Why Scandi Bushcraft Knives Rock? And Why They Don't/Joker Knives

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 867

  • @gideonstactical
    @gideonstactical  3 роки тому +39

    The GIVEAWAY IS CLOSED! Evilxxrage is our lucky random winner. Thank you all for participating and for your support! -Aaron

    • @wallytaggart2612
      @wallytaggart2612 3 роки тому

      Congrats Evilxxrage!

    • @evilxxrage
      @evilxxrage 3 роки тому +7

      Thanks a lot for choosing me I really love this channel!

    • @nateand3
      @nateand3 3 роки тому

      So i didn't win? Lol

    • @205jab4
      @205jab4 3 роки тому

      Congrats on your win. It always awesome see nomatter who wins.

    • @normfoley1452
      @normfoley1452 3 роки тому

      Congratulations

  • @greekveteran2715
    @greekveteran2715 2 роки тому +5

    Scandi Grind: Woodworking mainly (Super sharp edge can be used for utility tasks, like draw cutting leather)
    Full Flat Grind: Foodprep or general light and medium use (Great grind for small and medium size general use knives)
    Saber Flat Grind: General hard use (Ideal for choppers, for spliting wood or any hard use knife)
    Convex: Hunting-Field dressing/skinning (The raised cheeks, allow the blade, to glide on bones so that the edge doesn't hit them, also provides more edge stability, which is essential for these kind of jobs)
    Hollow Grind: General light use

    • @Btc1ml
      @Btc1ml 5 місяців тому

      So a scandi won't cut through a tomato? Doesn't a scandi do everything a flat blade does plus more?

  • @Saw_Squatch
    @Saw_Squatch 3 роки тому +17

    So I actually like having my fire steel on a lanyard, either around my next or looped around a belt loop and in my pocket. What I really like on the sheath is a honing rod, either steel or ceramic, so I have a knife and a way to keep it sharp

    • @shawnpepin7890
      @shawnpepin7890 3 роки тому +1

      A sheath is a terrible place to store a fire starter.. always keep 1 in your pocket and 1 in your pack.. I have had too many of these fire starters fall out of the sheath compartments.. most people just like the way it looks, function be damned

    • @OldNavajoTricks
      @OldNavajoTricks 3 роки тому +1

      I have a rod in a zippered compartment in my baccy pouch and another in a hardcase wallet, I keep meaning to drill some for use on my bootlaces but never get to doing it.

  • @ck7629
    @ck7629 3 роки тому +6

    I like having a firesteel loop on my sheath. It’s always there when you need it and if you happen to carry a ferro rod in a bag or pack, nothing wrong with having a backup.

  • @duncanchaboudy4187
    @duncanchaboudy4187 3 роки тому +3

    I bought the Nordico by Joker about a year a half ago (stainless version) and I am a huge fan.

    • @sopwithcamelus
      @sopwithcamelus 3 роки тому

      I don't have one yet, but the many positive reviews I'm hearing make me want to change that.

  • @Airik1111bibles
    @Airik1111bibles 3 роки тому +6

    Joker makes a really beautiful knife, considering the price points . I think for Bushcrafting these are the best deals on the market. The fit an finish is on par with some big name brands maybe even better then some.
    14C28N is a great steel choice and has me looking at their Ember with curly birch handles.

    • @mariocosentino20
      @mariocosentino20 3 роки тому

      Da forgiatore e utilizzatore di coltelli, posso dire che sono fra i peggiori sul mercato. Impugnatura liscia e senza guardia sono pericolosi se usati con le mani bagnate.

  • @ikon-wi1tn
    @ikon-wi1tn 3 роки тому +1

    I worry about losing a firesteel if it’s riding on the sheath, and not noticing, so I prefer somewhere more secure like a sealed pocket on pants or pack.

  • @nickmartino2839
    @nickmartino2839 3 роки тому

    I absolutely love having the firesteel loop on my sheaths!!!!it just makes life so much easier while out in the bush!!!! And making a fire that much easier to!!! Love the channel brother and thank you for the gaw!!!

