Afghan Taliban Victory: A Left Perspective (Urdu)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 сер 2021
- 1. Taliban in Afghanistan
2. War On Terror and the Left
3. Why didn’t Afghan Government Fight?
4. Pushtun Nationalists and and Taliban
5. China, Russia, Iran and Afghanistan under Taliban
6. Pakistan, Strategic Depth, and Apprehensions about Taliban
7. Can Taliban and Islamic Parties Modernise the Muslim World?
P.S. My apologies. In some parts I accidentally say TTP instead of TTA. Slip of the tongue.
![The Economic Disaster of Naya Pakistan [Urdu]](/img/n.gif)
This video is one of those times when I felt tremendous gratitude for being able to understand Urdu. The video has greatly helped me in understanding the consequences of Taliban rule and the problems associated with the religious parties in the Islamic world. I will definitely watch it again to absorb more. This was a very well informed, cogent and beautifully articulated talk. Keep up the good work sir.
Urdu is overrated 🙄
Keep up
ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب
میں نے اپنی زندگی میں بہت ہی کم لوگ دیکھے ہیں جو اپنے نظریات یا عقائد کی عصبیت کی بیماری میں مبتلا نہ ہوں
تھوڑی بہت عصبیت تو قابل قبول ہوتی ہے اور ہونی بھی چاہیے ورنہ انسان اپنے خود کے نظریات پر متزلزل ہوجاتا ہے۔
ماشاءاللہ آپ ان چند لوگوں میں شامل ہیں جو عصبیت کی بیماری میں مبتلا نھیں ہیں
اللّٰہ آپ کو مزید علم نافع عطا فرمائے
آپکی حفاظت فرمائے آمین یا رب العالمین
Wonderful. You are a remarkable man Dr. Taimur and we are blessed to have a person like you among us. Haven't seen such an articulate analysis done by anyone else on Afghanistan's situation. 🙏
Thank you so much :)
काफी समय होगया है तैमूर साहब के विडियोज देखते हुए। शुक्रिया सर। आप ऐसे ही नॉलेज, ज्ञान बढ़ाते रहिए। दिल्ली से आपका आभार।
I never thought i would have the attention span to go through this whole video but i did. I also thought that i knew alot about politics and history but this video made me realize that i know very little.
Imperialism is Downfall in Asia. Imperialist forces are drowning in total Bora and in the heart of progressive afghan patterns. USA has been always Downfall where ever they tried to occupy but so far are not successful yet. May never to do so.
Absolutely brilliant. Loved it. We need more open discussions on these subjects. Thank you.
A great analysis, would love to listen to your long lectures again
A very erudite explanation of the current scenario in the neighboring country. Each component is bifurcated and presented which made the picture vivid 👍
Bravo Dr. Rahman! Loved your perspective.
Your words are always the words of wisdom... We always learn form what you say... Keep us educating!
Sir, I couldn't find the videos of your Afghan tour.
Well explained with much clarity. Thank you for the video. 💕🙇♂️
Thanks sir.
Stay blessed 😊
53:00
Do bring the series on Maulana Maudidi and the narrative around this as soon you finish your Palestine-Israel finale.
Your lectures have so much of possibility of awareness..
A beautiful speech based on scientific truth. Very insightful.
Thank you for sharing such a detailed video especially the last part was totally spot on. Although some hardcore Islamists will find it hard to acknowledge some of the sharia laws are completely outdated. Women are full of determination and if you make a safe and sound way for their career then they'll never fail to make you proud. Peace be upon you, Prof. Taimur Rahman.
Like which Sharia Law ?? Can You Explain...
It was great and well organised video. I was captivated throughout. Hats off and keep up the good work.
Sir, totally perfect. Thank you so much stay blessed and stronger
Beautiful analysis. Logical and sequential.
Thank you sir for the wonderful analysis!
Great video, please keep your work up; We need someone who can give left's perspective on different issues in the modern world.
Thank you so much for this informative session
Love it sir. Will totally support your channel
Thanks for this video 👍👍👍
Great analysis, thoroughly enjoyed ☺️
Was waiting for your video❤
Great analysis. I like to point out one repeatedly slip of tongue - instead of TTA you used TTP
yes! because he is obviously an IDIOT for using TTP instead of TTA! LMAO!
You have ability to teach and make it teachable and understand able the trivial things
Mashallah Sir aaj jis flow Mey ap ne baatey ki hey, es se hamey bohut kuch seekney kou mila. ❤️
enjoyed the complete video , didnt get bored for a second , Sir you are awesome , i learn alot from you
Thank you for very detailed analysis. It was thorough and comprehensive
It was totally based on falsehodd, didnot you noticed he is calling them TTP again and again
Very informative. Ustaad
Excellent...many things to learn
Sir please different countries ke constitutions pe lectures de, belkul bi kisi aor se samaj Nahi ah rahy..
Please!
Very informative 👍
dr.sahib you have given uptodate analysis on issues in discussion viz afghans trough leftisit line internationally and pakistani internal statehood and shamrightists and establisment thank you doc
Bht ache arguments...Bht aala bat...unveil ki ap ne...
good analysis dr. taimur.
fantastic analysis. I have been requesting you to make a video on the Iranian parliamentary, political and economic system, for a long time. so, please make an effort for this. thanks
May be in sharia for latest stuff our scholar do ijtehad . Hope you know concept of ijtehad sir
very well explanation.
Murshid sain..
Apk lecture ka e intazar tha❤
Was eager to listen you sir❤ huge fan of yours❤
Main sadqey apk❤
Really enjoyed and loved the lecture 👍
i have no idea what he's saying but i liked the video anyway in the hopes that it's translated to english
@@AsadAli-jc5tg is this satire or did Prof. Rahman really call the execution of certain workers?
