The Most Used Progressive Metal Stereotypes (FEAT. Andrew Baena)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 882

  • @NikNocturnal
    @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +2219

    *Do you even 11 minute songs, bro?*

  • @michaelt1760
    @michaelt1760 5 років тому +1591

    “I’m so prog, I listen
    To concept albums on shuffle” - Kmac

    • @FGirao
      @FGirao 4 роки тому +26

      How to make cult musicians mad

    • @regdenee
      @regdenee 4 роки тому +19

      I think Kmac got inspired by a joke from this thread on Reddit. Found it in a post called "piss off /r/progmetal".
      www.reddit.com/r/progmetal/comments/351gg4/piss_off_rprogmetal_with_one_sentence_stolen_from/cr0cvuj?

    • @Malum09
      @Malum09 4 роки тому +12

      That line always cracks me up

    • @StraightWhiteMan
      @StraightWhiteMan 4 роки тому +4

      This should be made illegal btw

    • @Ivogrape
      @Ivogrape 4 роки тому +1

      That damn joke. Holy shit

  • @BaenaCarcosa
    @BaenaCarcosa 5 років тому +2290

    I forgot to put my strap real high for this one, please forgive me

    • @josuastangl7140
      @josuastangl7140 5 років тому +5

      Lmao I would have loved you for that😂😂

    • @FEBRIZIOtv
      @FEBRIZIOtv 5 років тому +9

      Baena. What guitar is that. its beautiful. I love the wood grain and matte paint job etc.

    • @SaintTrinasTorch
      @SaintTrinasTorch 5 років тому +16

      Automatic like for the Gojira shirt. Fuckin A.

    • @BaenaCarcosa
      @BaenaCarcosa 5 років тому +27

      @@FEBRIZIOtv Thanks! it's my Fast Guitars Orion 7 string with Seymour Duncan Alpha/Omega pickups

    • @FEBRIZIOtv
      @FEBRIZIOtv 5 років тому +2

      Andrew Baena nice nice. I’ll google the parts and do some research. Just ordered a Mayones Regius 7, gonna drop some Fishman Modern Fluence pickups in it. Hoping it comes out nice.

  • @tobibender7475
    @tobibender7475 5 років тому +3121

    After my last ex broke up with me I realized my life is a prog metal song
    95% are solo

  • @turniue
    @turniue 5 років тому +592

    Friend: What's the time signature of this song
    Me: *pulls out graphing calculator*

    • @tortis6342
      @tortis6342 4 роки тому +4

      So I read this late at night and tried to stifle my laughter by covering my mouth, and subsequently smushed my nose into my face. Stop being funny.

  • @aleksmonoxide2910
    @aleksmonoxide2910 5 років тому +950

    5/31 subdivided into 22nd notes is my favorite time signature xD also great video

    • @rehobalint1100
      @rehobalint1100 5 років тому +38

      Dude! Do you speak music? There’s no such thing as a 5/31... what about a 19/16?

    • @aleksmonoxide2910
      @aleksmonoxide2910 5 років тому +34

      It’s a very unknown time signature. See the beginning of the video xD and yes 19/16 is great

    • @alexandermueller4115
      @alexandermueller4115 5 років тому +25

      Alex Monoxide 5/31 is not possible, seeing as there is no such thing as a 31st note.

    • @brysonrichey6707
      @brysonrichey6707 5 років тому +34

      Alexander Mueller what do you mean, of course there are. Trust me, I play Dillinger Escape Plan on drums.

    • @DavidNwokoye
      @DavidNwokoye 5 років тому +41

      *Laughs in Tosin Abasi*

  • @ellistheshredlord8077
    @ellistheshredlord8077 5 років тому +605

    Solo over the clean part
    "There are never too many notes" riffs
    Ominous piano over heavy riff
    String intro
    Out of genre section
    Transcribed classical pieces

    • @shredmcfingers9342
      @shredmcfingers9342 5 років тому +41

      Also, guitarist singing and shredding while drumming

    • @thalloutboy
      @thalloutboy 5 років тому +10

      Ellis the ShredLord “Ominous piano over heavy riff”
      BTBAM where you at?

