MLB Blown Calls Leading To Ejections - April 2019
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 жов 2024
- Here are all of the plays from April that an umpire got wrong then proceeded to eject the player or manager for arguing the call. Note : There were a few plays that I debated on putting in here, such as Brandon Hyde arguing the sliding rule and Manny Machado being thrown out for tossing his bat in front of a catcher while going down the line. I decided against these plays because to me you could see the umpire's point of view for why the call was made the way it was, these are plays that they blatantly got incorrect.
Also sorry for the huge gap between videos, with finals, vacation, and working a job again I got very caught up with everything and struggled to have time to find interesting video ideas.
Huge shout out to MLB Ejection Tracker for compiling a video that contains every ejection from the month, from there I cut out plays that either had the correct call made, or plays involving batters being thrown at. If you want to see every ejection from the month, I highly recommend you check out that channel.
Check out my second channel : / aabbbcccdddify
This channel will feature sports video game gameplay
Anyone else notice it's the same umpires? Randazzo, Hernandez, Kulpa who are constantly blowing calls?
Yeah Joe West used to be on that list but he doesn't blow as many as he used to. I just think its crazy how these umpires are still in the league with as many blown calls as they have on a game to game basis.
They stink!!!
Ron kulpa is an ass really !
Brian Chambers Thank the umpire union for protecting these trash ass umpires from getting fired/suspended.
@@nicholaswong4537 Smug Ass Kulpa needs go!
MLB needs to start firing/suspending incompetent umpires.
And putting them on diets.
I agree. I'd use replay on strikes if these umpires can't get a call right then take it out of their hands
Some of them seem to think they never get anything wrong, the bad thing is a lot of those bad calls changed the outcome of the games.
Agreed!!! Lets start with smug ass Kulpa
Charles M What fun would that be🤣. Umpires where do they go for training for this career?
I love the camera angle from the top of homebase. It shows clearly if it was actually off the base or not
sss kkkooosss we need this view far more often than it’s shown. When we have a pitch that’s close to the top/bottom of the zone we need a face-on view. When we have a outside/inside pitch we need an overhead view. Yet what we get most of the time is a view from over the pitcher’s shoulder from the outfield, the worst possible view for ALL pitches.
Ikr, and I feel as if the umpire would have a similar view to that, just lower of course. Regardless, they still make terrible calls.
Here's the deal.
Couple things. First, because the umpire has to position himself on one side of the catcher or the other, it changes his "eye" or perspective. Batters are trained to realize this. Also batters should be paying attention to that umpires stroke zone. Most umpires are consistent the entire game. The players quickly realize this and they prepare for it.
Second, a good umpire is not going to give a hitter too much leeway on close pitches. These guys are professionals and should be at the plate ready to hit.
Not be looking for walks.
That may appear unjust or incorrect to some .
But this is the way it is. This is baseball.
Look gang, its way better than it used to be.
Before MLB started with stationing umpire supervisors at every game , strikes were called based on where the catcher set up.
For example if the catcher was 6 inches off the plate and the pitcher hit the glove without making the catcher move, those were strikes.
Gregg Maddux made a living off his impeccable ability to locate his pitches by "hitting the keyhole".
That guy had the respect of umpires and they gave that leeway. MLB put a stop to this because it was in fact getting pretty ridiculous.
Now, pitches more than half a ball width off the plate see rarely called strikes.
Yet still batters are overly patient with greater than 50% of all p5iches thrown , the batter makes no attempt at swinging.
Yet, strikeouts are way up over say 10 years ago
5head.
It's called home plate, not home base.
I love Brandon Belt's reaction. He never loses his cool. But if anybody knows the strike zone, it's him. His reaction was warranted.
And watch Corbin walk off the mound. He knows what just happened.
2:20 This Ron Kulpa has any annoying sadistic face when he looks to throw someone out. Like he gets off on the power he has over the players/managers.
He's needed to fuck off to retirement for a loooong time.
Well that is the ejection he kept repeating " I can do what I want" so ya he prob does lol
He's a piece of shit
@@kasey446 He said it once, and in context the comment makes sense.
Hinch, who has a history of trying to tell umpires what they can and can't do, was telling Kulpa he can't be looking in their dugout. Kulpa is correct that he can look in there if he wants to, and if AJ Hinch would do HIS job and manage his dugout, Kulpa wouldn't have to do it for him.
