@@twoturkey-c3s The majority of the skin will automatically translate to Korean. Where there is custom text, I will not be translating these as I do not speak any languages other than English. If users want to provide translations, I will then include them in future downloads, as has been done with French (translated by Feria), Czech (translated by VonTripps) and Portuguese (translated by Herr Jones).
It is not just the quality of the skin itself, but the community supporting aspect. In a world when most people on the internet and companies try to monetize everything and would sell their mother for a plus click or ad, you honestly just made the past 5 years biggest improvement on FM for free. And giving credits for the original authors of the parts of the skin and linking the "competition". You just restored my faith in humanity today, a much needed after feeling down, so a big THANK YOU! We need more people like you to make the FM community or general just the world a better place.👍
Thank you very much. I firmly believe that if we work to build one another up, everyone flourishes. I also say this fully aware that my skin and my YT channel tends to be catered more to a niche, so maybe I don't get drawn into the "competition" nature to begin with. All I can do is try and lead by example, and hope that others follow!
Wowzers. That's just a completely new level of skinning. Well done, Sir! 👏👏👏 And thank you for promoting our skin within your skin. That's beyond nice from you 🙂
This should be officially implemented in the FM as a skin option. Awesome. When I see Jonukas commenting, I have to ask if the skin also works with other languages than english?! And by that I mean german, cause I haven't seen it in the credits. @@mustermannfm
@@hawu22 so there are a couple of bits that won't work in German. Specifically the "Archetypes", as there aren't suitable existing translations for those phrases already in the game. There may be a couple of other areas, but these are places where the words are mostly there for cosmetic reasons - you don't miss anything important by it not being translated. There is also an issue with player instructions popup - your German words are too long! There is a fix for that already - just the follow the instructions here: twitter.com/MustermannFM/status/1729411817217151387
Fantastic work, I'm definitely an attribute less convert. On the match itself, what's the deal with feedback from the coach during the game? Some skins have it, others don't, sure someone said the main game is doing away with it anyway. Doesn't seem to pop up on yours unless I'm wrong. Cheers mate
@@alexathegreat15 the feedback appears during the game in the usual place, and then there is an archive of it in the tablet under the "Advice" tab. I have definitely noticed some games where there isn't much feedback given. And others, where the Assistant Manager won't shut up 😂
Good heavens - I'm speechless! This is amazingly creative, game-changing, and must have been an immense amount of graft to get to this. It is no less than a complete reimagining of the game - as you say, leading away from '14 vs 13 off the ball', and a more, dare I say, 'realistic' experience of life of a football manager - rough guides to 'he's fast' and then using statistics / metrics from performance to judge the reality. Can't wait to try it out!
This really show you how important the game's community really is for the success and longevity of a game. SI would not have all the resourses and manpower to make FM as in depth as this wihout people like Mustermann. Thank you,
Thank you very much. And absolutely; a lot (not all) of games live and die by their community, not just in terms of creation but also support and attitude. FM's community is fantastic!
"SI would not have all the resourses and manpower to make FM as in depth as this" .... "Sega Sammy Holdings has a market cap or net worth of $3.17 billion as of November 27, 2023. Its market cap has increased by 12.00% in one year."
I have a weird sleeping pattern. Sleep early evening, up around midnight. That way I get to do the things I enjoy whilst I've still got energy...and then finish the day with work.
Good god this is perfect , I’ve been searching for a skin which makes next opposition reports/info more easily available. Putting it in the tactics screen is a masterstroke - thanks for your work on this
Who's that good looking bald guy at 12:36? All jokes aside, what an amazing skin from an amazing creator! Sharing the love with the community is a class act, let alone creating a literal game changer!
Kind words, thank you! I will say that whilst the base FM interface gets a lot of flak, it's actually quite incredible. 1) To be as adaptive as it is to so many resolutions, and 2) to keep barrier of entry to the game reasonably low, considering just how much information is in the game. If the base interface didn't exist, I wouldn't be able to do this - because this skin can only exist in a world where something more universal is available. by default.
Thank you very much! It's interesting that SI have incorporated something similar in the Match Prepartion screen for training, so I'm keen to see if there's more possibilities there for future updates.
Wow. Congrats on an unreal skin. So, so impressive. The only thing I would love is some coloured tint to the screens depending on who I manage. I love the feel of the game changing (just a little bit) when I move a club. But that's a minor point in something which is as bold and innovative as this.
Thank you. As mentioned in the video, blame FC Augsburg!! Unfortunately anywhere that has text, club colours can cause problems - but I've kept it in on the Club Info/News/Vision pages and incorporated it into team sheets (well, technically it's the kit colour for team sheets) so there's little bits here and there.
I had the same thoughts as you, so I made the sidebar colours "dynamic". This has helped me massively. The sidebars change colours according to which players, staff, clubs or nation I'm currently on. I still can't figure out how to make the actual "namebars" dynamic but it'll do for now.
Thank you kindly. I'll never accept the statement "best ever" as there's so many amazing skins out there, but I'm certainly happy with it and appreciate the kind words.
I've been playing FM/CM since around CM2 and this is probably one of the best skins I've ever saw for the game. The flow, the details, the style is just perfect. Unfortunately I've been playing that long I can't get my head around playing without attributes it hurts my 40 year plus brain 😂 none the less the skin and the work you've put in kudos.
Ironically, I think that's the exact reason I'm drawn to this approach. After 20 years of playing FM, I've got attribute fatigue. Numbers have lost all meaning 😂
This is an amazing job!! I am really impressed and cant wait to try it out! It really stands out lot of important aspects of players and switches your focus to other things and not just to the attributes. Thank you very much for that!
For those within the FM community, I will always believe that it's important to lift everyone up. And also, should you not like the skin as a whole, but like certain parts, it's useful to know where they might have come from. It might just lead you to the skin that you want! For those outside the FM community, I think it's good to know where the ideas come from, and they'll be able to write about it far more concisely than I'll ever be able to!!
wowwww this is incredible. i’m sure it’ll take some getting used to but i’m looking forward to applying this to my game first thing tomorrow. incredible work thank you
Glad to hear it. I hope you enjoy it as much as I do. It does take a little bit of getting used to, but genuinely find the whole approach so liberating.
Fantastic skin, I’m gonna give it a try today. Never used a skin that got rid of numbered attributes, always been slightly nervous about doing so, but I’ll try this one out.
Looks great as always! Just my personal view: if all the tweaks you made were available with the original color/pattern design and font (the montserrat?(ish) isn't very readable for me) That would be the dream. But otherwise job well done and thank you for being so active with the community! Cheers from Prague!
