In a nutshell, Animate was designed to create vector based web graphics and animations capable of complex interactivity without the need to transfer large content files. SWF stands for Small Web File, and I would say is the best software for this use, formally Macromedia Flash, and my all-time favorite. After Effects was designed to handle the complete opposite, large high-resolution graphics and video files far larger than vector graphics being well into the MB and GB range, which isn't the concern it once was, point is one can't really compare AA to AE. IMO
Thanks a lot for the feedback and for the valuable input! We believe that this topic was requested in the comments because of the "animation" aspect that these software share, although they differ greatly. This is why we considered it to clear up the fog.
I've been working with Flash for over 20 years. I started with Flash MX. I love this program. I'm sorry that it is used to create simple animations, although it has much greater potential.
So much detailed and in-depth comparison to decide which sides you are on. What to choose and why? It does make your mind a lot clearer when you find yourself confusing. Very inspiring very of explanation.
adobe animate is like photoshop and after effects combined, and more focused in animation, so no complex stuff from ae Edit: im marc from the future, gotta correct my old self here, its more like illustrator than photoshop ✨
@@fridaypopcorns3462 hey, thanks for correcting me, indeed its more like an illustrator than photoshop, this comment was a year ago, didn't had that much knowledge with illustrator but now its my mainstream software for graphic design!
I can't understand why Adobe Animate users aren't using Tahoma2d instead of Animate. (Unless they have to stick with Adobe where they work) Although Tahoma2D is open source, it has many times more features and its workflow is similar to Animate. The software has vector and bitmap layers. A timeline just like Animate, tween features (even tween animation and framebyframe can be mixed), the camera layer and more...
Can you share an example of a good Tahoma2D animation? This is the first series of my project made with Adobe Flash CS6. Editing done with Adobe Premier. I did everything myself. ua-cam.com/video/KHLRwA6sGvU/v-deo.html
Yeah it's a child of Opentoonz, I very familiar in Opentoonz and Tohoma2d, but But there's limited tutorials for advance animation, whereas Adobe animate is unusual everyone use it thousand of tutorials available , so I have to use Adobe now.
Animate is adobe flash before 2015.. I use this as a student back in 2000's. It's focus is on handrawn frame by frame animation. After effects animation is focused on whatever you'll draw or create in Ai or. PS. You can also create effects for video in AE which is impossible for Animate.
I have been working with Flash for over 20 years. I believe that not all the features of the program are used. This is the first series of my project made with Adobe Flash CS6. Editing done with Adobe Premier. I did everything myself. ua-cam.com/video/KHLRwA6sGvU/v-deo.html
I am well versed in both AE and Ani CC. Both have their strengths and weaknesses. For character animation Animate CC is better, but it lacks a few things. Sound editing is poor. Built in transitions are not so great. Direct integration with mastering software like Premiere pro has been dropped. Illustrator, AE workflow is cumbersome.
@@processandbeing yes it does very well. Infact you can directly import .swf files directly in AE. I was pissed off when they dropped this support in Premiere. I needed to edit the final film in premiere because audio of PP is very good and Ani sucks in that department
This is the first series of my project made with Adobe Flash CS6. Editing done with Adobe Premier. I did everything myself.ua-cam.com/video/KHLRwA6sGvU/v-deo.html
can you guys create comparison between Cavalry vs After Effects, Fusion vs After Effects, Audition vs Fairlight, Premiere Pro vs DaVinci Resolve, Photoshop vs Affinity Photo, Illustrator vs Affinity Designer, Indesign vs Affinity Publisher, Lightroom vs Luminar Neo, Lightroom vs Capture One Pro!? Thanks
I've been using illustrator for a while now and actually used AE to do a quick project on fiverrr but I still don't know how to use it fully. But since I love illustrator I think ill use after effect instead of animate
animate is much much closer to illustrator than after effects because it is vector based! and much quicker! I used both AE and Animate! Recently i uninstalled AE! Pure frustration! You never fill that you know this app enough! Its bloated with too many features and slow! I decided to work with Animate and Premiere Pro for my animation projects!
