid1340 you, who else?
Some Muslims who claim them self as salafissm
they are not pleasent to be around they are very pushy
about religion and how to be in it especially for women if they are not covered like them I mean fully covered it seems never is good enough how much you do.
So be it. We can not compromise the deen
@@user-jg8eh8fw5z what deen full of extreme minded toxic individuals.
@@user-jg8eh8fw5z what deen doing sucide bombing killing innocent people that's your deen?
@@user-jg8eh8fw5zno you blindly follow a man that killed many Muslims and allowed kaffirs to kill Muslim… yeah so be it
In short, salafism or wahabism is not considered as mainstream Islam.
Actually ibnu Abdul Wahab misinterpreted the ideology of salafusswaliheen and make fake claim that he follows them. Actually that man represented some of deviant ideology of ibn taymiyyah who is controversial figure Muslim Scholars.
Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala bless you guys for your good work
I was watching your channel for sometime now, and I hope you will pose my question to Mr shabir ally because I watched a lot of his debates and very much enjoyed it.
And I would really happy if you will notice and answer my question which I was wondering for quite sometime. So my question is a little bit related to your today's topic. I would like to know about other great yearly scholars of islam who were very reputable and respected also in the first three generation but who's were not lucky to be survived or later embraced or joint with classical four schools. I would like to Mr shabir
ally will elaborate who were they at least just names and I could read their biography because it's so interesting for a lot of ordinary
people. I'm not sure I guess Sufian as Sauri was one of them.
I hope you won't ignore my message. Thank you very much and good luck in your job.
Truly yours Akimkhan from Kazakhstan.
Brother you can just Google the answers to your questions and you will find plenty of credible information that will satisfy your needs. If you have such a need for real answers please pursue a more expedited approach. Mr. Shabbir Ally will more than likely not be able to answer a UA-cam question in the comments. It's just not realistic.
I'd like to give you some leads with regards to your question:
- Suffian Al Thawri, like you said
- Al Awza'i, imam of Al Sham
- Al Laith ibn Sa'd
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
These 4 schools of thought were within the first 300 years. So Salafism is among them.
But not Wahabism.
Let me explain it to you more clearly there are two main sects shows I’m and Sunnis now Sunnis have four madahb Maliki Shafi Hanafi Hanbali Salafi are Hanbali now some salafis follow the teachings of Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab and some don’t but don’t separate them those who follow his teachings are still salafis just like how I can follow the teachings of a certain scholar but I will still stay Salafi also all people who follow Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab are Muslim Sunnis Hanbali Salafi but not all Salafi follow the teachings of Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab
For documentation purposes: who wrote this was a Muslim Sunni Hanbali Salafi and a follower of the teachings of Muhammad Ibn Abd Alwahab.
Have fun brother. Thank you.
Bother true salafis are the Ahle Sunnah waljamaah ie those who follow the experts in jurisprudence who were from the salaf asaalihun and earlier generations (khair al quroon) - Hanafi, Shafie, Maliki and Hambali.
In my opinion the new groups such as 'Salafis' have caused massive confusion. While they happily hail and strict rigidly to their recent scholars viz Albaani, they don't shy away from labelling the majority of the Ahle sunnah as 'blind followers'.
May Allah taala grant us true understanding and protect our imaan. AMEEN!
I asked one Rabbi did he read the Surah Al Qahf do they study the Quran to have knowledge what the Quran says ? He said yes I did. So I asked do you have the same story in the Torah about Moses traveling with Khidr Aleyhisalaam? He said there is not such an event in the live of Prophet Moses . If there was such an event we Jews must have it recorded in our records. And I said then why it is in the Quran ? He said I have no idea .
I'm guessing the story of Moses traveling with Khidr, and his journey for knowledge , was when he was still living with Pharaoh.
Thats why they were made to believe, that Whatever you ruler do, donot rise against him. This is the worst attack on the spirit of Islam.
Alhamdulillah, May Allah always guide Dr Shabir & his daughter Dr. Safiyyah.
He has beard goat. He is eb lease worship. That is why he calls himself Quran. Quran is not speaking. He is speaking. Only Mohammed can claim he is Quran speaking. Because he was the Quran walking. So he is saying he is like Mohammed. He is coo far.
@@cowsmuggler1646 bro, do u know google translate? use that atleast.
@@NSProductionmy You have goat beard? You a follower of ab lease too?
What is your problemet it is normal if a man have beard Jesus peace be upon him had beard.
Have some respect to other peoples I see in many off your comments you have personal problem against us Muslims.
May Allah guide you and remove the hate frome your heart my advice to you is read about Islam frome our Islamic books and leave the hate media they will never show you the correct information.
Peace
@@abdiasisali A certain type of beard. Goat has beard with no mustache. Goat is the symbol of say tonne.
We proud to be folowing salafisom as much we can .
We try to folow the sunna of Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him . We refuse to folow the innovation in islam ....
The people who are innovating new to islam the get ready to reserve seat to hellfire ..