Děkuji, Patrik. There is a colour scheme that is similar to the default FM one - "Elton". Interestingly, Montserrat won a public vote (my preferred choice came in 3rd), and you can't believe how much more difficult that made this, as I didn't realise just how wide the font was 🤣
@@mustermannfm as a Frontend developer I 100% feel your pain 😂 Thank you for your kind reply and I'll definitely give your skin a good try. Have an awesome day!☺
Looks absolutely stunning! I would appreciate a video with you using the skin in a save, showing how you go about setting the best team, what you are looking for in transfers recruitment etc. Yes I am stuck on the attributes. It feels like I'm going in blind when using the skin 😅
You're in luck, sir! It might have been on FM23, but I was using the beta version of this skin for my Ajax one-season save. Squad Assessment: ua-cam.com/video/kgD80sAX8AY/v-deo.html Staff Recruitment: ua-cam.com/video/bHyC5g_uROM/v-deo.html Tactics: ua-cam.com/video/es6aNRX-cC0/v-deo.html Data-Led Transfers: ua-cam.com/video/RV_f07Wet3w/v-deo.html Completely ridiculous semi-animated mockumentary to actually follow the story: ua-cam.com/video/c5lFLNiYNDc/v-deo.html Now the skin is released, I will also be starting up my main save with PAOK in the coming weeks. I will be using a slightly adapted version of the skin where I also disable player search, staff search and remove staff attributes entirely.
Thank you, and hopefully this will pique the interest. Of course, I imagine there will be things missing from here that you like from other skins. Sadly it's always a compromise 🤣
This is the cleanest and most polished skin I've seen. Sadly I'm very new to FM and I'm afraid of playing without exact attributes to begin with. When I master the game more I will definitively use it.
The newer you are, the better. You've not yet formed a dependency on attributes!!! Joking aside, it is definitely best to get familiar with the game before exploring the more niche sides.
Thank you, very much. I tried to ignore what was actually in the game when designing, and focus instead on what I think should be available on each page. It's definitely an extreme change!
What a fantastic skin game-changing skin. Only issue I can imagine is when trying to evaluate your team and sign new players early season when the stats reset. As a professional graphic designer I also really appreciate your design choices.
Indeed, there are limitations with stats resetting at season end, and I heartily recommend creating a save at season end before the reset, so you're able to go back and check previous seasons. And thank you for the compliment. As a non-designer, that means a lot!
Just spent another hour on this it’s absolutely incredible feel like I’m playing a new manager game for the first time looks beautiful in 3440 resolution on an ultra wide monitor aswell everything about it the tactics screen my favourite so clean and easy to use there’s no clutter anywhere.
Thank you everyone for your patience, and I hope you'll enjoy the skin as much as I do!! If you come across any issues or what to make suggestions please do so in the comments, or head on over to the SI Forums! Also, there appears to be approximately 10 seconds of blank screen at 14:46. Not sure what happened there!!
That is amazing design. Sadly it would probably slow down my time playing without attributes and I don't get much time to game these days, but as a statistician myself, this is really excellent.
You'll never know until you try it!! Joking aside, thank you for the kind words. I know it's a niche playing style and won't appeal to everyone, but if people still look at it and go "oh, cool, but not for me", I'm pretty happy with that!
Dude, you've done it again! Like everything you put out and upload to the channel, it is of a higher level. Without a doubt this is a real gamechanger. Thank you for this! P.S. I haven't had much time lately, but I watched the intro of your video "Ajax, everything or nowt" and...I think you've done it again!! he he
Really appreciate the support, dude 🙏 Got a few updates I need to make to the skin after the patch last week, and then looking forward to getting my teeth into my proper FM24 save.
WOW! I've been playing FM on my 720p laptop and let alone finding the best skin, just trying to find skin that looks good on 720p itself is a challenge. I will absolutely try this one when I come home today!
Hey Mustermann. Just finished watching your video. This is absolutely brilliant. I fell completely out of love with the game a while back but this makes me want to play again! The attribute ratings have for instance always bothered me. This makes the game much more realistic. That’s what I want, realism. I am working on finishing my masters degree right now but as soon as I’m done I will give this skin a try. Thank you. I can’t wait.
First - good luck with your Masters!!! Secondly, that's great to hear. I completely understand what you mean about falling out of love. It is very easy for a game based on a sport that barely changes over time to get stale!!
@@mustermannfm thank you! And I want to add that all the details, the little things that you have improved with your skin seem like such quality of life improvements… it’s going to feel like a new game and big upgrade, I’m sure. Two months to go! Also, SI should just hire you. At least as a consultant!
@@mustermannfm Update: Thesis turned in yesterday, bought FM24 today, downloaded the Mustermann Iconic and having my first look now. Looks brilliant. I can't wait to explore this (to me) completely new way of playing the game, focussing on data and performance metrics. Thank you!
They're all there - generic mental attributes are at the top, and other attributes in the area that is relevant. And from the sounds of things, it looks like you don't need a reminder either 😁
I've used last year numbered version. I'll give it a try this iconic version now, this is the best skin for lower res computers, it's a shame you're not going to make a numbered version, I hope I get used to it or mybe I'll try to edit the files myself later 👍
This looks a really nice skin that I'm going to try. I'm normally a numbers attributes guy but the effort you have put into it makes me want to try it on one of my saves so thanks for sharing. Slightly off topic, you said you are looking forward to making new videos. I was wondering if you're interested and have time to make match analysis videos on what you do in matches that aren't going your way, perhaps if you adjust player roles or what data you look at in-game. Basically what ever you do and look for. I have found written guides online but I'm more of a visual person and like videos to follow. I've watched lots of FM content creators, all good but I've not seen anyone cover this subject. Unless you can suggest someone's videos I should watch as I see you like to promote in the FM community. Just thought it would be interesting to see to the usual wonderkids recruitment videos that everyone seems to do, not that you do that as you're more of a story teller which is why I think you would explain it well for fairly newbies like me that have only played since FM23. Just a thought anyway.
Welcome to the dark side of attributeless 😈 If I ever get a chance to start this PAOK save, it will be more like a let's play, so there will be more game-management stuff. Of course, I am reactive to what happens, so I can't say - "hey, episode 3 I'll be focussing on in-game analysis and adjustment" as I won't know if and when things will happen ahead of time!
@@mustermannfmlook forward to the let's play then if you get the chance. Another question, what view or custom views are you using for this skin for scouting e.g in players in range? Unless I missed it in this video.
Never a better time than right now 🤣 Joking aside, I think my first venture into attributeless (albeit short lived) was during summer a few years ago. When you've played FM a lot, and the real season has ended, it was a nice challenge to make things feel fresh.
Great work man! Quick question if I’m not too late: is it possible to change the icon circles in “tactics” to show a miniature picture of the players instead of the circles?
You'll want to change panels/tactics/tactics icon info panel overview.xml. Your best approach will be to find a tactic screen you like in another skin and add that to this skin
Definitely gonna give this a go at some point!! might do a PL save to get used to it though as it seems like it'll take some getting used to without having to worry about the intricacies of the turkish 3rd division where I currently am in my main save!
It's definitely worth giving a try - and sure it might help to do so first time with a team you have a little bit of knowledge about! That said, I played South African second division in FM23 this way, and it was great fun. Icons meants I could easily see that my players were all rubbish!!
I never comment on videos. However, I feel that I need to say THANK YOU! Rarely I have made a change on FM that made me say out load HOLY FUCK! WELL DONE!!!
Disliking for complaining about my boys in Augsburg xD On a serious note this skin is insane, only thing I don't particularly like is the pseudo-attributeless nature (my issue, not yours) and even then I feel like for scouting I would prefer the generalised dots to trim my scout list at which point I would take interest in attribute values. But every other feature is just outstanding (especially love the player architypes, something small that looks great). Fantastic work.