If you're looking for simplicity we highly recommend Animate, but if you're aiming to achieve more complex stuff (adding compositing to the mix) then Ae would be your guy
Did you mean adobe after effects vs Adobe premiere pro cuz adobe animate is a drawing app and after effects is a editing app it's not a competition if its not the same case or subject but this video is still really helpful 😁
It was exactly the reason why we decided to make this comparison. It has been requested many times, so we thought that it would be useful for beginners. Not to mention that Animate isn't a drawing app only (it can be used for motion graphics with premade templates or characters for example), and Ae isn't dedicated for editing only because we use it extensively for motion graphics too! You'll be shocked at how the outcome can be similar, but there are differences (thus the reason why we made the video ;) glad you found it useful)
Anything on adobe cloud can be run simultaneously and assets and elements can be open simultaneously so you can edit and create in illustrator while using animate and in AE or photoshop
As a cartoonist, musician and artist, I am interested in this content. I am not completely familiar with the terminology. "Interface" in the music world refers to a physical device for running instruments into a computer by "interfacing" between a computer and an Interface device, with a USB cord. In this case, is the editing software of Animate, called the Interface? Or is there an actual physical "interface device" needed to use these programs? Is there an "interface device" used to put drawings onto the computer that "interfaces" a camera or iPad or scanner to the computer? If there is an interface device, then that is important to know for purchasing one of these programs. I will endeavor to hunt around to see if these programs need some interfacing device to import data into the computer, that is a physical device and not just software.
Interface it’s what you face to and figurate with as a user. It’s refers to engineering it’s interaction between real-world - machine - operator nor usb cabel.
you will need a drawing tablet or digital display to use programs like animate, photoshop and illustrator, you could on after effects, but if your desire is video editing, then I'm sure a mouse is fine
i recently started making pixel art gifs with aseprite... im very skilled with photoshop and illustrator but i never used affter effects... i m not sure wich one i should use for animating sprite sheets and pixel art...can it be animate/flash is better for it even it is basically dead lol?
@@georgizagorchev9655 no u cant compare them... animate has a total different purpose then after effects... u can do some things with both sofwares but if u get into details u will soon will realize the difference... in animate u basically can code a flash cartoon for example u can code a animated day night scene based on the real time clock for a website.... also its vector based and alot better for frame by frame animations...
Animate and after effects aren’t very similar, and have different use cases. It’s like comparing apples to clocks. Why would you compare the two? They don’t share enough similarities to make it a normal comparison. A better comparison would probably be animate and toon boom or after effects and premier pro.
Well I wanted to animate and that can be done on after effects which is why im curious about which one is better for animations… animate or after effects?
Yeah AE is good for motion/info graphics, but when Adobe will going to rewrite the whole thing lol... it's slow AF and barely taken any multicore optimization with it...
I want a character to run through a 3 D world and have the camera pan around him. I’m alright with animate but I don’t think i would be able to pull this off on there. What’s the best program for seeing a character in 3D
I am doing motion graphic in after effect but I just want to go in vfx like composting so I want a person who actually teach me the composting in affter effect .
You may laugh but I think that Adobe will merge those two programs one day. Nowadays you can transfer Animate project into AE. Imagine having those two programs merged. O__O It would be the best program ever made.
They are just too different. Animate is for actual animation of characters, you can even draw there (it has better tools for drawing). After effects is for compositing. Sure, you can animate there, but you depend on illustrator for almost always flat styles resulting in the cliche shitty explainer videos. Animate hurts less the eyes of actual Character Animators. But ToonBoom Harmony has always been the best and cooler version of Animate. It has now grown stronger and the industry standard for Character animators. With the ToonBoom Softwares you can even be a producer (director or coordinator of a film project) and a storyboard artist, that has to do more with actually creating or producing, and not only post-producing stuff really made by others. I hope blender hurries to become the industry standard to stop fucking around with so many software licenses, because in Blender you can do EVERYTHING from Production and Post.
How? It's very straightforward. One is extremely simple and geared more towards 2D animation the other has much broader capabilities like 3D work and live action video editing but is also far more complicated.
In a nutshell, Animate was designed to create vector based web graphics and animations capable of complex interactivity without the need to transfer large content files. SWF stands for Small Web File, and I would say is the best software for this use, formally Macromedia Flash, and my all-time favorite.
After Effects was designed to handle the complete opposite, large high-resolution graphics and video files far larger than vector graphics being well into the MB and GB range, which isn't the concern it once was, point is one can't really compare AA to AE. IMO
Thanks a lot for the feedback and for the valuable input! We believe that this topic was requested in the comments because of the "animation" aspect that these software share, although they differ greatly. This is why we considered it to clear up the fog.
