Welcome everyone! Please remember to LIKE this video and SUBSCRIBE to our channel! We do our best to give our genuine, honest and respectful reactions. May peace be upon you all! 🙂
Anyone can convert to Judaism but we make it very hard it used to be said that a rabbi will say no to you three times and if you ask the third time you definitely want it, it’s just to make sure you definitely want to convert as it’s a huge obligation and also because your not required to.
I am a Hasidic Jew and I love your channel. In Hasidic Judaism, we may walk into a synagogue or a mosque but never a church. This is because of the whole trinity thing,
Despite the contents of the Torah not changing in millennia, the reception of the text and the way that people have interpreted it has never stopped shifting and evolving. We believe that if even a letter of a Torah is faded, this copy of the Torah then becomes completely useless as it is no longer the word of HaShem/Allah (SWT)
I personally do not believe Jesus is burning in excrement but If he was the Messiah who would bring peace, then explain what is going on in Russia and Ukraine.
Let me correct you about the conversion if I may. Every person can convert to judaism but we don't make that easy life for the ones who want that because we believe it's a huge obligation.
I'd say that I don't want to turn the comments section into another discussion of Christianity instead of Judaism, but it looks like it has largely gone there already. Perhaps a way to view the Trinitarian reading of the Bible is to see it as compartmentalizing the immanence of God and the transcendence of God. We experience the transcendent Creator through the immanence of the incarnate Word and the indwelling Holy Spirit. Hence why many interpreters see instances of the Angel of YHWH as a pre-incarnate Christ: He is the visible aspect of the invisible God, not merely a heavenly messenger sent by God as a spokesperson on His behalf. So too, the glory of YHWH that fills the Jerusalem temple is associated with the Spirit.
He "rested" in the sense that he stopped to look over what he had created. No religious Jew believes almighty G-d requires rest like a human requires rest after a long run. The view of G-d's unified nature and perfect power in every regard is shared almost completely with Islam. A religious Jew cannot go into a Church or Buddhist temple, as they are houses of idolatry, but a religious Jew is not forbidden to go into a Mosque because they are dedicated to the same G-d that Jews worship.
The thing with there only being 15 million Jews before ww2, you got to remember that the Jews were....very not welcomed in Christian lands, for example the first crusade where instead of making it to the middle east and fighting the intended targets of the crusade the German contingent of crusaders instead attacked the much closer Jews of Germany, The Jews have faced alot of hardships (massacres, forced into very specific jobs that in the end caused conspiracy theories that they run everything, just being deported from what homes they had and having all of their belongings besides the cloths on their backs confiscated) in the west just for existing so it makes sense that their population numbers would be low.
No most of us moved to the Caribbeans (Surinam literally has a Jewish savanna where we used to live..) from Portugal, Sephardi and this is before ww2… The Ashkenazi mostly stayed behind…
The Dead Sea Scrolls were dated from between the 3rd century B.C. and the 1st century A.D. Prior to their discovery, the oldest complete copy of the Old Testament written in Hebrew was around 1000 to 1100 years old. When they compared the two, they were both pretty much the same, with some variations in spelling, but nothing major. If they managed to pretty much faithfully copy the Old Testament, why do you believe they weren't doing that previously, before the 3rd century B.C. Seems to me that the Muslim claim that the original Torah, and Gospels for that matter, have been corrupted and lost, is a theological argument not a historical one.
We don’t have an Old Testament earlier than the Dead Sea scrolls which is 1100 years after Moses and you don’t think this is a historical argument? There is no historical basis to believe in its preservation at all before this point. For someone to believe it’s been unchanged for over one thousand years would be a matter of religious faith not the other way around. -Rohaib
One possible idea for a video would be the afterlife in various religions. Even though i went to Catholic school and have read the bible a lot growing up, I found the process for afterlife and the endtimes very confusing for a long time. Catholic and Orthodox have the same teaching on it, but I found Orthodox a bit more clear on what happens in supplemental writing. Another idea, I know there were 3 main sects of Jews around the time of Jesus. Current Judaism (Rabbinic Judaism) and I think Christianity split from the Pharisees. There is also a small ethno religious group called the Samaritans that came from ancient Isrealites, and I think they don't use the Talmud. Completely unrelated but I would also be interested to see your opinions on Mormonism.
Note on the Talmud: As Cogito was explaining for a general audience, and not engaging in comparative religion, I'd just like to note that for clarity that "The Talmud" is a commentary on an older text called "The Mishnah", which is roughly equivalent to being an authoritative collection of Hadith in Islam. The Talmud will bring down Braitot (singular Braita), which come from other, lesser authoritative collections of Hadith-like texts, sometimes even bringing in an "independent Braita" and try to compare them to the Mishnah, and see if there is a way to reconcile Braitot that seem to contradict the Mishnah with the Mishnah. Also, there are technically two Talmuds, but the Babylonian Talmud is seen as a more authoritative commentary on the Mishnah and Braitot, which is why the Jerusalem Talmud is not often studied until one has studied the entire Babylonian Talmud.
