@@fidget0227 and he mentions Anakin in here, but the big difference is that even though Anakin was the most powerful force user born, he still had flaws and weaknesses
"She's not gonna grow into a warrior through cunning and hard work and perseverance?" "No, sir. She's just the Chosen One." "And what message do you think that's gonna be sending to kids?" "That they should've been the Chosen One."
@@mrnobody6609 Afaik the CCP also didn't like it. Not only did Disney appropriate and distort a treasured Chinese legend, the fact that Mulan is now just born as the chosen one also breaks with the egalitarian idea that every person is born equally valuable, which is a central pillar of communist ideology. Superior hero bloodlines don't really sit well there. So yeah, they did piss off everyone.
It feels like a teenager overcompensating due to a lack of experience. It's just very rich grown adults who've discriminated for years now trying to make it seem like they totally never would do that.
Especially not women. As if it's more affirming to females to make a main female character magically flawless because she has a uterus. Nope, not demeaning to women at all.
I love how her long hair shows she’s a woman even though in Confucian China men and women had long hair. They did literally no research for this movie lol
@@sarasthoughts Yes, but my point was that you can't really say "in Confucian China" indicating a historical period. Confucianism is still influental in China. And was before the period this movie is placed. So you could say aswell that in "Confucian China" men have short hair (talking about today).
90's film: "Mom, can I be strong like Mulan?" "Yes, honey, if you work hard and use your head." 2020 film: "Mom, can I be strong like Mulan?" "Yes, honey, if you activate your superpowers and brute force your way through every problem... Oh, you don't have those? Then no."
Well, it's possible he may have been able to fake it for the first week or so. Remember Mulan's regiment got called into battle before they were finished training. Although, I can't imagine that Dad would have been able to even attempt the water bucket challenge up that mountain.
There have been a lot of mary sue characters lately. Why does hollywood think people want to see that? You could cut the film in the first 5 seconds and miss nothing. We get it. Shes good at everything.
"Why doesnt he just shoot her again?" "Because theres an emotional scene going on" what a silly question everybody knows bad guys will wait patiently for you to have an emotional scene even in a fight
90s Mulan: has character, establishes herself as a heroine by persevering and ensuring her father's safety and is able to accept herself for who she is while also improving herself. 2020 Mulan: got the chi. Yep chi.
Pretty much all the female characters of the 80s and perhaps early 90s weren't a load of bullshit, had kickass attitude, and were more real than anything on the screen in these super PC days.
@@Istromus these remakes are just unoriginal cash grabs that disney want to use to milk the popular animations. none of the live action remakes add much new stuff. but i wouldn't have a problem with them remaking animations like atlantis: the lost empire and treasure planet
Chrioni Sta Ana depends on the context that ‘original’ was used. In this case the ‘original’ refers to Disney’s first creation of the story. Their original adaptation as opposed to this live action one.
@@gsiya4023 She can't act to save her life, not since the early 2000s when she landed her early starring roles. She has roughly one expression in every TV show and movie she's done for 2 decades. I reckon she got the role through knowing important people. She's not very popular in China and she can't act. Makes no sense that Disney picked her. She's Chinese-American though. Maybe they wanted a Chinese-American lead because representation and all that stuff.
Christian Joseph Englert Actually as a Chinese I don’t think it’s a good movie. It’s also a totally different story from the original Chinese version Milan. On Chinese media, people hate this movie.
I read in an article that why they didn't want to add Mushu in the live action movie, it was becuase they were going for "realistic" approach. Yup very realistic to see a women turning into a bird.
I think I heard that Disney were told to remove Mushu because dragons are meant to be respected! To tell the true, this movie is enough disrespectfull against whole China!
@@movienaut Oh no, this is the best movie for the CCP. Instead of overcoming tradition and great odds with your smart, independent thinking and non-conformity, you should instead use your heaven sent superiority over the barbarians and mystical Chinese arts to crush your opposition.
Mulan has got to be my favorite Disney movie. Because it was heavily based on the original folk lore of Milan but also had its own creativity like adding Mushu and the Cricket, and giving all these characters pleasant personalities that made it more enjoyable to watch. Milan didn’t have powers, she wasn’t a Mary Sue. She was a normal girl who only wanted to help her father because if he had gone, he could be killed. And she knew she was going to be killed if she got caught yet she did it anyways which is what shows her incredible mindset. And as she grew as a character, so did the other characters. They all messed up, had a hard time with training, and struggled to get through with things but over time they ALL became physically strong, smarter, and better fit for the reason they were all there, to fight in a war. It wasn’t Milan holding up the whole team. And the love story was so subtle yet precious I adored it. It was a good movie that showed healthy feminism and girl power without just shoving it down your throat. And then they remade it and now the children of the future will likely only watch the remake because ooo magic.
@@user-insight Good, the name had been tarnished forever by this movie now, so just like kids making up PG swear words, we have to make up a new name for the original movie and the character and the original tale, because otherwise it'd be an insult
@Bernie's Mittens What you just described has nothing to do with feminism. A strong PERSON is someone who fights through setbacks and earns their victory. Its not "feminist storytelling" just because the protagonist is female. No part of the story is about fighting for gender equality and none of the movies were meant as a "feminist" stories. Mulan is a role model for her bravery, love and unselfishness, but she is not a feminist icon.
"We want her to be a strong woman in this one." "Sure, like in the original, through hard training, determination, effort and--" "No, no, we don't want her to *get* strong, we want her to *be* strong!" "Oh, like, right off the bat? No arc? Just like all the other strong women? Okay..."
Even in Hua Mulan where she WAS better than most of the other characters... It was because she trained her entire life under the tutelage of one of the greatest masters. Her reason for joining the army was as much to save her father, who would have been killed due to his asthma, as it was because she knew she was the best for the job. Also her falling inlove with the general was a like more sweet because she liked him because he was caring and compassionate (For example, he... as the general... Would fill in for guards who needed rest). . Suffice it to say I like Hua Mulan better than this movie.
@@Nionivek Hua Mulan (2009) was better because even though she was a better fighter than others, the film was about responsibility and the horrors of war, not proving oneself. Mulan still had flaws and tribulations to overcome. It's not strong women that are the problem, Disney just suck at writing.
@@flockinify I was saying that even though Hua Mulan was amazing, they went through lengths that made her a far better character than this movie's Mulan. There is a difference between a Mary Sue and a Paragon.
Don't you just love that everybody is a chosen one now? No one needs to practice to become good at something... Just like real life. Great message for kids.
It's because the true goal of mainstream pop "feminism" these days isn't to empower girls to rise up and be equal to men... it's to create an imaginary narrative where they're automatically stronger just by existing. And Disney sees dollar signs by cashing in on this trend, instead of leaning into what made their girl characters _already_ strong and empowering role models in the first place.
well they give kids trophies for participation, so I'm not surprised that they also want them to think they're some sort of superheroes without working for it
@@TF2Fan101 She is popular in China because she is really pretty, and she got a few ethereal fairy-like characters which doesn't require much of an emotional range.
Plot Holes, Fake-Feminism, Plot Holes, disregarding and insulting the source material intensely, and also Plot Holes?! And also Fake-Feminism??? Wow, i cant believe we have ANOTHER ONE of those. AGAIN!?!? Again another one?!
I'm surprised he didn't mention that that the place were some part gets filmed was used for the Chinese government to spy on and kill Muslims for organ harvesting
I watched it with 6 people in my living room, we were excited about it, not knowing how bad it was. When the credits rolled at the end, everyone sat there in silence and my friend went: "can we watch Mulan now?"
Well, Producer Guy would know. He's also the Chosen One. Like Neo, in the Matrix. He can't wear leather. But he'll be Co-President of the USA one day! So he knows all about that being chosen stuff.
@Brian Cairns Reclusive doesn't mean nobody knows you're a genius. In fact, in order to be a recluse, historically, you either have to be rich or so good at something that people will tolerate or even facilitate this type of behavior. Isaac Newton, for example, was a recluse everybody knew was a genius.
@@ChristianJayTheCTrain that's insane. Way more than a movie ticket. Even if it was $10 it's still not worth it since we are already paying for Disney plus. They should've just delayed it until theaters are open like everything else.
