The Bee Gees Living Together Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2020
- The Bee Gees Living Together Reaction
Reaction starts at 01:01
FANTACULAR
1. The intro is not Bee Gees like at all BUT I do like it
2. I feel like this song is LOUD. Likes super loud with not much dynamic contrast which I'm actually okay with here.
3. The lyrics are REALLY GOOD. Tons of repetition but it's still really good.
4. I hear Barry and Robin but to me it doesn't sound like them the whole time. I feel like I hear a woman singing then it turns into them singing or something. Please someone tell me if I'm wrong here or not but that's what I'm hearing.
Living Together
Bee Gees
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of being so so far apart
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of being so so far apart
Why ain't we livin' together, livin' together instead of bein' alone
Why ain't we livin' together, livin' together instead of bein' alone
I lay my heart on you and you can show the way
I give my everlasting love until my dying day
Take this lonely soul , the water or the wine
A chance to make you mine
I lay my body on the line
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of bein' so so far apart
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of bein' so so far apart
Why ain't we livin' together ,livin' together instead of bein' alone
Why ain't we livin' together ,livin' together instead of bein' alone
My life was emptiness until you came along
I nearly fell apart , you took my heart and made me strong
I need all of you to get me through the night
A chance to see the light
I lay my body on the line
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of bein' so so far apart
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of bein' so so far apart
Why ain't we livin' together instead of bein' alone
Why ain't we livin' together instead of bein' alone
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of being so so far apart
Why ain't we livin', livin' together instead of being so so far apart
Why ain't we livin' together , livin' together instead of bein' alone
Why ain't we livin' together, livin' together instead of bein' alone
Why ain't we livin' livin' together instead of bein' so so far apart
Why ain't we livin' livin' together instead of bein so so far apart
Why ain't we livin' livin' together instead of bein' so so far apart(fade)
the bee gees living together reaction the bee gees living together reaction living together song lyrics bee gees living together demo bee gees living together cover bee gees living together lyrics bee gees living together reaction bee gees reaction bee gees reaction video bee gees reaction too much heaven bee gees reaction how deep is your love bee gees song bee gees songs bee gees songs greatest hits bee gees lyrics how deep is your love
The Bee Gees Living Together Reaction
Reaction starts at 01:01
FANTACULAR
1. The intro is not Bee Gees like at all BUT I do like it
2. I feel like this song is LOUD. Likes super loud with not much dynamic contrast which I'm actually okay with here.
3. The lyrics are REALLY GOOD. Tons of repetition but it's still really good.
4. I hear Barry and Robin but to me it doesn't sound like them the whole time. I feel like I hear a woman singing then it turns into them singing or something. Please someone tell me if I'm wrong here or not but that's what I'm hearing.
Hahahaha, I had the same reaction when listening to Robin's falsetto, I just felt like hearing a woman singing, then I realised that it was Robin.
Yes Robin does twice falsetto lead in this song...you have to listen Tragedy from this álbum . It was a massive hit around the world
I guessed that part had to be Robin doing falsetto by the vibrato. 🙂
@@cindyknudson2715 so did I, his trademark vibrato gave me the clues
The part that says: "why ain't we living, living together instead of being so so far apart" and "why ain't we living together, living together instead of being alone" is Barry that sings. Robin sings the verses "I lay my heart on you..." and "my life was emptiness...". I think Barry's voice is the same that you can hear in "tragedy"; "stayin' alive" but much higher and Robin's voice sounds more like a woman in my opinion
those three men are a musical miracle .
your point number 4 : you are listening robin's falsetto
One of the greatest lines that Robin Gibb did in falsetto: I lay my heart on you.......
The bets albun of history
Ohh man I don't know what I would pick for the bee gees best album.
Melhor vocal do mundo Robin esse e incomparável
Moxxxx has a fab voice too in this song Mo does the velvet deep voice ..without him , there would be no BGs ... Hes vocals are amazing n underrated, believe me...listen to ,Man in the middle, also ,wild flowers, ,Angel of mercy, just a few of the songs Mo Wrote. Ty
I was waiting for this one... Iit's a shame Robin didn't want to do falsetto more often. His falsetto sounds different, unique!!
I'm happy with all these sugestions on the comments, I'm looking forward to see them all. Great reaction as usual!!
Even ELVIS PRESLY couldn't resists their magic . He covered their hit song ( WORDS ) try it .
The leader sing in falsetto is Robin's!
Fabulous song.. chills all over...they can do any kind of music..
Impeccable harmonies. You can tell all their voices, Mo was that deep velvet sound..luved it. Luv them .. 😍👏🤩🌞💐💜💓💌🌞
That' was Robin's voice that you thought sounded like a woman. Robin's voice is second to none.
Gots be (Robin's) falsetta..Mo is strong too!!!! on this song 😍
Lolololol luv your expression 😆
jay SATISFIED another one that is a great song on SPIRITS HAVING FLOWN
that's Robin falsetto. Children of the world reaction will be nice
It sounds so different.
Piano Man by Billie Joel. Awesome song with great lyric by a legendary singer/songwriter/ pianoplayer/harmonica. Has written and sung many great songs!🎶🎶📝🎼🎤
Piano man billy Joel is hot stuff.