    • @Proggish
      @Proggish 5 років тому +8

      @@thalloutboy hell add the "out of genre section" for some BTBAM lol

    • @usaflagraybans
      @usaflagraybans 5 років тому +1

      Shred McFingers I didn’t know Rob Scallon was such a huge part of the prog community.

    • @ellistheshredlord8077
      @ellistheshredlord8077 5 років тому +3

      @@thalloutboy Persefone mastered doing though

  • @JacobMartin
    @JacobMartin 5 років тому +720

    Not sure what’s more impressive, the guitar skills or remembering all of those patreons off the top of your head goddamn 😂

    • @aleksmonoxide2910
      @aleksmonoxide2910 5 років тому +2

      Jacob Martin Right? XD

    • @bainmack
      @bainmack 5 років тому +3

      truth.

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +99

      It probably takes me over an hour each time, gotta show my patrons the luv

    • @yvancluet8146
      @yvancluet8146 5 років тому +11

      if you can remember the time changes to dance of eternity you can certainly remember 40 names

    • @Dipper1459
      @Dipper1459 5 років тому +3

      That's some Rain Man shit

  • @depousinho
    @depousinho 5 років тому +252

    Where are the modern "djenty" syncopations??? WHERE ARE THEM????

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +32

      Gabri Fuentes We used those in our Djent stereotype vid :)

    • @MichaelWeizenfeld
      @MichaelWeizenfeld 5 років тому

      I didn't heard djent in progmetal, maybe in the last album of Myrath.

    • @Zepla
      @Zepla 4 роки тому +4

      @@MichaelWeizenfeld djents a subdivision of prog

    • @kaelanmcalpine2011
      @kaelanmcalpine2011 3 роки тому

      @@Zepla So all Djent is secretly Rush?

  • @dannythejester
    @dannythejester 5 років тому +1051

    Master Of Time= John Petrucci
    Spider Hands= John Petrucci
    Above The Flying & You= Every Dream Theater Song
    Synth Theater= Dream Theater
    The Feels Are Reals= Almost All Dream Theater Song Before The Solo
    "Yeah Just Throw A Solo On Top"= John Petrucci
    The Synth Solo= Breaking All Illusions And More Songs
    Every Stereotype Of Prog Metal Is Dream Theater
    *Change My Mind*

    • @Giltindor
      @Giltindor 5 років тому +63

      Well...
      There is a lot of guitarist as good as John Petrucci ;) .
      Tosin Abasi,
      Bumblefoot,
      Mattias IA Eklundh,
      Every technical death metal band guitarist,
      ...
      :-P

    • @Abasedbymygrief
      @Abasedbymygrief 5 років тому +151

      Above The Flying & You is literally a pun on Between The Buried And Me you pleb 😤

    • @jessepinkeye2339
      @jessepinkeye2339 5 років тому +72

      Pass the TOOL- John Petrucci
      Amirite?

    • @NicklausSIR2
      @NicklausSIR2 5 років тому +9

      @@Abasedbymygrief ...I love BTBAM and I totally didn't spot that one :o

    • @NicklausSIR2
      @NicklausSIR2 5 років тому +49

      Well, no matter if you love or hate them, DT are the ones who set all those trends and defined a lot in the genre.

  • @charleslesorcier5028
    @charleslesorcier5028 4 роки тому +104

    "Where is the snare?" Sounds like Vicarious-Tool.

    • @m0th543
      @m0th543 4 роки тому +3

      It does!

  • @18FrozenAngels
    @18FrozenAngels 5 років тому +127

    The BTBAM pun was perfect for the long song section.

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +5

      Jesus_the_frog42 ^^ Andrew knows well

    • @joshstiehl1170
      @joshstiehl1170 5 років тому +5

      But ants of the sky is amazazing

  • @Forest_V19
    @Forest_V19 5 років тому +159

    It really shows that you care about your patrons. You literally memorized THAT many names. If I were a religious man, I’d say bless your soul.

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +20

      Akahoshi Thank you! Gotta show them the love

    • @henriquemontalvao8492
      @henriquemontalvao8492 5 років тому +10

      @@NikNocturnal Bless your soul bro.

    • @irti_pk
      @irti_pk 5 років тому +9

      I'll say it for you. Bless his soul.