  • @ahafy3260
    @ahafy3260 3 роки тому +1

    I like having the fire steel on the sheath, especially for trips where you don't expect to need a fire.

  • @krystianchlebek1008
    @krystianchlebek1008 3 роки тому +2

    I definitely like my fire steel separately. I love the Nessmuck. The blade shape and grind are perfect for bushcraft.

  • @davidrohlf4203
    @davidrohlf4203 3 роки тому

    I have just started to get into bushcraft skills after I found this wonderful hobby of hiking through this channel this last summer. Learning how much fun hiking with my kids and learning about new items to get or not get through the videos on this channel has actually saved my life in more ways that one. My heath most importantly!
    If I win this giveaway or not I will never stop watching your videos! I would prefer the one without the fire steel attached the the holster because if I ever wanted to carry the knife on my belt I would want the fire steel to be separate for when I would actually need it. Love the channel man! Keep it up!

  • @swhedge71
    @swhedge71 3 роки тому +2

    It all depends on what, when and where I am using the knife if I want the attached firesteel. Personally, I think that Joker Nessmuk S is a gorgeous knife and the leather sheath without the steel is nice all around carry! Thanks for all of your videos Aaron!

  • @youtubevoice1050
    @youtubevoice1050 3 роки тому +2

    I don't necessarily need the ferrorod attached to the sheath, but I don't mind it either. I'd probably prefer a honing rod in that place, but again, it depends on my overall loadout. Most commercial sheaths don't have such a loop in the first place, so it's sadly not always an option.

  • @mchinnii31
    @mchinnii31 3 роки тому +1

    I like having the fero rod attached to the sheath. It's not a must, but it makes life easier in my opinion.

  • @wazzeradk9398
    @wazzeradk9398 3 роки тому +1

    I have the firesteel loop on a few sheaths but prefer it without. Joker knives have something about them that grabs your attention and also are a great value!

  • @AriMalatesta
    @AriMalatesta 3 роки тому +1

    I usually prefer sheaths simpler, without attachments and have extra gear distributed in my pockets. Great knifes. Thanks, and cheers!

  • @f4nunez612
    @f4nunez612 3 роки тому +1

    I definitely see the benefit of having a spot on the sheath for firesteel but unless it's extremely streamlined, I'd prefer to keep it in a pack or in a belt pocket.

  • @ScentitarFragrance
    @ScentitarFragrance 3 роки тому +1

    Scandi grinds are very prefered to me on almost all knives. If you need to chop or split wood, i use a axe

  • @Cloudstrife112233
    @Cloudstrife112233 7 місяців тому +1

    So I've been starting to look at what the different grinds are good for, and the Saber seems like it's the Jack of All Trades grind. Like if you knew you might be in a survival situation, it would be the best option, but if you knew you were heading into the woods, then a Scandi would be the better option.

  • @Bman-xy2vh
    @Bman-xy2vh 3 роки тому +1

    I like having a firesteel loop on my knives. it's always with your knife, so you never forget it. And it doesn't take up much room.

  • @philpass7853
    @philpass7853 3 роки тому +1

    I do love having a fire steel with my Knife, but do find the having a sharpening stone on it to be more useful as it gets used far more often as I have better and quicker fire starting options in my EDC and bush craft kit.

  • @thehairywoodsman5644
    @thehairywoodsman5644 3 роки тому +10

    " let's see what these three jokers have going on "
    reminds me of my dad talking about my brothers and me ............50 years ago.
    i like fire steel loops on my sheaths .

  • @-o-The-Duke-o-
    @-o-The-Duke-o- Рік тому +1

    I keep my steels in various places yet like my sheath to keep as unobtrusive as possible. They tend to get in the way enough without a steel hanging off the side.

  • @tymccutchen
    @tymccutchen 3 роки тому +1

    Yes I prefer to have the Firesteel. Definitely the way to go in my opinion. Thanks for the Opportunity to win.

