Commander "Enters The Battlefield" Tier List
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 сер 2024
- How would we rank the most played creatures with enters the battlefield abilities from A to Poop tier??
Shop through CoolStuffInc and use code "NERDS" at checkout to save 5% on your order!
www.coolstuffi...
Buying Dragon Shield product in the United States? Use our affiliate link!
bit.ly/DragonS...
Buying Dragon Shield product in the EU? Use this affiliate link:
bit.ly/DragonS...
Follow us on Moxfield!
www.moxfield.c...
Come join our Discord community!
/ discord
Consider Supporting us via Patreon!
www.patreon.co...
Follow us on Twitter:
NitpickingNerds
OUR EQUIPMENT:
○Microphones: amzn.to/3wLlrcd
○Cloudlifter: amzn.to/3iZxZc3
○Beginner Microphone: amzn.to/3d0TghB
○Camera: amzn.to/2SQPuRa
○Lighting: amzn.to/3iZVQZe
To clarify, Orcish Bowmasters is not banned, we’re just poking fun that people seemed to want it banned immediately 😅
I had to check. I thought I missed something! 😄
Yeah, get him outta here 😂
I just bought a copy for my Ob Nixilis, Captive Kingpin deck
They also don’t trigger off of Jeska’s Will! However, it would be extremely funny if they did
As soon as you said knee jerk reaction, all I could think of was, "I used to be an adventure like you... till I took an arrow to the knee" 🤣🤣
Great job again Mia, but Amber always steals the show when she is on screen! We love Amber!
Amber > other nerds
We all miss Joe, obviously, but Mia is doing a good job, and the new editing style makes it great
Im sure everyone misses Joe, but you guys are doing a great job, especially on the new editing it feels super crisp and concise. Awesome work guys!
The editing and animations are great. Could this be what the “creative differences” Joe mentioned? If so, why would he be against them?
@@giancarlozambello5291considering she still does all the same bits and catchphrases, I think one would be Joe wanted to stop doing all the bits and catchphrases
What happened to Joe?
@@not_whysea flaked
Alternate Title: what should (or shouldnt) be putting in your Yarok, The Desecrated deck.
Second Yarok comment!
It feels like the editing is more involved now, seeing all the comparisons or game actions on screen is fun. Also Beezy is wrong, Amber cannot be in the way on The Amber Show.
I’ve said this before, but though I love the concept of tier lists like this, mixing opposing criteria for ratings causes confusion and overall negates consistency in said grading. For example, you graded duelcaster mage a C and Thassa’s Oracle an S using the same logic. I won’t argue that it is ultimately easier to combo out with the Oracle, but to say duelcaster is a c because if you aren’t comboing it sits in your hand and to not apply that logic to oracle doesn’t make sense. What is Thassa’s Oracle without the combo? A bad scry card when at least the dualcaster can copy more. Again, in the decks that have them tuned for it, it isn’t a contest and the Oracle is by far greater, but in a deck without combos the duelcaster is better IMO.
13:01 "White has trouble in terms of ramp..."
White has become the second colour of ramping in the meantime, iirc. I may be mistaking, but white got so much support in the last 4 years especially
Long time fan of the show. Mia is killing it, and beezy keep up the great work! Amber still steals the show whenever she makes an appearance
Don't really think avenger of zendikar was judged fairly. Saying its stopped by a board wipe gives it more credit.
If you leave plant dad up, in most decks they are dropping more lands or buffing/overrunning you the following turns.
If no one is solving avenger and the plant children, and people are living the following turns, there a deckbuilding problem.
I have it in an Aesi Deck.
Everytime it's played, it gets 2 land drops on its first turn while everything has summoning sickness, and at least 2 more the next turn, if not more. Meaning that by the time I can actually attack with them, they're at least 4/5's. That shits good if the deck supports it.
cant forget about heroic intervention which just helps you kill everyone the next turn
is amber A tier or S tier? either way, i love it when she enters the battlefield.
Amber is S+!
Imperial Recruiter is just a 5 mana dockside
😂😂😂
Coiling Oracle, a D? Wow, did not expect that... I love seeing that card in my Roon deck!
