Sisters of Silence, You've Been Lied to About Blanks - Warhammer 40k Lore

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 93

  • @CaptainPrincess
    @CaptainPrincess 4 місяці тому +28

    I could see SoS fighting Orks
    Like actually, I could see them being deployed to attempt to disrupt the collective psychic effect of a waagh, or to deal with a particularly problematic weirdboy

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +3

      That would be fun! Just in their current capacity I can only see them tagging along with a Space Marine chapter or Custodes Shield Host dealing with a waaagh. Just due to how Orks operate tbh. Or Sisters doing a spearhead assassination on a weirdboy or psychic warboss durring a larger assault. Which is just more of the part that how they're currently written, their role is side characters. And I want them to have the chance to be the main characters lol.
      Also I am now curious how blanks affect orks. I'll have to see if its been mentioned. I know their collective belief power isnt as powerful as its often talked about. But imagine how sad some Speed Freeks would get that their red bikes are slower lmao.

  • @notbob8252
    @notbob8252 4 місяці тому +11

    The inverse of a psyker makes more sense because you have different sizes of the pariah effect for each cycle some are much stronger than others

  • @isiahalcindor6278
    @isiahalcindor6278 4 місяці тому +17

    A psyker is just someone whose soul shines brighter in the warp so the inverse of that would be someone's soul being dimmer which looks like it not being there

  • @swordsman1_messer
    @swordsman1_messer 4 місяці тому +20

    Personally, I love how the Silent Sisters complement the Custodes; both hands of the Emperor, one to fight the mortal terrors, the other to silence the arcane.
    I’m still disappointed in recent decisions as of late in regard to plot developments (we all know what I’m talking about…), if only for perpetuating the meme of the Sisters continually getting shafted by absolutely everything.
    I’m still hoping we get another Watchers novel, if only to show where the money really is.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +3

      I adore how the Sisters and Custodes work together too. I would love to see it stronger if Sisters had a bit more too them though. But if that comes at the cost of destroying that work relationship? I'd be pretty upset.

    • @dildoswaggins2907
      @dildoswaggins2907 4 місяці тому

      GW wanted to do the boss b1tch thing. Like everyone else trying to promote the stronk wahman shit . Completely ignored the quiet achievers that the sisters are. They are very close to being able to flesh out their own faction/detachment

    • @nadiabairamis3854
      @nadiabairamis3854 2 місяці тому

      I absolutely hated the writers for not only killing off Jenetia Krole, but also the way in which they did it. On the rare occasions we DO get a well written and genuinely OP woman in Warhammer, they always kill them off or just nurf them completely.
      At least Saint Celestine and Commander Shadowsun seem safe for now.... but I expect they will be killed or Nurfed at some point too.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  2 місяці тому +1

      @nadiabairamis3854 The likelyhood of Celestine or Shadowsun getting killed off like that is incredibly slim. Its not a writer decision, its a business decision. Those characters move sales. Be it for books, or models. An HH character like Krole... not the same level of treatment. Every HH character save for Primarch or Space Marine was gonna die off in some way.
      If in some small chance they *do* get killed off or shoved aside, its gonna be in the Creed fashion. Immediately replaced by someone they're gonna try and sell as better or cooler. In this instance though its just good to view 40k as both a product to make money, as well as a large story with lots of authors. From what authors have said, many story decisions have come down to model sales.

    • @nadiabairamis3854
      @nadiabairamis3854 2 місяці тому

      ​@@glueboy I mean that makes perfect sense, after all its a game first and foremost. I feel a bit mollified now. TBH even tho I can't say I am the biggest Celestine fan, I would be pretty bummed if they messed with her.
      And that is only because she is the only genuinely OP female character. 😆(that is established and ongoing)
      I don't need female Primarchs or even space marines, but I do wish we had some female characters that were just as OP as them.

  • @kylehammer9154
    @kylehammer9154 4 місяці тому +24

    God Emperor I've wished for SoS lore dump for years. When God Emperor? When's gonna be my time???

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +2

      I have no clue how it would look, but I really want SoS to become a full faction like Custodes. My initial thought is how fun it would be to kinda go Deathwatch adjacent? Just become walking fuck you auras for people. Resurrection protocol? Nah, get shit on we got new Blank amplifiers to turn that off. Idk I want more from them that keeps their badass specialist vibe. But like I said its hard to keep in a war game where they gotta fight every other possible army.

