Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
RANGED ATTACKS! - Secret Stats Warhammer 2
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 лют 2021
- The hidden secrets of ranged attacks in Total War: Warhammer 2!
SUPPORT this channel by:
- Watching ads
- Buying games with GP: uk.gamesplanet.com/?ref=zerko...
- Twitch Sub: www.twitch.tv/zerkovich
- Patreon: / zerkovich
- Paypal: www.paypal.com/donate/?cmd=_s...
My PC gear of choice:
Mouse - amzn.to/342g0cN
Keyboard - amzn.to/3qNhSzY
Headset - amzn.to/3gFZape
Discord: / discord
Thank you to all those who support this channel.
My beard & I grow stronger with you at our side!
"...by blowing up some dwarfs." Aaaaand another Book of Grudges entry for Zerkovich.
He's a Greenskin Guy, There is an entire bunch of the whole pages of him already. One more won't hurt him... much...
With all the short leg jokes he makes, he should have a "Library of Grudges" by now.
@Johnathan Cason testing out these bots, looks... ehhh... maybe pro- no. How about quite poss- not gonna work. How about... ummmm... bad? Yeah that works
Joke is getting old
What else are 'em dwarves good for, apart from this and housework?
"Your favorite ranged units. *No dwarves.*"
*Angry writing in a book.*
Skaven Jezzail soldier: "My skaven lord! We should each aim at a separate soldier in front of us so we can kill them all at once!"
Lord: "Nonsense! We should all fire at that one man-thing at the very edge of the platoon just so we can be 100% sure we'll hit him yes-yes."
Realistically I think it would be a very effective tactic if you could achieve this level of accuracy. If the skaven shoot the entire unit, well that's that, you put your shield up and hope to stay alive. But imagine the Skaven unleashed two volleys, and both were aimed at the left edge of the unit. The people there were instantly killed with no hope of surviving, their bodies hit with bullet after bullet well beyond what it would take to neutralize them. And now it's your turn to stand in the left edge, where certain death awaits. Much higher chance of that person running, which can easily cause the entire unit to rout- especially considering if the first guy runs, someone else needs to take the left edge.
@@user-rw3kw7wx7e but units don't die replenishment doesn't cost money
The skaven just want to steal each others kills.
@@MouldMadeMind lol, most lore accurate explanation tbh
I mean to be fair its probably really difficult to achieve that sort of cohesion, especially among 32 different weapon teams. And these are skaven we're talking about, who struggle with cohesion at the best of times.
6:08 the commentary style description of the cannon's ass-shots were golden
Rectal bleeding. Jesus Christ.
Yo omg I actually spit my coffee a lil
That moment, just made me love this channel lol
@@goobermcboogerballs1420 made me subscribe from laughing.
Never thought I would hear someone utter 'How many trolls can it penetrate?'
I know a guy, He's penetrated way more than four trolls.
You should test the mortars again against a stationary far target, as the dwarves approach the target areas approach the same value, where as far away the areas are massively different
Yea i deffinitly thing this was cuased by the approach, since as you said, both values are approcing the same pooint, so the bonus will get less effective.
I think another factor is the attacking dwarf trying to dodge the shots. You can't dodge a shot that is so inaccurate noone knows where it will land.
Agreed. Definitely useful to know that chevrons aren't important to mortars firing into charging massed infantry--that's mortars' day job. But maybe it matters more in an artillery duel, or if you're trying to snipe Gelt off his stupid flying horse.
It seems like the easiest test is just to manually dump the entire ammo capacity on the ground at various ranges and see where they actually land. Gonna test this.
@@themekahippie991 how did it go?
Was just about to work on homework, perfect timing :)
this comment is so relatable
Understanding unit stats is homework in its own
Hope it was the study of missile ballistics 👍
Yo seriously. Dude saving lives out here.
This IS homework. I have work to do.
For the lack of difference between accuracy buffed units and non-accuracy buffed units, it's simply because the difference becomes much less significant the closer the ennemy unit gets.
Higher accuracy means the unit will remain accurate at longer distances, but when the ennemy units get close enough, the advantages of higher accuracy drop drastically.