Look, it's not my fault that Augsburg went for green and red!! Sadly, it's just one of the limitations of the game when using club colours, otherwise I have no qualms with them. Norwich are nearly as bad, too!
Your Skin is simply amazing, it has completely changed my FM experience, thank you. I have two questions tho, firstly, there were phrases in the manage profile of the default skin such as "hands on approach, loyalty to players, media handling" etc.. As far as I understand, you changed these with more realistic statistics, but is it possible to bring them back again by editing? Secondly, what do I need to edit to show the facilities and reputation levels with stars instead of just texts? I'm sorry if my questions are too general, I think I asked very specific questions about XML, but I hope the answers may be easy. Thanks again.
As neither are things I've sought to do, I don't know the exact answers and I'm not at home to check. Your best route is to find a skin that has what you're looking for, and identify which element controls what you're asking for. For the manager it will be panels/human/human profile.xml, and I think the element is referred to as "Manager Statistics". For facilities, I've never touched this at all, but I believe WTCS has, so that might be a good place to look.
This skin is simply incredible, but I do wonder if attributes could be shown or a separate version with the attributes will capture those who prefer it, other than that the skin tops everything.
The thresholds have been deliberately omitted, for two reasons. 1) The thresholds may change whenever there is a ME patch to ensure that roughly 10% of players within the target position group will meet the criteria. 2) The article it is inspired by does not have set thresholds.
i love this skin so much and have used it for months thank you! i did however want to ask if we'd be able to get a panel during matches that allows us to see the oppositions changes to their roles during the game. i think currently it just shows the formation. that would 100% stop me from swapping skins. thanks for all your hard work man
I'm afraid I have no pans to add that at all. That is not information that would be available to you. If you want to add it yourself, you can always look at copying over the panels/match/match in between highlights panel.xml from another skin.
I stumbled across this, downloaded and tried it, and while I love the idea of using no attributes and want to try it in its own save, I'd love if there is a version of the skin that has attributes. Great skin though. Very smooth, clean, and intuitive. One thing in particular is how easy it is to move players around while setting up tactics vs the vanilla skin!
Thank you for the feedback. I appreciate that attributeless isn't for everyone, but that is the area I am focussing my time. Unfortunately I do not have the time or passion for an attributed version, but there are plenty of fantastic alternatives out there. Tato is a great choice for a smooth, clean and intuitive design: www.fmscout.com/a-fm24-skin-tato.html Electric Panther might be more appropriate if you are looking for some of those data visualisation elements: www.fmscout.com/a-electric-panther-fm24-skin.html
8:13 can you or do you plan to add an indicator of role/position familiarity beside player name on tactics screen similar to older fms? I find it very useful especially when I'm not fully familiar with the players.
It's something I considered previously and decided against as the information is already available elsewhere on the screen - the role ability indicator is next to their name in the squad list, and tactical familiarity is available by clicking the third button on the top left of the pitch. I will add it to my list of future considerations, but just to be transparent and not give false expectations, I expect there is a good chance I'll reach the same conclusion
I really like the structure and graphs in your skins but sometimes I also like to display player stats in numbers for some of my testing. Can you guide me in editing the circle icons into numbers?
If I am to assume that you have some knowledge of skinning, then you need to basically change every instance of attribute_circle to attribute_label, change alignments and possibly some of the widths of every instance, and probably amend the colour schemes so the numbers are visible. If you don't have prior skinning knowledge, then unfortunately I cannot help you much further. It would take too long, but you can always check out the SIForums, and make use of the guides there. Or, alternatively try Electric Panther. Groot asked for permission to use the graphs, and is otherwise a numerical skin.
This is insane work!! But.. I am a numbers guy for my player attributes.. Any chance that in any further release we could switch from color indicators back to actual numbers?
I have an important question to address. The percentile statistics displayed on the pizza chart are not dynamic. This means that the xG values are consistently compared to specific numbers derived from a multitude of tests that have been conducted. In light of this, it raises the question of whether these numbers were generated using FME or QME. The disparity between the two methods can be significant and may present a distorted representation of a player's pizza chart. While I haven't delved deeply into testing FM24, my experience with FM22 and FM23 revealed that leagues simulated with QME tended to have more key tackles than those using FME (without getting bogged down in specific statistics). I hope you understand what I'm trying to convey. If I were to solely simulate my league with Full Detail and let other leagues progress quickly for a faster progression into the future, the player statistics in my league might not necessarily be comparable to those of players in different leagues. Is this still the case in FM24? Currently, I export data multiple times with filters for leagues that use QME or FME, manually calculating percentiles in an Excel sheet. This ensures that my percentiles are dynamic and calculated based on their respective detail levels. However, this process is time-consuming. Considering the overall aesthetic appeal of your skin, I would love to make the switch.
The data set used for the visualisations are FME only. Prior to that I had run tests with both, and found that the disparity in the stats used for the visualisations was relatively minor, with players usually ending up within a 10% bracket of the FME. Of course, with it not being possible to run large scale tests with perfect unchangeable conditions, it is difficult to assert how how much of this was to do the different between MEs and how much of it was coincidence. Furthermore, with each patch released, this initial test has not been re-run, so the usefulness of that assessment will diminish over time.
Hi Mustermann, your skin is fantastic and so are you videos about data aproach, i've learned a lot. But this is the first time i'm playing like you play and i'm having a hard time with the no attributes thing, do you know if its possible to make the numbers avalaible again? Thank you in advance.
Hi, sorry there is not/will not be a numerical version. If you want some of the analytical elements, I can heartily recommend Electric Panther by Groot, or any of the other more traditional skins that you can find over on FMScout.
Aye, it definitely takes a bit of time to adjust, but I genuinely believe it's a far more liberating way of playing - less focus on attributes means you're willing to consider signing players you otherwise might have never thought about!!
I do like a lot of this, but some things more than others. It would be great to be able to get toggleable bits. Love the media and data hub stuff especially
I love your skin mate, really changed the FM experience for me for the better. The only thing that I can't seem to find is the suspensions tab. Is it hidden behind a button by any chance?
Awww shuck! Although ironically, Mustermann is like the German equivalent of John Doe. So will be used for unidentified dead people. Looks like he might be on his way back to heaven (or hell)
In the video there was a key, but it's the exact same ranges used by the default game. Depending on the colour scheme you use, the specific colours will be different, but they also increase in size. These are as follows: Poor 1-5 Average 6-10 Good 11-15 Excellent 16-20
Indeed. But better, because you can't play a Wildcard and then see all the players you transferred out score more points than the ones you transferred in 🤣
I LOVE that skin, Unlike "Statman" Skin I can actually use it! Context: I play on a laptop which runs FM24 on 85 percent zoom. And in this version the "Statman" is a disaster. THANK YOU Mustermann - you are the hero of our little screen community. SOME graphics seem stretched, but its are totally playable.
That's a shame. Statman is a great skin, but _Ben_ does explicitly state it's designed for 1920x1080 at 85% zoom, which is sadly no consolation for those at lower resolutions. Glad I'm able to fill in that void.