    • @Optillistic
      @Optillistic 4 місяці тому

      @@glueboy It's because they are like 1 in a billion ..if custodes are like 1 in a million ..and so on

    • @averywyatt-luth1642
      @averywyatt-luth1642 4 місяці тому +1

      @@glueboyI’ve been wanting this since they became available in 40K 😭😭😭

  • @khartog01
    @khartog01 4 місяці тому +8

    Jurgen is best, Blank.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +4

      Just the greatest ally a man could ask for. Love him to death.

    • @joaoteixeira8349
      @joaoteixeira8349 4 місяці тому +2

      and his melta gun is some long lost daot artifact

  • @tonlito22
    @tonlito22 4 місяці тому +9

    The best thing for Sisters of Silence would be getting a detachment in Agents of the Imperium which well, clearly did not happen.
    Which is strange what with the war against the psychic bug hive mind going on.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +4

      Tbh I hope the exclusion from that means theres more of a chance they're gonna get fleshed out down the line

    • @CordovanSplotchVT
      @CordovanSplotchVT 4 місяці тому +2

      ​@@glueboymy bet is they're going to get the Harlequins treatment.

    • @nadiabairamis3854
      @nadiabairamis3854 2 місяці тому

      @@glueboy I REALLY hope so too, but I feel a bit skeptical and embittered because warhammer kills or nerfs all the cool OP female characters, and they are rare to begin with. To me, it seems like, Unless they hold some kind of "love" interest with a well loved Male character, they don't have any value to the writers.
      I know I am just ranting... but every time I become invested in and excited for a female character ... it was only to watch them get humiliated and/or killed or nerfed by the writers.

  • @fva1835
    @fva1835 4 місяці тому +2

    Jurgen confusing genestealer whenever they want to kill his beloved commissar.😅

    • @AAhmou
      @AAhmou 4 місяці тому

      Even a Genestealer Patriarch flinched when Jurgen came in.

  • @liamparker8877
    @liamparker8877 4 місяці тому +1

    I could see them being used against Psychic Xenos threats in addition to chaos I suppose, but they’d definitely have to flesh them out more as a faction to do so. I can also imagine them being deployed against specific nids units although extremely niche.

  • @GeoffryGifari
    @GeoffryGifari 4 місяці тому +4

    Total filthy casual here, there are some things I'm curious about
    1. Why is the silence aspect important for them as blanks?
    2. Are there also elite positions for male blanks? or maybe there are just far fewer male blanks
    3. Silly thought: If chaos in the warp are the main bad guys, wouldn't it be beneficial to either encourage blanks to procreate as much as possible or somehow mass-produce blanks, filling humanity with blanks, weakening the warp?

    • @GeoffryGifari
      @GeoffryGifari 4 місяці тому +1

      Oh and does the eldar have blanks? if so how are they treated?

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +4

      Good questions!
      1. Its part of their vow of tranquility. The meaning of which is so they dont "speak of the horrible things they learn to hunt warp threats. Or never speak mercy to those they hunt." Paraphrased quote from custodes 9th codex. But its a cultural thing largely with how its treated.
      2. Not in the sisters. They can find elite positions in Inquitor groups or in the Assassinorum. The Culexus specifically.
      3. Because most just don't know what a blank is. And the Imperium wont disseminate that cause it would mean telling people that Chaos exists. Which is a bad idea.
      4. Old lore hints at Eldar blanks but rn it looks like there are no blanks in Eldar society. Honestly, my money is on the fact that their might have been a long ass time ago. And then they were killed. Theres some hints at that too with Eldar stating they disaprove of humans allowing Blanks to live in the first place.

    • @jotesbe9117
      @jotesbe9117 4 місяці тому +1

      with the 1, in books sisters of silence curiously produce no sounds, be it a step, or a thump when falling, in Siege of Terra it's expanded with even one of the most powerful psykers not noticing when the leader of the sisters entered the room, reasoning only that if a door opened without anyone stepping in, and they actually asked her to come, she must be already there, after which they were able to notice that she was sitting at their table for some time. It seems being silent makes blanks supernaturally stealthy due to just mind willing to put itself in denial of their painful presence. Then of course in the tabletop rules you might notice - in a meta fashion - it's not there

  • @KatriaThePotato
    @KatriaThePotato 4 місяці тому +1

    I'd want to read something about them not as warriors but as personalities. How do they experience emotions? Do they experience romantic, familial or platonic affection? How do they see other SoS compared to non-nulls? Probably, I want a slice of life novel about them, ahaha. Anyways, BL authors should write more about characters' inner worlds, feelings and their relationships (not necessarily romantic).

