All of the players named are super. I'm not sure together, in one band, they'd be super. You need chemistry. I can't imagine Elvis in the same group as Hendrix. As far as a super group goes, I'll take The Beatles.
That is so true. I do not think this would be a supergroup. Actually, too many virtuosos would spoil it. They would be vying for attention. Will there ever be another Beatles? I don't think so. The combination of voices and writing skill was unique. Add in their masterful playing which served the song, rather than ego, and the production talent of George Martin, and you have something very hard to replicate. Think how many top rate songs they wrote and put out. You've even got masterpieces that were never played live or put out as singles!
@@richardmortimer8147 They could probably do it for a couple of songs one night just like the humongous group of musicians that get on stage together at the Hall of Fame induction ceremonies every year.
If you replaced Ringo with Bonham, The Beatles wouldn't have worked. If you replaced George with Jimi, The Beatles wouldn't have worked. Paul knows more than all of us that a group needs many things to thrive, and chemistry is a major factor.
Bonham's version is absolutely brilliant👍🏻i think it's cool he took time off for a minute from zep to work with Paul. Brilliant. And Billy Preston is another uncanny musician 🙏🏻 rest easy mates.
I would put in another super singer of all times. Steve Marriot of the Small Faces. BUT: Putting in musicians as members of a virtual super group is not putting a super group together. Maybe, they don't harmonize, personally. So the Beatles, the Rolling Stones, the Kinks, the Who, U2, Led Zeppelin were (are) supergroups as they were (are) musicians standing up and working together as a unit of musical friends.
Look, I’m not gonna argue with Paul McCartney. The only thing I can say is look at a lot of the super groups that got together and didn’t last very long……. I mean, the one that really comes to mind is blind faith, and they lasted one album… Even cream did it last that long….. It’s not easy
It is amazing that Cream lasted as long as they did. Baker was a violent sociopath and Bruce was a tough Glaswegian, who wouldn't put up with any nonsense. The brawling between Baker and Bruce backstage regularly reduced Clapton to tears. It is a wonder how they ever managed to get on stage together!
Based on singing, playing, songwriting, performing, UK Band Bass: Paul McCartney Guitar: John Lennon Drums: Phil Collins Keyboards: Elton John Lead Guitar: Jimmy Page/Eric Clapton/Pete Townsend Singer: Mick Jagger/Freddie Mercury US Band Bass: Brian Wilson Guitar: Bob Dylan/Paul Simon Drums: Don Henley Keyboards: Stevie Wonder/Billy Joel Lead Guitar: Jimi Hendrix Singer: Elvis Presley/Michael Jackson The categories with the slash are very close and could be either one on any given day
I totally agree, super musicians of totally different styles don't make a super group, as you say, it's a chemistry, can you imagine Hendrix playing Guitar for Elvis, Scotty would turn in his grave
It's funny that Billy Preston worked with John, George and Ringo on solo albums and even toured with George but never worked with Paul after the Beatles.
I would lean more towards songwriters/collaborators over virtuosity (though I love those guys as much as anybody does). I also think that backup vocal ability is huge, as is versatility, different influences, creative backgrounds and uniqueness. I expanded it from five because... well I could... but I tried to get everybody in that belonged. - Lead Vox: Ann Wilson - monster vocalist, good songwriter (adds a flute option and gets a female influence in here also). - Lead/rhythm guitars (swap back and forth): Jimmy Page - THE best combinatiion of songwriter, versatile musician and band leader. David Gilmour - songwriter, versatility, backing vox. - Bass: Chris Squire - unique, distinctive bass playing, songwriter, great backing vocalist. - Acoustic guitar: Paul McCartney - had to work him in because of the songwriting and vocals. - Piano: Elton John - songwriting and vocals again. - Keys: Keith Emerson - THE electronic virtuoso of virtuosos. Good songwriter, great classical interpreter. - Drums: Alan White - rocks great but more versatile than Bonham while adding backing vox and some songwriting. - Percussion - Ray Cooper: THE maestro of ALL percussion maestros. - Lyrics - Bernie Taupin: nobody else even remotely close (not Dylan, not the Fab Four even if all are combined)
What I would give to have an album from a creative session of these giants of music history!! And with Paul McCartney’s endorsement, the gold becomes platinum within nanoseconds!!! Just the thought brings joy to the soul!!!
@@rmongiovi He did say All-Time and not living. That's why the title of this video is HIS DREAM SUPERGROUP. I also don't know why the h-e-double toothpicks you replied to me and said that comment.
There’s only one bass player I’d put before McCartney & his name is Herbie Flowers. He was the biggest session player in Britain & also formed “ Blue Mink”. Played that bass line on “ Take a walk on the wild side” & played on so many great records it’s not funny. Including the best tracks on Elton John’s “ Tumbleweed Connection” album. Have a listen to his bass playing on Elton’s “ Country Comfort”, it’s mind blowing & not unlike McCartney’s own bass playing. Full of the melody & tastefulness!
