This video inspired confidence in my purchase! I just broke below the 250 mark-down from 319 and this seat (H2) was something I tied to my weight loss goal. I just ordered it yesterday and can’t wait to try it out! Thank you VERY much for such a common sense video!
CONGRATS!!! On such a massive loss! Takes. a tremendous amount of discipline to achieve that no matter the method you chose. Just remember, this seat is different than all others and you're likely going to have to play with its positions significantly to find your sweet-spot. Best of Luck and ride safe! BigSarge
Hi Charles! Thank You for commenting and rest assured, you will not be disappointed with the saddle once you find the magic position [The Sweet Spot]. Just remember that it's positioning is quite different than other saddles so it's recommended that you go to your local bike shop and have them do a basic fit with you on your bike with the saddle! Afterwards, is when you play with the tiniest measurements up/down, forward/back until you find what feels best. It may take several rides and adjustments before figuring it out but once you got it YOU'LL KNOW IT! Best of luck and stay safe out there!
Ooooops, sorry for the confusion Charles! Dude on The Piano is me. When I tried to reply from the email notification but it logged in to UA-cam under my other profile.
I know exactly what you mean! I thought my Brooks B17 was good (and I never got it broken in), but after switching to the Seller it brought a whole new pleasure to my riding. Enjoy that saddle, it will serve you right for a loooooonnnng time.
Thanks for the review. I own five Selle Anatomica X's. One note, looking at yours it appears you need to adjust the tension screw. You should always maintain 1/8" to 1/4" of space in that middle opening slot toward the rear of the seat just before it opens to that wide ending. Your slot sides in that area, appear to be, or are very close to touching in the video. From my experience the first few hundred miles on an X requires frequent tightening. After that very rarely. This aforementioned procedure will keep the saddle from sagging or getting that hammock look. Also, since your weight is above the X's spec, you could consider their new X2 saddles that just came out which are a little bit stiffer leather. Or if you have the cash the new carbon model is probably nice too. I'm 155lbs so the original X's are perfect for me. Thanks again for the review video. Always nice to see others who appreciate a good saddle.
Don B - Thank You Don! You are correct and thanks for pointing that out. I did adjust it the next day after posting this as when I did the video I had just finished riding and wasn't sure if it was wise to do it then or wait until I was sure it was dry. I'm afraid of the carbon since the Brooks B17 hurt. I will consider the newer X model though but I am very happy with this one still. Ride safe!
This man has worked so hard at getting a comfortably fitting saddle, and not a little money, either... I am so pleased he eventually got what he had earned.. (shall I say, the "hard" way?) ....
I went and bought the new H2 model-- for those of us at the 200+ lbs range for my Brompton, i just received it, took it apart and did some measurements just for curiosity. I commute around 40 odds miles per day (80km exact door-to-door and back) I'm HOPING that this will allow me to ride without padding. Thanks for the upload!
Congrats on your purchase Thomas! If you're putting in that many miles each day you should really have no issues going without padding with the Selle. Just keep in mind that MILLIMETERS COUNT when adjusting your saddle and I've learned that even after having my bike shop do a good bike fit I still needed to tweak the adjustments to fit my body position / weight / and style of riding. You may fare even better by doing the tiny adjustments on the fly since you're covering enough miles on each ride to really feel the difference. Good Luck and Ride Safe!!!
BigSarge Thank you! I really hope so. I just spent an hour doing initial setup, though i am finding it uncomfortable to have it at nose up position as recommended by manufacturer. I have it down to about level now so i will see how it goes tomorrow. Looks like i will need to carry the tools since the 6mm gap quickly shrinks-i had to tighten it about 4 times in 7 miles.
Just a thought. . .the Selle is a quite different style of saddle so when you're adjusting for comfort you may want to consider the sliding the saddle forward or backward as well since the recommended tilt really adds a whole new dimension to saddle positioning. The tilt was unbearable to me at first as well. Very small increments should help determine the correct position for you. Whatever you do please exhaust all avenues before throwing in the towel. It will be well worth it once you find that sweet spot. Good Luck!
