The way I see story is that it is a metaphor for a loved one with a incurable disease like leukemia. We all believe (or want to) that they will be the exception and survive, but fate is not always so merciful. That and as much it broke my heart, Hugo was always doomed even things played out differently.
just finished the game, what an emotional roller coaster. my understanding of the origin of the Macula: - in ancient times, there was a plague/disease that killed many. a divine power manifested itself in the presence of a Phoenix, with the Phoenix's healing power and reincarnation, it helped the world and its people. but some religious heretics formed a cult - The Order and they wanted to control the Phoenix, in a horrible turn of event, the Phoenix was murdered - the rage and hatred towards humanity turned the Phoenix into a malignant being, hence the Macula was born. and it's healing power became a power of correption, it's reincarnation remained and it passed on from one carrier to another. the dream the Macula showed to Hugo, i believe it was where the Phoenix once resided and worshiped before its murder. and this is my only explanation for why the Phoenix symbol appears on everything that's connected to The Order.
I genuinely don't understand how you don't have millions of views. Please don't ever stop posting, I _promise_ you're going to make it. Video essays (like you're making) and so popular & desperately needed. If you ever feel like making some on - Assassin's Creed Odyssey, Pokemon, elder scrolls, adventure time - I won't complain 😅
This guy is good and going places if he keeps up with the video quality, But the millions of followers will not happen, not anytime soon, simply because these kinda videos are not liked by a large audience because of many people’s shortening attention spans.
@@Irn_Knih Have you not seen some of the other big creators that make long video essays? They have millions of views...soooo.... You're objectively completely and factually incorrect 🤷🏼♀️
@@PeachShortcake_ views Not followers Edit: I was talking about the sub/follower count for content creators who make video essays with some form of meaning, and not those that are seen as nothing more other than overly-elaborate shit posts or satirical ones going over a meme made into a theory for a story meant to justify rooting for a villain, a hero being a bad guy, or some other kind of “going against the flow” kind of theory don’t get me wrong, these guys can get up there in the sub count, and I hope this guy makes it in the end. If there is a content creator who commonly makes long video essays with millions(plural) of followers, please let me know, I am would be quite interested in them.
@@Irn_Knih also - I have a few public playlists on my profile with almost 5k videos (video essays) from thousands of different creators. Plenty of them on there have 500k-1mil followers. Even the ones that don't have many followers, they ( _usually_ ) get hundreds of thousands - millions of views. It's a lot of videos to go thru (I'm constantly updating it & I'll make a *third* public playlist) but there are countless creators you can find on there 🥰✨ *Edit* I'm not affiliated or paid or sponsored btw lol. I have a hyper fixation on video essays/long form content, so I spend a fair amount of time finding new videos to add to my playlists.
9:20 The scene of Amicia being choked to death continues off camera BTW, while the camera zooms on Hugo's face. Robyn Wolf, the actress for Amicia, portrayed Amicia struggle for her life very realistic, and when you go into photo mode during the zoom, and turn the camera around, you see the fear, panic, despair and rage in Amicia's face (the CGI model projects it in every detail, even up to Amicia's tongue sticking out) - which Hugo is directly looking at. You can see photos of it on the IMDB page of the game. I suspect it became a "deleted scene", because it was too intense that early in the game and they feared some might be put off seeing a teenager almost being killed by choking from two large men after 15 minutes.
17:32 I don't think you knew, but there is a book released last year (only available in french), a plague tale tenebris, set between innocence and requiem in which Hugo passes through the second threshold. 48:00 It's not an unknown reason. Lucas was never on the boat, when Amicia broke the chain and simultaneously destroyed the dock, Lucas got stuck on the other side of the river and had to find a way to get past the rats on that side to get to the lockgates. 02:11:25 If I can speculate, Beatrice and Lucas followed the tracks of Amicia and Hugo and found the pilgrims who had the map that would possibly show where la cuna is. From there it would be easy to find a boat to the island, as the player learns early on that traders from the mainland go there during bright days to do business. If you're interested, one of the devs, Olivier Deriviere, did a playthrough of the game with many insights of the story.
