They definitely need to do this but i wonder if instead of a full episode they will just add moments in seversl episodes so they don't show it all at once. But victor flashbacks is one of the answers i most want this season
@@RoyRoyce_ yes there probably do it but by bit but as long as we some or couple of big answers in this season I'll be happy I watch the first season when it first came out and love it I'm happy other people love it too .
@@berisilin1337 i don't think it was a warning. The cicadas might need to build up to a swarm like they did. The monsters seemed to see them- they sure weren't surprised that Randall fell down freaking out.
If you have read the Goosebumps books you know about Slappy the evil living dummy who strangely resembles the talking dummy Christopher was talking to. Slappy can also control yup you guessed it monsters, ghouls, spirits, giant spiders just like the books he can make nightmares come alive and become real. What If the show was really set in the Goosebumps universe and the dummy is behind it. Think about it in season one I remember someone mentioned how the forest makes nightmares come alive and that is exactly what Goosebumps is about. Who are slappys best accomplices? Children. I think Victor is actually the key. He may have been manipulated by the dummy after Christopher or he could still be in control. Remember when Sara got a message from the forces that told her to "kill the boy" what if the boy isn't Ethan or the boy in white. The boy is actually Victor because he is still a child essentially just aged up from being stuck in the town. Victor is the key everything revolves around him, his sister Eloise, his mom, his father who just happened to wind up in an ambulance that was going to encounter the tree. The dummy is behind everything or whatever was possessing it. It wanted Victor to do something horrible as a kid. He got scared, disobeyed and hid the dummy went crazy. The dummy wants him dead. The monsters screech like the dummy because they are being controlled by it. It also showed itself in the tower with Boyd, it appeared to Jade. Victor saw it underneath the town in the monsters lair and he went batshit crazy like he was scared of it like he knew what it really was. The dummy is the real evil behind everything. I theorized that the baby Fatma is carrying is a ghoul or something trying to birth itself in physical form. In the Goosebumps books Slappy or whatever the entity inside him was only desired one thing to become real and turn the people into controlled puppets. The monsters don't eat, they have no blood, no emotions, they dont run and have atrophied organs because they are essentially that just puppets being controlled by someone like animatronics. The town isn't real. It's artificial like a playset with no power cables, telephone lines don't connect to anything and animals come from nowhere its all manufactured or created by something that controls everything and it just could be the dummy they kept showing us since season one. It all makes sense
I thought I knew that creepy-ass dummy !! My kids loved Goosebumps! They read many many Goosebumps books to get extra points in a book club- points gets you pizza, so that was the motivation. Yes , this makes a lot of sense!! Yes I agree!! Victor is definitely the key!!
I thought I knew that creepy-ass dummy !! My kids loved Goosebumps! They read many many Goosebumps books to get extra points in a book club- points gets you pizza, so that was the motivation. Yes , this makes a lot of sense!! Yes I agree!! Victor is definitely the key!!
For the scene where Tabitha is saying not to turn around she’s panicking that the monsters will intercept them in the woods further from town, remember when they drive the loop a large portion of it is wooded, if they are in town they have a better chance of reaching shelter before the monsters get to them
I think Victor does give us new information when he is telling Sara that he wants to build a fort in the basement. Victor tells Sara that the basement is for secrets and the bedroom is for stories, because Victor has a distinction about what is said in what rooms means that someone has made him promise to secrecy in a basement before just like he has told stories with his sister in the bedroom before. We see Victor walking in on Jasper talking on his own to Christopher in what looks like a basement. I think Christopher and Jasper made Victor swear to secrecy about Jasper being able to talk and how much Fromville had changed Christopher shortly before the whole town got murdered, and that's why Victor says that the basement is for secrets.
@@214Beans , yes! that's a great theory! But there are some inconsistencies in the show: monsters know everything but can't find people hiding in the bushes (it's like they have briefings just before coming out of the caves, but don't have connection with each other during the night), or maybe it's just the rules of the game?
@@kriild i think the entity that controls them like marionettes can only see where superficially, but not bellow. Maybe thats why he made a tent and thats why they can hide in the bushes. The entity might be able to hear them everywhere but the basement. The only inconsistency with this theorh is that i do think the negative entity controlled jasoer that marionette and it influenced Christopher, which potentially were in a basement..... so i wonder if it was in a basement or where.🤔
Ooh, love the fact this is over an hour long, appreciate your hard work! I'm also really intrigued by your observations about the town being like an amusement park. Colony house has always reminded me of a haunted house ride, The Brundles kind of looks like a water ride with the inflatable rings, and then alright, this is a bit of stretch but, the merry-go-round seems like a carousel? There's also the fact everyone arrives by a vehicle, like a car on a rollercoaster track, going around in loops.... In a previous video, I think you mentioned the monsters possibly being animatronics? This got me thinking of a ride that used to terrify me as a child - It's a Small World. I remember those animatronic dolls in various different roles and costumes... and that creepy song sang over and over by children - the first verse is interesting: It's a world of laughter A world of tears It's a world of hopes And a world of fears There's so much that we share That it's time we're aware It's a small world after all Feel like it might possibly be a reference? But also feel like a crazy person, this show really has that effect on people...
Everyone has complained about the lack of communication, but I believe it's very realistic. Imagine you're trapped in a town with complete strangers and that town is Fromville. A highly stressful place that makes people prone to psychotic breaks. How do you know you're hallucinating because of the location and not because your mind is slipping. It seemed odd but everyone understands why Fatima isn't talking about her condition. The kicker is, she didn't know it would get that bad just like everyone else thought it was just something that happens here. Basically you'd never tell total strangers you're hallucinating scary things, especially when you're on edge about mental health already due to the circumstances. Same for the 3 that got trapped by cicadads. They aren't sure how bad their situation is, they don't even know if it's getting worse or better. That's information that could get you kicked out of town.
When Boyd said "right now" I believe he was thinking, "what are they doing then? another ambush?". Then the ambulance cones and he realizes he needs to save the people before the monsters get them.
Re: the phone call from "Thomas" - it's now 100% clear it's not Thomas because the minute Jim took the phone he said "hi, JIM" ... there's no way his dead infant son would be able to speak anyway but if he theoretically could, why would he call him Jim and not dad?
@@jramirez617 To manipulate Ethan to get killed. Remember how he ran out there after the he saw the ambulance. If his father didn’t find out what was being said on the call, Ethan could have died. Once Jim came on the phone the entity saw no purpose to manipulate anymore
@@Trav83Ethan could have been killed several times already. I was just wondering where the old lady that is usually outside Matthew's house was when he opened that door a second time. I really thought she would be there when he ran out.
@@jmonique6409 yeah clearly they all were aware of there ambulance arrival which is why no one was in their respective locations. Honestly that's what bugs me out. The monsters seen to have no incentive to kill anymore. They could of literally killed everyone in the ambulance, Randall Boyd Tabitha and Jim included. I understand why they couldn't kill Randall but the others, no clue.
21:40 - The entire purpose of the creatures, unless they are actually killing, is to produce fear like a crop. This is evident in that they walk, they don’t run; and they smile and taunt constantly. The Waitress creature approaches with the key, this is a trade. Boyd called out in the woods after defeating the Dancer creature from the music box, “You won’t fuckin’ break me!”, and the night monsters weren’t anywhere around. The telephone calls over lines that don’t exist and the radio contact was a man who knew what the fake Thomas knows. The voices and visions tell people and the boy in white what is going to happen, then it happens. Two cars will arrive, etc. Therefore, the night creatures near the police officer were not going to kill her. They were pushing her to kill Nikki, because that was what was going to happen instead of them killing the police officer. Just like they know when the force that controls fromville is going to bring in two cars. It’s not a question. It’s a result that just hasn’t happened yet. So, time in the pocket universe doesn’t work the same way. The force that controls fromville already knows that if it waits in the barn that Boyd and Tian Chen will bring in the cow. And in that same way, the menace of the night creatures will force the police officer to kill Nikki. And the reason that’s important is because Nikki threatened Fatima. Not physically with violence, and she did apologize; but she openly opposed Fatima in front of others. The force that controls fromville didn’t like this, and so Nikki was eliminated by the police officer. But the police officer was not supposed to or not allowed to be killed by the night creatures. We’ve seen that a powerful creature was the dancer from the music box, with the potential to dream destroy everyone. Jasper is a ventriloquist doll, and likely a very powerful entity possesses it. Using this, it is not too much of a leap to think of the night creatures as marionettes, functioning as many armed force that controls fromville that uses the night creatures. Each night, they come out to “play”. The “play” is orchestrated by the force that controls fromville as he walks Waitress creature upto Randall’s bus first thing in act 1 of the night. So, the creatures do not have freewill as they are puppets. Fromville seems to be like “It”, as it has apparent cycles where it begins and ends a story where everyone dies. From the dates found where the talisman rocks were located (how did Boyd know they would work away from the cave or away from all the rest of the talisman rocks is a question I’d like answered), we can assume that the force that controls fromville has pulled people from all sorts of timelines, including the civil war. Victor was allowed to live. So, either Victor is immune, overlooked on purpose for some reason, innocent, no threat, or Victor is the force the controls fromville. Victor’s mind around the age of puberty when human beings are full of power results in Victor “playing” with people. Now, maybe Victor wants his dad in fromville. So the force the controls fromville causes it to happen. Because it can make sure that it does, it’s play time. The music box, the ventriloquist doll, the marionette puppets on strings at night. And Victor pointed a gun at Randall, now Randall is all fucked up on top of the ambulance. Victor doesn’t like being yelled at, and now Jade is seeing the symbols that end the story for awhile. It’s always summer, because Victor’s always a kid and kid’s always love summer. Victor likes Fatima, and the houses know what everyone does all the time, hear everything; because it is Victor “playing”, so he knows Nikki was mean to Fatima. Perhaps the power that Victor wields is his own dreams, as they playout in a lifelong coma somewhere after the accident where his mother smashed her car into the tree. I guess we’ll see what Henry has to say.