I'm glad to hear you found something that works for you. I bought a Brooks Flyer two years ago and went through a similar experience. When I put the nose flat, I found myself sliding forward as I rode. When I pushed the nose up further, it became very uncomfortable. I had to make minor adjustments to get the nose to the right height. Also, the leather was VERY hard at first and I had a lot of red abrasions on the skin covering the sit bones, even after short rides. I almost gave up on it, but after months of trying and a lot of oil, the saddle broke in and is comfortable now. This one works for me and I"m going to stay with it until it becomes uncomfortable.
Keefe Borden - Hi Keefe, glad you worked it out with the Brooks. I still have my B17 and will eventually take another stab at getting it broke in. I was afraid of putting excessive amounts of their oil on it but will probably opt for that route. How many miles would you guestimate you put on it before it finally broke-in. It is likely I just haven't gotten the necessary miles on it yet but being 280 pounds one would think that would help speed up break in.
THanks for the reply. I honestly don't know how many miles I put in, but I would estimate about 200 or maybe a few more... I don't think it really started softening up until I used copious amounts of neetsfoot oil. I don't use that anymore because I really don't want the leather to soften up anymore than it already has. I plan to switch to Sno Seal next, which is a product based on beeswax. My impression is that saddles are somewhat personal and that what works for one person may not work for the next. I'll stay with the Brooks as long as it remains comfortable, but I don't necessarily consider myself a Brooks aficionado yet. It's always good to know what the alternatives are.
Thanks Keefe! Since I can't even contemplate tossing my Brooks Saddle (since it cost a pretty penny) I think I'll give the neetsfoot oil a try and massage it into the seat to see if it softens up more. I unfortunately only have one bicycle so I ended up purchasing another seat post because my plan was to use one seat for training and the other for the local rides I paid go on. That way I was assured I didn't screw up the placement when I switched seats. Also, Brooks has such a long and proven history I'd be foolish to give up the seat when I can possibly pass it down to family in the future. Good Luck and Ride Safe!!! (and thanks for posting)
I'm waiting on my Selle Anatomica R2 rubber saddle to arrive in the mail. I'm 6'1", 240lbs, and my road bike's stock seat is giving me numbness "down there"! Not good. The R2 is rated up to 250lbs. That's a huge selling point, especially out here in Japan where most things are made for ppl under-170 pounds . It's hard to know from reviews whether I will like the new seat or not. But, Selle's website has a "GARAGE SALE" section, and I was lucky to find a used saddle for $80. If I like the design, maybe next time I'll try leather?
Jeff Caudle - Thank You for watching and for your comment. I will be adding another video for it soon addressing using the seat on an indoor trainer as opposed to outdoors on the road. Remember to have a bike fit done to ensure the best experience. Even then you may still end up doing micro adjustments until satisfied. Good luck and ride safe.
jazz time - I had it done at Bicycle Village in Colorado Springs because that's where I purchased the bike and the are excellent. Did a little more than basic fits for me at least 4 or 5 different times as I was trying new seats over a few years. Professional Fit had cost about $150 a couple of years ago but I never did it. I am also a frequent buyer as I've purchased at least 4 or 5 bikes from them for my family but I'm the only one who really rides. Basic fit usually will do the trick for us casual riders ensuring we don't injure ourselves with an improperly fitted bike. Best of luck to you and thanks for watching!!!
