A lot of people seems to get the Mary deduction dinner moment wrong and I do not understand why. "You asked for it!" yes, she did ask for it, but Sherlock did it in a way to make it purposefully uncomfortable. Also, the very original Sherlock Holmes (from the books) belongs to the old times not the modern.
Not saying modern Sherlock Holmes media can't be down, but there's a bigger level of imagination and thought that goes into having it set in the past. None of the convivences of modern tech to help, nothing say that's all a modern Sherlock would use, but it certainly simplifies things more. Being set in a time where electricity wasn't really a thing, cellphones didn't exist. fingerprint and DNA tech wasn't a thing, cars weren't the thing etc. Shows the strength of the writer to have to craft a very compelling and complex mystery that Holmes solves on brains/knowledge of the globe he lives in alone.
A series to check out that's been mentioned a few times here is elementary. Another modern take on sherlock with a few changes to it but they work so well. Worth the watch
Yeah both are completely different and both great. I like Cumberbatch's Sherlock but I love this movies. Waiting for 3rd Sherlock movie for 13 years.... :( 🤣
Well, if you go into a movie with already established biases then, although that is your prerogative, it is not fair to form an opinion of that movie. Personally, I do believe Benedict’s Sherlock is my favorite however I love RDJ’s version as well, particularly the second movie in the series. Both versions have their own place in my heart.
Maybe to anchor expectations, Elementary has a genius and socially difficult Sherlock, incorporates many of the classics storylines but is filmed and tells stories in a conventional way without visual effect, flashbacks and so on.
Ma'am, you are aware BBC's Sherlock was not the creation of the character, right? He's a icon fictional British novel character from the old series. The setting is pretty much one to one.
Its sad that people tend to compare sherlock holmes adaptations. Im a HUGE fan of the books and have liked most adaptations and i think thats the beauty of it. They all bring something new to the story. My all time fav adaptations are the granada holmes series, The private life of Sherlock Holmes and the BBC Sherlock (Mostly the earlier seasons), but i think these movies are good aswell!
I don't think it's a coincidence that those of us who love the Canon, and also the Jeremy Brett Holmes, love the earlier seasons of Sherlock more than the latter. (The BBC Radio series with Clive Merrison is equally fabulous, if you don't mind the lack of visuals)
for another modern day interpretation of Sherlock Holmes, look into Elementary is an American show, but they do have a British actor playing Sherlock may not be your cup of tea, but just a thought
You should check out jeremy Brett’s sherlock series. He is considered the closest to the books. And it’s with Granada so you won’t have to worry about the bbc.
If you check out a few episodes of the Jeremy Brett Sherlock series, you might get to like him in that role (but it is set in the original time period). His angular features seemed to fit the character. Those were based more on the original Sherlock stories, and there aren't all the modern special effects.
Yess, Jeremy is my favorite TV version of Sherlock! He was _almost_ perfect (the only "problem" to me was that he was a little too old, considering that Sherlock is still in his twenties in the first book. Other than that, Jeremy *is* Sherlock!)
I seriously missed a Sherlock joke when Robert "Iron Man" and Benedict "Dr. Strange" first met. "Okay, Sherlock, what's your plan" or something like this. Nevertheless Infinity War is a masterpiece in history of cinema!
I agree that you might enjoy an older classic take on the characters. Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is a vintage black and white classic. Rathbone did 14 Sherlock Holmes movies.
Sherlock and Co is a rlly good one to follow up BBC Sherlock with. It's a podcast, so idk if you could react to it, but its a great show and rlly underrated, great cases, good voice acting and great characters.
