How rich is it that the excellent caseworker was accused of being racially biased against the family but the “dad” of Noah thought it was ok the beat Noah to death because the thought Noah’s father was black !!!! Disgusting!!!
I listen to these while I do housework, I was sat down folding laundry listening to this. My 3 Yr old non verbal autistic son came and sat on my lap. And I just burst into tears.
Social worker with 4 years of college are paid $38k and the average worker lasts less than a year. Changing case workers who weren't required to be licensed social workers ruined my fostering experience. The children were the easiest part of foster parenting
All down to money. Poor pay and no where near enough case workers. Also far to much time is spent on mandatory Admin rather then getting time to spend with the families
Yes, it’s a lack of funding. But it’s also more than that. Consider social work as a job, Many social workers have a masters degree, but bachelors at minimum. They must be licensed. Then they are paid absolute crap to do an emotionally traumatizing job, with not enough support or resources. You barely make enough to feed yourself, but you spend part of your pay consistently on food and necessities for clients. You work 50+ hours per week, and are paid for 40. Your case load is 5x what your job contract says it is, and it is physically impossible to serve that number of cases properly, let alone to policy. Your clients are hostile and hate you, and getting threatened, sworn at, or even physical assaulted is not uncommon . You are exposed to vicarious trauma daily, and may experience traumatic scenes first hand. Case workers do that as long as they can, until they either can’t afford to do it anymore financially and leave for a higher paying job ( or new career), are so traumatized by the work that they need to leave for their own mental health, or finally leave due to the frustration of not being able to do the work to their own ethical standards due to high case loads and lack of resources. And some just stick around, not really caring, long enough to be promoted to management. I didn’t last in protection services long. I felt useless and powerless - identifying risk and abuse, but not given the tools to actually do anything about it.
Isn't this the same place that Gabriel Fernandez and Anthony Avalos died while DCFS turned a blind eye to rampant child abuse being reported??? Yes, they are certainly on the job in Antelope Valley. This is so disgusting.
Your precious Chase is commenting on your commentary, agreeing with your vehemence wholeheartedly❣️ He is literally opening and closing his mouth, speaking, but not making a sound out of complete respect for you❣️ The way he looks at you, with those precious squishy love eyes 😻, is so absolutely special. The story and subsequent case here is beyond horrific. The systems put in place to protect our most vulnerable are so beyond broken, nothing ever seems to change either! All this rhetoric about learning from our mistakes only serves to highlight them. So incredibly sad, such a grievous and obviously avoidable loss! Makes me want to find all involved and… oh, I don’t know, maybe stoop to their level perhaps, maybe and hell yes! 🤬
Nothing makes my blood boil more than incompetence and power plays with our children’s lives 😡😡😡😡 I went through hell and back to become a mother and was only able to achieve that dream because my son’s birth parents put HIS needs first and loved him enough not to bring him into the chaos that their lives were at that time. I have zero respect or sympathy for people that choose to bring a child into this world just to torture and abuse that precious innocent gift that a child is! It’s awful enough that some “parents” are horrible but to have people in safeguarding like the woman who let this beautiful life be taken on her watch by her egotistical actions is beyond appalling! I feel so badly for the caseworker who advocated so hard only to be removed and then have to hear that the life she tried so hard to protect was snuffed out exactly as she feared. It must have devastated her along with his family who loved and wanted to care for him. Just awful 😢
Absolute negligence and failure from the monsters he sadly had to call "parents" to an unspeakable amount of so called "professionals" from the moment he was born. Absolutely heartbreaking and completely avoidable. Rest in perfect peace sweet little Noah. 🩵 Thanks so much for covering this one Emma. It was a tough one to digest 😔💔
I have no words, only that these "parents" are worse than evil monsters. Little Noah deserved so much better. OMG, I want to gather all these children in the protective circle of my arms and give them all the love and justice they deserve. Why is it so easy for these "beings" to have children they don't want or care about while so many can't have even 1? Those that are fortunate to be loving parents, please hug them a little tighter and longer and tell them everyday that you love them.Thank you Emma for highlighting Noah's case and all the other innocents. Thank you for all your hard work.❤
My God, if i were in charge with DCFS and any child lost their life on my watch, it would utterly destroy me. That poor, beautiful baby did not deserve the absolute horror his life became. My heart truly breaks for the grandparents and other family members who loved that little baby boy. So beyond horrible! On another note, thank you, Emma, for all the cases you so passionately bring to us. You are very appreciated. We need to keep shining a spotlight on these cases if there is ever to be change.
If the situation was too bad in the home & I as the child's advocate was basically being ignored it could turn bad for the parents. I'm afraid I would lash out at them, not like physically, but you know WTF if I come back & this child hasn't gained 10 lbs & free of bruises or whatever I don't know my temper with these fools might get the best of me at seeing a starving beaten child 😢🤷🏼♀️❗️
What in the Hell is wrong with a society that doesn't put the best interests of the child above all else? There should never be a question or fear to do so.
Political Correctness can do a serious number on your brain, on the one hand you have an abused child, on the other hand you have a Government funded HR industry training our authorities in unconscious bias and white privellege on top of just a general fear of getting fired if a racial complaint is ever filed against you, which abusive morons are likely to do if you dare challenge them, they will play the race card.