@@ryanmichelz94 He (@Asad Ali) is trolling
@@ryanmichelz94 lol he’s a troll
@@AsadAli-jc5tg very accurate. Make sanitation great again
@@xyzmediaandentertainment8313 😂
Thank you sir
Mashalllah very beautiful and informative lecture
Just completed the video. It was awesome. My only concern remains when I think about " daaein bazu " is that I have to ponder which of my arm is daeen bazu :)
Naah, seriously it is a wonderful analysis of current situation...
Stay safe
same
Thank you sir.
Remarkable analysis.
Excellent Analysis
very well analysis, Comrade.
Very informative lecture
sir can u tell me something about george sanatyana philosophy of skepticism animal faith or link of any video
Dear Dr,
In spite what I know, nothing when it comes to you, Brilliant, asset as you are we are blessed
Thank you
Excellent talk.
Sir north koera south koera sy kasy pichy ha
Sir mjhy kya ap kuch essential books ka name bta skty hain history ki
Always appreciated
Much appreciated
Thx.....Sir
Such a well qualified person in Pakistan. Really appreciate your views
Waited for your video when the afghan crisis began .
Great Analysis...
Wow! Sir mind boggling session. Welldone
excellent
Sir your analysis is always good and critical.
Awesome
Good Analysis Sir...
Left hand or Right hand ko ko explain karde plz
14:00 sir I think mistakenly you said TTP instead of TTA.
Please make a video on Political Economy . I'm not sure why but I get the feeling that we might just start to think differently and head in a good direction as a nation ; I think it has to do with the quality of analysis and teaching in Urdu surfacing on social media
Love you Sir 💕💕💕💕💕
Allah bless you More ND more Sir
Behtareen.
As the student of political science I love rationality, I love knowledge,, I love the way you ignite us , I like the red color "leftist" of knowledge rather than rightist or fundamentalists . Political economy is the future of this regime but unfortunately we are suffering under the fantasies and dreams that is not able to have shape.
Thank you for this very interesting lecture Dr Taimur. It really helps in understanding the whole narrative. You often speak about the inherent weaknesses of capitalist system. Do you plan to make any videos on a viable alternative system?
Sure.
thank you
Asalamoalikum sir have some quetions???need your help...mery pappers strt ho rahy hy i need your help...about gender studies
amazing discussion
Thank u
Sir aapki videos kamal hoti h magar legnth bht zyada hoti h aap parts m videos bnaien. Ta k har bnda complete dekh sakhe.
Good analysis
I'd highly request you to make videos on English also, for such important issues.
I agree. I'm Bangladeshi and my Urdu is very basic. But I value Dr. Rahman's perspectives and analyses.
In English. ua-cam.com/video/PtP_agfRDmU/v-deo.html
@@Taimur_Laal thank you!
Sir don't make it in English mostly your followers are urdu speaking
NICE ANALYSIS
Salute to you Sir !!
You are great men to express your view about situation you don,t stand one side your thinking is so good on base of realism of internationship but Taliban is better than previous afghanistan government who could not save interest of afghanistan of people even president of afghanistan fled from his country without informing you are right afghans people has been facing a lot of war past four decade I hope this government would help the afghans people as well as make new action for building nation current government should make a plan to build nation interest because people satnd with Taliban government I hope for afghanistan people
So, How's the religion is necessary in the state of modernization?
Excellent Narrative
Sir aap taliban ko TTP keh rahay hain. Kia ye TTP ka matlab tahreek e taliban pakistan nhi?
Please sir make some video about Islamic zakat system and modudi political philosophy : waiting for your new series
Sri Lanka per video?
Well said sir
Appreciateddd
Sir, how do you maintain optimism as a person on the Pakistani Left? When will our Revolution arrive? Day by day, nihilism creeps in, but I'm sure the same dejection at one time was felt by Lenin, Mao and the cuban resistance. We need to work now!
Educate, organise, agitate
Keep fighting
@@atharvkulkarni2256 lol your country is a fascist state too
@Humanity Insaniyat they are ram worshipping jihadi
@Humanity Insaniyat Sure. Let's ask tabrez ansari
I m very happy to listen professor Taimur. I m 74 years old living in Europe for last 50 years. I m basically member of Pakistan socialist party and now with awami workers party. Very much agree with professor Taimur.
Sir your are doing great job and great service to our society. It's really a very comprehensive analysis and presented a very clear picture of the coming scenario. Dr. sb, what's the Left perspective about direct military rule and establishment role as a deep state? Further, is it necessary to take any positioning to Right, Left or Liberals? How if, instead of taking any fixed ideological position, we follow "What Works" approach, mixing the approaches and perspectives as per our spatio-temporal needs? What do you think about hybridity of ideologies, economies, cultures etc. in this postmodern age? Thanks.
Military rule in Pakistan has been a disaster.
Perfect!
Sir,14:15 haven't you misspelled this is TTA was not TTP
ڈاکٹر صاحب آپ کا کہنا ہے کہ عوامی حمایت کو آپ زیادہ اہمیت دیتے ہیں۔ حالانکہ کیمونسٹ ملکوں میں جمہورت نہیں ہوتی۔ وہاں تو ایک ہی پارٹی کی حکومت ہوتی ہے اور مخالف رائے کو تو سرے سے کسی طریقے سنا ہی نہیں جا سکتا۔
اس پہ آپ کیا تجزیہ دیں گے؟
Maza Agaya... Sir! MOLA salamat rakhe 💐 🤍
معروضی تجزیہ -> Objective analysis
معروضی -> Objective
Hats off sir🤩