You might enjoy the second one more. It's a much faster film, the conflict isn't as dragged on (especially since there's not as much 'occult' gibberish,) the action is fun with great set pieces, and the Watson and Holmes banter makes it much more enjoyable since they're together more in the second film. It's definitely the more engaging out of the two films.
my favourite sherlock holmes who i've seen is probably jeremy brett, who played him in the 1980s, that series is a lot more calm in its tone like it's not action-movie-ish like this film and even bbc sherlock (which i both love, too), so you do have to get used to the pace after the modern stuff, but i do think brett plays sherlock very well and really Gets the character and cares about him, it's very book-accurate too, if you'd like to see what the original stories were like. i'd love it if you reacted to it after the next movie if you wanna check it out. there's a playlist on youtube with all the episodes, just search "granada sherlock holmes" or "jeremy brett sherlock holmes" or something like that and it should come up :)
I watched Downey's Sherlock in theatre and it was okay. But watching Benedict & Martin in the tv show was a new experience. Acting, directing & writing are brilliant. Downey's second Sherlock movie is better and gave me a good feeling, so I can recommend it. I would really love to see a third movie with Robert. And I hope - of course - Benedict & Martin come back somewhen to make more SHERLOCK!
The Original Sherlocks stories are a Mish Mash of short story mysteries....The Movies are Loosely based on a Combination of a few multiple Stories Put Together to Create A Single case...
Also these are like 90 minute films, there's only so much they can so and only so many characters get a scene/line. You're comparing a show to a film. A show gets to explore more of the characters continuous because it's like a new novel every new episode in the universe. Makes sense. These are 90 minute Hollywood blockbusters meant to entertain in that time frame. So they focus only the important of important with namesake being the most important. So they're gonna take up most the screen time.
Well Its All Good if Youve got Your Own FLAVOR and Both of these Holmes' also Played Marvel BIG DAWGS!❤...I PERSONALLY Did Enjoy RDJ and The Mixture of Ealry Century..and Action....CUMBERBATCH...Kept the SAME LEVEL of SORT of MANIC IN 5HE BBC Version and ...Sharp, Sardonic Humor as WELL
I love them both, but I saw the RDJ films first so I prefer him to Benedict Cumberbatch. Maybe that’s why we’re opposites bestie Random fun fact, my physics teacher in school went to uni with Benedict Cumberbatch and used to refer to him as “Ben” as if she knew him really well😭
Is it possible for you to reupload your abominable bride reaction? If not, could you make a download link on the community tab? Really love your reactions, it's a shame they blocked this specific one.
Speaking of Mark Strong (Blackwood)he did play a vampire in a tv series (one ep) . don’t like RDJ really and then the accent 😂 the 2nd One I liked and you kinda get used to him playing the titular character. (I do love Jude as Watson tho even tho not as much as Martins
Did you forgot how brutal and badass your country USED to be? I mean the past is always like that for the world, but I weirdly I still think people used to be happier lol.
I found these films fun, but for me, Young Sherlock Holmes will always be my top Holmes movie. This film is how I always remember when Tower Bridge was built.
I started off watching the Basil Rathbone version of Holmes from the late 30's early 40's as a kid. Cumberbatch was amazing, but an actor is only as good as the material given, and Shelocks end for me didn't match the start. RDJ is an amazing actor and no real issues with either of his films, just not enough of them I suppose. And Johnny Lee Miller of Elementary is maybe my favorite of the bunch, just because you got to spend more time with said version and got to see a larger character arc. Each is their own version and each is well worth a watch so long as your a fan of the character in general.
Its not fair Robert is a awesome actor and these movies where there before the series. So its your fault that you watch the series before the movies. And btw, sherlock holmes is supposed to be played in the 18 hundrets.
NAH, this Holmes is superior lol. Not $hitting on Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock, he's a great actor, but if I'm being honest it's like CW Sherlock for women... Best way I can put it lol. MODERNIZED. Not only is these films set in the correct time of the Sherlock novels, but I like RDJ's interpretation of Holmes kind of being a partly deranged, anti-social/awkward half man-child genius that's a savant in many things, but a big ego because of it.