  • @jimbrown6139
    @jimbrown6139 3 роки тому

    I don't own a sheath that incorporates a fire steele, but have modified several of my knives to include one. When I do, it's a smaller, lighter weight ferro rod for emergency or backup purposes, not as my primary fire starting tool. It's how I give myself a little redundancy but keeps my lighter as the workhorse firemaker.

  • @wincingatlight
    @wincingatlight 3 роки тому

    Picked up the Joker Lynx after one of your recent videos, and liked it so much I added the Nomad and the scandi Ember to my collection. Fantastic knives. Thanks for introducing me to this brand!

    • @sopwithcamelus
      @sopwithcamelus 3 роки тому

      Unfortunately, his glowing reviews, along with their obvious beauty, have got me itching to buy several, lol. They look like fine tools.

  • @christinesomers4674
    @christinesomers4674 3 роки тому +1

    What a beautiful knife! I love the idea of having a fire stick available however my husband would rather not have one. We are impressed with the quality and versatility of the knife. Would love to add to our collection! Thanks for the opportunity!!

  • @Bullets4TheDevil
    @Bullets4TheDevil Рік тому

    I have the Joker Nessmuk full fat grind. I am pretty sure that the Nessmuk S is what Joker is selling as the Scandi version. Anyway, amazing kitchen knife. BTW, you are one of the best knife reviewers out there for us knife guys. I appreciate the fact that you actually use knives and don't buy them as fidget spinners..

  • @huejanus5505
    @huejanus5505 3 роки тому +1

    I like my smaller firesteel on my sheath, and my larger one (.5 x 6 inch) in my pack. Keeps things more streamlined

  • @Jonnyj1987DMI
    @Jonnyj1987DMI 3 роки тому

    I like having the fire rod on the side you never know when you might need it. I really like the matching handles

  • @not_frank_castle
    @not_frank_castle 3 роки тому

    I definitely prefer to have the fire steel loop on the sheath. It’s is just so convenient and if you don’t feel like carrying the steel for some reason you can just take it out. It’s all about convenience and options. Thanks for all the great videos I always look forward to seeing them!

  • @FARACI1
    @FARACI1 11 місяців тому +1

    I am a big fan of redundancy lol so I used both. I like to have my fire steel on my blade for convenience. And I keep another in my pouch in my bag backpack.

  • @TheChadWork2001
    @TheChadWork2001 Рік тому +2

    Lionsteel Knives are top quality Spanish performers at a value price. This makes them top tier knives. I have several of them.

  • @eagle9197
    @eagle9197 3 роки тому

    I usually use thicker firesteels, the loops seldom accommodate them. But I find it handy to have a steel on the knife.

  • @rebeccadeinl7802
    @rebeccadeinl7802 3 роки тому

    I use a Swedish fire steel that comes along with a tiny metal plate which is connected to the steel through paracord. Therefore you do not necessarily need a 90 degree spine on the back of your knife to get the job done.

  • @bryanstraw7010
    @bryanstraw7010 3 роки тому

    I do like having a firesteel attached to the sheath as long as it's on the smaller side and secure. When they get long, they tend to snag on brush.

  • @latigomorgan
    @latigomorgan 3 роки тому

    I like the firesteel loop on the sheath, but that doesn't mean I'll use it while busting through brush unless it holds it tight, or I have it tied down. I've lost too many knives while busting through thick brush and climbing steep hills while in the military.

  • @ezequielikonikoff
    @ezequielikonikoff 3 роки тому

    Hi, I have 2 joker knives, one with and one with-out the fire steel and I think to prefear the fire steel on the sheath for going out.

  • @sharpwhits0167
    @sharpwhits0167 2 роки тому +1

    Aaron, you got me hooked on Joker knives. I got the ember in k720. It's really nice. Haven't had a chance to really put it to the test but it is really nice. I continually peruse amazon for what's available. I'll have more before too much longer.

  • @seanthomas8864
    @seanthomas8864 3 роки тому

    There's something beautiful about the Joker handles and leather sheaths. I don't have any sheaths with a fire steel on it, but as long as it doesn't fall out easy I dig it.