This video is as much a fantastic instructional video as a review. I've played with saddles for what seems like forever because of sore sit bones and ended up, to my surprise, with a Selle SMP Glider. They are somewhat ugly but I don't use it for looks. :-) Here's the catch: I'm older and have neck issues. Therefore I need to sit in a more upright relaxed position. Looking at BigSarge's bike and the stem, its set up similar to mine. In fact, if it's a Roubaix, we have the same bike. :-) Most bike fitters seem to dismiss seat angle as connected to torso angle. As you rotate your body to a more upright position, your sit bones will rotate and follow. Therefore your saddle has to follow as well. I noted in the video how the saddle nose is pointed "up" which is what caught my attention. Using a level and documenting seat angle, I've adjusted my seat numerous times to find that sweet spot and now ride pain-free. At 5'11," and 160 pounds I am not a heavy cyclist. Perhaps without knowing it, BigSarge created a video for everyone and not just for someone who is big or for the Selle Anatomica. I went through the same thing with the same discovery: That seat angle is everything and the harder the seat, the more pronounced the problem is. If you still have saddle pain after following this video, I'd advise that its not the saddle. It can be chaffing from shorts as well. I use to use a name brand short and don't anymore because the chamois has tiny perforations in it (for breathability?) that abraided my skin. Now I use a less expensive brand with a smooth chamois and a channel down the middle to protect the private parts from rubbing,... and chamois butter. I typically ride 60 to 100 miles at a time on the weekends pain-free. Great video. Thumbs up! Final note: I wouldn't recommend the Selle SMP Glider because while it worked for me, it cost way too much and there are other options that cost far less. It should have a Gucci badge on it. It also had a since repaired problem with creaking that has now been resolved using Loc-tite on the rail clamps. It came that way from the factory twice and I am not the only one with this SMP problem. I found a video on UA-cam by a poster with the same issue.
Thanks for the great review, as a larger ride (5’9”, 250lbs) who does a lot of Randonneuring, I am finding that my 14 year old Terry Men’s saddle is pretty much unbearable on Brevets over 300k, and have been considering a Brooks, but I think I’ll be giving a Selle a try. Nothing keeps you off a bike more than a few sq. Inches of sever chaffing.
BigSarge, Just wanted to thank you for your video. Based on your commentary I purchase the Selle Anatomica H2. I'm 6ft at 220lb, been cycling just under 3 years and after 3 bike fits & my 4th saddles I'm still having discomfort & pain after long ride. For the last 6 months I've been riding with the Infinity saddle, its a nice saddle, but as it relieve the sit bone pain the outer perimeter of the saddle wears on the buttock soft tissue. But again I can't to get my H2 saddle and start sing it praises.
any updates? i was considering the infinity but im interested in the selle anatomica also. any thoughts or comparisons or conclusions drawn between the 2?
Hi Craig, I've never experienced any staining whatsoever from my Anatomica. Also, I've never used any conditioners, saddle soap, or leather was on the seat. . .ever! The seat has performed flawlessly out-the-box ever since I purchased it. However, my average rides usually don't last longer than 15 miles or so. The longest I've done on this saddle was the 62 mile Elephant Rock Bike Ride here in Castle Rock, Colorado. Even then, no staining issues. It could be that I just have exceptional padding in my cycling shorts that the sweat doesn't really pass thru to the seat (but doubtful). I just know that when I get off the bike I never have a 'noticeably' wet seat. I did notice the wetness on my Brooks saddle but even then, no staining (and I used loads of conditioner on that seat). Anyway, if you're one of the hard-core riders that ride without cycling shorts (padding) then maybe you could try switching out to cycling shorts. Other than that I'm not sure what the issue could be. Ride Safe and enjoy the journey!!!
Thanks for the info!! It was usually only on some of the longer rides... I actually swapped out the saddle for a few days, then realized stain or not, its the most comfortable saddle I ever rode and put it right back on (after letting it bake for a full day in the sun ) Keep on Pedalin'! - craig in Cleveland
Hmmm now you’ve got me thinking. I just got one of these and went for a fairly long ride on it the other day and couldn’t quite get comfortable on it, preferring the Brooks B17’s on my other bikes. I put it up for sale yesterday but after watching this I’m thinking maybe I should give it another go. I’m about 250 pounds. I’ve also found that the Brooks B17 didn’t take very long at all to break in. I really wanted to love the Anatomica X because it looks great on my hardtail mountain bike. Now I’m confused.
