Also Boc was over the line. Hearing his last words being "mum, i've let you down" hurts. Edit: MOTHERFUCKER, I JUST REMEMBERED RODERIKA! NOT MY RODERIKA!
Are you slow? It has nothing to do with a crockpot. The word crock simply means a pot. It’s called a double entendre. Edit: for a further explanation: "crock" is short for the phrase "crock of shit", which is a reference to chamber pots. The phrase basically means the same as "bull shit". I wouldn't expect the idiot kids who play Elden ring to get this
Boc's death is honestly one of the most saddening things I've seen in the entire series and that's saying something His last words were just about how he didn't want to be a disappointment to his mum, the poor guy... Kenneth Haight and D, too. Kenneth sounds so betrayed, while D just seems sad that he's leaving his brother alone.
Dude, I’m on my first play through, I alt/tabbed on second monitor to research the Npc and when I clicked back into Elden ring that apparently counts as an attack and I killed him in one blow :( you can’t even bring him back either, very sad times.
One way to look at it is that only a few of those characters can have a happy ending anyways. In a sense, you're doing them a favor by killing them (some of them anyway). A few NPC actually end up worst off after you've helped them.
Yeah that was sad, looks like they gave him 100k health to try to prevent this from happening lol. I kill the merchants sometimes because they’re often in terrible locations but I feel bad killing them
I love how he behaves in ER, based on his dialogue it’s almost as if he’s aware of all the other worlds he’s lived in and much of what he says seems like he’s talking directly to us veterans who’ve encountered and forgiven him countless times in the previous games. One of the quotes is “It's the same old story, everywhere I go. Ah, to hell with it all.” He’s talking about the survivors of the defeated army he’s working with, but it really feels like he’s also referencing the other universes. And this is kinda the overarching objective of Souls games, instead of saving the world or having some honorable goal these games don’t glorify the world and the powers that be, your ultimate goal is to say “to hell with it all” and make your own decision about the fate of everything, and it’s never totally good because of the nature of these realities
@@D1sc0rd- Forgive patches? Couldn't be me. I've been pushed into too many holes and seen one too many Siegwards get their armour yoinked but the worst offender has got to be when spider patches made some motherfucker shit my pants.
lol, amazing how games work on the human psychy. I killed on merchant so I could get his bell bearing and I still feel guilty. almost turned myself in to the County Police.
@@WVRLORD a baleful shadow, yes. But he isn't physical when you attack him in mistwoods or before Rannis ending As you see Godfrey has a shadow that he kills only after it becomes physical
I just realized something. Do all the empyreans have shadows like Marika? Godfrey is just her husband tho so why does he get one? Is it just the grace given?
Really goes to show how many characters there are in this game, and that wasn't even all of them Poor Boc 😭 he just wanted to become a seamster like his mum, he didn't deserve this
I feel like an amazing twist is if one of the more villainous characters had a change of heart and tried to stop you. Or you get tag-teamed by a few of the bosses because you've just become the main antagonist.
If you become a villain in the ending, like becoming the lord of fremzied, milenia will hunt you down, i think it would be cool plot for the next elden ring series
Armored core for anwser is a mech game with a lot of customization in it very fast paced game too. There is a number of branching paths in the game that let you get different endings depending on what you did. Game was made by From Soft as well.
@@xeibei4804 TBF, It’s probably equally as garbage having an entire aspect of the game ruined for you just because you set your controller down and imputed a heavy attack by mistake.
My first reaction was "how sad, killing everyone... most of them are so nice..." But then I realized that, by finishing their questline, I've also killed them all. (I mean even the one with a golden barrier are killable if you do their quest)
@@navneetyadav7139 yeah but I mean, by doing Pot kid quest, his entire village and his uncle are now dead. And of course Boc's good ending is nearly impossible to find. So I killed him.
@@aureldocks me exploring all of atlus plateau before even getting the option to indirectly kill Boc, therefore having the necessary item to save him, and knowing to use it due to the description saying it's a demihunan voice: yes
@@thein8ererator518 BIG SPOILERS AHEAD : EVERY NPC's DEATH/END OF THEIR QUESTLINE *inhales - Thops will be found dead at the bottom of the academy - Rogier dies of the black roots infecting his body - Boc will die if he tries to rebirth - D is killed by Fia at the roundtable - D's brother left his armor set and sword at the end of D's questline (death unsure) - brother corrin is not confirmed dead but you can find his clothing and bellbearing at the very end of the game (he killed himself or became a nudist) - same goes for Goldmask - Bernahl will invade you in Farum Azula, so you have to kill him yourself - Pidia will be killed by his own puppets - Alexander challenges you in a duel, ending in you killing him - Yura will be possessed by Shabriri - Varré will be invaded by you in Mogh's palace (and of course, you kill that bloody bastard) - Fia is killed by D's brother - Irina ends up killed by bandits - Edgar (her father) becomes a vengeful spirit and invades you - Diallos dies defending Jarburg against the perfumers - Gideon Ofnir is basically one of the last bosses - Hyetta asks you to use the flame of frienzy on her (which, surprisingly, kills her) - Dungeater dies due to the Curse I guess - Selvius is assassinated by black knives at the End of Ranni's quest line - Same for Iji - Blaidd (aka best boi) becomes mad and attacks you - Gowry will be found dead you accept to kill Milicent - Milicent dies by removing the needle that protected her from the scarlet rot (or killed by you if you chose to invade her) - Latenna... dies at the very beginning of her questline, becoming a spirit willingly - Ensha invades you - Jerren can live if you choose his side against Sellen, if you choose her side you kill him and... - Sellen ends up in a Ball of masks (alongside Azur and Lusat it seems) because she tried to take over Raya Lucaria - Big Boggart is killed by the Dung Eater - Rya asks you to kill her ... and that's it. Some of them have a good ending, like Boc, Jerren, Nepheli Loux, Gowry or Rya but death is one of their questline's valid end. The one with "good ending" (or at least that get to live) are : - Kenneth Haight - Pat - Gostoc -Tanith - Jar Bairn - Erika And of course Ranni. (note that I only listed npc with real questline, so finger reader, the spirits or merchant are not listed). Hope this has been helpful. So if there is one lesson to be learned from all of this, it would be this : you want to help theses people ? Leave them alone.