  • @haroldhyatt6337
    @haroldhyatt6337 3 роки тому

    I feel that the fire steel on the sheath makes it convenient as well as easy to carry and access

  • @Tracy81258
    @Tracy81258 3 роки тому

    I like having one on the sheath for quick access, but always have a backup in a pocket, and in my water bottle carrier. When it comes to fire and cutting tools, redundancy is the best life insurance in the woods.

  • @jparker5397
    @jparker5397 3 роки тому

    I would Much rather have the fire steel on the sheath. With it being connected it's much less likely to be forgotten or misplaced. Keep up the Awesome work!!. God Bless you and yours!. Amen.

  • @neesbushcraft
    @neesbushcraft 3 роки тому

    I like the idea of having a fire steel on the sheath as a back up. Great video. Beautiful knives.

  • @TheJoeCool1964
    @TheJoeCool1964 3 роки тому

    I don't like a fire steel on my knife, I keep a small pouch for fire making with me. Love your channel.

  • @barrybecker3706
    @barrybecker3706 3 роки тому

    As I use carry options with and without fire steels attached, I prefer with. It seems as though it makes sense to always have the ability to start a fire. My neck knife (Mora Eldris) also has a fire steel on its Kydex sheath.

  • @davidvaughn7752
    @davidvaughn7752 3 роки тому

    This alloy by the Swedish steel maker Sandvik, is more robust than most stainless and is an excellent modern alloy. For those who say that a scandi grind will not last as long are disputing an old argument. This alloy ups the game and belies these presuppositions. I would agree about food prep but in the field when using a scandi grind, my Nessmuk covers that pretty well and I haven't been inconvenienced by the geometry.

  • @kevinlange2107
    @kevinlange2107 3 роки тому +1

    Really enjoy watching all your test videos, I have definitely enjoyed all the knives I’ve purchased from your reviews! I prefer the fire steel loop on my sheath keeps me from digging around in my pack for it

  • @jayjaska8963
    @jayjaska8963 3 роки тому

    I'm pretty indifferent to whether or not the fire steel is attached to the sheath since I don't light fires very often, but I would not mind it one bit. Especially if there is also some sharpening/honing option as well.

  • @graydonwilkinson1458
    @graydonwilkinson1458 3 роки тому

    Just purchased a b.o.b. love it. I was going to get a joker love the look of this blade as well. Keep on plugging I enjoy your stuff keep it coming

  • @vojdanzaprov4643
    @vojdanzaprov4643 3 роки тому +3

    Please do some Muela knifes. Also made in Spain, long tradition of making knifes. Good luck, and god bless :-)

  • @walterb1997
    @walterb1997 3 роки тому

    Good video. I like the option of having a fire steel on the sheath. Thanks for doing videos with affordable options.

  • @jordangiven5557
    @jordangiven5557 3 роки тому

    I really enjoy having the firesteel loop. Instead of having to dig around in my bag or pockets looking for my firesteel its right on my sheath. Very convenient.

  • @CentralKyBushcraft
    @CentralKyBushcraft 3 роки тому

    I make it a habit of carrying 2 or 3 in different locations. Either on my person or in my pack. Great video. Keep them coming

  • @mathieufournier5835
    @mathieufournier5835 3 роки тому +1

    Hi ! Love the nessmuck!
    I don't really like having the fire steel on the belt sheath. As I found that it's always catching on branches or my backpack. I have them in a special compartments in my bag. Also as I live in a country where forest are highly flammable i avoid showing firesteels or other lighters as much as possible. I dream of such a knife !

  • @heckenka
    @heckenka 3 роки тому

    I like having the fire steel on the sheath. Nice to have it easily accessible and doesn't get in the way on the sheath.

  • @billbailey1517
    @billbailey1517 3 роки тому

    Love Joker knives and think it looks great having the matching fire steel with your knife.

  • @mikemyers9128
    @mikemyers9128 3 роки тому +1

    My only fixed blade knives are Mora...I tend to beat them up pretty good.

  • @apprenticegilligan1635
    @apprenticegilligan1635 3 роки тому

    I like the fire steel option added. Just gives another critical survival item as an add on.