Dean Herde - Hi Dean, thanks for viewing and posting. I believe you've got to play with the Seller a bit to find the correct sweet spot. Since the nose is supposed to tilt up a bit it really is a different fit from any other saddle. Centimeters really count here so please give it another go. Could be that you're just too hardcore and don't have a need for the Selle's fit. If/once you find the spot it will be a night and day difference. Good Luck!
Greatestmnalive hey thanks very much for your reply buddy. You’ve inspired me and I’m going to give it another go. I’m glad I found your video. Seems like very good timing. Hope you’re having great rides. Appreciate your advice.
You're welcome Dean! Please update us later after you've put in a few rides and tell us how it's working out for you. I haven't been on the bike in a while since I've been dabbling in adventure motorcycling and trying to get familiar with that sport. I plan to jump back into the saddle here in the next couple of weeks now that the weather is breaking here in Colorado. Just remember, cycling can easily turn into a passion once your butt and body get used to it so please (if you haven't already) be sure to get a bike fit done because it is infinitely important to your riding to prevent injury that can lay you up for weeks. Good Luck and Ride Safe!!!
BigSarge hi from Australia, just getting back to you about the Anatomica X. I took your advice and persisted with it. I'm very glad I did. Very comfortable, and I've done some long off road rides, about 50 kilometres on my Cotic Soul Hardtail mountain bike. I noticed that I told you I weighed 250 pounds back then. Well I'm 235 now so yeah, I've been riding a fair bit. Thanks again for telling me to stick with the sadd give it a chance.
Dean Herde Now that's some great news Dean. I applaud you for giving it another go and more time. I can imagine the smile on your face now that you're getting the time in the saddle that you want. Did you tweak your diet any or is the riding causing you to drop pounds like that?
I just got an H2 saddle. I've just got done with several 40+ mile rides and my gonads hurt too. How did you go about adjusting the tilt? Did you start at the recommended 1/4"-1/8" nose up recommendation and adjust it down from there or did you find you needed to tilt it nose up even more?
@David - my apologies for not seeing this sooner! I haven't been monitoring this site and am now seeing that there are several comments with questions. Yes, I started with the recommended position. I had a bike fit done first then proceeded to tilt it up. Afterwards I simply adjusted the tilt in very movements until arriving at the final position. It did take several rides though to figure out what worked. Good Luck and ride safe!
Hi Ca4Gochops, sorry but I don't remember Seller having an Aged color (like Brooks does) but this one is lighter in color than the Brooks Aged saddle and no, mine hasn't darkened at all since I've had it and I have never used any leather conditioners or cleaners on it. However, I'm not a go-hard rider by any measure and I rarely have gotten caught in heavy rain. Ride safe and good luck!
That's correct! However, I don't think that H model existed when I purchased the X. I may be wrong but I remember looking thru all of their saddles before making the X purchase. Thanks for responding and ride safe!☺️
This video inspired confidence in my purchase! I just broke below the 250 mark-down from 319 and this seat (H2) was something I tied to my weight loss goal. I just ordered it yesterday and can’t wait to try it out! Thank you VERY much for such a common sense video!
CONGRATS!!! On such a massive loss! Takes. a tremendous amount of discipline to achieve that no matter the method you chose. Just remember, this seat is different than all others and you're likely going to have to play with its positions significantly to find your sweet-spot. Best of Luck and ride safe! BigSarge
6' 2", 230#, and thanking you right now.
Completely agree. I am 6'3 ,300lb and just switched over to their H2 model for heavier riders. Night and day difference.
Bought one rode it 10 miles, ordered another for my wife. Now ordering a third for my road bike. No break in, awesome!
How is it holding up? I've heard some people having trouble with it stretching and sagging over time.
Thanks for taking the time to make this, just ordered one because of your review..