I noticed that as well. I don't know if just his facial expressions or what, but he does seem to develop an arrogant smirk when he ejects someone. I swear he's worse than Hernandez.
The unsung heroes in these are the catchers making phenomenal frame jobs to fool the umpires. Notice how Grandal is in a lot of these, also Jeff Mathis, two of the best framers
Also Russel Martin
Damn man that is so true! U can see where they catch it and move right to the sweet spot! 😂
When commentators start with and as usual he throws him out .... you know that guy shouldn't be in charge of game
1:50 “no way! We knew the pitch he was gonna throw by their signal he was throwing it in the dirt!”
metalman5 😂😂😂
metalman5 😂😂😂😂😂
"And we relayed that to the batter, that's why he didn't swing!"
The ten people who disliked are 10 different umpires 😂😂
Brayden Fyffe 21
One of them is Angel Hernandez for sure
Roger Smith ty
Hgyvtfygyhuh Ygihvutctvnininnin ahahah fr
Hgyvtfygyhuh Ygihvutctvnininnin ahaha yup
1:12 The catcher starts with his glove down, then raises it up to catch the pitch, then keeps moving it up to hold the ball in the strike zone. Instead of holding his glove in the zone somewhere as a target for the pitcher, then having to bring his glove down to catch the pitch and then having to bring it back up into the strike zone.
A few other catchers did this too in the video. The umps need to get better at watching the pitch and not the ending position of the catcher’s gloves.
Yup, I agree some of these "professional" umpires need to watch some tape on just how badly they get CONNED by catchers "framing" balls that are WELL OUTSIDE the strike zone and pull them in. But then maybe if umpires set up properly they would see it.
The very fact that framing is an actual factor in calling balls and strikes is an indictment of how bad umpires are. I learned as a hack rec league umpire that you watch the ball as it crosses the plate, not where it lands in the catchers glove.
Alternative title: 15 minutes of arguments for an electronic strike zone.
Umps need to be ejected.
And mic them.
Just realized how much I miss baseball during this quarantine
Yeah , the ump makes a terrible call but then ejects the batter? They need to FINE the ump for being an idiot! MLB has turned into a joke.
Madison Greene agreed man, pro sports need to start punishing these shit calls
@@mikemathis2220 They do. Umps get fined and suspended
Yeah umpires today are tiny little pussies who only live to piss people off
@@pyropilot1421 then explain Angel Hernandez' s and that fat ass Joe West's woeful existence as umpires LOL. If I was as bad at my job as they are, my current coworkers would never know I even existed! LOL
Yeah a lot of sports are becoming terrible because of the umps... In football they basically aren't allowed to touch eachother without it being called targeting. In baseball, the umps are getting wprse vision, and in Soccer the players are be coming either mean or babies because of the faked injuries (no offense to any of these).
The technology exists today to take away balls and strikes from the umpires and make it absolutely reliable
You'll miss all the fun booing umpires and arguing calls. On average you'll get the same calls for and against.
It's actually being tested in the feeder leagues for the MLB. Hopefully implemented soon.
@@krisv8407 And hasn't proved to be any more accurate than human umpires.
Unfortunately the technology when tested in minor leagues, calls some rediculusly low looking breaking balls a strike
Yeah I agree that’s the fun of baseball.. giving shit to the umpires for calls and just the whole game! That’s what makes it interesting.. that it’s still human and mistakes can be made. Haha I kno it would be better in a way to have cameras but at the same time it’s good to have umpires! Lol
"They're making a muck of things."
They always do.
I’ve always wondered what the pitchers and catchers think during this.”Geez. Your horrible but thanks anyway”
12:02 is the best reaction by a commentator
This is an odd question but, can they fire bad umpires? Like x amount of mistakes gets you fired or?
Angel Hernandez would've been fired a long time ago if that were the case.
Guy says take the box away yet so many are clamoring for the box to replace the ump, lol. That second one hit the edge.
I’m a referee in hockey, so I know how hard it is to officiate. However it’s ok to make mistakes as they tell us but they always tell us if you make a mistake you can’t throw someone out if their right unless they really cross the line. Most coaches/managers shouldn’t have been thrown out here because they were right
Problem is the ONE thing you can’t do is argue balls and strikes. This really gives the umps carte blanch.
Alvin Wagner true
@@alvinwagner6745 And at least on the first one, it wasn't the argument-it tapping the dirt where he said the pitch was. Whether you're right or wrong, that'll get you tossed 95% of the time.