I have a stupid question: Is it possible to see the abilities? While I love your changes, sometimes I miss the overview of abilities lmao@@mustermannfm
@@flyingaviator8158 no need to apologise. I only asked to make sure I understood, instead of making an assumption! I'm afraid not. My priority with the skin is to be without attributes. If you are looking for something with numbers, I can recommend Electric Panther. It is a very different style, but incorporates some of my data work, and is a well thought out skin: www.fmscout.com/a-electric-panther-fm24-skin.html
The skin is incredible and I will definitely use as soon as possible. However I think it would be nice to allow users to show attributes. Like by pressing a button that switch between non attribute to attribute values and contrary.
Thank you and I hope you enjoy it. Just to manage expectations, there will not be a numerical version. If you prefer (like most people) numerical, I heartily recommend trying Electric Panther skin. It's a different style, but very well put together and contains some of the additional analysis elements.
Hi, is it possible to make stats range narrower? 6-10 and 11-15 wouldn't help much since 90% of the relevant player would be there. If there are 6 ranges 1-4 (terrible), 5-7 (poor), 8-10 (reasonable), 11-13 (good), 14-16 (great) and 17-20 (excellent) for any attributes, this will be a game changer.
I'd originally intended for 5 ranges, as 20 divides into it naturally, and it allows an "Average" range which straddles the middle. Unfortunately, the game is designed to support 4 ranges, and there are some places where it's hardcoded so you'd end up with attributes being displayed in 5 ranges in one place, but 4 in another.
Hi Mustermann, I really love the skin however a bit of feedback would be to bring the attribute ratings back. It acts as a good indicator for newer players to see ratings rather than a circle increasing in size to highlight attributes. Or if theres a way to turn them on please let me know!
Thank you for the feedback. This is an attributeless skin, so there won't be a version with numeric attributes I'm afraid. Thankfully, there are a number of fantastic traditional skins out there. If you want some of the data elements, I'd recommend Electric Panther by Groot: www.fmscout.com/a-electric-panther-fm24-skin.html
@@mustermannfm absolutely! This is such a refreshing and inclusive take on FM. I work in data but I sometimes get so overwhelmed with the amount of information available. This is a practical approach to finding hidden gems and not just falling into recruitment patterns.
@@adamroark8204 I think the default game skin does a fantastic job of serving a wide and varied player base, and naturally when that happens, you end up with a lot of compromise. I'm just glad that there is the facility to make your own skins, and I'm able to explore my slightly more niche preferences and hope others get some use out of it too!
Removing the detailed attributes marks isnt for me, unfortunately. I would absolutely love to use your skin but with the regular numbers, this would be the absolute best. Great job !
The skin is more real life-like. You can see from watching someone like De Bruyne that he has elite passing... but you cant determine whether its 17, 18, 19 or 20/20. The game is already tediously easy having every single (scouted) players' exact attributes available to compare and this skin provides a level of ambiguity meaning that sometimes you make the wrong choice(s). Novel idea, I know.
That's fine. As said, I'm not trying to make something for everyone - but if one day you decide to try something a little different, you know where to look!
Minor Fix Files added to end of opening post on SI Forums: bit.ly/46zPxAP
Korean Ver. PLZ !!!
@@twoturkey-c3s The majority of the skin will automatically translate to Korean. Where there is custom text, I will not be translating these as I do not speak any languages other than English. If users want to provide translations, I will then include them in future downloads, as has been done with French (translated by Feria), Czech (translated by VonTripps) and Portuguese (translated by Herr Jones).
It is not just the quality of the skin itself, but the community supporting aspect. In a world when most people on the internet and companies try to monetize everything and would sell their mother for a plus click or ad, you honestly just made the past 5 years biggest improvement on FM for free. And giving credits for the original authors of the parts of the skin and linking the "competition". You just restored my faith in humanity today, a much needed after feeling down, so a big THANK YOU! We need more people like you to make the FM community or general just the world a better place.👍
Thank you very much.
I firmly believe that if we work to build one another up, everyone flourishes. I also say this fully aware that my skin and my YT channel tends to be catered more to a niche, so maybe I don't get drawn into the "competition" nature to begin with. All I can do is try and lead by example, and hope that others follow!
Wowzers. That's just a completely new level of skinning. Well done, Sir! 👏👏👏
And thank you for promoting our skin within your skin. That's beyond nice from you 🙂
Danke, sire!
This is the single best thing to happen to me in all my years of playing FM. Thank you, sir.
Those are very kind words indeed. I'm glad you're enjoying it!
From the idea, to the work, to the final result... simply an incredible skin. I bow down to you. 🙌🏻
Thank you, dude. Although, there's a skin in the bottom right at about 13:00 that looks pretty damn sexy, too!
@@mustermannfm 🫶
incredible work. thank you so much for all the hours you put into this 👏👏👏
Thank you for your support, and if you give it a go, I hope you enjoy it!!
This should be officially implemented in the FM as a skin option. Awesome. When I see Jonukas commenting, I have to ask if the skin also works with other languages than english?! And by that I mean german, cause I haven't seen it in the credits. @@mustermannfm
@@hawu22 so there are a couple of bits that won't work in German. Specifically the "Archetypes", as there aren't suitable existing translations for those phrases already in the game. There may be a couple of other areas, but these are places where the words are mostly there for cosmetic reasons - you don't miss anything important by it not being translated.
There is also an issue with player instructions popup - your German words are too long! There is a fix for that already - just the follow the instructions here: twitter.com/MustermannFM/status/1729411817217151387
Fantastic work, I'm definitely an attribute less convert. On the match itself, what's the deal with feedback from the coach during the game? Some skins have it, others don't, sure someone said the main game is doing away with it anyway. Doesn't seem to pop up on yours unless I'm wrong. Cheers mate
@@alexathegreat15 the feedback appears during the game in the usual place, and then there is an archive of it in the tablet under the "Advice" tab. I have definitely noticed some games where there isn't much feedback given. And others, where the Assistant Manager won't shut up 😂
Good heavens - I'm speechless! This is amazingly creative, game-changing, and must have been an immense amount of graft to get to this. It is no less than a complete reimagining of the game - as you say, leading away from '14 vs 13 off the ball', and a more, dare I say, 'realistic' experience of life of a football manager - rough guides to 'he's fast' and then using statistics / metrics from performance to judge the reality. Can't wait to try it out!
That's very kind, thank you. I hope you enjoy it!!
hi there! It's an spanish FM podcast here so glad to finally see the result of your great work! we're ready to change the game
¡Gracias! Keep up the good work yourself!!
This really show you how important the game's community really is for the success and longevity of a game. SI would not have all the resourses and manpower to make FM as in depth as this wihout people like Mustermann.
Thank you,
Thank you very much.
And absolutely; a lot (not all) of games live and die by their community, not just in terms of creation but also support and attitude. FM's community is fantastic!
"SI would not have all the resourses and manpower to make FM as in depth as this"
....
"Sega Sammy Holdings has a market cap or net worth of $3.17 billion as of November 27, 2023. Its market cap has increased by 12.00% in one year."
Recording a video at 4am, what a boss. Will definitely be giving this skin a try on my LLM save. Looks incredible.
I have a weird sleeping pattern. Sleep early evening, up around midnight. That way I get to do the things I enjoy whilst I've still got energy...and then finish the day with work.
