🇮🇳🇵🇰🇧🇩 But Partition abhi bhi incomplete hai. Today 23 crore Muslims India mein rahte hai. Jab tak India se sare Muslims Pakistan or Bangladesh nahi chale jate hai aur Sare Hindu India jab tak nahi aa jate hai. tab tak Partition complete nahi hoga. - Dr . Babasaheb Ambedkar.🙏
@@ghulammustapha8245 Jinnah ne demand kiya tha ki Muslim majority Area Pakistan banane ke liye chahiye. 1947 mein Muslim majority area already Muslims ko mil gaya. Phir bhi Muslim India mein hi raha gaye. Indian subcontinent ka partition karne se Hindu's ko kya benefit mila . - Zero benefit 😐 Aaj India mein Muslim Population 25 crore ho gaya hai. World's second largest Muslim population in India. More than Pakistan 🇵🇰 🇧🇩. Aaj Pakistan se bhi jada radical Muslims India mein rahte hai.
Partition incomplete nhi hai sahi bola kyunki Abhi 5 State muslim ka thai jissai India mai chor Gaye thai Kashmir, Hyderabad,some part ko west Bengal and Assam Bhopal Agra Muradabad, Kishanganj Lakshdweep some parts of Kerala jungarh bhut sare places India ka muslim kai under tha jissai convince kar kai sardar Patel nai apnai ander liya tha lol
@@DailyViral-q2c Hyderabad jungarh Kerala Lakshadweep Bhopal kashmir Muradabad bhut sare chote chote district thai muslim kai paas lekin nhi diya gya usai convince kar kai Sardar Patel nai rakh liya tha aur bhut Sara state India nhi tha prince ley state jisko baad mai milaya lol Aur abb partion Dharam kai naam par to nhi hone wala agar hoga to Wo banega Language To iske liye ready raho ki Racism jada na failao nhi to kab South seprate ho jayega tum kuch kar bhi na paogey Lol
But you forgot the data of reduction of people. Almost 95% Hindu/Sikh minorities reduced in Pakistan through whole partition. Now they stands almost 1.5% in Pakistan who are segregated almost 26 places in official constitution. Secondly, almost 24% of Indian muslims got almost 33% seperate Islamic nations where they dominate decisively and remaining partitioned India become an innards. So Pakistan gov officially captured almost 98% thier land including temples too. On the other hand the muslims who left India for Pakistan were just 7%. Almost 93% Indian muslims who demanded Pakistan even voted to denied to go Pakistan. They never accepted Indian identity only focuses on Hijab , Halal , Sharia , namaz on street etc. No doubt Partition was a bad Idea but time proved it right. Now we can sea and feel that United India would have been a dangerous idea.
Dude, In a United India on the lines of the Cabinet Mission Plan FAR FAR MANY MORE MILLIONS MUSLIMS WOULD HAVE BEEN SLAUGHTERED IN A CIVIL WAR. Hindu and Sikh loss of life would have been no where close to what the loss of life would have been on Muslim side, with Superpowers choosing sides in a Communal Civil War. Post Civil War, India and Pakistan would have ended up as SEPARATE COUNTRIES ANYWAY ✌🏻 Thank Indian National Congress leadership for the lives and India's landmass they could save.
One more factor ( not related with this study ) which nobody considers is compensation. Many refugee families actually got benifitted because of partition, because of the compensation properties they got.
@@pravahsaxena3537 I can understand brother both my maternal & paternal grandparents were partition refugees from Haripur, Hazara & Muzaffarabad/Rawalpindi
Common Myth debunked- "Pakistan was created based on religion" Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan. It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Akalis with Congress VOTED FOR PARTITION OF PUNJAB BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T WANT TO LIVE UNDER A COMMUNAL GOVT. LED BY ALL INDIA MUSLIM LEAGUE. Good they voted for Partition else entire Indian Punjab including Himachal Pradesh and Haryana would have been cleansed of Hindus and Sikhs and we could have waved present day Jammu and Kashmir goodbye. The loss of life of Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs as well as Dogri, Pahari and Kashmiri Hindus and Sikhs would have been FAR FAR MORE than what this research has estimated. Also, include the various Haryanvi Dialects speaking Hindus as Collateral!! IMAGINE A HARYANA EMPTY OF JAATS!
@@Hardeep1984singYOU DID NOT GET YOUR OWN COUNTRY BECAUSE YOU WERE NOT IN A MAJORITY IN ANY DISTRICT IN THE BRITISH PUNJAB. KHALISTANI LOSER! BRINGING BAD NAME TO ALL SIKHS.😮 More than 50% Punjabi Hindus, a MAJORITY, HAD TO MOVE ACCROSS THE RADCLIFFE LINE WHEREAS ONLY 30% SIKHS HAD TO MOVE ACCROSS THE RADCLIFFE LINE. DISPLACEMENT AND CATASTROPHE WAS FAR MORE ON THE HINDU SIDE THAN THE SIKH SIDE. AND I HAVEN'T EVEN COUNTED THE HINDU REFUGEES FROM SINDH, FRONTIER PROVINCE AND BALOCHISTAN, WHERE HINDUS FAR FAR OUTNUMBERED THE SIKHS. ALSO, HINDU PUNJABI REFUGEES WERE MOSTLY SETTLED IN NON PUNJABI SPEAKING DISTRICTS OF THE EAST PUNJAB AND IN HINDI SPEAKING PROVINCES OF INDEPENDENT INDIA, RENDERING HINDU PUNJABIS ORPHANED FROM THEIR LANGUAGE AND CULTURE. THIS WAS DONE BY THE CONGRESS BOWING DOWN TO THE AKALI LEADERSHIP'S DEMAND!