Pot is calling the kettle black
@@yusuf786baig your statement is empty
@@Randomhandlename Not as empty as Salafi's heart and brains. Salafis are just white washing the current sheikhs in the throne and their acts.
Please prove:
1) Music Concert in Saudi.
2) Saudi National Day
3) Bombarding Muslim countries or supporting the oppressor.
4) The Saudi Clock Tower
(I can list things which Salafis won't dare to speak against)
You are koofar. You put a clock tower in Mecca. In the West clock tower is symbol of shaytan. He is known as father time. The Burj Khalifa is designed like the Tower of Babel. You put moons on your mosques. And you destroy the tombs of the prophets and hurt Muslims. You are shaytan worshipers. Koofar. Know them by their fruit. You can say whatever you want. That don't mean nothing.
@@cowsmuggler1646 we proud to be follower of true islam. Not like
Fruit salad mixing all fruits then branded as single fruite juice .
Study islam properly by authentic hadhees ... avoide the punishment from Allah by doing unislamic way ...
Understanding Quran and Sunnah are important, read and lean on your own that’s very important, my Allah forgive all our sins
Thank you for your message, to understand Islam we have the Quran, to understand the Quran we have the Sunnah (Hadiths) to understand the Sunnah we have the Companions (the Salaf).
Simply put, each need to be in correlation with the other and thus the Quran.
We have people here who are arguing and making statements with words/sentences on the face that may seem correct and/or nice, but remember (this part isn't directed at you, but generally to all who may read) some of the people here reject the Hadiths in entirety, thus negating the Sunnah. However, we find God in the Quran clear tell us to follow the Sunnah, thus true Hadiths and our sources of the Hadiths are the Companions and naturally the Salah that follow.
It is unfortunate that there are so many misunderstandings, confusions and paradigms flawed by politics and/or misconceptions. Yet it is by the Will of Allah that these occur.
May Allah give us deeper sincerity, a better understanding and a sharper capacity to distinguish matters and not fall into traps of misinterpreting what comes our way as a trial, ameen.
actually understaing the quran and "ahlul bayt" is important, the "thaqalayn" (two weighty, precious things)
@@KenanTurkiye I am incapable in believing that stoning human beings for homosexuality or apostasy is credible…
@@KenanTurkiye
Do not forget to follows the uelamas who follow the teachings of the prophet (ulama warosatul anbiya),.which they took knowledge from their teachers, the teachers.of their teachers up to the Salaf (isnad).
This is the Sunni Ahlussunnah wal Jamaah's way.
Anyone who claimed following the Quran & Sunnah without having isnad would be on the wrong path for sure as mentioned in Hadith "anyone who learned Quran and Sunnah by his self understanding (bi Ro'yi) will be put on ashtray"
HR Tirmidzi
وَمَنْ قَالَ فِى الْقُرْآنِ بِرَأْيِهِ فَلْيَتَبَوَّأْ مَقْعَدَهُ مِنَ النَّارِ
Allahu a'lam...
@@ibnadam9606 then you are either an ignorant Muslim influenced by secularism (if that's the case then fear Allah ) or you are a clear disbeliever which makes your options useless and not of importance when it comes to Islam and it's adherents
What are the names and spelling of the all the teachers Dr. Shabir in the 18th century…I would like to research them
The Wahhabism is a movement founded by Abd al-Wahhab ibn Rustam al-Ibadi in 171 AH, and it is a group of Kharijites that originated in Morocco, where its founder declared all Muslims to be infidels and disrupted the Hajj.
When the call for monotheism was established in the Arabian Peninsula at the hands of Imam Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab, may God have mercy on him, at the beginning of the twelfth century of migration, and Imam Muhammad ibn Saud supported him, the Ottoman Empire at that time called their call Wahhabism to alienate Muslims from them.
They overwhelmed the ignorant people because the names are similar, but history has revealed them.
The Arabized Standard in the Fatwas of the People of Morocco (1/168)
quotation:
Noor Muhammad bin Fayd Ahmad Al-Arkani
Such an accessible discussion. Great to learn as a Catholic.
qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed.
@Maths PC qurans are manmade books, they write about 7th century ideas, like a FLAT EARTH, like a bed (43;10) , a SKY THAT CAN FALL DOWN on EARTH (22;65), incorrect embryology ; BONES ARE FORMED FIRST THEN CLOTHED WITH FLESH (23;14)....these (and other) were POPULAR BELIEFS back then and SIMPLY COPIED by Mohammed.
@Maths PC Christian
@PC Maths no
@PC Maths you think the sky can fall on earth like allah says? (qurans 22;65) sky is a gas resting on earthsurface/ light shines through it.....people in 7th century believed sky was up there....this was a very COMMON POPULAR BELIEF.....now what do think about 22;65?