Then constantly drone on & on & on, "What about the CHILDREN, we have to (do this completely unrelated or unnecessary thing) for THE CHILDREN❗️" wah, wah, wah 🙄 🤢 🤮❗️
Thanks so much for highlighting this case. Redirecting the focus of child security for reasons of political correctness is horrifying. Poor Noah - poor Eva - poor society 😢
I'm glad you recognize there are other good channels, I watch them also 👏, and I see so many comments on other channels, especially Misery Machine (❤ channel) though, stating that whatever channel they're commenting on is the best & the other's suck & here's why...🤷🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️⁉️ I always say I'm appreciative of many channels because I'm a glutinous consumer & it takes multiple channels for my true crime needs or we'd run poor Emma ragged 😂❗️
Not necessarily, that's three generations up. There's no reason to think there couldn't have been intermarriage by then... if you are white and your kid or grandkid married a black person yr great grandkid would be considered black in the US and you'd be white
How does that matter? His Great Grandmother clearly loved and cared for him, she stepped up, she did a grand job, that showed in his behaviour changes. Skin colour matters not one iota!
“Grandma it’s time for you to hold me and tell me you love me” absolutely broke my heart. It shatters me how badly this beautiful boy was failed. His case is one of many who moved me to tears. I had never heard of Noah’s case before which is even more harrowing. If this level of failure is hidden, God knows how many more have yet to see the light of day.
The irony of the biases’ of that horrific worker who arranged the, ‘family team meeting’, her essentially saying the parents were victims! Disgusting! And little Noah, oh bless. His face in that photo smiling with his, Nanna 💔😔
Poor Eva, and she'd know Noah wouldn't understand she had no choice. Yet, she did everything to give that little boy the love he absolutely deserved and memories to hold to. My heart aches for Eva.
Emma, I have been a loyal viewer of yours since you started this channel. This case truly breaks my heart. And causes ny blood to boil. How can this keep happening with a system in place meant to safeguard vulnerable children? Infuriating that this sweet young life was lost, when he was loved and safe with his grandmother. RIP, sweet Noah. 💔😢
The purring noise in the background is so soothing, your cat is gorgeous. What a horrific story, I can't count children who were sent back to their abusive parents, it breaks my heart. 😢
😻 Not ashamed to admit that after I watch/listen to a video, I have many times gone back and found those moments with Chase, turned volume down to fully focus on, feel and enjoy seeing his love for her 😻 Will add, there’s a bit of envy in that that no cat of mine has ever acted that way toward me 🥺
Noah's great grandmother was feeling torchered and helpless because she was guilty of loving her grandson what an insane situation all those whose job it is to care for children failed, shame on them all unable to compare the differences between the parents and carers including the grandparents it should have been obvious to all when he was happy and contented and when he was unhappy and uncared for
So I'm not the only one who thinks that the authorities "not wanting to be racist" in situations like this or the British grooming gangs is just a facetious cover for not wanting to do their jobs properly As opposed to this idea that they actually sincerely believe that holding non white people accountable for crimes would be racist, or something
Even Chase has an unbelievably disgusted look on his face whilst listening about this ridiculous case. The amount of people that unequivocally and catastrophic failure of Noah. Even when so many people that were trying to save him and give him the loving supportive place to thrive and grow to become a happy little boy. This is unreal...
How do social workers think they have the right to overrule a JUDGE - I hope those workers can’t eat or sleep at night and feel guilt until their dying breath for letting this occur
This is exactly why as a family Support Worker I go above and beyond every day in my role. Often working in an evening/weekend in my own time to ensure I miss nothing!!! Every tiny detail is noted and I will push against any system that does not listen. My kids have come first since the day they took their first breath. This will not change until I take my last breath. Every child is precious and a gift. People say how can I do my job? I do because I do well. I trust myself. I want to keep vulnerable children safe!!!
This is beyond horrific!! That poor little boy. I cannot begin to imagine the terror he faced on a daily basis. Parole should NEVER be an option for those 2 vile evil monsters. You are now safe Noah, fly high little man ❤
I had a couple of s.workers that wouldn't listen to me ,then another, Simon Lewis came in and got my son assessed and now he's in a school for kids like him,he's on medication for adhd and has been diagnosed ASD, I nearly lost him because no-one would listen, this case has really upset me because my boy was never abused and this not-right kept her kid after what she did !!!!! By the way my boy now thriving ❤❤❤ not saying I wasn't struggling but I needed help not just undermining ❤
I was in the same situation as you,unfortunately the only social worker who backed us up was told not to attend court in our defence, all I did was try to get my son tested for autism but they said it was because I neglected him.My children were both forcibly adopted 13 years ago,and after their adoption both my children were diagnosed as on the spectrum.I'm so glad you got the correct help in the end and got to keep your child.
In Gabriel Fernandez case, DCFS promised that this will never happend. Gabriel, Noah, Brianna, Tesslynn and hundres children dies because DCFS not doing their job. They killed children.
Anyone and I mean anyone who is in an official capacity dealing with small vulnerable children and then leaves them in a dangerous household needs going to prison themselves!
Wow, I can’t believe it took me this long to stumble onto your channel. Emma, you are cut from an amazing cloth. Your realism, your direct style of not mincing words or tip-toeing around PC subjects is so needed and refreshing. And then I find after binging you, you did this case. I grew up where these 3 little boys were murdered brutally by their parents. I’m 44 and I know that all that area like the back of my hand, I don’t live there now, but my childhood home is still there, in probate, next to the now infamous pillowcase rapist that no city in California wanted so they dumped him there. The AV (Palmdale, Lancaster) is bigger than all the cities in the actual LA area, and yet it’s rural. Police are tasked with driving 80 miles a day to patrol one area to the next minimum. While there’s a community hanging on of military, old generation, good people they’re moving or expiring. It’s been dumping grounds for the last 20 years of everything from homeless, mentally ill disabled, section 8, gangs, drugs, pillowcase rapists, you name it. Picture the ugliest barren desert street with a decaying couch on the side- and that’s the AV. It’s sad to see it juxtaposed with my memory. DCFS has always been problematic; in the 90s they were too aggressive, and now with the influx of people of backgrounds other cities pushed out, they don’t care now. You’re right- for being so many miles away, the AV is a place of failure. Great job researching this, and all your cases. I heard details I didn’t know, and I definitely followed this, along with Gabriel and Anthony. Amazing job! And your empathy and dedication to cover details and stories no one else is really shows! You are above and beyond the best researcher I have seen! Thank you for giving these children the dignity they so deserved in life but didn’t receive.