You can actually kill sellen but when she is chained up during her questline ... I was trying to free her by hitting her chains with me sword , you can guess the rest lol
You can kill Millicent actually. If you progress her questline until right after the godskin apostle fight in Altus she can be slain to get Millicent's Prosthetic.
I'll give Alexander a warriors death either way, might as well speed up the process, especially because he ends up killing my favorite dragon in the game by progression of his story,... hint... its where you kill alexander
@@vizic9561 really I was able to complete it without. It's more luck based on whether you meet him in certain places rather than complex objectives. Definitely simpler than rannis questline for sure
@@tylermech66 I mean duh but no other pest talks,can seemingly switch bodies, and has ulterior motives its obvious more to him than just being a regular pest
@@dakarai47 his "human" form is just an illusion, and where did you get that Pests can't talk? they are sapient creatures , and can cast magic. It's not a stretch to think they can either talk or use magic to speak for them.
Not gonna lie, I did laugh a little when Alexander asked if his whole existence was "just a crock" RIP, you were the best crock pot a tarnished could know
Boc and Pope are the only NPCs that deserve a chance and I will NEVER-EVER harm them under any circumstance. They are the epitome of kindness in this cruel world.
If you killed D, give his brother the armor and reload the area, he'll be hostile and you can kill him. Or just kill him at the end of Fia's questline. Same goes for Rya, you can kill her at the end of her questline. Also you missed Tanith. And Hyetta and Shabriri, technically.
@@kakagakakerger4165 go to Nokron, where you fight the second Ancient Moose, and check out the borders of this place. You should see a way to drop down and get to the building with two crucible knights. Go through it and eventually you'll find him, he's literally in front of the double gargoyle fight.
You didn't actually kill Sellen by the way! The one you see in Waypoint Ruins is a projection made by her. Try progressing the questline until you give her a new body using her primal glintstone and see what happens. :-)
fun fact: gostoc has different lines for killing him at different points in his quest. this may be true for others as well - guess you'll have to check them all.
Gostoc has a different line if you kill him after beating Godrick and it's something along the lines of "finally being set free", which I found pretty fitting albeit slightly depressing
on every single playthrough, i've killed varre, gostoc, haight, dungeater, and all the starving nomadic merchants, like the one in mt. gelmir. every time i went to buy something they just made me feel bad and they don't stop starving no matter how much money you give them
I killed Patches since he still had the boss health bar and I thought he was just trying to distract me from attacking him while he would transform into his second form. Nope, just killed an NPC that would have been very useful later on.
1st: you can kill Millicent after you give her the needle and cure her, but Gowry disappears then, BUT after she first visits Gowry's chair and moves then to the next location Gowry is back and you can kill both of them. 2nd: The real body of Sellen is trapped in a basement in Witchbane Ruins. I guess you can kill her there, and do it after already clearing her mirage, just to be sure? 3rd: You can kill D(evin) if you give him Twinned Armor that drops from D(arian) and then reload the area - after you do that he will be hostile and no longer protected. 4th: Rogier just dies if you progress through his quest that is not even long, and does only involve Fia and Ranni, after which Ranni can be effectively... un-miraged? 5th: Also if you proceed Fia's quest D(arian) just dies and then you can kill both Fia at the end of her questline AND D(evin), which is nice. 6th: You can also kill Rya if you proceed some into volcano manor questline. Then there's also lady Tanith at the end eating Rykard's corpse so you can kill her there also, which together with Bernahl, Patches and Diallos, killed before, effectively wipes out the entire volcano manor NPC crew. 7th: Also when you proceed the Volcano Manor quest a bit there's a bunch of NPC's to kill that you can't normally access, like Lionel or Juno Hoslow. And even more if you keep Bernahl and Patches alive to this point, as they have additional invasions for you, however you can then kill Bernahl only way later at Farum Azula where he invades you. But he still dies ;) and Patches is then at Shaded Castle. 8th: There's also Pidia to kill in a hidden location in Carian manor. And Seluvis. And Iggy. And i believe all of them can be killed there. 9th: And it seems like you forgot about Nepheli Loux in Stormveil Castle/Albinaurics Village. You can easily kill her. 10th: There's total of 17 nomadic/isolated/hermit merchants to slain. + 1 imprisoned merchant... + 1 Kale. That's a total of 19 merchants including Kale. 11th: There's also Ensha who will just invade you after obtaining Haligtree Secret Medallion (Right), so that also counts. 12th: Witch Hunter Jerren is also at thing. I belive you can kill him as early as in the Redmane Castle, after defeating Radahn. 13th: Finally, Dung Eater's real body is in the Sewergaol/ Subterrean Shuning Grounds, under the capitol. That narrows it down to leaving only Roderika, Hewg and Enia alive. I'm not counting the obvious ones that will just evaporate rather than die (like Ranni/Renna or Geowry) but let's assume that you killed their physical form ;) And since Gideon Ofnir is a bossfight already, he will die eventually. And i guess it would be suiting for this to be an actual challange run to kill them all and do the frenzied flame ending. As, you know, Irina still dies, you can still kill Edgar then later in Liurnia, and Hyetta also dies or can be killed after obtaining the frenzied flame. Therefore you can kill them all, defile their corpses, and then burn it all. Make all of them burn! Burn in hell! Them cross-eyed Hollows! There's no hope for anyone like them! The Gods will not have it! Die! Die! Die! Die! Die a thousand times again! Curses upon them! Upon them, and theirs, for generations eternal! All of them! Eternal pain and suffering! Lots and lots! A curse upon them... wait, i got carried away... anyways, yeah, might do that.