Mulan is one of my favourite Disney princesses, only because she achieved a place for herself with her hard work and intellect, she proved herself. You ruined it Disney OMG- Never got so many likes, thanks everyone.
@@axisboise "Hey guys we need an Asian princess for diversity points" "Well we don't have an Asian princess, but we have is Mulan, who is a beloved character in her own right without being a princess" "That's not good enough, let's just ignore the truth and pretend she's a princess" "Isn't that kind of dishonest and condescending?" "Yes but having a well-written character isn't the good representation people have been asking for" "It's....it's not?" "No, they don't want well-written characters, they just want toys that are identical except for their skin color and facial features. Trust me, Harvey Weinstein and I were talking about this last week." EDIT: It has now come to my attention that Princess Jasmine exists and (obviously) is Asian, so they did, in fact, have an Asian princess from a different culture. (Sorry Aladdin was never one of my favorites and I forgot about Jasmine)
@ram mulan is not a princess, and you got brainwashed by disney studio feminist department, this movie sets a really bad example!, 1, ignore the advice of your father, 2, ignore your culture and your place in society, 3 lie and be deciteful to everyone i mean, what is exactly the message this movie is sending?? that the difference between men and woman in china is so small, a chinese woman can pull her hair back, put some mud on her face and pass as a man??, really?? because that is the message this movie gave me!..
"Also the characters are going to make references to the original songs even though they don't actually fit into the conversations" "Why would we do that?" "Because references means nostalgia and you know what nostalgia means" "Oh nostalgia means money!" "That's right" "Wowwowwowwow wow"
“So were are we going to film this thing” “Oh I was thinking we could do it right next to a literal concentration camp were a genocide is occurring” “That might affect our brand image and Make us lose money” “Nah I am sure no one will notice”
@@marc0523 China has concentration camps which ethincally cleanse and torture Uygher Muslims. Women are raped, abused and forcefully sterilized(I don't know the proper word but basically make sure they can't reproduce). Men and women are used as force labour and such. all of it is said to be reducation centres which is all a facade. Hopefully this helped
"She's gonna go into training and meet some other soldiers" "and they're gonna have fun personalities like in the animation?" "No because that will be fun" "Right , my bad" I'm dead xD
The original is meant to be silly and fun. Thats not what this movie was aiming for. If you prefer the silly, fun version over the more serious action/adventure then stick to the original. Both offer something different.
@@jimduggan8962 ay ay , I went to watch the movie and overall it was great and probably the only way to really love the movie is if you don't expect it to really feel like or live up to the animated ay.
I watched it and overall ok as a standalone movie, but falls flat when compared to animation. Same with the characters; characters don't have as much depth as in the animation.
@@greedow Oh Mulan had personality you're just a dullard who couldn't see it. She was funny, wise caring, and also a badass. She was afraid of getting caught so limited the time she socialized with anyone. But you could still learn plenty about her from watching the movie. Again you're just a fool that thought Mulan was a different kind of story. Rather than a fantasy war film.
"Cuz if they don't live up to his expectations they get sent home" "So wouldn't have Mulan's Dad just gotten sent home?" "......... oh my God!" 🤣🤣🤣 ffr
tbh, that was a minor plot hole in the original animated movie. Mulan's dad would've been sent home because of his age, meaning Mulan shouldn't need to do a thing (and she could've gone home too when she was deemed "unsuited for war", but I guess her own honor is more important for her dad's and her own's safety) (realistically in ancient China, men don't get sent home just because they're not as tough since the army needs every man they could find...so Mulan has good reasons to save her father)
@Rafael Garcia Haven't seen or intend on paying to see it, but did neighbors and other townfolk make a deal about if someone didn't go they be dishonour and backs turned etc during the film. If not then the threat of dishonor is somewhat a empty threat within the film if it's not shown as having social consequences to those who fall under it.
@@jinhunterslay1638 no he wouldn't, he'd already served so he would have gone with General Lee rather than remaining at the training camp. Chi Fu clearly doesn't think his age excludes him.
The animated Mulan was great! It inspired me to get into sports when I was a tiny weird child! The new Mulan inspired me to stay indoors and not try, because I wasn’t born a super hero.
@@brendonhavener It's a reference to old Maybelline commercials from the late 90's/early 2000's. He used a hook and punchline that was a complete blast from the past, you wouldn't understand unless you were from that era lol
I was expecting a comment on Mulan's suddenly existing sister going like: "Oh she has a sister, huh? What's she like" "Well, she's afraid of spiders" "... That's it?" "That's it." "Huh."
@OmgLookAtTheYuckerMan Waaiong I scrolled and scrolled and could not find a single mention of BLM in the comments. There's is no reason to talk about BLM. Also super weird of you to imply that you're not against concentration camps.
Lol, the average theater kid has the aggresion of a slightly tepid glass of water. They are nice, but they couldn't hurt a fly if their life depended on it
The witch had more character development than Mulan. There. I said it. Stopped caring for the movie the moment 6 year old Mulan was freerunning on buildings, backflipping and used a freaking bamboo stick to stop her fall... All to chase a chicken. Rolled my eyes when AFTER her armor already saved her life, she decides to strip it all off before running back into battle because woo women power. And not, y'know... Just taken her helmet off and let her hair down. Last I checked, women don't gain skin made of steel when they believe they're being "true."
Apparently, the old Mulan growing from a normal girl into a capable fighter through nothing but dedication, courage, and wit just isn’t “girl power” enough for modern Disney. Now she’s just ancient Chinese Rey.
@@Wisegirl6521 Horrible stereotype, tbh. I'm a woman that plays a lot of games. Not too many online games, I'll admit, but I've seen enough. Games like FFXIV and I think AdventureQuest is VERY adamant on gender equality for their armor. And by that I don't mean they avoid sexy outfits. You have your normal-looking outfits and armors, sure, but when the girls are given bunny suits SO ARE THE MEN. This, my fellow weebs, IS TRUE GENDER EQUALITY. I played WOW for some time too, but only a demo and didn't really make note of the outfits. Not that I even particularly care, mind you - hell, when I can play a woman, I want that eyecandy to be a sexy badass too that I can simultaneously insert myself into and drool over (in case you haven't notice, I have a bit of gay~). BUT I honestly think people think bikini-armor is more of a thing than it actually is.
People back then are afraid of black magic and so magic tricks was used to win war and battle. But then for some people to realize such logic is too much critical thinking for them. Back to simpleton village.
But of course! Little known fact, General Patton was a necromancer. You don't hear that a lot in the documentaries but he totally raised the dead during the Battle of the Bulge.
I really loved this episode, I'm instantly hooked! By the way... Dishonor on you Disney! Dishonor on your cash cows! Dishonor on all of the critics that actually liked this crap! And Dishonor on all of those Disney remakes! May every dishonor push them deeper into a grave of no return! If there is anything good that came from this, it's how I discovered Screen Rant's Pitch Meetings.
Considering it cost 200 million, had reshoots to make it China Appropriate, and then got banned in China anyway, my chi is telling me even Money, is avoiding this trash heap!
Plot Holes, Fake-Feminism, Plot Holes, disregarding and insulting the source material intensely, and also Plot Holes?! And also Fake-Feminism??? Wow, i cant believe we have ANOTHER ONE of those. AGAIN!?!? Again another one?!
People love animated Mulan because she started from an ordinary woman and do her best to prove herself that she's a worthy warrior just like any other, not someone with special power, not only she represent strong woman, but people can relate to her. Nowadays people think a way to make a woman strong is by making that women gloating over her womanhood in a way.
This was the goofiest movie I've seen in a long time. You nailed it. When she teleports behind enemy lines I was like "Wtf?". How she literally goes from being banished to "you're our leader now" in a matter of 5 seconds. What the hell is Disney thinking?
@@sgtkort97 Who? I'm asking because I want to see if it was because of legit reasons or if they were brought on due their skin color or some other blue checkmark and lacked the skills for the job.