I agree i think coiling Oracle is better than D tier personally
I really like the animations. Keep upping that production value!! 💜🧡
I will say imperial recruiter gets Yawgmoth and that is amazing.
That’s SUPER nice
Gary+saw in half+ reanimate
Love the video idea! Would LOVE to see death triggers or LTB triggers tier list
Putting the goose in poop tier is a travesty, I play it in all my bant decks, Shanna, Purifying Blade, Rigo, Streetwise Mentor, and Chulane, Teller of Tales, they all love the goose
love the new format you guys rock!
🥳
I like mia. I can't wait to see her develop her nitpicking skills
Mia is doing well! I’m surprised there was no ravenous chewbs on this list, you guys talk about it almost every episode 😂
BOJUKA BOG? In MY GRAVEYARD?!
Love the video and the discussions only criticism I have is the editing sound effects. Felt a bit out of place and distracting. I think just showing the cards you're talking about that synergies with the cards you're discussing felt more then enough. Otherwise keep up the great work as always !
I made a big mistake as a newbie the other day at Commander night at my LGS...I played an Enchanted Evening in my Azorius deck EARLY (it's part of an infinite combo with either Archon of Sun's Grace or Ajani's Chosen) and I didn't have a great hand but had the 5 mana to play it so I thought "Eh, why not, I didn't wanna reveal that I have this...but I'll go ahead and play it". Little did I know the other guy had a Dockside Extortionist just waiting to be played and he didn't even realize that Enchanted Evening makes ALL PERMANENTS IN THE GAME into an enchantment in ADDITION to their other types. We all scooped. Sadface.
I love using sad robot in my Osgir deck, with Osgir and Feldon to make copies from the graveyard that I can then sacrifice for even more value it's just one of the best ramp and card advantage pieces available
I just finished tooling up Aminatou flicker, so lets find out what I missed. 👀
Kiora Bests the Sea God can be fun with Aminatou.
Great job, Mia!!!!... but NN really needs to come up with another unique intro. Have it tailored to Mia's personality. Until then you won't get away from comparisons to Joe.
I second this opinion
“Well Hi-C is a drink, we’re talking about magic cards”. That was so stupid, I hate that it got a laugh out of me
It was cheesy, but also felt natural and spur of the moment. Thumbs up for it from me.
A big one worth noting for more recent releases (after this video): Ghalta, Stampede Tyrant. Definitely, either top of A tier or bottom of S tier.
Imperial recruiter also gets bane of progress, frostfang, ewit, etc. It's the master of toolbox
Great video! Being a Gishath lover, I am very biased towards Etali and Zacama as some of the best dinos to hit. However, I ultimately would consider the best outcome as Gishath hits Etali and Etali hits Zacama. This is because Etali technically "casts" Zacama from exile, so I think all lands would be untapped for free. Thus, I think the letter grade ends up being A + D = S with totally sound logic :D
Coiling oracle a D? nah. I either get an untapped land or I drew a card. that is at least a C imo.
"...You have a 4 drop commander (proceeds to show Atraxa and then Bill the ****ing PONY)..." !!!
Great editing, great Mia
funny that this comes out as I am deciding if i want to take apart Yarok
Let us know the verdict 👀
keep him bro Yarok is amazing
I don’t find any other sultai commander as compelling, maybe besides the mimeoplasm for old school vibes
Love the best of series! Especially for my flickers deck, all the annoying stuff to repeat
Gilded Goose sees play in Baba Lysaga decks as well as it gives you a creature and an artifact.
I'm surprised snapcaster mage isn't on this list 🤔
I was surprised Atraxa, Grand Unifier didn’t make it on here. If it did what would you rate it??
I think it’s cause it’s the most popular ETB creatures from EDHREC and I don’t think the new Atraxa has been out long enough to make the list -it’s a super strong card tho, I’m sure it would be high
I watched the old ETB video with Cherries this morning….
Gilded goose was is a bad mana dork but with more food token synergy decks coming out I would consider a D tier for good in situational decks
Great needed to know this for my elesh norn commander deck k
My main disagreement is Gary. Gary is just black Craterhoof. It’s just as easy an S tier. Your reasoning for it not being played in a black deck can be mirrored to not playing Craterhoof in a green deck.