In your test against the dwarf units, for example, if the dwarf units had remained at long distance instead of closing in, the upgraded mortar would've performed better, but since they were getting closer and closer, the accuracy difference shrank rapidly, leading to this result.
So accuracy bonuses are much more effective if you're planning on shooting on targets that remain quite far away, like ballistas or eagle bolt throwers brought to snipe ennemy artillery, on these the accuracy upgrade will be a plus, but the value of the accuracy bonus will become insignificant when shooting at close targets
Size of the target also helps. If the target area is smaller then the unit, its hard to miss. Single model targets might make for a better target to find out how many hits are accidents actualy aimed at the guy next to him. Like, how many shots miss and instead hit Morghur, who was just strolling around peacefully...
Also it could have to do with where it aims at the unit, like his last point. If all 3 mortars are aiming for one spot, and they all hit that spot, theyre wasting damage. But if theyre hitting around that spot, the damage could be spread out.
6:58 Skyhawks (Yvresse Mistwalker Unit): *Looks around nervously* "Yeah penetrating arrows would just be absurd haha..."
Alith anar appears in the distance*
@@alfyanrauf6616 Arrows don't penetrate he lied, and Anar laughed.
@@alfyanrauf6616 Alith Anar counts as artillery, I think, as I remember him being able to target towers and walls.
14:00 outrider plugging the archer in the back of the head
Z did say "at the risk of safety". He never said safety from what.
Pretty tough dude to get shot in the back of the head at that range and keep going
@@delboythethird1200 haha ye that bois just gets back up like he only took a slap
Don't sleep with the outrider's wife.
"Accidents" can happen.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who saw that
"Tsss, I have hundreds of hours on this game. This video is obviously useless for me"
Pressing alt with artillery allow you were to shoot AND you have a circle which represents accuracy...
"Dawn you Zerkovich, once again you learn me something usefull than I never notice despite the fact that it was before my eyes all this time !" (That and the others info, great video as usual)
Srsly, at the moment he explained the circles I was like " NO FUCKING WAY!" Hundreds of hours ingame and I never noticed that.
I suspect that accuracy can be a bit of a double edged sword at the highest end of it. My recent Wood Elf campaign I noticed that quite often all of the Waywatchers within a single unit would shoot a single soldier in the enemy unit that I targeted, wasting most of the shots. Obviously if you're too inaccurate you won't hit anything, but without the spread the targeting algorithm they use can stack shots on a single guy and waste damage output.
I've put almost 2000 hours into this game and I learned A LOT from this video. Great job Z!
It's terrible that CA hides so many stats & gameplay elements from its players.
I recently discovered that you can put your handgunners behind your Frontline in a chequered pattern so that they can keep firing while not being attacked since the AI units get caught on the Frontline units despite the massive gaps.
Dude I piratically learned how to play TWW on your channel. You still kick out the best vids to help new and older players. I salute you for your awesome work man. I'm not new to the Total War Franchise yet I still learn more from your channel than I've learned in all the tutorials I've been through playing the Total War franchise. Again, awesome work man. Congrats.
12:40 This doesn't look like a fun experiment to be CHOSEN into
Boooo
"No arrow is gonna go through one man and into a second one is it now, that would be ridiculous."
Legolas: and I took that personally
That edge trick is super cheeky. This will come in handy.
Super useful info. Here, have some timestamps:
0:00 - introduction
0:20 - missile unit types overview
1:28 - range weapon damage
2:53 - explosive damage
4:24 - penetration cap
7:13 - range
10:05 - calibration distance demonstration (artillery)
11:09 - calibration distance demonstration ("infantry")
14:05 - accuracy and marksmenship bonus
17:16 - accuracy testing
20:10 - shields
21:35 - projectile types
22:58 - bonus versus large
23:15 - high ground
23:32 - unit angling
14:05 Loved it, that the bowmen got shot in the back by friendly fire right on the word "safety" -- nice one
Literally just started a wood elves campaign!! Perfect timing
WayWatchers were nerfed by nerfing the talent of kuronos hero trait. Go treemen, they were buffed by adding phisical resistence, which also blocks phisical type ammo.