And they actually thank the people running the camp in the credits... So I guess Disney is openly supporting genocide, slave labor, forced sterilization involuntary organ harvesting and the rape of the prisoners wives now. Great positions for them to defend.
But really though, what's the context there? What is the witch motivation? Anyone who has seen the movie can explain it? Or is really that sudden develoment?
@@blushingralseiuwu2222 What they were going for was the Witch was always rejected and see's helping the bad guys as a chance to take her place. When she see's Mulan going through the same she empathizes with her and asks her to join her. Then when Mulan gets accepted by the army she feels there is a place for her among the Kingdom and decides to help Mulan save it and because she empathized with Mulan decides to sacrifice herself to save her. That's what they were going for but it was executed very poorly. The bad guys treat the Witch like crap even though she's basically fighting a one woman war for most of it, it really makes you wonder why she needs the bad guys help at all, it seems like she could just fly into the palace and kill the Emperor then take the throne for herself. It also makes no sense why she tells Mulan the plan, she was trying to get her to join her but there's no reason for her to expose the plan. Showing her the way and the sacrifice make sense but the exposing the plan does not.
By turning Mulan into Ray they completely destroyed how dramatic her decision to replace her father was. In the original it was a sacrifice of a simple girl as it was likely for her to die in very first battle.
At least Rey had a personality and was beaten by Kylo Ren when they first met, and even after Kylo was almost mortally wounded, he almost beat her. Mulan 2020 didn't succeed all the time only because she didn't want to look special.
Its like whoever did this remake just did not understand or even maybe watch the original and does not know real human emotions very well at all. AI would do a better job than this Fubared version.
Nope. Worse than Rey. By a lot. Rey was a character with personality and flaws. She was hot headed, reckless, and didn't seem to care much about the cause she found herself fighting for until it started killing off all of her father figures, just to name a few. Mulan's just like "Hey, I'm a badass, and that's really it. Don't question it or I'll kick you in the head with my obvious CGI and cheesy 80s action movie wirefighting-I mean, my magic chi powers."
@@NickTheGreatAndPowerful Rey also formed a quick relationship with BB-8 because they were both lonely souls who were separated from the people they were closest to. That's a great way to show personality.
“But if they don’t live up to his expectations they get sent home” “So wouldn’t have Mulans father just would’ve got sent home if he had gone?” ... “Oh my god..”
What's funny is that in the original version, Mulan's father was hinted to be a renowed soldier in his prime, so even if he failed Shang's physical tests he would have been kept around as either a tactician or an assistant training officer so him going would get him killed by the Huns regardless of his physical condition, as there was no way he'd be turned away. Remember how surprised Shang and the advisor were at the news that "THE Hua Zou" had a son? In this version though...yeah, wait, why bother taking his place at all when he has no proud legacy to either uphold or use for non-combat military positions? It's astounding how one dialogue exchange that only lasts a few seconds gives all the context needed for why Mulan's father's weak physical condition wouldn't have spared him from military service, yet something that easy couldn't be assed to be given in the 2020 version.
I heard somewhere also that, by having the "normal" sister just continue to serve her common duty, this also shows young girls that if they aren't especially gifted, they're less important. I agree with that. The sister probably shouldn't have been made...much like this movie in general
But at least Rey and Neo didn’t manifest any special powers until they were adults. And Anakin was already too old and nowhere near being acknowledged as the best Jedi. Mulan seems to know about her powers her whole life and no one else seems to have these powers. Hmmmm... who will win: the super powered woman being helped by the magic witch or an ordinary bad guy with an army?
term02 that’s unfortunate. Mulan was probably one of the only Disney movies that actually merited a live action serious remake. Weak that they went the Mary Sue route and didn’t do any real character development. Could have been a great female hero
When the one dude literally said "tranquill as a forest, but on fire within" I felt mocked because it was like they were throwing the lack of songs in my face
“She should wear armor.”
She’s already wearing the plot armor.
that is...the best armor there is.
All kindzzz
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🙆♂️💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
LMAO
Watch 2009 film.
90s Mulan: untrained, but determined to show her worth.
2020 Mulan: The one.
Its like rocky but instead of training montage, he just go around one puching everyone
Even Neo worked for his superpowers.
@@fidget0227 and he mentions Anakin in here, but the big difference is that even though Anakin was the most powerful force user born, he still had flaws and weaknesses
I can hardly stand to watch a movie or series these days. What happened to good writing?😥
she killed off all the other Mulans to absorb all their power, she has truly become the one XD
"Contains Spoilers"
Me: Yeah, don't care. Shred it, Ryan.
Yeah, I feel like I've seen enough, and he saved me $7/month plus $30 to _lease_ a Disney movie that was released in 1998. Great pitch!
Exactly!!
Neither do I.
my thoughts exactly.
i don’t like this movie
"She's not gonna grow into a warrior through cunning and hard work and perseverance?"
"No, sir. She's just the Chosen One."
"And what message do you think that's gonna be sending to kids?"
"That they should've been the Chosen One."
Wow wow wow wow....wow.
"Fair enough"
I guess this is a superhero movie now
Shes going to kill the kids because shes the chosen one
@@lucascorazza2252 Oh sh-!
He watched it so we didn't have to. He's the hero we need.
.. But don't deserve.
@@berengustav7714 ... and he'll keep watching them, because he can take it.
@@marcor.cacereslopez3050 Because he's not our hero. He's a silent reviewer. A watchful satirist...
@@salerac6496 What makes him a hero.
Yeah I don’t know The Dark Knight’s script word for word so I can’t play along. Sorry 😐
Her character arc wasn't an arc. It wasn't even a straight line. It was just a dot. She stayed exactly the same from start to finish.
David Graves I agree for the bad ones. But most of the well made ones have great character development and storylines (:
Francine Siew Fearless by Jet Li first comes to mind! Next level character development
@@DavidGravesExists filmed in china and made by americans*
She's just the freaking Chose One.
She could literally never ever lose.
Wow.
I've seen Manga that were way better than this character arc...
“They’re basically violent theater students.”
*I felt that...*
Zerda Quil Same😅
Is that why the makers of this movie ignored human atrocities and thanked those committing said atrocities?
@@jellyfishi_ Yeah. Real world stuff.
Is there any other kind of theatre kid?
@@westreaper9681 no there is not. We are violent all the time. Depends on the situation the level of violence
It's weirdly impressive how this movie managed to anger EVERY side of the culture war at once.
When you pander to everyone you end up pleasing nobody.....such a paradigm altering idea I know.
China liked it.
And you'd think they'd know after The Last Jedi
@@mrnobody6609 Afaik the CCP also didn't like it. Not only did Disney appropriate and distort a treasured Chinese legend, the fact that Mulan is now just born as the chosen one also breaks with the egalitarian idea that every person is born equally valuable, which is a central pillar of communist ideology. Superior hero bloodlines don't really sit well there.
So yeah, they did piss off everyone.
@@danielschroedinger2090 but if u know Mulan in the true legend is actually a good warrior since childhood
She still had to learn tho
"Spoilers Ahead"
Me: Yeah, I dont plan on watching the movie. Spoil away.
We’ve seen all the good bits anyway!
“Spoil away”
Two words I never thought I would ever say about a movie. But I am saying them now
Same same
As people have said: "I wouldn't even waste the data on pirating it."
@@papertroll1876 there are good bits??
I feel that there is a misconception among movie makers lately, where strong compelling characters can't have flaws or fail at anything.
Whamen are ALWAYS STRONG and INDEPENDENT and they don’t fall in love with their captains🤣
only a handshake as "equals"🤣🤣🤣
Just Disney films maybe.
It feels like a teenager overcompensating due to a lack of experience. It's just very rich grown adults who've discriminated for years now trying to make it seem like they totally never would do that.
Especially not women. As if it's more affirming to females to make a main female character magically flawless because she has a uterus. Nope, not demeaning to women at all.
@@Canadish More like people who got rich by preaching a "message", so they have no idea they're contradicting it by their actions.
I can hear Mushu ranting on this movie.
“Dishonor on you! Dishonor on your cow.”
Don’t you mean cash cow.
I’m taking notes on this!