Actually you can't kill Gowry until Millicent dies even after she visits. Apprently he's not really there in person until he's either grieving or celebrating Millicent's death.
U can actually kill Sellen in the witchbane ruins. I killed her on my first playthrough trying to break her chains lol. The specter of Sellen disappears if u do that too. You can also kill Devin at the end of Fia's quest after he's gloating about killing her I think he has bonus dialog too.
i don’t care that gostoc tries to kill you, or that he steals some of your runes when you die in stormveil, his dying words makes me feel really fucking bad.
Thanks for being the experimental Psychopath none of us wanted to be, there's a lot of interesting, and moreover depressing stuff to be gleamed from all this.
@@xkillerq apparently for convenience some people want to collect all the merchant bells to give to the twin husk maidens so all their goods will be in one shop. Pretty fucked up
I recently found out in my own playthrough that Kenneth Haight drops a golden seed if you kill him,(which you showed in you video) given that completing his quest only gives you a crappy erdsteel dagger, it makes more sense to just off him immediately for the seed.
seeing u kill boc and alexander made me genuinely sad edit: oh and thops cuz he's basically a defenseless old man edit: oh and turtle pope... actually a lot of these are really upsetting
Rya moves to the top pf the Dectus elevator later in her questline so she might be vulnerable there. The spirit tuner moves to roundtable if you kill Godrick but she can also be found next to a pile of bodies that has her quest item. Not sure when she goes there though.
@@general_jellyfish4202 That only tells you the name of "D, Hunter of the Dead" i.e. the first D you meet. The questline never tells you the name of his twin, "D, Beholder of Death."
I love how NPCs have different death quotes depending on where you are in their quest. Attacking Ranni after you give her the ring is a different kind of emotional turmoil, I’ll just tell you from experience.
@@Shane2444 What hopest thou to profit? Hmph. So, this is the measure of my Lord? Perhaps it is precisely what I deserve. ...For surrendering myself to delusion.
First of all... I would like to say is: *"Thank you for the sacrifice you have shown us."* I have seen what the comments telling how they are *not forgiving* this player for doing such a thing to the NPCs especially the one that are harmless and sweets in this dark and cruel world. However... I just wanted to say that... While some of them really deserves it, due to their story quests that made them end up for us to feel disgusting that we wish to slay them early on. *Note that:* There is still that is a lot of the other NPCs like I have mentioned earlier, those NPCs that are either, harmless, or sweets or even both sweets and harmless in this video. What I meant that, in this video, it has taught us. *DO NOT DO THIS!* 😅
Probably wouldn't be hard in NG+ with some of the lifesteal built into the game, but doing that on a 1st playthrough sounds like a monumental challenge.
I've thought about trying this.. it's inherently impossible though since at least some of the bosses require you to use portals and those respawn enemies as well. But I suppose the next best thing would be to kill as many things as you can without respawning. So no fast travel, no resting, no dying and no teleporting (which may or may not include the trapped chests). Good luck!
@@ElProf Check out some of the WR speedruns. I have a feeling people can get around some of the portal issues through some very clever abuse of animation interactions of block and forward propelling them at mach 5 speeds. Now that I think about it. I'm not sure the WR holder actually uses portals. A bit outside of the intended scope of a no grace run, but theoretically possible.
Oof, watching Alexander and the little pot get clapped as well as Miriel was really brutal. I love how some NPCs literally have golden passive barriers that prevent you from killing them.
I can forgive the vast majority of these but you crossed the line when you killed Turtle Pope.
Aaa...aaargh!
when he killed boc Sadge
Also Boc was over the line. Hearing his last words being "mum, i've let you down" hurts.
Edit: MOTHERFUCKER, I JUST REMEMBERED RODERIKA! NOT MY RODERIKA!
when he killed jar-bairn tho😭
Dog ahead
“You’ve cracked my heart” 😢
“Please don’t crack the others” 😩
I felt that
I almost cried TBH
For the sake of the run he should crack the others
You already know this sadist went out of his way to commit jar genocide after hearing this
@@hussamtahir915 i actually did before going to Ng+3 out of curiosity
This just made me realize how nice most of these NPCs are compared to almost every other souls game
Alexander "Was my whole existence... just a crock?"
I laughed way too hard at this crock pot joke
His death quote shouldn't be that funny lmao
Tbh I feel like Alexander is the catarina knight of ER
Literally facepalmed at this dad joke
that makes me want corned beef and cabbage
Are you slow? It has nothing to do with a crockpot. The word crock simply means a pot. It’s called a double entendre.
Edit: for a further explanation: "crock" is short for the phrase "crock of shit", which is a reference to chamber pots. The phrase basically means the same as "bull shit". I wouldn't expect the idiot kids who play Elden ring to get this
@@sublimesense7761 Whoa, easy there...
I will not forgive anyone who hurts Boc, Pope Turtle and Jar-Bairn. The little Jar was literally a child.
I always kill Boc
@@amon1085 you monster he just a little rat that need love ! 🐭 JK Not really how dare you!? 😲 lol
@@amon1085 How is your relationship with your mother?
@@chipbutty3645 no u
@@amon1085 no u * infinity +1
Props to Patches for being the definition of "how to be annoying even while dying".
Nah he knows what’s up. Every world in Souls is a shit show, our goal is always to end the world or just change its path
Not gonna lie, after patches kicked me in the back I snapped and went back to kill him
I felt my soul gutted out piece by piece with every fallen NPC...
If it helps quite a few of these are merciful in comparison to completing their quests xD
i dont feel bad for the old hag i dont like them and i do NOT trust them ! They can curse me all they want !