That's Robin Gibb singing in falsetto.
sounds so different.
@@jaybrielakoi7747 I think is the only song that Robin sings lead in falsetto,, hey Jaybriel please react to "I'm satisfied" from the same "Spirits" album, great song, great falsetto singing from Barry, love your channel and your in-depth comments.
The verses "I lay my heart on you" etc are Robin in falsetto. When I first heard the album, I thought it was a woman and possibly Samantha Sang who had sung the song Emotion (written by Barry and Robin) which was a big hit in 1978 (check it out). I truly think Robin sung the verse as a female part. I would have love to have heard more falsetto from him in other songs. Maybe it just wasn't his thing.
Barry said they had 5 voices they could use. ( each individual, plus Barry & Robin and Barry & Mo)...he wasn't counting the falsetto. Mo said that Barry & Robin blend so well together it sounds like one voice. ( That was from an interview where Mo was talking about Fanny be tender w/ my love. He said that it is a whole different sound and if you listen close ( is it Barry or Robin, hard to tell sometimes). This is a killer album! In my opinion, so is Living Eyes and Still Waters for their later work. But there was nothing to compare with Bee Gees live! They were such nice people too!
Robin sings falsetto lead in this. The strong preference in the recording business seemed to be to push Barry's reinforced falsetto and restrict Robin to supporting Barry. Possibly why this did not make concerts or live performances.
This is one of my favourite song for Bee Gees
Unfortunately was not well known
The same for Stop think again
That one is fantacular. I can’t believe stop think again wasn’t a hit.
How is possible that after all The Bee Gees songs you’re done, you still have done “Night Fever” or “More Than a Woman” or “How Deep is Your Love”? Three their most well known songs!
Love this tune - keep hitting them up Jay....please react to '' FACE TO FACE '' Olivia Newton John and Barry Gibb . Beautiful duet and written by Barry.
I could suggest you one great,but very underrated song from their era of fame called "You Stepped Into My Life".It's stunning!
Doing it.
@@jaybrielakoi7747 Looking foreward,buddy.Thank you
I'm satisfied reaction please Bee Gees & Omega Man reaction
i think the best Maurice gibb lead voice out of all BEE GEES songs are from the 1971 album called TRAFALGAR, the song its self is called TRAFALGAR and its Maurice singing the lead
Please check out SHE KEEPS ON COMING by the Beegees thanks
If you want to hear Maurice sing,
Above and beyond
From the 1993 album Size isn't Everything.
Try Paying the price of love.
Alone
My world
I'll check it out
React Love so Right live in Austin
👍👍💕💕
🔝❤️
Falsetto this is Robin Gibb!!!
Okay gotcha. Sounds like a woman
@@jaybrielakoi7747 I know right 👍👍👍👍 Lol 😆😆😆😆 whenever a man sings in high pitched falsetto he's gonna sound like a woman 👠👠👠♀️♀️♀️, his Falsetto voice is amazing though ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Try Tragedy. Big #1 song.
Living together, in the middle it's Robin Gibb doing the falsetto. That's why it's different.
Please also try Love So Right
Thank you for keeping the Bee Gees alive.
I just finished that reaction I'm releasing it tomorrow
Jay, if you would like to hear Maurice on vocals, then listen to "Closer Than Close".
I'll take a look.
Man in the middle
Omega Man
I think that the parts you feel it might be a woman is the parts where Robin has the lead and is using his falsetto.
Now you soon need to react to "I'm Satisfied", which must be the only song you have not reacted to from the Spirits album. I always liked that one.
And maybe you have not reacted to "Until" yet which is nice song but a little of in respect to the rest of the album.
Robin really? It's so different sounding in this songs I think .
Very good!! React making of Music Tragedy!!
It’s coming up.
👌
I love the song and most of this album, but critics tended to find it boring. Of course, the critics tended to still love the Doors and only liked dead musicians...my mom called the magazine I received "Dead Musician" because the featured artist tended to be some recently dead person who stood for "real"music, not my beloved Bee Gees!
hi jay may i request you to please react on Oh Darling by Robin Gibb?
react to beeggees the only love
robins falsetto is much much smoother than barry's...not irritating it has sweetness!
please react to: Bee Gees - UNTIL
Further proof that this is a great album. I would say probably their last GREAT album. 🤷🏻♂️
I’ll get back to you in a few months on thAt.
Hi Jay - This is obviously a big production number from the brothers and they and it soars! Falsetto and harmonies married in heaven and presented on this most excellent of albums. Another song that could have been features on so many movie soundtracks. I agree with you regarding the repetition - it adds to the eloquence of their urging the lady....just WHY are we not living together???? Its Barry all the way - not a lady in sight! LOL
If a song can say the same thing over and over again and make it good then you knob they got skill.
@@jaybrielakoi7747 Knob?
@@jaybrielakoi7747 You mean 'know'....lol.....was wondering what I had done to annoy you?!!! lol
@@mujahidamin8504 I think you're thinking of 'noob'?
@@munizdaniel7 What is noob?