"Dishonor on you. Dishonor on your cash cow. Dishonor on your whole franchise!"
Although I haven't watched this movie, but I somehow get the feeling that this one joke brings people more fun than the entire movie does...
Dishonor on superheroes! Dishonor on Jedi! Dishonor on TRON Ascendency!
I love how her long hair shows she’s a woman even though in Confucian China men and women had long hair. They did literally no research for this movie lol
For real
Dude you might want to do some reasearch yourself, "Confucian China" is not a historic period...
@@konsta9600 it's a cultural tradition in which men had long hair. your point?
@@sarasthoughts Yes, but my point was that you can't really say "in Confucian China" indicating a historical period. Confucianism is still influental in China. And was before the period this movie is placed.
So you could say aswell that in "Confucian China" men have short hair (talking about today).
@@konsta9600 With the context given I'd say it makes sense
Fair to assume they're talking of a practice in the time period of the movie.
I hope they're gonna call this Disney era "the creatively bankrupt age".
Considering both the fact that we came off of (and use as a crutch) the golden era, and your actual name, I feel the Tarnished Age is more apt-
How about the tainted age since all of those Disney sequels were a thing.
Creativity is the only area they're bankrupt in so I don't think they'll even care at this point
I would call it that.
An amazing number of creative plays on words in this comment subsection...
Chinese guy with abacus: "Her midichlorian count is off the charts!"
Over 9000!!!!!
Omg i'm wheezing🤣
Bad guy appears..."Hello there!"
She is the chosen one!!!
Apprentice: I told you master, we needed bigger paper for the charts.
90's film: "Mom, can I be strong like Mulan?" "Yes, honey, if you work hard and use your head."
2020 film: "Mom, can I be strong like Mulan?" "Yes, honey, if you activate your superpowers and brute force your way through every problem... Oh, you don't have those? Then no."
Kinda reflects the changes in our system of governance
@@vincenturquhart1370 nah
@@MountainTomb yeah
MOM: is your name Maybelline?
No...
Then no.
@Former Auror It’s less ridiculous then having magic powers.
This pitch meeting actually made the movie sound better than it really is.
Yeah WAY better than it actually is. I think if it was original it would have been good
At this point, i think that Disney is making these trash movies just so The Pitch Meetings can be even better.
The live-action remakes are the best thing to ever happen to Screenrant.
@@MegamanXfan21xx True.
Cultural demoralization.
We're not not ready for that conversation yet.
Lmao
It seems more like to keep their creative licenses on the characters but maybe they got some shares in Screen Rant, who knows.
“So wouldn’t Mulans father just been sent home if he had gone?”
🤯🤯🤯🤯
you know its bad when Writer-Ryan doesnt say Woopsie just utter shock... ahaha
Well, it's possible he may have been able to fake it for the first week or so. Remember Mulan's regiment got called into battle before they were finished training. Although, I can't imagine that Dad would have been able to even attempt the water bucket challenge up that mountain.
Concepcion30 a crippled old veteran wouldnt even be able to go halfway up the mountain even without the water buckets
to be fair that was also an issue with the original movie.
Solus except in the original he wouldn’t have been sent back and most likely wouldve been sent to the frontline as cannon fodder
I can't believe they turned the most character-driven Disney Princess into a Mary Sue
nobody is even commenting this comment since there's nothing to be add. You're right, we're done, Disney is done. still making a lot of money though.
The dark side is a path to many abilities...
The new Star Wars trilogy made lots of money and Rey was a Mary Sue, so why shouldn't Mulan?
@@jamesbalch1325 because the new mulan did'nt...
There have been a lot of mary sue characters lately. Why does hollywood think people want to see that? You could cut the film in the first 5 seconds and miss nothing. We get it. Shes good at everything.
“Compares her to a dog”
Fun fact: dogs actually hold sacred meaning to Mongolians
I extremely doubt the ‘researchers’ at Disney knew that, or would have cared even if they you told them
I kinda love how through the whole movie the actress has so many expressions from just normal to bored up to normally bored.
Lol she's look almost thesame throughout the movie. No emotions whatsoever
@@midnighttsukky3459 That's the main screenwriting concept: tell, not show. I'm pretty sure I remember it correctly.
@@midnighttsukky3459 I've heard it's because the actress really doesn't want to look silly in any way.
Wasn't there a conversation in the movie where she said that she didn't have any expressions 🤣
Mando from The Mandalorian emotes better than she does, and he wears a helmet for 99% of the show!
" emotional moment with the witch dying "
// Shows mulan's blank face // nice
Sadly, she showed more emotion in that scene than in the rest of the movie.
Mulan no curr
So true lol this actress can’t act with emotions.. her fighting scenes were good though.
Yeah, asian faces do be like that xD
😂😂
"Why doesnt he just shoot her again?"
"Because theres an emotional scene going on"
what a silly question everybody knows bad guys will wait patiently for you to have an emotional scene even in a fight
Not Voldemort 😅
@@latetootheparty No but he did care enough about Harry's education to wait until the end of the school year to try and kill him.
Bad guys usually are very polite
@@NoPowerintheVerse actually 7 years
@@thedreamscripter4002 not really
90s Mulan: has character, establishes herself as a heroine by persevering and ensuring her father's safety and is able to accept herself for who she is while also improving herself.
2020 Mulan: got the chi. Yep chi.
Exactly. Plus she has Ultra Instinct.
she dont need no armour too
Pretty much all the female characters of the 80s and perhaps early 90s weren't a load of bullshit, had kickass attitude, and were more real than anything on the screen in these super PC days.
Very Progressive 😑
She's a newtype!
"She learned the art of the dramatic entrance."
Underrated statement.
Underrated comment.
@@ViniagretteCannibal underrated reply to a reply.
By Megamind's logic, that makes her the super villain.
@@ViniagretteCannibal Underrated reply to a reply to a reply to a reply.
@@aouadkingdom4807 underrated reply to a reply to a reply to a reply to a reply.
"She's Maybelline."
"Being born with it is tight."
That was subtle, but genius.
Maybelline... sounds like "make-belief".
It's really not that subtle.
Oooooh myyyyy goooooooosh!!!
I don’t get the joke, maybe because I’m French ?
Yes using a giant coorporation's main slogan that everyone knows in the exact form it exists is the definition of subtle. I checked the dictionary.
"she's Anakin, she's Rey, she's Neo, she's Maybelline"
"Oh, being born with it is TIGHT"
😆 One of the best setups to a "(blank) is tight" moment ever
When the pitch meeting is better than the actual movie.
That’s just bad movies in general.
*real pitch meeting
Let's be honest, that's the case with at least half of these pitch meetings. Probably more.
SithCats Honestly, live action Aladdin was really good imo. As long as they don’t mess up Tangled, I’m fine with these remakes.
@@Istromus these remakes are just unoriginal cash grabs that disney want to use to milk the popular animations. none of the live action remakes add much new stuff. but i wouldn't have a problem with them remaking animations like atlantis: the lost empire and treasure planet
I’ll stick with the original animated one, it’s more realistic.
That is the most underrated comment I not even talking bout in this video, just in general about this movie as a whole
Yeah, animated movie has really dragon and still felt more grounded, that is really saying something.
Why stick with it? The animated movie isn't original in itself.
Chrioni Sta Ana depends on the context that ‘original’ was used. In this case the ‘original’ refers to Disney’s first creation of the story. Their original adaptation as opposed to this live action one.
The 2009 film is more realistic. A talking dragon is realistic? Lol. You Disney fanboys are really butthurt over this?
This actually kinda makes me want to watch Mulan, the animated movie.
Always a good time to do it.
Oh, remakes that make you want to watch the original are TIGHT!
When I finished watching the live, I just straight up went to the animated
x2
@@tmartin95 TIGHT!
Mulan's expressions:
Happy 😐
Sad 😐
Angry 😐
Concerned 😐
Scared 😐
Just like Ray and Captain Marvel.
Damn, she really is Anakin, huh. On the plus side, there's no sand.
The actress that played Mulan should have just worked on las vegas, she probably is really good at poker.