I’m in tears for Noah… may he be in peace with the angels, singing, playing and having as much ice cream and cake as his blessed heart desires. I’m furious that Noah’s grandmother was blackmailed and threatened! It actually happened to me, I was forced to move back with my ex that was brutally violent towards me, with my two little boys and be under his and his mother’s “ supervision “ under the threat of having my babies being put for adoption. Today I am physically disabled, mostly bedridden and suffering with severe CPTSD. My boys are older, but I don’t have any contact with them. By the time they were in their early teens, they started assaulting me. All I asked was to be assisted with housing so I could stay away from these psychopaths and protect my children. Instead, my beautiful children were thrown into the lions den… My love and prayers for Noah, let it always be cuddle time little one. 💙💙💙
My kitten Minnie loves the sound of your voice Emma ❤ she will always come and lay with me when I watch your channel when I’m not cleaning lol and she will purr and go to sleep . This is such a horrific case 😢
This is sad and infuriating. Nothing is going to change until the CPS DHS and the people that are supposed to be protecting these children are held accountable period point blank there is no punishment and no repercussions for social works or child protective services and until there is this shit is going to keep happening!!!
The dcfs workers who were also responsible for the outcome of Noah's fate, should also be held accountable with a prison sentence. Its about time these workers who fail in their jobs with such great incompetence should be held to account in every part of the world. Its just criminal. Rest in peace sweet Noah 🙏🕊
They obviously didn't care for him. So why did they keep taking Noah back home from the great grandmother over and over again. This is causing me physical pain to listen to this. I couldn't imagine how Noah's siblings, great grandmother, and faith feel. Or the agony that Noah suffered through in his short painful life.
I believe the photo of the woman with the hat on next to the little child is not someone involved in this case. That photo appears on an article related to COVID that’s on the same website as one about Noah, and it comes up on google when you search for pictures of Noah’s family. Just wanted to point that out so that person doesn’t get associated with this unnecessarily! ❤
Such a shame how this baby was failed by so many around. I just finished binging british's biggest taboo so I'm definitely a fangirl of your work on that true crime series . Please keep the good work and exposing these True Crime cases!
You are such an amazing story teller and advocate for violence, especially against children and you are dearly loved for that quality as well. I have been trying to piece together the WHY of Michael Topp and would like to ask you to cover this story. *warning* will definitely feel like a gut punch just reading what he did. Thank you and thank you for just being you! Much love from the US🇺🇸
Howdy from Houston, Texas USA everyone. So happy to be here. Emma you always make my day! So excited about your book I pre-ordered woot woot! P.S. Chase always makes my day as well, love him SO MUCH :)
Why oh why. Heart breaking. As always Emma, you told Noah’s tragic story with compassion and sensitivity. I cried and will never forget his beautiful words to his Grandma. 😢 Thank you for sharing that beautiful boy with us. Sleep peacefully Noah, nobody will ever hurt you again. 😢xx
That precious baby! This makes me sick at my stomach. While my daughter-in-law has tried and tried to have a baby and would be such a good mother. I am devastated at the number of stories that I have heard over and over. These monsters !
Hearing you say the memory from the Grandmother, "Do you know what time it is Grandma?" has broken my heart into pieces. I don't understand child abuse or neglect. I was 19 when I had my first child and 13 months later I had my second child. Life was not easy. I was a single mother for several years until I met the FANTASTIC MAN I have been married to for 32 years. He was NEVER their "Stepdad" he was and always will be Daddy. Our oldest was killed in a car wreck before she turned 16 and it's now been 20 years. I would give ANYTHING to have her back or trade my life so she could live. I am saying all of this because I DON'T understand why these children are being abused and killed. Many of us in this world would GLADLY take these children. Bless this Grandmother and Grandfather to this baby boy. They are in my prayers with the people who knew and loved him.
The whole time I kept thinking he couldn't be the only abused one (and even then it is abuse and traumatic seeing someone else get tortured) until you mentioned the other children got abused too. They went harder on him because he knew better and had access to better 😢.
I live in Florida & am well aware of this case & the horrific, continued failures of DCF in this state. My heart breaks for this little angel & the foster parents that pour so much of themselves into these babies. The system is broken. Foster parents have my prayers & my respect.
What does one do if you see children neglected emotionally, but they are not 'abused'? They are left to own devices in room with computer, barely passing school, sometimes they don't eat dinner. No set bedtime. Benzodiazepine misuse in house, sometimes other drugs. I think kids have been exposed to porn on laptop & one kid was given benzos to go to sleep. Not in highschool yet. It haunts me but I'm not a family member just a close friend of the uncle. All the grandparents can't cope/ ill health & drink. What can I do? I can't report it but feels like there is no-one. I don't want kids to be taken away or parents to be arrested. The worst thing is the parents not even trying, they shout and it feels like there's no love in that house.
If they're being exposed to pornography, they're being sexually abused or groomed to believe it's normal and will be physically abused in a sexual way in the future..