  • @studioofshred1050
    @studioofshred1050 5 років тому +430

    been listening to prog so long that all this stuff is just a given, my bandmates always get on me for writing "weird" stuff lol, but to me its just music

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +33

      STUDIO OF SHRED I love weird stuff

    • @admatlydian
      @admatlydian 5 років тому

      Finally! My user name has meaning! Get WEIRD! Just do it!

    • @marioi.carrillo6264
      @marioi.carrillo6264 5 років тому +4

      Lol same here. I make weird and utterly non-sensincal Electronic things and my friends always seems to dislike everything I do. And I don't know if that's good or bad. But I like what I do so fuck it.

    • @gq._.guitar9613
      @gq._.guitar9613 5 років тому +2

      My band mates are prog and I’m thrash aka 4/4 whore, doesn’t work too well

    • @alfonzog6327
      @alfonzog6327 2 роки тому

      God, I know the feeling
      *only* time signature that still sounds weird to me is 11/8

  • @jeversilveira8904
    @jeversilveira8904 5 років тому +73

    Andrew's Tool needs more hammer-ons and pull-offs

  • @tarkenton3895
    @tarkenton3895 5 років тому +200

    You forgot "That Jazz Section" and "Insta-Prog" (add9 power chords)

    • @T114466
      @T114466 5 років тому +6

      Tarkenton add9 power chord is the same as sus2 chord, isn’t it?

    • @tarkenton3895
      @tarkenton3895 5 років тому +7

      @@T114466 right you are

    • @paulferguson1074
      @paulferguson1074 5 років тому +1

      What are some prog bands that add a lot of jazz?

    • @thalloutboy
      @thalloutboy 5 років тому

      Paul Ferguson Do you mean bands that incorporate jazz into their regular sound or bands that include jazz breaks in songs?

    • @paulferguson1074
      @paulferguson1074 5 років тому +2

      @@thalloutboy Bands that include jazz breaks

  • @yvancluet8146
    @yvancluet8146 5 років тому +41

    also the
    "yeah it's kinda death metal with syncopated 8 strings riffs but how about a carnival acapella fugue part"

    • @MattxxMatt
      @MattxxMatt 4 роки тому

      Yvan Cluet aka BTBAM - Voice of Trespass.

  • @josephvanni
    @josephvanni 5 років тому +203

    I almost thought this was a BTBAM cover

    • @VOYAGEUR-YT
      @VOYAGEUR-YT 5 років тому +21

      Seeing them tomorrow. Fucking pumped

    • @themadminuteman
      @themadminuteman 5 років тому

      lol this^^

    • @DiePixelkrieger
      @DiePixelkrieger 5 років тому +4

      Theyre awesome, enjoy the show

    • @insertname8889
      @insertname8889 5 років тому +1

      Good you're so fucking lucky
      They'll never come here in Italy

    • @norlanderduwallis9074
      @norlanderduwallis9074 4 роки тому +1

      @@VOYAGEUR-YT I saw em like three months ago, didn't like them from the recordings, now I love them. What an awesome show dude.

  • @greysinclaire
    @greysinclaire 5 років тому +90

    "Did he even Berkley"😂

  • @pronathan92002
    @pronathan92002 5 років тому +14

    This video not only demonstrates the prog stereotypes, but also the difference between 30 and 60 fps.

  • @phantomtearsca
    @phantomtearsca 5 років тому +56

    Post-hardcore or hardcore punk stereotypes next?

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +17

      AFSD I don’t think my landlord would like me smashing walls

  • @beyondin
    @beyondin 5 років тому +45

    Synth Theater lmao. The names are amazing

  • @zacharymosley1523
    @zacharymosley1523 5 років тому +82

    Personally, I favorite time signature is 19.39/74. I'm sure you heard that one in BTBAM's "Mordecai".

    • @FluffyHippos5692
      @FluffyHippos5692 4 роки тому +6

      Zachary Mosley i dunno man I prefer -34^2/34y79

  • @Crocodonk
    @Crocodonk 4 роки тому +46

    Another stereotype I see a lot is guitarists looking bored while playing.