I agree with you
I would say Animate is more for frame-by-frame animation and aftereffects is for compositing shots that can be animated.
SWF was Shockwave Flash
@@jagannathishere Correct, and one of the best apps ever made, IMO.
I've been working with Flash for over 20 years. I started with Flash MX. I love this program. I'm sorry that it is used to create simple animations, although it has much greater potential.
So much detailed and in-depth comparison to decide which sides you are on. What to choose and why?
It does make your mind a lot clearer when you find yourself confusing. Very inspiring very of explanation.
We're glad it was useful, thanks a lot for the feedback!
Titmouse in Vancouver used both softwares on the animation of the Animaniacs revival for Hulu.
adobe animate is like photoshop and after effects combined, and more focused in animation, so no complex stuff from ae
Edit: im marc from the future, gotta correct my old self here, its more like illustrator than photoshop ✨
?? Mmm you cant draw quite like Photoshop,with textutes etc or if then I would ask you how?
No its illustrator and AE combined bcoz it uses vector graphics instead of pixels
@@fridaypopcorns3462 hey, thanks for correcting me, indeed its more like an illustrator than photoshop, this comment was a year ago, didn't had that much knowledge with illustrator but now its my mainstream software for graphic design!
I adore these animation videos
I can't understand why Adobe Animate users aren't using Tahoma2d instead of Animate. (Unless they have to stick with Adobe where they work) Although Tahoma2D is open source, it has many times more features and its workflow is similar to Animate. The software has vector and bitmap layers. A timeline just like Animate, tween features (even tween animation and framebyframe can be mixed), the camera layer and more...
Can you share an example of a good Tahoma2D animation?
This is the first series of my project made with Adobe Flash CS6. Editing done with Adobe Premier. I did everything myself. ua-cam.com/video/KHLRwA6sGvU/v-deo.html
Yeah it's a child of Opentoonz, I very familiar in Opentoonz and Tohoma2d, but But there's limited tutorials for advance animation, whereas Adobe animate is unusual everyone use it thousand of tutorials available , so I have to use Adobe now.
Huh, never heard of it. I don't get paid for animation, but I just do it for fun and use animate.
Breadwinners bro I miss that show plus Harvey beaks man and the others bro they are always Messing something up
FACTS MY MAN
DUDE BRUH IT IS ON NICKTOONS + ANSWER MEEE LIKE NOPONY!!!!
@@Get0Ver1t.shorts DUDE BRUH IT IS ON NICKTOONS + ANSWER MEEE LIKE NOPONY!!!!
@@tihoprskalo7719 wait what.?
Very helpful explanation! thank you!
It’s okay to feel that why. I felt like that sowhat at the beginning. Just use the love you have for making soft to overpower that feeling
Animate is adobe flash before 2015.. I use this as a student back in 2000's. It's focus is on handrawn frame by frame animation. After effects animation is focused on whatever you'll draw or create in Ai or. PS. You can also create effects for video in AE which is impossible for Animate.
I have been working with Flash for over 20 years. I believe that not all the features of the program are used. This is the first series of my project made with Adobe Flash CS6. Editing done with Adobe Premier. I did everything myself. ua-cam.com/video/KHLRwA6sGvU/v-deo.html
So if I don't know drawing and use midjourney prompts to get sketches, then I should use after effects right?
First view, first like!
Nice explaination. Thanks for your work!
you are welcome
Thank you for the great effort 🌹
Thank you this video! It was very helpful
I have been traumatized by after effects. Adobe Premiere is where it's at.
I am well versed in both AE and Ani CC. Both have their strengths and weaknesses. For character animation Animate CC is better, but it lacks a few things. Sound editing is poor. Built in transitions are not so great. Direct integration with mastering software like Premiere pro has been dropped. Illustrator, AE workflow is cumbersome.
Does Animate support integration with AE?
@@processandbeing yes it does very well. Infact you can directly import .swf files directly in AE. I was pissed off when they dropped this support in Premiere. I needed to edit the final film in premiere because audio of PP is very good and Ani sucks in that department
@@SantanuProductions You can just edit on Audition and save you a lot of space haha.
Get overlord plugin for importing illustrator stuffs to AE..