Why do sociopaths get away with everything - it seems as if they always have luck on their side and despite the flagrant behavior and actions, they are always overlooked or dismissed by those in authority? I have experience dealing with a sociopath and I was constantly viewed as the problem; it was stunning.
Emma, you look absolutely beautiful in this video today. RIP Noah 💙 your huge brown eyes are unforgettable. You deserved soooo much better. I wish we weren't here today to hear this tragic tale x
Hi Em ❤ I have been with you from the get go. When you started premiere's I would turn on every device in my house and log on to raise your viewership. I never missed a premier until you were at over 200k because I felt you had substantial support. I dont mind you having a membership channel. Its a good business decision and you work hard. You deserve so much. I live in a third world country and could never consider adding luxuries, I completely respect that is my problem and prerogative. Totally. You are my "crime and consistency" on a Sunday night. It's almost my comfort since I lost my 14 year old son. Sundays are planned out and it's comforting. I have not come to complain or try and gain pity AT ALL. Please don't misunderstand. I also am not asking for a membership whatsoever. If I did have a membership, I would certainly want to pay. I would insist. It was just such a heart sinking moment last night, being a Sunday night, to find that only members would be able to view the regular Sunday night slot 😢😮🥺💔 I know you have been announcing changes but maybe I missed it because I don't watch episodes that contain children since I lost my son, the gorgeous, funny, warm, kind, affectionate, centre of my universe, Branson. I just really wanted you to know how sad I was 😔 Perhpas somebody will be able to relay the new schedule to me so I can reorientate myself. Well done on all your success. Well deserved ❤🎉❤
It's heartbreaking to see the size of these two creatures in court and their children starving and abused! I love food but would starve myself before letting my kids go without😡 Devastating case 💔
What sort of agency refuses to follow a judge's order? Made on the evidence of a conscientious social worker? I am so grateful that my grandmother was able to get custody of me (as her ward) when I was four years old; no agency needed, but straight to the courts. My poor mother was both physically and mentally unable to care for me. If I had depended on an agency such as that, I would most likely not have made it past that age. My heart breaks for Noah and those who so loved him.
Well I’m watching this through tears , my hearts breaking for poor Noah and Eva. I’ve never heard of Noah’s case Emma, thank you for covering it and giving g Noah a voice ❤
I love that when Emma is really condemning him personally, Chase is also looking at the camera with disdain. 😅 you tell em buddy.
The DFS worker needs to be held accountable
How rich is it that the excellent caseworker was accused of being racially biased against the family but the “dad” of Noah thought it was ok the beat Noah to death because the thought Noah’s father was black !!!! Disgusting!!!
So in the end it's confirmed the real racist is Noah's so called dad
That's probably why he knew to play that card. Too many people back right off.
I listen to these while I do housework, I was sat down folding laundry listening to this. My 3 Yr old non verbal autistic son came and sat on my lap. And I just burst into tears.
How can one of the single handedly MOST IMPORTANT agencies we have in this world STILL be so broken??????
Social worker with 4 years of college are paid $38k and the average worker lasts less than a year. Changing case workers who weren't required to be licensed social workers ruined my fostering experience. The children were the easiest part of foster parenting
It seems beyond broken
All down to money. Poor pay and no where near enough case workers. Also far to much time is spent on mandatory Admin rather then getting time to spend with the families
Yes, it’s a lack of funding. But it’s also more than that. Consider social work as a job, Many social workers have a masters degree, but bachelors at minimum. They must be licensed. Then they are paid absolute crap to do an emotionally traumatizing job, with not enough support or resources. You barely make enough to feed yourself, but you spend part of your pay consistently on food and necessities for clients. You work 50+ hours per week, and are paid for 40. Your case load is 5x what your job contract says it is, and it is physically impossible to serve that number of cases properly, let alone to policy. Your clients are hostile and hate you, and getting threatened, sworn at, or even physical assaulted is not uncommon . You are exposed to vicarious trauma daily, and may experience traumatic scenes first hand. Case workers do that as long as they can, until they either can’t afford to do it anymore financially and leave for a higher paying job ( or new career), are so traumatized by the work that they need to leave for their own mental health, or finally leave due to the frustration of not being able to do the work to their own ethical standards due to high case loads and lack of resources. And some just stick around, not really caring, long enough to be promoted to management. I didn’t last in protection services long. I felt useless and powerless - identifying risk and abuse, but not given the tools to actually do anything about it.
Underfunding. Always is.
Isn't this the same place that Gabriel Fernandez and Anthony Avalos died while DCFS turned a blind eye to rampant child abuse being reported??? Yes, they are certainly on the job in Antelope Valley. This is so disgusting.
YES!!!!! All the cases originating out of there are ATROCIOUS! This people shouldn't be allowed to supervise a flea circus, no less CHILDREN IN NEED!
Your precious Chase is commenting on your commentary, agreeing with your vehemence wholeheartedly❣️ He is literally opening and closing his mouth, speaking, but not making a sound out of complete respect for you❣️ The way he looks at you, with those precious squishy love eyes 😻, is so absolutely special.
The story and subsequent case here is beyond horrific. The systems put in place to protect our most vulnerable are so beyond broken, nothing ever seems to change either! All this rhetoric about learning from our mistakes only serves to highlight them.
So incredibly sad, such a grievous and obviously avoidable loss! Makes me want to find all involved and… oh, I don’t know, maybe stoop to their level perhaps, maybe and hell yes! 🤬
LA DCFS are responsible for so many child deaths, but nothing changes did they not learn from Gabriel Hernandez 😭😭😭😭
This is why my sister stopped fostering. She couldn’t take the failures of the system.