  • @5118eman
    @5118eman 3 роки тому

    Love them with the fire steel lope, it gives the sheath a real pop to it.

  • @christopherjones7513
    @christopherjones7513 3 роки тому

    I'm a lighter guy so I keep fire steel in my pack as back up. I do have some nice kydex sheathes with firesteel on them but I can't recall ever using it to start a fire.

  • @nathannettik685
    @nathannettik685 3 роки тому

    I like the firesteel loop on the sheath. One stop one shop.

  • @anangryranger
    @anangryranger 3 роки тому

    I will carry a firestarter on many of my knives if convient or built into the sheath. Often attach one to the sheath with "Ranger Bands" (bicycle innertube). Its just one less item I don't have to dig out of a pack when needed.

  • @nobodyshero5594
    @nobodyshero5594 3 роки тому +1

    Another great video on Joker knives. I generally carry the fire steel in my pack and not on the sheath but I do have to admit I do like the joker setup with the matching handle scales.

  • @ryanbong9984
    @ryanbong9984 3 роки тому

    Good morning. Awesome review! I prefer to keep my fire steal off the knife. That’s just one more thing to get caught on a belt, backpack strap, gear that I’m carrying, etc. and can get knocked loose. I like to keep it in a pocket and go. Have a great day!

  • @nancyopalka9109
    @nancyopalka9109 3 роки тому

    I would prefer the fire steel attached to the sheath as it ism
    convenient to get to, quick access vs searching. Great, infomative video!!

  • @johnwest4492
    @johnwest4492 3 роки тому +1

    Hwy Aaron, could you carry a companion blade for food prep?

  • @singingtoad
    @singingtoad 3 роки тому

    I usually carry my firesteel in my bag or in my pocket, I've never really had a need to carry it on my knife sheath. It doesn't bother me either way though...

  • @crasharound9999
    @crasharound9999 3 роки тому

    I like having the firesteel loop available for those situations when I need a firesteel close at hand. I find myself missing it on my sheaths that don't include it.

  • @jennifermiller7802
    @jennifermiller7802 3 роки тому

    Love the Skinner. I do all the skinning for us. The handle would not slip when wet with blood. As for a fire steel I have no preference I carry several.

  • @surferbum65
    @surferbum65 3 роки тому

    The preference that I have always liked with my knife setup is without the ferro rod my fire starting system is kept elsewhere in my pack. Awesome review on those outstanding and beautiful knives keep up brother!

  • @garthholden1759
    @garthholden1759 3 роки тому

    I prefer the fire steel attached to the sheath, but also a larger one in a fire kit. Beautiful knife.

  • @TheKalkara131
    @TheKalkara131 3 роки тому

    I honestly have never had a fire steel on the sheath for a knife, but I don't see any reason why it'd be bad. Having a compact fire steel right there could be a good backup for the larger, main ferro rod I keep in a pack

  • @icebear5554
    @icebear5554 3 роки тому

    Love the Nessmuk with or without the fire steel attachment. Not a deal breaker as fire steel is easy to carry in any configuration.

  • @johnfromscotland1050
    @johnfromscotland1050 3 роки тому

    I love fire steel holder....you know at all times where you fire steel should be....great video....👍👍👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @0z33y
    @0z33y 3 роки тому

    Been using them for years, great value for money , most of the people that give them bad comments, have never owned one ….

  • @scottseverythingoutdoors462
    @scottseverythingoutdoors462 3 роки тому

    I like the firesteel option because it's nice to know nomatter what happens if you have your knife on you a fire is possible for the most part! Especially canoeing or just on the water and you dump over and lose everything!

  • @wjennekens
    @wjennekens 3 роки тому

    I love a firesteel attached to the sheath, always ready when you need it! 👍

  • @thomasmaloney843
    @thomasmaloney843 3 роки тому

    Cutting ability more depends on manufacturer than type of grind. Scandinavia will work for food prep. I prefer the fire steel with the knife, so you don't forget it. Update. Try a Marttini Skinner for food prep with a scandi grind. Illuminating.