Mr. Jinnah was reluctant to the partition at first. Even after the partition, he wanted the relations of India and Pakistan, similarly like the relations of the United States and Canada. But, unfortunately everything turned exactly opposite of it.
@@abhi.ku2432 Then I would ask wasn't Mr. Gandhi and Shri Nehru Ji the agents of the Britishers, who started the Hindi-Urdu controversy, and what was the reason behind the Bihar Massacre?
@@abhi.ku2432 Bihar Massacre is another name for Direct Action Day, and Gandhi Ji let Bhagat Singh and his fellow friends die, he was a hypocrite and a agent of Britishers, along with Nehruji.
Common Myth debunked- "Pakistan was created based on religion" Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan. It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Yes, my friend. Pakistan is a completely secular country in the sense that Pakistanis even kill each other along with minorities. The fact that they're killing Ahmedias, Sunnis and Shias indiscriminately says it all. @@KHamasInternational
Bangladesh main 47 main 30% hindu tha aab 7% matlb 22/23% hindu west Bengal Assam Tripura chale gaye but Assam West Bengal main hindu decrease hua 😢 India Pakistan Bangladesh milake hindu 100 crore Muslim 67 crore 50% se upr 😨😨😨
Common Myth debunked- "Pakistan was created based on religion" Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan. It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Very good video Thank you very much I was looking for these figures from long time You have presented in very simple way Great Work, Keep it up and pls make more videos on same topic Amit Agarwal Delhi, India
She didn't presented the data of reduction of people. Almost 95% Hindu/Sikh minorities reduced in Pakistan through whole partition. Now they stands almost 1.5% in Pakistan they are segregated almost 26 places in official constitution. Secondly, almost 24% of Indian muslims got almost 33% seperate Islamic nations where they dominate decisively and remaining partitioned India become an innards. So Pakistan gov officially captured almost 98% thier land including temples too. On the other hand the muslims who left India for Pakistan were just 7%. Almost 93% Indian muslims who demanded Pakistan even voted to denied to go Pakistan. They never accepted Indian identity only focuses on Hijab , Halal , Sharia , namaz on street etc. No doubt Partition was a bad Idea but time proved it right. Now we can sea and feel that United India would have been a dangerous idea.
Voting happened during time of partition -Majority of Muslim voted for jinnah & Muslim league for making a separated for Muslim - majority of Hindu voted against partiton of India - 5-10% very less Hindus want a separate country for Hindus and very less Muslim want to live in undivided India 5-10% - but Muslim won by majority and Pakistan got formed in 1947 - Hindi= Sanskrit+ Persian and Urdu= arabic+ Persian+Sanskrit originated in meerut, india - But India got credited of ancient & medieval history because of it's Hindu population and that's why this subcontinent is called Indian subcontinent. India is 300BCE word used for Hindu jain culture in book Indica written by Megsthaneez
I think there must have been violation in Punjab and Bengal during partition. In the rest of the Indian state, rich Muslims (land lords) have sold their land and migrated smoothly. In the region (Saurashtra, Gujarat) where I belong, I have heard such story from our elders. Well done Misha, good speaker with excellent story teller. 👍 Recommendations content : Wahhabism
This is very good information. We know so little of that event in our shared history- outside of the large number of human stories. The methodology used makes a lot of sense. Btw 1941 census is not used/ available because of World War II. I look forward to part two of this series. I would be very interested in such analysis/ information/ research done on partition in particular and history of the Indian subcontinent in general.
There is no history of Urdu in Punjab before British takeover in 1849. In fact you hardly find names of high-calibre Urdu poets during the climax period of Urdu shayri (approx 1700 - 1870s). Mostly Persian was used for administrative purposes till Sikh rule, and Urdu literature after that was nothing but just ordinary. British deliberately imported Urdu in order to just artificially create Hindu, Muslim, Sikh identities and associate them with language.
Agar Pakistan Bangladesh India aaj ek hi hota to is pure Bharat ka prime minister koi Musalman hota kyunki inki Abadi bahut jyada hoti aur voton se Musalman party hi Jeetati
@@azaruddinshaikhmir ahar sewal war kab tak chalti har taraf Muslim hony thy or Hindo zada time Tek he na pary 😂🤣🤣🤣 or abi tak Nepal me hoty ha khi side or werany me reh rahy hoty
When she said India ka data genuine nhi h then you will know about the quality of this rubbish research typical pak studies. My great grandfather and 12 relative died alone by the Muslim mob.
She was talking about British Indian census of 1941. While the 1951 indian census was considered genuine by the research. Also she also mentions violence on Both sides of the border and not just one side like typical pak studies or Indian studies.
Very sad, that’s why I always says British 🇬🇧 government wanted to break the strength of this region…now you can see Pakistan they gave in a hand of wrong people and India is still under there influence
Your methodology is good , hiwever , the quality of data from the sources will be doubtful. Official number of people died in partition is put at about a million whereas your analysis shows nearly 3 million .. its 3 times of official number ..