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +1

      Black Library does do all that, at least the good books do. Depends on the book. I'm into the ones that have more plot or meat on it and less dumb action scenes. And blanks can feel all of that. The problem is they are deprived of it in their life. Due to that effect on regular people they have. If you want the best look at how shit being a blank is read the Eisenhorn trilogy. Theres a depressing af blank you meet very early in those books.

  • @alastor8091
    @alastor8091 4 місяці тому +1

    10:30 Real life militaries do the same thing. Look up how many things in the US Army had the title of "M1" back in the day. M1 Garand, M1A1 Carbine, M1A1 Thompson, there was an M1A1 truck not to be confused with the M1A1tank, so on and so forth.

  • @Tommy-5684
    @Tommy-5684 4 місяці тому

    talking about the sisters of silence working with the custodies the Cypher novel suggests in the 42nd millennium the relationship between the Sisters ad the Custodians as at the very least strained if not broken

  • @benjaminmoser6890
    @benjaminmoser6890 4 місяці тому +1

    I want to see you create a well designed live background, awesome lighting, and a fancy little mic to clip to your collar or can have out of frame. That, my good man, will elevate your videos so much, because - quite frankly - you're a good listen. Have a good day, and dare to make the invest.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому

      I hope to! Main issue is space. Better visuals like lighting is a space issue. My current place isnt big enough for a perfect green screen setup. So I gotta work with basic lights, editing tricks, and a nice handheld mic. Cause the only way I can upgrade my stuff further if I wanna go handheld is by getting a really nice standing mic. There is a lav ceiling. Though tbh I also like the vibe of the handheld? Its content I watch already on youtube actually lol.
      If its hard to tell, I'm a film student lol. I've put some thought into this. I plan to keep upgrading as it becomes more and more successful.

  • @SCUBAelement-Intl
    @SCUBAelement-Intl 4 місяці тому

    Cool, good rundown on origins and mechanism!

  • @Ave_Christus_Rex3777
    @Ave_Christus_Rex3777 4 місяці тому +2

    It's a shame that GW would rather gender swap the Custodes than give the Sisters some love

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +2

      People say that like adding women to the custodes somehow deleted any new SoS stuff they were working on. Or that single paragraph of text in the codex took so much time it prevented a whole ass book for the sisters lmao. I dont get it. Especially cause new book/animation releases show they haven't been just dropped like people keep doom posting.

  • @chriswalsh6893
    @chriswalsh6893 17 днів тому

    Well think about it they have sneak the tanks/ artillery into position. Execute an attack/ ambush. And if the target and anyone that could spot you is dead……..that’s as successfully as u can be I would say

  • @riccardocarminatigalli2852
    @riccardocarminatigalli2852 4 місяці тому

    The sound is much better

  • @alannatherson7721
    @alannatherson7721 4 місяці тому

    I think a Sisters of Silence Kill Team would be cool and could be interesting in a story or part of a story where some sort of pirates (I'd go with Orks or Dark Eldar) attacking the Black Ships operated by the Sisters of Silence.

  • @cameronpoupard9966
    @cameronpoupard9966 4 місяці тому

    He's gettin a little explodey is wild 🤣🤣🤣

  • @tyrant-den884
    @tyrant-den884 4 місяці тому

    The way i would do a story where they fight Necrons: _they were not there to fight Necrons_
    They show up to deal with some rogue Word Bearers, but then the planet turns out to be a tomb world or something.
    Or, they beat the Word Bearers; story starts right afterwords. Its was a fairly simple win but they are still tired and hurting-BAM, Orks show up.

  • @tyrant-den884
    @tyrant-den884 4 місяці тому

    An Inquisitor could arrange for SoS to enter conflict with a division of T'au they know to include Ethereals just to see how and if they affect them.

  • @anotherperson2627
    @anotherperson2627 4 місяці тому

    I feel your main arguement as to why more lore is difficult to make is EXACTLY why they need more lore. Like they are too focuswd on their 1 thing because the havent had enough stories experimenting with them.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +2

      Yeah pretty much. Then the issue is it feels like a loop. The solution is to write more lore, but if they go too far then its too much of a change. SoS are fun *because* of their specialization. But now they're still limited and need more lore... I want more stuff, I think its gotta be delicate. And idk how I would even start with it lol.