This is an absolute game changing skin! Well done 👏
Found your channel on my UA-cam recommendations. Really enjoying the content
Welcome! A pleasure to have you onboard, and glad you're enjoying things so far. I hope it continues!!
This absolutely great. Unbelievable work from you. Every year you push it on a next level. Very inspiring…
Thank you very much. Just 12 months to wait to see what next year brings!
Good god this is perfect , I’ve been searching for a skin which makes next opposition reports/info more easily available. Putting it in the tactics screen is a masterstroke - thanks for your work on this
Fantastic Work. It is like a different game. Well done and thank you for all your hard work.
That's very kind. Thank you!
Unreal, but I wouldn’t expect anything less. You set the bar time and time again, long may it continue mate. ❤
You are always such a gentleman. Thank you again!
So much useful info right on the pages and I love the way to get more info by clicking to open boxes.
Cannot wait to try this.
Really great work!!
Thank you very much. I do love buttons!
Who's that good looking bald guy at 12:36?
All jokes aside, what an amazing skin from an amazing creator! Sharing the love with the community is a class act, let alone creating a literal game changer!
He is a handsome fella, isn't it!!
Appreciate the love, dude ❤
I have been looking forward for this! Great job again mate, thank you for your effort
No worries - I just hope it lives up to expectations!!
I already fell in love!!! @@mustermannfm
This is incredible. SI should take note for FM 25 because this is what it should be from a UI perspective.
Kind words, thank you!
I will say that whilst the base FM interface gets a lot of flak, it's actually quite incredible. 1) To be as adaptive as it is to so many resolutions, and 2) to keep barrier of entry to the game reasonably low, considering just how much information is in the game. If the base interface didn't exist, I wouldn't be able to do this - because this skin can only exist in a world where something more universal is available. by default.
Love the tactics screen, such a wonderful addition for me
Thank you very much! It's interesting that SI have incorporated something similar in the Match Prepartion screen for training, so I'm keen to see if there's more possibilities there for future updates.
Not even hyperbole, this is already changing the way I play the game. Grazie mille.
Thank you 🙏 I'm glad you're enjoying it!
Wow. Congrats on an unreal skin. So, so impressive. The only thing I would love is some coloured tint to the screens depending on who I manage. I love the feel of the game changing (just a little bit) when I move a club. But that's a minor point in something which is as bold and innovative as this.
Thank you.
As mentioned in the video, blame FC Augsburg!! Unfortunately anywhere that has text, club colours can cause problems - but I've kept it in on the Club Info/News/Vision pages and incorporated it into team sheets (well, technically it's the kit colour for team sheets) so there's little bits here and there.
I had the same thoughts as you, so I made the sidebar colours "dynamic". This has helped me massively. The sidebars change colours according to which players, staff, clubs or nation I'm currently on. I still can't figure out how to make the actual "namebars" dynamic but it'll do for now.
Amazing work mate! This is literally the best skin ever. Hats off to you...
Thank you kindly. I'll never accept the statement "best ever" as there's so many amazing skins out there, but I'm certainly happy with it and appreciate the kind words.
I've been playing FM/CM since around CM2 and this is probably one of the best skins I've ever saw for the game. The flow, the details, the style is just perfect.
Unfortunately I've been playing that long I can't get my head around playing without attributes it hurts my 40 year plus brain 😂 none the less the skin and the work you've put in kudos.
Ironically, I think that's the exact reason I'm drawn to this approach. After 20 years of playing FM, I've got attribute fatigue. Numbers have lost all meaning 😂
This is an amazing job!! I am really impressed and cant wait to try it out! It really stands out lot of important aspects of players and switches your focus to other things and not just to the attributes. Thank you very much for that!
Thank you, and I hope you enjoy it. I expect it will take a little getting used to, though!
very cool of you to cite the sources of your inspiration. big respect
For those within the FM community, I will always believe that it's important to lift everyone up. And also, should you not like the skin as a whole, but like certain parts, it's useful to know where they might have come from. It might just lead you to the skin that you want!
For those outside the FM community, I think it's good to know where the ideas come from, and they'll be able to write about it far more concisely than I'll ever be able to!!
wowwww this is incredible. i’m sure it’ll take some getting used to but i’m looking forward to applying this to my game first thing tomorrow. incredible work thank you
Glad to hear it. I hope you enjoy it as much as I do. It does take a little bit of getting used to, but genuinely find the whole approach so liberating.
Absolutely GOATED Skin I'm never going back to any other skin thank you so much
Thank you 🙏 glad you're enjoying it so far!
Incredible, the best skin I've seen in 5 years of fm. Thank you.
Very kind words, thank you 🙏
This is the best skin I've seen in more than 9 years playing this game. IMPRESSIVE! 😱😎😃
Thank you, Juan 🙏
And also Merry Christmas 🌲
Just a comment to say: Thank you for the awesome effort and beautiful outcome.
Great work on the skin! Hopefully when I have more time I can sit down and utilize it, but design is beautiful and love the statistics.
Thank you kindly, sir!
WOW. This is amazingly impressive. I can't wait to use this
Hope you enjoy it as much as I do!
Amazing skin, really love how clean looking it is, awesome design. Top work!
Thank you very much!!
Fantastic skin, I’m gonna give it a try today. Never used a skin that got rid of numbered attributes, always been slightly nervous about doing so, but I’ll try this one out.
What's the worst that can happen!? You give it a try, and decide it's not for you. No harm, no foul.
Great Job! How did you get the stadiums to appear in the home tab?
I downloaded a stadium pack. There is a link in the description - and also on the start screen of the skin under the "Graphics" tab.
Looks great as always!
Just my personal view: if all the tweaks you made were available with the original color/pattern design and font (the montserrat?(ish) isn't very readable for me) That would be the dream.
But otherwise job well done and thank you for being so active with the community!
Cheers from Prague!
Děkuji, Patrik.
There is a colour scheme that is similar to the default FM one - "Elton". Interestingly, Montserrat won a public vote (my preferred choice came in 3rd), and you can't believe how much more difficult that made this, as I didn't realise just how wide the font was 🤣
@@mustermannfm as a Frontend developer I 100% feel your pain 😂
Thank you for your kind reply and I'll definitely give your skin a good try.
Have an awesome day!☺
@@Patrik38cz then you'll see right through my lies when I blame everything wrong with the skin on the back-end, in this case SI themselves 🤣
Looks absolutely stunning! I would appreciate a video with you using the skin in a save, showing how you go about setting the best team, what you are looking for in transfers recruitment etc.
Yes I am stuck on the attributes. It feels like I'm going in blind when using the skin 😅
You're in luck, sir! It might have been on FM23, but I was using the beta version of this skin for my Ajax one-season save.
Squad Assessment: ua-cam.com/video/kgD80sAX8AY/v-deo.html
Staff Recruitment: ua-cam.com/video/bHyC5g_uROM/v-deo.html
Tactics: ua-cam.com/video/es6aNRX-cC0/v-deo.html
Data-Led Transfers: ua-cam.com/video/RV_f07Wet3w/v-deo.html
Completely ridiculous semi-animated mockumentary to actually follow the story: ua-cam.com/video/c5lFLNiYNDc/v-deo.html
Now the skin is released, I will also be starting up my main save with PAOK in the coming weeks. I will be using a slightly adapted version of the skin where I also disable player search, staff search and remove staff attributes entirely.
