Phil Collins doesn't "hate" any of those bands. He once said about Oasis, he liked some of their stuff, because their guitar-driven style reminded him of The Beatles, one of his favorite bands from his youth. But in the wake of Noel Gallagher's insulting towards Collins, he said Oasis was overrated, after they self-described as the best band in the world. That's a different thing but hating. He definitely doesn't hate Led Zeppelin. The drum pattern of Genesis' "Squonk" was inspired by John Bonham, who in return taught his son the drum pattern of "Turn In On Again". Collins produced and played on Robert Plant's first two album and went on tour with him. Collins is also well known to Nick Mason, who came to visit Genesis live in 2007. The only thing he said about Pink Floyd is, that it's not a band he liked to listen to. But that's not HATING! This is absolute clickbait and lies telling!
Probably not the band music, but maybe particular members of them (may understandably be Roger Waters from Pink Floyd, or Jimmy Page from Led Zeppelin)
@@rodolfo1673 Collins' anger is aimed at Page, not Plant. Collins asked for at least one rehearsal and Page rejected it. Thompson actually did rehearse with them. I actually saw the performance and I didn't think it "ruined" the song. It was just a bit looser. Classic rock fans get very upset when a song isn't rendered perfectly. This standard crept in slowly through the 70s. It becomes a bit odd when you consider that renditions of classical works can vary significantly from conductor to conductor.
@@garygomesvedicastrology Good comment. Who asks two drummers who have never worked together before to play at the same time with them? Ridiculous. Collins was set up.
GLORY!!!'m favoured, $140K every 3weeks! And I am retired i can now give back to the locals in my community and also support God's work and the church. God bless America🇺🇸❤️
Hello, how do you achieve such biweekly returns? As a single parent i haven't been able to get my own house due to financial struggles, but my faith in God remains strong.
YES!!! That's exactly her name (Elizabeth Ann Larson) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her 😊 from Brisbane Australia🇦🇺
Phil Collins was criminally underrated as a drummer and also as a songwriter. Some of the later songs were commercial but it was always quality. He played with John Martyn and Martyn certainly didn't accept fools gladly.
@@MikeFlood-oe3tu Well , with me being a Prog guy , I found the increase in the use of synthesisers in pop, fascinating! A lot of great, inventive music in that decade !
@@paulbrookes413 ,,,also a "prog guy" as well, over here. Hardcore, in fact. Other than the first 'neo prog' emergence given the likes of Marillion, Pallas and Twelfth Night, I found the 80s wretched. I worked - as a univ student, mid-80s - at a Sam the Record Man outlet for a few years, and there was very little agreeable new music to listen to in the 'play' bin. In particular, and by way of example, I also found this THE poorest decade for Rush offerings - if (like most folk do) consider them to be prog - and despite being a HUGE Rush fan, I would offend most proggers by debating that they're even true 'prog', in fact. Most of their catalogue isn't - 2112, AFTK, Hemis, Perm Waves, and (slightly) Moving Pics certainly are. The rest? ....nope, not imho.
It's strange how hate can be such an attraction. If this video was called "Top 3 bands Phil Collins LOVED the most" the average viewer would likely just skip it and watch something else. But finding out who he hates, that will get much more views.
@@Buddha-of8fk ...absolutely. Aren't we all? One reason I will never say Floyd was better is because of Steve Hackett, for one. An utter marvel. Still - for my Top 5 five albums all time, two are from Floyd. Nobody else could've done that!
@@Buddha-of8fk ...for sure. Go listen to their song 'Be Hard On Yourself', easy to find here on YT. Released about 2yrs ago. One of the best new songs I've heard in years.
BS clickbait video using AI (although there is some animosity with Oasis). Jimmy Paige was the problem at Live Aid not Collins. Why did they have another drummer with Collins? Zeppelin politics. Phil really loved Led Zeppelin and snuck into bars to hear them play as a teenager. Plus, he and Robert Plant were best of friends. Pink Floyd.....neutral for Collins. Me, love the band's music.
About Zeppelin he is right. Many overrated band Bands without a keyboard for me it is impossible to play memorable melodic music. For that and they have no more 5 world hits. To them you could add the Roling Stones. About Pink Floyd however, I can't agree
Phil has just gone down in my esteem not appreciating the fabulous music of LZ and PF!!! Collins' simple and popular songs will NEVER reach the stratospheric flights of these two groups!
its good i don t like Oasis and Lez leppellin much of Pink floyd dificult band to said because have 3 singers and diferent periods in the video saids Collins don t like early Pink floyd maybe Syd Barret period o some o first albums
Oasis sucks...in fact,Suede are way better...Led Zeppelin is the biggest band ever...and Genesis with Peter Gabriel fronting them were the best in the whole universe
I like them but overrated. I've made many Zeppelin fans mad when I often say it's just Plant and a group of session players. As for Collins playing with LZ what were they thinking? That like oil and water
@@chrisbacos Collins could play with anyone. Collins asked for and received no basic run through...and Page was a bit "under the weather" Page is a great player, but that would throw anyone off. Plus, the performance is not really bad, just a bit busier than usual!
