When To Release The Golf Club For Maximum Speed (My Experiment)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 чер 2024
- I decided to do an experiment to see how the timing of the release in the golf swing affects clubhead speed. Here's what I learned.
Get access to my FREE Rotational Golf Swing Blueprint: milolinesgolf.com/5-keys-to-u...
How we release the golf club is a hot topic, but not only that, it's important to discuss when we release. I've long been of the belief that the release in general should feel rather passive and that it should happen as more of a byproduct, with physics ultimately taking command. It is after all nearly impossible to truly hold wrist angles forever, especially at maximum speed.
In this episode I share with you my experiment using Trackman to determine which "release" style is most effective in producing the maximum speed for me. How you interpret my findings are ultimately up to you, but for me there was one apparent winner. I hope you enjoy and look forward to your feedback!
START YOUR TRAINING TODAY!
Become an online member of the Milo Lines Golf Academy! milolinesgolf.com ...Included with membership: monthly swing analysis, invitation to monthly member-only webinars, entry to our community and Q&A, reduced online lesson rates with our team of coaches, and access to 100’s of exclusive how-to videos (covering my foundations, golf swing drills, practice plans, and strategies to help you improve your game). It’s the ultimate platform and roadmap for learning the concepts I lay out across this channel. It’s time you Learn to SWING LIKE AN ATHLETE™ for yourself! 📈
BOOK AN ONLINE OR IN-PERSON GOLF LESSON
milolinesgolf.com/schedule-le...
WATCH THESE NEXT!
• SECRET Downswing Move ...
• How To Move Your Right...
• Golf Lesson: BIGGER Ba...
MILO APPROVED TRAINING GEAR + DISCOUNTS!
milolinesgolf.com/training-gear/
FOLLOW MILO
Instagram: / milolines_golf
Facebook: / milolinesgolf
Twitter: / milolinesgolf
SUBSCRIBE TO MILO LINES GOLF
/ @milolinesgolf
Don’t forget to LEAVE A COMMENT with any and all questions, video tip requests, and thoughts. We do our best to respond to every comment and sincerely appreciate your feedback!
Learn to Swing Like an Athlete™ with Milo Lines Golf! My channel and coaching team will provide you with lessons and tips to help you play better at this game. Most of our content is filmed at the beautiful Superstition Mountain Golf & Country Club in Gold Canyon, Arizona.
#golf #golfswing #milolinesgolf - Спорт
As a hitter in baseball I never manually tried to hit with the trail arm, and as a pitcher I never tried to unload the wrist yet it happens every time I throw or hit. I have experimented with every golf swing idea I can find and have found for me any effort to hit with the trail arm or wrist drastically slows my swing down and causes poor contact and face control problems.
Thank you for this experiment Milo. I’m completely sold. Now I just have to stick with the countless hours of drills it will take me to rewire my brain into this release pattern as my natural hardwired urge is to cast/release the angles early
Thanks! The part that confuses me is the difference between held off and natural. Are they the same body swing and held off is adding tension with the wrists? If you were whipping a towel with your golf swing where would it snap for maximum speed? I can't get Driver over 108mph but I feel like I should be able to. Drives me nuts - lol.
@@-Thunder yes swing 3 I tried to hold it back with my wrists as hard as a can.
@@samridgebag Just practice hitting low punch shots
my issue is hitting AT the ball which causes a casty in to out, toe down action that i cant stand!! its like my idea of "throw" is destroying my action
This was the best tip I've had in a long time . The last 4 rounds were amazing. Thank you so much for this video it's amazing how on plane my swing feels . My son was.like a( always beats me) we were tied going into last two holes he shot 79 and I ended up shooting 82. But I only had 5 hours sleep and wearing a brace on my injured knee. He couldn't believe how I was striking ball. I told him I'll send you the video. So thanks again!!
Well Milo, I've been following you for 4 weeks now, and I'm now playing the best golf I've ever played in 40yrs, I'm also getting more distance than I have ever had to, I wish I had found you a long time ago, I'm now 70yrs old, and I have driven the third hole at my club two days on the bounce, I've never done this before in 4oyrs, it's a par 4 290yrds, thanks Milo, your swing is amazing.