Bina soche samje partition kr diti gai c jinu kea gea ohnu punjab bare te etho de culture bare kuj ni pta c..... Ik lakeer kich k kine ghar ujaarte... Khateaa kuj vi ni bhave vand lae mulk
56 islamic country fir bhi khus nahi ha jana ha non muslim country ma jaha democracy ha wha demographic changes karna 10 12 bacha pada karkha , family planning haram ha ,this comunity swings halal and haram 😂😂
Common Myth debunked- "Pakistan was created based on religion" Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan. It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Endianz ko ye to btain k Urdu Endia mn originated hoi lekin Arabic Persian and Turkish ko mixup kr k jb k wo kehte hn k ye hamari language hai r official bhi😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Madam, 1947 partition of India was a monumental tragedy comprising of millions of muslims and hindus losing their lives during the forced sudden migration of hindus and muslims across new borders of Punjab and Bengal. This was not a planned event which turned out to be extremely traumatic. The 3 important political players of this traumatic event were : 1. Mr Jinnah 2. Lord Mountbatten 3. Mahatma Gandhi. Of the 3 Mr Jinnah turned out to be most insulated from the blood bath following 15 August 1947 partition. Mr Jinnah was least interested in blood bath of human lives whether muslims or hindus. Recall his call for Direct Action in Bengal and a speech at AMU where he publicly proclaimed his readiness to sacrifice 2 crore indian muslims to secure a homeland for muslims of west India.
I really want to but its so difficult to get accurate information on it because its so heavily censored. But lets see thats definitely a an issue thats always in my heart 💞
Agr ainsi baat h to jra es bare me batao ki aaj ke tarik me kitne sikh aur hindu bache h punjab me sindh me kp me .. agr imaandar ho tou es pr bhi video jarur banana
Tum log bary imaandar ho? Doodh se dhulay hoye ho? Farishty ho? Kabi world history mein khoon nai bhaya masoom logon Ka? Video mein or other reports mein already btya ja chuka k partition mein sub Hindu Sikh migration kr k India ja chuky thy or boht he small numbers mein Hindu or Sikh idr Pakistan mein stay kiye rahy, ab ye tum jesy hypocrites or hatred filled Modi agenda waly Hindus jhoot aisy bolty hain jesy bara punnay (swaab) wala kaam kr rahy hain 👎🏻
Rukhsaar ko 🥵dekhe ya Guftaar❣️ ko dekhe Is majmu-e-khoobi ke kis kirdaar ko dekhe 🧸 🌺Misha🌺 ki soch se bahar nikalta hi nahi Aa kar Zara is dil-e-beemar ko dekhe 💕
@@gondalvelogs786 na lala anj te na bol meri baat suno saraiki culture history aor log punjabi history culture or logo se alag hein or hamari zuban me bhi kafi farq hein lala ji
@@general_Asim_munir_is_love pher to Lahore ke Punjabi lag caltuer Alg Gujrat ke Punjabi or caltuer alag narowal mandi bahawaldin Sargodha Rajan our sahi Wal har city ka andaz alag h bat krny ka or caltuer be alag h to kia wo he sary alag mulk st thy bat Suno zaban hamesha wo alg hoti h jis k dusry ko samaj na aay jasy India me kairla ke zaban Malbari h or tamilnado ke zaban Alag h or dono tarf k logo k aik dusry ke zaban samj nhi ati kab k Rehan sehan sab aik jsa h or chakl o surat be same h Pakistan me Sindhi blochi pashto or panjabi gilgit ye 4 zaban Hain mare Pindi me pothari Punjabi bolo jati h Kal ko wo bayn ham Dubai k log Hain hamra caltuer or zaban Alag h to es leye hmara jud be alag Hain 🤣😂🤣
@@general_Asim_munir_is_love Kal ko Pindi or os k aas pas k pothari log ye bolna shuru ho jayn ham panini nhi Hain to es y haqeqat badal nhi jay ge Jab Mohammad bin qasam aia tha os time blochistan Iran ka tha sindh ke alag hakomat thi or Punjab pura di Kahn sy ly kr multan tak kr multan sy ly kr taxila jhang or atock tak or behar k border sy ly kr blochistan tak Punjab thi or os ko indeswaly kaha jata tha Muhammad bin qasam sy pahly hr zaban waky ke apni govt thi raky mahrajy huva krty thy 🤣😂😂😂
@@general_Asim_munir_is_love Punjabi k andr 20 sy 25 lehjy Hain Mary gujart me or lehja sailokt me or lehja h kharian me or lehja h indai me be asa he h
You use a pic of lord Krishna in your profile and your mind is full of hate!! How filthy you are...give some respect to Radhe. Don't spread hate... which part of our veda and Upanishads teach us hate!!