Except varré
@@themaidenlesswretch7819 all my homies hate varre
even patches?
Props to patches for knowing that pranks are always risky
You're not supposed to kill him?
@@DragonHuman00 yeah if you want to do a quest with him.
@@DragonHuman00 when he gives up, stop talking and he will sell you things
@@smokeybear6404 huh i got a pearl that let me buy his stuff anyways
@@DragonHuman00 because you killed him, but he tells you useful information in his questline
i cannot forgive killing the merchants, Alexander the Warrior Jar, Turtle Pope, Yura, Nepheli, and Blaidd
heartless, maidenless brute😭
I mean don't go back to rannis rise after you finish her quest then
@@Scyclo in a similar vein, don't go to Farum Azula either
WHAT ABOUT BOC
Blaidd doesn't care. What use is it to kill a shadow?
lol I always kill the merchants. Wouldn't want to run all the way through an area just because I couldn't afford the merchandise at that moment
Boc's death is honestly one of the most saddening things I've seen in the entire series and that's saying something
His last words were just about how he didn't want to be a disappointment to his mum, the poor guy...
Kenneth Haight and D, too. Kenneth sounds so betrayed, while D just seems sad that he's leaving his brother alone.
Fr 😭😭
I love boc, it really hurt seeing him die.
Dies anyway if you give him a larval tear
Dude, I’m on my first play through, I alt/tabbed on second monitor to research the Npc and when I clicked back into Elden ring that apparently counts as an attack and I killed him in one blow :( you can’t even bring him back either, very sad times.
One way to look at it is that only a few of those characters can have a happy ending anyways. In a sense, you're doing them a favor by killing them (some of them anyway). A few NPC actually end up worst off after you've helped them.
I can not get over Turtle Popes death. That was the most heart wrenching thing to watch😭.
Turtle that not right? It's a dog.
Yeah. Had to give the vid a Thumbs down b/c of that. The "almost" should have been Mr. Turtle Pope.
*dog pope
No, if you don't save best snek it's far worse :(
Yeah that was sad, looks like they gave him 100k health to try to prevent this from happening lol. I kill the merchants sometimes because they’re often in terrible locations but I feel bad killing them
I like how the first guy uses his last breath to call you a virgin one last time
Patches saying "What a shit show." is so on-brand for him.
I'm sorry, but it made me burst out laughing.
I love how he behaves in ER, based on his dialogue it’s almost as if he’s aware of all the other worlds he’s lived in and much of what he says seems like he’s talking directly to us veterans who’ve encountered and forgiven him countless times in the previous games. One of the quotes is “It's the same old story, everywhere I go. Ah, to hell with it all.” He’s talking about the survivors of the defeated army he’s working with, but it really feels like he’s also referencing the other universes. And this is kinda the overarching objective of Souls games, instead of saving the world or having some honorable goal these games don’t glorify the world and the powers that be, your ultimate goal is to say “to hell with it all” and make your own decision about the fate of everything, and it’s never totally good because of the nature of these realities
@@D1sc0rd- Forgive patches? Couldn't be me. I've been pushed into too many holes and seen one too many Siegwards get their armour yoinked but the worst offender has got to be when spider patches made some motherfucker shit my pants.
I ain't gonna lie this is extremely depressing. I can't bring myself to kill any of these people. Most of them are too kind
Idk Varre is pretty douchie. So is that bridge guy.
@@porkerpete7722 oh I killed varre but with his quest
@@porkerpete7722 I mean Varre gives you access to the most op farming spot in the game fairly early if you do his quest
lol, amazing how games work on the human psychy. I killed on merchant so I could get his bell bearing and I still feel guilty. almost turned myself in to the County Police.
I can
The amount of lore in even their final words is so amazing
Fun fact, if you kill blaidd after rahdan and sit at the grace he respawns and immediately fights you again
Now I know why my mate was screaming after radahn but wouldn't tell any of us why
Hes like that in general at the start
He even asks if you think you could kill a shadow
Because that's all he is, Rannis shadow
@@Joyous395 spoiler alert… yes you can kill a shadow
@@WVRLORD a baleful shadow, yes. But he isn't physical when you attack him in mistwoods or before Rannis ending
As you see Godfrey has a shadow that he kills only after it becomes physical
I just realized something. Do all the empyreans have shadows like Marika? Godfrey is just her husband tho so why does he get one? Is it just the grace given?
i cannot get over the merchant laugh
it sounds like Sans lmao
2:06
@@yournans_fridge969 more like Elemer Fudd.
Or peter griffin
@@yournans_fridge969 I will gonna say that lmao
Blaidd "you're strong of arm. But ask yourself. What harm can be done... to a shadow?" that line is so damn good!
Really goes to show how many characters there are in this game, and that wasn't even all of them
Poor Boc 😭 he just wanted to become a seamster like his mum, he didn't deserve this
I feel guilty just watching a video of him being offed. Wanna start a new game just to get avenge him yet again in that cave lol
@@MinecraftMartin just make sure not to give him the larval tear, I learnt that the hard way the first time around
@@maxwhite4732 Apperently you can use the wood carving that says :"You're beautiful"
@@maxwhite4732ko
I killed him by mistake inside his cave.
Killing jar bairn is on par with the loathsome dung eater
Yeah that shit actually fucked me up
And sweet prince Boc, too.
Like good content I guess and I watched it and I ain't actually hating on the man xD But I hate this video lol
THE SHRIEKING SHIT SHOVELLER
pretty sure even dung eater didn't kill a child. 😤
This is exactly what I did on the end of my first play through to see if there was a secret boss to unlock but all I got was depression..