You an press Alt to manually target the artillery? thats amazing ....
Can't believe it took this long for this video to be made. Thank you, that was so fucking necessary!
@Zerkovich another amazing Secret Stats video, thank you for these! I missed this when it came out, just came across it while doing some research, so glad I did!
Chevrons on ranged is probably pretty useful in campaign and in sieges where you can maintain a degree of range with the AI. Might be worth testing static ranged targets, though again that's going to be pretty rare in skirmish.
You have to take into consideration overkill with units that are highly accurate. Overall, you will get more shots off with an upgraded ranged unit, but the chance of overkill is higher. So picking the correct targets is all that more important if the investment to upgrade them is made. It also is worth while to note that this allows you to switch and do more reliable spread out damage to an opponents army (with artillary).
If you compare jezzails or rattling gun RoR to standard the RoR are SIGNIFICANTLY better at killing single entities than their nonupgraded counter parts.
It is also noteworthy that with jezzails you are wasting ammunition on unit that has more than 65 models or so because of the amount of overkill.
Interesting! I'm playing savage orcs right now and I couldn't help but wonder what the point of ranged units with "poor accuracy" was (orc archers)... I guess I just need to use them at closer range for them to get value, which fits the theme as a bonus
I heard somewhere before (do not remember where), that units with better accuracy are more accurate at shooting area where the target was at the moment of projectile going out of the shooting unit model not at the moment of hitting the target. So units with higher accuracy will be very effective vs standing targets, but a lot less accurate against moving targets.
Still, blackpowder weapons fire in a straight line, sort off, so if they only walk towards you, it should not matter. Arrows and mortars on the other hand...
Zerkovich - pretty much the only Total War peep I watch/listen to these days. Great vid dude, thanks!
Man I realy love your videos, your a saint for giving us all those minute details tips and explanations ! Thanks a lot for your work !
Here is one of my discovery in WH 3 : I did some testing and found out that missiles get negated by physical resistance (PR) along with missile resistance (MR). The catch though is with magic missiles, they DON'T get negated by PR but they DO get negated by MR.
Which actualy gives meaning to them, since MR negates ALL missiles, they still get benefits against PR.
So here you go focusing an enemy who has high physical resistance (like a ghost units) will shread them when using magical arrows, while regular arrows will do very low damage to them.
Another one of Zerk´s awesome tutorials!! Mate, the work you put on these videos... its freakin awesome. I always enjoy and learn a lot of things, thx for so much work for da community, you rock dude!
These sorts of advanced videos are what I'm most excited about. Keep it up, and don't forget about us experienced viewers!
This was one of the most interesting video I've seen so far. Thanks for the amazing content!
About Dwarf blowing : maybe you can't really see the differences between unranked and ranked shooters because the weapons land zone is mostly always smaller than the target unit, and the target is slow... You should try with a smaller & faster target, Minotaurs for example
That last bit of info was very helpful. Thanks Z
That accuracy buff info is game changing.
Absolutely stellar video mate, helped explain things very well, I'm off to cheese with some dwarfen guns now
Great video. I've poured many 1000s of hours into TotalWar since the first Shogun came out, and there were still nuances in this vid I was unaware of - well done and thanks!
I swear this game can be deep if you go searching
Thanks Zerk, love this kind of mechanic videos!!!
That angle trick is cheeky. Minimize models exposed to maximize ammo wasted by overkills. It's even worse with some breath attacks or magic missiles that end up clipping a few models instead of smacking a unit.
As a side-note, widening the formation of the missile unit should make it less likely to happen (increases the angle at which the target needs to be for all entities to aim for the edge)
'Blowing up some dwarfs' well that's definitely going in the book. In bold.
Great video mate, hundreds of hours and I've never noticed the expertise bonus playing such a large part of accuracy. Always assumed it impacted on damage and reload speed the most.
Actualy, the damage boost is per 10 seconds because of the faster reload. Check their unit card, damage per shot remains the same.
Awesome video! Clearly explained and demonstrated! Got yourself a sub : )
Amazing video. Well explained and well demonstrated.