The actress that played her tho is good at no expressions
I saw her in a drama
Disney cherrypicks everytime and I'm pretty sure they wanted that
@@gsiya4023 She can't act to save her life, not since the early 2000s when she landed her early starring roles. She has roughly one expression in every TV show and movie she's done for 2 decades. I reckon she got the role through knowing important people. She's not very popular in China and she can't act. Makes no sense that Disney picked her. She's Chinese-American though. Maybe they wanted a Chinese-American lead because representation and all that stuff.
It’d be more jarring if Disney actually got something right at this point.
I foolishly had high hopes. Watched it last night. It was boring. The cinematography was pathetic.
Well there's the mcu and Pixar... That's it
@@CJEnglert yuck
I would say the MCU but that is Kevin Feige and the studios, not Disney
Christian Joseph Englert Actually as a Chinese I don’t think it’s a good movie. It’s also a totally different story from the original Chinese version Milan. On Chinese media, people hate this movie.
I read in an article that why they didn't want to add Mushu in the live action movie, it was becuase they were going for "realistic" approach. Yup very realistic to see a women turning into a bird.
And because dragons are respectful figures in China.
So yeah, because China brings Disney tons of money.
I think I heard that Disney were told to remove Mushu because dragons are meant to be respected!
To tell the true, this movie is enough disrespectfull against whole China!
and born w/ jedi power. At least in the animation, Mulan was just a regular girl.
@@movienaut Oh no, this is the best movie for the CCP. Instead of overcoming tradition and great odds with your smart, independent thinking and non-conformity, you should instead use your heaven sent superiority over the barbarians and mystical Chinese arts to crush your opposition.
@@Moonhermit- manifest destiny, all is rightfully the middle kingdoms
“Are the soldiers going to have fun personalities......No because that would be fun” 😂🤣😂
Mulan has got to be my favorite Disney movie. Because it was heavily based on the original folk lore of Milan but also had its own creativity like adding Mushu and the Cricket, and giving all these characters pleasant personalities that made it more enjoyable to watch. Milan didn’t have powers, she wasn’t a Mary Sue. She was a normal girl who only wanted to help her father because if he had gone, he could be killed. And she knew she was going to be killed if she got caught yet she did it anyways which is what shows her incredible mindset. And as she grew as a character, so did the other characters. They all messed up, had a hard time with training, and struggled to get through with things but over time they ALL became physically strong, smarter, and better fit for the reason they were all there, to fight in a war. It wasn’t Milan holding up the whole team. And the love story was so subtle yet precious I adored it. It was a good movie that showed healthy feminism and girl power without just shoving it down your throat.
And then they remade it and now the children of the future will likely only watch the remake because ooo magic.
you wrote her name as "milan" a couple of times after getting it right the first time
@@user-insight well the u is right next to the i
@@user-insight Good, the name had been tarnished forever by this movie now, so just like kids making up PG swear words, we have to make up a new name for the original movie and the character and the original tale, because otherwise it'd be an insult
The animated movie is no more "heavily based" on the original folklore than the live-action.
@Bernie's Mittens What you just described has nothing to do with feminism. A strong PERSON is someone who fights through setbacks and earns their victory. Its not "feminist storytelling" just because the protagonist is female. No part of the story is about fighting for gender equality and none of the movies were meant as a "feminist" stories. Mulan is a role model for her bravery, love and unselfishness, but she is not a feminist icon.
This is a dishonor to all of our cows.
Omg the mushu statment dishonor to your cows 😂
Amen. 😥
(🤣😂🤣)
DISHONOR ON YOU, DISHONOR ON YOUR COW, DIS-
especially for removing Mushu
Lol I saw this same comment in another page by someone else!!
"We want her to be a strong woman in this one."
"Sure, like in the original, through hard training, determination, effort and--"
"No, no, we don't want her to *get* strong, we want her to *be* strong!"
"Oh, like, right off the bat? No arc? Just like all the other strong women? Okay..."
Sad how much Hollywood likes this Mary Sue trope.
Even in Hua Mulan where she WAS better than most of the other characters... It was because she trained her entire life under the tutelage of one of the greatest masters. Her reason for joining the army was as much to save her father, who would have been killed due to his asthma, as it was because she knew she was the best for the job. Also her falling inlove with the general was a like more sweet because she liked him because he was caring and compassionate (For example, he... as the general... Would fill in for guards who needed rest).
.
Suffice it to say I like Hua Mulan better than this movie.
@@Nionivek Hua Mulan (2009) was better because even though she was a better fighter than others, the film was about responsibility and the horrors of war, not proving oneself. Mulan still had flaws and tribulations to overcome. It's not strong women that are the problem, Disney just suck at writing.
@@flockinify I was saying that even though Hua Mulan was amazing, they went through lengths that made her a far better character than this movie's Mulan. There is a difference between a Mary Sue and a Paragon.
Oh hey, sounds like Rey! Thanks for ruining things Disney.
Don't you just love that everybody is a chosen one now? No one needs to practice to become good at something... Just like real life. Great message for kids.
Thats sadly so many kids and teens are devolving into spoiled brats :(
It's because the true goal of mainstream pop "feminism" these days isn't to empower girls to rise up and be equal to men... it's to create an imaginary narrative where they're automatically stronger just by existing. And Disney sees dollar signs by cashing in on this trend, instead of leaning into what made their girl characters _already_ strong and empowering role models in the first place.
Mulan Su
Daniel Morris Exactly!
well they give kids trophies for participation, so I'm not surprised that they also want them to think they're some sort of superheroes without working for it
"Are they gonna have fun personalities like in the animation?"
"No because that would be fun!"
"My bad."
"Then Mulan has an emotional moment with the witch as she's dying...."
Mulan: stares a completely blank emotionless stare into her dying eyes
this is so funny because the actress's most famous character from a franchise is literally called “Emotionless”
Honestly, I wonder if she was being directed to give that performance, because I’ve heard she’s a pretty big star over in China.
Her acting range was pretty similar to all the animals from the Lion King 2019.
@@TF2Fan101 I think you answered your own question.
@@TF2Fan101 She is popular in China because she is really pretty, and she got a few ethereal fairy-like characters which doesn't require much of an emotional range.
“are they gonna have fun personalities like in the animation?”
“no cause that would be fun.”
“right, my bad” 😭😭😭😭
How is there 1.4k likes on this and no comments yet?
"Will they at least have personalities?"
"No"
@@joebomb1019 There's three now...
@@arcrisgonzaga7324 Well at the time there was 0 lol
@@joebomb1019 "because"
"So wouldn't Mulan's father have just been sent home if he had gone?"
"...........oh my god..."
LMAO
Same with the original too.
THIS! LOLOL
I died at this realization 😳😳😳
@@John_the_Paul No, cripples are sent to the vanguard. Aristocrats need a lot of meat shields.
I love how no one knew how to act in that movie, yet Disney decided to charge $30 to watch it on the streaming service everyone was already paying for
i wonder how many people actually pay for it. Imagine being head of disney and watch this happening
Donnie Yen carried this movie really, the only character I liked, although Bori Khan's actor was pretty good too
2000: "I can't wait to see the live-action adaptation"
2020:
"I can't wait to see the pitch-meeting adaptation"
It will stream like all other movies on Disney+ on Dec 4th 2020... you just have to pay extra between Sep and Dec if you want to see it earlier.
Wrong. Nobody was ever excited for the live-action adaptations
@@noodlesmaster69420 I was. At first :'(
“They’re basically violent theatre students.”
“Wowowowowowowow.”
I’m surprised he didn’t mention that Shang had been screwed too
You mean he was Shang - Hai-ed?
@@josiahwhitworth6153 hahahaha very clever xD
Plot Holes, Fake-Feminism, Plot Holes, disregarding and insulting the source material intensely, and also Plot Holes?!
And also Fake-Feminism???
Wow, i cant believe we have ANOTHER ONE of those.
AGAIN!?!?
Again another one?!
there is no shang-li in ba sing se
I'm surprised he didn't mention that that the place were some part gets filmed was used for the Chinese government to spy on and kill Muslims for organ harvesting
I watched it with 6 people in my living room, we were excited about it, not knowing how bad it was. When the credits rolled at the end, everyone sat there in silence and my friend went: "can we watch Mulan now?"