The thudding in the forest reminds me of Season 1 when the tent got blown away. Theres something bigger out there in the forest, and its crazy how these questions from earlier are still getting remember, and hopefully answered. I think the writers won't go down the 'lost' route, and they actually have a direction, which makes me even more excited!!!
Competitive shooter here on the “mis-fire”, it’s in no way shape or form a “shooters” term, she said it like she meant it was an ND (negligent discharge). 1 of the 5 gun safety rules is to know your target and what’s behind it. Hope this helps!! Ps:you described a jam, there’s a couple different types. Failure to extract, failure to feed and a double feed.
Ah , you've seen my rendez vois joke explanation, that's nice! ) btw you were absolutely right in that "Thomas" is trying to lure Jim into blind obeying by giving him correct urgent information each time. But the hook is probably barbed.
It's still nighttime.....so we still dont know whats gonna happen in the woods. I literally get scared every time i sit down to watch it....even though i watched the spoilers. This show is soooo awesome!!!!
I think, the people will be upset at the minimum with Boyd for leaving Randell and I don't think he will be forgiving, he is not the type.. Also I think it is going to be a controversy with Tabitha, people are going to want to find this tree and take there own chances. Surely it wont work this way and people will probably jump to death, but people are probably going to want to know where this tree is located, she probably wont tell...I think it is going to be some division in the town next week. We are at the half way point of the season already, it's fast. Really I think we are at the half way point of the series, realistically it's probably a 4-5 year plan for the creators .. I would imagine. So at this point it is probably half way and It will be nice to get some answers this year before more new plots are opened going forward
Hey, yay! It was me who told you.😊 I knew it was tarot scholar Gertrude Moakley instantly.🎉 I make art books and have used her image in a tarot inspired piece. 🃏
One thing lve noticed is Tabitha said "if l get out of the car, what are you going to do? Am I going to wake up in the hospital? Or back in that place?!" a few episodes back. While she never managed to fully leave the vehicle, she was being sent to the hospital...and ended back in Fromville.
Different from Jim and Boyd, the ambulance took too long to get to the city. This shows that the city controls who enters and when because they weren’t allowed to get inside until the trap was in place. Another point is that the monsters allowed the cop to live and they lured her to the colony house. Also, Fatima was already feeling attracted by the blood from the wound and that is why she asked to be alone with the body. Maybe the place felt that she had bloodthirsty and killed the person to satiate her desire.
It's interesting how it's basically the boy in white vs the town, convinced that the "Thomas" phone calls were just him trying to help. And since he used Tabitha to get Victor's Dad, the town did it's best to sabotage the arrival, so it's magic vs magic and I love it. So many layers
True but most people drive into this camp and the entrance seems to be the fallen tree road. It's like the minute you see it you're trapped in some parallel dimension bubble cut off from the rest of the world but Tabatha discovered a way out thru the lighthouse.
The "things" on the dresser are not a single object, but several organized from front to back - front - a small white stone - behind that, a small rounded rock, behind that - a small jar - from the jar are loosely arranged twigs of various lengths and shapes. If I had to guess, the twigs are being held in place by sand in the jar. No idea what any of it is, but there are 6 of them in a row.
There is an empty clear drinking glass on the right side in front of the last two. The night table has some jars and a pine cone and a serving tray with two handles behind them. Also no idea why.
Do you think they hired those amazing cake decorators to create the rotten food for Fatima. Just super curious what it was really made of for the scene :)
34:51 The only card we see when Tillie is holding the deck is the Justice card. It says Justice at the bottom in what I think is a Forestarms font (see the star in that word?) but the J is a 7, so 7ustice. The 7 is a nod to it being a deck made for the show, a prop. The box front has the two of swords on it and a a blindfold, similar to people blinding themselves for knowledge. There is also a sun and moon similar to the talisman. I tried searching for the deck long and hard since I collect decks but with the nod to the 7 in Justice, being 7ustice…it has to be a cheeky prop made by the showrunners.
Hi Igor! Great catch with the painting of the person with cheek injury (hope Randall doesn’t turn 😳😂) Also, I feel like this “world” could be a high tech or supernatural escape “room”. I used AI to ask if FROM was an acronym for an escape room what would the letters represent, it was a long answer but basically FEAR - Players confront their fears, RESCUE - Players are tasked with/ saving people, OBSTACLES- there’s puzzles & challenges testing wit & teamwork, MYSTERY- there’s a plot twist Players must unravel during their quest. Could be? 🤷🏽♀️
Isn't the writing on the talismans Hungarian runes? By the way, love your videos and your whole vibe, Igor. As soon as I finish an episode, I come to youtube to hear your recap and theories. Congratulation on all your success! 🎉❤❤
The phone completely reminds me of the Twlight Zone episode, Stopover in a Quiet Town. I am also thinking of the way the monsters seem to always know what the people are up to.
The “Merry -go-round “, thing is a yarn winder. The black square box looks like a “Viewfinder” popular toy in the 40’s -60’s. You pot in a round disc that has 3 d photos and it brings them to life. Most of historical sites-vacation spots Disneyland etc. You could purchase many different discs with many subject matters.
Definitely a Wendigo Baby. "Bringer of Gifts" makes me think of how Vampirism is often referred to as a "gift" by evil vampires, almost like Jasper gave Christopher the monster curse somehow, which led to the massacre. The Thomas voice felt mostly like the town just taunting Jim, like "they're mine now," but maybe it's implying something changed in the family dynamic.
I can understand Jim's anger at (supposedly) Thomas saying that Julie and Ethan are not his children anymore. It can imply that they don't love Jim anymore as their father as they did before. And it can be emotionally devastating for a parent to lose their children's love, especially if it's the parents' faults. It brings feelings of grief and guilt. I am speaking from the point of view of parents, and I am indeed one.
@geekademy i feel like when Boyd said "right now" he realized that if they weren't there, it was because they had a live hunt elsewhere. It just seemed like he knew it meant danger for someone.
Why didn't Boyd try running over the monsters with that ambulance once he got the keys? Atleast try saving Randall dudee! I don't know why this season seems so frustrating Fatima not choosing to get that baby out of her is absolutely damn beyond dumb. Like wtf GIRL? You're having cravings for blood you dumbass. Talk to your husband. "Oh he's happy so I can't abort." YOU'RE DRINKING BLOOD AND EATING ROTTEN FOOD! ARE YOU CRAZY?!
Si Boyd intentaba atropellar a los monstruos hubiera matado a Randall pues Randall estaba alucinando con la cigarras en el suelo y no se podía levantar este reacciono justo cuando Boyd decide tomar las llaves como si hubiesen cerrado un trato así que no solo lo hubise matado atropellado intentando salvarlo sino que los monstruos al ver que este no cumplió intentarían ahora así atacar la ambulancia pinchando la llantas con sus uñas y ahora así matarían a todos menos a Boyd, segundo no sabemos si lo que tiene Fátima sea un embarazo o si se está convirtiendo en algún monstruo pero como diablos vas decir que comes comida podrida y que comes sangre humana imagina la reacciones que todos pondrian tratar de matarla por llevar un anticristo dentro se convertiria en una paria me imagino que no dice nada por que tiene miedo aunque si debería intentar decirle a su esposo que es con el que más confianza tiene
Reincarnation seens like the most on point theory. That also might be what Randall was getting at, that the fate worse than dying is always coming back forever in cycles. Jasper imo gives a hint to whats going on. All the monsters in a way are just puppets, and the main final boss is controlling them like puppets and speaks through them. Feel Fatima is for sure going through a transformation into one of them. Why her idk. And yeah Victors has gotta snap out of it with his freaking Dad there safe and sound, the boy in white used up so much magic to make that happen, dont waste it! And only way i can see a mix of science and magic if its aliens, their tech could be like magic but that imo would be goofy so most likely not
I think Randall saying there are worse things than dying ties back to when we see the three cicada prisoners chained to the wall like Martin. The first thing Martin asked for when Boyd found him was death.