I also know 2 or 3 hadtih ,,
Muhammad (pbuh) said I fear most of one thing in our islamic age that
at end time , a group of follower will come to existence and they will claim they are true Muslim (extremist) ,but they were far from Islam is like an arrow will separate from his bow,,whenever you see them killed them and that reward will grant you on day of judgment..
2. A man will come from najd who cause greatest fitna amongst the whole Muslim world ,they will call themselves true follower but there back is always in front of true teaching. ..
So nice try to defend deviants,,,
3. Whenever u find difficult to follow the true teaching of Islam in end time,,,,follow largest group of Islam,,,
Now which group have largest group of Islam in current time it's Sunni sect( hanfi,shafi,hanbali,Maliki)..
And a nice try to defend Medina university who is established in 1900 century,,,,
Pls share sources for these hadeeth. Especially the second hadeeth you mentioned about a prophecy of a man coming from najd who would cause great fitnah.
@@rehanasyed8831 the horns of the devil will come from najdn and najd is Ryadh. Some people in order to escape this, they try to say that najd is Iraq and not Ryad. But it is well established that najd is Ryad and when the prohet a.s. blessed Sham and Yemen, some people said bless z
nejd as well, but the prophet a.s. refused to do so and here he mentioned the horns of the devil will come from there
Just a food of thought for my Sunni brothers and sisters:
This Hadith is from Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) and I'm sure everybody is familiar with but nobody take it seriously.
My ummah will be divided into 73 sects. All of them will be in the Hell Fire except one. (Sahih Moslem)
The DAY when We shall call together all human beings with their (respective) Imam. Quran 17:71
Personally I TAKE my religion from the one who was appointed by Allah, the one who was the first accepted Islam.
The one who was raised by Prophet himself and the one who was married the daughter of the Prophet.
Off course there are so many other proofs to support my believes but that I just leave it to this for now.
How about you follow the prophet Muhammad s.a.w.? Wouldn't that be a better idea?
Sunan Ibn Majah Hadith 3950
36 Tribulations (8) Chapter: The great majority
Anas bin Malik said:
“I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’”
Khotay follow ajmah on Quran and hadith If Wana follow great majority then Christians are majority...
@Farhan Salaam brother first of all learn some Manners then the guidance will follow Insha’Allah. If you want to discuss this hadith and anything else in a civilised manner then I'm here
DR Shabir is avoiding the question that the four schools of thought developed after the first generation of the Salaf. And Salafism did not developed in the 20th Century, nor did the medhhab of Wahabism developed in the 18th century. Both Salafism and Wahabism is the medhhab of Muhammad ibn 'Abdullah. And the Muslim brotherhood are not considered Salafee.
🩸🩸🩸If you go around the world many incorrect teachings have crept into Islamic practice ( especially in South Asian part of the world). I believe Islamic teachings have to be understood the way earlier generations of Muslim understood from prophet and for that you need proper extensive education from Islamic universities. Imagine every Tom, Dick and Harry read Islamic scriptures and give their own interpretation then even none Muslims can read Islamic scriptures and give their own understanding. I think that would be disastrous. We should always strive to understand Islamic teachings the way prophet taught and I think that earlier generations of Muslims were the best at this. FYI, Salaf is not a sect. Peace ✌️
true but don’t worry the Sahaba didn’t behave like most self proclaimed “salafis” do today
Salafist are new they only emerge after Muhammad bin Abdul wahhab
@@mumtaz4327 He did quality control by following the earlier generations of Muslim that is the proper ways the Islamic teachings has to be understood from prophet Mohammed (pbuh). Peace ✌️
How can someone so cruel and harsh with words claim they are among people of the sunnah , salafi is some of the most harsh peoples with words ive met in the comment,
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
As a libral, has anyone asked these scholars who gave the four imams the authority to devide?
Nobody divided anything, that's only your perception
@@altappomaktappo7060 you could be right but I know for a fact madhabs had their own area years back.
Arabs are known for creating issues and my religion Islam is perfect.
Arabs the imperfect creed of shaitan
What did they devide
They won't dare. Only the salafis hammer them.
@@altappomaktappo7060 Of course devided. nearly all Indian muslims are mushriqs.
Finally, someone acknowledged the Ibadi school! Al hamdulillah. @2:42
Damn, that is a Khawarij like sect.
@@mohamudahmed6554 why? what makes them extreem? they are not extreem at all. Oman is the best country in the middle East.
@@hassendelft3907 They agree with the Khawarij in denying the attributes of Allah, they claim the Quran is created and allow rebellion against the Muslim ruler.
Also 45% Omanis are Sunni so we can't claim Omani is mostly ru, governed,influenced by Ibadis.
@@mohamudahmed6554 they allow rebellion against Muslim ruler 🤣🤣
That's good thing. Most of rules in Muslim countries are Zionists.
@@hassendelft3907 That goes against the Ijma (consensus) of the Sahaba and the tabien and tabu tabien. In fact, the majority of the Ummah do not allow this because of the Authentic hadith of Prophet ﷺ where he forbids rebelling against the Muslim leader. I don't think anyone who is a deviant would go against this consensus.