  • @NoPlayJack
    @NoPlayJack 3 роки тому

    I've never had a sheath with a firesteal loop. I'd love to give it a try though!

  • @rcompton
    @rcompton 3 роки тому

    Thanks for you video reviews. I just bought 3 of the Joker knives to add to my collection.

  • @dan338lm
    @dan338lm 3 роки тому

    Never had a knife with rod on the sheath but I do like that on the joker you can loop the cord around the rod to better secure it

  • @us24575
    @us24575 3 роки тому

    For this style of bushcrafty knife with leather sheath I prefer the firesteel loop on the sheath; it just completes the 'ambience' of the system.

  • @darrenhawkins5394
    @darrenhawkins5394 3 роки тому

    Gideon, can you do a video on sharpening the Joker Nomad - only sharpened Scandi grinds previously so wondering how hard it is and what tool/s might be needed. Many thanks.

  • @daltonmitchell1469
    @daltonmitchell1469 3 роки тому

    I would definitely dig these knives for some bushcrafting. I love your videos man. Very informative on what to buy

  • @jeremyhollstrom7818
    @jeremyhollstrom7818 3 роки тому

    Having a fire steel attached is convenient for sure. Always carry a backup to steel too!

  • @jimmyc7803
    @jimmyc7803 3 роки тому

    I build most of my sheaths with a rod loop. I always add shock cord just in case. loving the joker vids by the way.

  • @bobbieschke599
    @bobbieschke599 2 роки тому

    I use my Mora's and Finnish puukko 's on all my food prep with no problems, they sit in my kitchen, all with Scandi's......I own the Joker Canadiene and Nordic, great bush knives for the money.

  • @fabieneldridge3414
    @fabieneldridge3414 2 роки тому

    You have helped me decide to get one. I’ve already been looking at the Joker line of knives and especially the three you went over. I think the ember is the way I’ll go. I won’t be using it for cooking so much as more of a EDC . Thanks

  • @brucej6124
    @brucej6124 3 роки тому

    I like having the fire steel with the sheath. Its just right there for emergencies and quick use.

  • @VisionWords
    @VisionWords 3 роки тому

    I always like having a firesteel loop on a sheath. I'll carry another on me as well, but you can never have too many!

  • @markbeckwith7057
    @markbeckwith7057 3 роки тому

    It's always a good idea to have multiple sources for making a fire.
    Having a firesteel on the sheath seems like a good idea.

  • @jimbo_shed
    @jimbo_shed 3 роки тому

    I like the look of a sheath without fire steel, but honestly have never owned a sheath with that option and I like the idea of knowing my ferro rod is always with my knife.

  • @HectorSuzy
    @HectorSuzy 3 роки тому

    I like to have firesteel loop on there, however I usually don't use that firesteel but have it as backup, my main firesteel is on my body somewhere, pocket or latched to my belt or whatever :)

  • @Niko.7
    @Niko.7 3 роки тому

    I prefer things clean and simple. I don't like additional stuff. Keep up the great work! The best of luck!

  • @igorace3362
    @igorace3362 3 роки тому

    I like the clean design without fire steel loop :) Awesome knives!

  • @stevenalfano5116
    @stevenalfano5116 3 роки тому

    I may not always carry a fire steel on the sheath but I do love the having the option. Just depends on where I’m going.

  • @Lacunan
    @Lacunan 3 роки тому

    I prefer a separate fire steel, I like to carry a larger one on me and it if it was connected to the sheath it would be to cumbersome. Thanks for continuing to make great content.

  • @ApostolicITTech
    @ApostolicITTech 3 роки тому

    I like having a fire steel on my sheath if it comes with it but I don’t think I would pay more for it. Or, buy another stealth for my knife just so I would have one. Consider it icing on the cake but not a ‘must have.’ Great video as always!!

  • @mike_carries
    @mike_carries 3 роки тому

    Preferably sheaths with loops for the extra gear. Not worried about losing it, that’s why spares come in handy