4:46. As Christians, we believe that the Angel of the Lord is sometimes God Himself, because the Bible says in Revelation 22:9 that it is forbidden to worship angels. Angels are not divine and shoud not be viewed as such. Meanwhile, when Hagar saw the Angel of the Lord, she said: "I have seen the Seer (i.e. God) and I am alive", and she called Him Yahweh.(Genesis 16:13). Furthermore, in Exodus 3, the Angel of God introduces himself to Moses as I AM, the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Therefore, we believe that since God the Father was not seen by anyone, the God who spoke to Hagar, among others, is Jesus, who was a messenger, i.e. an angel, of God.
Hey Lubuszanin, appreciate the info. What you are saying is quite confusing though, Angels are not divine but people in the Bible saw the Angel and viewed it as God?? If they did wouldnt that make the angel divine? I do not understand -Hamza
@@MuslimMindsUS The point is that angel means "messenger." Humans, angels and all beings sent by God can be called angels, because angel means "messenger" in Greek. According to the Bible, angels (spiritual creatures) cannot receive worship, which is due only to God. Since a being is called "Angel of God" and at the same time "Yahweh God" (like the being talking to Hagar), it means that he is not a creature, but the Creator, otherwise calling him Yahweh would be blasphemy. The Messiah, or Christ, is God's messenger, as stated in the Septuagint (the Greek translation of the Old Testament) in Isaiah 9:6: "He will be called the Messenger of the great council." In Greek, the word for "messenger" is "angelos," so Christ can be called the Angel of the Father. But according to Hebrews 1, Christ is not an angel (creature), but the Son of God. I hope it will be helpful. Peace - Natan.
@@MuslimMindsUS, just as the Holy Spirit is not just any spirit it is God's Spirit so the term "Angel of God" is used to describe God manifested in the physical realm. You can see it here also where three "men" visited Abraham then see what one of the three was called... and the (two) men turn from thence, and go towards Sodom; and Abraham is yet standing before Jehovah. Genesis 18:22 YLT98 Then later you get this, Yehovah still physically standing on earth... and Jehovah hath rained upon Sodom and upon Gomorrah brimstone and fire *from Jehovah, from the heavens;* Genesis 19:24 YLT98
We use electricity on Shabbat/Shabbos; we just do not "activate it"; meaning, we turn on what needs to be on, and we turn off what needs to be off, before lighting the Friday night candles. ANd then we "leave the electrical things as they are" until Saturday night when Shabbat/Shabbos is over. We can ride an elevator, the problem is we can't "push the buttons" to move it. A Gentile needs to push the buttons instead, or there are "Shabbat elevators" in some places which are programmed to automatically stop and open at each floor, so that the Jews may ride it without pushing the buttons, which would cause them to personally activate the electricity.
Correction on the Messiah: Some Jews (Myself included) believe that when the Messiah comes, only Prophets and certain Righteous figures (roughly corresponding to the Muslim idea of Awliya) will be resurrected. After this, the "Time of the Messiah" will see humanity slowly evolve in spiritual perfection, after which GD will resurrect ALL Humans for a Last Judgement, which we agree with Islam on it being Yawm al-Qiyamah, and Yawm ad-Din (in fact, one of the names of this day is the Hebrew cognate "Yom HaDin")
18:15: you can convert to Judaism, it's called "gioor" (גיור). But the thing is you have to really want that, and they will test you and give you a hard time just to make sure you're serious about that. Being Jewish is a full time job. In Judaism we believe that the jews have their own purpose, while non-jews also have a purpose, and not everyone have to be jews. As your friends said, we believe that non-jews need to follow 7 Noah rules, which is basically: don't k*ll, don't steal, don't eat a live animals, do justice, & believe in g-d.
Loving your content guys and your approach. I have an honest and genuine question that comes from a good place I’d love to ask though. Do you in any way relate or empathize with Jews/Israelis as to why Israel was created and it’s long extensive history and promise made by God. I realize it’s very controversial but I would love to hear your views as I feel you guys are open to discussion and very respectful. Thank you 😊
Hey Hazel, Here is my personal take: the situation is such that now you have people that were born and lived in Israel their entire lives, and that they are Jewish people with Zionist heritage from European countries, but they themselves have lived and known Israel for their entire lives. If the Palestinians go in, and reclaim the land so to speak, then those people will just get exiled from their homes like the Palestinians are suffering. What is happening to the Palestinians is sad, unjust, and immoral, but to be quite frank if you were to ask what I believe should happen, I haven’t got a clue. I really wouldn’t be able to tell you what the solution is because both groups of people have a right to be there and it would be unjust to rob one from the other. My whole point on this is that it never should’ve happened in the first place in the manner that it did. There have been plenty of times, where Arabs, Jews, Muslims, and Christians all lived together in harmony. Now it’s just slowly being taken over and the Palestinians are being drowned out as time goes on and the conflict is such that it’s just heartbreaking all around. And it is my sincere belief that our brothers and sisters in monotheism deserve to live in the holy land but again I will reiterate the way it was done, was messy, sad, and criminal, but the greatest Islamic empires all encouraged the Jews and Christians to live along side with the Muslims in the holy land, because we show respect to our brothers and sisters in the Abraham faiths. If the situation was reversed and innocent Jewish families were being removed wrongfully from their homes and their land was taken, then I would detest that as well. -Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS thank you for your insight. I relate to your perspective and e wish more thought the same. Very tricky situation also bearing in mind Jews were thrown out of their homelands such as Spain, Iraq etc which makes it more trickier. I pray for peace and a resolution that can satisfy everyone’s needs where posssible. Love your channel ❤️
I don't know about Jews esteeming Moses more than the messiah, sounds like a straw attack on the divinity of Jesus Christ. While Jews do not agree that Jesus is the messiah, both Jews and Christians have a definite idea that the Messiah refers to a person who will bring salvation. He is a specific person with a specific purpose and is *the messiah* as opposed to random application of messiahs (meaning anointed to several people) Islamic scholars struggle to explain why the Quran specifies Jesus as the Messiah. Again, I see their fight with divinity of Jesus but the problem still remains, why is he the messiah, and not a messiah. Similar to the Quran describing him as the Word of God, meaning other prophets are not really the word of God
Not a straw attack, I said this was an opinion of a well known rabbi Ram Bam or Maimonides. We were just highlighting this as an opinion. Muslims view Jesus and Moses on the same level anyway so to us it’s not a worthwhile argument, and it wasn’t intended to be a point of contention. -Rohaib
Why can't God make sure that every prophecy and revelation remains unchanged despite the actions of people who, of course, can change or forget or confuse something over time?