This is exactly the nonsense Khawarij wanted and that is why Uthman ibn Affan رضي الله عنه was killed.
Very good clear moderate pace not too long appropriate English language. No open criticism of govt a key point of story
As a Muslim from the Shia school of thought this man speaks truth unlike a lot of others like him who spread false lies and who destroyed the shrine of imam Hussein.
Listen to Hassan Allahyari
Avoid every group who spread anger and divide Muslim more than before
The only truth is in following the Quran and the sunnah with the understanding of the 3 favored generations. Anyone who goes against that is the one who divided and ran away from true Islam
just about every salafi that i have met are experts in divisive tactics
@@sisoshsasa some people that ascribe themselves to the way of the salaf don't truly follow it and go extreme in refutations. But in general salafis forbidding evil and not uniting with other deviant groups is a good thing. How can the muslims unite upon different beliefs? We'll unite when all the groups with false beliefs return to the quran and the sunnah
@@xhalo_4137 problem is that many “salafis” have opinions that are often subjective at best. in every community i have ever been salafis divide, start drama and feel totally justified for all the chaos they create. we are what like 1,500 years removed from the best generation that that ever lived? we’re too weak as Ummah right now to be divided. i take solace in knowing that the Sahabah didn’t behave ANYTHING like most “salafis” today
Subhaanallah, the status of our ummah.
"And glad tidings to the strangers".
When i saw the scarf and the line of questioning i know some ignorance is about to go down.
What a joke. Notice how he disassociates himself. Tap dancing. Be firm!!!
May Allah guide us. Ameen.
Unfortunately people will think all he’s said is what salafi is all about
@@Alaminzaid1 They are coo far. Followers of goat.
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
Need to emphasize here that despite of factions among Muslims worldwide, we are being confronted with some ideologies that have brought down Islam as a way of life. To some extent that LGBT and One World Religion are on the rise while ulama' are stunned with worldly matters and wealth. Don't get involved with mazhabs and perceptive thinking as means and ways to conclude which one is right because we still have alQur'an and Hadiths for reference.
Sincerely,
You either read and learn a lot to know or you don't read and you don't know. Dr. Shabir Ally is mistaken in his definitions of salafi and "wahhabi". Salafism is Aqeedah not a school of jurisprudence (madhab). All 4 major schools of jurisprudence are salafi. Sheikh AbdulWahhab is of the Hanbali school of jurispudence. As for the phrase "Wahhabi",,,, accusing a man with that phrase ( one of the 99 names of Allah) is linguistically the equivalent of calling him godly. As for its use as an insult or term of derision, well,,,,, after you meet God, tell us how it went. Would love to learn what you know about God's names and their use(s) that the rest of the Ummah does not know.
As an interesting observation,,, in general I have noticed that those who comment on the opposing side of the salafi/"wahhabi" videos online are on the whole the rudest and most insulting.
If you have no manners, you have no Deen.
Regardless of which side you are on.
17:34 I respectfully disagree. If everyone picks whatever he wants from every movement, everyone would have his own version of Islam
Agreed
This is not time to bring dispute speech of Islam rather talk to unity. Allah show us true path. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤💕
What? Allah cannot unite his own believers????
He is not disputing. He is explaining the issues brought by whoever is asking. And toward the end he does talks and calls for unity. Salam.
You are very correct this is not right time to talk about religion we need to unite and save our brother from the country like india sri lanka and mianmar
Sure shabir debates Christians and debates western preachers, I have not yet seen a sunni preacher coming out and telling sunnis that sunnis have no evidence that Rasulallah appointed abu baker to be Khalifa, and abu baker lied to Rasullallah and banned the writing of hadith.
What do you mean? Explain
Rasullallah Said " I am leaving among you two successors: * The Book of Allah, is a rope stretched between the heavens and the earth, and عترتي اهل بيتي Ahllulbeity, and they will not be separated until they come back to me at alhawd.*
Al-Suyuti's graduation
(Hamm Tabb) on the authority of Zaid bin Thabit.
Al-Albani's investigation
(Sahih) See Hadith No.: 2457 in Sahih Al-Jami’.
According to this hadith, unless you follow Ahlullbeit, you will lead yourself astray.
We have Qura'n now...!!
Where are ahl e byt now to guide us (after Hassan Askari died without leaving any heir/or when his non existant son went into hiding).?
@@zahidfareed3218 (we have Quran now) that's what omar said in (razia khamis) . omar was exposed by Rasulallah as fasik munafik. Second point about the Mahdi, nore that 65 sunni scholars confirmed his birth on the ( 15th of Chabaan.) So, sunna is also Quran and the Mahdi, son of Imam Askhari, is the 12 successor of Rasulallah.
@@tryemc3026
Where is the non existant imam to guide us now .... when Hassan al Askari left this world without leaving any heir ..!!!!
@@tryemc3026
To whom we should turn for guidence now ..???