Don't forget Randall tied Donna to a tree a few weeks ago almost causing her death, so he can't be mad at Boyd when he willingly decided to go outside to help. The monsters could kill all of them since there was no talisman in the ambulance.
Another clue we saw was the motel/hotel finally had a name! It was shown during the massacre recap by Victor. It was called Star Magic! In all other episodes the name of the place is missing.
Absolutely love your work bro, big fan! But a lil bit of advice if I may, PLSSS… Try to keep the intros a lil shorter in the future 😊. Could sometimes be a turn off, otherwise tho great job AGAIN!!
I'm glad you mentioned the monster's clothing. In addition to inconsistencies with blood splatter, I've wondered how their clothing has survived decades of creeping through woods. The fabric should be in tatters. The bandage on Randall's cheek also reminded me of Miranda's painting back in Maine. The only issue I see is that I don't see an ear piercing on him. And, did you notice in the last episode how Fatima made a disgusted look when she smelled water? She is repelled by anything that life depends on, including the essential one, water.
Igor. Love your reviews. My theory on Fatima not wanting to drink water. From the previous episode when they autopsied a monster, it was completely dehydrated on the inside. If she or the baby are turning, they wouldn’t want any water.
Insane theory using Jim/Tabitha/Victor's dad bracelet: They are the same people. Victor's dad is Jim. Victor's mom is Tabitha. Ethan is Victor. But from like a different timeline or something. I dunno. Kinda dumb and I hope this isnt what they do, but man that bracelet is really fucking hard to make sense of. If it really has the same defect. Unless they are magical items like Taran says and can teleport or something. Definitely something to pay attention to o
Just in case if you missed it, Wikipedia says that From is a science fiction show. (Well, Lost, too) I checked some other shows that are kinda similar, and Yellowjackets is a thriller drama, Wayward Pines - also science fiction, 1988 - mystery science fiction, Dark - science fiction. So, From should definitely have some kind of “scientific” explanation to it in the future
@@ElizRued well, yes, they can. But you need to have pretty good public proofs to write something there. I worked on a project once and we were trying to create a wiki page for a legit company and it still wasn’t approved due to lack of articles about it (and we had dozens of them)
Black smoke monster in lost was suposed to be a cloud of nanomachine at first that why he make electric sound wrtters changed they mind to much hope they dont do that in from...
The idea that everything is mechanical and controlled, somehow makes sense that the puppet would be able to talk and move because something is able to control things and animate them
if the watch was still running when he took it off Mr Dead Guy then that explains why it's different in the suitcase, otherwise yes a continuity error, although this doesnt seem like the kind of show that makes continuity errors
Igor! I've been enjoying your videos for some time now. Every video that comes out is better than the previous. I'm curious, what are some of your favorite streamers/games? Keep up the awesome stuff 👍🏻
They’re Slaugh fae fairies It just makes soooo much sense Explains the crows (better than the Odin thing cause like common) Slaughter fairies are able to turn into crows and teleport people to a pocket dimension that can accessed from anywhere but once youre taken by a slaugh you can’t escape their little pocket world. (Sounds familiar) The stone circle in the middle of town is quite literally a fairy circle. Dark fairies (what slaugh are) Tend to pretend to be human, they enjoy torture and derive pleasure from other peoples suffering. (Sound familiar) They also like to use and collect human items to learn more about them and better deceive them. They use trees to teleport from their world to ours (sounds familiar) There’s a lot a lot more (Look up them up it’s just “from dark fae theory” there’s a Reddit theory that goes deep into the exploration)
When I first looked up dark fairy lore after watching this show I was shocked by how many elements matched up. If it's not all fae then they have to play a significant role for whatever else is controlling Fromville
Jasper and Jade are both precious stone names. Although they are of different color and mineral composition, so no connection here. But that Jade sees Jasper and only two of them have gemstone names can't be a coincidence, imo.
Igor: regarding houses looking alike, (the Sara/Victor scene) in Chicago, we have a "Bungalow Belt". Almost ever house built in the 50s, two windows in triangles on the second floor for the expensive ones, one window for the cheaper one. I think the town is/was a company town. Example. we had a town called Argo because everyone worked for Argo Ham. That's long gone, the town is now called Summit and has another thirty streets attached. If you look at that one street,that is a company town. That taller building with al the windows, near the gas station, I would actually call that rooming house. For single people. I think that whatever company the town was based around is gone, because the turn is in the road. It would be in ruins, but if this were the case, I'd just be curious about the town. A factory likely.
I recently uncovered a significant clue that Jack Bender placed all the way back in Season 1. The realization gave me chills-it’s clear it was carefully hidden, and it may be the key to understanding much more. i will release 17th Oct 2024 .
Card on tillies deck was the Two of Swords, means stalemate. Also the only witch named Tillie was in a book called "Wicked Witches of the Midwest" and she was a mischievous and powerful witch.
One thing I noticed about boyds seen with the female cop is that it seems similar to what happened with his wife in the town when she shot up everyone. And that combined with what just happened made him snap on her.
Plus she handcuffed Tabitha to the ambulance and then ran off with the keys, abandoning her surrounded by monsters. I'm more mad at her for that than for accidentally shooting someone who thought it was a good idea to stand in a window and watch a gunfight
"finally they are talking to each other" They have been already, off screen. Then followed by, "I don't know why they are showing them telling people when we already saw it happen." This is the stupidity of that judgment.
We can see that in one of Victor's drawing there's broken glass on the ground with some blood I think. Maybe it's connected to the story Sarah was telling her brother about the girl with the broken glass in season 1. Also the reincarnation theory makes a lot of sense to me. That the chosen one always returns. Also, the bracelet is a huge clue. Tabitha made it for her husband cause she is a reincarnation of Miranda and Miranda found an identical one in fromville from the chosen one before her. It maybe also connected to the dates written in the lighthouse. I think the date Miranda died and the date Tabitha was born are connected. This theory suggests that these vision are not actually just visions but memories of past lives. They have to remember where they came FROM.
I'm not sure about Jasper as just a name, but in the bible is really meant as a stone: Revelation 21:19 (KJV): "And the foundations of the wall of the city were garnished with all manner of precious stones. The first foundation was jasper; the second, sapphire; the third, a chalcedony; the fourth, an emerald;" Exodus 28:20 (KJV): "And the fourth row shall be a beryl, and an onyx, and a jasper: they shall be set in gold in their in closings." Not sure if this means anything?
It could be Thomas though. I know he died as a baby in the real world, but he died because of a phone call. It might've been the evil force from the town on the other side of that line. Or it might've been one of the tower kids trying to lure Tabitha into town so that she could free them since Miranda failed to do so. That phone call set a chain reaction in motion. 1) Thomas dies 2) Jim and Tabitha can't process the grief and decide to divorce 3) They take the kids on a trip in the RV for one last family vacation together before telling the kids about the divorce 4) On their trip they encounter that tree in the road, which leads them to fromville This whole chunk of events could imply that the evil thing or the tower kids had a connection to the Mathews family (An ancestral connection and litterally a direct phone line to their household in the real world.) I think the town is a place where dimensions clash. Sure, the timeline in Fromville matches the one in the real world for the people who end up there, but the town itself has multiple dimensions in it where time is of little meaning. There are night creatures from the 50s, ghosts, weird apparitions from the civil war, tower kids, illusions, etc. So Thomas is dead in the real world but his ghost might be trapped in that tower in fromville along with the other kids. He died as a baby but his ghost takes an older apparition of a helpful boy in white, around Ethan's age (he visits him and Tabitha quite a lot and he guides them). Before the Mathews family, there was Victor's family. What if Miranda and Henry had a baby son too and he died like Thomas? Could it explain Henry's alcohol abuse and problems with Miranda? She took off with the Eloise and Victor because something/someone was calling to her (tower kids). Miranda saw this coming since the day they dropped acid under that tree and she told Henry about it all these years but he wouldn't believe her. She'd try to make sense of it by drawing what she saw that day (in the basement - which is for the secrets as Victor told Sarah in this episode). Years later, when her baby died as her acid visions predicted, Miranda pissed at Henry for not believing her, took the car and the kids and drove to the tree where her acid visions began. She didn't make it to the tree because there was another one blocking the road. They end up in Fromville and it all goes south. Victor is alone after "his mom dies and everyone dies" as he puts it. But he's not completely alone. The boy in white guides him and keeps him company. It might be the spirit of his dead baby brother appearing as a boy around Victor's age to help him survive the town. It's the same apparition of a boy in white for Ethan and Victor but it's 2 different spirits from 2 different timelines - Thomas and Unknown. Maybe it's not Thomas on the phone with Jim, but he exists in this town one way or another. The foreshadowing in first season gives it away when Ethan says that Thomas is on his own quest. That's my theory sofar.