Pakistan cencus 1951 Hindu 23 persentage today 1.8 persentage, Bangladesh 1972 19 persentage today 7.9 persentage, India 1951 cencus 7.8 persentage today 14 persentage 😂, India hindu fertility rate,1.94 muslim 4.4 ,bacha allha ki dan ha , Pakistan muslim women fertility rate 5.2 per women 😂,bacha allha ki dan ha ,what is really,no husband xy+wife xx=children born 😂, allha ka koi yogdan nahi ha,non muslim democracy per population bada kha kabja karna 😂😂😂 hypocracy 😂,sab samaj raha ha Europe and America, Australia sab 😂😂
Dear Ashok your fertility data is from the Southern part of India, mostly Karnataka, Kerala, Tamilnadu...now in UP and Bihar ?? Yess more than 4 ....now you decide!! This is not about religion it is all about education and poverty... and please stop hate comments all over UA-cam...its disgusting really
Haram=family planning haram ha or ,bacha allha ki dan ha. Hallal=beggars in other country export,non muslim country fastly demographic changes 😂😂😂 kya logic ha
Bhai majboori me hi gye the 1946 me 3 percent indian population ne vote kiya tha muslim 25 percent the to 95 percent muslims ne vote hi nhi kiya jo 5 percent ne vote kiya usme se jyada tar log muslim league ko support kiya lekin 95 percent muslims ne vote hi nhi kiya tha
Jitne muslim the vo dange ke baad gye the jaise east punjab rajasthan me jab riots hue tab muslims majburi me gye Pakistan kyuki 1946 me 95 percent muslims ne vote nhi kiya tha 5 percent ka vote ko pure muslim ka vote nhi keh sakte tum us 5 percent muslims ne majority me muslim league ko vote diya 95 percent muslims ne election me vote kiya tha
🇮🇳🇵🇰🇧🇩
But Partition abhi bhi incomplete hai.
Today 23 crore Muslims India mein rahte hai.
Jab tak India se sare Muslims Pakistan or Bangladesh nahi chale jate hai aur Sare Hindu India jab tak nahi aa jate hai. tab tak Partition complete nahi hoga.
- Dr . Babasaheb Ambedkar.🙏
Bilkul sahi kaha dost
Yes, give them their share of land as per % of the Muslim population and then the Hindu will have pure Hindu home land
@@ghulammustapha8245
Jinnah ne demand kiya tha ki Muslim majority Area Pakistan banane ke liye chahiye.
1947 mein Muslim majority area already Muslims ko mil gaya.
Phir bhi Muslim India mein hi raha gaye.
Indian subcontinent ka partition karne se Hindu's ko kya benefit mila . - Zero benefit 😐
Aaj India mein Muslim Population 25 crore ho gaya hai. World's second largest Muslim population in India.
More than Pakistan 🇵🇰 🇧🇩.
Aaj Pakistan se bhi jada radical Muslims India mein rahte hai.
Partition incomplete nhi hai sahi bola kyunki Abhi 5 State muslim ka thai jissai India mai chor Gaye thai Kashmir, Hyderabad,some part ko west Bengal and Assam Bhopal Agra Muradabad, Kishanganj Lakshdweep some parts of Kerala jungarh bhut sare places India ka muslim kai under tha jissai convince kar kai sardar Patel nai apnai ander liya tha lol
@@DailyViral-q2c Hyderabad jungarh Kerala Lakshadweep Bhopal kashmir Muradabad bhut sare chote chote district thai muslim kai paas lekin nhi diya gya usai convince kar kai Sardar Patel nai rakh liya tha aur bhut Sara state India nhi tha prince ley state jisko baad mai milaya lol
Aur abb partion Dharam kai naam par to nhi hone wala agar hoga to Wo banega Language
To iske liye ready raho ki Racism jada na failao nhi to kab South seprate ho jayega tum kuch kar bhi na paogey
Lol
But you forgot the data of reduction of people. Almost 95% Hindu/Sikh minorities reduced in Pakistan through whole partition. Now they stands almost 1.5% in Pakistan who are segregated almost 26 places in official constitution.
Secondly, almost 24% of Indian muslims got almost 33% seperate Islamic nations where they dominate decisively and remaining partitioned India become an innards. So Pakistan gov officially captured almost 98% thier land including temples too.
On the other hand the muslims who left India for Pakistan were just 7%. Almost 93% Indian muslims who demanded Pakistan even voted to denied to go Pakistan. They never accepted Indian identity only focuses on Hijab , Halal , Sharia , namaz on street etc.
No doubt Partition was a bad Idea but time proved it right. Now we can sea and feel that United India would have been a dangerous idea.
Well said . There is a reason why it is called Islamic Republic .
She is giving all fake data and analysis. What a shame to Islam
@@i_nehatiwari what do u expect from a citizen of a country , whose existence is based on a narrative.(2 nation theory)
Dude,
In a United India on the lines of the Cabinet Mission Plan FAR FAR MANY MORE MILLIONS MUSLIMS WOULD HAVE BEEN SLAUGHTERED IN A CIVIL WAR.
Hindu and Sikh loss of life would have been no where close to what the loss of life would have been on Muslim side, with Superpowers choosing sides in a Communal Civil War.
Post Civil War, India and Pakistan would have ended up as SEPARATE COUNTRIES ANYWAY ✌🏻
Thank Indian National Congress leadership for the lives and India's landmass they could save.
One more factor ( not related with this study ) which nobody considers is compensation. Many refugee families actually got benifitted because of partition, because of the compensation properties they got.
I talk a bit about this in the next video
@@hr5581 no body likes to be uprooted from it's ancestral homeland and run to another place at short notice just for a minute compensation.
@@pravahsaxena3537 I can understand brother both my maternal & paternal grandparents were partition refugees from Haripur, Hazara & Muzaffarabad/Rawalpindi
Common Myth debunked-
"Pakistan was created based on religion"
Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes
But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders
Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan.