Nothing makes my blood boil more than incompetence and power plays with our children’s lives 😡😡😡😡 I went through hell and back to become a mother and was only able to achieve that dream because my son’s birth parents put HIS needs first and loved him enough not to bring him into the chaos that their lives were at that time. I have zero respect or sympathy for people that choose to bring a child into this world just to torture and abuse that precious innocent gift that a child is! It’s awful enough that some “parents” are horrible but to have people in safeguarding like the woman who let this beautiful life be taken on her watch by her egotistical actions is beyond appalling! I feel so badly for the caseworker who advocated so hard only to be removed and then have to hear that the life she tried so hard to protect was snuffed out exactly as she feared. It must have devastated her along with his family who loved and wanted to care for him. Just awful 😢
Chase is an adorable little cat 🐱 ❤ Emma the way he looks at you is so precious
Chase little? I wouldn't want to be bitten by this cool cat.
I thought the same thing! Chase loves Emma. It's so sweet!❤
Not ashamed to admit that more than once after I watch/listen to the videos, I’ve gone back, turned volume off and fully admired this beautiful 😻
Emma what breed of cat is chase
@@alisonsarahcarroll6063 I had done a search and believe he is a Abyssinian cat.
Absolute negligence and failure from the monsters he sadly had to call "parents" to an unspeakable amount of so called "professionals" from the moment he was born.
Absolutely heartbreaking and completely avoidable.
Rest in perfect peace sweet little Noah. 🩵
Thanks so much for covering this one Emma. It was a tough one to digest 😔💔
I have no words, only that these "parents" are worse than evil monsters. Little Noah deserved so much better. OMG, I want to gather all these children in the protective circle of my arms and give them all the love and justice they deserve. Why is it so easy for these "beings" to have children they don't want or care about while so many can't have even 1? Those that are fortunate to be loving parents, please hug them a little tighter and longer and tell them everyday that you love them.Thank you Emma for highlighting Noah's case and all the other innocents. Thank you for all your hard work.❤
My God, if i were in charge with DCFS and any child lost their life on my watch, it would utterly destroy me. That poor, beautiful baby did not deserve the absolute horror his life became. My heart truly breaks for the grandparents and other family members who loved that little baby boy. So beyond horrible!
On another note, thank you, Emma, for all the cases you so passionately bring to us. You are very appreciated. We need to keep shining a spotlight on these cases if there is ever to be change.
Me too I don't know how I would go on...
If the situation was too bad in the home & I as the child's advocate was basically being ignored it could turn bad for the parents. I'm afraid I would lash out at them, not like physically, but you know WTF if I come back & this child hasn't gained 10 lbs & free of bruises or whatever I don't know my temper with these fools might get the best of me at seeing a starving beaten child 😢🤷🏼♀️❗️
What in the Hell is wrong with a society that doesn't put the best interests of the child above all else? There should never be a question or fear to do so.
Political Correctness can do a serious number on your brain, on the one hand you have an abused child, on the other hand you have a Government funded HR industry training our authorities in unconscious bias and white privellege on top of just a general fear of getting fired if a racial complaint is ever filed against you, which abusive morons are likely to do if you dare challenge them, they will play the race card.
Totally!!!!!+
Then constantly drone on & on & on, "What about the CHILDREN, we have to (do this completely unrelated or unnecessary thing) for THE CHILDREN❗️" wah, wah, wah 🙄 🤢 🤮❗️
Thanks so much for highlighting this case. Redirecting the focus of child security for reasons of political correctness is horrifying. Poor Noah - poor Eva - poor society 😢
I feel your anger with this one Emma, what an absolute travesty 😢
I can’t stop crying. I would have loved to be his mommy. He deserves so much more. Rest in peace beautiful little boy❤
Emma, That Chapter and Explore with Us in one day? This is the best Friday ever ❤
❤
I'm glad you recognize there are other good channels, I watch them also 👏, and I see so many comments on other channels, especially Misery Machine (❤ channel) though, stating that whatever channel they're commenting on is the best & the other's suck & here's why...🤷🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️⁉️ I always say I'm appreciative of many channels because I'm a glutinous consumer & it takes multiple channels for my true crime needs or we'd run poor Emma ragged 😂❗️
Being politically correct was more important to them than saving a child.
26 mins in well said Emma . If a child is loved and well looked after they wouldn’t need to announce it
Stereotyping? The poor baby would be going to this great grandmother, whom I assume, is from the same racial background he was from!
Not necessarily, that's three generations up. There's no reason to think there couldn't have been intermarriage by then... if you are white and your kid or grandkid married a black person yr great grandkid would be considered black in the US and you'd be white
@@SpecialBlanketthey still share the same genetics. And they look similar in the photos.
@@SpecialBlanketwhat does that have to do with the clear fact that the great grandmother is obviously the same ethnicity?
How does that matter? His Great Grandmother clearly loved and cared for him, she stepped up, she did a grand job, that showed in his behaviour changes. Skin colour matters not one iota!
@@sironagibson7252 um, the comment references the “racism” authorities were using
“Grandma it’s time for you to hold me and tell me you love me” absolutely broke my heart. It shatters me how badly this beautiful boy was failed. His case is one of many who moved me to tears. I had never heard of Noah’s case before which is even more harrowing. If this level of failure is hidden, God knows how many more have yet to see the light of day.
Great grannies are the best. I'm sorry to see that she was hurt this way😢
When will these agencies who are there to protect and provide safety for these most vulnerable children be held accountable . This is so infuriating.