Thanks Zerk. Your videos really help beginners like me.
Always love it when I see a long WH II video from you in my feed
Zerkovich: "No arrow would go through more than one infantry unit, that would just be ridiculous."
Alith Anar: *grins evilly*
Very good guide, here´s some support
Awesome video man! Love the analysis
Always bringing good info, thanks Zerkovich.
Good content, learned alot from these videos, thanks man, keep it up
Great video. That's a lot of useful knowledge!
About 1000 hours in the game and this man teaching me things I never knew. Calibration and how to see it? Honestly never had a clue.
That's some sweet old game science. What we've really all been waiting for!
While all this info is appreciated, I have the ask, how the hell did he find all this?
Probably by looking in the game files for the logic (the code).
this correlation between better results at close range for range troops has actually been present in all TW games that Im aware of since at least M2TW. Same as fighting better downhill (including extending effective shooting range), bonuses for light infantry in forests etc.
Nice video!. Regarding accuracy, is it possible that its more helpful when trying to shoot single entities as opposed to a stack of infantry, since missing 1 dwarf warrior means a good chance itll land on another in the stack?
This video is incredibly helpful. Thank you.
Long video but I just learned a lot of things! Great job 👍👍
Excellent video. Subbed.
6:34 yo my boy in the front was already falling over and still took another cannon ball stuck straight to his face xD
I've been playing this game for years, but I always learn something from Z's videos
oh, there is the information. Zerkovich never disappointed
damn, this is something I came across discovered on my own as I was playing but didn't quite sure what it means, nice work
I never thought I'd say this but that rectal bleeding was hilarious
Génial d'apprendre de nouvelles techniques comme ça !
I appreciate this. I knew a lot of it, but specifically the accuracy section I always wondered about. I also didnt know the specifics of what counted as what type of weapon i figured shields worked on globadiers, but I guess not.
Awesome info!
"No arrow is going to go through one man and into a second one, is it now? That would be a little bit ridiculous." *legolas has entered the chat*
Gunner/Archer heroes and lords definitely penetrate infantry with their arrows, though. Had no idea about a lot of the other stuff, great info!
Thought heroes and lords were more about splash damage? Never rewatched a battle in slow-motion, might be worth trying...
great video, never knew how those mechanics worked before.
Great informative video.
Huh, never realized that range units would target the closest model. Seems like it might be abusable if running a melee unit at enemy range. A slight angle to keep the shield block chance, and make them target a corner. Similar to tacking when sailing.
Excellent video as always
for the focusing on forward edge of the unit part at the end... I'd guess that it is because the angle is so deep that the penetration was actually clipping more units than the only slightly tilted, but that would imply that arrows do actually punch through... OR, perhaps because the ones that miss their 'intended' target have more chances to hit his buddy to the rear of him?
It has to be the second theory since as we just learned arrows and shot do not penetrate at all.
Either way it is true, the steeper you cut a rectangle the longer the resulting site will be.
I love Darkelves, i suck at using Darkshards/Shades. This helped a lot thanks
5:21
A solid croch shot from a bloody artillery's unit. RIP troll and all the possible future generations.
That shot easily deserves a 10 turn debuff of +100% increase in training time for trolls on the enemy faction.
.."the poor fella". Great video!
Accuracy is less important the more models there are in a unit so there is like a catchup mechanic inherent in the accuracy test. More of the explosive damage will go to waste the fewer units there are or the thinner the unit is. Nice video 10/10 unironically loved it
Very interesting info, thanks for the research.
I'm not sure it would affect the result, but to reduce randomness, I think you should use a no-armour unit as target (f.ex. savage orcs). If you are making a follow-up, it would be very interesting to see how accuracy affects different missile types in different scenarios.
Great job, thank you. 👏
Great video, thanks.
Very very informative!
But what I saw in your experiments and you didn't mentioned is, that there is certain number of shots that land in the exact spot of the attack. That implies, that there is also a garantied number of shot in a volley that will hit no matter the calibration stat.
The jazzail experiment couldn't show differences, because the missing shots hit the unit next or behind the targeted one, a hero as target would have given more results I guess.