Just an add-on: Miranda and the kids didn't make it to the tree where it all began so Tabitha and Henry weren't going to make it either - I'm obviously drawing parallels here. The road from Henry's house to that special "original" tree has an intersection with the other dimension where the town exists. That's why both (Tabitha and Henry and Miranda and the kids) couldn't make it to the tree. There might be dimensional intersections like this throughout the states. Roads that might lead to special "original" trees that connect the real world with the place that traps the souls of dead kids/unfortunate deaths. The roads are blocked by the evil force so that no one can reach this place and traps them in this so called town. It's a trap where dimensions bleed into each other.
@@mandolyn He was carrying a sixpack early in the day when Tabitha showed up. Usually it wouldn't mean much, but the writers specifically chose to show him carrying beer. Introducing a character to the audience this way always has a meaning. Plus, his wife Miranda made the bottle tree by their house with various empty, alcoholic bottles. There are other clues as well but that would take even longer to elaborate.
@reynam2576 a six pack after work or whatever doesn't prove alcohism. If it's a thirty pack, maybe, but that's really gasping. He coulldve started drinking after because of depression. Miranda could've been a drinker before ,we don't know
It's very disturbing to see Fatima licking blood off Nicki's corpse. I can still accept if she likes to eat rotten foods, but enjoying blood or corpse as food, is definitely Unacceptable in any way.
The monstors were following orders by the bigger entity. The Entity knew that Boyd and the Matthews had to drive away from Randall, so Randall could see that and remember. Then they left him super damaged, but alive. That creates division. So maybe Randall won't talk about the habits and patterns of the creature again. That's why she gave him the keys.
That flashlight could be a connection to Boyd's torch. When he used that torch from the otherworld, he was able to access it again. Also, Victor, Tabby, and Jade all accessed the Underworld (the caves) with a torch, the flashlight. Although I don't think Tabitha needs one since she's is primordial fire. Tabiti is the goddess name. That's why I think she has to light a fire to save the children.
Why do you think the town waited for so long to have new residents? I need to know more about Victor's lost years. Is the sound that the doll is making the same sound as the creatures screams?
The red lamps in the jasper section appear to be the same (sarah tied in basement & Christopher/jasper scenes). Most likely an insignificant coincidence
Your point about seeing the infinity symbol everywhere popped into my head when I was re-looking at a picture of some of the toys/cards on the stairs in the lighthouse/tower scene before the boy in white pushes Tabitha out of the window. I've been wracking my brain about the significance of the numbers 4 & 7 and always go back to the fact that there are three cards - a 4 of hearts (red) and an 8 of clubs (black) with a 7 of diamonds or hearts (its red but you cannot see the suit) right underneath it. If you turn an infinity symbol 90 degrees, it's essentially an 8, is it not? In the image you used in your video of the breadbox, are those almost "clubs" on each end of the infinity symbol?! Just like the 8 of clubs on the stairs! Separately, I think Tilly's card deck is bespoke and not one that you would find on the market in real life. I did notice that when she was getting ready to read Fatima's cards and holding the deck to her chest, the card at the bottom of the deck that was visible was the "Justice" card, which is usually card #8 in tarot. I don't have any idea if there is any significance to this other than that, I too, am clearly losing my mind trying to find patterns LOL
Jasper is on the TV screen and is showed behind Eljin like three times as he follows the Kamono girl out of the ktichen, even after he's bumped into and "wakes up", no longer seeing the ghost girl yet Jasper can still be seen on the TV as the man bumps into him.
Could be some kind of jammer or faraday cage type thing around the whole place. To block the satellite. I personally think it's a pocket dimension, and will be pissed if it is not. But just saying. Mabuse might be the last name of someone who works on the show. Shows/movies like to do that type of thing sometimes
In season one Ethan tells the story about the lonely dragon collecting things that were considered trash to most but treasure to him and he ended up helping the cromenackle find their way home by giving her a map. In Henry’s house there’s a wood piece that says spitfire. I’ve been thinking he could be the lonely dragon and I know it sounds crazy but what if Cristopher is actually Henry and jasper was his puppet
The onion story goes with a lot of mythology and folklore. There was a Greek prince called Cromus. From Crommyon, which is Onion in Ancient Greek. He was a son of Poseidon. That actually make him a demigod, as well. I don't know much else yet. But in Game of Thrones, Ser Davos Seaworth, also known as The Onion Knight, was probably based on the myth. There's a character in Stephen Universe, apparently, that is inspired by the same myth. The name Gerber actually means tanner. I don't know the connection yet, but I bet onion juice could be used for leather preparation. I wonder if that character was a counterpart to Ellis. The story seems to be connected to Odysseus, too, though Poseidon hated him. But he was a captain on a ship.
We need a whole episode of young Victor's life in this town before and after the massacre.
Yes definitely how did he survive so long of so many questions
They definitely need to do this but i wonder if instead of a full episode they will just add moments in seversl episodes so they don't show it all at once. But victor flashbacks is one of the answers i most want this season
Possibly one of the revelation’s episodes
@@RoyRoyce_ yes there probably do it but by bit but as long as we some or couple of big answers in this season I'll be happy I watch the first season when it first came out and love it I'm happy other people love it too .
@@MarilynVision13the boy in white most likely helped him survive by himself and he developed a routine/pattern to survive by.
I was waiting for your video! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
THANK YOU for being the only reaction channels that doesn't dismiss things like Randall seeing the cicadas as "a hallucination".
He also sees them in the bus, is it a warning/threat?
@@berisilin1337 i don't think it was a warning. The cicadas might need to build up to a swarm like they did. The monsters seemed to see them- they sure weren't surprised that Randall fell down freaking out.
The opening - damit you're genius! 😂
Had to fast forward at the # Nikki feast!😂
If you have read the Goosebumps books you know about Slappy the evil living dummy who strangely resembles the talking dummy Christopher was talking to. Slappy can also control yup you guessed it monsters, ghouls, spirits, giant spiders just like the books he can make nightmares come alive and become real. What If the show was really set in the Goosebumps universe and the dummy is behind it. Think about it in season one I remember someone mentioned how the forest makes nightmares come alive and that is exactly what Goosebumps is about. Who are slappys best accomplices? Children. I think Victor is actually the key. He may have been manipulated by the dummy after Christopher or he could still be in control. Remember when Sara got a message from the forces that told her to "kill the boy" what if the boy isn't Ethan or the boy in white. The boy is actually Victor because he is still a child essentially just aged up from being stuck in the town. Victor is the key everything revolves around him, his sister Eloise, his mom, his father who just happened to wind up in an ambulance that was going to encounter the tree. The dummy is behind everything or whatever was possessing it. It wanted Victor to do something horrible as a kid. He got scared, disobeyed and hid the dummy went crazy. The dummy wants him dead. The monsters screech like the dummy because they are being controlled by it. It also showed itself in the tower with Boyd, it appeared to Jade. Victor saw it underneath the town in the monsters lair and he went batshit crazy like he was scared of it like he knew what it really was. The dummy is the real evil behind everything. I theorized that the baby Fatma is carrying is a ghoul or something trying to birth itself in physical form. In the Goosebumps books Slappy or whatever the entity inside him was only desired one thing to become real and turn the people into controlled puppets. The monsters don't eat, they have no blood, no emotions, they dont run and have atrophied organs because they are essentially that just puppets being controlled by someone like animatronics. The town isn't real. It's artificial like a playset with no power cables, telephone lines don't connect to anything and animals come from nowhere its all manufactured or created by something that controls everything and it just could be the dummy they kept showing us since season one. It all makes sense
Great theory ❤❤❤
Did you watch the series ? With sloppy
@@Thegrumbledore I watched it on Hulu but not all of it.