I can never tell if this is an unpopular opinion or not because I have seen different reactions in different places, but I quite liked Elementary. Its another modern day interpretation starring Jonny Lee Miller as Holmes and Lucy Liu as Joan Watson. It has a little bit more of a focus on Sherlock's addiction, but it is still a detective show and Jonny Lee Miller does a good job with his interpretation of the character.
@@kaigunnarsson7148 I mean they do give an explanation pretty early on about why he needed to relocate from London to New York and that reason is fleshed out further as the show goes on. However, I do understand how New York gives the show a different vibe from all of the versions set in London.
Wow, what? A female character sidelined in a male-aimed piece of media where the title is literally the character's name, but still play an important role in motivation are making up for the male character's short-comings? What a shock... It's almost like the same thing happens in female-aimed media, but without the same respect of making the male characters a form of motivation or making up for the female characters' short-comings because women write from a place of self-insert insecurity rather than you know... COMPELLING and SMART. They go for emotion and wish fulfillment at the expense of logic.
It’s a good movie didn’t like RDJ’s accent. Yeah Benedict Cumberbatch’s version is just on another level. The only version that made me actually read all the original stories by Conan Doyel.
I don't prefer it modern day, that's so... CW. No offense, but it's very simplistic. Also I'm a history buff. Also Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield, Christian Bale and Robert Patterson are all British lol. They've all played American made superheroes in live-action films respectively, Spider-Man & Batman. Bale even being Patrick Bateman, the lead in the classic satirical, psychological thriller novel turned film film: _American Psycho_ This is not new.
People dont like that, you as the viewer, dont get the clues to follow along. He just stares at things and you need to kind of guess, but this version feels more of a John poV. I like my Holmes more in the late 19 hundreds early 20er years. And I like Robert as Holmes with Jude as Watson, tho they indeed dont hold a candle to Benedict and Martin. They are filming a third one rn. I am not the this or that is better kind of guy, more of the thing I like is better :)
There's a lot's of actors who play sherlock holmes why don't you watch them all, and i hear your complain about modern day, first? Sherlock holmes book is made in 19th centuries by sir arthur conan doyle so robert downey jr sherlock holmes is acurate for the periode
The Sherlock series took the original stories and twisted them in ways that made the familiar and fresh for those of who knew them. They did a great job overall. The RDJ movies are took the characters we knew and put them into something new. These do fit the books a little more closely than the TV series. The series from the 1980's with Jeremy Brett is the most faithful to the books overall. They were really good, but they are very not what you're used to here. You'll probably dislike hos slow they are, and they are set in Victorian times. If you want to experience the actual stories, but don't want to read them. The Brett Series is a reasonable choice. You'll 100% HATE the TV show Elementary. It's set in the modern world, but in a funhouse mirror way. The characters are all distorted. For example... Holmes has tattoos and Watson is his addiction councilor. It was good for a while, and a really interesting take on the characters, but there is nothing about what you loved from The BBc Sherlock series. The movies from the 1940's with Basil Rathbone twists the relationship to the point that Watson is little more than at stumbling buffoon. You'll probably hate them too.
If you’re seeing people smoke backwoods (if it’s the same as what a backwoods is in the US), they’re most likely smoking a weed/spliff. If they’re actually just smoking the tobacco, that’s the trashiest thing I’ve ever heard of
I DO SO AGREE… I DO like the actors in this movie (when they’re playing other roles)… But for me, Benedict is the ULTIMATE Sherlock Holmes (Then, in Second Place or possibly even tied for First Place with Benedict, is Jeremy Brett from the “Granada” Sherlock Holmes TV series - I think they were filmed in the 1980s?) …I also agree that the Young Sherlock Holmes movie is great! …The other two “Sherlock Holmes renditions” that I appreciate because they address other aspects of Sherlock’s character, are: A movie titled “The Seven Percent Solution” (I think it was filmed in the 1970s?) …which addresses Sherlock’s often-overlooked relationship with drugs… And then lastly, the movie - just titled Mr. Holmes - about an elderly Sherlock Holmes nearing the end of his career, played by Sir Ian McKellen. Oh AND… Re. those Sherlock Holmes-related Netflix movies/series: Enola Holmes and… The Irregulars …With Enola Holmes, I can actually “live with” Henry Cavill playing Sherlock (I just WISH it were Benedict!😄) …But, The Irregulars!! It’s really TOO BAD, because the show has a neat premise based on Sherlock’s Homeless Network … but that’s the ONLY “good” thing about a disaster of a show that made Dr. Watson into a Person Of Color.😖
I actually like the movies much more than the show. In fact i think the show is terrible and benedict cumberbatch does not play a very good sherlock and it is very badly written. I dont wanna spoil anything but Moriarty is just so much better in the movies. In the show i think he is frankly ridiculous and just a joke of a character and in the movies he is actually really threatening. But thats just my opinion.