Hi Charles! Thank You for commenting and rest assured, you will not be disappointed with the saddle once you find the magic position [The Sweet Spot]. Just remember that it's positioning is quite different than other saddles so it's recommended that you go to your local bike shop and have them do a basic fit with you on your bike with the saddle! Afterwards, is when you play with the tiniest measurements up/down, forward/back until you find what feels best. It may take several rides and adjustments before figuring it out but once you got it YOU'LL KNOW IT! Best of luck and stay safe out there!
Ooooops, sorry for the confusion Charles! Dude on The Piano is me. When I tried to reply from the email notification but it logged in to UA-cam under my other profile.
I have the H and love it!
5'11 and 240 - I have one on my gravel bike, but started Zwifting indoors and just got a new one for the old Trek 1200. Oh what a difference it makes!
I know exactly what you mean! I thought my Brooks B17 was good (and I never got it broken in), but after switching to the Seller it brought a whole new pleasure to my riding. Enjoy that saddle, it will serve you right for a loooooonnnng time.
Most comfortable saddle I've owned
Thanks for the review. I own five Selle Anatomica X's. One note, looking at yours it appears you need to adjust the tension screw. You should always maintain 1/8" to 1/4" of space in that middle opening slot toward the rear of the seat just before it opens to that wide ending. Your slot sides in that area, appear to be, or are very close to touching in the video. From my experience the first few hundred miles on an X requires frequent tightening. After that very rarely. This aforementioned procedure will keep the saddle from sagging or getting that hammock look.
Also, since your weight is above the X's spec, you could consider their new X2 saddles that just came out which are a little bit stiffer leather. Or if you have the cash the new carbon model is probably nice too. I'm 155lbs so the original X's are perfect for me.
Thanks again for the review video. Always nice to see others who appreciate a good saddle.
Don B - Thank You Don! You are correct and thanks for pointing that out. I did adjust it the next day after posting this as when I did the video I had just finished riding and wasn't sure if it was wise to do it then or wait until I was sure it was dry. I'm afraid of the carbon since the Brooks B17 hurt. I will consider the newer X model though but I am very happy with this one still. Ride safe!
This man has worked so hard at getting a comfortably fitting saddle, and not a little money, either... I am so pleased he eventually got what he had earned.. (shall I say, the "hard" way?)
....
The video I’ve been looking for, thanks!
I went and bought the new H2 model-- for those of us at the 200+ lbs range for my Brompton, i just received it, took it apart and did some measurements just for curiosity. I commute around 40 odds miles per day (80km exact door-to-door and back) I'm HOPING that this will allow me to ride without padding. Thanks for the upload!
Congrats on your purchase Thomas! If you're putting in that many miles each day you should really have no issues going without padding with the Selle. Just keep in mind that MILLIMETERS COUNT when adjusting your saddle and I've learned that even after having my bike shop do a good bike fit I still needed to tweak the adjustments to fit my body position / weight / and style of riding. You may fare even better by doing the tiny adjustments on the fly since you're covering enough miles on each ride to really feel the difference. Good Luck and Ride Safe!!!
BigSarge Thank you! I really hope so. I just spent an hour doing initial setup, though i am finding it uncomfortable to have it at nose up position as recommended by manufacturer. I have it down to about level now so i will see how it goes tomorrow. Looks like i will need to carry the tools since the 6mm gap quickly shrinks-i had to tighten it about 4 times in 7 miles.
Just a thought. . .the Selle is a quite different style of saddle so when you're adjusting for comfort you may want to consider the sliding the saddle forward or backward as well since the recommended tilt really adds a whole new dimension to saddle positioning. The tilt was unbearable to me at first as well. Very small increments should help determine the correct position for you. Whatever you do please exhaust all avenues before throwing in the towel. It will be well worth it once you find that sweet spot. Good Luck!