I thought I knew that creepy-ass dummy !! My kids loved Goosebumps! They read many many Goosebumps books to get extra points in a book club- points gets you pizza, so that was the motivation. Yes , this makes a lot of sense!! Yes I agree!! Victor is definitely the key!!
I thought I knew that creepy-ass dummy !! My kids loved Goosebumps! They read many many Goosebumps books to get extra points in a book club- points gets you pizza, so that was the motivation. Yes , this makes a lot of sense!! Yes I agree!! Victor is definitely the key!!
For the scene where Tabitha is saying not to turn around she’s panicking that the monsters will intercept them in the woods further from town, remember when they drive the loop a large portion of it is wooded, if they are in town they have a better chance of reaching shelter before the monsters get to them
I appreciate that this video is longer than the episode 😂 👏
bro i was refreshing my page yesterday waiting for this, your breakdowns are the best
Nooooo. That intro 😂😂
Love it. This youtuber has top notch content. He should make the intro into a reel to make it viral 😂
That was ME! I found out about Gertie. And commented. Also, she died in 1999. So, Tillie has been at the tarot thing for a while.
You are awesome!
I think Victor does give us new information when he is telling Sara that he wants to build a fort in the basement. Victor tells Sara that the basement is for secrets and the bedroom is for stories, because Victor has a distinction about what is said in what rooms means that someone has made him promise to secrecy in a basement before just like he has told stories with his sister in the bedroom before. We see Victor walking in on Jasper talking on his own to Christopher in what looks like a basement. I think Christopher and Jasper made Victor swear to secrecy about Jasper being able to talk and how much Fromville had changed Christopher shortly before the whole town got murdered, and that's why Victor says that the basement is for secrets.
....or maybe the entity cannot hear or see what occurs in the basement.
@@214Beans it can - it saw Tabitha digging that hole, didn't it?
@FraternityOfShadows Tabitha talked about digging the hole with Jim in the kitchen.
@@214Beans , yes! that's a great theory!
But there are some inconsistencies in the show: monsters know everything but can't find people hiding in the bushes (it's like they have briefings just before coming out of the caves, but don't have connection with each other during the night), or maybe it's just the rules of the game?
@@kriild i think the entity that controls them like marionettes can only see where superficially, but not bellow. Maybe thats why he made a tent and thats why they can hide in the bushes. The entity might be able to hear them everywhere but the basement. The only inconsistency with this theorh is that i do think the negative entity controlled jasoer that marionette and it influenced Christopher, which potentially were in a basement..... so i wonder if it was in a basement or where.🤔
Ooh, love the fact this is over an hour long, appreciate your hard work!
I'm also really intrigued by your observations about the town being like an amusement park. Colony house has always reminded me of a haunted house ride, The Brundles kind of looks like a water ride with the inflatable rings, and then alright, this is a bit of stretch but, the merry-go-round seems like a carousel? There's also the fact everyone arrives by a vehicle, like a car on a rollercoaster track, going around in loops....
In a previous video, I think you mentioned the monsters possibly being animatronics? This got me thinking of a ride that used to terrify me as a child - It's a Small World. I remember those animatronic dolls in various different roles and costumes... and that creepy song sang over and over by children - the first verse is interesting:
It's a world of laughter
A world of tears
It's a world of hopes
And a world of fears
There's so much that we share
That it's time we're aware
It's a small world after all
Feel like it might possibly be a reference? But also feel like a crazy person, this show really has that effect on people...
Everyone has complained about the lack of communication, but I believe it's very realistic. Imagine you're trapped in a town with complete strangers and that town is Fromville. A highly stressful place that makes people prone to psychotic breaks. How do you know you're hallucinating because of the location and not because your mind is slipping. It seemed odd but everyone understands why Fatima isn't talking about her condition. The kicker is, she didn't know it would get that bad just like everyone else thought it was just something that happens here. Basically you'd never tell total strangers you're hallucinating scary things, especially when you're on edge about mental health already due to the circumstances. Same for the 3 that got trapped by cicadads. They aren't sure how bad their situation is, they don't even know if it's getting worse or better. That's information that could get you kicked out of town.
When Boyd said "right now" I believe he was thinking, "what are they doing then? another ambush?". Then the ambulance cones and he realizes he needs to save the people before the monsters get them.
Re: the phone call from "Thomas" - it's now 100% clear it's not Thomas because the minute Jim took the phone he said "hi, JIM" ... there's no way his dead infant son would be able to speak anyway but if he theoretically could, why would he call him Jim and not dad?
Was there any doubt before
@@Trav83no, but the caller seemed more invested in the illusion on the first call
@@jramirez617 To manipulate Ethan to get killed. Remember how he ran out there after the he saw the ambulance. If his father didn’t find out what was being said on the call, Ethan could have died. Once Jim came on the phone the entity saw no purpose to manipulate anymore
@@Trav83Ethan could have been killed several times already. I was just wondering where the old lady that is usually outside Matthew's house was when he opened that door a second time. I really thought she would be there when he ran out.
@@jmonique6409 yeah clearly they all were aware of there ambulance arrival which is why no one was in their respective locations. Honestly that's what bugs me out. The monsters seen to have no incentive to kill anymore. They could of literally killed everyone in the ambulance, Randall Boyd Tabitha and Jim included. I understand why they couldn't kill Randall but the others, no clue.
Amazing video, keep up the great work. Your English is amazing.
21:40 - The entire purpose of the creatures, unless they are actually killing, is to produce fear like a crop. This is evident in that they walk, they don’t run; and they smile and taunt constantly. The Waitress creature approaches with the key, this is a trade. Boyd called out in the woods after defeating the Dancer creature from the music box, “You won’t fuckin’ break me!”, and the night monsters weren’t anywhere around. The telephone calls over lines that don’t exist and the radio contact was a man who knew what the fake Thomas knows. The voices and visions tell people and the boy in white what is going to happen, then it happens. Two cars will arrive, etc.
Therefore, the night creatures near the police officer were not going to kill her. They were pushing her to kill Nikki, because that was what was going to happen instead of them killing the police officer. Just like they know when the force that controls fromville is going to bring in two cars. It’s not a question. It’s a result that just hasn’t happened yet. So, time in the pocket universe doesn’t work the same way. The force that controls fromville already knows that if it waits in the barn that Boyd and Tian Chen will bring in the cow. And in that same way, the menace of the night creatures will force the police officer to kill Nikki. And the reason that’s important is because Nikki threatened Fatima. Not physically with violence, and she did apologize; but she openly opposed Fatima in front of others. The force that controls fromville didn’t like this, and so Nikki was eliminated by the police officer.
But the police officer was not supposed to or not allowed to be killed by the night creatures.
We’ve seen that a powerful creature was the dancer from the music box, with the potential to dream destroy everyone. Jasper is a ventriloquist doll, and likely a very powerful entity possesses it. Using this, it is not too much of a leap to think of the night creatures as marionettes, functioning as many armed force that controls fromville that uses the night creatures. Each night, they come out to “play”. The “play” is orchestrated by the force that controls fromville as he walks Waitress creature upto Randall’s bus first thing in act 1 of the night. So, the creatures do not have freewill as they are puppets.
Fromville seems to be like “It”, as it has apparent cycles where it begins and ends a story where everyone dies. From the dates found where the talisman rocks were located (how did Boyd know they would work away from the cave or away from all the rest of the talisman rocks is a question I’d like answered), we can assume that the force that controls fromville has pulled people from all sorts of timelines, including the civil war.
Victor was allowed to live.
So, either Victor is immune, overlooked on purpose for some reason, innocent, no threat, or Victor is the force the controls fromville. Victor’s mind around the age of puberty when human beings are full of power results in Victor “playing” with people. Now, maybe Victor wants his dad in fromville. So the force the controls fromville causes it to happen. Because it can make sure that it does, it’s play time. The music box, the ventriloquist doll, the marionette puppets on strings at night. And Victor pointed a gun at Randall, now Randall is all fucked up on top of the ambulance. Victor doesn’t like being yelled at, and now Jade is seeing the symbols that end the story for awhile. It’s always summer, because Victor’s always a kid and kid’s always love summer. Victor likes Fatima, and the houses know what everyone does all the time, hear everything; because it is Victor “playing”, so he knows Nikki was mean to Fatima. Perhaps the power that Victor wields is his own dreams, as they playout in a lifelong coma somewhere after the accident where his mother smashed her car into the tree. I guess we’ll see what Henry has to say.
The thudding in the forest reminds me of Season 1 when the tent got blown away. Theres something bigger out there in the forest, and its crazy how these questions from earlier are still getting remember, and hopefully answered. I think the writers won't go down the 'lost' route, and they actually have a direction, which makes me even more excited!!!