Then there was no reason to react to this, since you Knew he wasn't in it. I can only surmise you only watch things for views...strange reason to "choose" to watch something. 😂😂
No, I’m not necessarily watching for views I like watching things that you guys ask me to watch and everybody who was watching along with me to Sherlock,The TV series,Wanted me to watch the films so I wanted to try them.
“Not modern day.”
You’d hate almost every Sherlock show and movie ever made then.
A lot of people seems to get the Mary deduction dinner moment wrong and I do not understand why. "You asked for it!" yes, she did ask for it, but Sherlock did it in a way to make it purposefully uncomfortable. Also, the very original Sherlock Holmes (from the books) belongs to the old times not the modern.
Not saying modern Sherlock Holmes media can't be down, but there's a bigger level of imagination and thought that goes into having it set in the past. None of the convivences of modern tech to help, nothing say that's all a modern Sherlock would use, but it certainly simplifies things more. Being set in a time where electricity wasn't really a thing, cellphones didn't exist. fingerprint and DNA tech wasn't a thing, cars weren't the thing etc. Shows the strength of the writer to have to craft a very compelling and complex mystery that Holmes solves on brains/knowledge of the globe he lives in alone.
A series to check out that's been mentioned a few times here is elementary. Another modern take on sherlock with a few changes to it but they work so well. Worth the watch
its a good movie its not fair to compare them
Yeah both are completely different and both great. I like Cumberbatch's Sherlock but I love this movies. Waiting for 3rd Sherlock movie for 13 years.... :( 🤣
RDJ actually won a Golden Globe for his performance as Sherlock in this movie.
Well, if you go into a movie with already established biases then, although that is your prerogative, it is not fair to form an opinion of that movie. Personally, I do believe Benedict’s Sherlock is my favorite however I love RDJ’s version as well, particularly the second movie in the series. Both versions have their own place in my heart.
Was kinda the joke bestie
I'd second Elementary. I've always thought it was a good Holmes adaptation
If you want a different take on it, then watch the TV Series Elementary. It is very different, but it is very good.
Maybe to anchor expectations, Elementary has a genius and socially difficult Sherlock, incorporates many of the classics storylines but is filmed and tells stories in a conventional way without visual effect, flashbacks and so on.
Bloody love these films.
Ma'am, you are aware BBC's Sherlock was not the creation of the character, right? He's a icon fictional British novel character from the old series. The setting is pretty much one to one.
I reckon you would enjoy elementary as well which is another version of sherlock holmes its a good series to watch
Its sad that people tend to compare sherlock holmes adaptations. Im a HUGE fan of the books and have liked most adaptations and i think thats the beauty of it. They all bring something new to the story. My all time fav adaptations are the granada holmes series, The private life of Sherlock Holmes and the BBC Sherlock (Mostly the earlier seasons), but i think these movies are good aswell!
I don't think it's a coincidence that those of us who love the Canon, and also the Jeremy Brett Holmes, love the earlier seasons of Sherlock more than the latter.