"She's Anakin, she's Rey, she's Neo - she's frickin' MAYBELLINE!!" Oh my god, genius! 🤣
_"Oh, being born with it is _*_TIGHT."_*
That's what Maybelline is for? O_O
Came down here for this.... Not dissapointed at all~
someone explain the maybelline reference please? :'(
@@jamiep679
The Maybelline slogan is "Maybe she's born with it."
Mulan is now "Born with it", because she's the chosen one.
Message of the movie: "If you are the chosen one, act Like the chosen one."
Isn't that inspiring to all the little chosen ones?
I always say “if you’re not the chosen one then make yourself the chosen one.”
@Brian Cairns Oh yeah, because people who are genius tend to be very low-key about it...
Well, Producer Guy would know. He's also the Chosen One. Like Neo, in the Matrix. He can't wear leather. But he'll be Co-President of the USA one day!
So he knows all about that being chosen stuff.
@Brian Cairns Reclusive doesn't mean nobody knows you're a genius. In fact, in order to be a recluse, historically, you either have to be rich or so good at something that people will tolerate or even facilitate this type of behavior. Isaac Newton, for example, was a recluse everybody knew was a genius.
@Brian Cairns "all" is pretty strong word. I'm pretty sure there were a bunch of "great thinkers" that were extraverted and/or a show off
"Be yourself! Don't hide who you are!"
"Even if I'm a religious minority?"
"No."
Oh, references to ongoing genocides are TIGHT!
@@stabbymcstabberson5814 Looks like china disowned us!
Whoopsie!
"Whoopsie!"
tolerance (made in china addition)
Underrated comment
@@stabbymcstabberson5814 Yeah wow USA killed more muslisms than China
Ryan missed the part where instead of china bowing to her, she becomes the emperor's bodyguard...
Did that actually happen?
Straight to Disney plus seems about right!
Not for an additional $30 though 🙄
@@ChristianJayTheCTrain that's insane. Way more than a movie ticket. Even if it was $10 it's still not worth it since we are already paying for Disney plus. They should've just delayed it until theaters are open like everything else.
@@jhandle900 I was gonna say that maybe it comes from splitting the profit with the streaming platform then I realized they own the platform. . .
TheRamirezGuys yep lol but I would have payed 50 lol I loved this movie
@@ChristianJayTheCTrain Yes exactly for extra 30, so nobody watches it.
Mulan is one of my favourite Disney princesses, only because she achieved a place for herself with her hard work and intellect, she proved herself.
You ruined it Disney
OMG- Never got so many likes, thanks everyone.
I can't help but think why Mulan is included in the Disney Princess roster when she's not legitimately a princess
@@axisboise "Hey guys we need an Asian princess for diversity points"
"Well we don't have an Asian princess, but we have is Mulan, who is a beloved character in her own right without being a princess"
"That's not good enough, let's just ignore the truth and pretend she's a princess"
"Isn't that kind of dishonest and condescending?"
"Yes but having a well-written character isn't the good representation people have been asking for"
"It's....it's not?"
"No, they don't want well-written characters, they just want toys that are identical except for their skin color and facial features. Trust me, Harvey Weinstein and I were talking about this last week."
EDIT: It has now come to my attention that Princess Jasmine exists and (obviously) is Asian, so they did, in fact, have an Asian princess from a different culture. (Sorry Aladdin was never one of my favorites and I forgot about Jasmine)
@ram mulan is not a princess, and you got brainwashed by disney studio feminist department, this movie sets a really bad example!,
1, ignore the advice of your father,
2, ignore your culture and your place in society,
3 lie and be deciteful to everyone
i mean, what is exactly the message this movie is sending??
that the difference between men and woman in china is so small, a chinese woman can pull her hair back, put some mud on her face and pass as a man??, really?? because that is the message this movie gave me!..
一个美国人拍的一个美国烂片而已，这电影在中国评分也很低，你们继续骂就行
@@axisboise I think they basically just call any female lead a princess. They probably don't know what princess means.
"She's straight up Maybelline."
"Being born with it is tight."
😂😂😂
Best part
Right there I paused the video, hit the like button, and resumed watching
A very guide-y witch 🤣🤣
My favorite joke in this one lol genius!!
Good writing
"Sounds like maybe she should have turned into a thousand bats on that one."
Lmao
"Also the characters are going to make references to the original songs even though they don't actually fit into the conversations"
"Why would we do that?"
"Because references means nostalgia and you know what nostalgia means"
"Oh nostalgia means money!"
"That's right"
"Wowwowwowwow wow"
Yeah yeah yeah
He did the finger thing! The finger thing means the money
Money is tight!
@@iau are you having financial troubles?
Oh, I member!
“Idk sir, but what I know is that this is a super hero movie now”
“Oh, those make us money so please continue”
I loved those lines
4:47 "...then Mulan has a pretty emotional moment with the witch as she's dying."
*actress is absolutely stone-faced*
Pure GOLD.
The Mulan actress and Bri Larson, who can play the better tree?
Michael Gonzalez
Tree? I thought they were playing trash cans...
Saw more emotion on Drago's face when he watches Apollo die.
Only one poker face from beginning to end
“So were are we going to film this thing”
“Oh I was thinking we could do it right next to a literal concentration camp were a genocide is occurring”
“That might affect our brand image and Make us lose money”
“Nah I am sure no one will notice”
And actually nobody cares. Did they go bankrupt? No. Im sure they lost a few million because of boycotts, but they have billions.
people were outraged for like...1 week and then it disapeared.
@@dakat5131 I didn't watch it because of this.
And going on its box office results, others might have done the same.
I'm sorry - what concentration camp are we talking about?
@@marc0523 China has concentration camps which ethincally cleanse and torture Uygher Muslims. Women are raped, abused and forcefully sterilized(I don't know the proper word but basically make sure they can't reproduce). Men and women are used as force labour and such. all of it is said to be reducation centres which is all a facade. Hopefully this helped
"Shes Maybellyne"
"Being Born with it is Tight"
LMAO
Let's get down to business! To defeat! My respect for Disney!
*disheartened scream*
Oooh that's long gone!!
@@ribhavgupta6148 yeah bout to say i lost that like a decade ago or more.
@@Dan8975 I lost it when star wars died
But I don't think I'm ready
"She's gonna go into training and meet some other soldiers"
"and they're gonna have fun personalities like in the animation?"
"No because that will be fun"
"Right , my bad"
I'm dead xD
The original is meant to be silly and fun. Thats not what this movie was aiming for. If you prefer the silly, fun version over the more serious action/adventure then stick to the original. Both offer something different.
@@jimduggan8962 ay ay , I went to watch the movie and overall it was great and probably the only way to really love the movie is if you don't expect it to really feel like or live up to the animated ay.
I watched it and overall ok as a standalone movie, but falls flat when compared to animation. Same with the characters; characters don't have as much depth as in the animation.
@@jimduggan8962 I prefer when the characters have personallities. So I would like to pass on the nothing characters that we got in this movie
@@greedow Oh Mulan had personality you're just a dullard who couldn't see it. She was funny, wise caring, and also a badass. She was afraid of getting caught so limited the time she socialized with anyone. But you could still learn plenty about her from watching the movie. Again you're just a fool that thought Mulan was a different kind of story. Rather than a fantasy war film.
"and she's gonna have an emotional moment with the witch."
*Shows Mulan having the same expression I have when I'm daydreaming in class.*
"Cuz if they don't live up to his expectations they get sent home"
"So wouldn't have Mulan's Dad just gotten sent home?"
"......... oh my God!"
🤣🤣🤣 ffr
@Rafael Garcia Instead his daughter fought in his place, dishonoring the family forever.
tbh, that was a minor plot hole in the original animated movie. Mulan's dad would've been sent home because of his age, meaning Mulan shouldn't need to do a thing (and she could've gone home too when she was deemed "unsuited for war", but I guess her own honor is more important for her dad's and her own's safety)
(realistically in ancient China, men don't get sent home just because they're not as tough since the army needs every man they could find...so Mulan has good reasons to save her father)
@@analyticalalchemist3298 got em
@Rafael Garcia Haven't seen or intend on paying to see it, but did neighbors and other townfolk make a deal about if someone didn't go they be dishonour and backs turned etc during the film. If not then the threat of dishonor is somewhat a empty threat within the film if it's not shown as having social consequences to those who fall under it.