Late, but thanks for stating there's a book! I'd love to read it, though it's only in French as far as I can find. Is there an English version out there somewhere, or is it Google Translate all the way?
Beat this game in 24 hours of starting it, I knew it was gonna be heavy but when I finished. I didn't even have words to describe it, it hurt so badly. Just sat at my desk in the dark stareing at the screen for like 5 minutes trying to just understand everything. I knew it was coming, just not this way Once we saw what happened to the old carrier, I knew it was too late to save him. No game before has impacts me this way, not even any movie or book
I just finished this amazing game and I loved Hugo so much. He was a sweetheart and innocent being. He didn't deserve all suffering he had in his short life. This kid had more suffering than happiness. I wondered if anyone could really endure such suffering. The game isn't perfect, as none are, but the story is incredible, as sad as it is.
Amicia is one of the most tragic video game characters I’ve seen she lost literally everything she could. Across two games you really feel her childhood innocence and humanity slowly slipping away. By the end of requiem she was completely broken and a shadow of the person she once was. I also feel like she cut her hair short at the end not only as a sign of her new self but also because her hair is a painful reminder of Hugo because he use to put flowers in it so she cut it all off
2:47:49 Saying as a Hindu who studied Sanskrit and speaks Hindi, Oppenheimer was wrong in his translation of Shrimad Bhagvad Gita here. The word काल that he thinks means death is also the word used for time, because time is death. Death doesn't destroy worlds, but time does. Therefore, the more acceptable translation of the quote is "Now I've become time, the destroyer of worlds". Because even non-living entities aren't capable of surviving time.
I’ve been watching this on my way to work this past week, and I cannot thank you enough for making this superb video. Both Innocence and Requiem are so underrated and I’m glad we all get to experience this story broken down to see the masterpiece that it is
Amazing video friend. Loved this game so much. Going through both these games back to back was savage. One day I'll put myself through it again. For now I'll hug those I love a little tighter and longer. Thanks so much for your content, keep up the great work
Heartbreaking, to me that is the correct word, but not based on the story, rather, based on the missed potential if this is the final story of the DeRune family.
Some of the missing context between the two games likely came from the book that came out between the release of both games. The book is called A Plague Tale Tenebris and is currently only available in French.
I dont even like video games all that much, i just enjoy casual long form content and so that means i watch a lot of gaming and lore videos. I REALLY enjoy your content, found you a couple days ago and now have watched/listen to everything youve got. Theres no question that as soon as the algorithmic gods start favoring you then there's no doubt you'll pick up with extreme speed. I know youre relatively new to the scene, but i really do hope you stick around, ill definitely be there to watch whatever multi-hour content you produce Also early congrats on the almost 1k!
Watching this was simply fantastic!! If your future projects are done with as much superb storytelling as this video shown. You will rise to the top echelon of youtube storytellers. I'm excited to watch your channel and yourself as a storyteller grow!!
Bro you deserve so many more views. Shit i could watch this a million times myself if i had the time haha thanks for the great content. Just finished my first playthrough and immediately checked this out
If you do the windmill puzzle, you get a special bit of armour that i think helps you recover from being hit quicker or something; i never noticed much of a difference
broo you didn't mention the scene at the very end where they tease a new carrier. An infant hooked up to a machine. You hear someone walking in heels. Most likely set another few hundred years in the future. 1900s is my guess. I was looking forward hearing your thoughts on that one after watching the two plaguetale vids. I really hope we get a cool answer to the very origins of the macula next game. Kind of hard to guess how thats gonna happen considering its further ahead in time.. unless it is not.. but a long long time ago.
27:20 It's difficult and it only results in a couple of lines of dialogue, but it *is* possible to save the herbalist if you do it before they reach the spot where the soldier will kill him.
I adored the first game but just couldn't get into Requim for some reason. I was actually quite upset by that and plan on giving it another try. I'm sure this retrospective will give me a new desire to play!