(The BBC Radio series with Clive Merrison is equally fabulous, if you don't mind the lack of visuals)
The second film is worth it. Moriarty is fantastic. You'll definitely like how he's portrayed.
for another modern day interpretation of Sherlock Holmes, look into Elementary
is an American show, but they do have a British actor playing Sherlock
may not be your cup of tea, but just a thought
You should check out jeremy Brett’s sherlock series. He is considered the closest to the books. And it’s with Granada so you won’t have to worry about the bbc.
For another side of Robert Downey Jr., see him sing the Police song "Driven To Tears" at Sting's 60th birthday concert.
You can also see him sing alongside Sting in a scene from Ally McBeal
Ooooo you're watching the Sherlock Holmes film, what a pleasant surprise 👀
If you check out a few episodes of the Jeremy Brett Sherlock series, you might get to like him in that role (but it is set in the original time period). His angular features seemed to fit the character. Those were based more on the original Sherlock stories, and there aren't all the modern special effects.
Maybe she have to read the books before.
Yess, Jeremy is my favorite TV version of Sherlock! He was _almost_ perfect (the only "problem" to me was that he was a little too old, considering that Sherlock is still in his twenties in the first book. Other than that, Jeremy *is* Sherlock!)
8:38
"Death is only the beginning"
*The* *Mummy* reference ?
Well, there is whole series of movies where you can see both "Sherlocks" and both "Watsons" at the same time - Marvel Cinematic Multiverse.
Rachel McAdams even shows up.
Doctor strange
Iron man
Everett Ross
Yon rogg
I seriously missed a Sherlock joke when Robert "Iron Man" and Benedict "Dr. Strange" first met. "Okay, Sherlock, what's your plan" or something like this. Nevertheless Infinity War is a masterpiece in history of cinema!
@@josefhorndl3469 very true bro
This would have to be my one of favorite movie mommy
I personally think the RDJ movies are much better. But I still love Sherlock so much.
The thing about the show is that it completely goes off the rails in the later seasons. These RDJ movies are consistently good.
I agree that you might enjoy an older classic take on the characters. Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is a vintage black and white classic. Rathbone did 14 Sherlock Holmes movies.
Sherlock and Co is a rlly good one to follow up BBC Sherlock with. It's a podcast, so idk if you could react to it, but its a great show and rlly underrated, great cases, good voice acting and great characters.
There's even a Sherlock Holmes movie starring Sir Ian McKellen. It's about his last case. "Mr Holmes" 2015.
You might enjoy the second one more. It's a much faster film, the conflict isn't as dragged on (especially since there's not as much 'occult' gibberish,) the action is fun with great set pieces, and the Watson and Holmes banter makes it much more enjoyable since they're together more in the second film. It's definitely the more engaging out of the two films.
my favourite sherlock holmes who i've seen is probably jeremy brett, who played him in the 1980s, that series is a lot more calm in its tone like it's not action-movie-ish like this film and even bbc sherlock (which i both love, too), so you do have to get used to the pace after the modern stuff, but i do think brett plays sherlock very well and really Gets the character and cares about him, it's very book-accurate too, if you'd like to see what the original stories were like. i'd love it if you reacted to it after the next movie if you wanna check it out. there's a playlist on youtube with all the episodes, just search "granada sherlock holmes" or "jeremy brett sherlock holmes" or something like that and it should come up :)
The second one is actually my favourite of the 2 films in this series. I hope you watch it 😀
I watched Downey's Sherlock in theatre and it was okay. But watching Benedict & Martin in the tv show was a new experience. Acting, directing & writing are brilliant. Downey's second Sherlock movie is better and gave me a good feeling, so I can recommend it. I would really love to see a third movie with Robert. And I hope - of course - Benedict & Martin come back somewhen to make more SHERLOCK!
The Original Sherlocks stories are a Mish Mash of short story mysteries....The Movies are Loosely based on a Combination of a few multiple Stories Put Together to Create A Single case...