So all accuracy buffs do is make units better at significant range. Very interesting! I didn't know this and often used Warlock Engineers to boost the max range of cannons and weapon teams, I didn't know that the accuracy boost is most effective when you're buffing units you're planning to shoot at max range
i noticed at 22:49, normal ushabti great bow arrows can't pierce through more than 1 infantry model, even if they're on the less tanky side. For smaller infantry(goblins, skaven, humans, elves, undead), it would be nice for their arrows to be able to penetrate through at least 2 models. Against tankier infantry(orcs, chosen, temple guard), great bows should only be able to kill 1 per projectile.
For the test with shooting at a angled enemy, I wonder how the missiles would work end on - shooting down the line. I wonder if the issue with the more angled enemy was that it was starting to approach firing down the line, so missiles would have more chances to hit and would have less chance of 'overkill' , where multiple archers fire at the same enemy.
Great info! Thanks, man =).
This series is immensely helpful and cool, this is something i think that was supposed to be covered by CA in some manner at least. I understand that it might bee too much to cover in tutorials and blogposts, but goddamn it, you should at least give some info to players how your game actually works in some official way. That being said, keep up the good work man!
I've been watching you for a little while now and your videos are incredibly informative. On that note I have a question about cavalry charges and flanking. If you notice enemy cavalry attempting to flank an infantry unit that is committed in battle, would it help to have your infantry turn and countercharges the enemy cav? Also, does it make sense to have your infantry without charge defences charge enemy cavalry instead of bracing for impact? In older games like medieval 2 this was definitely the case.
Every time you upload a bloody video I need to go play more Warhammer!
That was great AND informative. I especially liked the "Jesus Christ!" after the giant got shot in the arse with a cannon.
Sometimes my arse feels like it's been shot by a cannon!
it is worth noting that in the chevron accuracy test with the Jezzails the upgraded ones killed more models than the un upgraded ones despite the actual damage done being pretty much the same. At least for the test shown.
6:57 Wrong. There is a unit that can shoot arrows and penetrate more than one enemy. It's the skyhawks, recruitable by the Yvresse faction (IE eltharion the grim).
Also, i love how they added damage counters but you still use enemy's health to measure things. XD
Also Alith Anar, but those are special cases, a legendary lord and a unit unique to 1 faction only in campaign.
@@Xeonzs IIRC it's an artillery shot. It explodes too, and you can shoot towers with it.
@@Salderosan99 oh I never realized that, still cool, but still a very specific case only for those 2 units, just meant to say that's probably why he left them out of the vid.
@@Xeonzs nah. No reason to not say it in a video that goes insanely into detail on the topic
I like zerkovich's videos but he's known to half ass things from time to time
26:43: That's useful against high damage units the opposite, placing units paralelle to firing units is good against small arms since it distributes the damage more evenly.
The buffs to accuracy probably would show more impact if the battles stay at a longer range, which for pretty much every battle won't be the case.
Wow, the last part is the only thing I didn't know. I know it happens but now I also know why. Which also means that I can draw some implications from it. If you want to mitigate the enemy being slightly angled to you, instead of having your ranged units in a square formation you should spread them out as much as possible so the distance between the flanks is bigger which will lead to them targeting the opposing unit more evenly.
sometimes it's benificial for a unit to be innaccurate, 4 mortar shells hitting the identical spot in a blob of infantry is doing less damage than 3 shells spread across it.
Watching trolls go flying is hilarious.
as funny and as informative as always
I never knew that Master Engineers improved accuracy by that much, that difference is absolutely insane, holy shit!
About the Rank 9 Mortars, it is a siege weapon - higher acc for them matters alot when you siege a settlement with walls and you need to clear out high value targets before you move in, Cannons are okay to get down towers and walls but provide nearly no other value in a siege battle then that; but out perform mortars by a good chunk when it comes to open battlefield devastation - atleast thats how i feel about it
25:17 that is the same reason why units with better "accuracy" sometimes do less damage. bigger calibration provides a better chance of hitting moving targets. golden chevron units are good at dealing damage to slow moving large monsters such as giant