The one boss that no one can beat. Cant bloodhound step away from the feels
The only boss you found was yourself🌚
Maybe in the end the real treasure was all the friends we killed along the way
@@raptorxrise5386 "try jump from high place"
Sans
I feel like an amazing twist is if one of the more villainous characters had a change of heart and tried to stop you. Or you get tag-teamed by a few of the bosses because you've just become the main antagonist.
That's one of the endings in For Answer.
If you become a villain in the ending, like becoming the lord of fremzied, milenia will hunt you down, i think it would be cool plot for the next elden ring series
@@MarilynMalkovich For Answer? what is that some game?
Armored core for anwser is a mech game with a lot of customization in it very fast paced game too. There is a number of branching paths in the game that let you get different endings depending on what you did. Game was made by From Soft as well.
@@rando2284 Miyazaki's second game.
"Your path only leads to death!"
Madness ending Followers: "Counting on it."
Praise the frenzied flame
i believe you mean enjoyers
may chaos take the world
MAY CHAOS TAKE THE WOOOOOOOORRRRRLLLD!!!
MAY CHAOS TAKE THE WORLD!
5:00 was timed so perfectly 😭
I find it hilarious that some NPCs like Roderika have a super shield, just to make sure you don’t miss out on the ash summoning feature.
"RPG"
I think thats pretty garbage
@@xeibei4804 TBF, It’s probably equally as garbage having an entire aspect of the game ruined for you just because you set your controller down and imputed a heavy attack by mistake.
Well I think it's a good feature, shootout to the time I killed milicent by accident after jumping on her, after the fight with her sisters.
@Zeldaplayer 67 It's not a matter of oneshotting them, just a matter of doing enough damage and triggering hostilities
My first reaction was "how sad, killing everyone... most of them are so nice..."
But then I realized that, by finishing their questline, I've also killed them all.
(I mean even the one with a golden barrier are killable if you do their quest)
not the kid jar. He lives 😤
also Boc if you do the "You're beautiful"
@@navneetyadav7139 yeah but I mean, by doing Pot kid quest, his entire village and his uncle are now dead. And of course Boc's good ending is nearly impossible to find. So I killed him.
@@aureldocks me exploring all of atlus plateau before even getting the option to indirectly kill Boc, therefore having the necessary item to save him, and knowing to use it due to the description saying it's a demihunan voice: yes
How do they all die?
@@thein8ererator518 BIG SPOILERS AHEAD : EVERY NPC's DEATH/END OF THEIR QUESTLINE
*inhales
- Thops will be found dead at the bottom of the academy
- Rogier dies of the black roots infecting his body
- Boc will die if he tries to rebirth
- D is killed by Fia at the roundtable
- D's brother left his armor set and sword at the end of D's questline (death unsure)
- brother corrin is not confirmed dead but you can find his clothing and bellbearing at the very end of the game (he killed himself or became a nudist)
- same goes for Goldmask
- Bernahl will invade you in Farum Azula, so you have to kill him yourself
- Pidia will be killed by his own puppets
- Alexander challenges you in a duel, ending in you killing him
- Yura will be possessed by Shabriri
- Varré will be invaded by you in Mogh's palace (and of course, you kill that bloody bastard)
- Fia is killed by D's brother
- Irina ends up killed by bandits
- Edgar (her father) becomes a vengeful spirit and invades you
- Diallos dies defending Jarburg against the perfumers
- Gideon Ofnir is basically one of the last bosses
- Hyetta asks you to use the flame of frienzy on her (which, surprisingly, kills her)
- Dungeater dies due to the Curse I guess
- Selvius is assassinated by black knives at the End of Ranni's quest line
- Same for Iji
- Blaidd (aka best boi) becomes mad and attacks you
- Gowry will be found dead you accept to kill Milicent
- Milicent dies by removing the needle that protected her from the scarlet rot (or killed by you if you chose to invade her)
- Latenna... dies at the very beginning of her questline, becoming a spirit willingly
- Ensha invades you
- Jerren can live if you choose his side against Sellen, if you choose her side you kill him and...
- Sellen ends up in a Ball of masks (alongside Azur and Lusat it seems) because she tried to take over Raya Lucaria
- Big Boggart is killed by the Dung Eater
- Rya asks you to kill her
... and that's it. Some of them have a good ending, like Boc, Jerren, Nepheli Loux, Gowry or Rya but death is one of their questline's valid end.
The one with "good ending" (or at least that get to live) are :
- Kenneth Haight
- Pat
- Gostoc
-Tanith
- Jar Bairn
- Erika
And of course Ranni.
(note that I only listed npc with real questline, so finger reader, the spirits or merchant are not listed).
Hope this has been helpful. So if there is one lesson to be learned from all of this, it would be this : you want to help theses people ? Leave them alone.
what we learned from this video:
1. almost every NPC in Elden Ring has a sad dialogue when they’re dying
2. Leviathan is a menace
Boc calling for his mum legitimately broke my heart
Better not kill him near the end of his quest, because he was literally asking you to forgive him when you yourself killed him out of god knows what
Dude the kid jar was horrible :(
“You’ve...cracked my heart...please...don’t crack the others...”
This is how my nephew plays any game he kills all npcs while laughing and telling me to look.
Boc, turtle pope, little pot, Alexander has me crying inside
Cracked my heart
Same😢
Alexander violently exploded
You can actually kill sellen but when she is chained up during her questline ... I was trying to free her by hitting her chains with me sword , you can guess the rest lol
That's not her...
@@aeriagloris4211 it is
@@aeriagloris4211 the chained body is her real body. You pull her soul out of it during her questline
Same dude
Same 😂 I hit her a bit to hard with my inferno crozier,
3:13 Turtle Pope: "I cannot die"
*whirling blade of doom*
"Wait aaaAAAARGGHH***"
Oh you sick monster
Is this the new speedrun strat? After all, almost every NPC's quest ends in them dying, so you might as well skip to the end step.