13:31
will it be correct?
Not unless you cheated!
Is orcish bowmaster really banned? I’ve been looking and haven’t seen anywhere where it says it’s banned
Nah, we were just poking fun at everyone wanting it banned before it has been in players hands 😂👍🏻
I'm doing a tier list of the most watched Nerds!
Are we on it?!
@@NitpickingNerdsS Tier Baybee!
Goose is a wonderful mana dork for a Korvold deck.
One mana for a body and a token bare minimum so it's never really a dead draw because worst case scenario I can just feed it to Korvold and keep digging. Its a mana dork that triggers Korvold every time I make mana with it. If for whatever reason I dont have any fodder I can use 2 mana to make another Food which will let me swing with Korvold without negatively impacting my boardstate.
NEEDING Food to make mana IS a downside, and Jund isnt exactly blink city but Food isnt actually all that hard to come by even with a small suite of cards to enable it. Academy Manufactor, Witch's Oven, and Tireless Provisioner alone make it quite easy to incidentally wind up with a bunch of Food just by doing their usual thing.
Guilded goose is legit in Korvold for sure. Versatile and can give something to sacrifice, including itself. Also sacrifice a food to make a mana will trigger Korvold once on the field.
Was gonna say exactly this. You dont NEED to run Food to make Korvold strong obviously, but a small package of like: Goose, Cauldron Familiar, Witch's Oven, and Academy Manufactor can really put in surprising work even in a tuned list meant for high power (non cEDH) games where an added gimmick like that would usually be quite bad
Dualcaster is a red counterspell for counterspells.
Did cherries get a haircut or something
Mia is doing good! Glad to see
She’s doing great!
Beezy - Should I run Loran, Cathar Commando or both in my Celestine deck? I’ve been meaning to try out Loran in a deck!
Only place I’d play Gilded Goose is in my Gimbal deck or a dedicated food deck. Being able to get good with it’s activated is GOOD, but only if you want the food at all.
Well, if this is in alphabetical order like the other ones, then the Moxfield ad will probably be in front of Mulldrifter or something.
Ayyyyy
👀
Gilded Goose works well in Korvold. it gives Korvold something to sac as soon as it enters for just 1 mana, and can create more things for Korvy to sac. also goes nicely with Academy Manufactor
For real... The Gilded Goose synergies are so good. Academy Manufacturer? Food decks? Playing green + black and need some lifegain to spend on card draw? Aristocrats? Skullclamp? Flying blocker in green? Need a 1 drop dork for a turn two 3 mana commander? Definitely C minimum.
Food deck is coming up with lotr, man how far ahead was this vid made
Rather amazed Atraxa Grand Unifier isnt on a list of most played.
Man o man, gilded goose is pretty awesome in my 5 color ninjas deck :)
I have one deck that does run Gilded Goose, Yorvo. I run literally every single 1-mana manadork that taps for green mana to maximize the chance of a turn 2 Yorvo.
For G-X decks with Commanders that are three mana with ALL color pips AND that want to ALWAYS want to play their Commander on turn 2, I think the Goose is fine. 8:10
Aw man, gilded goose is one of my favorite cards. 😂😂
Yo first comment?! Let's go. Moxfield at 13:27
Sadly incorrect
Could you guys do a video on playstyle key terms? For example you'll often reference a deck as tutor or some other variant and I would like to better understand those common ones
I think you guys should change the style a bit with a new host. It'll help it not feel like you're just replacing Joe.
Seconded
I puased at 0:55 and I think the Mox add will be at 12:41
Long live the Nerds.
It hurts to see Zacama put in D tier. I know all metas are different, but in my Omnath, Locus of Creation deck, Zacama coming out turn 4 always brings groans of frustration from the table. Despite Zacama being the only dinosaur in the deck, it somehow has gotten the reputation as my "dumb dinosaur deck". I agree there are better options for my mana, but the utility of the card makes it better than D tier in my opinion.
yeah definitly, i'm also playing her, but in a Samut Voice of dissent deck; and it's just a stupid card, in fact, she's an alternative wincon. She doesn't deserve a D tiers, B tiers would be the right grade to me.