I'm glad to hear you found something that works for you. I bought a Brooks Flyer two years ago and went through a similar experience. When I put the nose flat, I found myself sliding forward as I rode. When I pushed the nose up further, it became very uncomfortable. I had to make minor adjustments to get the nose to the right height. Also, the leather was VERY hard at first and I had a lot of red abrasions on the skin covering the sit bones, even after short rides. I almost gave up on it, but after months of trying and a lot of oil, the saddle broke in and is comfortable now. This one works for me and I"m going to stay with it until it becomes uncomfortable.
Keefe Borden - Hi Keefe, glad you worked it out with the Brooks. I still have my B17 and will eventually take another stab at getting it broke in. I was afraid of putting excessive amounts of their oil on it but will probably opt for that route. How many miles would you guestimate you put on it before it finally broke-in. It is likely I just haven't gotten the necessary miles on it yet but being 280 pounds one would think that would help speed up break in.
THanks for the reply. I honestly don't know how many miles I put in, but I would estimate about 200 or maybe a few more... I don't think it really started softening up until I used copious amounts of neetsfoot oil. I don't use that anymore because I really don't want the leather to soften up anymore than it already has. I plan to switch to Sno Seal next, which is a product based on beeswax. My impression is that saddles are somewhat personal and that what works for one person may not work for the next. I'll stay with the Brooks as long as it remains comfortable, but I don't necessarily consider myself a Brooks aficionado yet. It's always good to know what the alternatives are.
Thanks Keefe! Since I can't even contemplate tossing my Brooks Saddle (since it cost a pretty penny) I think I'll give the neetsfoot oil a try and massage it into the seat to see if it softens up more. I unfortunately only have one bicycle so I ended up purchasing another seat post because my plan was to use one seat for training and the other for the local rides I paid go on. That way I was assured I didn't screw up the placement when I switched seats. Also, Brooks has such a long and proven history I'd be foolish to give up the seat when I can possibly pass it down to family in the future. Good Luck and Ride Safe!!! (and thanks for posting)
I'm waiting on my Selle Anatomica R2 rubber saddle to arrive in the mail. I'm 6'1", 240lbs, and my road bike's stock seat is giving me numbness "down there"! Not good. The R2 is rated up to 250lbs. That's a huge selling point, especially out here in Japan where most things are made for ppl under-170 pounds
.
It's hard to know from reviews whether I will like the new seat or not. But, Selle's website has a "GARAGE SALE" section, and I was lucky to find a used saddle for $80. If I like the design, maybe next time I'll try leather?
Thanks for posting this! Great video. Just bought my selle anatomica and my “gonads” look forward to many pain free rides!
Jeff Caudle - Thank You for watching and for your comment. I will be adding another video for it soon addressing using the seat on an indoor trainer as opposed to outdoors on the road. Remember to have a bike fit done to ensure the best experience. Even then you may still end up doing micro adjustments until satisfied. Good luck and ride safe.
BigSarge Awesome! I do most of my riding indoor on Zwift thanks to the Austin drivers so look forward to your next video for indoor riding. Be safe!
BigSarge may I ask where you had your fit done, I'm in Denver too, but don't want to spend $300 for it since I only ride touring bikes.
jazz time - I had it done at Bicycle Village in Colorado Springs because that's where I purchased the bike and the are excellent. Did a little more than basic fits for me at least 4 or 5 different times as I was trying new seats over a few years. Professional Fit had cost about $150 a couple of years ago but I never did it. I am also a frequent buyer as I've purchased at least 4 or 5 bikes from them for my family but I'm the only one who really rides. Basic fit usually will do the trick for us casual riders ensuring we don't injure ourselves with an improperly fitted bike. Best of luck to you and thanks for watching!!!
@@bigsarge8412
Excellent video 👍. How's the seat holding up?