@@jinhunterslay1638 no he wouldn't, he'd already served so he would have gone with General Lee rather than remaining at the training camp. Chi Fu clearly doesn't think his age excludes him.
"So wouldn't Mulan's father just have been sent home if he had gone?"
"OMG!"
The animated Mulan was great! It inspired me to get into sports when I was a tiny weird child!
The new Mulan inspired me to stay indoors and not try, because I wasn’t born a super hero.
"She's frickin' Maybelline." "Oh, being born with it is tight." This is everything.
It had me on the floor in TEARS.
Forget using the Mary Sue description, I'm just going to call such characters Maybelline characters now!
There is NOT enough appreciation for that joke
I... I don’t get it, would someone mind letting me in on the joke?
@@brendonhavener It's a reference to old Maybelline commercials from the late 90's/early 2000's. He used a hook and punchline that was a complete blast from the past, you wouldn't understand unless you were from that era lol
I was expecting a comment on Mulan's suddenly existing sister going like:
"Oh she has a sister, huh? What's she like"
"Well, she's afraid of spiders"
"... That's it?"
"That's it."
"Huh."
Reading this in Ryan's voice is super easy, barely an inconvenience
You are forgetting! she gets matched to a guy who isn't afraid of spiders! she gets an arch!
Zaga Studios I couldn’t understand that part because the mom immediately cuts her off
@@OReily08080 🤣 so memorable...
"she's afraid of spiders?"
"She's afraid of spiders"
"THAT IS TIGHT."
"They're basically just violent theatre students" LMFAO
"She's freakin' Maybelline!"
"Oh, being born with it is tight!"
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ryan with the galaxy brain jokes!
Hey! I actually recognize your picture/name from tumblr
"Are they gonna have fun personalities like in the animated one"
"Nope cause that would be fun"
"Right my bad"
So good🤣🤣
Writer: "And I think we should film it near concentration camps"
Producer: "Noice, concentration camps are tight"
They high five and think about money
@Omglookatthe
Conservative here. Just so you know, it is not considered only a liberal thing to be against concentration camps, you ccp troll
@@hilaryhongkong they don't know that yet in this scenario
@OmgLookAtTheYuckerMan Waaiong No one was talking about BLM here before you brought it up.
@OmgLookAtTheYuckerMan Waaiong I scrolled and scrolled and could not find a single mention of BLM in the comments. There's is no reason to talk about BLM. Also super weird of you to imply that you're not against concentration camps.
They should make a sequel to this. They can give her force healing, a bankai, instant transmission, and the regenerative powers of Cell.
Dont forget the domain expantion.
A demon fox, a titan and a STANDO POWAH.
2:17
"They're basically violent theater students"
So just theater students, then.
You caught that joke like the golden snitch. thank you.
*YES*
Lol, the average theater kid has the aggresion of a slightly tepid glass of water.
They are nice, but they couldn't hurt a fly if their life depended on it
😸
@@Anonymos185 All I'm saying is when he said that I got flashbacks from when I was a crew member in high school. Ha ha
The witch had more character development than Mulan.
There. I said it.
Stopped caring for the movie the moment 6 year old Mulan was freerunning on buildings, backflipping and used a freaking bamboo stick to stop her fall... All to chase a chicken.
Rolled my eyes when AFTER her armor already saved her life, she decides to strip it all off before running back into battle because woo women power. And not, y'know... Just taken her helmet off and let her hair down. Last I checked, women don't gain skin made of steel when they believe they're being "true."
What about every online game with women characters. They all wear bikinis Armor that for some strange reason work as protection.😀
She needed to show the army them titties for more proof you know. 😂
Apparently, the old Mulan growing from a normal girl into a capable fighter through nothing but dedication, courage, and wit just isn’t “girl power” enough for modern Disney. Now she’s just ancient Chinese Rey.
@@Wisegirl6521 Horrible stereotype, tbh. I'm a woman that plays a lot of games. Not too many online games, I'll admit, but I've seen enough. Games like FFXIV and I think AdventureQuest is VERY adamant on gender equality for their armor. And by that I don't mean they avoid sexy outfits. You have your normal-looking outfits and armors, sure, but when the girls are given bunny suits SO ARE THE MEN. This, my fellow weebs, IS TRUE GENDER EQUALITY. I played WOW for some time too, but only a demo and didn't really make note of the outfits.
Not that I even particularly care, mind you - hell, when I can play a woman, I want that eyecandy to be a sexy badass too that I can simultaneously insert myself into and drool over (in case you haven't notice, I have a bit of gay~). BUT I honestly think people think bikini-armor is more of a thing than it actually is.
No no no
You don't get it
Women get stronger the more skin they show
This is why higher level female armor look like iron clad bikins in RPG's
In a real war, people don't randomly burst into song.
But they do have magical powers. Good to know.
I mean some soldier have cadences and do sing when not in battle so, again, Disney lacks any understanding.
*Cough* Zulu *cough*
People back then are afraid of black magic and so magic tricks was used to win war and battle. But then for some people to realize such logic is too much critical thinking for them. Back to simpleton village.
But of course! Little known fact, General Patton was a necromancer. You don't hear that a lot in the documentaries but he totally raised the dead during the Battle of the Bulge.
Well duh. Saving Private Ryan was basically 80% magic
I really loved this episode, I'm instantly hooked! By the way...
Dishonor on you Disney! Dishonor on your cash cows! Dishonor on all of the critics that actually liked this crap! And Dishonor on all of those Disney remakes! May every dishonor push them deeper into a grave of no return!
If there is anything good that came from this, it's how I discovered Screen Rant's Pitch Meetings.
She does a backflip, snaps the bad guy's neck, and saves the day.. lol..
From which episode that reference comes from?
@@ElGuerreroMaya it's from the first guy to ever tell a story... or something like that
from Ryan's personal UA-cam channel. First guy to tell/write a fictional story.
@@littlestan6625 thank you I was wondering the same thing
Oooh, using catch phrases in an almost litteral way is tight !!
“So why did you make this movie?”
Disney: *I like money*
Cash grabs are tight!
I imagine disney sounding like Dax Shepard in idiocracy.
Considering it cost 200 million, had reshoots to make it China Appropriate, and then got banned in China anyway, my chi is telling me even Money, is avoiding this trash heap!
Plot Holes, Fake-Feminism, Plot Holes, disregarding and insulting the source material intensely, and also Plot Holes?!
And also Fake-Feminism???
Wow, i cant believe we have ANOTHER ONE of those.
AGAIN!?!?
Again another one?!
... *but I'm too lazy to work for it.*
Is what you should have added :-D
People love animated Mulan because she started from an ordinary woman and do her best to prove herself that she's a worthy warrior just like any other, not someone with special power, not only she represent strong woman, but people can relate to her.
Nowadays people think a way to make a woman strong is by making that women gloating over her womanhood in a way.
Yea, there was more development in the old one. But there was less connections to the old traditional story in the old one also.
@@taekwontheo That is irrelevant
Pizza Time Parker also, they wanted to satisfy the Chinese market that has too big of an ego. The dragon was apparently “offensive”
@@taekwontheo This whole movie sounds like an ego trip
Pizza Time Parker yup basically. They just want to satisfy the Chinese parents.
"Mulan has a pretty emotional moment..."
*cut to Mulan's emotionless facial expression*
This was the goofiest movie I've seen in a long time. You nailed it. When she teleports behind enemy lines I was like "Wtf?". How she literally goes from being banished to "you're our leader now" in a matter of 5 seconds. What the hell is Disney thinking?
That women are always right.
I think goofy is the wrong word, cause there's no fun at all. Maybe head scratching? Or weird?