Kind regards
Glynn
Thanks for the amazing update!!
Net so far away, neighbors windows so close. Luckily Milo is an elite athlete. I'd be breaking glass for sure
Trackman needs some distance to be able to track the shot.
lol, i was thinking the same thing, especially that right window
First thing I thought 😂😂
@@MiloLinesGolf that window dngaf
This is one of the most informative experiments I've watched! It was great to have the Trackman data to observe as I could see the difference in launch angles as your release changed. Thanks for thinking outside the box and providing evidence of what happens under different conditions!
Thanks for following along!
Milo I keep coming back to this video. For some reason I think this is one of your best videos ever. I am trying to copy this whole sequence of what you are doing here. Thanks for this Gold.
Go for it!
Nice illustration. I would imagine if the golf club was engineered in the opposite way where the weight was in the handle versus the head there would be a need to use the trail arm to generate speed. As long as people watch golf on TV and the numerous golf gurus on UA-cam who continually point out characteristics, positions, etc. of swings by professional golfers by using a still frame and/or slow motion video, the more the amateur golfer (and aspiring professionals) will struggle. As you have mentioned, the swing like many other motions in other sports is dynamic and what happens along the way and at impact are a result of numerous factors, but not something manipulated during the motion. This is why you will always have job security Milo. My swing doesn't look like yours because this is your swing, but the principles of motion you teach for the golf swing I try to apply to my swing and when I get it right, it feels good and doesn't hurt my body like the past few decades of trying to achieve a look or position of another golfer. Keep up the great work.
Thanks for watching!
Thank you, Coach Milo! I'm always gobsmacked at how you smash the ball with what looks like minimal effort. Seriously, it's like you're channeling some sort of golf wizardry. And by the way, you're looking pretty fit too-keep up the hard work . . .
I've done this experiment myself a few times. I think the feels are going to be a little different for everybody, and ultimately you never know what is correct for you until you try it yourself. My own results sometimes change day to day. Golf is hard.
Thanks for watching! Self-discovery is definitely a big part of this crazy game.
Yeah and it will change as a swing changes. I used to throw from the top and I worked on holding on as much as possible just to have a "natural" release. After a while holding on was holding me back and I had to go to not holding to have a natural release. Always re-evaluate!
Awesome video, I’ve always wondered if trying to apply force was beneficial with regards to club speed, you answered that with this video, thanks!
Could be different for others, but these are my findings.
This was very cool!👌🏻
Thanks for watching Chris!
I basically learned my swing from Hogans stuff for the most part and prefer your method for sure.
I know you all think I'm crazy ... but the release point is the result of the direction of force. It happens naturally, with a slight delay, after force is exhausted. You cannot actively control where the release happens. It has to be reverse engineered with trial and error. The release happens about 30º to 40º, rotationally, after force is no longer be applied. To assume you can control the release point in real time is to assume the golf club has no weight, mass or inertia and if it didn't have any of those attributes, that would be like trying to hit a golf ball with a paper straw.
You are correct that direction of force determines when the release occurs however I would say every elite player can control the direction and magnitude of force therefore they have control of release point and can control trajectory at will.
@@MiloLinesGolf Yes, exactly.
Great experiment sir, this is exactly what double pendulum model experiment confirms.
@@andrew.derevo bingo
Milo, please do a collaboration video with the guys at Athletic Motion Golf! I would LOVE to see a video like this because your philosophy and AMG’s philosophy are drastically different. I know that one of your students and one of their students has the potential to appear the same on camera but the fact is that you guys teach in very different ways. I’d love to see a video to reconcile your guys different teaching FEELS. Not a combative video where one way is the correct way but at the same time, I’d love to hear you guys discuss differences in philosophy. I think us golf student’s would be better off understanding why two teachers have such different philosophies.
@milo The biggest difference between your guys approaches is the emphasis on body rotation. It isn’t that AMG doesn’t think it’s necessary but you have more emphasis on it than they do.
Thanks Milo! Makes sense
Glad you enjoyed it!
Great video, Milo.
I've noticed that whenever I try Release #3, I get great lag, but horrible contact and speed. Smash factor is at about 1.35 to 1.4 and I can't seem to swing no more than 97 or 98 mph.