As we have to take knowledge only from infallibles ...!!
@@zahidfareed3218
You just went in a circle, did you read what my reply? More than 65 sunni scholars in thir books conformed the birth of Imam Mahdi on the 15 of Chabaan. If you are sunni then you have to believe in hadith same as you believe in the Quran, that's why yiu have bukhari muslim and other hadith books.
Rasullah said in ghadir khum
اني تارك فيكم خليفتين كتاب الله وعترتي أهل بيتي، لن يفترقا حتى يردا علي الحوض (الصواعق المحرقة)
Rasulallah also said
لاىتقوم الساعة حتى يبعث الله رجلا من اهل بيتي يملا الأرض قسطا وعدلا كما ملات ظلما وجورا
Rasulallah is telling that the Mahdi is the last Khalifa, and his absence is ordained b Allah, and your guidance is to verify taken from Imams of Ahlullbeit during the absence of thr Mahdi (as)
Thank you my scholar, you explain very well
I don't see no Quran speaking. I see some man speaking. The man is koofar. He is claiming to be Quran. He is a wasabi himself. The goat beard is their thing. The bafomet goat.
@@cowsmuggler1646He does not invite you. go to your favourite mullah
@@cowsmuggler1646 obvious troll is obvious
Islam Mya 4 Imam Ke Followers Hain Aur Alhamdulillah Ye 4 Ke 4 Imams Sabse Ke Sab Ehle Sunnat Wal Jamat Ke Hain
Aur Sabke Ke Sabse Sab Ashike-e-Rasool Hain
Ye Koi Firke Nahi Hai Ye 4 Musselle Hai
Jo Ashike-e-Rasool Hain Aur Mussalman Inke Followers Hain
Aur Gustak-e- Rasool Mussalman Ho Nahi Shakta
Jitne Bhi Firke Wo Sab Ya Gustak-e- Rasool Ya Fir Gustak-e- Sahaba
1 Firka Shia
2 Bohri
3 Ehle Hadish Saudi's Followers
4 Jamat e Islami
5 Wahabi Saudi's Followers
6 Najdi Saudi's Followers
7 Devbandi
8 Tabligki Jamat
9 Zhikri
Kadyani
Ye Sabke Sab Allah Aur Allah Ke Rasool Aur
Din e Islam Ke Dusman Hain
Inse Hamsa Bachke Rahaho Nahi Ye
Tumhare Imam Ko Nuksan Phuchayage
05 Ramadan 1444.
I enjoyed and learned by watching this episode .
I come across this Chanel only today and subscribed .
May Allah bless you .
Can you make a video on how saint qabar khurafat and amliyat entered in Islam
They can dress it up all they want but schools, wahabis, salafis etc are all sects forbidden within Quran. There is only submission to one God. The Quran warms against sects but man can't help following other men.
You are confusing sincere efforts to strive to understand and share Islam with secterianistic polarization (which is not allowed in Islam), yet bundling the sincere efforts to investigate, learn and propagate Islam with such secterianism is an orientalist ambition in order to curb the spread of Islam. In another message in this video, you clearly detailed how you reject Hadiths and only Quran is enough, whereas in the Quran Allah says follow the Sunnah and the source of Sunnah is the true Hadiths. Again, your complete rejection of Hadiths is another orientalist/western ideological attempt to cause a breakup of the Muslim unity.
I request you reevaluate your standing, but obviously you are free to choose as you wish as this life is a life of trial and I wish you the best that you deserve in both worlds.
@@KenanTurkiye And this is nothing to do with western "orientalists". It's to do with those who do what Quran tells us, to think. It was sent to a people who are capable of thought and to seek knowledge, not follow dogma or imams or pirs or schools or sects. That is why Islam flourished in the early days when it came to science and progress as Europe was in the dark ages. Over time we reverted to backwardness with a focus on rituals and style over substance, choosing outward appearance over heart. Hadiths are merely allegations, they are alleged saying of the prophet according to third parties and therefore hearsay. Imagine if no one collected them, where would you be today? Because God certainly never told anyone to write anything else. The Quran is huge and before you start if Prayer is essentially the key to heaven why is each "namaz" and wudu steps not categorically listed step by step in its current from today? If Iblis prayed so much like nonother and had so much knowledge how was that still not enough to save him for simply refusing to bow to Adam AS? If prayer was proscribed to Jews and Christians why aren't they doing it today either, the Jews at least because they preserved their books better apart from adding in Talmud and Mishna. It is because just like other "sects" of monotheism we created our own based on man made books too. Doesn't Quran warn to follow in the footsteps of our forefathers? What do you think that means? To me it's the mainstream today.
@@SK991dvdhd Do you realize Hadiths are the source of the Sunnah of the Last Prophet (peace be upon him)?
Do you realize the Creator in the Quran, explicity informs the reader that the previous 'people of the book' lost their religion because they did not follow the Sunnah of the Prophets that were sent to them (peace be upon them all)?