It really is a triumph once you give it a proper go! Although it is fairly different from Innocent as it’s scale is a lot larger, the emotional toil it takes on you is phenomenal. I also recommend you don’t watch this video until you’ve finished the game yourself as its best moments are only truly spectacular if you don’t know about them imo!
I have been having the same issue for some reason. Maybe its because I am also trying to complete the achievements and knowing I have to play the almost entire game again that for some reason those two things are feeding into each other.
I'm very late, but in Innocence, Amicia finds an artwork of an alchemical process symbolically shown through a Lion devouring the sun, and says "I hope it's not a prophecy. I think this is a sort of subtle nod to the Nebula, despite that drawing being an actual symbolic representation of Salpeter canceling Sulphur if i'm not mistaken.
Great video, much enjoyed listening to it after finishing both games. One picky remark is about the title of Chapter V, "Hath" is the old form of "Has" for the third person singular, thus wasn't/cannot be used for the "They" pronoun. Great work in any case, would love to see/hear more from your channel!
I know I already commented, but I had to pop back in and say this part killed me. "Married to her (abridged). Who was also his first cousin..." *hoe down music plays* 😂
I'm confused. The title says "analysis" but I'm 20 minutes in and all you've done so far is summarize events. Does the analysis begin at some point? and can someone timestamp when?
2:04:14 What a STUPID obvious conclusion, from Amicia I mean. It took her a whole game to figure out all they need to do is chill out somewhere together? The whole Basilius discovery and what they got out of it was so underwhelming and just boiled down too "We should never let it come to this, if we just stay together and live in peace something like this will never happen" no shit.
1:53:10 in medieval times, Asia was the term used for what we now call Anatolia, which would be controlled by the Eastern Romans at this time, maybe the game means that?
There's a game I'd like to see more attention drawn to. It's a game called IXION and is rather unsung. That could be good to cover and if not that, then perhaps Helldivers for something popular.
After watching the innocence video and this one back to back, I’m beginning to think you are Joseph Anderson on a brand new channel so people don’t ask about the Witcher 3 video 🧐
The thing for me is that if someone was blind and they heard you playing the 2 games they would assume you were playing 2 games with different characters. The irony is that Plague Tale Requiem has the same voice actors as its predecessor 🤷 The decision to change the characters accents was a big L in my opinion. How you speak is a big part of your identity from style, speech patterns to accent. The deuteragonists seem like different people. It’s like watching a movie when the main characters are recast for the sequel. The only way I could have got on board is if it was 10 years later, the main characters were living in England and they developed English accents to hide from those pursuing them. Given that the sequel is only like 6 months or so later, it was a bit jarring for me. I wasn’t able to invest in the sequel. Many seem fine with it but could you imagine if In Ghost of Tsushima 2 Jin Sakai spoke with a British cockney accent or a generic American accent even though it was the same voice actor and the game was still set in Japan. Would be asinine wouldn’t it? So why does Plague Tale Requiem get a pass? Because the graphics are good? People obviously loved the first game and the characters, why change something that people already loved and were invested in. At least with Spider-Man they had the excuse of wanting a different face model to emote better for Mo cap, but in this case it’s the same actors. I would of had less problem with the characters looking more like the actors playing them to improve lip sync and mocap with them still sounding the same, than for them to look the same and sound and behave significantly different. They could just as well of had the sequel cover a new story with different characters set in England, set in the same game universe and the game would have played out pretty much the same. Even when Clementine aged up over the walking dead telltale series the actress maintained the character’s identity. She sounded like she was voiced by the same actress and the character felt the same just older. Thats how you do a sequel.