    • @tomasrodrioguezmoser8400
      @tomasrodrioguezmoser8400 4 роки тому +5

      Well, it’s kinda difficult to look excited while playing 12 min songs xd

    • @kaelanmcalpine2011
      @kaelanmcalpine2011 3 роки тому +3

      @@tomasrodrioguezmoser8400 I mean, Kirk Hammet got tired after playing a 9 minute song alot. Though in his defense, And Justice For All doesn't sound nearly as fun as say Dream Theater or BTBAM would to play.

  • @pinkponyofprey1965
    @pinkponyofprey1965 4 роки тому +4

    "That clean part" was a relief when there was no James LaCheese vibrating away like there's no tomorrow.

  • @giorgiomatraxiamusic4874
    @giorgiomatraxiamusic4874 5 років тому +16

    2:01 Nailed Dream Theater's style!!🔥🔥🔥
    Ps: That riff sounded a bit like Bridges in The Sky

  • @firkinja
    @firkinja 4 роки тому +2

    My favorite is the one where there are like zero dynamic changes in three songs in a row on an album then the next song has an acoustic guitar so it’s “quieter,” but I love it anyway.

  • @crowing3886
    @crowing3886 5 років тому +24

    "Above the flying an you"
    Between the buried an me wants to know your location!

  • @theknifesedge57
    @theknifesedge57 5 років тому +86

    2 things
    1) you forgot ridiculously high straps
    2) my brother says you look like you run off 2 hours of sleep per month and are fueled by coffee
    Great vid 🤘

    • @SubBubz
      @SubBubz 5 років тому +1

      It's the thumbnail, lol.

    • @mattbecker743
      @mattbecker743 4 роки тому +1

      High guitars do improve your ability to play. Allows for better technique, closer to that when you're sitting and playing.

  • @synystergaties6396
    @synystergaties6396 5 років тому +17

    You should do a video on stereotypical post breakdowns! Love the vids man keep up the great work!

  • @TheNorthernJake
    @TheNorthernJake 5 років тому +1

    EXCITED FOR PART 2!

  • @lauronamieltoral462
    @lauronamieltoral462 5 років тому +187

    Please do Thrash or Black Metal Stereotypes

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  5 років тому +53

      Lauron Amiel Toral I don’t know if my neighbours would like me summoning satan for a youtube video

    • @wiktorcichobazinski5175
      @wiktorcichobazinski5175 5 років тому

      I know I would

    • @samkoch4829
      @samkoch4829 5 років тому +6

      Nik Nocturnal can you do power metal stereotypes

    • @justinesdepiscis343
      @justinesdepiscis343 5 років тому +1

      @@NikNocturnal screw neighbours

    • @miguelbarahona6636
      @miguelbarahona6636 5 років тому

      @@NikNocturnal summoning the Devil, well, that's the first stereotype

  • @lucarzewski3455
    @lucarzewski3455 4 роки тому

    Is it wrong that literally every single one of these little snippets excited me? Like if these were all actual songs I’d be tracking them all down instantly

  • @liambenn1214
    @liambenn1214 5 років тому +1

    Bruh “above the flying & you” is the best between the buried and me impression I’ve ever seen

  • @BrandonGetty
    @BrandonGetty 5 років тому +2

    Glad to see Baena on here!!!

  • @ironpeeb
    @ironpeeb 5 років тому +1

    Wow, this was a great video, I'm amazed every time I come to this channel to see so many genres portrayed in such funny and clever ways, it boggles my mind how you stay fresh. Keep doing what you do man!

  • @zr00we64
    @zr00we64 5 років тому +18

    Yes! My genera. I love prog metal!
    I cannot express the happeness thus brings me
    The weird time signatures, key changes, and long songs are what makes a prog song

  • @ws8672
    @ws8672 5 років тому +1

    Synth theater was dope. Would be cool to hear a full song with that one.