  • @80Elminster
    @80Elminster 4 місяці тому

    the black ships belongs to the Astra Telepathica but are used by the inquisition often. But they are the same ships, not two different kinds

  • @tyrant-den884
    @tyrant-den884 4 місяці тому

    I like playing SoS with Imperial Knight armies. Another badass army without much psycher defense.
    Heck, a lot of Knight stories start with a psycher f_cking with them.

  • @leovalenzuela8368
    @leovalenzuela8368 4 місяці тому

    You sound great GB!

  • @Grudgebearer4life
    @Grudgebearer4life 4 місяці тому

    Nobody has a soft spot for sos, that’s not how they’re designed!!!

  • @celdur4635
    @celdur4635 4 місяці тому +2

    As cool as they are. They can't remain "silent" if they are actually going to be used in combat, specially in larger numbers. It would also make sense lore wise, since now they are being active.
    I would even make it so they are in similar but different gear when on "fighting and speaking" terms.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +1

      Personally disagree. Its too tied into their identity and I doubt it would ever be something GW would do. Mainly with how much effort they've put in to potray Thoughtform as legit sign language. That and they already do have methods to get around the non-speaking stuff. Asperants who translate and tech that does it on the fly. If anything I can only see them adding units to the faction that can speak and translate. So it isnt just asperants.

  • @velenvskaelhas
    @velenvskaelhas 4 місяці тому +1

    Do you wish a sister of battle was your girlfriend?

  • @hallroney
    @hallroney 4 місяці тому +3

    eldar say blanks have no soul and they have a deeper knowledge of this kind of things than humans

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +7

      The Voice short story is just one example in lore that blanks have souls. And its a specific plot point/twist that everyone believes they don't. Large part because of the Eldar saying that. So when (spoilers) a Sister of Silence sold her soul to daemons, it was hard to believe. They didn't think that was possible in the first place, but nah she had a soul to exchange. Based on all the evidence in lore, it only ends in the fact that Blanks have souls. And the souless belief is one born out of prejudice from psychic based species.

    • @hallroney
      @hallroney 4 місяці тому +2

      @@glueboy oh amazing, so eldar full of bs like always lol

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +3

      @hallroney I can forgive this one from them only because Blanks much especially suck from their perspective. But yeah lol. They just were dead wrong. Though the people in universe who know Blanks have souls are pretty few and far between. Can't judge too harshly. I only judge other 40k loretubers who spread half info lol

    • @xaviergould8747
      @xaviergould8747 4 місяці тому +2

      they said about the tau too, now they have a warp god

    • @xaviergould8747
      @xaviergould8747 4 місяці тому

      @@glueboy it's probably more like they have souls similar to the realm of souls energy aka pre war in heaven fucking up the realm of souls into the warp

  • @gahngis8158
    @gahngis8158 4 місяці тому

    I dont understand why we dont see Sisters of battle making use of Blanks, they seem perfect for what the SoB mostly like to fight.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому

      Had to double check but turns out they've had next to no in book encounters. Except for Plague Wars. Though would get real goofy when Celestine or their other "totally not warp stuff its pure faith trust us" powers get fucked up by the SoS lmao

    • @gahngis8158
      @gahngis8158 4 місяці тому

      @@glueboy Thats legit insane to me that theyve essentially no screen time with eachother. Though it makes sense with their new"er" Imperial Deamon stuff theyve got going on.
      Also Holy shit you replied back Q U I C K.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому

      Lol you happened to catch me on a lunch break.
      And yeah, I imagine its mostly a timeline thing. SoS being mainly HH until recently and SoB popping up later. Only now is the chance they can interact. And SoS just isnt that big so the likelihood of a notable encounter isnt that large. I hope we get more though.

  • @joelcasseus628
    @joelcasseus628 4 місяці тому +1

    Yoooo Glueboy! Great Vid brother! stupid question: adding a Sisters Squad to Black Templars, yeah or nay?