Imperial recruiter works great in my veyran deck. It finds me either archmage emeritus or storm kiln artist and that’s all it really has to do since tutoring creatures is hard in red/blue. If I already have both those cards out and it’s kind of dead, I don’t really care because at that point I’m probably already winning
I know it may have been Joe's outro, but I miss hearing, "Peace out, tribe scouts." at the end of NN videos. Would y'all have to pay Cherries royalties to use his line?
Mia is great but it's kinda awkward if she just replicates Cherries. Don't be afraid to be weird or say things how YOU want to!
Almost sad there wasn't a Murderous redcap/kitchen finks mention, but I get that they aren't exciting outside of their combos.
cant believe zacama is AS good if not worse than that coil oracle, and gilded fucking goose
OBVIOUSLY the ad is at 13:47 this episode
fuuuuuuuuck
Imperial is really good in my bjorna/wernog blink. Grabs urza, marionette master, or dockside.
what’s a better recursion piece for isshin: Guardian Scalelord or Sun Titan?
Gary netted me 120 life in 2 turns last night and I won the game at 143 life (using Meren, fiend artisan, and bramble sovereign)
Yall missed scourge of fleets. Card is sooo good in budget
i think the ad moxfeild will come after loran
I've only drawn Gary once in my Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker deck. I wound up 1v1, and kept bringing back Gary with my Fume Spitter lowering his power so he comes back... I clung on, but couldn't quite secure the win.
One day he'll get there.
@@mofomiko I was coming off a board wipe and just didn't have Gary hitting the one player left for all that much. Multiple players would have really given me the life on that one.
@@mofomiko Lifelink! I was fighting back against lifelink creatures.
Gilded Goose goes in Chatterfang
That's all I can think of
And maybe Chulane
It is a lot of fun in the new hobbits and food precon. It survived the upgrade I did and is an all star
People talk about suntitan and guardian scalelord but they always disrespect my boi bishop of rebirth.
Miss joe . But beezy and mia are doing good snitzle
Are Mia and Joe cool? How did it all go down? Is there no way to make this a 3some?
what about angel of invention? 2/1 Angel for 3WW that gives +1/+1 to all other creatures but has Fabricate 2 (give here 2 +1/+1 or create 2 Servo 1/1 artifact creature token with flying). She's awesome in my Orzhov sacrifice/reanimate/token deck :D
Is the commander tier list in the works or are you moving away from that?
Ranking Every Commander? It’s in the works!
Awesome! Thank you!
It's one of my favorite series!
Amber! The star of the show, we love you kitty kitty
I love playing witchbane orb in my graveyard decks, makes bojuka big useless
Moxfield ad time (16:47)
Avenger of Zendikar in my Esix Fractal Bloom deck is an A+ 👍
Knight of the White Orchid is bottom of poop tier for sure. White has many better ways of ramping these days it’s just a 2/2 first strike for two mana the majority of the time. I wouldn’t ever play White Knight, so I definitely wouldn’t ever play Knight of the White Orchid
What happened to proper HD or 2k? or 4k?
Is shuffle scuffle still happening?
Only 720p? Editing is good, but quality is very sussy..... :(
Wait, is orchish bowmaster already banned? When did it happen?
Same what?
It’s not banned we’re teasing because people wanted it banned immediately
I've been down on Gilded Goose forever, but as Boreal Druid is good in snow decks, this bestest goosey boi is gettin right into my Samwise food deck.
But, yeah, otherwise, card's not great.
New tier: Goose poop tier'
Also: Atraxa and Bill are the two best four-drop commanders, obviously.
Where do you rank the etb "take initiative" and "become monarch" effects
They can be decent! I think in weaker or budget decks I’d like Initiative more, but in higher power I’d rather just draw a card every turn with Monarch
My treebeard deck loves guilded goose
I really want to know, what you think about a super underrated card: Insight
As a yarok player, I'm interested...
It up for banning = S tier then E Witness should be S tier apparently back in the day articles called for it to be banned
Moxfield guess for today. 15:22 Let's go!