I chalked it up to England, France, and Britain having this sort of round table rivalry thing happening. Throughout history they have influenced each other in fashion, diction, and food among other things. I haven't read Tenebris since it's in French, but I just assumed the English accent has somehow become popular in their region of France during this interlude and that's why they're using it. Or if you prefer it, you can consider it more of a "translation error." Of course, since the characters are in France, they would still be speaking French in-world; to us, the audience, this has been translated into a language we can understand. The accent switch is kinda like how Irish and Scottish can get mixed up, or Australian and New Zealand's accents get mixed around by actors (usually in older stuff). Or you can take it as it is; the voice actors are just more comfortable using their own voices, and the acting direction was lax. You could always play it in French!
Ah yes. Hugo. One of the most annoying and dumb characters i have ever seen in a game. This game was just awfully bad. Just a tad better than the first, but Thats it.
The way I see story is that it is a metaphor for a loved one with a incurable disease like leukemia. We all believe (or want to) that they will be the exception and survive, but fate is not always so merciful. That and as much it broke my heart, Hugo was always doomed even things played out differently.
I agree, that's how I view it as well
just finished the game, what an emotional roller coaster.
my understanding of the origin of the Macula:
- in ancient times, there was a plague/disease that killed many. a divine power manifested itself in the presence of a Phoenix, with the Phoenix's healing power and reincarnation, it helped the world and its people. but some religious heretics formed a cult - The Order and they wanted to control the Phoenix, in a horrible turn of event, the Phoenix was murdered
- the rage and hatred towards humanity turned the Phoenix into a malignant being, hence the Macula was born. and it's healing power became a power of correption, it's reincarnation remained and it passed on from one carrier to another.
the dream the Macula showed to Hugo, i believe it was where the Phoenix once resided and worshiped before its murder. and this is my only explanation for why the Phoenix symbol appears on everything that's connected to The Order.
good explanation.
This is my favorite modern game. Completely blown away, I was not expecting any of it
I genuinely don't understand how you don't have millions of views.
Please don't ever stop posting, I _promise_ you're going to make it. Video essays (like you're making) and so popular & desperately needed.
If you ever feel like making some on - Assassin's Creed Odyssey, Pokemon, elder scrolls, adventure time - I won't complain 😅
This guy is good and going places if he keeps up with the video quality,
But the millions of followers will not happen, not anytime soon, simply because these kinda videos are not liked by a large audience because of many people’s shortening attention spans.
@@Irn_Knih Have you not seen some of the other big creators that make long video essays? They have millions of views...soooo....
You're objectively completely and factually incorrect 🤷🏼♀️
@@PeachShortcake_ views
Not followers
Edit: I was talking about the sub/follower count for content creators who make video essays with some form of meaning, and not those that are seen as nothing more other than overly-elaborate shit posts or satirical ones going over a meme made into a theory for a story meant to justify rooting for a villain, a hero being a bad guy, or some other kind of “going against the flow” kind of theory
don’t get me wrong, these guys can get up there in the sub count, and I hope this guy makes it in the end.
If there is a content creator who commonly makes long video essays with millions(plural) of followers, please let me know, I am would be quite interested in them.
@@Irn_Knih no one ever said followers except for you. My original comment said millions of views & he will grow in subs.
@@Irn_Knih also - I have a few public playlists on my profile with almost 5k videos (video essays) from thousands of different creators. Plenty of them on there have 500k-1mil followers.
Even the ones that don't have many followers, they ( _usually_ ) get hundreds of thousands - millions of views. It's a lot of videos to go thru (I'm constantly updating it & I'll make a *third* public playlist) but there are countless creators you can find on there 🥰✨
*Edit* I'm not affiliated or paid or sponsored btw lol. I have a hyper fixation on video essays/long form content, so I spend a fair amount of time finding new videos to add to my playlists.
9:20 The scene of Amicia being choked to death continues off camera BTW, while the camera zooms on Hugo's face. Robyn Wolf, the actress for Amicia, portrayed Amicia struggle for her life very realistic, and when you go into photo mode during the zoom, and turn the camera around, you see the fear, panic, despair and rage in Amicia's face (the CGI model projects it in every detail, even up to Amicia's tongue sticking out) - which Hugo is directly looking at. You can see photos of it on the IMDB page of the game. I suspect it became a "deleted scene", because it was too intense that early in the game and they feared some might be put off seeing a teenager almost being killed by choking from two large men after 15 minutes.