OK you can skip to the end of Varre's quest, but you'll never have an audience with mohgwyn, and a massive part of the game is now removed
@@ethereal5322 you can get there via a portal in the consecrated snowfield.
@@alexandervowles3518 i had no idea
@@ethereal5322 what's up first half lol
@@ethereal5322 its in the northwest part of the area near the cliff
Bro this video legit gave chills with the creepy music and boc saying he let down his mum
The saddest one by far. "Mum" will haunt my dreams. I'm so glad I helped him in my game
That creepy music is the Ikana Canyon theme from The legend of Zelda Majoras Mask.
I feel so bad i killed boc at the start because it took me so long to figure out he was in the tree , i killed him out of pure rage
@vv109 what?
@@recht_voor_zijn_raap5506 I am so glad someone pointed this out. Loved that game and that soundtrack is burned into memory
You can kill Millicent actually. If you progress her questline until right after the godskin apostle fight in Altus she can be slain to get Millicent's Prosthetic.
Even in Varre's last breathe
He has the passion to roast Tarnished
Literally dying
Heh What I should expect from a maidenless.. Hah ahaha.. *Dies*
You can just do their quests. Killing (almost) every NPC is intended gameplay.
Except patches, that bastered probably got away somehow
I noticed this. I don't get attached to them anymore...
Blaidd... 🥺
Lmaooooo that's deeeepp💀💀💀💔
@@SadCoffeeBear same
@@salmason1256 That's what she said
You can kill Millicent after healing her with the Golden Needle, then you can kill Gowry for real after killing Millicent.
You can't kill him for real, he was never there.
Gowry is a mind controlled insect man.
The real gowry is manipulating the pest.
@@amineelyoussoufi4371 it's his real body after you complete her quest line. Don't know about killing her early though
He straight up kills himself if you continue Millicent's quest and betray Millicent when if gives you the choice.
Fun fact you actually get invaded by her in the scarlet rot lake and she has the wild swing skill so yeah watch out I guess
Law:
Cannot kill dog pope.
Cannot kill Jar-bairn.
Cannot kill Alexander until the end of his questline.
What about Boc?
I'll give Alexander a warriors death either way, might as well speed up the process, especially because he ends up killing my favorite dragon in the game by progression of his story,... hint... its where you kill alexander
Dog pope alright, everyone else don't care a single bit
I love Alexander but he drops a very good talisman and his quest is a pain in the ass without a guide
@@vizic9561 really I was able to complete it without. It's more luck based on whether you meet him in certain places rather than complex objectives. Definitely simpler than rannis questline for sure
For those wondering what the music is, it’s the theme of Ikana Valley, one of the areas of LoZ: Majora’s Mask.
This was brutal to watch honestly. Miriel, Boc and Jar Bairn were particularly gut wrenching.
Gowry’s dialogue coupled with the pests body and eerie music gave me maximum chills.
Huh
Yea that's still kinda creeping me out what exactly is our ole buddy gowry?
@@dakarai47 ... he's a pest dude, my dude. didn't you notice, wit your eyes?
@@tylermech66 I mean duh but no other pest talks,can seemingly switch bodies, and has ulterior motives its obvious more to him than just being a regular pest
@@dakarai47 his "human" form is just an illusion, and where did you get that Pests can't talk?
they are sapient creatures , and can cast magic. It's not a stretch to think they can either talk or use magic to speak for them.
Not gonna lie, I did laugh a little when Alexander asked if his whole existence was "just a crock"
RIP, you were the best crock pot a tarnished could know
Boc and Pope are the only NPCs that deserve a chance and I will NEVER-EVER harm them under any circumstance.
They are the epitome of kindness in this cruel world.
what about lil pot boy and alexander the pot
@@vomix9370 Roderika as well.
What about patches
what about diallos? he literally tried to save the pot people.
@@chipbutty3645 It's just a prank, bro.
If you killed D, give his brother the armor and reload the area, he'll be hostile and you can kill him. Or just kill him at the end of Fia's questline. Same goes for Rya, you can kill her at the end of her questline. Also you missed Tanith. And Hyetta and Shabriri, technically.
shabriri is hyetta(irina) and yura at the end of their quests
@@jinji_xo Sure, but they have different death dialogue, which I assumed was the point of this video.
where can i find D brother?
@@kakagakakerger4165 go to Nokron, where you fight the second Ancient Moose, and check out the borders of this place. You should see a way to drop down and get to the building with two crucible knights. Go through it and eventually you'll find him, he's literally in front of the double gargoyle fight.
Do you get the sword from D's brother if you kill him there?
“Is my own existence just a crock.”
Classic Alexander
You didn't actually kill Sellen by the way! The one you see in Waypoint Ruins is a projection made by her. Try progressing the questline until you give her a new body using her primal glintstone and see what happens. :-)
She gets an existence worse than death if you help her completely through her quest.
@@aashishbadami95 how exactly does she turn into that ball anyway
@@asersah Rennala I believe
I couldn't find her body before I finished the game (and her Flintstone shook) where is her body, so I know for NG+?
@@HowDz2 In the western ruins in the Weeping Peninsula. Don't have the name off the top of my head but I think it's the Witchbane Ruins
fun fact: gostoc has different lines for killing him at different points in his quest. this may be true for others as well - guess you'll have to check them all.
Or check the wiki
@@loto7197 shush, its funnier if we force him to make the video all over again
@@quanariin1290 he can just edit his video
Alexander has another when you encounter him in Farum Azula
Or not
you chasing Kalés horse made me choke on my water i’m crying
3:16 Nooooo, not the pope turtle!! I'm crying 😭😭😭😭😭
This is incredibly disturbing to me for some reason. Even more disturbing than the same thing in Dark Souls.