This is the first series of my project made with Adobe Flash CS6. Editing done with Adobe Premier. I did everything myself.ua-cam.com/video/KHLRwA6sGvU/v-deo.html
loved the efforts you put in this video. totally awesome
after effect is the king 😍
can you guys create comparison between Cavalry vs After Effects, Fusion vs After Effects, Audition vs Fairlight, Premiere Pro vs DaVinci Resolve, Photoshop vs Affinity Photo, Illustrator vs Affinity Designer, Indesign vs Affinity Publisher, Lightroom vs Luminar Neo, Lightroom vs Capture One Pro!? Thanks
Wow! Thank you for the great list of suggestion, we'll definitely keep it in mind. Stay tuned ;)
Anything else?
I dont use animate but i dont think after effects is that complicated
w vid + your mine+ look through your window
I've been using illustrator for a while now and actually used AE to do a quick project on fiverrr but I still don't know how to use it fully. But since I love illustrator I think ill use after effect instead of animate
animate is much much closer to illustrator than after effects because it is vector based! and much quicker! I used both AE and Animate! Recently i uninstalled AE! Pure frustration! You never fill that you know this app enough! Its bloated with too many features and slow! I decided to work with Animate and Premiere Pro for my animation projects!
Imagine to compare 2 different programs.. same as “what is better, refrigerator, or microwave”
Which one is Best for simple explainer vector animation?
If you're looking for simplicity we highly recommend Animate, but if you're aiming to achieve more complex stuff (adding compositing to the mix) then Ae would be your guy
@@InspirationTuts2D like if we wanna create Goku Anime So must go for Adobe After Effects?
Thank you for the great effort
Thank you for the video
Organization is a key to success
I tought the video will compare luffy animation vs goku
What's the best online source to learn 2D animation, and really good FX 2D?
adobe animate tools are inside adobe after effects, so plunge into after effects to be a master animator
Did you mean adobe after effects vs Adobe premiere pro cuz adobe animate is a drawing app and after effects is a editing app it's not a competition if its not the same case or subject but this video is still really helpful 😁
Yeah I don't think the versus was an exact competition. More of a comparison than a competition
It was exactly the reason why we decided to make this comparison. It has been requested many times, so we thought that it would be useful for beginners.
Not to mention that Animate isn't a drawing app only (it can be used for motion graphics with premade templates or characters for example), and Ae isn't dedicated for editing only because we use it extensively for motion graphics too! You'll be shocked at how the outcome can be similar, but there are differences (thus the reason why we made the video ;) glad you found it useful)
Anything on adobe cloud can be run simultaneously and assets and elements can be open simultaneously so you can edit and create in illustrator while using animate and in AE or photoshop
The reason for comparison is for animation and motion graphic not for video editing.
Thanks, I just want to use photoshop brushes for animation.
I use clip studio and after effects
Love from Pakistan
Use both togetherness
As a cartoonist, musician and artist, I am interested in this content. I am not completely familiar with the terminology. "Interface" in the music world refers to a physical device for running instruments into a computer by "interfacing" between a computer and an Interface device, with a USB cord. In this case, is the editing software of Animate, called the Interface? Or is there an actual physical "interface device" needed to use these programs? Is there an "interface device" used to put drawings onto the computer that "interfaces" a camera or iPad or scanner to the computer? If there is an interface device, then that is important to know for purchasing one of these programs. I will endeavor to hunt around to see if these programs need some interfacing device to import data into the computer, that is a physical device and not just software.
Interface it’s what you face to and figurate with as a user. It’s refers to engineering it’s interaction between real-world - machine - operator nor usb cabel.
@@oliodesign thanks for the information.
@@kernjames interface , is which user interact with. you’re welcome.
@@kernjames interface , is which user interact with. you’re welcome.
you will need a drawing tablet or digital display to use programs like animate, photoshop and illustrator, you could on after effects, but if your desire is video editing, then I'm sure a mouse is fine
I like both but I hate how slow AF buffers your project just replay.
Same issue
Which is best for making sprites to export into a game engine?
I choose blender
why not use both?
Nice vid
i recently started making pixel art gifs with aseprite... im very skilled with photoshop and illustrator but i never used affter effects... i m not sure wich one i should use for animating sprite sheets and pixel art...can it be animate/flash is better for it even it is basically dead lol?
After Effects is better compared to Animate.