17:32 I don't think you knew, but there is a book released last year (only available in french), a plague tale tenebris, set between innocence and requiem in which Hugo passes through the second threshold.
48:00 It's not an unknown reason. Lucas was never on the boat, when Amicia broke the chain and simultaneously destroyed the dock, Lucas got stuck on the other side of the river and had to find a way to get past the rats on that side to get to the lockgates.
02:11:25 If I can speculate, Beatrice and Lucas followed the tracks of Amicia and Hugo and found the pilgrims who had the map that would possibly show where la cuna is. From there it would be easy to find a boat to the island, as the player learns early on that traders from the mainland go there during bright days to do business.
If you're interested, one of the devs, Olivier Deriviere, did a playthrough of the game with many insights of the story.
Late, but thanks for stating there's a book! I'd love to read it, though it's only in French as far as I can find. Is there an English version out there somewhere, or is it Google Translate all the way?
Wait there's a book !? Please tell me where to find it !
@@sachagacha9570 Amazon/Kindle has it. I can still only find it in French.
Beat this game in 24 hours of starting it, I knew it was gonna be heavy but when I finished. I didn't even have words to describe it, it hurt so badly. Just sat at my desk in the dark stareing at the screen for like 5 minutes trying to just understand everything. I knew it was coming, just not this way
Once we saw what happened to the old carrier, I knew it was too late to save him. No game before has impacts me this way, not even any movie or book
Same.
Still hurts a week later. It's left a hole
I just finished this amazing game and I loved Hugo so much. He was a sweetheart and innocent being. He didn't deserve all suffering he had in his short life. This kid had more suffering than happiness. I wondered if anyone could really endure such suffering. The game isn't perfect, as none are, but the story is incredible, as sad as it is.
Amicia is one of the most tragic video game characters I’ve seen she lost literally everything she could. Across two games you really feel her childhood innocence and humanity slowly slipping away. By the end of requiem she was completely broken and a shadow of the person she once was. I also feel like she cut her hair short at the end not only as a sign of her new self but also because her hair is a painful reminder of Hugo because he use to put flowers in it so she cut it all off
Just ordered a physical copy of this last week. Just finished the first loved it
I cry at the end every time. No shame. Thanks for this awesome rundown and analysis. I'm off to check out your Horizon videos now!
2:47:49 Saying as a Hindu who studied Sanskrit and speaks Hindi, Oppenheimer was wrong in his translation of Shrimad Bhagvad Gita here. The word काल that he thinks means death is also the word used for time, because time is death. Death doesn't destroy worlds, but time does. Therefore, the more acceptable translation of the quote is "Now I've become time, the destroyer of worlds". Because even non-living entities aren't capable of surviving time.
Man...oppenheimer was dumb asf
From now on, I am officially your loyal subscriber. I hope the passion you deliver during your speech will never fade!
I’ve been watching this on my way to work this past week, and I cannot thank you enough for making this superb video. Both Innocence and Requiem are so underrated and I’m glad we all get to experience this story broken down to see the masterpiece that it is
Amazing video friend. Loved this game so much. Going through both these games back to back was savage. One day I'll put myself through it again. For now I'll hug those I love a little tighter and longer. Thanks so much for your content, keep up the great work
Heartbreaking, to me that is the correct word, but not based on the story, rather, based on the missed potential if this is the final story of the DeRune family.
Underatted channel and video right here👏 Cried again when I saw the end😢
Remarkable video man. I enjoyed every second of it. Thank you for making this.
Some of the missing context between the two games likely came from the book that came out between the release of both games. The book is called A Plague Tale Tenebris and is currently only available in French.
One word for this video "beautiful". You did an amazing job, please keep doing the great work that you are doing.
i love this series. compelling story and superb gameplay
thanks for the wonderfull analysis of this story. It is my favorite video game story ever
Wow, thank you for this video. A great narrative of a great narrative.