Ironicly timed seeing what is going on in Leeds regarding abused children and finger pointing about race.
For a moment I thought, Oh no, don't tell me they've uncovered yet another grooming gang, :-( then I remembered what you're talking about.
What’s happening in Leeds atm?
What is happening in Leeds?
Yeah, what's happening in Leeds????
The irony of the biases’ of that horrific worker who arranged the, ‘family team meeting’, her essentially saying the parents were victims! Disgusting! And little Noah, oh bless. His face in that photo smiling with his, Nanna 💔😔
All of your productions are top notch, just brilliant, but when we get a Chase cameo, it’s like a cherry on top.
Poor Eva, and she'd know Noah wouldn't understand she had no choice. Yet, she did everything to give that little boy the love he absolutely deserved and memories to hold to. My heart aches for Eva.
I don’t understand how social services can ignore an order from a judge ?
Emma, I have been a loyal viewer of yours since you started this channel. This case truly breaks my heart. And causes ny blood to boil. How can this keep happening with a system in place meant to safeguard vulnerable children? Infuriating that this sweet young life was lost, when he was loved and safe with his grandmother. RIP, sweet Noah. 💔😢
So you mentioned the grandma sued the DFS, what happened with that, or is it still pending. This story is just so tragic and heartbreaking 💔
The purring noise in the background is so soothing, your cat is gorgeous. What a horrific story, I can't count children who were sent back to their abusive parents, it breaks my heart. 😢
Find yourself a man that looks at you like Chase looks at Emma 😂 😍
😂
@hannahmcatasney1473 -Haha! Love your comment! I needed a laugh today! Thank you! ❤
😻 Not ashamed to admit that after I watch/listen to a video, I have many times gone back and found those moments with Chase, turned volume down to fully focus on, feel and enjoy seeing his love for her 😻 Will add, there’s a bit of envy in that that no cat of mine has ever acted that way toward me 🥺
@@AmericanMom1976😂❤
Emma is married isn't she
Noah's great grandmother was feeling torchered and helpless because she was guilty of loving her grandson what an insane situation all those whose job it is to care for children failed, shame on them all unable to compare the differences between the parents and carers including the grandparents it should have been obvious to all when he was happy and contented and when he was unhappy and uncared for
*tortured
Poor baby should've been protected from those monsters😭
They did not fear being seen as racist, that’s just a convenient excuse. They were probably too scared to act or just didn’t want to bother.
I agree. Seems like BS
So I'm not the only one who thinks that the authorities "not wanting to be racist" in situations like this or the British grooming gangs is just a facetious cover for not wanting to do their jobs properly
As opposed to this idea that they actually sincerely believe that holding non white people accountable for crimes would be racist, or something
Even Chase has an unbelievably disgusted look on his face whilst listening about this ridiculous case. The amount of people that unequivocally and catastrophic failure of Noah. Even when so many people that were trying to save him and give him the loving supportive place to thrive and grow to become a happy little boy. This is unreal...
How do social workers think they have the right to overrule a JUDGE - I hope those workers can’t eat or sleep at night and feel guilt until their dying breath for letting this occur
Like the Hart women. Nobody dared to question them or take the children away because authorities were scared they would be called homophobic
Exactly, so sick
I don't think this is a thing tbh.
@@SpecialBlanketyou don’t think WHAT “is a thing?!” Those cases happened. And yea, people get so politically correct, children d!e.
@@SpecialBlanket keep lying to yourself
@SpecialBlanket keep your head in the sand....
I've just paused the video to sort my kids out with stuff and Chase is just like 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 at Emma!🤣 amazing.
He's so unique 😍🧡
These systems keep failing the children that need them most. This case reminds me of the Heaven Watkins case, these systems just keep failing us!
This is exactly why as a family Support Worker I go above and beyond every day in my role. Often working in an evening/weekend in my own time to ensure I miss nothing!!! Every tiny detail is noted and I will push against any system that does not listen. My kids have come first since the day they took their first breath. This will not change until I take my last breath. Every child is precious and a gift. People say how can I do my job? I do because I do well. I trust myself. I want to keep vulnerable children safe!!!
This is beyond horrific!! That poor little boy. I cannot begin to imagine the terror he faced on a daily basis. Parole should NEVER be an option for those 2 vile evil monsters. You are now safe Noah, fly high little man ❤
I had a couple of s.workers that wouldn't listen to me ,then another, Simon Lewis came in and got my son assessed and now he's in a school for kids like him,he's on medication for adhd and has been diagnosed ASD, I nearly lost him because no-one would listen, this case has really upset me because my boy was never abused and this not-right kept her kid after what she did !!!!! By the way my boy now thriving ❤❤❤ not saying I wasn't struggling but I needed help not just undermining ❤
I was in the same situation as you,unfortunately the only social worker who backed us up was told not to attend court in our defence, all I did was try to get my son tested for autism but they said it was because I neglected him.My children were both forcibly adopted 13 years ago,and after their adoption both my children were diagnosed as on the spectrum.I'm so glad you got the correct help in the end and got to keep your child.
In Gabriel Fernandez case, DCFS promised that this will never happend. Gabriel, Noah, Brianna, Tesslynn and hundres children dies because DCFS not doing their job. They killed children.
Anyone and I mean anyone who is in an official capacity dealing with small vulnerable children and then leaves them in a dangerous household needs going to prison themselves!
I love how an Emma rant can take her viewers thoughts and distill them into a one crysal clear monologue of how we feel.