When I let my arms (what I think is a natural) fall, it FEELS like I'm getting great lag, but when I film myself, I'm actually fully releasing the club at about P6 (pre-impact, just as my hands reach the side of my leg). Contact is perfect, swing speed is at my max (roughly 103-105), and smash factor is 1.45 or slightly above.
I just can't seem to do those super lag swings that Cameron Champ and Jake Knapp seem to pull off with ease. (It doesn't help that I'm over 50 years old, 5'8, with a body built on black beans and rice.)
So much depends on our ability to pivot dynamically.
Study Hogan’s swing in freeze frame then the swings of Moe Norman and Harry Frankenberg (Count Yogi). All three of them had a lot of side bend which maintained radial deviation lag deep into their downswings and then they release the club with the same action as cracking the tip of a whip past the sound barrier, maxing out unlar deviation as club head met, compressed and release the ball as hands and face locked square to the target.
It creates huge amount of acceleration and exponential increase in club head kinetic energy and striking force. I discovered this retooling my swing twenty years ago using Five Lesson, doing Hogan’s waggle with the wrists and letting a ball get in the way. It exploded off the face and flew straight.
I’ve studied each of these and they were all efficient.
Thanks for the video. Ive been experimenting with hitting a fade, and was curious as to where i should release the club , as I dont think swinging over the top would give great results. I learned something different here, but very useful. I'll stay tuned, thanks again
I don't feel like ever actively release the club, it just happens naturally and my alignments and matchups create the fade for me. I'd have to see your swing to offer you the best feedback. Have you looked into working with me or joining my online academy? milolinesgolf.com
Cool video 👍
Thanks 👍
Good stuff as usual. There's so much conflicting info on UA-cam, it's hard to know what's effective for my swing. For #4, are there some key feels or things to watch for to know that I'm doing this effectively?
Putting these together in one video is very helpful. It makes it easier to understand the different techniques and you have clearly shown that the tension free approach works very well. Thanks!
For #4 you still want to see some dynamic hinging and maintaining of hinge midway through the downswing before the angles begin getting let out. Watching some Tour pros in slow motion would help in illuminating this. The release really doesn't have to be all that important in my opinion, more of a byproduct. Otherwise, I'd have to see your swing to offer personal feedback - milolinesgolf.com.
Impressive clubhead and ball speed with your natural swing ! Keep it up Milo and thanks for the video !
@@bjmgolf3651 thanks
@@MiloLinesGolfwhat ball speed device/ app did you use?
@@gemelos79 trackman
Each scenario I believe help new golfers as they are doing too much of 1 or the other. I started golf later in life, & nothing feels natural to me. I have really fast twitch reflexes, I couldnt even feel the club release. Ur videos are great Milo, thanks.
Thanks for the comment David! No doubt, self-discovery is a crucial part.
@@MiloLinesGolf and BTW, your hockey stick drill has done wonders for helping me understand the feeling for releasing the club.
Awesome to hear!
Interesting insight! I wonder how much of this depends on what type of ground force the person mostly uses. I imagine that (vertical force) and (lateral force) driven players need to feel more early release, and (torque driven/pivot driven) players need to feel like they hold the angles. 🤔
Solid video, gave me some things to think about🤙
@@GarthOJ interesting question and I believe players with loads of lateral do need more manual throw because rotation isn’t creating the unloading for them however My main ground force is vertical force and I have a little above average torque and almost no lateral force.
@@MiloLinesGolf makes sense. I tend to shift alot laterally and I've always liked the feel of throwing the club or releasing it early. If I try to hold the angle I feel stuck. Probably just poor transition habits I reckon
First of all, great video, thanks Milo! A question, how do you ensure you don't get stuck with your arms and elbow? I see you manage to keep a very good structure, but when I try the sameI get my left arm pinned against my chest.
I think that's why some teachers advocate for an early release, as that is putting the arms in motion and help you get unstuck.
You learn to build proper structure and how to flex and rotate correctly. Most players are trying to push off their trail side and spin their hips which leaves the arms in a bad spot.
Are we then just doing a flail with the arms?.... body flails the arms and club kind of automatic? Would love to hear more on the arms with rotation.
