Meinl Classics Custom vs. Meinl Classics Custom Dark
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
- Comparison of Meinl Classics Custom and Meinl Classics Custom Dark cymbals.
The audio for both sets of cymbals were recorded exactly the same (e.g. same mics, EQ, preamps, volume, etc.). The only difference is the cymbal sets.
Meinl Classics Custom:
14" Medium Hi-Hat, 16" Medium Crash, 18" Medium Crash, 20" Medium Ride
Meinl Classics Custom Dark:
14" Dark Hi-Hat, 16" Dark Crash, 18" Dark Crash, 20" Dark Ride
Music by: Todd McVicker
This is how a comparison video is supposed to be made.. thanks for the effort in producing it!
The Dark crashes have a more particular character than the brilliant, but both sets are nice.
Exactly, you can compare perfectly with a reference back and forth and here all the tones quickly.
I think im team custom dark
Agree except not sure about the hats
darks “speak” more
Same
Darks are brighter
Digging the Darks, because they have a more sparkling ,shimmering quality. More character.
Best comparison video I've seen yet, I would go with a mixed set
Thanks, Frank!
Same. I like the ride on the classic but I like the 18 and 16. the high hats I cant decide.
I would use classics custom medium hi hats and powerful ride and the dark for my 18 and 19 inch crashes and 18 China.
_"Best comparison video I've seen yet"_
Obviously you haven't seen many so far then...
@@ethanmuellerdrums Great cymbal comparison! Quick question Ethan - what is the song at the beginning of this video!?
Always appreciate these comparison videos folks take the time to do. Thank you.
Thank you for watching!
This is how you do a comparison folks. Great video
This is exactly what I was looking for! Thanks for helping me figure out the classics are the way to go for my setup.
Thank you this is exactly the kind of video I was looking for. 👍
The 16 dark crash sounded brighter than the normal classics custom 16 crash 😆
Outstanding method of comparison!
Dave Franco agreed!!!
The winner is snare
Joke. Classics custom dark wins
I love the way the darks look but I like how the medium sounds better I think
This is the comparison I’ve been waiting for. Team dark!!!
Great video! I‘m using both series in a mixed setting, but I lean more towards the dark cymbals.
Best price-value ratio to me!
These, the dual customs and pure alloys actually sound really good when in a mix. Solo you definitely hear the lacking weight and depth that the Byzance have. But for the price, especially used, they really sit in heavy or electronic music really nicely. So much better than other companies budget cymbals ive heard.
Best cymbal comparison video I've seen. The recording is very honest and lets the cymbals' true character be heard.
Thank you for the comparison video. I'm thinking of getting the classic customs.
I’m team classics custom. I play metal mainly, so I prefer having a relatively bright sounding crash and lighter hats. I think the darks sound great, but they have a darker tone that I don’t think works for me personally. Both rides sounded great, but I preferred the classics custom, though the ride is the only cymbal that I prefer to be heavy, so neither were my favorite.
my thoughts exactly
@WolfstyleZ I think the thinking is that, if you are a low tuned band with alot of low pitch instruments its better to stand out with the drums. higher pitched cymbals, snare crack and bass drum clickiness.
But after careful consideration, i think these dark cymbals will work fine. They will still cut through but offer potentially a more unique sound in the mix to other metal bands.
I like the bell on the ride of the classic custom
Same
Same
Owned Classi Customs for years.. great series
Finally a good video on this!
I like both. They are quite similar. I like the bite in the regular hi hats, and the dark crashes would take repeated hitting quite well, but for a single crash hit you let ring, the regular suits me. I think a mixed set would be nice. Meinl, well done playing around with B10 bronze! And excellent comparison video.
Hi-hat: both were great
Crash: good for different reasons
Ride: Dark. 100%.
This is a perfect demo video!!
Do the custom classics sound like sabians B8’s or is it just me
Yes, I was thinking that as well
My exact thoughts, especially with the crashes! The darks actually sounded pretty nice, the brilliant were a little underwhelming.
No, B8 is brighter…B10 is a little darker!!!
these comparison videos are fantastic! I'm digging the Custom Classics just a lil bit more than the Darks but it's close!
Thanks for the comment! Classics Custom are what I use
Great comparison video thank you for doing it.
the darks sound brighter...wtf
Put in earbuds
I like the dark a lot better sound wise. Less hiss and deeper tone.
Classic customs are bright, custom darks are dark. Not much else to say. Let your ear be your guide. Of course those darks look pretty nice don't they.
Good demo bro. Thanks for the post.
Thanks for the vid. Buying the darks now!!