Omg Emma you work hard. So good at what you do xx
Wow, I can’t believe it took me this long to stumble onto your channel. Emma, you are cut from an amazing cloth. Your realism, your direct style of not mincing words or tip-toeing around PC subjects is so needed and refreshing. And then I find after binging you, you did this case. I grew up where these 3 little boys were murdered brutally by their parents. I’m 44 and I know that all that area like the back of my hand, I don’t live there now, but my childhood home is still there, in probate, next to the now infamous pillowcase rapist that no city in California wanted so they dumped him there. The AV (Palmdale, Lancaster) is bigger than all the cities in the actual LA area, and yet it’s rural. Police are tasked with driving 80 miles a day to patrol one area to the next minimum. While there’s a community hanging on of military, old generation, good people they’re moving or expiring. It’s been dumping grounds for the last 20 years of everything from homeless, mentally ill disabled, section 8, gangs, drugs, pillowcase rapists, you name it. Picture the ugliest barren desert street with a decaying couch on the side- and that’s the AV. It’s sad to see it juxtaposed with my memory. DCFS has always been problematic; in the 90s they were too aggressive, and now with the influx of people of backgrounds other cities pushed out, they don’t care now. You’re right- for being so many miles away, the AV is a place of failure. Great job researching this, and all your cases. I heard details I didn’t know, and I definitely followed this, along with Gabriel and Anthony. Amazing job! And your empathy and dedication to cover details and stories no one else is really shows! You are above and beyond the best researcher I have seen! Thank you for giving these children the dignity they so deserved in life but didn’t receive.
I love the way chase looks at her, like she's the best person in the world, which she is, chase is a clever kitty:)
Kaiser Permanente is a healthcare system in California not a physician. Just wanted to note
Trying to follow along Emma, but Chase is gorgeous!!! Staring at the camera, he is brilliant!!😂❤❤😂
Fuming!!!!!! He was starved before and they send him back! I’m lost for words I really am
Noah was failed on so many levels. He should have been in a safe and caring home. Rest in peace little one ❤
I’m in tears for Noah… may he be in peace with the angels, singing, playing and having as much ice cream and cake as his blessed heart desires.
I’m furious that Noah’s grandmother was blackmailed and threatened! It actually happened to me, I was forced to move back with my ex that was brutally violent towards me, with my two little boys and be under his and his mother’s “ supervision “ under the threat of having my babies being put for adoption.
Today I am physically disabled, mostly bedridden and suffering with severe CPTSD.
My boys are older, but I don’t have any contact with them. By the time they were in their early teens, they started assaulting me. All I asked was to be assisted with housing so I could stay away from these psychopaths and protect my children. Instead, my beautiful children were thrown into the lions den…
My love and prayers for Noah, let it always be cuddle time little one. 💙💙💙
💔
My kitten Minnie loves the sound of your voice Emma ❤ she will always come and lay with me when I watch your channel when I’m not cleaning lol and she will purr and go to sleep . This is such a horrific case 😢
What a beautiful little boy, RIP darling 🙏🏻
The system not only fail Noah they didn’t care about Noah
This is sad and infuriating. Nothing is going to change until the CPS DHS and the people that are supposed to be protecting these children are held accountable period point blank there is no punishment and no repercussions for social works or child protective services and until there is this shit is going to keep happening!!!
I LOVE all of the extra content Emma. Both you and Dusted are amazing for creating it. Thank you SO much.
The dcfs workers who were also responsible for the outcome of Noah's fate, should also be held accountable with a prison sentence. Its about time these workers who fail in their jobs with such great incompetence should be held to account in every part of the world. Its just criminal.
Rest in peace sweet Noah 🙏🕊
Their son is starving but Mom's makeup is extravagant and her very stylized eyebrows in pristine order
This was heartbreaking makes you so angry that these children are let down😥💔
DCFS has a bad habit sending children back to horrible backgrounds.
So many of us would have loved you, Noah.
Eva will be reunited with her grandson one day until then im so sorry for your loss x
I love Chase just being 😊🥰 :3 while talking about horrible situations
They obviously didn't care for him. So why did they keep taking Noah back home from the great grandmother over and over again. This is causing me physical pain to listen to this. I couldn't imagine how Noah's siblings, great grandmother, and faith feel. Or the agony that Noah suffered through in his short painful life.
This is happening so often from dad or cps that these little children constantly keep getting sent back to horrendous parents
I believe the photo of the woman with the hat on next to the little child is not someone involved in this case. That photo appears on an article related to COVID that’s on the same website as one about Noah, and it comes up on google when you search for pictures of Noah’s family. Just wanted to point that out so that person doesn’t get associated with this unnecessarily! ❤
I was trying to figure out who that blond lady was.
Such a shame how this baby was failed by so many around. I just finished binging british's biggest taboo so I'm definitely a fangirl of your work on that true crime series . Please keep the good work and exposing these True Crime cases!
How? Just how.
In the picture of the boy with his parents his smile does not "reach the eyes" that fake smile is so devastating to see on a child
You are such an amazing story teller and advocate for violence, especially against children and you are dearly loved for that quality as well. I have been trying to piece together the WHY of Michael Topp and would like to ask you to cover this story. *warning* will definitely feel like a gut punch just reading what he did. Thank you and thank you for just being you! Much love from the US🇺🇸
Beautiful child its horrific and the agencys need to be held accountable imo.