This video is as much a fantastic instructional video as a review. I've played with saddles for what seems like forever because of sore sit bones and ended up, to my surprise, with a Selle SMP Glider. They are somewhat ugly but I don't use it for looks. :-) Here's the catch: I'm older and have neck issues. Therefore I need to sit in a more upright relaxed position. Looking at BigSarge's bike and the stem, its set up similar to mine. In fact, if it's a Roubaix, we have the same bike. :-) Most bike fitters seem to dismiss seat angle as connected to torso angle. As you rotate your body to a more upright position, your sit bones will rotate and follow. Therefore your saddle has to follow as well. I noted in the video how the saddle nose is pointed "up" which is what caught my attention. Using a level and documenting seat angle, I've adjusted my seat numerous times to find that sweet spot and now ride pain-free. At 5'11," and 160 pounds I am not a heavy cyclist. Perhaps without knowing it, BigSarge created a video for everyone and not just for someone who is big or for the Selle Anatomica. I went through the same thing with the same discovery: That seat angle is everything and the harder the seat, the more pronounced the problem is. If you still have saddle pain after following this video, I'd advise that its not the saddle. It can be chaffing from shorts as well. I use to use a name brand short and don't anymore because the chamois has tiny perforations in it (for breathability?) that abraided my skin. Now I use a less expensive brand with a smooth chamois and a channel down the middle to protect the private parts from rubbing,... and chamois butter. I typically ride 60 to 100 miles at a time on the weekends pain-free. Great video. Thumbs up! Final note: I wouldn't recommend the Selle SMP Glider because while it worked for me, it cost way too much and there are other options that cost far less. It should have a Gucci badge on it. It also had a since repaired problem with creaking that has now been resolved using Loc-tite on the rail clamps. It came that way from the factory twice and I am not the only one with this SMP problem. I found a video on UA-cam by a poster with the same issue.
Thanks for the great review, as a larger ride (5’9”, 250lbs) who does a lot of Randonneuring, I am finding that my 14 year old Terry Men’s saddle is pretty much unbearable on Brevets over 300k, and have been considering a Brooks, but I think I’ll be giving a Selle a try. Nothing keeps you off a bike more than a few sq. Inches of sever chaffing.
Don't forget that Selle's H-series is intended for substantially heavier riders (i.e. over 260 lbs. up to a max. of 350 lbs.).
Their site says its maximum limit is 250lbs for the H1 and H2.
BigSarge, Just wanted to thank you for your video. Based on your commentary I purchase the Selle Anatomica H2. I'm 6ft at 220lb, been cycling just under 3 years and after 3 bike fits & my 4th saddles I'm still having discomfort & pain after long ride. For the last 6 months I've been riding with the Infinity saddle, its a nice saddle, but as it relieve the sit bone pain the outer perimeter of the saddle wears on the buttock soft tissue. But again I can't to get my H2 saddle and start sing it praises.
any updates? i was considering the infinity but im interested in the selle anatomica also. any thoughts or comparisons or conclusions drawn between the 2?
Would you still recommend this seat I will be doing my riding for recreation and weight loss 6'2 about your weight and height actually
Great review! Gonna check one out, like you a big guy here.
Hi.... I love this saddle.. lbut have issues with staining from the leather... do you ever have this problem? Great and comfy ride.
Hi Craig, I've never experienced any staining whatsoever from my Anatomica. Also, I've never used any conditioners, saddle soap, or leather was on the seat. . .ever! The seat has performed flawlessly out-the-box ever since I purchased it. However, my average rides usually don't last longer than 15 miles or so. The longest I've done on this saddle was the 62 mile Elephant Rock Bike Ride here in Castle Rock, Colorado. Even then, no staining issues. It could be that I just have exceptional padding in my cycling shorts that the sweat doesn't really pass thru to the seat (but doubtful). I just know that when I get off the bike I never have a 'noticeably' wet seat. I did notice the wetness on my Brooks saddle but even then, no staining (and I used loads of conditioner on that seat). Anyway, if you're one of the hard-core riders that ride without cycling shorts (padding) then maybe you could try switching out to cycling shorts. Other than that I'm not sure what the issue could be. Ride Safe and enjoy the journey!!!