Don't think he hated Led Zeppelin, otherwise he wouldn't have opted to play with them at Live Aid. He obviously just hated being blamed for their performance. As for Pink Floyd, probably just jealousy.
Collins was convinced to perform with Zeppelin as a publicity stunt for Live Aid-playing in the UK then jetting to the United States on the Concord. Page was screwed up, he felt resentment and asked for rehearsal time but was ignored. Tony Thompson had also rehearsed and Collins was not welcome. But he agreed to do it, so he did. Not everyone loves Pink Floyd (I only like a few of their early albums and Wish You Were Here. Floyd was, for me, pretty slow paced and unexciting most of the time. (Tony Banks said he tends to fall asleep listening to later Pink Floyd, for example.) If you like them, more power to you, but not every criticism is jealousy. Genesis sold, I think, 150 million records; Pink Floyd, 250 million. Those are both stratospheric totals; tough to get jealous if you sold 150 million records (and that excluded Phil's solo career). I respected 1980s Genesis; didn't like Phil's solo work as much. But, while I respected PF , I never enjoyed them as much as Genesis. I also don't think Phil hated Zep, but Genesis direction, both during the Gabriel and post-Gabriel years, was far more nuanced than LZ. He may have admired Bonham but that would not necessarily extend to the rest of LZ 'S output.
Replacing John Bonham with Phil Collins is laughable . He hated Led Zeppelin because they were way out of his League . Anyone who hates Pink Floyd needs to have their Head examined . Everybody hates Oasis , what else is new ?
I get the criticism of Collins as an 80s solo artist, but as a drummer? Nah. He is easily one of the best of the modern era. There is no way that he was out of anyone's league.
Phil Collins doesn't "hate" any of those bands.
He once said about Oasis, he liked some of their stuff, because their guitar-driven style reminded him of The Beatles, one of his favorite bands from his youth. But in the wake of Noel Gallagher's insulting towards Collins, he said Oasis was overrated, after they self-described as the best band in the world. That's a different thing but hating.
He definitely doesn't hate Led Zeppelin. The drum pattern of Genesis' "Squonk" was inspired by John Bonham, who in return taught his son the drum pattern of "Turn In On Again". Collins produced and played on Robert Plant's first two album and went on tour with him.
Collins is also well known to Nick Mason, who came to visit Genesis live in 2007. The only thing he said about Pink Floyd is, that it's not a band he liked to listen to. But that's not HATING!
This is absolute clickbait and lies telling!
He didn't hate Pink Floyd nor Led Zeppelin this is totally out of context.
Probably not the band music, but maybe particular members of them (may understandably be Roger Waters from Pink Floyd, or Jimmy Page from Led Zeppelin)
If people are tuning into this video it's because they already know who Phil Collins is. Save the history lesson and just get to the bands he hated!
He hated bands that criticised him - fancy that! He was right about Oasis, though...
Lies. Phil Collins is a great friend of Robert Plant. He also performed as a drummer at the Live Aid festival. 🎉
Sure... but Jimmy Page hates him because he sabotage Live Aid. Tony Thompson did a better job playing the drums than Collins
@@rodolfo1673 Collins' anger is aimed at Page, not Plant. Collins asked for at least one rehearsal and Page rejected it. Thompson actually did rehearse with them. I actually saw the performance and I didn't think it "ruined" the song. It was just a bit looser.
Classic rock fans get very upset when a song isn't rendered perfectly. This standard crept in slowly through the 70s. It becomes a bit odd when you consider that renditions of classical works can vary significantly from conductor to conductor.
@@rodolfo1673 BS. Thompson was auditioning for LZ (didn't work, did it) Page was drunk out of his mind that day and used Collins for an excuse.
@@garygomesvedicastrology Good comment. Who asks two drummers who have never worked together before to play at the same time with them? Ridiculous.
Collins was set up.
@@garygomesvedicastrology I agree with you
I like Phil Collins
GLORY!!!'m favoured, $140K every 3weeks! And I am retired i can now give back to the locals in my community and also support God's work and the church. God bless America🇺🇸❤️
Hello, how do you achieve such biweekly returns? As a single parent i haven't been able to get my own house due to financial struggles, but my faith in God remains strong.