I did not think that Robin had a falsetto - please treat comments that make this claim with caution!
Both Robin and Maurice are singing in falsetto in harmony with Barry on their songs. For this song it is definitely Robin on lead in falsetto. I am 100% certain on that.
@@JR-bm8dl I hear you JR but respectfully disagree with you. Only Barry had a falsetto. Mo and Robin had high harmonies. There is a massive difference. If you have proof that Robin sang falsetto then please let me know.....proof such as a video or an official website but NOT Wikipedia.
@@mujahidamin8504 Here is a quote from Spencer, Robin's son in talking about the song in an article done on the 40th anniversary of the "Spirits" album.
Tucked away on the album’s second side is “Living Together,” arguably one of the most interesting pieces of ear candy they crafted during this period. Opening with a full symphonic, Beethoven-esque overture, it escalates into a waft of strings before it dissolves into a low synth hit and transitions into a satisfying funk shuffle. The refrains break twice and fold into verses with Robin’s lead vocal, which is a startling, and quite wonderful, contrast to Barry’s.
“[It] really showcases my dad’s crazy falsetto. It’s nuts,” Spencer muses. “Spirits was one of the first Bee Gees records that didn’t feature my dad heavily on lead vocals. And I wish there had been more of that. It’s my only real criticism of it."
The article is entitled"Bee Gees Spirits Having Flown Turns 40" by Grant Walters featured on albumism.com. The article goes in depth on all the songs on the LP and I recommend it to anyone who wants more info on the album.
This was Robin's lone contribution to the Spirits album and he tries his own falsetto here. The song itself has a nice funky groove, but Robin's falsetto and the piercing vocals at the pitch change is just too much. One song after another in high intense falsetto makes these songs too similar. It all lent itself to the backlash and criticism that followed.
What do you mean by Robin's falsetto was too intense and are you blaming the Bee Gees for the Disco backlash because they sang in falsetto ,I Love their falsettos but I don't know why Robin Gibb didn't use his Falsetto voice more it sounds excellent 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
@@afreakaboucher1316 Yes, there was a huge backlash against the "Bee Gees Sound" by 1980 due to the constant use of falsetto on a large number of hits (Bee Gees, Andy Gibb, Samantha Sang) in a short period of time. In 1978 and 1979, their music was dominating US radio and the rock crowd hated that falsetto sound. Prior to the Spirits Having Flown, the falsetto was used in conjunction with normal voices in the harmonies but on Spirits even the harmonies were high falsetto, which even by Bee Gees fans standards was too much. They were selling millions of records every week while they were recording Spirits so no one had any idea that there would be a backlash.
@@allisons3663 I disagree. They were swept into the disco backlash which was a whole thing in and of it itself. It was a hate movement by a rock radio DJ. Nothing to do with the falsetto. There were plenty of rock songs in the top 40 at that time and AOR stations. Nobody HAD to listen to them or buy their records. Also, many rock artists were releasing disco records. The Stones, Rod Stewart, Kiss, the Kinks, ELO, Paul McCartney and Wings among them. People not surprisingly were just looking for something to hate. That's why radio stations in the US stopped playing their music. I was around then as I imagine you were too. That's how I remember it.
@@bsquared4604 They were an easy target. Constant radio play and the overexposure gave people a symbol of the backlash movement. Many other artists did disco (even Frank Sinatra), but The Bee Gees were so popular and when you reach the peak, someone always wants to tear you down. The falsetto just added fuel to that simmering fire. Rockers in the midwest didn't appreciate singing in higher registers. Even ardent fans complained that it became too much on the Spirits album.
tobin
robin
when I saw tobin it totally threw me off. My mind went nuts for a split second.
When men sing in high pitched falsetto they're gonna sound like women
Just a quick general comment: As I have said on a few posts...Robin and Maurice did not have falsettos. But if anyone has proof and evidence that they did and that Robin sang falsetto on those parts of 'Living Together' then please let me know. Those video excerpts from Tragedy are a million miles from a falsetto and certainly from the falsetto in Living Together. I think the Wikipedia article is to blame for this misinformation amongst fans. Keep listening and nice work Jay!
Here is a quote from Spencer, Robin's son in talking about the song in an article done on the 40th anniversary of the "Spirits" album.
Tucked away on the album’s second side is “Living Together,” arguably one of the most interesting pieces of ear candy they crafted during this period. Opening with a full symphonic, Beethoven-esque overture, it escalates into a waft of strings before it dissolves into a low synth hit and transitions into a satisfying funk shuffle. The refrains break twice and fold into verses with Robin’s lead vocal, which is a startling, and quite wonderful, contrast to Barry’s.
“[It] really showcases my dad’s crazy falsetto. It’s nuts,” Spencer muses. “Spirits was one of the first Bee Gees records that didn’t feature my dad heavily on lead vocals. And I wish there had been more of that. It’s my only real criticism of it."
The article is entitled"Bee Gees Spirits Having Flown Turns 40" by Grant Walters featured on albumism.com. The article goes in depth on all the songs on the LP and I recommend it to anyone who wants more info on the album.
@@JR-bm8dl Article proves your point.