Competitive shooter here on the “mis-fire”, it’s in no way shape or form a “shooters” term, she said it like she meant it was an ND (negligent discharge). 1 of the 5 gun safety rules is to know your target and what’s behind it. Hope this helps!!
Ps:you described a jam, there’s a couple different types. Failure to extract, failure to feed and a double feed.
Ah , you've seen my rendez vois joke explanation, that's nice! ) btw you were absolutely right in that "Thomas" is trying to lure Jim into blind obeying by giving him correct urgent information each time. But the hook is probably barbed.
It's still nighttime.....so we still dont know whats gonna happen in the woods. I literally get scared every time i sit down to watch it....even though i watched the spoilers. This show is soooo awesome!!!!
I think, the people will be upset at the minimum with Boyd for leaving Randell and I don't think he will be forgiving, he is not the type.. Also I think it is going to be a controversy with Tabitha, people are going to want to find this tree and take there own chances. Surely it wont work this way and people will probably jump to death, but people are probably going to want to know where this tree is located, she probably wont tell...I think it is going to be some division in the town next week. We are at the half way point of the season already, it's fast. Really I think we are at the half way point of the series, realistically it's probably a 4-5 year plan for the creators .. I would imagine. So at this point it is probably half way and It will be nice to get some answers this year before more new plots are opened going forward
The episodes are too short . Seems we only get 1 scene of a play each episode 😢
Hey, yay! It was me who told you.😊
I knew it was tarot scholar Gertrude Moakley instantly.🎉
I make art books and have used her image in a tarot inspired piece. 🃏
You are awesome!:)
One thing lve noticed is Tabitha said "if l get out of the car, what are you going to do? Am I going to wake up in the hospital? Or back in that place?!" a few episodes back. While she never managed to fully leave the vehicle, she was being sent to the hospital...and ended back in Fromville.
The puppet dummy talking to Christopher is very similar to Boyd talking to the ghost of the priest.
Different from Jim and Boyd, the ambulance took too long to get to the city. This shows that the city controls who enters and when because they weren’t allowed to get inside until the trap was in place.
Another point is that the monsters allowed the cop to live and they lured her to the colony house.
Also, Fatima was already feeling attracted by the blood from the wound and that is why she asked to be alone with the body. Maybe the place felt that she had bloodthirsty and killed the person to satiate her desire.
@@wfveloso great point there definitely a boss in fromville we haven't seen yet or we have and don't know it.
Wow exactly, why did it take them so long to arrive...
It's interesting how it's basically the boy in white vs the town, convinced that the "Thomas" phone calls were just him trying to help. And since he used Tabitha to get Victor's Dad, the town did it's best to sabotage the arrival, so it's magic vs magic and I love it. So many layers
Yummy 😋 😂😂😂😂 “Dis is Victor, getting ready for his bar mitzvah” 😂😂😂😂
I think what's impersonating "Thomas" in those phonecalls and the voice on the radio S1 it's actually Jasper the creepy talking doll
Ohhhh, mate that's a wonderful point you have made.
I think all the same. Thomas, jasper, the visions, all are one evil entity 😢
I do not believe a car is a requirement to be captured in Fromville. People were trapped before cars existed
There are some big wagon wheels in the cabin area, so people in horse drawn carriages were getting trapped there back in the day.
True but most people drive into this camp and the entrance seems to be the fallen tree road. It's like the minute you see it you're trapped in some parallel dimension bubble cut off from the rest of the world but Tabatha discovered a way out thru the lighthouse.
Horseback, car, same, both forms of transportation 😅😂❤
I love love your long videos thank you
Thank you!
The "things" on the dresser are not a single object, but several organized from front to back - front - a small white stone - behind that, a small rounded rock, behind that - a small jar - from the jar are loosely arranged twigs of various lengths and shapes. If I had to guess, the twigs are being held in place by sand in the jar. No idea what any of it is, but there are 6 of them in a row.
There is an empty clear drinking glass on the right side in front of the last two. The night table has some jars and a pine cone and a serving tray with two handles behind them. Also no idea why.
Would love to see you do severence. It’s just 9 episodes but it’s really good! And season two comes out in January.
yes please
Do you think they hired those amazing cake decorators to create the rotten food for Fatima. Just super curious what it was really made of for the scene :)
Doughnuts... )
34:51 The only card we see when Tillie is holding the deck is the Justice card. It says Justice at the bottom in what I think is a Forestarms font (see the star in that word?) but the J is a 7, so 7ustice. The 7 is a nod to it being a deck made for the show, a prop. The box front has the two of swords on it and a a blindfold, similar to people blinding themselves for knowledge. There is also a sun and moon similar to the talisman. I tried searching for the deck long and hard since I collect decks but with the nod to the 7 in Justice, being 7ustice…it has to be a cheeky prop made by the showrunners.
Hi Igor! Great catch with the painting of the person with cheek injury (hope Randall doesn’t turn 😳😂) Also, I feel like this “world” could be a high tech or supernatural escape “room”. I used AI to ask if FROM was an acronym for an escape room what would the letters represent, it was a long answer but basically FEAR - Players confront their fears, RESCUE - Players are tasked with/ saving people, OBSTACLES- there’s puzzles & challenges testing wit & teamwork, MYSTERY- there’s a plot twist Players must unravel during their quest. Could be? 🤷🏽♀️
Isn't the writing on the talismans Hungarian runes?
By the way, love your videos and your whole vibe, Igor. As soon as I finish an episode, I come to youtube to hear your recap and theories. Congratulation on all your success! 🎉❤❤
Henry for Ms. Lu and Acosta for Nicki
But no replacements for Paula or Reggie?
The phone completely reminds me of the Twlight Zone episode, Stopover in a Quiet Town. I am also thinking of the way the monsters seem to always know what the people are up to.
Oh this is a BIG one!!!
The “Merry -go-round “, thing is a yarn winder.
The black square box looks like a “Viewfinder” popular toy in the 40’s -60’s. You pot in a round disc that has 3 d photos and it brings them to life. Most of historical sites-vacation spots Disneyland etc. You could purchase many different discs with many subject matters.
u crazy for that opening lol... I subbed just off that, hadn't even heard a word yet lol
Definitely a Wendigo Baby. "Bringer of Gifts" makes me think of how Vampirism is often referred to as a "gift" by evil vampires, almost like Jasper gave Christopher the monster curse somehow, which led to the massacre. The Thomas voice felt mostly like the town just taunting Jim, like "they're mine now," but maybe it's implying something changed in the family dynamic.
Amazing, I love your breakdowns
I can understand Jim's anger at (supposedly) Thomas saying that Julie and Ethan are not his children anymore. It can imply that they don't love Jim anymore as their father as they did before. And it can be emotionally devastating for a parent to lose their children's love, especially if it's the parents' faults. It brings feelings of grief and guilt.
I am speaking from the point of view of parents, and I am indeed one.
@geekademy i feel like when Boyd said "right now" he realized that if they weren't there, it was because they had a live hunt elsewhere. It just seemed like he knew it meant danger for someone.
Thanks for the shoutout. Meagan means pearl. This is a clue to la Peregrina IMO.
Why didn't Boyd try running over the monsters with that ambulance once he got the keys? Atleast try saving Randall dudee!
I don't know why this season seems so frustrating
Fatima not choosing to get that baby out of her is absolutely damn beyond dumb. Like wtf GIRL? You're having cravings for blood you dumbass. Talk to your husband. "Oh he's happy so I can't abort."
YOU'RE DRINKING BLOOD AND EATING ROTTEN FOOD! ARE YOU CRAZY?!
Actually insane how quickly that otherwise mediocre subplot took off lol
Run them over with Randell laying on the ground ? 😅😂 yeah that’ll work
We dont know she has a baby. She only has signs but she could be becoming a moster o having baby. Yea all is so frustrating
Si Boyd intentaba atropellar a los monstruos hubiera matado a Randall pues Randall estaba alucinando con la cigarras en el suelo y no se podía levantar este reacciono justo cuando Boyd decide tomar las llaves como si hubiesen cerrado un trato así que no solo lo hubise matado atropellado intentando salvarlo sino que los monstruos al ver que este no cumplió intentarían ahora así atacar la ambulancia pinchando la llantas con sus uñas y ahora así matarían a todos menos a Boyd, segundo no sabemos si lo que tiene Fátima sea un embarazo o si se está convirtiendo en algún monstruo pero como diablos vas decir que comes comida podrida y que comes sangre humana imagina la reacciones que todos pondrian tratar de matarla por llevar un anticristo dentro se convertiria en una paria me imagino que no dice nada por que tiene miedo aunque si debería intentar decirle a su esposo que es con el que más confianza tiene
Omg thank you!!!!! Wtf you have a demon spawn thats making you snack on your housemate....it's eviction time!!