@@AR-ke8wg arms provided structure and because of the loading of facial lines and muscles they automatically unload when things are sequenced correctly. The wrists are more of a free hinge not something to be used as a power source though much of the speed is extracted from the unwinding of the wrist lever.
Great video. I was testing this at driving range on Saturday and saw this posted on Sunday morning. Trying to actively start the wrist release as you're turning down to the ball halts the upper body rotation as we can't do two upper-body things at once with any speed. It makes me pull/hook everything unless I use insanely weak grip and my clubhead speed drops off a cliff. Big question here Milo - Are the golf teachers who push the active-release L to L just not realizing what's actually happening in their own swings? Feel vs real.
@@tomsettles6873 I don’t care to talk about other coaches and their ideas. I try to present what I have found to work for the majority of my students and make individual tweaks where necessary for the individual in front of me.
super cool experiment. confirms my feels.. But sometimes my old "steery" hockey slapshot habits come back out and mess it all up. so I'll keep building trust and let club swing. As long as I don't stall the body.. :)
👊
Great experiment. It shows that you found "your" swing for sure. Btw, without the cap you look really different ☺
Thanks for watching! And yeah, I believe this was after a full day of coaching and having multiple people ask me about the release, so thought I'd just whip something together. Filmed it a while back and thought what the heck, maybe I'll post it 😂.
Are those different releases difficult with a strong grip? I've always been under the impression that a strong grip is heavily dependent on an exaggerated body rotational release
I totally get it. Casting slows swing speed. Shallowing without holding the angle increases swing speed.
Since "feel isn't real" and with all your good golf analysis toys, I'd love to see actual measurements of the vector forces your hands apply to the club along with a plot of the hand and clubhead speeds and resulting ball speed. In #4, the "natural" swing, is this the feel like with a rope drill with no wrist torque, just swinging and letting the weight of the head dictate the hand forces?
In swing 4 my arms provide structure while my wrists are more or less a free hinge responding the inputs from the rotating body and swinging arms and extending legs and pelvis.
@@MiloLinesGolf perfect. Thanks for that.
‘my wrists are more or less a free hinge ‘
Definition of Release …
Great video.
loose wrist joints on your swing through the strike Milo?
Fairly, yes.
Your three wood swing at 6:32 looks like so many of my videos of my swing. 3:03 is what I am struggling with.
I want so much to understand how to get to the feeling you describe before the 8:56 swing.
I’d love to help!! Get personalized coaching at milolinesgolf.com
@@MiloLinesGolf I will contact you there. :)
I’ve always been an early releaser. Would you exaggerate by holding the release for awhile to help break that habit?
Could be a good practice and it's in a way one of the foundations for my athletic swing model. Have you looked into joining my online academy or working with me one-on-one so I could offer the best feedback and guide? milolinesgolf.com
Young players all have that strong left hand grip that you have. Would you please, please, do a video explaining how it works. I slow down the "intro" of each of your vids to watch your hand action as you get to impact and through release. Any added forearm rotation with that grip makes the clubface hook closed. I watched your Duval video where he threw the club behind him for the follow through. It seems if the body stays "back," hooks or pushes result. The drill where you sanded the ground seems to get you through. Would you be willing to give the secrets of it?
Maybe these will help: ua-cam.com/video/vTsNOGnIfGs/v-deo.html , ua-cam.com/video/H6VRYvFrFEk/v-deo.html
would love to see a video with someone with restricted turn ability. 64 with back/neck issues and no way i can rotate like this. i have to have more hands/forearms action to make any speed. more like what larry rinker does. great stuff as usual.......................
Gotta use what you have. If you have everything use it if all you have left is arms and wrists then learn to be as efficient as possible with the lever system.
ua-cam.com/video/efC-Z8A6uco/v-deo.htmlsi=IFHB4vaoG3ndo15t
Likewise, would love to see you, Milo, do videos with people who aren’t able to rotate as much as the younger more nimble golfers 🏌️♂️ you usually use. Not all of us can rotate like this… show us how to compensate please 🙏.
Look up my lesson with John Gehrisch
@@MiloLinesGolf Watched. Good stuff, but club face control wasn’t mentioned. With that ⬆️ ⬇️ swing how do you control the club face to shape shots?