16:25 Just a quick clarification: not all Jews will be resurrected, the righteous Jews will be, as will the righteous gentiles. It's a lot of people, yes, but Earth is also pretty big.
The Jewish population was also very small before the holocaust because many were systematically destroyed by Muslim caliphates and other authoritarian regimes throughout their history. They are just now meeting their Pre WWII population
@09:50 He has a HUGE incentive to tell people there is one all powerful God they must follow. Oh, and this one God talks directly and only to Abraham. "There is one God that will help us and you better do what I say because this God talks to me," People make similar claims today. Some are denounced as crazy, but some amass a following and huge amounts of wealth and power. It is a grift as old as spoken language
When a Jew worships Jesus, he throws his Israelite identity in the trash. The true Israelites would never worship a human being. Jews don't worship Moses (phuh) and Muslims do not worship Muhammad (pbuh). We worship G-d. Not men.
Hey Earth, the Jews that accept the new texts are a minority, I was speaking for the majority. Messianic Jews definitely accept the New Testament, but I was speaking more specifically of the main stream religious Jewish tradition for most of history. Thanks for commenting -Rohaib
Sunni and Shia disagree on relativity minor matters, however the core is the same (belief in God, prophethood, the Quran, concept of Hadith) and Shia make a very small percentage. Sunni Islam is about 90% of the adherents. Christianity on the other hand is severely fractured with differing beliefs about the core beliefs, including the Trinity and nature of Jesus. Whether works or faith alone will save you. The differences regarding the relationship of the three persons of the Trinity for Orthodox and Catholic. From its inception of well, you have ebionites, Docetism, paganism, attributed to Christianity.
3:16 Each day is 1000 years. This is why Adam died at age 930 years. God said Adam would die the “day” that Adam ate of the fruit. People often take this to mean the Bible is false, but it happened just as God said. Adam died that day. Adam was 33.5 years old when he ate of the fruit. Jesus was 33.5 years old when He died on the cross and was resurrected.
Is messianic jew so i believe jesus or isa was the messiah adonai means lord or god and yhwh is the name of god or in hebrew יהוה (yud hey vav hey) because Hebrew don't have "w" to you muslims abraham was muslim right but made judaism
"youm " is a time period of rotation for stabilisation of what God create, the universe-s?!!! since there are one day = 1000 earth year or a day that is 50000 earth years. so it is not earth year since the universe time started long before the earth creation
Denying the Triune Identity of God is denying the trinity image of God in which mankind were made so that, irrefutably, mankind are the only beings to represent the Triune Identity of God in their trinity combination of Body + Soul + Spirit-of-life. Likewise, the Likeness of God's perfect Oneness ascribed to them by ordaining to them ONE the Dominion (Gen 1:26 & 28, Mic 4:8), ONE the Body (Gen 2:21-22, Mal 2:15) and ONE the Name (Gen 1:26, Gen 5:2). Sadly, there is an utter lack of understand of the true meanings & Spiritual implications of the Triune Identity of God (just as Jer 51:17 testifies, "EVERY MAN IS SENSELESS AND WITHOUT KNOWLEDGE.." Here's the opportunity for all who may heed the Truth: 1. God is the Father simply means God is the Creator, the Provider and the Sustainer of all that He created - the reason it is forbidden to call anyone on earth Father. 2. Likewise, God is the Son simply means God is the Heir, for God being ONLY ONE, He is the ONLY HEIR of all that He created and is to create anew - the reason just as it is revealed, one cannot even hope to partake of the 'divine sonship' without the Son. 3. Finally, God is the Holy Spirit simply means God is Spirit and surpassingly Holy - the reason just as it is revealed the Holy Spirit knows those who are His and will gather those His own. Now that God has revealed Himself in the Fullness of His Triune Identity, men clearly have no excuse for their persistent denial and ignorance. This is just what Isa 9:6 testifies to: The Son given us is the Mighty God who is also called the Everlasting Father, the Prince of Peace and the Wonderful Counselor - in other words, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit respectively. Perhaps now you will begin to understand why just as it was prophesied since of old, God is the ONLY ONE to have come NOT BORN of the cursed seed of the fallen man, and the ONLY ONE, who, perfectly in keeping with the prophesied Sign 'virgin with Child', proved even the woman HAD NO ROLE in His holy conception - her role being merely to offer her womb for His surrogacy. Thus He is the ONLY ONE to prove neither Sin nor Death and for that matter, Satan, have any power over Him. And the ONLY ONE to have truly & fully Fulfilled, Exemplified, Taught & Reinstated the surpassing Righteousness of God - which to date no man has replicated and NONE ever shall. Lastly, understand and be warned that the Triune Identity of God is that which utterly exposes Satan who lest we forget is also ONE. So, where is the boasting in Monotheism if one is actually worshiping Satan? Also, let