Excuse me for real?,how is that
possible I have struggling
financially, how was that possible?
Thanks to my co-worker whom God used to give a great opportunity of crossing paths with 'Mrs ELIZABETH ANN LARSON'.
YES!!! That's exactly her name (Elizabeth Ann Larson) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her 😊 from Brisbane Australia🇦🇺
I have heard a lot of wonderful things about Elizabeth Ann on the news but didn't believe it until now. I'm definitely trying her out
Phil Collins was criminally underrated as a drummer and also as a songwriter. Some of the later songs were commercial but it was always quality. He played with John Martyn and Martyn certainly didn't accept fools gladly.
You left out his well known issues with Timmy & The Lords of the Underworld.
Phil Collins ruined the eighties.
the eighties ruined itself... worst decade in music BY FAR.
@@MikeFlood-oe3tuNO WAY !
@@paulbrookes413 tell me why, then
@@MikeFlood-oe3tu Well , with me being a Prog guy , I found the increase in the use of synthesisers in pop, fascinating! A lot of great, inventive music in that decade !
@@paulbrookes413 ,,,also a "prog guy" as well, over here. Hardcore, in fact. Other than the first 'neo prog' emergence given the likes of Marillion, Pallas and Twelfth Night, I found the 80s wretched. I worked - as a univ student, mid-80s - at a Sam the Record Man outlet for a few years, and there was very little agreeable new music to listen to in the 'play' bin. In particular, and by way of example, I also found this THE poorest decade for Rush offerings - if (like most folk do) consider them to be prog - and despite being a HUGE Rush fan, I would offend most proggers by debating that they're even true 'prog', in fact. Most of their catalogue isn't - 2112, AFTK, Hemis, Perm Waves, and (slightly) Moving Pics certainly are. The rest? ....nope, not imho.
It's strange how hate can be such an attraction. If this video was called "Top 3 bands Phil Collins LOVED the most" the average viewer would likely just skip it and watch something else. But finding out who he hates, that will get much more views.
He was probably pissed at Pink Floyd because they was better than Genesis.
LMAO, even though I'm a major Genesis fan. Although I can't agree, either - I could not live without either band and dare not even compare the two.
@MikeFlood-oe3tu I'm a bigger Peter Gabriel fan than a new Genesis.
@@Buddha-of8fk ...absolutely. Aren't we all? One reason I will never say Floyd was better is because of Steve Hackett, for one. An utter marvel. Still - for my Top 5 five albums all time, two are from Floyd. Nobody else could've done that!
@MikeFlood-oe3tu The one band l wish got more attention was Marillion. As far as progressive Rock that is amazing.
@@Buddha-of8fk ...for sure. Go listen to their song 'Be Hard On Yourself', easy to find here on YT. Released about 2yrs ago. One of the best new songs I've heard in years.
I never realized that anyone actually lived at the Marquis
I never got Genesis, went off Led Zep, and Oasis? Who???
You like what you like but I do have respect for the musicians in the first two I mentioned 👍
BS clickbait video using AI (although there is some animosity with Oasis). Jimmy Paige was the problem at Live Aid not Collins. Why did they have another drummer with Collins? Zeppelin politics. Phil really loved Led Zeppelin and snuck into bars to hear them play as a teenager. Plus, he and Robert Plant were best of friends. Pink Floyd.....neutral for Collins. Me, love the band's music.
To be fair Oasis sucks. Collin’s liked Led Zeppelin and drummed for Robert Plant. So, that part is BS.
I agree Oasis sucks!
A lot of Collins ' stuff SUCKS !!
Beatles sucks
Fucking 60s sound sucks
About Zeppelin he is right. Many overrated band Bands without a keyboard for me it is impossible to play memorable melodic music. For that and they have no more 5 world hits. To them you could add the Roling Stones. About Pink Floyd however, I can't agree
No seriously PF! Best musical group in the world lyrics music creativity and imagination
I laughed so hard when Noel Gallagher called him the antichrist 😆 👏 it’s so fucking random
He's aged poorly and is the same age as me, bless him.
Phil has just gone down in my esteem not appreciating the fabulous music of LZ and PF!!! Collins' simple and popular songs will NEVER reach the stratospheric flights of these two groups!
This video is nonsense.
Don't forget that he hated Lords of the Underworld featuring Timmy
4:20 honestly, who cares about what Roger Waters thinks?... 🙄🙄🙄
I agree with Oasis but not with LZ or PF
coming from someone who wrote easy lover, sussudio,one more night,etc😂😂😂truly laughable 😂😂
Damn, the guy who turned Genesis into bublegum pop doesn't like Led Zeppelin and Pink Floyd!!?? It is serious?