“As usual he misses a call and tosses the hitter “😂
The complete confusion of the Mets announcers at 11:25 was the funniest part of this
Ump blows the call. Then double downs and ejects someone because of their incompetence.
5:25 these were the worst. Always get help. I’m glad they fixed this.
Does anyone else watch these videos when they want to get mad
I watch them when I want laugh. Lol To me, they're so bad that it is funny.
When the Astros coach said there's nothing for you to worry about over her I started thinking about trash cans 😂
Eli Black samee
Har har. Come up with that all by yourself. They were in Arlington dipshit
@@tommygavin911 fuck you and fuck the stros
So i have a severe DYSLEXIA problem and i laughed so hard @ 5:50 if i dont laugh at myself, who will? #stinker
Bryce Harper loves yelling at umps and pitchers, but I think he should be yelling at his barber
Am I tripping or did that pitch at 13.30 look pretty damn good? I’m not sure if I’m missing it or what.. I kno the little foxtrac thing said it was out but it looked pretty good to me..
edit: ok the camera over the plate looked different but damn it looked good from the other view.. lol
2:15 ...because that mask came off and he was ready to tear into that Ass...tro dugout. I see what he did there lol
Javy Huerta lol that’s funny 😂😂😂
Man Zach Davies loves that low and outside fastball and so do the umps 😂
I've been out of the sport for a while. Why was he ejected at the beginning?
How come the stands for baseball are always empty?
How much is the fine if you knock out the umpire after getting ejected ?
A lot of clips showing bad calls by umpires 🤔🤔 is it getting worse season on season?
8:39 So this might confuse people because this situation is quite irregular. Regardless of the ball being hit into fair play, it hit Cano so the ball is dead. However, because he swung at the pitch, it is called a strike and the at bat continues as is.
What did the first hitter say? He just walked away after a small point.
Love or hate the astros, 3:00 is gold every time
Astros arguing balls and strikes cause they know what pitch was coming LMAO
The one taller ump throwing guys in the dugout out is a few fries short of a happy meal. They need to put him in the field.
6:07 that's the look my son gives me when he knows he messed up! LMAO!!
That 1st ejection was the definition of unjustified. Peralta doesn't even say anything to him
He drew a line in the dirt-pretty much an automatic ejection
@@joshvogt2651 This. Also observe that the batter just kept walking and made no argument. He knew he was gone when he did it.
@@joshvogt2651 He tapped the ground, no line was drawn.
If a line in the dirt is grounds for ejection, I hope the ump never set foot on a beach.
Its way past due these sorry umps start getting heavy fines, suspension's and terminated, for these constantly bad calls.
constantly bad calls? how stupid are you?
Have you ever been an umpire? Matter of fact. Have you ever been a human? Umpires are human. Humans make mistakes.
Ok, then let’s also fine, suspend and terminate players and managers for arguing correct calls and subsequently being ejected. Hint, you’ll have a lot more players fined than umpires!
@@blake60ah41 especially after they argue AFTER replay
I don’t see managers kicking umps out of games for arguing their shit call....I’ve reffed ice hickey for years and yeah sometimes there is a bad call but I’m making 45$ a game as opposed to several thousand so yeah these guys with bad track records need to be fined and if players overstep then the rules are in place to deal with them but to let shut refs and blues continue to red is absurd
After the game, the players are at the bar drinking with the umps.
12:02 LOL 😂
Love the reaction
It’s 2020, can we please get umpires miccd up! I wanna hear the arguments 😭
They need to start putting mics on every ump and every manager. This is must see TV.
The ump that tossed the Braves manager over that check swing knows he messed up.
I was at the first game the ejection was definitely uncalled for.
I'm a rangers fan and the pitch against the Astros was nearly in the dirt so I agree with the Astros
Fuck em. They had trash cans going.
Me: So, you’re telling me you’ll give me $50K if I play in this game, even if I don’t finish?
Me in the 1st inning: That’s bulls*** Mr. Ump. You fat fu** waste of space. Get some glasses!
Ump: You’re outta here!
Me in the clubhouse: Ahhh, free money.
MLB will always lack a certain credibility until they put a stop to these rouge umpires. It's the same few guys all the time and they are not held responsible for anything. I never thought I would say this but Bring On the RoboUmps
2:35 Ump notice the camera, trash can, and buzzer
Ham Sup Lo lmao Fr tho, they ass was prob sweating 😂
These guys are like weather forecasters wrong half the time and still have jobs!
cano did swing. the bat finished through the zone, its unfortunate that he got hit in the wrist but it was a dead ball strike. the commentators not knowing what was going on didnt help the situation. the argument is if he hadnt swung he wouldnt have been hit.