it be known, just as it is revealed, the last act of counterfeiting that Man and Satan combo will accomplish to mislead all mankind into the singular worship which is to be soon enforced on all mankind is counterfeiting the Triune Identity of God. I, as a faithful servant of God, repeat, be warned! P.s. It is surprising that people choose to remain in the dark about the fact that it was mankind's fallen first father, the very first man, who disobeyed God and CHOSE Death over Life, despite faithful forewarnings from God. Ever since, irrefutably, Death is the Evil Scepter of Power with which man has been furthering his evil dominions on earth. And, ever since, the vicious cycle of sowing Death and reaping Death is all that the fallen human race has been capable of, all through their bloodied history. So, denying yourselves the Salvation God alone has made possible for you, are you not also exactly like your fallen first father CHOOSING Death over Life for yourself? Just as God testifies in Prov 8:36, "..ALL WHO HATE ME, LOVE DEATH."
@christophercano4809 Spoken just like your fallen first father who, despite God's faithful forewarnings, chose Death over Life upon himself and upon all his accursed descendants. This is the reason you blindly call injustice when God over whom Death has no power provenly paved the Way for the Salvation of the fallen human race. Woe to you!
@@ninaballerina2807 I correctly called it injustice because it is, my blind friend, and you couldn't even disprove this fact, why? Well, because it's the logical conclusion of what you believe. You deserve eternal damnation, you don't want it therefore you have an innocent die so you can avoid your deserved punishment. That's called injustice. And if you respond you'll be yet again unable to deny the fact that it's injustice, as injustice lies at the core of christian salvation.
@@ninaballerina2807 I called it injustice because that's exactly what it is, and obviously you weren't able to disprove such fact. You deserve eternal damnation but you don't want it so you have an innocent die for it so you can avoid it. So you have someone die so you can avoid your well deserved punishment. That's called injustice, my friend, and you're unable to refute that fact.
@christophercano4809 In other words, you choose Death and I choose Life thanks to God who Alone has made possible the impossible for me by Resurrecting and proving that Death has absolutely no power over Him. So, carry on shedding your crocodile tears until at last, as is your wont, you perish with your blasphemies.
Interesting. In fact, Israel has been restored as a country. The Jews have a place to live and they seem to no longer be oppressed as before. And we have the figure of Jesus, recognized as the messiah, who was the beginning of a new era for humanity. It turns out that quite a few predictions have already come true?
#MuslimMinds, every word in the Tanakh, and the Bible are uncorrupt. Whoever says that Tanakh or the Bible are not same today, he is a liar, and he shall be judged by the LORD the God.
The earliest copy we have of the Old Testament is the Dead Sea scrolls, 1000+ years after Moses. We don’t know who wrote them and Orthodox Rabbis today consider those texts to contain errors. Even the New Testament, two of the four gospels mention two different dates of the crucifixion. These books are compiled over time from various authors who made a lot of contradictions among each other. These books are not the fully preserved teachings of the prophets. We aren’t “lying” the history is just not in favor of the traditional Christian narrative. -Rohaib
Welcome everyone! Please remember to LIKE this video and SUBSCRIBE to our channel! We do our best to give our genuine, honest and respectful reactions.
May peace be upon you all! 🙂
Anyone can convert to Judaism but we make it very hard it used to be said that a rabbi will say no to you three times and if you ask the third time you definitely want it, it’s just to make sure you definitely want to convert as it’s a huge obligation and also because your not required to.
Hey Tom thanks for commenting, now that you mention it, I do remember hearing that before. Thanks for the comment!
-Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS love you guys content btw hope you make some more on Judaism it’s quite similar :)
Well at least you don't need to conver to be saved in judaism, that's cool i guess
Rejected 3 times after 3 asks; the "4th" ask should get a yes. "Should".
I am a Hasidic Jew and I love your channel. In Hasidic Judaism, we may walk into a synagogue or a mosque but never a church. This is because of the whole trinity thing,
We don't believe that HaShem/Allah (SWT) NEEDS anything. He rested by choice and to sanctify the Israelites to observe the sabbath.
From a Hasidic perspective, Jacob (pbuh) wrestled with the angel of his brother Esau.
Despite the contents of the Torah not changing in millennia, the reception of the text and the way that people have interpreted it has never stopped shifting and evolving. We believe that if even a letter of a Torah is faded, this copy of the Torah then becomes completely useless as it is no longer the word of HaShem/Allah (SWT)
I personally do not believe Jesus is burning in excrement but If he was the Messiah who would bring peace, then explain what is going on in Russia and Ukraine.