Howdy from Houston, Texas USA everyone. So happy to be here. Emma you always make my day! So excited about your book I pre-ordered woot woot! P.S. Chase always makes my day as well, love him SO MUCH :)
Why oh why. Heart breaking. As always Emma, you told Noah’s tragic story with compassion and sensitivity. I cried and will never forget his beautiful words to his Grandma. 😢 Thank you for sharing that beautiful boy with us. Sleep peacefully Noah, nobody will ever hurt you again. 😢xx
RIP Noah💞
Such a beautiful young child
Absolutely devastating
That precious baby! This makes me sick at my stomach. While my daughter-in-law has tried and tried to have a baby and would be such a good mother. I am devastated at the number of stories that I have heard over and over. These monsters !
Hearing you say the memory from the Grandmother, "Do you know what time it is Grandma?" has broken my heart into pieces. I don't understand child abuse or neglect. I was 19 when I had my first child and 13 months later I had my second child. Life was not easy. I was a single mother for several years until I met the FANTASTIC MAN I have been married to for 32 years. He was NEVER their "Stepdad" he was and always will be Daddy. Our oldest was killed in a car wreck before she turned 16 and it's now been 20 years. I would give ANYTHING to have her back or trade my life so she could live. I am saying all of this because I DON'T understand why these children are being abused and killed. Many of us in this world would GLADLY take these children. Bless this Grandmother and Grandfather to this baby boy. They are in my prayers with the people who knew and loved him.
The whole time I kept thinking he couldn't be the only abused one (and even then it is abuse and traumatic seeing someone else get tortured) until you mentioned the other children got abused too. They went harder on him because he knew better and had access to better 😢.
Love your hair Emma!❤️
Thank you Emma xx
This is so awful that poor baby. Your beautiful baby looking up at you lovingly and hearing the purring was def needed light during this ❤
I live in Florida & am well aware of this case & the horrific, continued failures of DCF in this state. My heart breaks for this little angel & the foster parents that pour so much of themselves into these babies. The system is broken. Foster parents have my prayers & my respect.
What does one do if you see children neglected emotionally, but they are not 'abused'? They are left to own devices in room with computer, barely passing school, sometimes they don't eat dinner. No set bedtime. Benzodiazepine misuse in house, sometimes other drugs. I think kids have been exposed to porn on laptop & one kid was given benzos to go to sleep. Not in highschool yet. It haunts me but I'm not a family member just a close friend of the uncle. All the grandparents can't cope/ ill health & drink. What can I do? I can't report it but feels like there is no-one. I don't want kids to be taken away or parents to be arrested. The worst thing is the parents not even trying, they shout and it feels like there's no love in that house.
If they're being exposed to pornography, they're being sexually abused or groomed to believe it's normal and will be physically abused in a sexual way in the future..
The judge who made the decision to send this defenceless little boy back has blood on his hands and guilty of the death of this child .
Why do sociopaths get away with everything - it seems as if they always have luck on their side and despite the flagrant behavior and actions, they are always overlooked or dismissed by those in authority? I have experience dealing with a sociopath and I was constantly viewed as the problem; it was stunning.
Emma, you look absolutely beautiful in this video today.
RIP Noah 💙 your huge brown eyes are unforgettable. You deserved soooo much better. I wish we weren't here today to hear this tragic tale x
Awwwww Chase is so adorable, and the way he looks at you is so precious.
Hi Em ❤
I have been with you from the get go.
When you started premiere's I would turn on every device in my house and log on to raise your viewership. I never missed a premier until you were at over 200k because I felt you had substantial support.
I dont mind you having a membership channel. Its a good business decision and you work hard. You deserve so much.
I live in a third world country and could never consider adding luxuries, I completely respect that is my problem and prerogative. Totally.
You are my "crime and consistency" on a Sunday night.
It's almost my comfort since I lost my 14 year old son. Sundays are planned out and it's comforting.
I have not come to complain or try and gain pity AT ALL. Please don't misunderstand. I also am not asking for a membership whatsoever. If I did have a membership, I would certainly want to pay. I would insist.
It was just such a heart sinking moment last night, being a Sunday night, to find that only members would be able to view the regular Sunday night slot 😢😮🥺💔
I know you have been announcing changes but maybe I missed it because I don't watch episodes that contain children since I lost my son, the gorgeous, funny, warm, kind, affectionate, centre of my universe, Branson.
I just really wanted you to know how sad I was 😔
Perhpas somebody will be able to relay the new schedule to me so I can reorientate myself.
Well done on all your success. Well deserved ❤🎉❤
What a beautiful little boy. So sad
Why do these horrible people always want their kids back? They clearly don't love him,why ask for him back? I can't get my head round that.
It's heartbreaking to see the size of these two creatures in court and their children starving and abused! I love food but would starve myself before letting my kids go without😡 Devastating case 💔
LOVE the extensions on you, Em! So stunning!!! 🤍
Now I am going to watch the story. 😥
What sort of agency refuses to follow a judge's order? Made on the evidence of a conscientious social worker? I am so grateful that my grandmother was able to get custody of me (as her ward) when I was four years old; no agency needed, but straight to the courts. My poor mother was both physically and mentally unable to care for me. If I had depended on an agency such as that, I would most likely not have made it past that age. My heart breaks for Noah and those who so loved him.
It is so hard for social workers as they are so over worked. My heart breaks for this little Lad who fell through the gaps.
Go Emma!! It's just disgusting and needs to be called out..the poor children❤
this is one case never leaves my mind. I wont ever forget about this little boy😢. So so sad!
Well I’m watching this through tears , my hearts breaking for poor Noah and Eva. I’ve never heard of Noah’s case Emma, thank you for covering it and giving g Noah a voice ❤
It’s absolutely heartbreaking and appalling. Rest in eternal peace little Noah, safe in gods loving arms. 🙏🏻💔 x