The Air Con Isn’t it immediately dead as soon as it hits the batter? The ball was dead before he even finished swinging. Fuck, the bat wasn’t even over home plate. The only reason the bat crossed home plate is because he dropped it because he got popped in the wrist. And bullshit, it doesn’t matter if your in the windup if your swing, or in the middle of it. If you didn’t swing you didn’t swing. If you got a strike called anyway even if you were in your load, you’d have to reverse the 2001 World Series, and get blasted by players and fans alike for being so fucking dumb.
Can anybody explain why the umpire isn’t always stood directly behind the plate??
watching like damn that's a ton of blown calls then realizing it was only for one month of games 🤦 the amount of blown calls in a season must be astronomical
Harper is the only player in baseball who can make me root for the umpires.
Agreed.
Carlos Gomez? Manny Machado?
Sounds like you have a personal vendetta.
With all fairness it’s where it passes the plate not with the catcher catches it
Dan Bellino's known for calling check swings himself without checking at 1st or 3rd.
Reminds me of that Cheers episode where Sam Malone was arguing with a retired umpire in his bar over over a blown pitch call many years ago. They argued and the ex ump refused to admit he was wrong. After he threw Sam out of his own bar he quietly admitted "Eh, maybe it was a strike, I was going through a divorce that year!". Managers HAVE to contest it, and umps HAVE to hold their own. It's just how it is.
This is where I’ll never understand MLB. Love baseball but having an umpire when you can literally livestream the strike zone and get accurate calls 100% of the time is ridiculous.
Calloway is literally Heddo from Rookie of the Year. And their both Mets.
5:35 the ball hit the ground and they called strike?
At the MLB level, do umps get fined or suspended for repeated bad calls?
Richard Wade unfortunately no
The only time the mlb tried to do something, when they tried banning angel hernardez from umping playoff games, he sued saying it was based of his race and the mlb lifted the ban
Echo Zero race card always wins, nothing to do with the fact he’s absolutely terrible at his job lol
Drw07 W yeah is it sucks
@@echozero8213 The second part of your post, the part about Angel Hernandez, is completely false.
hbk314 your right I was wrong about the mlb banning him, I had been given misinformation, but the part about angel Hernandez suing the mlb for discrimination is still true
Harper needs to do something with that hair. It’s hard to take him seriously when he’s ranting with a bouffant.
He looks like a werewolf and it is so hard not to laugh when he gets angry
Well mabey he shouldn't have signed with the Phillies
I'm still salty about that
@@charlesdolling42 yeah all about $$...
You can tell you fucked up when the Mets commentators who are very neutral and non biased are complaining lmao
While they were correct that it wasn't a swing, it was hilarious to listen to them thinking out loud forever before they finally figured it out.
Some of these are great strikes
Correct calls included in the video: 1:12, 1:48, 5:13, 12:05 (the call to Harper only), 13:20 (he gave him all day to walk away as well)
Calls within the margin of error: 4:39, 7:05
Gotta be a little more thorough than you were in going through the calls. Certainly none of the calls I listed above were "blatantly incorrect," and five of the seven were clearly correct.
1:12 and 1:48 were incorrect but not terrible calls, no idea how you look at 5:13 and call that a strike
Let me defend myself here, I left the Harper part in there just to give context as to why he was so upset about the call against cesar. Which maybe I shouldn't have done, but idk I felt like it made sense considering Harper most likely doesnt get that heated about the call on cesar. At 5:13 in my opinion he definetly didnt go around.
Ron Kulpa’s strike call was also correct. The k-zones are never calibrated for each hitter in real time, and post game analysis of the data shows this call in the strike zone.
@@ClosestToTheSun 1:12 and 1:48 were both conclusively in the zone, not even in the borderline (margin of error) range.
5:13 is definitely an offer.
Check out www.closecallsports.com for solid analysis.
@@bosten56 I debated including that in my list as well because it wasn't really the call he got tossed for. In that case I wanted to note more that it was a correct call than jump on you for including it. I think the context does help.
At 5:13, I'm basing my statement on my own opinion as well as the opinion of much more experienced umpires than I.