Also these are like 90 minute films, there's only so much they can so and only so many characters get a scene/line. You're comparing a show to a film. A show gets to explore more of the characters continuous because it's like a new novel every new episode in the universe. Makes sense. These are 90 minute Hollywood blockbusters meant to entertain in that time frame. So they focus only the important of important with namesake being the most important. So they're gonna take up most the screen time.
To me, after Sherlock, the best adaptation of the character in a TV show or a movie was House M.D. ... and Young Sherlock Holmes
Have you seen Elementary yet?
You need to take another look at "Ren" he has a song out an upbeat one called "Ren - Back on 74 / Message In A Bottle (Live retake)"
I love robert downey jr as Iron Man and sherlock holmes
Well Its All Good if Youve got Your Own FLAVOR and Both of these Holmes' also Played Marvel BIG DAWGS!❤...I PERSONALLY Did Enjoy RDJ and The Mixture of Ealry Century..and Action....CUMBERBATCH...Kept the SAME LEVEL of SORT of MANIC IN 5HE BBC Version and ...Sharp, Sardonic Humor as WELL
Jared Harris (from the 2nd movie) is such a much better Moriarty than the one from the show, who was cringe as hell.
I love them both, but I saw the RDJ films first so I prefer him to Benedict Cumberbatch. Maybe that’s why we’re opposites bestie
Random fun fact, my physics teacher in school went to uni with Benedict Cumberbatch and used to refer to him as “Ben” as if she knew him really well😭
Is it possible for you to reupload your abominable bride reaction? If not, could you make a download link on the community tab? Really love your reactions, it's a shame they blocked this specific one.
Speaking of Mark Strong (Blackwood)he did play a vampire in a tv series (one ep) .
don’t like RDJ really and then the accent 😂 the 2nd One I liked and you kinda get used to him playing the titular character. (I do love Jude as Watson tho even tho not as much as Martins
If you run out of strictly Sherlock movies there's always the 2, so far, Enola Holmes movies with Millie Bobby Brown. They are quite good too.
And we get Sherlock too
RDJ trained in martial arts for this film.
no he had been training in jeet kune do for years before the movie
Did you forgot how brutal and badass your country USED to be? I mean the past is always like that for the world, but I weirdly I still think people used to be happier lol.
What is the next show that you chose to react to? maybe you can react to peaky blinders.
Want to try an other sherlock story? Elementery is awsome, a tv serie about a modern one!
I found these films fun, but for me, Young Sherlock Holmes will always be my top Holmes movie. This film is how I always remember when Tower Bridge was built.
You could watch Enola Holmes I think it‘s good
Hello, is it possible to order a reaction song from you? Or do you choose yourself?
I started off watching the Basil Rathbone version of Holmes from the late 30's early 40's as a kid. Cumberbatch was amazing, but an actor is only as good as the material given, and Shelocks end for me didn't match the start. RDJ is an amazing actor and no real issues with either of his films, just not enough of them I suppose. And Johnny Lee Miller of Elementary is maybe my favorite of the bunch, just because you got to spend more time with said version and got to see a larger character arc. Each is their own version and each is well worth a watch so long as your a fan of the character in general.
The best version of Holmes to me is Jonny Lee Miller in Elementary great series
To me it's Jeremy Brett.
Have you seen tropic thunder
More the boys
It’s coming!!
It’s overrated
@@HermioneGranger-sr4vz you can't force your perception on others
Its not fair
Robert is a awesome actor and these movies where there before the series. So its your fault that you watch the series before the movies.
And btw, sherlock holmes is supposed to be played in the 18 hundrets.
The second one is better for me.
Jeremy Brett's the best Holmes
NAH, this Holmes is superior lol. Not $hitting on Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock, he's a great actor, but if I'm being honest it's like CW Sherlock for women... Best way I can put it lol. MODERNIZED. Not only is these films set in the correct time of the Sherlock novels, but I like RDJ's interpretation of Holmes kind of being a partly deranged, anti-social/awkward half man-child genius that's a savant in many things, but a big ego because of it.