It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular
As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination
Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Muslims get benefited in pakistan alot…. Sikhs in fact loose properties because sikhs were bigger jagirdars before partition
ਯੂਪੀ ਬਿਹਾਰ ਵਿੱਚ ਉੱਰਦੂ ਬੋਲਣ ਵਾਲੇ ਨਵਾਬਾ ਨੂੰ ਅਲੱਗ ਦੇਸ਼ ਚਾਹੀਦਾ ਸੀ ।ਉਹਨਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਕਿਓ ਦਿੱਤਾ ਯੂਪੀ ਬਿਹਾਰ ਹੀ ਦੇ ਦਿੰਦੇ ।ਪੰਜਾਬ ਵਿੱਚ ਤਾਂ ਕੋਈ ਰੋਲਾ ਹੀ ਨਹੀਂ ਸੀ ।ਸੱਭ ਤੋ ਵੱਧ ਨੁਕਸ਼ਾਨ ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਤੇ ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਦਾ ਹੋਇਆ ।
ਸਿਰਫ ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਦਾ ਹੋਇਆ ਹੋਰ ਕਿਸੇ ਦਾ ਨਹੀਂ।ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਓਨਾ ਦਾ ਮੁਲਕ ਨੀ ਮਿਲਿਆ।
Akalis with Congress VOTED FOR PARTITION OF PUNJAB BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T WANT TO LIVE UNDER A COMMUNAL GOVT. LED BY ALL INDIA MUSLIM LEAGUE.
Good they voted for Partition else entire Indian Punjab including Himachal Pradesh and Haryana would have been cleansed of Hindus and Sikhs and we could have waved present day Jammu and Kashmir goodbye.
The loss of life of Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs as well as Dogri, Pahari and Kashmiri Hindus and Sikhs would have been FAR FAR MORE than what this research has estimated.
Also, include the various Haryanvi Dialects speaking Hindus as Collateral!!
IMAGINE A HARYANA EMPTY OF JAATS!
@@Hardeep1984singYOU DID NOT GET YOUR OWN COUNTRY BECAUSE YOU WERE NOT IN A MAJORITY IN ANY DISTRICT IN THE BRITISH PUNJAB.
KHALISTANI LOSER! BRINGING BAD NAME TO ALL SIKHS.😮
More than 50% Punjabi Hindus, a MAJORITY, HAD TO MOVE ACCROSS THE RADCLIFFE LINE WHEREAS ONLY 30% SIKHS HAD TO MOVE ACCROSS THE RADCLIFFE LINE.
DISPLACEMENT AND CATASTROPHE WAS FAR MORE ON THE HINDU SIDE THAN THE SIKH SIDE. AND I HAVEN'T EVEN COUNTED THE HINDU REFUGEES FROM SINDH, FRONTIER PROVINCE AND BALOCHISTAN, WHERE HINDUS FAR FAR OUTNUMBERED THE SIKHS.
ALSO, HINDU PUNJABI REFUGEES WERE MOSTLY SETTLED IN NON PUNJABI SPEAKING DISTRICTS OF THE EAST PUNJAB AND IN HINDI SPEAKING PROVINCES OF INDEPENDENT INDIA, RENDERING HINDU PUNJABIS ORPHANED FROM THEIR LANGUAGE AND CULTURE.
THIS WAS DONE BY THE CONGRESS BOWING DOWN TO THE AKALI LEADERSHIP'S DEMAND!
All thanks to your jinnah ..
Mr. Jinnah was reluctant to the partition at first. Even after the partition, he wanted the relations of India and Pakistan, similarly like the relations of the United States and Canada. But, unfortunately everything turned exactly opposite of it.
@@samiuddinthepakistani who did direct action day?????
@@abhi.ku2432 Then I would ask wasn't Mr. Gandhi and Shri Nehru Ji the agents of the Britishers, who started the Hindi-Urdu controversy, and what was the reason behind the Bihar Massacre?
@@samiuddinthepakistani gandhi , nehru delayed the independence that's why I don't like them.
And I don't know much about Bihar massacre.
@@abhi.ku2432 Bihar Massacre is another name for Direct Action Day, and Gandhi Ji let Bhagat Singh and his fellow friends die, he was a hypocrite and a agent of Britishers, along with Nehruji.
I can spend ♾️ times in your informative videos keeping eye contact with you, how beautiful your eyes are, you are talented orator.
You should also do a study on Bengal Partition done by cruzon
Only tragedy of partition is that Rascal Gandhi did not allow muslims to leave India. Poor Hindus got killed in the millions in paxtaan
Common Myth debunked-
"Pakistan was created based on religion"
Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes
But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders
Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan.
It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular
As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination
Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Yes, my friend. Pakistan is a completely secular country in the sense that Pakistanis even kill each other along with minorities. The fact that they're killing Ahmedias, Sunnis and Shias indiscriminately says it all.
@@KHamasInternational
Bangladesh main 47 main 30% hindu tha aab 7% matlb 22/23% hindu west Bengal Assam Tripura chale gaye but Assam West Bengal main hindu decrease hua 😢 India Pakistan Bangladesh milake hindu 100 crore Muslim 67 crore 50% se upr 😨😨😨
Percentage konsa teacher sai pdha hai gendu😂
*Sindh* saw comparatively less violence in comparison to *Punjab* & *Bengal* !!
No in the 1950s Muslims of Bihar and UP started violence against Hindus in Sindh under the supervision of Punjabi and Pathan army and police.
@@saifsamo9750 due to sufi influence
@@Navadayarohini he is talking about the partition time.
@@pravahsaxena3537 Yes true , 100% 👍 !!
Common Myth debunked-
"Pakistan was created based on religion"
Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes
But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders
Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan.