Jewish conversion is a difficult and extensive process but ANYONE who is GENUINE can convert irrespective of race.
Let me correct you about the conversion if I may.
Every person can convert to judaism but we don't make that easy life for the ones who want that because we believe it's a huge obligation.
Yes how that you mention it, I do remember reading that before.
Thanks for commenting!
-Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS Your welcome🫶🏻
I'd say that I don't want to turn the comments section into another discussion of Christianity instead of Judaism, but it looks like it has largely gone there already.
Perhaps a way to view the Trinitarian reading of the Bible is to see it as compartmentalizing the immanence of God and the transcendence of God. We experience the transcendent Creator through the immanence of the incarnate Word and the indwelling Holy Spirit. Hence why many interpreters see instances of the Angel of YHWH as a pre-incarnate Christ: He is the visible aspect of the invisible God, not merely a heavenly messenger sent by God as a spokesperson on His behalf. So too, the glory of YHWH that fills the Jerusalem temple is associated with the Spirit.
Aka the Memrah and the ruach hakodesh
He "rested" in the sense that he stopped to look over what he had created. No religious Jew believes almighty G-d requires rest like a human requires rest after a long run. The view of G-d's unified nature and perfect power in every regard is shared almost completely with Islam. A religious Jew cannot go into a Church or Buddhist temple, as they are houses of idolatry, but a religious Jew is not forbidden to go into a Mosque because they are dedicated to the same G-d that Jews worship.
The thing with there only being 15 million Jews before ww2, you got to remember that the Jews were....very not welcomed in Christian lands, for example the first crusade where instead of making it to the middle east and fighting the intended targets of the crusade the German contingent of crusaders instead attacked the much closer Jews of Germany, The Jews have faced alot of hardships (massacres, forced into very specific jobs that in the end caused conspiracy theories that they run everything, just being deported from what homes they had and having all of their belongings besides the cloths on their backs confiscated) in the west just for existing so it makes sense that their population numbers would be low.
If there were only 15 million jews then how come over 60 million was the estimate for the holocaust?
Makes sense Knight of BlackFyre, thank you for sharing!
-Hamza
@@DARKthenoble where did you get 60 million from? It was 6 million that perished during the holocaust.
No most of us moved to the Caribbeans (Surinam literally has a Jewish savanna where we used to live..) from Portugal, Sephardi and this is before ww2…
The Ashkenazi mostly stayed behind…
@@knightofblackfyre7950It was a number some sources were peddling a few years ago.
The Dead Sea Scrolls were dated from between the 3rd century B.C. and the 1st century A.D. Prior to their discovery, the oldest complete copy of the Old Testament written in Hebrew was around 1000 to 1100 years old. When they compared the two, they were both pretty much the same, with some variations in spelling, but nothing major. If they managed to pretty much faithfully copy the Old Testament, why do you believe they weren't doing that previously, before the 3rd century B.C. Seems to me that the Muslim claim that the original Torah, and Gospels for that matter, have been corrupted and lost, is a theological argument not a historical one.
We don’t have an Old Testament earlier than the Dead Sea scrolls which is 1100 years after Moses and you don’t think this is a historical argument? There is no historical basis to believe in its preservation at all before this point. For someone to believe it’s been unchanged for over one thousand years would be a matter of religious faith not the other way around.
-Rohaib
One possible idea for a video would be the afterlife in various religions.
Even though i went to Catholic school and have read the bible a lot growing up, I found the process for afterlife and the endtimes very confusing for a long time. Catholic and Orthodox have the same teaching on it, but I found Orthodox a bit more clear on what happens in supplemental writing.
Another idea, I know there were 3 main sects of Jews around the time of Jesus. Current Judaism (Rabbinic Judaism) and I think Christianity split from the Pharisees.
There is also a small ethno religious group called the Samaritans that came from ancient Isrealites, and I think they don't use the Talmud.
Completely unrelated but I would also be interested to see your opinions on Mormonism.
Hey Aaron, thank you for the recommendations, we will plan on making videos on those topics
-Rohaib
Note on the Talmud: As Cogito was explaining for a general audience, and not engaging in comparative religion, I'd just like to note that for clarity that "The Talmud" is a commentary on an older text called "The Mishnah", which is roughly equivalent to being an authoritative collection of Hadith in Islam. The Talmud will bring down Braitot (singular Braita), which come from other, lesser authoritative collections of Hadith-like texts, sometimes even bringing in an "independent Braita" and try to compare them to the Mishnah, and see if there is a way to reconcile Braitot that seem to contradict the Mishnah with the Mishnah.
Also, there are technically two Talmuds, but the Babylonian Talmud is seen as a more authoritative commentary on the Mishnah and Braitot, which is why the Jerusalem Talmud is not often studied until one has studied the entire Babylonian Talmud.
4:46. As Christians, we believe that the Angel of the Lord is sometimes God Himself, because the Bible says in Revelation 22:9 that it is forbidden to worship angels. Angels are not divine and shoud not be viewed as such. Meanwhile, when Hagar saw the Angel of the Lord, she said: "I have seen the Seer (i.e. God) and I am alive", and she called Him Yahweh.(Genesis 16:13). Furthermore, in Exodus 3, the Angel of God introduces himself to Moses as I AM, the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Therefore, we believe that since God the Father was not seen by anyone, the God who spoke to Hagar, among others, is Jesus, who was a messenger, i.e. an angel, of God.