I can’t believe you compare that to CW. You need brain surgery lol
i feel you like two more?
I can never tell if this is an unpopular opinion or not because I have seen different reactions in different places, but I quite liked Elementary. Its another modern day interpretation starring Jonny Lee Miller as Holmes and Lucy Liu as Joan Watson. It has a little bit more of a focus on Sherlock's addiction, but it is still a detective show and Jonny Lee Miller does a good job with his interpretation of the character.
I loved Elementary, but I’ve found the rewatchability to be quite low for some reason. I can watch (most) episodes of Sherlock over and again.
yeah the only thing about elementary is its in new york that felt a little off
@@kaigunnarsson7148 I mean they do give an explanation pretty early on about why he needed to relocate from London to New York and that reason is fleshed out further as the show goes on.
However, I do understand how New York gives the show a different vibe from all of the versions set in London.
I started watching Elementary last year and it quickly became my favourite Sherlock Holmes adaptation.
Where did the reaction to 4x2 go? Can't find it
They blocked it :(
@@EllieroseReacts What a pity. I love your reactions and commentaries, so I hope this will not happen again with your other content.
@@EllieroseReacts that's the only way to block !! 💀
(POV :- I k its called a copyright...)
where's your reaction to the second episode of season 4?
@@yukivermillion blocked :(
I was confused as why you keep calling Irene’s character “Regina”. Her real name is Rachel McAdams
she plays a character called regina in the film mean girls
Sherlock Holmes' stories is NOT supposed to set in the modern times. You do know that, don't you?
@@Ali-xs2ij I do
Please more SUPERNATURAL🙏
When are you uploading more of The Boys?
today if I finish the video edit :)
@@EllieroseReactsyou’re in for a treat with this show, season 4 is airing right now
Wow, what? A female character sidelined in a male-aimed piece of media where the title is literally the character's name, but still play an important role in motivation are making up for the male character's short-comings? What a shock... It's almost like the same thing happens in female-aimed media, but without the same respect of making the male characters a form of motivation or making up for the female characters' short-comings because women write from a place of self-insert insecurity rather than you know... COMPELLING and SMART. They go for emotion and wish fulfillment at the expense of logic.
It’s a good movie didn’t like RDJ’s accent. Yeah Benedict Cumberbatch’s version is just on another level. The only version that made me actually read all the original stories by Conan Doyel.
Shame there weren’t enough quality British actors to fill out the cast.
(Yes, that was a bit sarcastic.)
I don't prefer it modern day, that's so... CW. No offense, but it's very simplistic. Also I'm a history buff. Also Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield, Christian Bale and Robert Patterson are all British lol. They've all played American made superheroes in live-action films respectively, Spider-Man & Batman. Bale even being Patrick Bateman, the lead in the classic satirical, psychological thriller novel turned film film: _American Psycho_
This is not new.
Because British do better American accents than the other way around and just because it’s modern day doesn’t make it CW. Dios mio 🤦🏻♀️
People dont like that, you as the viewer, dont get the clues to follow along. He just stares at things and you need to kind of guess, but this version feels more of a John poV.
I like my Holmes more in the late 19 hundreds early 20er years. And I like Robert as Holmes with Jude as Watson, tho they indeed dont hold a candle to Benedict and Martin.
They are filming a third one rn.
I am not the this or that is better kind of guy, more of the thing I like is better :)
There's a lot's of actors who play sherlock holmes why don't you watch them all, and i hear your complain about modern day, first? Sherlock holmes book is made in 19th centuries by sir arthur conan doyle so robert downey jr sherlock holmes is acurate for the periode
The Sherlock series took the original stories and twisted them in ways that made the familiar and fresh for those of who knew them. They did a great job overall.