It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular
As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination
Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Very good video
Thank you very much
I was looking for these figures from long time
You have presented in very simple way
Great Work, Keep it up and pls make more videos on same topic
Amit Agarwal
Delhi, India
She didn't presented the data of reduction of people. Almost 95% Hindu/Sikh minorities reduced in Pakistan through whole partition. Now they stands almost 1.5% in Pakistan they are segregated almost 26 places in official constitution.
Secondly, almost 24% of Indian muslims got almost 33% seperate Islamic nations where they dominate decisively and remaining partitioned India become an innards. So Pakistan gov officially captured almost 98% thier land including temples too.
On the other hand the muslims who left India for Pakistan were just 7%. Almost 93% Indian muslims who demanded Pakistan even voted to denied to go Pakistan. They never accepted Indian identity only focuses on Hijab , Halal , Sharia , namaz on street etc.
No doubt Partition was a bad Idea but time proved it right. Now we can sea and feel that United India would have been a dangerous idea.
Voting happened during time of partition
-Majority of Muslim voted for jinnah & Muslim league for making a separated for Muslim
- majority of Hindu voted against partiton of India
- 5-10% very less Hindus want a separate country for Hindus and very less Muslim want to live in undivided India 5-10%
- but Muslim won by majority and Pakistan got formed in 1947
- Hindi= Sanskrit+ Persian and Urdu= arabic+ Persian+Sanskrit originated in meerut, india
- But India got credited of ancient & medieval history because of it's Hindu population and that's why this subcontinent is called Indian subcontinent. India is 300BCE word used for Hindu jain culture in book Indica written by Megsthaneez
I think there must have been violation in Punjab and Bengal during partition. In the rest of the Indian state, rich Muslims (land lords) have sold their land and migrated smoothly. In the region (Saurashtra, Gujarat) where I belong, I have heard such story from our elders.
Well done Misha, good speaker with excellent story teller. 👍
Recommendations content : Wahhabism
This is very good information. We know so little of that event in our shared history- outside of the large number of human stories. The methodology used makes a lot of sense. Btw 1941 census is not used/ available because of World War II. I look forward to part two of this series.
I would be very interested in such analysis/ information/ research done on partition in particular and history of the Indian subcontinent in general.
Thank you for the insight full video.
Good Analysis
Thanks 🙏 from India
Make a video on history of urdu and Persian in Punjab before partition.
There is no history of Urdu in Punjab before British takeover in 1849. In fact you hardly find names of high-calibre Urdu poets during the climax period of Urdu shayri (approx 1700 - 1870s).
Mostly Persian was used for administrative purposes till Sikh rule, and Urdu literature after that was nothing but just ordinary.
British deliberately imported Urdu in order to just artificially create Hindu, Muslim, Sikh identities and associate them with language.
Knowledgeable video.
Enforced partition of Punjab in 1947 and resulting bloodshed and misery was one of the greatest injustice and cruelty in human history 😢
Ye tarin ki horn aaj vi sunte hai to dil cheer jati hai 😢
💡BAHRIA TOWN LAHORE
💡BAHRIA TOWN KARACHI
💡BAHRIA TOWN ISLAMABAD
💡BAHRIA TOWN RAWALPINDI
I will love doing a PowerBI data visualisation on it
Very informative
Agar Pakistan Bangladesh India aaj ek hi hota to is pure Bharat ka prime minister koi Musalman hota kyunki inki Abadi bahut jyada hoti aur voton se Musalman party hi Jeetati
ye concept hi na hota bhai fir
we would have been an intellectual state , above all this crap
India me aaj be muslim.zayda Hain 🤣🤣🤣 fake Hindu papoletion batai jati h or Hindu govt me dhoky sy aty Hain dhandhli kr k
Qash k mulk alag na hota to aaj hindo nipal bhag gay hoty mar mar k chetar dhul nekal Dani thi 😂
Absolutely wrong, there would have been civil wars, and partition would have hppnd either way.
@@azaruddinshaikhmir ahar sewal war kab tak chalti har taraf Muslim hony thy or Hindo zada time Tek he na pary 😂🤣🤣🤣 or abi tak Nepal me hoty ha khi side or werany me reh rahy hoty
Very nice explained
Waheguru ji 🙏
Waiting for 2nd part, but history of 1947 is v tragic
👏 appreciated ❤ work
Plsss Ottomans per or details me bataye jese Wonke Architectures Mastermind or Navel captain barbarosa ruled in maditerian see
☪️hut😂
Me indian muslim hu
Aapne bahut acchi jankari di hai
When she said India ka data genuine nhi h then you will know about the quality of this rubbish research typical pak studies. My great grandfather and 12 relative died alone by the Muslim mob.
She was talking about British Indian census of 1941. While the 1951 indian census was considered genuine by the research. Also she also mentions violence on Both sides of the border and not just one side like typical pak studies or Indian studies.
Very sad, that’s why I always says British 🇬🇧 government wanted to break the strength of this region…now you can see Pakistan they gave in a hand of wrong people and India is still under there influence
@@jamalmushtaq There is nothing called Indian studies.Under Congress govt. Indians got proper education on partition and freedom movement.
@@masoodkhan3287 Pakistan is under western influence and now Chinese influence, India is an independent nation.
@@Football-Pundit-n9m everyone thinks they get proper history till they study more.
informative.
Make a video on realities of indopak wars, not that is written in our text books
Your methodology is good , hiwever , the quality of data from the sources will be doubtful. Official number of people died in partition is put at about a million whereas your analysis shows nearly 3 million .. its 3 times of official number ..