NO.
BTW, all the three members of Genesis turned the band into what you call bubblegum pop: it was THEIR choice, not HIS.
@@ykar18 Agreed. Phil just did a great job facilitating it. Motown to the rescue. Like it or not, the move was VERY popular.
@@ykar18Collins was the instigator!
I've detested Phil Collins for over FORTY years. It would be an honor to be hated by him
Oasis..never cared for them
Oasis ist menschlich wie musikalisch nichts wert....nur hype,aber warum nur ? 🤔
Collins should be imprisoned for numerous crimes against music.
guarantee alot more people hat fkn Genesis and Phil collins
Lo digo en español y bien claro.
Lo de Oasis es cierto, es resto es basura.
Agree with Phil over Oasis they are the worst over rated band in the last 30 years.
Definitely wrong about LED Zeppelin
its good i don t like Oasis and Lez leppellin much of Pink floyd dificult band to said because have 3 singers and diferent periods in the video saids Collins don t like early Pink floyd maybe Syd Barret period o some o first albums
Oasis sucks...in fact,Suede are way better...Led Zeppelin is the biggest band ever...and Genesis with Peter Gabriel fronting them were the best in the whole universe
Oasis is a woke band. Are they twins????? I thought it is 1 guy. Even worse lol. As a 42 year old man I just can not stand Oasses.
Don't believe this one bit . Anyway who cares 🤷
Led Zeppelin sucks.
I like them but overrated. I've made many Zeppelin fans mad when I often say it's just Plant and a group of session players. As for Collins playing with LZ what were they thinking? That like oil and water
As opposed to who? I'm genuinely curious.
@@chrisbacos Collins could play with anyone. Collins asked for and received no basic run through...and Page was a bit "under the weather"
Page is a great player, but that would throw anyone off. Plus, the performance is not really bad, just a bit busier than usual!
Don't think he hated Led Zeppelin, otherwise he wouldn't have opted to play with them at Live Aid. He obviously just hated being blamed for their performance. As for Pink Floyd, probably just jealousy.
Also Jack, Bonham was one of his favourite drummers
Led Zeppelin at Live Aid were atrocious. They tried to blame it on Phil though.
Collins was convinced to perform with Zeppelin as a publicity stunt for Live Aid-playing in the UK then jetting to the United States on the Concord. Page was screwed up, he felt resentment and asked for rehearsal time but was ignored. Tony Thompson had also rehearsed and Collins was not welcome. But he agreed to do it, so he did.
Not everyone loves Pink Floyd (I only like a few of their early albums and Wish You Were Here. Floyd was, for me, pretty slow paced and unexciting most of the time. (Tony Banks said he tends to fall asleep listening to later Pink Floyd, for example.) If you like them, more power to you, but not every criticism is jealousy. Genesis sold, I think, 150 million records; Pink Floyd, 250 million. Those are both stratospheric totals; tough to get jealous if you sold 150 million records (and that excluded Phil's solo career). I respected 1980s Genesis; didn't like Phil's solo work as much. But, while I respected PF , I never enjoyed them as much as Genesis.
I also don't think Phil hated Zep, but Genesis direction, both during the Gabriel and post-Gabriel years, was far more nuanced than LZ. He may have admired Bonham but that would not necessarily extend to the rest of LZ 'S output.
@@garygomesvedicastrologyPhil wants all the attention - Even when he's crap and sat in a wheelchair 😂
@@paulbrookes413What is so funny about a person stuck in a wheelchair?
Damn, every long careered rock musician seems to hate Oasis.
Because they are crap and unoriginal.
They must be threatened by youth
Replacing John Bonham with Phil Collins is laughable . He hated Led Zeppelin because they were way out of his League . Anyone who hates Pink Floyd needs to have their Head examined . Everybody hates Oasis , what else is new ?
He didn't hate Led Zeppelin. Out of his league? Really? I Don't think so. Collins is an incredible drummer.
I get the criticism of Collins as an 80s solo artist, but as a drummer? Nah. He is easily one of the best of the modern era. There is no way that he was out of anyone's league.
@rodstrong8539 He's good, not great. Imo not in the same league with Moon, Baker, Peart or Copeland.
@@greatloverofmusic1No; he was better... and I am a fan of the other drummers as well. Have you heard Brand X? He's unbelievably good.
Then I am checking in. Pink Floyd was increasingly well crafted and increasingly dull to me, personally. No energy.
PC madman🤪🥸🤓
Insane 🫵