This just made my mind up.. going for the darks
I own the brand new 18 classic custom trash stack dark and it sounds better than any byzance/ artists concept stacks go figure but the rest of my cymbals are byzance. Now about this video in my personal opinion I only like the darks 18 inches and above that's including all types . From a 17 inch and smaller cymbal all types including hi hats I like the classic customs
Norman Wilmoth yeah the small dark crash cymbal by the hi hat seemed to get lost in the mix.
i think the darks get a little lost behind distorted guitars and the brilliant ones can still be heard..even though my mind tells me i should go dark for metal,my ears are saying to go brilliant
I want both because of the contrast
I think the dark cymbals blend into the sound more
Need to do one including the Duo's, also maybe toss in a Zildjian A just for reference.
Dark hats and ride sound good but the crashes aren’t my cup of tea
Have a look at the larger crashes like the 19”,20”, and 21”. They sound amazing
I like them both. I would mix for sure.
What Promark sticks are you using?
Great vid.. thanks. Definitely the darks for me!
You can have both Brilliant and Dark Cymbals the same size... They will give you contrast
They probably sound a lot better if they weren't choked so much. Loosen up or just get rid of the wingnut. Even the clutch on the hi-hat is so tight we don't really get to hear a good wash. You've got good style, your comfortable behind your kit and good pocket work. 🥁🤘
Now add the duals to the comparison… :)
For me, a mix of Classic and Classic Dark but Dark if I had to pick just one.
Perfecta sa demostració, bravo !!!
Sounds really nice my man! Which one have you been using more?
I just ordered the 10 piece dark set see how they do
Classics for days
Has anyone here used either the 20" or 22" Classics Custom Dark Ride(s) cymbals? I am trying to find as many public opinions before buying. What do you like/dislike? How does it sit in a mix? For reference, I use the 18"/16" Classics Custom cymbals, not looking to switch those to Darks, but the ride has me interested. Thanks in advance!
@Jonathan Gonzalez Thanks for the reply, that's really helpful!
I've just owned them, but I haven't have the chance to play them. Being honest with you, i ironically have seen toon of videos of the typical set (14 hats, 16,18 crash & 20 ride) because im afraid they maybe not sound as i imagine... Probably this incoming weekend i be able to finally play them live... So... Im gonna find out if they're worth it. Im afraid of the ride more than anything... but who knows, ive reading half & half comments (50% ride bell sucks & 50% it is amazing). Wish me luck & if it is still useful to you, i'll share u my opinion after i play them).
@@krugerschubaltz4806 Much appreciated, let me know how it goes!
So personally I feel the dark ride in the 20 inch has too much wash when you crash the bow of the cymbal. I have the whole set. I got the 21 inch ride and you can crash and ride it!❤️ much better. I love the rest of the dark set. 18,16 crash 16 trash China, 14 trash crash, 10 splash. 14 hats. At my last show, 2 drummers complimented the look and sound of them. Great price too!
@@jppavon9504 Thanks for the response! That is great to hear, I ended up going with the 22", its a beast!
I dig the second track. Original?
can someone help me? i am looking for a 16´´ trash crash and i have istanbul samatya 14 inch crash and splash and idk what trash crash will fit better, the classic custom or the classic custom dark pls help me because i think they both sound good but idk wich one to choose
I think the Dark in "Classics Custom Dark" simply refers to their color, there's nothing dark about their tone lol
The sound is different, yes. The darker is slightly heavier.
I mean, the classic customs seem pretty bright, so the classic custom darks sound darkER than them
I think you are deaf
@@tjaekeysofficial fr lmao
they are definitely crispier
What a great video!
Seems like the Dark ones blend in with the overall mix better. My band mates complain about the Classics beings too bright and almost ear piercing during louder parts :(
What music do you play? I play in a Death Metal Band and I'll be going for either the 18" CC Extreme Metal Big Bell or the 18" CC Dark Big Bell. Leaning towards the dark tbh.
@@Luger0312 we play psychedelic rock/metal. Lots of distortion and other effects. I just got a Custom Dark Pack and they all sound amazing!
@@roniszR
Yeah I would have said for psychedelic stuff the darks might be the better choice. Their dark sound just adds to the music I guess.
Dark crashes , classic ride and hi hat
Why in every demo video do they choke the hell out of the cymbals? Please loosen or get rid of the top felts & nut. Does anyone else feel this way?
Good job man! Great idea 💡
do a revamp of this video, using both set at the same time. or only changing out the hi hats and rides. leaving the crash`s up all the time.
Man. Tough choice but I think I prefer the dark except the 16 inch and the classic sounds better.
I think the larger the cymbal, the dark sounds better. I'm thinking I'll love the 16 inch hats and larger cymbals in the dark series.