The realities of fabricated Hadiths is in no means an excuse to reject ALL Hadiths, as you reminded us, in the Quran The Creator calls on us readers to contemplate, reason and evaluate the evidences in existance, so rejecting ALL the Hadiths goes even against that.
Orientalist/enemies of Islam want ALL Hadiths to be rejected by muslims, because they did the same with other peole of the book (their ancestors in disbelief did) hence why the previous people of the book became ''those who are astray or those who gained ''His'' anger''.
Muslim community is under attack by the same disbelievers who want to take Sunnah away from the Muslims and leave them with the Quran (sounds so nice, but the Quran says don't leave the Sunnah), that's how word play fools some people into thinking that they are right.
Islam is understood with Quran, Sunnah and the Example of The Companions.
And yes Allah in the Quran says, follow the Sunnah and brings to us the The Companions as examples.
So you trying to dismantle this does not do harm to Islam, but to your own knowledge and faith.
@@KenanTurkiye Quran tells you it is complete and hadiths are 3rd party hearsay. Take it or leave it.
@@SK991dvdhd With your last message you are again making a confused mistake.
The Quran is complete, anyone who doubts that is in the wrong. That is not the point I brought across, nor should that be your anchor to continue your confused statements.
We are talking of the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace be upon him), his Sunnah was observed by the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, and they took His Way as an example in their lives. The Way of the Prophet (peace be upon him) is collected in the Hadiths, some original, some fabricated, and these have been deduced and cleared by Islamic scientist and scholars.
So you claim to completely reject ALL Hadiths is rejecting the Prophet, who's Way is pointed out to us in many verses in the Quran and we are commanded by The Creator to follow his path (peace be upon him).
Of course as muslims, we take the Prophets Way (peace be upon him).
I hope you understand how you are confusing two issue, The Quran is complete, the Sunnah/The Way of the Last Prophet (peace be upon him) is in the Hadiths.
Disbelievers want to shoot the muslims by claiming The Quran is perfect yet reject the Sunnah, I hope you wont fall for that trap anymore.
The tv program should invite the right alim ulama who really understands what is salafy, so the world not miss took about salafy, in our country Indonesia Masya Allah and Alhamdulillah spread really fast.. Salafy teachs us back to the right path to the way Rosulullah alaihi sholatu wassalam and the sahabat from the wrong traditions that we follows over years and years..
what do you mean by the right ulama
@@modoulaminsanyang1324 right ulama means right Schølar , people who teaches the Quran and Sunnah according to the understanding of the three earlier generations
They destroy the tombs of sahaba and prophets. They are koofar. Anyone can say anything they want. Know them by their fruits.
@@modoulaminsanyang1324 sory i meant scholar or syekh, in Indonesia we called alim ulama or Ustad
@@ayilaramutmaheen6779 who do you meant by destroying tombs of para sahaba?
Assalamu AAalaykum: I am keenly following you a lots and endlessly loves for both of you. Can you kindly sends me 30 different recitations of Glorious Qur' an...
Aleyküm Selam
Māsha-Allah Wa Jazakumullah Khairan!!
I am a irreligious person and even I can say, this man is very good. He makes a very informative and clean explanations. He never do any propaganda. A value resource for Muslims and an irreligious person myself. Regardless of your beliefs and ideologies, it is very important for self to gain information, make and understanding of things, and keep your self objective. As long as you keep your objectivity and senses, ideologies, beliefs keep you from extremist and very subjective thinking. This will result with non-hate and harmony between different groups of people. I personally find it stupid to see any Muslim or Cristian, etc. person to be bad just because I am irreligious, I believe religious people should do the same against people like me. It is of course applicable as long as red lines are not crossed, in which it is very important where those red lines are drawn. It is very important to judge a person by his/her character and not by only by his/her beliefs and ideologies.
Why didn't dr. Shabeer mention the reson as to why Mohammed bin abdullwahab start the movement? The biddah in the Arabian peninsula and the Islamic world was spreading very much and people started to do shirk as to worship trees or rocks or Graves. It was a dark time . Thank Allah that people like Mohammed bin Abdul wahab were there to teach people the right way .
You baffoon, they didnt worship trees. Or rocks. Bidah doesnt mean you mass takfir the entire Arabian peninsula. Abdul Wahaab declared everyone in Mecca and Medina kafirs, he even declared his own teacher a kafir. His own brother and father opposed him citing he was a lunatic
@@abdulhaseeb6091 you're the ignorant one and bluntly lie don't spread false claims . He didn't said that to the scholars of Islam he fought against those who do shirk like worshipping Graves and Jin and rocks . I am a Saudi and I know the history of my country.
@@abdulhaseeb6091 also I'm sure you didn't read any of his books. If you did you'll know that you've wrongly accused him. You just repeat what his haters say and lie about without researching.
@@abdulhaseeb6091
Study history and you will realise who the buffoon actually is. But that requires one not to be a buffoon to start of with.