Thanks. Very helpful. Do your neighbors hate you?
My neighbors all have their own golf nets and spend lots of time practicing in their own yards 😁
@@MiloLinesGolf LOL. I need new neighbors.
@@MiloLinesGolf golf ball wars! Lol!
I somehow manage to not release driver and longer clubs, producing a duck hooked, topped or skyed driver due to negative loft. To hit it solid I need to feel the right arm / shoulder low in setup and right arm going under in the strike.
I’d have to see your swing to give you the best advice on how to make your swing more efficient.
@@MiloLinesGolfNeed to get myself a tripod or something to film the caddie view. As I believe it is more difficult to see the release from down the line. Then maybe I can send something in via the web site.
So when is “when or where in the downswing” is the release happening? Thanks
That depends on a few factors but if you have a dynamic pivot it will happen from p5.5- p7.5
@@MiloLinesGolf Thanks !
Awesome video. I don't disagree with you, but it seems like Monte Scheinblum does. He's adament about throwing away lag (#2 in your experiment) fast and early. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding something or perhaps 'feel is not real'. But whatever the case, I know he doesn't swing it slow. Maybe guys like you just innately know how to swing sticks fast. IDK
@@MrMarkAODonnell I know he and others may disagree with the findings in this video which is why I was hesitant to release this video to the public. This video was made 1 year ago for my academy members and I know I sent it to you way back then. What’s interesting is if you look at hack motion data we don’t see angles unloading early, they are generally retained or increasing until somewhere after p5 for almost all elite players regardless of the release pattern they employ.
They claim that the vast majority are very late with their arms and that their hips dominate their swings. It seems to me the solution would be an earlier and faster shoulder turn that allows the hips and arms to be better coordinated. Not having dominant arms that start the DS, as that would be reverse sequencing and specifically casting. Even if it's just a "feel" it's still wrong.
I have seen greater distance and accuracy in “casting the club”. Sounds weird but it has improved my game dramatically. It gets the club back on plane quicker. I’ve had terrible success using a “body swing”. There is no “one way” to swing club. I would say that what ever helps you with regards to increased distance and accuracy, is the “best way” to swing the club.
@@hisstuff1973 cool glad you have found what works best for you.
IMHO, the best release comes very late with a will of straightening both arms in line.
Speed out front!
FOS
@@mmiittyy ?
Have you spoke to Mike Malaska as to why he advocates the “tipping” of the club? After 50+ years of teaching, he seems to swear by the technique. Thanks.
Yes I was Mike’s assistant for 7 years. Mike is a great teacher and a great guy I simply have my preferences and he has his.
I don’t know if this is supposed to be the ‘Malaska move’ but it definitely isn’t the ‘tipping out’ which Mike Malaska advocates. As Mike Malaska says, the tipping out move has nothing to do with the unhinging of the wrists but that is what is being shown here.
@@drleftie watch again I tested that feeling on the last tip out 3 wood.
@@drleftie I agree with you. A person can certainly “tip out” incorrectly and destroy the action. I’m sort of confused about what Milo is advocating here.
I've done the same experiment and gotten the opposite results. For me, a late release is very slow at the ball. Obviously, there are other factors going on. The way you release the club with the hands and arms can actually impact how you use the body. It can also happen in reverse. People are wired differently and need to feel different things.
Glad to hear you have made your own discoveries and are willing to test and explore. Different methods and preferences can certainly work. I'd be interested to see a video similar to mine that shows your findings.
Hey Milo , all I would be able to focus on is your neighbours windows lol.
This seems to be a common concern in this comment section 😂
For me-Not enough net to keep from breaking glass!
😂
What might low does not address is the fact that most people if they swung the way, he recommends would not be able to close the club face at the right time. For most people, the club face would be wide open.
@@commane21 I may not have addressed it in this video but that is one of the first things I address in my coaching.
My ball could find that inch break in that netting so my ball would go sailing through. On to damage
haha
I would lose a few balls in the tree.😂
I can help with that
Ben Hogan taught golf in Five Lessons. This guy is 921 and counting videos. Yeah, think about it.
Never release the club or it will go flying out of your hands.
@@JJ_Khailha 😎