Purerly amazing, thank you!
I'm always changing skins because one has something the other doesn't but this is amazing........complete new look I love it........thank you
Thank you, and hopefully this will pique the interest. Of course, I imagine there will be things missing from here that you like from other skins. Sadly it's always a compromise 🤣
This is the cleanest and most polished skin I've seen. Sadly I'm very new to FM and I'm afraid of playing without exact attributes to begin with. When I master the game more I will definitively use it.
The newer you are, the better. You've not yet formed a dependency on attributes!!!
Joking aside, it is definitely best to get familiar with the game before exploring the more niche sides.
this is incredibly good! it does actually look like fm24 was a new improved game!
Thank you, very much. I tried to ignore what was actually in the game when designing, and focus instead on what I think should be available on each page. It's definitely an extreme change!
What a fantastic skin game-changing skin. Only issue I can imagine is when trying to evaluate your team and sign new players early season when the stats reset. As a professional graphic designer I also really appreciate your design choices.
Indeed, there are limitations with stats resetting at season end, and I heartily recommend creating a save at season end before the reset, so you're able to go back and check previous seasons.
And thank you for the compliment. As a non-designer, that means a lot!
Fantastic, been patiently waiting for your skin for fm 24. I can now begin playing my career 🫡
Oh no. I'm sorry to keep you waiting! I hope it lives up to expectations.
Just spent another hour on this it’s absolutely incredible feel like I’m playing a new manager game for the first time looks beautiful in 3440 resolution on an ultra wide monitor aswell everything about it the tactics screen my favourite so clean and easy to use there’s no clutter anywhere.
Thank you dude 🙏 I really appreciate it, and glad that you enjoy it.
Do you not find all the text and buttons kind of squished or stretched?
@@scruffylooking5957 no mate if it’s like that you might need to zoom out in preferences mines perfect though but got a wide monitor
Thank you everyone for your patience, and I hope you'll enjoy the skin as much as I do!! If you come across any issues or what to make suggestions please do so in the comments, or head on over to the SI Forums!
Also, there appears to be approximately 10 seconds of blank screen at 14:46. Not sure what happened there!!
That is amazing design.
Sadly it would probably slow down my time playing without attributes and I don't get much time to game these days, but as a statistician myself, this is really excellent.
You'll never know until you try it!!
Joking aside, thank you for the kind words. I know it's a niche playing style and won't appeal to everyone, but if people still look at it and go "oh, cool, but not for me", I'm pretty happy with that!
You sir, are a king amongst men.
You are too kind! Thank you.
Oooh, why didn't I see this yesterday? Will be downloading this evening 😎
Great to hear. Hope you enjoy it, and it's an improvement on last year's offering!
Dude, you've done it again!
Like everything you put out and upload to the channel, it is of a higher level.
Without a doubt this is a real gamechanger.
Thank you for this!
P.S. I haven't had much time lately, but I watched the intro of your video "Ajax, everything or nowt" and...I think you've done it again!! he he
Really appreciate the support, dude 🙏
Got a few updates I need to make to the skin after the patch last week, and then looking forward to getting my teeth into my proper FM24 save.
Dream pretty! Our eyes will be eager to follow up on that content 😉✌🏽
WOW! I've been playing FM on my 720p laptop and let alone finding the best skin, just trying to find skin that looks good on 720p itself is a challenge. I will absolutely try this one when I come home today!
720p might still be a challenge. The minimum supported resolution here is 1360x768 at 100% zoom. 1280x720 should work at 85% zoom, though.
Oh mine is 768, I just forgot the number I thought it was the same lol thanks!
Best skin last year, couldn't wait to use it again. Great work, congrats
Thank you for your kind words, and hope you enjoy it again this year!
Fantastic job mate. Love your work and I appreciate the work you have put into this to put that personal touch on it!
Thank you very much, dude.
Hey Mustermann.
Just finished watching your video. This is absolutely brilliant. I fell completely out of love with the game a while back but this makes me want to play again! The attribute ratings have for instance always bothered me. This makes the game much more realistic. That’s what I want, realism. I am working on finishing my masters degree right now but as soon as I’m done I will give this skin a try. Thank you. I can’t wait.
First - good luck with your Masters!!!
Secondly, that's great to hear. I completely understand what you mean about falling out of love. It is very easy for a game based on a sport that barely changes over time to get stale!!
@@mustermannfm thank you! And I want to add that all the details, the little things that you have improved with your skin seem like such quality of life improvements… it’s going to feel like a new game and big upgrade, I’m sure. Two months to go!
Also, SI should just hire you. At least as a consultant!
@@mustermannfm Update: Thesis turned in yesterday, bought FM24 today, downloaded the Mustermann Iconic and having my first look now. Looks brilliant. I can't wait to explore this (to me) completely new way of playing the game, focussing on data and performance metrics. Thank you!
@@KasperKristjansson Fantastic! Congratulations on getting your masters done. Enjoy your time playing...you deserve it!
I'm definitely looking forward to trying this skin .
great job
Hope you enjoy it. Might take a little getting used to if you haven't played attributeless before, but once you get going it's liberating!
This is incredible. All I miss are the relevant attributes for a staff member, such as DDM for coaches, adaptability on scouts, etc...
They're all there - generic mental attributes are at the top, and other attributes in the area that is relevant. And from the sounds of things, it looks like you don't need a reminder either 😁
Yep, totally missed it! Absolutely no reason for it to become my all time favourite skin now! Thanks so much!@@mustermannfm
@@edenra8734 easy to miss, especially as it's such a departure from how everyone's used to things looking!
Love the concept, going to give it a go after not playing FM for the last few years.
Thank you, and that's awesome. Hope it helps get into the new FM!!
My body is ready for this!
Thank you very much, dude. Appreciated as always!
I've used last year numbered version. I'll give it a try this iconic version now, this is the best skin for lower res computers, it's a shame you're not going to make a numbered version, I hope I get used to it or mybe I'll try to edit the files myself later 👍
Come on over to the dark side of (pseudo) attributeless. It's not too bad over here!
This looks a really nice skin that I'm going to try. I'm normally a numbers attributes guy but the effort you have put into it makes me want to try it on one of my saves so thanks for sharing. Slightly off topic, you said you are looking forward to making new videos. I was wondering if you're interested and have time to make match analysis videos on what you do in matches that aren't going your way, perhaps if you adjust player roles or what data you look at in-game. Basically what ever you do and look for. I have found written guides online but I'm more of a visual person and like videos to follow. I've watched lots of FM content creators, all good but I've not seen anyone cover this subject. Unless you can suggest someone's videos I should watch as I see you like to promote in the FM community. Just thought it would be interesting to see to the usual wonderkids recruitment videos that everyone seems to do, not that you do that as you're more of a story teller which is why I think you would explain it well for fairly newbies like me that have only played since FM23. Just a thought anyway.
Welcome to the dark side of attributeless 😈
If I ever get a chance to start this PAOK save, it will be more like a let's play, so there will be more game-management stuff. Of course, I am reactive to what happens, so I can't say - "hey, episode 3 I'll be focussing on in-game analysis and adjustment" as I won't know if and when things will happen ahead of time!