  • @samkoch4829
    @samkoch4829 5 років тому +51

    This whole thing is dream theater in a nut shell

    • @SaintTrinasTorch
      @SaintTrinasTorch 5 років тому +8

      Dream Shell Nut Theater

    • @rosev.7007
      @rosev.7007 5 років тому +2

      They pioneered the genre so

    • @samkoch4829
      @samkoch4829 5 років тому +1

      Keyser Soze I believe rush was first for prog

    • @sharpstick8674
      @sharpstick8674 5 років тому +13

      Dream Theater pioneered prog metal. If we talking just prog, you're gonna have to go further back than Rush, my guy

    • @rosev.7007
      @rosev.7007 5 років тому +1

      @@sharpstick8674 correct

  • @unamericano
    @unamericano 5 років тому +1

    That synth solo at 2:45 was actually pretty good

  • @Hellion6325
    @Hellion6325 5 років тому +3

    "Where is the snare?" is a game I play whenever I listen to Tesseract.. lol

  • @drductape
    @drductape 5 років тому +1

    Thanks for the tips!

  • @PaulKingMetal
    @PaulKingMetal 5 років тому

    Awesome as always bro!

  • @blckspce7683
    @blckspce7683 5 років тому +3

    I hear Prog Metal I cry 9 minutes long in 6/9 changing tempos

  • @asenovbruh8575
    @asenovbruh8575 4 роки тому +2

    To be honest this was all fking dream theater

  • @deepsolar169
    @deepsolar169 5 років тому

    Oh thank you very much! I love it!

  • @shredmcfingers9342
    @shredmcfingers9342 5 років тому +8

    Lastly, just slap a bunch of notes in solos and drum at the same time

  • @elliottlazary8207
    @elliottlazary8207 5 років тому +2

    Synth theatre sounds and feels are reals sounds a lot like dream theatre

  • @brenjmorris
    @brenjmorris 2 роки тому +1

    well im gonna be using all of these
    no, really

  • @Fishfishfishfishfishfishfishfi
    @Fishfishfishfishfishfishfishfi 4 роки тому

    The throw the solo on top one has never described Mastodon better

  • @TYFLOL
    @TYFLOL 5 років тому

    wait, Andrew finally got his production together, this sounds way better than his previous videos!

  • @animal1439
    @animal1439 5 років тому +1

    Love that he is playing on a majesty guitar :)

  • @SaintTrinasTorch
    @SaintTrinasTorch 5 років тому +30

    Synth solo? Sounds alot like Rammstein. 🤔😁

  • @dixinears8004
    @dixinears8004 5 років тому

    There were some really great riffs here!

  • @ilay829
    @ilay829 Рік тому

    The where is the snare one got me the hardest since all of the other ones are well known.

  • @JimiHL
    @JimiHL 4 роки тому +1

    My davorite part of the video was that Petrucci guitar. Nice

  • @noelrenteria2347
    @noelrenteria2347 5 років тому +1

    the synth theater was hard tho 🔥😂

  • @sangeetsing128
    @sangeetsing128 5 років тому

    Amazing work guys

  • @PNWZach
    @PNWZach 5 років тому +2

    Between the buried and me reference. I love them haha.

  • @BungCentra
    @BungCentra 4 роки тому +2

    1:10 is literally just the Vicarious riff. Sounds cool

  • @thewolfden4680
    @thewolfden4680 4 роки тому

    The synth part was super children of bodem lol..I gotta start patreon for u man.foreal.the only youtuber I'd have no problem giving "back" to🤘🖤🤘

  • @cime62
    @cime62 5 років тому +7

    1:36 i want a full song with that

  • @ccdrums5312
    @ccdrums5312 5 років тому

    Nice shot at between the buried and me. Actually laughed at the accuracy

  • @nabilcapillaire3362
    @nabilcapillaire3362 5 років тому

    Simply Awesome!

  • @mitcheldenhartog1886
    @mitcheldenhartog1886 5 років тому

    Superfluous tempo changes are my morning coffee

  • @gh0stdem0n666
    @gh0stdem0n666 5 років тому +6

    My face during the patreon names 😦😧😵

  • @brianmesser8924
    @brianmesser8924 5 років тому +1

    Patterns based on some kind of math formula. Like Pi by After the Burial.

  • @WesleyKhalil
    @WesleyKhalil 5 років тому

    Spider Hands was the first surprise I’ve encountered trying to play Opeth

  • @monsi6663
    @monsi6663 5 років тому +1

    beautiful Guitar , Love this Band and John Petrucci

  • @thehalfblood9559
    @thehalfblood9559 4 роки тому

    I think there is something to add. that's amazing parts of tapping

  • @denisorourke4444
    @denisorourke4444 4 роки тому +2

    Dude, that 7-string Musicman is *badass.*

  • @roccobierman4985
    @roccobierman4985 5 років тому +1

    Spider Hands and The Feels are Real are my ear candy.