I dont even like video games all that much, i just enjoy casual long form content and so that means i watch a lot of gaming and lore videos. I REALLY enjoy your content, found you a couple days ago and now have watched/listen to everything youve got. Theres no question that as soon as the algorithmic gods start favoring you then there's no doubt you'll pick up with extreme speed. I know youre relatively new to the scene, but i really do hope you stick around, ill definitely be there to watch whatever multi-hour content you produce
Also early congrats on the almost 1k!
These videos are my favorite night time watch. please never stop your awesome lore videos!
Great analysis, thanks for making it!
I’m going to miss amicia😢
Well at least she's still alive
Watching this was simply fantastic!! If your future projects are done with as much superb storytelling as this video shown. You will rise to the top echelon of youtube storytellers. I'm excited to watch your channel and yourself as a storyteller grow!!
Hi Adam! I just found your channel a few days ago and just wanted to say that you make great stuff! Good work my guy! Wishing you the best🎉
Bro you deserve so many more views. Shit i could watch this a million times myself if i had the time haha thanks for the great content. Just finished my first playthrough and immediately checked this out
This is amazing. thank you for the analysis
the game is a purest gem )
So excited to watch this, I love all these types of videos. Especially yours
Your videos are made with such excellency and thought, I can't believe you don't have more subscribers! Awesome video as always
This is awesome! Very well thought out and made.
Great stuff 🙏 im looking forward to the next game.
If you do the windmill puzzle, you get a special bit of armour that i think helps you recover from being hit quicker or something; i never noticed much of a difference
since i played on hard any interaction with a minor enemy would oneshot amicia, the bracer allowed me to take 1 hit without dying
It helps you a lot if you want to do a NG+ run which is required for the platinum trophy.
Thank you
broo you didn't mention the scene at the very end where they tease a new carrier. An infant hooked up to a machine. You hear someone walking in heels. Most likely set another few hundred years in the future. 1900s is my guess. I was looking forward hearing your thoughts on that one after watching the two plaguetale vids. I really hope we get a cool answer to the very origins of the macula next game. Kind of hard to guess how thats gonna happen considering its further ahead in time.. unless it is not.. but a long long time ago.
27:20 It's difficult and it only results in a couple of lines of dialogue, but it *is* possible to save the herbalist if you do it before they reach the spot where the soldier will kill him.
I adored the first game but just couldn't get into Requim for some reason. I was actually quite upset by that and plan on giving it another try. I'm sure this retrospective will give me a new desire to play!
It really is a triumph once you give it a proper go! Although it is fairly different from Innocent as it’s scale is a lot larger, the emotional toil it takes on you is phenomenal. I also recommend you don’t watch this video until you’ve finished the game yourself as its best moments are only truly spectacular if you don’t know about them imo!
I have been having the same issue for some reason. Maybe its because I am also trying to complete the achievements and knowing I have to play the almost entire game again that for some reason those two things are feeding into each other.
@@davidestabrooks211so dont do achievements. Play to enjoy and soak it in.
I'm very late, but in Innocence, Amicia finds an artwork of an alchemical process symbolically shown through a Lion devouring the sun, and says "I hope it's not a prophecy. I think this is a sort of subtle nod to the Nebula, despite that drawing being an actual symbolic representation of Salpeter canceling Sulphur if i'm not mistaken.
I finished this game the other day but never knew about the option for Lucas to kill Hugo instead 😭
Great video, much enjoyed listening to it after finishing both games.
One picky remark is about the title of Chapter V, "Hath" is the old form of "Has" for the third person singular, thus wasn't/cannot be used for the "They" pronoun.
Great work in any case, would love to see/hear more from your channel!
Regardless, excellent video and great analysis. I look forward to the next one!
I know I already commented, but I had to pop back in and say this part killed me.
"Married to her (abridged). Who was also his first cousin..." *hoe down music plays* 😂
GREAT VID!