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +2

      I'm a very bad source for whats good in tabletop rn lol. But it is a fun kit. And shouldn't hurt? I'd have to consult with my inner council. That being the actual comp players I'm friends with lol

  • @lenajohnson6179
    @lenajohnson6179 4 місяці тому

    Sister's of silence should just be an attachment of the Sister's of Battle/Costodes interface sect... I mean honestly what more IS there too them that can be explored? They're anti-Psykers... that's it. That's what they do... and there's even already a Sister's of Battle regiment that don't talk much so even... I honestly don't know what more you can really do with them in the same way you can with other factions. They're more like a specialized unit OF a faction.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому

      Thats my point at the end. They're limited when I think thats unintended by the writers. I'd love to see them fix that in the future somehow.

    • @lenajohnson6179
      @lenajohnson6179 4 місяці тому

      @@glueboy I guess what I mean to say is I don't know what else they even COULD do with them. I don't think they are a concept that works as a 'faction'. The entire idea of them works well as a specialized unit or highly trained 'spec ops' with a specialized usage and execution... I honestly don't think there's enough you can do with the concept of anti-psykers to warrant an entire faction of them (and do we really need ANOTHER all female 'Sisters of' faction?)
      I think they're fine as is, just make them viable as units in a few different factions and they can both get more play, and be involved in more stories.

  • @N0TYALC
    @N0TYALC 4 місяці тому

    Brother, you do *not* belong in front of a camera.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +3

      Okay. But what if I... keep doing it anyways?

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому

      @@jamesisaacson6379 I dont know. Next vtm video will be whenever I get the hankering to do so.

  • @toniviskari417
    @toniviskari417 4 місяці тому +1

    Thoughtmark is actually pretty hilarious when reading in books as they are just having these bizarrely complicated discussions with a few gestures and in less time than it would take to speak them out. Especially in the Wraight books they really went overboard on it. Also, I will say that I liked The Emperor's Legion, but it was just scattered as hell and was already straining with the Valoris problem.
    I'd actually the bigger problem narratively with the Sisters of Silence is how much they thematically overlap with the Sisters of Battle, who in turn are already much more established faction. Also the Silent Sisters are currently so tightly tied into the Custodes, who in turn themselves are struggling to stand out in stories as characters. So the end result is not exactly thrilling.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому

      Overlap with the other Sisters who then as a faction can be significantly more flexible story wise. So one feels like an easier choice to throw front and center. Which they do, Sisters of Battle have a lot of books and shit put out about them. I say this lovingly, cause I also like them a lot lol. Also big agree on that part about their Custodes pair up. The intention seems to be more like 2 groups that work really well together. The result hits more like Sisters of Silence are just the best faction of side characters ever.

  • @asaenvolk
    @asaenvolk 4 місяці тому

    I would love to see the sisters of silence to be confirmed bio-enhanced some how, which is why they are all women, because the enhancements don't work with male blanks.
    As for them as a full army, less so interested, they work better as a support group, than a real army.
    Now a return of the Slann... (ie Lizardman army) yes please.

  • @celdur4635
    @celdur4635 4 місяці тому

    Aren't blanks being stuffed with warp entities by Valdor?

  • @peteturabo9278
    @peteturabo9278 4 місяці тому +2

    Please don’t have them talk.

    • @glueboy
      @glueboy  4 місяці тому +1

      Making them talk would be the worst move possible. I don't think they'd do that in the first place though lol. They have the Sisters in training and thoughtmark translator tools to work around that.

    • @American-Royarch
      @American-Royarch 4 місяці тому

      I agree, don't let 'em say a word.

  • @jaydayee
    @jaydayee 4 місяці тому +4

    C'mon GW how bout Brothers of Silence??🙄

    • @kylehammer9154
      @kylehammer9154 4 місяці тому +2

      Lmao nail on the head battle brother😂😂😂

    • @jaydayee
      @jaydayee 4 місяці тому +2

      @@kylehammer9154 lol Ive already started the kit bash ...their going to love me at tournies...

    • @tyrant-den884
      @tyrant-den884 4 місяці тому +5

      If Custodes can be women, it's like: why not?
      Doesn't add anything, but it doesn't really contradict anything.

    • @probablythedm1669
      @probablythedm1669 4 місяці тому

      Come on man, learn what you're talking about if you're gonna bitch about it! The Culexus Temple are the ones who take the male blanks and the Sisters of Silence rejects. What you're asking for already exists! Enough with the culture-war tourism, it's embarassing and tedious... 🤦‍♂️