Reincarnation seens like the most on point theory. That also might be what Randall was getting at, that the fate worse than dying is always coming back forever in cycles.
Jasper imo gives a hint to whats going on. All the monsters in a way are just puppets, and the main final boss is controlling them like puppets and speaks through them.
Feel Fatima is for sure going through a transformation into one of them. Why her idk.
And yeah Victors has gotta snap out of it with his freaking Dad there safe and sound, the boy in white used up so much magic to make that happen, dont waste it!
And only way i can see a mix of science and magic if its aliens, their tech could be like magic but that imo would be goofy so most likely not
I think Randall saying there are worse things than dying ties back to when we see the three cicada prisoners chained to the wall like Martin. The first thing Martin asked for when Boyd found him was death.
Don't forget Randall tied Donna to a tree a few weeks ago almost causing her death, so he can't be mad at Boyd when he willingly decided to go outside to help. The monsters could kill all of them since there was no talisman in the ambulance.
Another clue we saw was the motel/hotel finally had a name! It was shown during the massacre recap by Victor. It was called Star Magic! In all other episodes the name of the place is missing.
In a previous episode showing young Victor, we were shown that Star Magic sign.
Absolutely love your work bro, big fan! But a lil bit of advice if I may, PLSSS… Try to keep the intros a lil shorter in the future 😊. Could sometimes be a turn off, otherwise tho great job AGAIN!!
Thanks for the advice! I'll think about it, I put timecodes all the times, so anyone can skip whatever they want)
great video, thanks!
I really hate Tabitha, I find her character unbearably annoying.
Love the rewind sound effects!!
I'm glad you mentioned the monster's clothing. In addition to inconsistencies with blood splatter, I've wondered how their clothing has survived decades of creeping through woods. The fabric should be in tatters.
The bandage on Randall's cheek also reminded me of Miranda's painting back in Maine. The only issue I see is that I don't see an ear piercing on him.
And, did you notice in the last episode how Fatima made a disgusted look when she smelled water? She is repelled by anything that life depends on, including the essential one, water.
The cow's blood on the milk man should have turned brown now instead of still being red.
Igor. Love your reviews.
My theory on Fatima not wanting to drink water.
From the previous episode when they autopsied a monster, it was completely dehydrated on the inside. If she or the baby are turning, they wouldn’t want any water.
@cawestification, good point.
Insane theory using Jim/Tabitha/Victor's dad bracelet:
They are the same people.
Victor's dad is Jim. Victor's mom is Tabitha. Ethan is Victor.
But from like a different timeline or something.
I dunno. Kinda dumb and I hope this isnt what they do, but man that bracelet is really fucking hard to make sense of. If it really has the same defect.
Unless they are magical items like Taran says and can teleport or something.
Definitely something to pay attention to o
@@kakalis2323 interesting. So
Henry = Jim
Amanda = Tabitha
Victor = Ethan
Eloise = Julie
The boy in white = Thomas?
its so sweet and sad that he remembers all of them, and as a kid he wanted to keep their memory alive😢
Fantastic job bro 👏
You need to make a shirt with your slogan " I notice, I share" I would buy one for sure!
Just in case if you missed it, Wikipedia says that From is a science fiction show. (Well, Lost, too)
I checked some other shows that are kinda similar, and Yellowjackets is a thriller drama, Wayward Pines - also science fiction, 1988 - mystery science fiction, Dark - science fiction.
So, From should definitely have some kind of “scientific” explanation to it in the future
Anybody can edit Wikipedia tho.. not sure how reliable that is
But good catch
@@ElizRued well, yes, they can. But you need to have pretty good public proofs to write something there. I worked on a project once and we were trying to create a wiki page for a legit company and it still wasn’t approved due to lack of articles about it (and we had dozens of them)
Black smoke monster in lost was suposed to be a cloud of nanomachine at first that why he make electric sound wrtters changed they mind to much hope they dont do that in from...
Great job 👏 👍
The idea that everything is mechanical and controlled, somehow makes sense that the puppet would be able to talk and move because something is able to control things and animate them
if the watch was still running when he took it off Mr Dead Guy then that explains why it's different in the suitcase, otherwise yes a continuity error, although this doesnt seem like the kind of show that makes continuity errors
Igor! I've been enjoying your videos for some time now. Every video that comes out is better than the previous. I'm curious, what are some of your favorite streamers/games? Keep up the awesome stuff 👍🏻
Thanks!
Love your videos and the way you see things in the background and try to point them out.
Thank you so much Sarah!
Your obsession with time in the show and infinity symbols is very funny 🤣
They’re Slaugh fae fairies
It just makes soooo much sense
Explains the crows (better than the Odin thing cause like common)
Slaughter fairies are able to turn into crows and teleport people to a pocket dimension that can accessed from anywhere but once youre taken by a slaugh you can’t escape their little pocket world. (Sounds familiar)
The stone circle in the middle of town is quite literally a fairy circle.
Dark fairies (what slaugh are)
Tend to pretend to be human, they enjoy torture and derive pleasure from other peoples suffering. (Sound familiar)
They also like to use and collect human items to learn more about them and better deceive them.
They use trees to teleport from their world to ours (sounds familiar)
There’s a lot a lot more
(Look up them up it’s just “from dark fae theory” there’s a Reddit theory that goes deep into the exploration)
When I first looked up dark fairy lore after watching this show I was shocked by how many elements matched up. If it's not all fae then they have to play a significant role for whatever else is controlling Fromville
Ethan mentions faeries too in one of his stories in the very first episode
Jasper and Jade are both precious stone names. Although they are of different color and mineral composition, so no connection here. But that Jade sees Jasper and only two of them have gemstone names can't be a coincidence, imo.
Igor: regarding houses looking alike, (the Sara/Victor scene) in Chicago, we have a "Bungalow Belt". Almost ever house built in the 50s, two windows in triangles on the second floor for the expensive ones, one window for the cheaper one. I think the town is/was a company town. Example. we had a town called Argo because everyone worked for Argo Ham. That's long gone, the town is now called Summit and has another thirty streets attached. If you look at that one street,that is a company town. That taller building with al the windows, near the gas station, I would actually call that rooming house. For single people. I think that whatever company the town was based around is gone, because the turn is in the road. It would be in ruins, but if this were the case, I'd just be curious about the town. A factory likely.
I recently uncovered a significant clue that Jack Bender placed all the way back in Season 1. The realization gave me chills-it’s clear it was carefully hidden, and it may be the key to understanding much more. i will release 17th Oct 2024 .
Tabitha was worried about reaching the town before dark. It takes a while to make that full loop so turning around would get them there after dark
Tabitha after getting out of ambulance and seeing the tree:
-Just when I thought I was out... THEY PULL ME BACK IN
Card on tillies deck was the Two of Swords, means stalemate. Also the only witch named Tillie was in a book called "Wicked Witches of the Midwest" and she was a mischievous and powerful witch.
It's quite possible Eloise died before Miranda and Victor got to Fromville🤔 Would explain why Henry hasn't really mentioned her.
@@iamnwb I thought about that too great theory
We see Eloise in the flashback hiding with Victor though
@@ikimeht yes, but from Victors perspective. Could have been a (his) coping mechanism.
Geekadamy, I just thought you might like to know that pica is pronounced with a hard “I” sound. (Like: pike-ah)😉
The picture of pinned hands may be what Boyd saw when martin and the other 3 were chained up in that place
I wasn’t expecting the beginning 😂😂😂😂😂😂
One thing I noticed about boyds seen with the female cop is that it seems similar to what happened with his wife in the town when she shot up everyone. And that combined with what just happened made him snap on her.
Plus she handcuffed Tabitha to the ambulance and then ran off with the keys, abandoning her surrounded by monsters. I'm more mad at her for that than for accidentally shooting someone who thought it was a good idea to stand in a window and watch a gunfight
That cop looks really similar to Boyds wife. I assumed the physical appearance I what triggered him.
"finally they are talking to each other"
They have been already, off screen.
Then followed by, "I don't know why they are showing them telling people when we already saw it happen."
This is the stupidity of that judgment.