@@mustermannfmlook forward to the let's play then if you get the chance. Another question, what view or custom views are you using for this skin for scouting e.g in players in range? Unless I missed it in this video.
A thing of absolute beauty. Can't wait to get stuck in
Can't wait to see the first Hemel player with an elite attribute!
This is really cool! Nice work! Maybe one day I will attempt an attribute less save…
Never a better time than right now 🤣
Joking aside, I think my first venture into attributeless (albeit short lived) was during summer a few years ago. When you've played FM a lot, and the real season has ended, it was a nice challenge to make things feel fresh.
Great work man! Quick question if I’m not too late: is it possible to change the icon circles in “tactics” to show a miniature picture of the players instead of the circles?
You'll want to change panels/tactics/tactics icon info panel overview.xml. Your best approach will be to find a tactic screen you like in another skin and add that to this skin
Absolutely phenomenal work, and really great video
Appreciate the love, dude - and sending it right back to ya ❤
Incredible work! I will for sure give this a go. TY.
It can be a steep learning curve, but a really fun way of playing the game differently!
Definitely gonna give this a go at some point!! might do a PL save to get used to it though as it seems like it'll take some getting used to without having to worry about the intricacies of the turkish 3rd division where I currently am in my main save!
It's definitely worth giving a try - and sure it might help to do so first time with a team you have a little bit of knowledge about! That said, I played South African second division in FM23 this way, and it was great fun. Icons meants I could easily see that my players were all rubbish!!
I never comment on videos. However, I feel that I need to say THANK YOU! Rarely I have made a change on FM that made me say out load HOLY FUCK! WELL DONE!!!
That is very much appreciated, thank you, dude!
Amazing work! This has almost made FM a new game!
Thank you, sire!
Disliking for complaining about my boys in Augsburg xD On a serious note this skin is insane, only thing I don't particularly like is the pseudo-attributeless nature (my issue, not yours) and even then I feel like for scouting I would prefer the generalised dots to trim my scout list at which point I would take interest in attribute values. But every other feature is just outstanding (especially love the player architypes, something small that looks great). Fantastic work.
Look, it's not my fault that Augsburg went for green and red!! Sadly, it's just one of the limitations of the game when using club colours, otherwise I have no qualms with them. Norwich are nearly as bad, too!
Your Skin is simply amazing, it has completely changed my FM experience, thank you.
I have two questions tho, firstly, there were phrases in the manage profile of the default skin such as "hands on approach, loyalty to players, media handling" etc.. As far as I understand, you changed these with more realistic statistics, but is it possible to bring them back again by editing?
Secondly, what do I need to edit to show the facilities and reputation levels with stars instead of just texts?
I'm sorry if my questions are too general, I think I asked very specific questions about XML, but I hope the answers may be easy. Thanks again.
As neither are things I've sought to do, I don't know the exact answers and I'm not at home to check.
Your best route is to find a skin that has what you're looking for, and identify which element controls what you're asking for. For the manager it will be panels/human/human profile.xml, and I think the element is referred to as "Manager Statistics".
For facilities, I've never touched this at all, but I believe WTCS has, so that might be a good place to look.
This skin is simply incredible, but I do wonder if attributes could be shown or a separate version with the attributes will capture those who prefer it, other than that the skin tops everything.
I'm afraid not, sorry.
Hey man - absolutely loving this! Would love to know the thresholds you use for the player archetypes?
The thresholds have been deliberately omitted, for two reasons. 1) The thresholds may change whenever there is a ME patch to ensure that roughly 10% of players within the target position group will meet the criteria. 2) The article it is inspired by does not have set thresholds.
i love this skin so much and have used it for months thank you! i did however want to ask if we'd be able to get a panel during matches that allows us to see the oppositions changes to their roles during the game. i think currently it just shows the formation. that would 100% stop me from swapping skins. thanks for all your hard work man
I'm afraid I have no pans to add that at all. That is not information that would be available to you. If you want to add it yourself, you can always look at copying over the panels/match/match in between highlights panel.xml from another skin.
Amazing!! Fantastic work!! Thank you 🙏🏻
Thank you very much. I really appreciate it!
After your video, I have to try to play with this skin. So far for me the best was Vince Skin but maybe yours will be better for me. Looks interesting
It might take a little getting used to, but I hope you enjoy it!
I stumbled across this, downloaded and tried it, and while I love the idea of using no attributes and want to try it in its own save, I'd love if there is a version of the skin that has attributes. Great skin though. Very smooth, clean, and intuitive. One thing in particular is how easy it is to move players around while setting up tactics vs the vanilla skin!
Thank you for the feedback.
I appreciate that attributeless isn't for everyone, but that is the area I am focussing my time. Unfortunately I do not have the time or passion for an attributed version, but there are plenty of fantastic alternatives out there.
Tato is a great choice for a smooth, clean and intuitive design: www.fmscout.com/a-fm24-skin-tato.html
Electric Panther might be more appropriate if you are looking for some of those data visualisation elements: www.fmscout.com/a-electric-panther-fm24-skin.html
8:13 can you or do you plan to add an indicator of role/position familiarity beside player name on tactics screen similar to older fms? I find it very useful especially when I'm not fully familiar with the players.
It's something I considered previously and decided against as the information is already available elsewhere on the screen - the role ability indicator is next to their name in the squad list, and tactical familiarity is available by clicking the third button on the top left of the pitch.
I will add it to my list of future considerations, but just to be transparent and not give false expectations, I expect there is a good chance I'll reach the same conclusion
I really like the structure and graphs in your skins but sometimes I also like to display player stats in numbers for some of my testing. Can you guide me in editing the circle icons into numbers?
If I am to assume that you have some knowledge of skinning, then you need to basically change every instance of attribute_circle to attribute_label, change alignments and possibly some of the widths of every instance, and probably amend the colour schemes so the numbers are visible.
If you don't have prior skinning knowledge, then unfortunately I cannot help you much further. It would take too long, but you can always check out the SIForums, and make use of the guides there. Or, alternatively try Electric Panther. Groot asked for permission to use the graphs, and is otherwise a numerical skin.
@@mustermannfm Thank you my brother
This is legendary. Many thanks!
Thank you kindly!
This is insane work!! But.. I am a numbers guy for my player attributes.. Any chance that in any further release we could switch from color indicators back to actual numbers?
With numbers, I would switch to this skin immediately and never look back.
Sorry guys, I'm not making a "traditional" numeric skin.
I have an important question to address. The percentile statistics displayed on the pizza chart are not dynamic. This means that the xG values are consistently compared to specific numbers derived from a multitude of tests that have been conducted.
In light of this, it raises the question of whether these numbers were generated using FME or QME. The disparity between the two methods can be significant and may present a distorted representation of a player's pizza chart. While I haven't delved deeply into testing FM24, my experience with FM22 and FM23 revealed that leagues simulated with QME tended to have more key tackles than those using FME (without getting bogged down in specific statistics). I hope you understand what I'm trying to convey.
If I were to solely simulate my league with Full Detail and let other leagues progress quickly for a faster progression into the future, the player statistics in my league might not necessarily be comparable to those of players in different leagues. Is this still the case in FM24?