What is the right way? The teaching of Muhammad abdullwahab who says Allah sits on arsh c'mon man I'm not a scholar but we need to pray for a better guidance political power and religion doesn't mix and Muhammad Abdullah was using religion to gain political power! May Allah guide us towards the right path inshallah
The mind boggling thing is Quran and bukhari-Hadith both say “DONT BE DIVIDED INTO SECTS”
Yet we have plenty
And yet we like to identify with one or the other
So confusing
Just follow Quran. And read authentic Hadith for certain explanations and authentic narrations. Disagreements happen everywhere all the time among people, it happened even among Sahabas. Just don't let this be a cause of division among ummah.
The Salafis or Wahabis are more accurate and follows references from Quran and Sahi Hadith but others just follow their Mulllah and Maulavi without accurate references
@@Mu5tyLaghmani Brother there isn't such a thing as a Wahabis. These terms don't exist it's a derogatory form to describe those who follow the pious predecessor.
you have no understanding.
And imam bukhari followed shafi madhab (shafi jurisprudence ).
Thank you much brother and sister may ALLAH bless you two!
In the name of Allah, the most gracious, the merciful.
Is Calling Oneself As AHLUL HADEES or a SALAFI Justified when Allah Named us as Muslims:
And who is better in speech than one who invites to Allah and does righteousness and says, "Indeed, I am of the Muslims." (Quran 41:33)
The verses in which Allah the Lord almighty called us as Muslims were revealed at the time where there were no sects in Islam, The Whole Muslim Ummah was One body,
By the Passing of time unfortunately the Muslim Ummah was divided into several sects, Khawarij , Shia, Qadiyani, Baha'i, Parvezi, Barelvi (Grave worshippers), Deobandi and many more sects, Every sect call themselves to be Muslims. All these Sects seperated from the main body (Rasoolallah ﷺ and his Sahaba) follow their dignitaries blindly even if they contradict in the vital issues of Aqeedah (Belief) hence they are deviated. The way of Understanding Quran and Sunnah (Hadees) according to the understanding of Rasoolallah ﷺ and his Sahaba is Called
MANHAJ E SALAF, people those who follow this understanding are the part of that Main body, called as Salafi's or AHLUL HADEES. This is the only Rightly guided Sect.
Sunan Ibn Majah 3992
It was narrated from 'Awf bin Malik that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
“The Jews split into seventy-one sects, one of which will be in Paradise and seventy in Hell. The Christians split into seventy-two sects, seventy-one of which will be in Hell and one in Paradise. I swear by the One Whose Hand is the soul of Muhammad, my nation will split into seventy-three sects, one of which will be in Paradise and seventy-two in Hell.” It was said: “O Messenger of Allah, who are they?” He said: "The main body."
("What I am upon and my Companions." Jami` at- Tirmidhi 2641).
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 JAZAKALLAH KHAIR 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Shabir Ally's face is seperate from his beard it's mind boggling...it's like two different things in one. I wonder what led him to do that the need behind it and why he did not do it in his past years. I feel as if it's showing his facial features just like a modern day hijabis who wear hijab while showing everything.
Then close your eyes and just listen, if its mind boggling for you.
C'mon man. From this whole video all you gathered was sheikh's facial features?
If you learn Salafy methods. You'll found that all imam ahlu hadits is following salaf in understanding Quran and Hadits.
بارك الله فيك ....
SubhanAllah excellent!
So if the hadith doesn’t agree with science today then we reject it but tomorrow if the science agree with hadith we go back and accept the hadith ?? Is my understanding correct??
Confusion , contradictory and zombies
The first place he should have started was to rectify the question. The 4 schools is not a branch of Islam. It is a school of jurisprudence (fiqh). It is not a branch nor a sect in Islam. These 4 imams rhm all had the same understanding of aqeedah. Aqeedah is essentially an understanding of Allah from Revelation ie Qur'an and Sunnah. Wagabi is a derogatory term for Muslims that really want to strive to learn tawheed as understood from the Qur'an and Sunnah. We should refrain from using these derogatory terms as Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahab has done great work contrary to what some Muslims may say.
I like how Dr Shabir Ally tried his best to be neutral but still had to admit that salafism is a politicised movement that developed later and took things like Allah's throne and hand literally
@Takaeshi Nobi how old are you?
it is called anthropomorphism (mojasimaet ) it is well known facts in some of their ageeda ... listen to yasir qahdi and bro Hajj and books of al barbahari
@@sam59995 yeah i know these people believe Allah can sit and that Allah has 2 right hands (Astagfirullah)
@@zahinelahi2655
Did the salafist tell Allah has two right hands, even human wouldnt have two right hands right?
Did the salafist tell Allah sit, how's Allah sit in your opinion?
@@firmanhidayat8624 astagfirullah Allah does not sit but the salafis say that he sits like on a throne
To quote just one Hadith : 'Stay with the Majority of my Ummah for the Majority of you will never go astray " The Salafi movement is a very small minority. Just think about that for a moment. Thank you
Exactly and they are mostly found online , even their scholars
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Source to this hadith?