It is not her data,but that is compiled by Harward University Usa through multiple channels and ways.Salute to their hectic research
My family migrated from Ludhiana. I want to visit that place
Partition gift for india given by lord shiva ❤
The answer lie in the question , why the partition happened in the first place ?
Nice video
🍎🍏BAHRIA TOWN 🍎🍏
*Your eye❤*
Good eyes Muslti 🧕😂
😅
Make a video on baloch history
Please try to avoid too much video cutting
Madame computation ki opportunity dund RAHE Ho kyaa
She seems to be pro Pakistan
❤
*Didi, jakham par namak chirakne ka kaam kar rahe hoo aap.*
Bina soche samje partition kr diti gai c jinu kea gea ohnu punjab bare te etho de culture bare kuj ni pta c..... Ik lakeer kich k kine ghar ujaarte... Khateaa kuj vi ni bhave vand lae mulk
Pehle apne India -Pakistan Map ko toh sudhaar lo...Jammu Kashmir is an integral part of India...
Please make a video on Hindu Kush . thanKYOU
56 islamic country fir bhi khus nahi ha jana ha non muslim country ma jaha democracy ha wha demographic changes karna 10 12 bacha pada karkha , family planning haram ha ,this comunity swings halal and haram 😂😂
Common Myth debunked-
"Pakistan was created based on religion"
Pakistan was created for people that communal wanted peace and no conflict between communes
But in India it was impossible for the open declaration of communalist viola/nce of congress leaders
Muslim league never claimed Pakistan is to be created for muslims only Muslim league said those who want peace,Join Pakistan.
It is the congress that created Hindu-Muslim thing Only the congress has created communalist polarization by saying India is for hindus only while hypocritically they have also claimed to be secular
As we can see now,India is only good for Brahmans and rest of the people have to bear the discrimination
Muslim league never had such hipocricy
Endianz ko ye to btain k Urdu Endia mn originated hoi lekin Arabic Persian and Turkish ko mixup kr k jb k wo kehte hn k ye hamari language hai r official bhi😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Nhi batayegi. India map me green dikhaya😂😂 maqsad smjho.
❤🌷🌹❤
What’s your village name in India..¿
Tum my kia krna h
Pachranga Jalandhar
Madam, 1947 partition of India was a monumental tragedy comprising of millions of muslims and hindus losing their lives during the forced sudden migration of hindus and muslims across new borders of Punjab and Bengal.
This was not a planned event which turned out to be extremely traumatic.
The 3 important political players of this traumatic event were :
1. Mr Jinnah
2. Lord Mountbatten
3. Mahatma Gandhi.
Of the 3 Mr Jinnah turned out to be most insulated from the blood bath following 15 August 1947 partition.
Mr Jinnah was least interested in blood bath of human lives whether muslims or hindus.
Recall his call for Direct Action in Bengal and a speech at AMU where he publicly proclaimed his readiness to sacrifice 2 crore indian muslims to secure a homeland for muslims of west India.
Muslim separatist thinking
What you can expect. She is Pakistani..😂😂😂
Make a video on balochistan please we all need the real story of Balochistan
I really want to but its so difficult to get accurate information on it because its so heavily censored. But lets see thats definitely a an issue thats always in my heart 💞
Agr ainsi baat h to jra es bare me batao ki aaj ke tarik me kitne sikh aur hindu bache h punjab me sindh me kp me .. agr imaandar ho tou es pr bhi video jarur banana
Tum log bary imaandar ho? Doodh se dhulay hoye ho? Farishty ho? Kabi world history mein khoon nai bhaya masoom logon Ka? Video mein or other reports mein already btya ja chuka k partition mein sub Hindu Sikh migration kr k India ja chuky thy or boht he small numbers mein Hindu or Sikh idr Pakistan mein stay kiye rahy, ab ye tum jesy hypocrites or hatred filled Modi agenda waly Hindus jhoot aisy bolty hain jesy bara punnay (swaab) wala kaam kr rahy hain 👎🏻
You should bringing some Indian scholar and you tuber....to more information & growth your channel
Do more research... Migration is very broad topic.. Pull and push factors are responsible.. Jinko Pakistan chahiye tha woh Pakistan gaye hi nahi...
Pehle azaad mulkon ke missing ka to hisaab laga lijiye mohtarma, yeh phaltu ki sadi-gali baaten utha kar koi fayda nahin.
Dadi nani story 😂
Aa jao India
Didi please don't say like this. We will get back to our country. Any way you are most welcome to Norway. Anytime if you like.