Some editor really fucked that scene up its really abrupt
@@sgtkort97 Who? I'm asking because I want to see if it was because of legit reasons or if they were brought on due their skin color or some other blue checkmark and lacked the skills for the job.
my theory is they made it bad so they have an excuse to remake the remake in 5 years for another cash grab
"She's Anakin. She's Rey. She's Neo. She's MAYBELLINE" 😆
I don’t get the Maybelline joke.
@@TF2Fan101 The slogan of Maybelline was "Maybe she's born with it. Maybe she's Maybelline."
7superdaimajin Ah, got it.
@@TF2Fan101 the joke doesn't make sense, it is opposite the slogan.
Being born with it is tight!
-wont it be hard to screw up this movie, having the original and the Legend as reference?
+No, its going to be super easy, barely an inconvenience
“She’s not gonna because she learned the art of the dramatic entrance, now”
“fair enough”
“We can film next to a Chinese concentration camp to save money too” “wow wow wow” actually happened.
Shut up white savior.
@@nathanielyee9203 shut up wu mao
@@thurin84 Actually the Chinese government only pay them 10 cents now, so they are yi mao, rather than wu mao (50 cents)
@@shang-hsienyang1284 hahaha well that make sense with their tanking economy lol. thanks for the update!
And they actually thank the people running the camp in the credits... So I guess Disney is openly supporting genocide, slave labor, forced sterilization involuntary organ harvesting and the rape of the prisoners wives now. Great positions for them to defend.
"The witch teams up with the bad guys... als she tells Mulan wherever she has to go to stop the bad guys and then sacrifices herself"
Wait what?
She just wants to fit in!!!
She's female. Females make no sense obviously. At least, I assume they don't, I don't actually know any.
Yeah, that made me scratch my head when I heard that.
But really though, what's the context there? What is the witch motivation? Anyone who has seen the movie can explain it? Or is really that sudden develoment?
@@blushingralseiuwu2222 What they were going for was the Witch was always rejected and see's helping the bad guys as a chance to take her place. When she see's Mulan going through the same she empathizes with her and asks her to join her. Then when Mulan gets accepted by the army she feels there is a place for her among the Kingdom and decides to help Mulan save it and because she empathized with Mulan decides to sacrifice herself to save her.
That's what they were going for but it was executed very poorly. The bad guys treat the Witch like crap even though she's basically fighting a one woman war for most of it, it really makes you wonder why she needs the bad guys help at all, it seems like she could just fly into the palace and kill the Emperor then take the throne for herself. It also makes no sense why she tells Mulan the plan, she was trying to get her to join her but there's no reason for her to expose the plan. Showing her the way and the sacrifice make sense but the exposing the plan does not.
By turning Mulan into Ray they completely destroyed how dramatic her decision to replace her father was.
In the original it was a sacrifice of a simple girl as it was likely for her to die in very first battle.
At least Rey had a personality and was beaten by Kylo Ren when they first met, and even after Kylo was almost mortally wounded, he almost beat her. Mulan 2020 didn't succeed all the time only because she didn't want to look special.
Its like whoever did this remake just did not understand or even maybe watch the original and does not know real human emotions very well at all. AI would do a better job than this Fubared version.
Nope. Worse than Rey. By a lot. Rey was a character with personality and flaws. She was hot headed, reckless, and didn't seem to care much about the cause she found herself fighting for until it started killing off all of her father figures, just to name a few. Mulan's just like "Hey, I'm a badass, and that's really it. Don't question it or I'll kick you in the head with my obvious CGI and cheesy 80s action movie wirefighting-I mean, my magic chi powers."
@@NickTheGreatAndPowerful Rey also formed a quick relationship with BB-8 because they were both lonely souls who were separated from the people they were closest to. That's a great way to show personality.
so true, they literally just destroyed the female empowerment and the drama of the first movie
"She's freaking Maybelline." Love it. Took me a second to get that though.
took me 9 months
I don't get it!!! 😭
“Wait, isn’t it impossible to run up a wall?”
“Actually, it’s super easy, barely an inconvenience.”
If Drew Drechsel can do it, why can't Mulan?
Don't those caravan people in Mexico do it all the time?
Oh, right... they don't have to. BECAUSE THE WALL FELL INTO THE RIO GRANDE.
"They have people that can run up walls?"
"Sure they do."
"Why is anyone even building walls?"
"..."
@@davidanderson_surrey_bc They're related to the people in Attack on Titan
Ever seen “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon”? Apparently Chinese people run up walls all the time!
Also: why did they add Mulan’s sister to this movie when all she did was be afraid of spiders???
Because
Jose Juan that works
Women who are afraid of everything needs representation, too.
@@b.lazing9923 fair enough!... 😂😂😂
Spiders are scary
“But if they don’t live up to his expectations they get sent home”
“So wouldn’t have Mulans father just would’ve got sent home if he had gone?”
...
“Oh my god..”
Well, he would have been sent home in disgrace, and honor is absolutely everything in the movie.
Still a garbage movie.
@@zacharygilmore1075 still carries not near enough weight compared to the threat of her father's inevitable demise in battle in the original Mulan
But Mulan's father's pride would refuse to let himself quit in the 98 version. The argument at the dinner table was proof of that.
What's funny is that in the original version, Mulan's father was hinted to be a renowed soldier in his prime, so even if he failed Shang's physical tests he would have been kept around as either a tactician or an assistant training officer so him going would get him killed by the Huns regardless of his physical condition, as there was no way he'd be turned away. Remember how surprised Shang and the advisor were at the news that "THE Hua Zou" had a son?
In this version though...yeah, wait, why bother taking his place at all when he has no proud legacy to either uphold or use for non-combat military positions? It's astounding how one dialogue exchange that only lasts a few seconds gives all the context needed for why Mulan's father's weak physical condition wouldn't have spared him from military service, yet something that easy couldn't be assed to be given in the 2020 version.
@@joshuakim5240 Well that would require actually caring about the product. Something Disney doesn't do anymore.
I heard somewhere also that, by having the "normal" sister just continue to serve her common duty, this also shows young girls that if they aren't especially gifted, they're less important. I agree with that. The sister probably shouldn't have been made...much like this movie in general
“Well it’s a superhero movie now”
“Oh those make us money :)”
I'm a bilingual chinese and this is the best 5 mins I've had in a while. This hits so many nails a coffin became an iron maiden.
Lmao 😂
That's a very interesting analogy. I love it!
😂😂😂😂
Have any other awsome analogys?
yeah so im definitely stealing this overtly morbid metaphor. thats an instant classic
“I was thinking we could remake the animated movie but just... remove all the fun stuff.” “Great!”
Replacing the fun stuff with cringe is TIGHT
We can't have fun. It's not convenient.
@@SLAYEROFTHEBEAST555 It's so EASY!
@@chasehedges6775 lmfao
and the logic.
"Yeah just take all the joy out of it and see how that feels" is very TIGHT!!
"She's Anakin, she's Rey, she's Neo, she's Maybelline"
"Oh being born with it is TIGHT"
Great one this. Best screen rant banter ever.
Now Mulan translates to Mary Sue in English.
Ryan has great chemistry with himself.
But at least Rey and Neo didn’t manifest any special powers until they were adults. And Anakin was already too old and nowhere near being acknowledged as the best Jedi.
Mulan seems to know about her powers her whole life and no one else seems to have these powers.
Hmmmm... who will win: the super powered woman being helped by the magic witch or an ordinary bad guy with an army?
If it's Maybelline, the idea is she's NOT born with it...
If this is even 10% accurate, sounds like Disney ruined it again
It's 100% accurate unfortunately.
I’m pissed. Shan yu was my favorite villain in movie history and they just completely screwed it
term02 that’s unfortunate. Mulan was probably one of the only Disney movies that actually merited a live action serious remake. Weak that they went the Mary Sue route and didn’t do any real character development. Could have been a great female hero
it's 100% hahaha
It was amazing actually
When the one dude literally said "tranquill as a forest, but on fire within" I felt mocked because it was like they were throwing the lack of songs in my face
That was Donnie Yen and he was wasted on this dumpster fire of a movie.
@William Eric Wolff I didn't have a choice it was at a family gathering 😂