@@georgizagorchev9655 no u cant compare them... animate has a total different purpose then after effects... u can do some things with both sofwares but if u get into details u will soon will realize the difference... in animate u basically can code a flash cartoon for example u can code a animated day night scene based on the real time clock for a website.... also its vector based and alot better for frame by frame animations...
Animate and after effects aren’t very similar, and have different use cases. It’s like comparing apples to clocks. Why would you compare the two? They don’t share enough similarities to make it a normal comparison. A better comparison would probably be animate and toon boom or after effects and premier pro.
Well I wanted to animate and that can be done on after effects which is why im curious about which one is better for animations… animate or after effects?
Yeah AE is good for motion/info graphics, but when Adobe will going to rewrite the whole thing lol... it's slow AF and barely taken any multicore optimization with it...
Thanks
Tq
I want a character to run through a 3 D world and have the camera pan around him. I’m alright with animate but I don’t think i would be able to pull this off on there. What’s the best program for seeing a character in 3D
Clip studio privides a 3d character to manipulate it as much as u like like hands legs n angles so u will get perfect angle faster
Blender (a free program) is great for 3D and it can also do 2D, but it has a very steep learning curve.
Cinema 4d easier then blender so you can use it
Hey which text to speech service you used ? I am extremely looking for it..
Thank you for the feedback! We actually work with a voice over artist that is very human x) we don't use text to speech services
ah yes the best text to speech service, human person.
@@ThumberBulls6 I mean you're not wrong. Not at all.
Congrats!!! When did you first start investing
虽然听不懂，但我就是喜欢这些简单却五彩缤纷的快乐
I am doing motion graphic in after effect but I just want to go in vfx like composting so I want a person who actually teach me the composting in affter effect .
Half one of the time the information is wrong and most of the time it is stretched out (for more watch time may be)
I have digital pridise samples working adobe actionscrpt 3 all life field if u wont show this samples
Bro i want to beco dj but i'm smart enough to learn soft soft but have financial problem.
6:16 WHAT IS BRO DOING WITH HIS LEFT HAND?!?!
What about TV Paint?
Adobe After effect come from beginning
Adobe Animate come from Macromedia Flash
👍
Blender anyway...
Want to animate my version of onepiece fights
You may laugh but I think that Adobe will merge those two programs one day.
Nowadays you can transfer Animate project into AE.
Imagine having those two programs merged. O__O
It would be the best program ever made.
Where's that voice.
Did I just switched to an alternative universe?
THE NEXT GENERATION + ANSWER MEEEEEEEE!!
Are these available on iPad Pros?
They are just too different. Animate is for actual animation of characters, you can even draw there (it has better tools for drawing). After effects is for compositing. Sure, you can animate there, but you depend on illustrator for almost always flat styles resulting in the cliche shitty explainer videos.
Animate hurts less the eyes of actual Character Animators. But ToonBoom Harmony has always been the best and cooler version of Animate. It has now grown stronger and the industry standard for Character animators. With the ToonBoom Softwares you can even be a producer (director or coordinator of a film project) and a storyboard artist, that has to do more with actually creating or producing, and not only post-producing stuff really made by others.
I hope blender hurries to become the industry standard to stop fucking around with so many software licenses, because in Blender you can do EVERYTHING from Production and Post.
Combine.
Finally Ae win
Your voice is really low even at the highest volume
boa animação
lol you mean AE has more robotic animation and animate is more realistic
Blender.
them "happen". Only tNice tutorialng I can do is click on kick snare and Nice tutorial-hats lol
Bro this is goku
haters guna hate.
Bitmap vs Vector
Very useless thanks
edited - i meant very useful* damn, autocorrect did this 😬
😂
How? It's very straightforward. One is extremely simple and geared more towards 2D animation the other has much broader capabilities like 3D work and live action video editing but is also far more complicated.
Thanks for saving 10 minutes of time of my life.
@@CastleValentine it was a typo or autocorrect i think, i honestly loved the video and it was quite helpful. sorry for the mix up
@@Vastfill useful* 😹 typo
*Adobe Animate = Adobe Flash.*
Clickbaited.
Ai voice feelingless boring
naive video, hahhhahaahah
OMG please dont use Adobe Animate... FLASH is dead people!!! Animate is just a rebranding of old tech.
Bro I wanna make an animation comedy series with atleast 5 characters. Do you think after effects is ideal for that?
Blender.