@@mercyoil If it’s a very well known hadith according to you then you shouldn’t have a problem citing the source.
As a proud atheist, this content is very informative and helpful to understand the different branches of Islam.
Perhaps Allah is calling you❤
Brother Shabbir, I used to listen you in past, but since you displayed very weak knowledge and weak faith when discussing with Christians regarding some important faith and beliefs like Israa and Meraj.
I pray to Almighty give you wisdom and strength to understand and defend our beliefs without giving up in pressure from others, Aameen.
Thank you for the informative topics. I would like to ask a question which you may consider answering in a future video if possible. Considering that the differences between Shia Islam and Sunni Islam is based on which hadeeth the two decided to follow and also the way they interpret respective hadeeth and Sunna. Also taking into account that the 4 main Sunni schools of thought also differ in the sunna and hadeeth they follow. Question is why the Shia isn't considered another school of thought, if they base their core agreed authentic hadeeth also? Thank you
At least he admits that he has to lean on the salafis as they rely strictly on Qur'an and sunnah
But also they rely on extreme view of Ibn Abdulwahab
Do they follow the salaf? I doubt ,the followers of salaf are follower of Madh hab in this case neo salafi don't follow Madh hab nor they follow salaf ,they follow Ibn Taymiyya and MUHAMMAD ABDULWAHAB and they are not salaf s they are khalafs
@@sadofaraji5999 blind followers of Madhab are full of innovations and no emphasis on the worship of Allah only emphasis on innovation
@@sadofaraji5999 I have been leveled as THIEF for not doing man made innovated worship also I belong from a village of India with a tomb where people are drawn to the grave and not to mosques, where people are drawn to Milad not to obligatory prayers. No one speaks about keeping beard
@@sadofaraji5999 my hanafi friend saw me not doing congregational dua after prayer and then called me to talk with me for 1 h 40 minutes
Great explainations. Thanks Dr Shabir. Assalamualaikum
Aleyküm Selam
Salafi are those adhere to the creed and methodology to the best generation of the salaf and sunnah, they follow the teachings firmly and practices according to the pious predecessors(salaf) and sunnah who were granted paradise that’s the main goal. They’re salafis that are too harsh and water down the aqeedah nowadays. Stay with the jamaah who are upon the truth ie Abu khadeejah, Abu hakeem, Abu idris etc
Lol 😂 finally met some one from salafi masjid lol though I was the only one nice to see salafi Manhaj growing also shout out to abukhadeeja Abu Hakim Bilal David and Abu iyad
@@ThePhoenixrisen01 Alhamdullilah akhi the dawah is growing Alhamdullilah
And imam bukhari followed shafi madhab (shafi jurisprudence )....
Assalamu alaikum, please have a detail about aqidha by watching " Do you really know Home" From "0newaytoparadise" by abu mussab.
11:34 I guess Imam malik, The founder of the Maliki madhab was was a salafi then? As he said:
Abdullah ibn Nafi’ reported: Malik, may Allah have mercy on him, was asked about the saying of Allah Almighty, “The Most Merciful rose above the Throne,” (20:5). The man said, “How is his rising?” Malik said, “The rising is acknowledged, its modality is unknown, and asking about it is an innovation (Bidah). I see you are a man who intended evil with this question.”
Source: al-Istidhkār 2/529
Ibn Abdul Barr said, “The people of the Sunnah agreed upon affirming the divine attributes as related in the Book and the Sunnah, interpreting them as reality and not as a metaphor, except that they do not ask ‘how’ is the modality of any of that.”
Source: al-‘Ulūw lil-‘Alī al-Ghaffār 1/250
عَنْ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ نَافِعٍ قَالَ سُئِلَ مَالِكٌ رحمه الله عَنْ قَوْلِ اللَّهِ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ الرَّحْمَنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَى قَالَ كَيْفَ اسْتَوَى فَقَالَ اسْتِوَاؤُهُ مَعْلُومٌ وَكَيْفِيَّتُهُ مَجْهُولَةٌ وَسُؤَالُكُ عَنْ هَذَا بِدْعَةٌ وَأَرَاكَ رَجُلَ سُوءٍ
2/529 الاستذكار
قال ابن عبد البر أهل السّنة مجمعون على الْإِقْرَار بِالصِّفَاتِ الورادة فِي الْكتاب وَالسّنة وَحملهَا على الْحَقِيقَة لَا على الْمجَاز إِلَّا أَنهم لم يكيفوا شَيْئا من ذَلِك
One of good scholars i know, thanks Doctor...
He isn’t a scholar but he has some knowledge.
@@holdshiftt2run308 google the definition of a scholar wahabi
@@ShahJee101 He literally denies ahadith based on opinion and his degree in Islamic studies is from a Canadian University. Maybe do some digging first jahil. Allah is Al Wahhab and I am his slave. So I am a Wahhabi lol