Thanks for the info!! It was usually only on some of the longer rides... I actually swapped out the saddle for a few days, then realized stain or not, its the most comfortable saddle I ever rode and put it right back on (after letting it bake for a full day in the sun ) Keep on Pedalin'! - craig in Cleveland
Hmmm now you’ve got me thinking. I just got one of these and went for a fairly long ride on it the other day and couldn’t quite get comfortable on it, preferring the Brooks B17’s on my other bikes. I put it up for sale yesterday but after watching this I’m thinking maybe I should give it another go. I’m about 250 pounds. I’ve also found that the Brooks B17 didn’t take very long at all to break in. I really wanted to love the Anatomica X because it looks great on my hardtail mountain bike. Now I’m confused.
Dean Herde - Hi Dean, thanks for viewing and posting. I believe you've got to play with the Seller a bit to find the correct sweet spot. Since the nose is supposed to tilt up a bit it really is a different fit from any other saddle. Centimeters really count here so please give it another go. Could be that you're just too hardcore and don't have a need for the Selle's fit. If/once you find the spot it will be a night and day difference. Good Luck!
Greatestmnalive hey thanks very much for your reply buddy. You’ve inspired me and I’m going to give it another go. I’m glad I found your video. Seems like very good timing. Hope you’re having great rides. Appreciate your advice.
You're welcome Dean! Please update us later after you've put in a few rides and tell us how it's working out for you. I haven't been on the bike in a while since I've been dabbling in adventure motorcycling and trying to get familiar with that sport. I plan to jump back into the saddle here in the next couple of weeks now that the weather is breaking here in Colorado. Just remember, cycling can easily turn into a passion once your butt and body get used to it so please (if you haven't already) be sure to get a bike fit done because it is infinitely important to your riding to prevent injury that can lay you up for weeks. Good Luck and Ride Safe!!!
BigSarge hi from Australia, just getting back to you about the Anatomica X. I took your advice and persisted with it. I'm very glad I did. Very comfortable, and I've done some long off road rides, about 50 kilometres on my Cotic Soul Hardtail mountain bike. I noticed that I told you I weighed 250 pounds back then. Well I'm 235 now so yeah, I've been riding a fair bit. Thanks again for telling me to stick with the sadd give it a chance.
Dean Herde Now that's some great news Dean. I applaud you for giving it another go and more time. I can imagine the smile on your face now that you're getting the time in the saddle that you want. Did you tweak your diet any or is the riding causing you to drop pounds like that?
I appreciate you
I just got an H2 saddle. I've just got done with several 40+ mile rides and my gonads hurt too. How did you go about adjusting the tilt? Did you start at the recommended 1/4"-1/8" nose up recommendation and adjust it down from there or did you find you needed to tilt it nose up even more?
@David - my apologies for not seeing this sooner! I haven't been monitoring this site and am now seeing that there are several comments with questions. Yes, I started with the recommended position. I had a bike fit done first then proceeded to tilt it up. Afterwards I simply adjusted the tilt in very movements until arriving at the final position. It did take several rides though to figure out what worked. Good Luck and ride safe!
Is that the "aged" color? Does it darken over time? Do you still ride this seat?
Hi Ca4Gochops, sorry but I don't remember Seller having an Aged color (like Brooks does) but this one is lighter in color than the Brooks Aged saddle and no, mine hasn't darkened at all since I've had it and I have never used any leather conditioners or cleaners on it. However, I'm not a go-hard rider by any measure and I rarely have gotten caught in heavy rain. Ride safe and good luck!
Selle lists the X for riders 120-190lbs. The H series is for >190.
That's correct! However, I don't think that H model existed when I purchased the X. I may be wrong but I remember looking thru all of their saddles before making the X purchase. Thanks for responding and ride safe!☺️
Correct pronunciation of Selle is 'Sell' not 'Sell-e' - the 'e' is silent.
Thanks Shannon! I'd never heard anyone say the name before but shoulda figured the 'e' as silent.