  • @Lectwar6
    @Lectwar6 5 років тому

    The new Between the Buried and Me documentary is coming along nicely

  • @thatclemsonfandudeguymanwo7234
    @thatclemsonfandudeguymanwo7234 5 років тому

    Well that was fun seeing you 2 together in a video you guys are great

  • @Warriorz1979
    @Warriorz1979 4 роки тому

    That synth solo was badass

  • @Jamfjr
    @Jamfjr 5 років тому

    The playing the same riff in any metal prog sounds like some sort of warmup lol

  • @DNMii
    @DNMii 5 років тому

    Yo that last synth solo actually sounded really cool lmao

  • @fracturebeats1273
    @fracturebeats1273 5 років тому +2

    You forgot the “odd time breakdown but the drummer keeps playing in 4/4”

  • @neonblack211
    @neonblack211 4 роки тому

    Omg you’re like Jared Dines, subscribed! Oh patreon? Take my money! oh t shirts, where do you come up with these crazy ideas and crazy stuff?

  • @polarthus175
    @polarthus175 5 років тому

    Man I love your intro sooo much

  • @kenconify
    @kenconify 5 років тому +1

    Pretty sick gojira cover boys

  • @joelco92
    @joelco92 4 роки тому

    Damn dude, most the riffs you use in these videos could be part of a song on their own. And I would dig it. Creative shit.

  • @andresromero3127
    @andresromero3127 4 роки тому

    The fact he used a Majesty guitar is amazing

  • @it_is_meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    @it_is_meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee 4 роки тому

    I got an ad for a prog metal song right before this video. Can confirm stereotypes are accurate

  • @bailey5924
    @bailey5924 5 років тому

    "yeah, just throw a solo on top" is too real, and I've been the one to do the solo in that situation. At least you made it sound cool here xD

  • @nirvand7431
    @nirvand7431 5 років тому +1

    "The Feels Are Real" (that clean part) - so basically old, progressive death metal era Opeth?

  • @YuriRadavchuk
    @YuriRadavchuk 5 років тому +2

    Thisnwas hilarious. More prog related content

  • @hsjdjjcjfdheuxyh5282
    @hsjdjjcjfdheuxyh5282 5 років тому +1

    Oh jesus, synth theater 2:02 was incredible...I wanna here whole song like this !!!

  • @RghtBrnd
    @RghtBrnd 5 років тому

    Love the Vicarious nod.

  • @ShroomRPG
    @ShroomRPG 5 років тому +3

    Is it bad that I love literally all of these cliches lmao

  • @jordanadams7129
    @jordanadams7129 4 роки тому +1

    Throw a solo on top is literally animals as leaders lol

  • @ethanj.9271
    @ethanj.9271 5 років тому

    Great vid Nic, have a great day.👏🏼👏🏼😁

  • @nisus_drums
    @nisus_drums 4 роки тому

    As a Drummer, I love moving the snare in order to create polirythms with cymbals and kick, and viceversa

  • @hankhill2940
    @hankhill2940 5 років тому +1

    The spider hands and music man majesty made me think you were John petrucci for a second 😂
    And the synth theater

  • @jalenali684
    @jalenali684 5 років тому +2

    Oh my god
    “That Clean part” 😂

  • @nickp3949
    @nickp3949 5 років тому

    The long song one felt like a personal attack

  • @kenlee5015
    @kenlee5015 5 років тому

    New band name for the YT age Patreoni, and you deserve it after that roll of the tongue.

  • @AltWaveResearch
    @AltWaveResearch 4 роки тому

    Bro those time signatures at 0:55 was fucking awesome.
    Great idea for a song.

  • @coreyw5981
    @coreyw5981 5 років тому

    Granted "where's the snare?" Is hilarious and true, the example used was so easy of snare part

  • @psychosalad6653
    @psychosalad6653 4 роки тому

    Need a full version of The Key Chain!