We can see that in one of Victor's drawing there's broken glass on the ground with some blood I think. Maybe it's connected to the story Sarah was telling her brother about the girl with the broken glass in season 1. Also the reincarnation theory makes a lot of sense to me. That the chosen one always returns. Also, the bracelet is a huge clue. Tabitha made it for her husband cause she is a reincarnation of Miranda and Miranda found an identical one in fromville from the chosen one before her. It maybe also connected to the dates written in the lighthouse. I think the date Miranda died and the date Tabitha was born are connected. This theory suggests that these vision are not actually just visions but memories of past lives. They have to remember where they came FROM.
from is Roanoke. Don't bully my boy's Victor drawing abilities, he may not draw but he can throw some hands okay lol ? XD
I'm not sure about Jasper as just a name, but in the bible is really meant as a stone:
Revelation 21:19 (KJV): "And the foundations of the wall of the city were garnished with all manner of precious stones. The first foundation was jasper; the second, sapphire; the third, a chalcedony; the fourth, an emerald;"
Exodus 28:20 (KJV): "And the fourth row shall be a beryl, and an onyx, and a jasper: they shall be set in gold in their in closings."
Not sure if this means anything?
Jade is a stone, there is a type of marble called Elgin and pearls are also shown in many scenes. Many gemstones and similar materials in this show!
The last two episodes of this season are “Revelations part 1” and “revelations part 2” so super interesting connection imo
@geekademy Jasper's scream reminds me of how the monsters scream when they have live hunt initiated.
It could be Thomas though.
I know he died as a baby in the real world, but he died because of a phone call. It might've been the evil force from the town on the other side of that line.
Or it might've been one of the tower kids trying to lure Tabitha into town so that she could free them since Miranda failed to do so.
That phone call set a chain reaction in motion.
1) Thomas dies
2) Jim and Tabitha can't process the grief and decide to divorce
3) They take the kids on a trip in the RV for one last family vacation together before telling the kids about the divorce
4) On their trip they encounter that tree in the road, which leads them to fromville
This whole chunk of events could imply that the evil thing or the tower kids had a connection to the Mathews family (An ancestral connection and litterally a direct phone line to their household in the real world.)
I think the town is a place where dimensions clash.
Sure, the timeline in Fromville matches the one in the real world for the people who end up there, but the town itself has multiple dimensions in it where time is of little meaning. There are night creatures from the 50s, ghosts, weird apparitions from the civil war, tower kids, illusions, etc.
So Thomas is dead in the real world but his ghost might be trapped in that tower in fromville along with the other kids. He died as a baby but his ghost takes an older apparition of a helpful boy in white, around Ethan's age (he visits him and Tabitha quite a lot and he guides them).
Before the Mathews family, there was Victor's family.
What if Miranda and Henry had a baby son too and he died like Thomas?
Could it explain Henry's alcohol abuse and problems with Miranda?
She took off with the Eloise and Victor because something/someone was calling to her (tower kids).
Miranda saw this coming since the day they dropped acid under that tree and she told Henry about it all these years but he wouldn't believe her.
She'd try to make sense of it by drawing what she saw that day (in the basement - which is for the secrets as Victor told Sarah in this episode).
Years later, when her baby died as her acid visions predicted, Miranda pissed at Henry for not believing her, took the car and the kids and drove to the tree where her acid visions began.
She didn't make it to the tree because there was another one blocking the road.
They end up in Fromville and it all goes south.
Victor is alone after "his mom dies and everyone dies" as he puts it. But he's not completely alone.
The boy in white guides him and keeps him company. It might be the spirit of his dead baby brother appearing as a boy around Victor's age to help him survive the town.
It's the same apparition of a boy in white for Ethan and Victor but it's 2 different spirits from 2 different timelines - Thomas and Unknown.
Maybe it's not Thomas on the phone with Jim, but he exists in this town one way or another.
The foreshadowing in first season gives it away when Ethan says that Thomas is on his own quest.
That's my theory sofar.
Just an add-on:
Miranda and the kids didn't make it to the tree where it all began so Tabitha and Henry weren't going to make it either - I'm obviously drawing parallels here.
The road from Henry's house to that special "original" tree has an intersection with the other dimension where the town exists. That's why both (Tabitha and Henry and Miranda and the kids) couldn't make it to the tree.
There might be dimensional intersections like this throughout the states. Roads that might lead to special "original" trees that connect the real world with the place that traps the souls of dead kids/unfortunate deaths.
The roads are blocked by the evil force so that no one can reach this place and traps them in this so called town. It's a trap where dimensions bleed into each other.
How do you know Henry abuses alcohol?
@@mandolyn He was carrying a sixpack early in the day when Tabitha showed up.
Usually it wouldn't mean much, but the writers specifically chose to show him carrying beer.
Introducing a character to the audience this way always has a meaning.
Plus, his wife Miranda made the bottle tree by their house with various empty, alcoholic bottles.
There are other clues as well but that would take even longer to elaborate.
@reynam2576 a six pack after work or whatever doesn't prove alcohism. If it's a thirty pack, maybe, but that's really gasping. He coulldve started drinking after because of depression. Miranda could've been a drinker before ,we don't know
@@mandolyn Did you not read my comment?
It's very disturbing to see Fatima licking blood off Nicki's corpse. I can still accept if she likes to eat rotten foods, but enjoying blood or corpse as food, is definitely Unacceptable in any way.
The monstors were following orders by the bigger entity. The Entity knew that Boyd and the Matthews had to drive away from Randall, so Randall could see that and remember. Then they left him super damaged, but alive. That creates division. So maybe Randall won't talk about the habits and patterns of the creature again. That's why she gave him the keys.
That flashlight could be a connection to Boyd's torch. When he used that torch from the otherworld, he was able to access it again. Also, Victor, Tabby, and Jade all accessed the Underworld (the caves) with a torch, the flashlight. Although I don't think Tabitha needs one since she's is primordial fire. Tabiti is the goddess name. That's why I think she has to light a fire to save the children.
The comments about the drawings Ethan was looking at had me spit my drink 😂
Great video by the way🫶
I love your reviews lol also,
What discord are you in?
Why do you think the town waited for so long to have new residents? I need to know more about Victor's lost years.
Is the sound that the doll is making the same sound as the creatures screams?
The red lamps in the jasper section appear to be the same (sarah tied in basement & Christopher/jasper scenes). Most likely an insignificant coincidence
@@chrismccullough6428 maybe not
Your point about seeing the infinity symbol everywhere popped into my head when I was re-looking at a picture of some of the toys/cards on the stairs in the lighthouse/tower scene before the boy in white pushes Tabitha out of the window. I've been wracking my brain about the significance of the numbers 4 & 7 and always go back to the fact that there are three cards - a 4 of hearts (red) and an 8 of clubs (black) with a 7 of diamonds or hearts (its red but you cannot see the suit) right underneath it. If you turn an infinity symbol 90 degrees, it's essentially an 8, is it not? In the image you used in your video of the breadbox, are those almost "clubs" on each end of the infinity symbol?! Just like the 8 of clubs on the stairs!
Separately, I think Tilly's card deck is bespoke and not one that you would find on the market in real life. I did notice that when she was getting ready to read Fatima's cards and holding the deck to her chest, the card at the bottom of the deck that was visible was the "Justice" card, which is usually card #8 in tarot.
I don't have any idea if there is any significance to this other than that, I too, am clearly losing my mind trying to find patterns LOL
Hey, we don't hear your signature music playing in the background! I like that music!
What do you think happens if you manage to get past the tree? could it be an away to avoid the 'curse'??
Jasper is on the TV screen and is showed behind Eljin like three times as he follows the Kamono girl out of the ktichen, even after he's bumped into and "wakes up", no longer seeing the ghost girl yet Jasper can still be seen on the TV as the man bumps into him.
Could be some kind of jammer or faraday cage type thing around the whole place. To block the satellite.
I personally think it's a pocket dimension, and will be pissed if it is not.
But just saying.
Mabuse might be the last name of someone who works on the show. Shows/movies like to do that type of thing sometimes
In season one Ethan tells the story about the lonely dragon collecting things that were considered trash to most but treasure to him and he ended up helping the cromenackle find their way home by giving her a map. In Henry’s house there’s a wood piece that says spitfire. I’ve been thinking he could be the lonely dragon and I know it sounds crazy but what if Cristopher is actually Henry and jasper was his puppet
The onion story goes with a lot of mythology and folklore. There was a Greek prince called Cromus. From Crommyon, which is Onion in Ancient Greek. He was a son of Poseidon. That actually make him a demigod, as well. I don't know much else yet. But in Game of Thrones, Ser Davos Seaworth, also known as The Onion Knight, was probably based on the myth. There's a character in Stephen Universe, apparently, that is inspired by the same myth. The name Gerber actually means tanner. I don't know the connection yet, but I bet onion juice could be used for leather preparation. I wonder if that character was a counterpart to Ellis. The story seems to be connected to Odysseus, too, though Poseidon hated him. But he was a captain on a ship.