The intervals where it’s just your character smiling with fire eyes made me laugh ngl
Gostoc has a different line if you kill him after beating Godrick and it's something along the lines of "finally being set free", which I found pretty fitting albeit slightly depressing
5:22 actually hurt
Cmon coz😪
on every single playthrough, i've killed varre, gostoc, haight, dungeater, and all the starving nomadic merchants, like the one in mt. gelmir. every time i went to buy something they just made me feel bad and they don't stop starving no matter how much money you give them
Lord Of The Frenzied Flames Is The True Embodiment Of Maidenless Behavior
Ironically. It’s the one which saves your maiden.
It would have worked on a beta tarnished. But im based and cannot read. Its time to chew ass and kick gum.
Lord Of The Frenzied Flame is the best ending lol better than simping for 2 hoes that treat u like a crock of shite and 1 guy who eats shit.
Are you sure?
small price to pay
Me-
Kills NPC: Yeah! get them! LOL!
Attempts to kill the donkeys: How dare you?!
I only see Dog…
@@superbroshd6393 funny...
the majority of them
“how could this happen…
________ i failed you…”
3:56 had me dying
I killed Patches since he still had the boss health bar and I thought he was just trying to distract me from attacking him while he would transform into his second form. Nope, just killed an NPC that would have been very useful later on.
You've done right! F**** Patches. This guy is a pain in the ars since Demon Souls. Literally.
Patches the hyena or patches the betrayer should explain a thing or two
I was spamming attacks when he started asking for mercy. I wished to but i couldnt stop the animations...
Yes I came back like lvl 150 and had rivers of blood, just LT deleted him........oops
I love how you stopped chasing the horses LOL
you forgot to show how blaidd re-spawns endlessly even after you kill him
Nani?!
@@Sorrowdusk what harm can be done to a shadow?
1st: you can kill Millicent after you give her the needle and cure her, but Gowry disappears then, BUT after she first visits Gowry's chair and moves then to the next location Gowry is back and you can kill both of them.
2nd: The real body of Sellen is trapped in a basement in Witchbane Ruins. I guess you can kill her there, and do it after already clearing her mirage, just to be sure?
3rd: You can kill D(evin) if you give him Twinned Armor that drops from D(arian) and then reload the area - after you do that he will be hostile and no longer protected.
4th: Rogier just dies if you progress through his quest that is not even long, and does only involve Fia and Ranni, after which Ranni can be effectively... un-miraged?
5th: Also if you proceed Fia's quest D(arian) just dies and then you can kill both Fia at the end of her questline AND D(evin), which is nice.
6th: You can also kill Rya if you proceed some into volcano manor questline. Then there's also lady Tanith at the end eating Rykard's corpse so you can kill her there also, which together with Bernahl, Patches and Diallos, killed before, effectively wipes out the entire volcano manor NPC crew.
7th: Also when you proceed the Volcano Manor quest a bit there's a bunch of NPC's to kill that you can't normally access, like Lionel or Juno Hoslow. And even more if you keep Bernahl and Patches alive to this point, as they have additional invasions for you, however you can then kill Bernahl only way later at Farum Azula where he invades you. But he still dies ;) and Patches is then at Shaded Castle.
8th: There's also Pidia to kill in a hidden location in Carian manor. And Seluvis. And Iggy. And i believe all of them can be killed there.
9th: And it seems like you forgot about Nepheli Loux in Stormveil Castle/Albinaurics Village. You can easily kill her.
10th: There's total of 17 nomadic/isolated/hermit merchants to slain. + 1 imprisoned merchant... + 1 Kale. That's a total of 19 merchants including Kale.
11th: There's also Ensha who will just invade you after obtaining Haligtree Secret Medallion (Right), so that also counts.
12th: Witch Hunter Jerren is also at thing. I belive you can kill him as early as in the Redmane Castle, after defeating Radahn.
13th: Finally, Dung Eater's real body is in the Sewergaol/ Subterrean Shuning Grounds, under the capitol.
That narrows it down to leaving only Roderika, Hewg and Enia alive. I'm not counting the obvious ones that will just evaporate rather than die (like Ranni/Renna or Geowry) but let's assume that you killed their physical form ;) And since Gideon Ofnir is a bossfight already, he will die eventually.
And i guess it would be suiting for this to be an actual challange run to kill them all and do the frenzied flame ending. As, you know, Irina still dies, you can still kill Edgar then later in Liurnia, and Hyetta also dies or can be killed after obtaining the frenzied flame. Therefore you can kill them all, defile their corpses, and then burn it all. Make all of them burn! Burn in hell! Them cross-eyed Hollows! There's no hope for anyone like them! The Gods will not have it! Die! Die! Die! Die! Die a thousand times again! Curses upon them! Upon them, and theirs, for generations eternal! All of them! Eternal pain and suffering! Lots and lots! A curse upon them... wait, i got carried away... anyways, yeah, might do that.
Thank you Gideon Ofnir the all knowing.
Doesn't Enia also die after you burn the Erdtree?
@@p.b.9364 Right, i wrote that before i got to Faarum Azula.
Edge lord
Actually you can't kill Gowry until Millicent dies even after she visits. Apprently he's not really there in person until he's either grieving or celebrating Millicent's death.
And here I thought I was a monster for killing merchants for convenience.
3:50 now this brings me joy
rip pot and turtle pope 😞
Wow Mox
Boc?
Hey moxxy
U can actually kill Sellen in the witchbane ruins. I killed her on my first playthrough trying to break her chains lol. The specter of Sellen disappears if u do that too. You can also kill Devin at the end of Fia's quest after he's gloating about killing her I think he has bonus dialog too.
"Hey babe I'm here for a hu---"
...
...