The Angel of God is God interacting in the physical realm...
Hey Lubuszanin, appreciate the info. What you are saying is quite confusing though, Angels are not divine but people in the Bible saw the Angel and viewed it as God?? If they did wouldnt that make the angel divine?
I do not understand
-Hamza
@@MuslimMindsUS The point is that angel means "messenger." Humans, angels and all beings sent by God can be called angels, because angel means "messenger" in Greek. According to the Bible, angels (spiritual creatures) cannot receive worship, which is due only to God. Since a being is called "Angel of God" and at the same time "Yahweh God" (like the being talking to Hagar), it means that he is not a creature, but the Creator, otherwise calling him Yahweh would be blasphemy. The Messiah, or Christ, is God's messenger, as stated in the Septuagint (the Greek translation of the Old Testament) in Isaiah 9:6: "He will be called the Messenger of the great council." In Greek, the word for "messenger" is "angelos," so Christ can be called the Angel of the Father. But according to Hebrews 1, Christ is not an angel (creature), but the Son of God. I hope it will be helpful. Peace - Natan.
@@MuslimMindsUS, just as the Holy Spirit is not just any spirit it is God's Spirit so the term "Angel of God" is used to describe God manifested in the physical realm.
You can see it here also where three "men" visited Abraham then see what one of the three was called...
and the (two) men turn from thence, and go towards Sodom; and Abraham is yet standing before Jehovah.
Genesis 18:22 YLT98
Then later you get this, Yehovah still physically standing on earth...
and Jehovah hath rained upon Sodom and upon Gomorrah brimstone and fire *from Jehovah, from the heavens;*
Genesis 19:24 YLT98
@@MuslimMindsUS angel in Hebrew means messanger and is even used for humans
We use electricity on Shabbat/Shabbos; we just do not "activate it"; meaning, we turn on what needs to be on, and we turn off what needs to be off, before lighting the Friday night candles. ANd then we "leave the electrical things as they are" until Saturday night when Shabbat/Shabbos is over. We can ride an elevator, the problem is we can't "push the buttons" to move it. A Gentile needs to push the buttons instead, or there are "Shabbat elevators" in some places which are programmed to automatically stop and open at each floor, so that the Jews may ride it without pushing the buttons, which would cause them to personally activate the electricity.
Correction on the Messiah: Some Jews (Myself included) believe that when the Messiah comes, only Prophets and certain Righteous figures (roughly corresponding to the Muslim idea of Awliya) will be resurrected. After this, the "Time of the Messiah" will see humanity slowly evolve in spiritual perfection, after which GD will resurrect ALL Humans for a Last Judgement, which we agree with Islam on it being Yawm al-Qiyamah, and Yawm ad-Din (in fact, one of the names of this day is the Hebrew cognate "Yom HaDin")
18:15: you can convert to Judaism, it's called "gioor" (גיור). But the thing is you have to really want that, and they will test you and give you a hard time just to make sure you're serious about that. Being Jewish is a full time job. In Judaism we believe that the jews have their own purpose, while non-jews also have a purpose, and not everyone have to be jews. As your friends said, we believe that non-jews need to follow 7 Noah rules, which is basically: don't k*ll, don't steal, don't eat a live animals, do justice, & believe in g-d.
Loving your content guys and your approach. I have an honest and genuine question that comes from a good place I’d love to ask though.
Do you in any way relate or empathize with Jews/Israelis as to why Israel was created and it’s long extensive history and promise made by God. I realize it’s very controversial but I would love to hear your views as I feel you guys are open to discussion and very respectful. Thank you 😊
Hey Hazel,
Here is my personal take: the situation is such that now you have people that were born and lived in Israel their entire lives, and that they are Jewish people with Zionist heritage from European countries, but they themselves have lived and known Israel for their entire lives. If the Palestinians go in, and reclaim the land so to speak, then those people will just get exiled from their homes like the Palestinians are suffering. What is happening to the Palestinians is sad, unjust, and immoral, but to be quite frank if you were to ask what I believe should happen, I haven’t got a clue. I really wouldn’t be able to tell you what the solution is because both groups of people have a right to be there and it would be unjust to rob one from the other. My whole point on this is that it never should’ve happened in the first place in the manner that it did. There have been plenty of times, where Arabs, Jews, Muslims, and Christians all lived together in harmony. Now it’s just slowly being taken over and the Palestinians are being drowned out as time goes on and the conflict is such that it’s just heartbreaking all around.
And it is my sincere belief that our brothers and sisters in monotheism deserve to live in the holy land but again I will reiterate the way it was done, was messy, sad, and criminal, but the greatest Islamic empires all encouraged the Jews and Christians to live along side with the Muslims in the holy land, because we show respect to our brothers and sisters in the Abraham faiths.
If the situation was reversed and innocent Jewish families were being removed wrongfully from their homes and their land was taken, then I would detest that as well.
-Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS thank you for your insight. I relate to your perspective and e wish more thought the same. Very tricky situation also bearing in mind Jews were thrown out of their homelands such as Spain, Iraq etc which makes it more trickier. I pray for peace and a resolution that can satisfy everyone’s needs where posssible. Love your channel ❤️
I don't know about Jews esteeming Moses more than the messiah, sounds like a straw attack on the divinity of Jesus Christ.
While Jews do not agree that Jesus is the messiah, both Jews and Christians have a definite idea that the Messiah refers to a person who will bring salvation. He is a specific person with a specific purpose and is *the messiah* as opposed to random application of messiahs (meaning anointed to several people)
Islamic scholars struggle to explain why the Quran specifies Jesus as the Messiah. Again, I see their fight with divinity of Jesus but the problem still remains, why is he the messiah, and not a messiah. Similar to the Quran describing him as the Word of God, meaning other prophets are not really the word of God
Not a straw attack, I said this was an opinion of a well known rabbi Ram Bam or Maimonides. We were just highlighting this as an opinion.
Muslims view Jesus and Moses on the same level anyway so to us it’s not a worthwhile argument, and it wasn’t intended to be a point of contention.
-Rohaib
Rejected 3 times after 3 asks; the "4th" ask should get a yes. "Should". - The correct "FOUR LETTERS" of the Name is Y H V H (not "w").
The Christians think and teach that it is a - - w - but that would be incorrect Hebrew construct, vowel-consonant-vowel-consonant pattern.
Why can't God make sure that every prophecy and revelation remains unchanged despite the actions of people who, of course, can change or forget or confuse something over time?
Moses wrote all the laws,no other Jewish prophets brought any other new laws for Israel.
Yes, the rest were prophets without scripture or revelation. The only ones that brought revelation to the Jews were Moses and Jesus.
@@MuslimMindsUSDawud? Don’t know your deen???
16:25
Just a quick clarification: not all Jews will be resurrected, the righteous Jews will be, as will the righteous gentiles. It's a lot of people, yes, but Earth is also pretty big.
also the reason we only had 15 million is because for thousands of years we were killed sent into exile and diaspora
I am hindu i love your reaction
The Jewish population was also very small before the holocaust because many were systematically destroyed by Muslim caliphates and other authoritarian regimes throughout their history. They are just now meeting their Pre WWII population
@09:50 He has a HUGE incentive to tell people there is one all powerful God they must follow. Oh, and this one God talks directly and only to Abraham.
"There is one God that will help us and you better do what I say because this God talks to me,"
People make similar claims today. Some are denounced as crazy, but some amass a following and huge amounts of wealth and power. It is a grift as old as spoken language
Not all Jews think like what you have said,the new testament is a Jewish book.
When a Jew worships Jesus, he throws his Israelite identity in the trash. The true Israelites would never worship a human being. Jews don't worship Moses (phuh) and Muslims do not worship Muhammad (pbuh). We worship G-d. Not men.
Hey Earth, the Jews that accept the new texts are a minority, I was speaking for the majority. Messianic Jews definitely accept the New Testament, but I was speaking more specifically of the main stream religious Jewish tradition for most of history.
Thanks for commenting
-Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS the Jews wrote both the old and the new testament.
In Islam, aren't there Suna and Shia? What is the difference between these and the other "problems" in Judaism and Christianity?
Sunni and Shia disagree on relativity minor matters, however the core is the same (belief in God, prophethood, the Quran, concept of Hadith) and Shia make a very small percentage. Sunni Islam is about 90% of the adherents.
Christianity on the other hand is severely fractured with differing beliefs about the core beliefs, including the Trinity and nature of Jesus. Whether works or faith alone will save you. The differences regarding the relationship of the three persons of the Trinity for Orthodox and Catholic.
From its inception of well, you have ebionites, Docetism, paganism, attributed to Christianity.
Sam Aronow has a video about the Jews of China.
Can anyone tell me the name of Adam's wife from the Quran? What surah and verse.
Hey Earth Adam’s wife’s name is not mentioned in the Quran
-Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUSso it means we don't know the name of Adam's wife because the Quran doesn't say it and the bible is corrupted.we are left hanging.
3:16 Each day is 1000 years. This is why Adam died at age 930 years. God said Adam would die the “day” that Adam ate of the fruit. People often take this to mean the Bible is false, but it happened just as God said. Adam died that day. Adam was 33.5 years old when he ate of the fruit. Jesus was 33.5 years old when He died on the cross and was resurrected.
Is messianic jew so i believe jesus or isa was the messiah
adonai means lord or god and yhwh is the name of god or in hebrew יהוה (yud hey vav hey) because Hebrew don't have "w"
to you muslims abraham was muslim right but made judaism
"youm " is a time period of rotation for stabilisation of what God create, the universe-s?!!! since there are one day = 1000 earth year or a day that is 50000 earth years. so it is not earth year since the universe time started long before the earth creation
No First Copy is Christian second copy is Islam And Judaism is copy of Zoroastrain
Denying the Triune Identity of God is denying the trinity image of God in which mankind were made so that, irrefutably, mankind are the only beings to represent the Triune Identity of God in their trinity combination of Body + Soul + Spirit-of-life. Likewise, the Likeness of God's perfect Oneness ascribed to them by ordaining to them ONE the Dominion (Gen 1:26 & 28, Mic 4:8), ONE the Body (Gen 2:21-22, Mal 2:15) and ONE the Name (Gen 1:26, Gen 5:2).