Lots of money to fork out if I don't like em. Gonna be a big jump from these cheesy sabian 8s I'm now playing
Dont really black cymbals but those custom dark sounds so good
Whose playing guitar? N is that a song?
Are these cymbals cast or sheet?
derrick robertson B10 on both
Classics Custom hats and crashes, and the Classics Custom Dark ride.
Definitely Classic Custom
Ethan which did you like better?
Great video. Would these Darks work for funk/r&b or just rock?
Jim Channick I think they are pretty versatile cymbals and would work for most any genre. Having said that, I personally would probably lean towards the regular classics custom for those genres specifically. In my humble opinion.
They are pretty heavy though. Take a look at Zultan cymbals (from Thomann), they got all sorts of Cymbals in B20 Bronze (CS are even B25) for pretty low prices.
Great video
Awesome!!
Hihat and ride custom dark is good
DARK SOUNDS SO SO EEERIEE... TRUE TO ITS NAME
I'm going to go with the k and a's....lol... just kidding ... I like the darks I think...hard to say
bro cual es el tema que tocas ya al finalizar jeje
Ehhh I like the reg better for some reason, dark hats seems a little too trashy when open
DARK all the way
Classic custom nice metal hithat.
Con la música tam alta apenas se oye la batería
Woo!
Custom dark is the best
All I paid attention to was the snare
any idea what snare?
WHAT USE DRUM SET?
HUMAN USE DRUMSET
@@itsthemightyd2339 DRUM-SET NICE!
dark totalmente.
I absolutely hate, when cymbals have a distinctive pitch,
those classics sound about as bad as my Meinl HCS..
The custom dark are not nearly as bad, but still..
For the price of the Custom Dark set,
you can get a Zultan Dune set from Thomann, which is like Meinl Byzance on a budget.
Allmost anything from Zultan is better than the low-budget Meinl Stuff
The custom Dark Trash china is pretty good though
Dark wins
and the winner is PAISTE PST7
But classics sound way better
No on the dark
NEITHER
Never liked the classic series. They sound cheap... (which they are). However the custom dark set sounds quite well even if it's cheaper...
I'm going with the foundry reserve. They are expensive as fuck but eh... well worth it.
incubus!
darks are better but the hi hats in both kinda suck
Those tightened rides are painful to watch
In the mix the difference between the two is apparent .
The Dark Classic stood out for distinct room for the drums with a full range Tone.
Compressed better than the way the other brighter wide tones of the Classic regular series.
With this said, without the drums in the mix just cymbals, the Classic cymbals clearly have a wide range of overtones and brightness.
Seemingly the Dark Dark Classic Tone wasn't going anywhere against the Brilliance of the Classic regular series.
It's the way they mix in the drums.
#BabyMichaelJSome
#permenantly
"@"
#PermanentlyRingo
"Dast Ist Das Boot"
" @ "
#DastLastBoot
"It's A Universal Picture" tm
🕊🏵©#ΜΘ➕
King David🔯
Holy Sepulcher
.IC XC.
+.
.NI Ka.
#Bish
@
#MarciaMarciaMarcia
#HeresJawsy
#TapThatHatCatMac
#ColdRubberRoomWelcomeHomeNotATomb
#ImpeachBiden
#onebama
#hopefortheholidays
#SeeTheFInFacebook
#Jaws
#BadHatHarry
#BadHats
#BigFangs
#BigHearts
#GrannySlave
#OBAMAsinner
#MadAsMaximumMaxine
#HeBrokeMeToo
#WigWeaveRoadKill
#nappyGodivas
#NappyAutoParts
#GetEaten
#drumtalk
#DammitQuint
#TheJawsGro
#truth
#shutmysurenuffin
#ElTonNoSoupaForYouJohn
#upandpooppandtototoop
#usallnow
#DreamTimeWasVenialInsteadOfCorporal
Save your money and get some Zildjian
darks sound terrible, for the most part 🤔
I prefer the Ride & Hi Hat of the Dark Series.
But I don't like the crashes of either series.
For Crash Cymbals I prefer the Meinl Extreme Series or Power Crash Series.
Or at the very least the HCS Bronze Meinl Crash Cymbals.
But the Crash Cymbals of the Dark Series are too trashy & metallic & the Medium Series isn't powerful enough to cut through the mix.
I actually like & have the 12" Dark Splash by Meinl & 18" Dark China also by Meinl.
So thanks for the review, & for making me considering getting the Hi Hat & Ride of the Dark series as well.
Also, loved the outro song. A very well mixed instrumental track with a shining & audible bass is always nice to hear in Metal.
Cheers
Team dark!