**draws sword**
Jar Bairn will be missed
Elden Ring Genocide Run
"Father, please be safe"
He ain't safe G
It's rly kind of uncomfortable to watch, and gotta admit those zooms on the character's frenzy eyes are scary af
3:07 nooooooo
1:36 Unforgivable
People with an iron deficiency in the morning: 2:59
I laughed harder than I thought I would've when you chased after the donkey.
I felt bad :(
@@bloodlustphuture Yeah, I felt bad when Boc got killed.
AHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA SAME REACTIONS. I was like, 'oh shit, he ain't ever gonna let even the donkey live!'
i don’t care that gostoc tries to kill you, or that he steals some of your runes when you die in stormveil, his dying words makes me feel really fucking bad.
this legitimately scared me. ive been wanting to do a genocide run before but i think this just scared me straight...
Thanks for being the experimental Psychopath none of us wanted to be, there's a lot of interesting, and moreover depressing stuff to be gleamed from all this.
2:06 what have i ever done? Heh heh heh 😂
'Sans Noise'
Whenever I kill a merchant I feel like I need to kill the horse too. I never want one to suffer without the other😭
@@xkillerq apparently for convenience some people want to collect all the merchant bells to give to the twin husk maidens so all their goods will be in one shop. Pretty fucked up
They did such a great job with the voice lines in this game, some of them are genuinely sad.
1:43 "Was my whole existence... just a crock?"
A crockpot, yes.
Man...That Frenzied eyes montage...It´s like the absolute descend to the madness. So cool.
I recently found out in my own playthrough that Kenneth Haight drops a golden seed if you kill him,(which you showed in you video) given that completing his quest only gives you a crappy erdsteel dagger, it makes more sense to just off him immediately for the seed.
If you follow his quest all the way to the end you get an ancient smithing stone
There are so many on the world that you don't need, I maxed out the flasks and still had some on iventory, no ng+
@@Yuri-xx2gi yeah, I have max flasks too and still 9 seeds left over
There are excessive numbers of Golden Seeds in just 1 playthrough.
golden seed is plenty, no need of that
Minute 1:06
Player: kills merchant
Merchant’s donkey: “FTS I’m out”
"what happens when--"
either drowns out any dialogue whirligigging donkeys or cuts to the next event without letting them finish. 8.5/10
seeing u kill boc and alexander made me genuinely sad
edit: oh and thops cuz he's basically a defenseless old man
edit: oh and turtle pope... actually a lot of these are really upsetting
"lovable sort ahead"
"could this be friend?"
"likely friend"
-tarnished
Killing Turtle Pope is like killing Paarthunax in Skyrim. "I know what I must do, but I don't know if I have the strength to do it!:
Rya moves to the top pf the Dectus elevator later in her questline so she might be vulnerable there. The spirit tuner moves to roundtable if you kill Godrick but she can also be found next to a pile of bodies that has her quest item. Not sure when she goes there though.
rya can be killed at some point. roderika always has plot armour tho.
@@Jman0163 Oh right her questline takes her outside of the Volvano Manor after you find out her sssecret.
"Was my whole existence just a crock?"
Wonderful
Huh, is that the only way to find out D's brother's name?
Who is the brother of the man, whos name is D
You can know it at the end of Fia's quest.
@@general_jellyfish4202 That only tells you the name of "D, Hunter of the Dead" i.e. the first D you meet. The questline never tells you the name of his twin, "D, Beholder of Death."
Deez Nuts
Nice use of a frenzied warming stone while not having the frenzied flame, it makes it shoot out your eyes and take frenzied status effect
Ranni: Did you do it Tarnished one?
Tarnished: Yes.
Ranni: And what has thy took?
Tarnished: Everything.*tears*
Alexander still with the pot puns after being reduced to sherds.
I love how NPCs have different death quotes depending on where you are in their quest.
Attacking Ranni after you give her the ring is a different kind of emotional turmoil, I’ll just tell you from experience.
What does she say? I don't think I'll ever try it but I want to know
@@Shane2444 What hopest thou to profit?
Hmph. So, this is the measure of my Lord? Perhaps it is precisely what I deserve. ...For surrendering myself to delusion.
@@Thunderscent damn, I'm glad I don't have to actually hear that. Thanks tho
@@Thunderscent "for Godwyn" should be the last thing she hears
First of all... I would like to say is:
*"Thank you for the sacrifice you have shown us."*
I have seen what the comments telling how they are *not forgiving* this player for doing such a thing to the NPCs especially the one that are harmless and sweets in this dark and cruel world.
However... I just wanted to say that... While some of them really deserves it, due to their story quests that made them end up for us to feel disgusting that we wish to slay them early on.
*Note that:* There is still that is a lot of the other NPCs like I have mentioned earlier, those NPCs that are either, harmless, or sweets or even both sweets and harmless in this video. What I meant that, in this video, it has taught us. *DO NOT DO THIS!*
😅
I’m gonna need a how to on how to kill every enemy and boss without resting a site of grace
Probably wouldn't be hard in NG+ with some of the lifesteal built into the game, but doing that on a 1st playthrough sounds like a monumental challenge.
@@BigChimpEnergy people beating game with ,,no damage" challange, I belive this is more or less the equivalent of this
I've thought about trying this.. it's inherently impossible though since at least some of the bosses require you to use portals and those respawn enemies as well.
But I suppose the next best thing would be to kill as many things as you can without respawning. So no fast travel, no resting, no dying and no teleporting (which may or may not include the trapped chests). Good luck!
@@ElProf Check out some of the WR speedruns. I have a feeling people can get around some of the portal issues through some very clever abuse of animation interactions of block and forward propelling them at mach 5 speeds. Now that I think about it. I'm not sure the WR holder actually uses portals. A bit outside of the intended scope of a no grace run, but theoretically possible.
Oof, watching Alexander and the little pot get clapped as well as Miriel was really brutal. I love how some NPCs literally have golden passive barriers that prevent you from killing them.