I'm confused. The title says "analysis" but I'm 20 minutes in and all you've done so far is summarize events. Does the analysis begin at some point? and can someone timestamp when?
It's interspersed, but the video is worth a watch in its entirety.
Yep, seems to be a summary rather than an analysis.
2:04:14 What a STUPID obvious conclusion, from Amicia I mean. It took her a whole game to figure out all they need to do is chill out somewhere together? The whole Basilius discovery and what they got out of it was so underwhelming and just boiled down too "We should never let it come to this, if we just stay together and live in peace something like this will never happen" no shit.
1:53:10 in medieval times, Asia was the term used for what we now call Anatolia, which would be controlled by the Eastern Romans at this time, maybe the game means that?
There's a game I'd like to see more attention drawn to. It's a game called IXION and is rather unsung. That could be good to cover and if not that, then perhaps Helldivers for something popular.
So what do you think about the final, final scene??
After watching the innocence video and this one back to back, I’m beginning to think you are Joseph Anderson on a brand new channel so people don’t ask about the Witcher 3 video 🧐
😂😂
What's the music playing in the background in chapter 2?
A masterpiece of a video
What is the opening piece of music for this video?
I'm not sure I even want to watch this video. I'm thinking I really should play the game first.
Just the main theme of the game
The thing for me is that if someone was blind and they heard you playing the 2 games they would assume you were playing 2 games with different characters. The irony is that Plague Tale Requiem has the same voice actors as its predecessor 🤷
The decision to change the characters accents was a big L in my opinion. How you speak is a big part of your identity from style, speech patterns to accent. The deuteragonists seem like different people. It’s like watching a movie when the main characters are recast for the sequel. The only way I could have got on board is if it was 10 years later, the main characters were living in England and they developed English accents to hide from those pursuing them. Given that the sequel is only like 6 months or so later, it was a bit jarring for me.
I wasn’t able to invest in the sequel. Many seem fine with it but could you imagine if In Ghost of Tsushima 2 Jin Sakai spoke with a British cockney accent or a generic American accent even though it was the same voice actor and the game was still set in Japan. Would be asinine wouldn’t it? So why does Plague Tale Requiem get a pass? Because the graphics are good? People obviously loved the first game and the characters, why change something that people already loved and were invested in. At least with Spider-Man they had the excuse of wanting a different face model to emote better for Mo cap, but in this case it’s the same actors. I would of had less problem with the characters looking more like the actors playing them to improve lip sync and mocap with them still sounding the same, than for them to look the same and sound and behave significantly different. They could just as well of had the sequel cover a new story with different characters set in England, set in the same game universe and the game would have played out pretty much the same. Even when Clementine aged up over the walking dead telltale series the actress maintained the character’s identity. She sounded like she was voiced by the same actress and the character felt the same just older. Thats how you do a sequel.
I chalked it up to England, France, and Britain having this sort of round table rivalry thing happening. Throughout history they have influenced each other in fashion, diction, and food among other things. I haven't read Tenebris since it's in French, but I just assumed the English accent has somehow become popular in their region of France during this interlude and that's why they're using it.
Or if you prefer it, you can consider it more of a "translation error." Of course, since the characters are in France, they would still be speaking French in-world; to us, the audience, this has been translated into a language we can understand. The accent switch is kinda like how Irish and Scottish can get mixed up, or Australian and New Zealand's accents get mixed around by actors (usually in older stuff).
Or you can take it as it is; the voice actors are just more comfortable using their own voices, and the acting direction was lax. You could always play it in French!
Play this game in French with English subs for a more immersive experience
Harris Linda Gonzalez Matthew Williams Shirley
7:( D
More of a story recap then an "analysis"
Ah yes. Hugo. One of the most annoying and dumb characters i have ever seen in a game. This game was just awfully bad. Just a tad better than the first, but Thats it.
Why waste your time commenting on a game you hate then? Go away if you’re going to insult a genuine good game