Here are two fixes: 1) remove the home plate umpire's ability to call strikes, and 2) if both managers agree, they have the ability to eject an umpire
Zach Davies must have a lot of drinking buddies in the umpiring crew.
I remember the game where Cano got hit. The umps were really blowing it all day.
I think it's funny listening to home play by play announcers when something is happening to their player they're like "oh how can the ump call that that?"
The biggest problem with these poor Umpires continually being allowed to make terrible calls and then being allowed to eject Players and Coaches to cover up the poor calls, is the corruption that exists within the MLB Commission, eject the corruption that exists within Commission, and you get rid of, and stop poor Umpires
make a bad call and then quickly walk away hoping for another umpire to step in between...cowards.
you don' t understand diffusing a situation then do you?
@@jfraz684 work in prison system. Can't make bad decision and run an and hide. They hide behind "can't argue..."with ump. No matter how bad they are
Best part to is when the umpires don’t even care they made a shit call and have a smile on their face when arguing with the coach after the ump ejects a player
i like how we all critique using replay what they have to do in real time
The Desmond strike call was definitely a strike. Painted the outside corner. Nothing to argue about.
two inches off the black.
@@tomy5868 No, it was a strike. The overhead camera is clearly not centered.
@@hbk314 camera fine. You are not centered
@@tomy5868 lol. It clearly wasn't two inches outside. Not even close.
@@hbk314 at least 2" off the black
The only requirement to be an umpire in the MLB, have a thin skin.
And a giant bloated chest
and a massive ego
I don't know if the 1st 2 are blown calls necessarily. They were obviously wrong...with replay and the imaginary square made up by the television. But blown call seems a bit extreme in those cases
at the end of the day, you still can't argue balls and strikes
Yeah because the League and Umpires KNOW they fuck up so much they don't wanna be embarrassed publicly.. entire reason that rule exist
I like how the score box says H0T1
the Mets hit by pitch, the home plate ump called time - hands clearly go up to signal dead play and base granted.
At least we now know why the astros were so confident that this pitch wasn’t a strike. 1:50
Announcers need to realize a strike is called due to where the ball crosses the plate and it's not where the catcher ends up catching it. Yes framing a pitch and mastery of being able to do so can and will help get the call most of the time. I can see why many of the curves are called strike due to the umpire believing he saw the ball catch the bottom of the strike zone.
Umpires need to start using their brains and not let their egos run the game.
12:55 how my manager at work yells at me for not getting work done on time even during this pandemic times
In the 1st vid.. baffles me that the ump is on the far right side of the plate but ringing dudes up with outside pitches on the far left side of the dish .. he cant even see that
Im waiting to watch one of these and just see an ump get decked
I know it wont happen
Almost happened with George Brett.
With the Desmond situation at the end, the commentators were missing the point that the coaches were doing a piss poor job of moving him off the field or even attempting to keep him away from the other umpire. If they want to complain about umpires putting their hands on players, at least make it seem like a legitimate argument.
gabe is a young buck who still hasnt seen enough baseball these umps arent scared of him
This is why I prefer Cricket. The umpires in cricket do not have a problem with being challenged and will actually ask for reviews themselves. MLB Umpires are really bad when it comes to keeping their cool.
The fact this is 15 minutes long says a lot about the umpiring.
Not really
I understand people are human and are gonna make mistakes. But it goes both ways sometimes you get a pitch that is called a strike when it was a ball and sometimes a ball when it’s a strike.
Never forget the time David Ortiz threw out the home plate ump 😂
The worst call was picking the job at being the commentator for the Astros
I'm sure some tech can be devoped aside from replays where strikes/balls can be called more accurately than say an umpire behind the plate
one of the greatest pitchers ever--Steve Carleton---would never have got out of A ball, if a "box" was used with him pitching. he admitted often that he rarely threw strikes, rather he threw pitches that looked good enough to be strikes but weren't
I've watched baseball my whole life and what I have never understood is they will throw a player out for saying just one word but when the manager comes out and argues with them and yells at them for like 20 - 30 seconds they don't throw them out. Like come on just give the players a break.
It depends on what's said.
Also, the manager is sort of like the team spokesman. He's the one who communicates with umpires. Assistant coaches get almost no rope. Players get more. Managers get most because it's their job to represent the team in communicating with the umpires.
"I'm a MLB umpire. I act like a little bitch cuz I can't handle being called out on bad calls. So I throw people out when they should be waiting for me outside to beat me to death cuz I act tough but can't fight." Lol