Rukhsaar ko 🥵dekhe ya Guftaar❣️ ko dekhe
Is majmu-e-khoobi ke kis kirdaar ko dekhe 🧸
🌺Misha🌺 ki soch se bahar nikalta hi nahi
Aa kar Zara is dil-e-beemar ko dekhe 💕
Mai India se hun
👍👌❤️🌹😊
maka a video on Saraiki
Saraiki koi afrecan zaban nhi h wo Punjab ka he part h 20 lahjy Hain Punjabi k
@@gondalvelogs786 na lala anj te na bol meri baat suno saraiki culture history aor log punjabi history culture or logo se alag hein or hamari zuban me bhi kafi farq hein lala ji
@@general_Asim_munir_is_love pher to Lahore ke Punjabi lag caltuer Alg Gujrat ke Punjabi or caltuer alag narowal mandi bahawaldin Sargodha Rajan our sahi Wal har city ka andaz alag h bat krny ka or caltuer be alag h to kia wo he sary alag mulk st thy bat Suno zaban hamesha wo alg hoti h jis k dusry ko samaj na aay jasy India me kairla ke zaban Malbari h or tamilnado ke zaban Alag h or dono tarf k logo k aik dusry ke zaban samj nhi ati kab k Rehan sehan sab aik jsa h or chakl o surat be same h
Pakistan me Sindhi blochi pashto or panjabi gilgit ye 4 zaban Hain mare Pindi me pothari Punjabi bolo jati h Kal ko wo bayn ham Dubai k log Hain hamra caltuer or zaban Alag h to es leye hmara jud be alag Hain 🤣😂🤣
@@general_Asim_munir_is_love Kal ko Pindi or os k aas pas k pothari log ye bolna shuru ho jayn ham panini nhi Hain to es y haqeqat badal nhi jay ge
Jab Mohammad bin qasam aia tha os time blochistan Iran ka tha sindh ke alag hakomat thi or Punjab pura di Kahn sy ly kr multan tak kr multan sy ly kr taxila jhang or atock tak or behar k border sy ly kr blochistan tak Punjab thi or os ko indeswaly kaha jata tha Muhammad bin qasam sy pahly hr zaban waky ke apni govt thi raky mahrajy huva krty thy 🤣😂😂😂
@@general_Asim_munir_is_love Punjabi k andr 20 sy 25 lehjy Hain Mary gujart me or lehja sailokt me or lehja h kharian me or lehja h indai me be asa he h
khuda kry kay ap kanwari hon? aur mari shaeri mai rang ay
I am from india u look beautiful
1941 census Pakistan don't consider because this census clearly shows Lahore District was given wrongly to Pakistan.
51 percent muslim live in lahore i see in census and i think 30 percent hindus 15 percent sikh i think
@@kunalsamotra2072 HINDU SIKHS WERE TO SEE COMBINED. MORE THAN 80% PROPERTY AND BUSINESSES WERE OF SIKHS AND HINDUS IN LAHORE DISTRICT
@@redchillyvids you only talk Lahore district in lahore more than 4 5 district have
@@kunalsamotra2072 61% muslim population
Gurdaaspur, pathankot, ambala, kashmir , even calcata all belonged to pak
بیک گراونڈ چینج کریں
تذبذب پھیلا ہوّا تھا ہوا میں باجی
F. K. Urdu. Speak Punjabi.
Madam India hindu majority choice democracy and equal right but Pakistan and Bangladesh muslim country why ,ghyan mat bathu 😂😂😂😂
You use a pic of lord Krishna in your profile and your mind is full of hate!! How filthy you are...give some respect to Radhe. Don't spread hate... which part of our veda and Upanishads teach us hate!!
@@DebadritoDuttawhich part teach us to spread love to child grapist????
@@DebadritoDutta he is right....
Why is this????
*I Saw A Lot Of Flaws In Your Content* 👎🏻👍🏻
Kya kar skte hai. Pakistani jo hai 😂😂😂😂
Congress boycott 1941 census
پھین
Pakistan cencus 1951 Hindu 23 persentage today 1.8 persentage, Bangladesh 1972 19 persentage today 7.9 persentage, India 1951 cencus 7.8 persentage today 14 persentage 😂, India hindu fertility rate,1.94 muslim 4.4 ,bacha allha ki dan ha , Pakistan muslim women fertility rate 5.2 per women 😂,bacha allha ki dan ha ,what is really,no husband xy+wife xx=children born 😂, allha ka koi yogdan nahi ha,non muslim democracy per population bada kha kabja karna 😂😂😂 hypocracy 😂,sab samaj raha ha Europe and America, Australia sab 😂😂
Dear Ashok your fertility data is from the Southern part of India, mostly Karnataka, Kerala, Tamilnadu...now in UP and Bihar ?? Yess more than 4 ....now you decide!! This is not about religion it is all about education and poverty... and please stop hate comments all over UA-cam...its disgusting really
Haram=family planning haram ha or ,bacha allha ki dan ha. Hallal=beggars in other country export,non muslim country fastly demographic changes 😂😂😂 kya logic ha
First viewer and first comment
Mam what's a name your
Koi mazboori mein nai gaya india side up wale musalmano ne Pakistan banne ke liyea vote kiya par gaye nai
Bhai majboori me hi gye the 1946 me 3 percent indian population ne vote kiya tha muslim 25 percent the to 95 percent muslims ne vote hi nhi kiya jo 5 percent ne vote kiya usme se jyada tar log muslim league ko support kiya lekin 95 percent muslims ne vote hi nhi kiya tha
Jitne muslim the vo dange ke baad gye the jaise east punjab rajasthan me jab riots hue tab muslims majburi me gye Pakistan kyuki 1946 me 95 percent muslims ne vote nhi kiya tha 5 percent ka vote ko pure muslim ka vote nhi keh sakte tum us 5 percent muslims ne majority me muslim league ko vote diya 95 percent muslims ne election me vote kiya tha
So basically total voter turnout was 3 percent only and muslim voter turnout was 4 percent yani 100 me se sirf 4 muslim ne vote kiya tha
@@IslamicInsight-z6w madesechap Education 🐖🤣
Abhi bhi bahot bache hue hai, nikalna padega inhe