The RDJ movies are took the characters we knew and put them into something new. These do fit the books a little more closely than the TV series.
The series from the 1980's with Jeremy Brett is the most faithful to the books overall. They were really good, but they are very not what you're used to here. You'll probably dislike hos slow they are, and they are set in Victorian times. If you want to experience the actual stories, but don't want to read them. The Brett Series is a reasonable choice.
You'll 100% HATE the TV show Elementary. It's set in the modern world, but in a funhouse mirror way. The characters are all distorted. For example... Holmes has tattoos and Watson is his addiction councilor. It was good for a while, and a really interesting take on the characters, but there is nothing about what you loved from The BBc Sherlock series.
The movies from the 1940's with Basil Rathbone twists the relationship to the point that Watson is little more than at stumbling buffoon. You'll probably hate them too.
for me RDJ is the best sherlock of all time and i saw even the movies from 1939
You plan to do the Enola movies?
Shall I..?
@@EllieroseReacts By my humble opinion. Indeed.
@@EllieroseReacts yup
@@EllieroseReactsyesssss
You are incredibly beautiful❤
Maybe need to change your title to get people to watch it. Stating upfront that you didn’t give the movie an honest chance, why would I watch? Pass.
You don't like honest persons? Maybe need to change your forced up expectations?
plz dont skip the movie Holmes and Watson 2018, its a fun time
Sherlock shouldn't be played by an American, we suck at doing British accents, lol.
I agree, this version is not for me, I enjoy the one with Benedict.
RDJ always plays RDJ to me))) Benedict's SHERLOCK is untouched❤
If you’re seeing people smoke backwoods (if it’s the same as what a backwoods is in the US), they’re most likely smoking a weed/spliff. If they’re actually just smoking the tobacco, that’s the trashiest thing I’ve ever heard of
I DO SO AGREE…
I DO like the actors in this movie (when they’re playing other roles)…
But for me, Benedict is the ULTIMATE Sherlock Holmes (Then, in Second Place or possibly even tied for First Place with Benedict, is Jeremy Brett from the “Granada” Sherlock Holmes TV series - I think they were filmed in the 1980s?)
…I also agree that the Young Sherlock Holmes movie is great!
…The other two “Sherlock Holmes renditions” that I appreciate because they address other aspects of Sherlock’s character, are:
A movie titled
“The Seven Percent Solution” (I think it was filmed in the 1970s?)
…which addresses Sherlock’s often-overlooked relationship with drugs…
And then lastly, the movie - just titled Mr. Holmes - about an elderly Sherlock Holmes nearing the end of his career, played by Sir Ian McKellen.
Oh AND…
Re. those Sherlock Holmes-related Netflix movies/series:
Enola Holmes
and…
The Irregulars
…With Enola Holmes, I can actually “live with” Henry Cavill playing Sherlock (I just WISH it were Benedict!😄)
…But, The Irregulars!!
It’s really TOO BAD, because the show has a neat premise based on Sherlock’s Homeless Network …
but that’s the ONLY “good” thing about a disaster of a show that made Dr. Watson into a Person Of Color.😖
I actually like the movies much more than the show. In fact i think the show is terrible and benedict cumberbatch does not play a very good sherlock and it is very badly written. I dont wanna spoil anything but Moriarty is just so much better in the movies. In the show i think he is frankly ridiculous and just a joke of a character and in the movies he is actually really threatening. But thats just my opinion.
Exactly. Just your opinion and you can have it or of course. Thank you for sharing 😊
Then there was no reason to react to this, since you Knew he wasn't in it. I can only surmise you only watch things for views...strange reason to "choose" to watch something. 😂😂
No, I’m not necessarily watching for views I like watching things that you guys ask me to watch and everybody who was watching along with me to Sherlock,The TV series,Wanted me to watch the films so I wanted to try them.
I couldn't get into these movies.
It’s just not the same 🥺
Woke sherlock tv show is 🤢🤮