Sadly, there is an utter lack of understand of the true meanings & Spiritual implications of the Triune Identity of God (just as Jer 51:17 testifies, "EVERY MAN IS SENSELESS AND WITHOUT KNOWLEDGE.." Here's the opportunity for all who may heed the Truth:
1. God is the Father simply means God is the Creator, the Provider and the Sustainer of all that He created - the reason it is forbidden to call anyone on earth Father.
2. Likewise, God is the Son simply means God is the Heir, for God being ONLY ONE, He is the ONLY HEIR of all that He created and is to create anew - the reason just as it is revealed, one cannot even hope to partake of the 'divine sonship' without the Son.
3. Finally, God is the Holy Spirit simply means God is Spirit and surpassingly Holy - the reason just as it is revealed the Holy Spirit knows those who are His and will gather those His own.
Now that God has revealed Himself in the Fullness of His Triune Identity, men clearly have no excuse for their persistent denial and ignorance. This is just what Isa 9:6 testifies to: The Son given us is the Mighty God who is also called the Everlasting Father, the Prince of Peace and the Wonderful Counselor - in other words, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit respectively.
Perhaps now you will begin to understand why just as it was prophesied since of old, God is the ONLY ONE to have come NOT BORN of the cursed seed of the fallen man, and the ONLY ONE, who, perfectly in keeping with the prophesied Sign 'virgin with Child', proved even the woman HAD NO ROLE in His holy conception - her role being merely to offer her womb for His surrogacy. Thus He is the ONLY ONE to prove neither Sin nor Death and for that matter, Satan, have any power over Him. And the ONLY ONE to have truly & fully Fulfilled, Exemplified, Taught & Reinstated the surpassing Righteousness of God - which to date no man has replicated and NONE ever shall.
Lastly, understand and be warned that the Triune Identity of God is that which utterly exposes Satan who lest we forget is also ONE. So, where is the boasting in Monotheism if one is actually worshiping Satan? Also, let it be known, just as it is revealed, the last act of counterfeiting that Man and Satan combo will accomplish to mislead all mankind into the singular worship which is to be soon enforced on all mankind is counterfeiting the Triune Identity of God. I, as a faithful servant of God, repeat, be warned!
P.s. It is surprising that people choose to remain in the dark about the fact that it was mankind's fallen first father, the very first man, who disobeyed God and CHOSE Death over Life, despite faithful forewarnings from God. Ever since, irrefutably, Death is the Evil Scepter of Power with which man has been furthering his evil dominions on earth. And, ever since, the vicious cycle of sowing Death and reaping Death is all that the fallen human race has been capable of, all through their bloodied history. So, denying yourselves the Salvation God alone has made possible for you, are you not also exactly like your fallen first father CHOOSING Death over Life for yourself? Just as God testifies in Prov 8:36, "..ALL WHO HATE ME, LOVE DEATH."
At the core of christian salvation lies injustice. You'd rather have an innocent pay for what you deserve.
@christophercano4809 Spoken just like your fallen first father who, despite God's faithful forewarnings, chose Death over Life upon himself and upon all his accursed descendants. This is the reason you blindly call injustice when God over whom Death has no power provenly paved the Way for the Salvation of the fallen human race. Woe to you!
@@ninaballerina2807 I correctly called it injustice because it is, my blind friend, and you couldn't even disprove this fact, why? Well, because it's the logical conclusion of what you believe. You deserve eternal damnation, you don't want it therefore you have an innocent die so you can avoid your deserved punishment. That's called injustice.
And if you respond you'll be yet again unable to deny the fact that it's injustice, as injustice lies at the core of christian salvation.
@@ninaballerina2807 I called it injustice because that's exactly what it is, and obviously you weren't able to disprove such fact.
You deserve eternal damnation but you don't want it so you have an innocent die for it so you can avoid it. So you have someone die so you can avoid your well deserved punishment. That's called injustice, my friend, and you're unable to refute that fact.
@christophercano4809 In other words, you choose Death and I choose Life thanks to God who Alone has made possible the impossible for me by Resurrecting and proving that Death has absolutely no power over Him.
So, carry on shedding your crocodile tears until at last, as is your wont, you perish with your blasphemies.
Interesting. In fact, Israel has been restored as a country. The Jews have a place to live and they seem to no longer be oppressed as before. And we have the figure of Jesus, recognized as the messiah, who was the beginning of a new era for humanity. It turns out that quite a few predictions have already come true?
Ok islam is fist copy of Jew😂😂😂😂
No First Copy is Christian second copy is Islam And Judaism is copy of Zoreitrian
#MuslimMinds, every word in the Tanakh, and the Bible are uncorrupt. Whoever says that Tanakh or the Bible are not same today, he is a liar, and he shall be judged by the LORD the God.
The earliest copy we have of the Old Testament is the Dead Sea scrolls, 1000+ years after Moses. We don’t know who wrote them and Orthodox Rabbis today consider those texts to contain errors.
Even the New Testament, two of the four gospels mention two different dates of the crucifixion. These books are compiled over time from various authors who made a lot of contradictions among each other. These books are not the fully preserved teachings of the prophets. We aren’t “lying” the history is just not in favor of the traditional Christian narrative.
-Rohaib