Currently, I export data multiple times with filters for leagues that use QME or FME, manually calculating percentiles in an Excel sheet. This ensures that my percentiles are dynamic and calculated based on their respective detail levels. However, this process is time-consuming. Considering the overall aesthetic appeal of your skin, I would love to make the switch.
The data set used for the visualisations are FME only.
Prior to that I had run tests with both, and found that the disparity in the stats used for the visualisations was relatively minor, with players usually ending up within a 10% bracket of the FME. Of course, with it not being possible to run large scale tests with perfect unchangeable conditions, it is difficult to assert how how much of this was to do the different between MEs and how much of it was coincidence. Furthermore, with each patch released, this initial test has not been re-run, so the usefulness of that assessment will diminish over time.
FM community more than other gaming community. UA-camrs actually add stuff to the game.
Every community has it's good and bad, but the FM community is definitely one of the most supportive and wonderful I've seen!
Hi Mustermann, your skin is fantastic and so are you videos about data aproach, i've learned a lot.
But this is the first time i'm playing like you play and i'm having a hard time with the no attributes thing, do you know if its possible to make the numbers avalaible again? Thank you in advance.
Hi, sorry there is not/will not be a numerical version. If you want some of the analytical elements, I can heartily recommend Electric Panther by Groot, or any of the other more traditional skins that you can find over on FMScout.
@@mustermannfm thank you very much!
Please add the option to see attributes as well, maybe as the toggle. Thank you 😊
Please see description for answer!
this makes a new game out of FM! Not easy at the beginning, but worth it.
Aye, it definitely takes a bit of time to adjust, but I genuinely believe it's a far more liberating way of playing - less focus on attributes means you're willing to consider signing players you otherwise might have never thought about!!
I do like a lot of this, but some things more than others. It would be great to be able to get toggleable bits. Love the media and data hub stuff especially
Naturally; I don't expect everyone to share my exact vision, and there willll always be some bits people like and others that people hate.
I love your skin mate, really changed the FM experience for me for the better. The only thing that I can't seem to find is the suspensions tab. Is it hidden behind a button by any chance?
Well spotted. It's not there at all. You're the first person to notice in 6 months! I'll look at how to incorporate it
@@mustermannfm Would be amazing!
u know why they call him mustermann??? cuz he muster fell from heaven the way he moves so angelic!!!!!!
Awww shuck!
Although ironically, Mustermann is like the German equivalent of John Doe. So will be used for unidentified dead people. Looks like he might be on his way back to heaven (or hell)
@@mustermannfm hes going to hell and back just to say he did it!
SI, give this man a job!!
Very kind words, thank you!
This is crazy... just wonderful...!!!
Great job!! How do I know what the colours represent in term of elite, good or average attributes?
In the video there was a key, but it's the exact same ranges used by the default game. Depending on the colour scheme you use, the specific colours will be different, but they also increase in size. These are as follows:
Poor 1-5
Average 6-10
Good 11-15
Excellent 16-20
this is so freaking awesome, well done man
Very kind words, thank you!
Its like playing FPL if you like stats. Then you can watch the games in FM24 to see if the player passes the eye test. 🙂
Indeed. But better, because you can't play a Wildcard and then see all the players you transferred out score more points than the ones you transferred in 🤣
I LOVE that skin, Unlike "Statman" Skin I can actually use it! Context: I play on a laptop which runs FM24 on 85 percent zoom. And in this version the "Statman" is a disaster. THANK YOU Mustermann - you are the hero of our little screen community. SOME graphics seem stretched, but its are totally playable.
That's a shame. Statman is a great skin, but _Ben_ does explicitly state it's designed for 1920x1080 at 85% zoom, which is sadly no consolation for those at lower resolutions. Glad I'm able to fill in that void.
I have a stupid question: Is it possible to see the abilities? While I love your changes, sometimes I miss the overview of abilities lmao@@mustermannfm
@@flyingaviator8158 as in the attributes?
@@mustermannfm A yes Attributes- sorry Englisch is not my 1 language.
@@flyingaviator8158 no need to apologise. I only asked to make sure I understood, instead of making an assumption!
I'm afraid not. My priority with the skin is to be without attributes. If you are looking for something with numbers, I can recommend Electric Panther. It is a very different style, but incorporates some of my data work, and is a well thought out skin: www.fmscout.com/a-electric-panther-fm24-skin.html
The skin is incredible and I will definitely use as soon as possible. However I think it would be nice to allow users to show attributes. Like by pressing a button that switch between non attribute to attribute values and contrary.
Thank you and I hope you enjoy it. Just to manage expectations, there will not be a numerical version. If you prefer (like most people) numerical, I heartily recommend trying Electric Panther skin. It's a different style, but very well put together and contains some of the additional analysis elements.
Hi, is it possible to make stats range narrower? 6-10 and 11-15 wouldn't help much since 90% of the relevant player would be there. If there are 6 ranges 1-4 (terrible), 5-7 (poor), 8-10 (reasonable), 11-13 (good), 14-16 (great) and 17-20 (excellent) for any attributes, this will be a game changer.
I'd originally intended for 5 ranges, as 20 divides into it naturally, and it allows an "Average" range which straddles the middle. Unfortunately, the game is designed to support 4 ranges, and there are some places where it's hardcoded so you'd end up with attributes being displayed in 5 ranges in one place, but 4 in another.
Hi Mustermann, I really love the skin however a bit of feedback would be to bring the attribute ratings back. It acts as a good indicator for newer players to see ratings rather than a circle increasing in size to highlight attributes.
Or if theres a way to turn them on please let me know!
Thank you for the feedback. This is an attributeless skin, so there won't be a version with numeric attributes I'm afraid. Thankfully, there are a number of fantastic traditional skins out there. If you want some of the data elements, I'd recommend Electric Panther by Groot: www.fmscout.com/a-electric-panther-fm24-skin.html
SO clean, amazing work!
Thank you kindly 🙏
Absolutely unreal! This has to be the best skin yet!
Thank you for the kind words!
@@mustermannfm absolutely! This is such a refreshing and inclusive take on FM. I work in data but I sometimes get so overwhelmed with the amount of information available. This is a practical approach to finding hidden gems and not just falling into recruitment patterns.
@@adamroark8204 I think the default game skin does a fantastic job of serving a wide and varied player base, and naturally when that happens, you end up with a lot of compromise. I'm just glad that there is the facility to make your own skins, and I'm able to explore my slightly more niche preferences and hope others get some use out of it too!
This is amazing - thank you!!
Thank you, and I hope you enjoy it!
Removing the detailed attributes marks isnt for me, unfortunately. I would absolutely love to use your skin but with the regular numbers, this would be the absolute best. Great job !
The skin is more real life-like. You can see from watching someone like De Bruyne that he has elite passing... but you cant determine whether its 17, 18, 19 or 20/20.
The game is already tediously easy having every single (scouted) players' exact attributes available to compare and this skin provides a level of ambiguity meaning that sometimes you make the wrong choice(s). Novel idea, I know.
That's fine. As said, I'm not trying to make something for everyone - but if one day you decide to try something a little different, you know where to look!
i am with u cool skill but would love this skin if it just kept the attributes or an option to show the attribute numbers would be amazing