Absolutely!!!! Paul McCartney is the melody bassist of all time, John Entwhistle is the killer bassist technically of all time (excluding the slapping community). He did BASS like classical guitar!!!
Drums: John Bonham Keys: Billy Preston Bass: John Entwistle Guitar: Jimi Hendrix Vox: Elvis Presley For keys I would tap Jon Lord, and for the voice... Elvis would be a hell of a frontman, but I gotta go with Paul McCartney himself. He can do tender ballads, goofy sing-a-longs, and hard Rock anthems. Throw on Golden Slumbers and he goes from one extreme to another in a single line. The kid's got talent. As for Bonzo, The Ox, and Jimi, hell yeah!
Yes, all the picks for his dream supergroup are perfectly logical; the trick, however, would be to do the arrangements so that they could play together *as a cohesive band* (not just everyone simultaneously soloing) To experience (no pun intended) what sort of original material they could come up with. . . that would be the aforementioned "dream"
Growing up a fan of sports in America you get used to looking at year-end All pro teams, All Star games and the like. About twenty years ago, after realizing the eraa of Rock n' Roll had passed, I made an All Star lineup involving positions
Bonzo and The Ox were both considered as early members of Jimmy Page's "new Yardbirds" group that became Led Zeppelin. In fact that name was first proposed by Entwistle.
Macca and The Ox are neck and neck in my eyes as the greatest bass players I have ever heard in Rock. Elvis,although great is of a different style than the rest and I do not know how well he would fit.
Two hypothetical supergroups I’d like to see, with living members, would be Paul and Ringo with the current Rolling Stones lineup, and/or Paul and Ringo with Jeff Lyne and Todd Rundgren, playing Beatles songs.
Billy Shepherd--the spitting image of Phil Ackrill of Denny Laine And The Diplomats. Also looks just like Vivian Stanshall. Silly Willy with the Philly Band. Ooo-Wee!
I wish he only used current musicians in this exercise. Personally I would go with his own Abe Laborial Jr. as the drummer. He is a powerful and mighty drummer. Entwistle hell yes. Total agreement there. Torn on the rest of the band.
And my comment got added when I wasn't finished. It was about the SIX positions in my All Time Band based on everything they did, and not how they would play together. The sixth position is the 2nd guitarist which was both fairly common, but also just a blaay to get one more
would have loved to seen what the Beatles with Dave Clark and Brian Wilson in the band could produce, today's ultra super group; Paul McCartney, Bill Bailey, Buckethead, El Estepario Siberiano
While all his choices are exceptional, I'm disappointed he didn't choose any of his old mates from Liverpool. You can't possibly have a more "SuperGroup" then The Beatles. To me, it's as if he dismissed them as inferior.
They'd need another guy, though, because there are five killer performers, but no killer songwriter. They'd need Paul - rhythm guitar, piano, and bass when John was playing horns.
I was totally onboard with this band idea ... until the vocalist was revealed. You'd need someone better-versed in Experimental Rock and Rock Fusion, IMO. Because - I think - that sort of music is probably what would work best for this combination of talent.
The same dude that the media reported as deceased for two weeks straight, which then suddenly reverted, claiming he was brought back to life. I'm sure the same media have beachfront property for sale in Nebraska as well 😂
"I Saw Her Standing There" was the first one that came to mind. It's been done a lot of times involving Paul in one shape or another. I can imagine Elvis giving it a try.
Paul must have always wanted some non wimp cred to be in an acid rock, hard rock, pioneers of metal with blues traits kinda band. He coulda easily picked Joe Walsh or Rick Derringer guitar , Geddy Lee Bass, Richard Carpenter or Edgar Winter keys Brad Delp or Karen Carpenter Vocals and the awesome Dino Danelli on Drums.,.. sounds like people who would never get togther for the most part but this lineup woulda written some unreal songs and played em like a huirricaine live. He coulda named another band with Carol Kaye, Brian Wilson and Glenn Campbell, Billy Joel or Elton John for starters as well. I'm sure Paul respects all these people.
Paul has already had some experience with those music genres with one band. Songs like: acid rock: Tomorrow Never Knows hard rock: Revolution metal: Helter Skelter I'm pretty sure that The Beatles did some blues as well. He's even done disco with another band. (Wings' "Goodnight Tonight") Paul is a fan of all types of music. He's even done a couple of songs with Kanye West.
When He stood outside that curtain at the Paladium and sang his song all by himself he showed what a shit he was internally. Nothing has changed, he is still a good front man for what ever story he wants to tell.
I find it interesting that most members of this supergroup died of drugs or alcohol poisoning. Is that the cost of pushing yourself to be at the top of your craft?
@ yes.,worship at the feet of the great McCartney. Stop being a fanboy and open your eyes. Just because he’s a unique talent doesn’t mean he’s not a dick. He’s a liar and a pathetic rewriter of history. He took credit for stuff he didn’t do but only after John and George were dead. He’s a coward. But you feel free to kneel before him.
II don’t know who comes up with this BOT garbage but the idea Macca was ever humble is HILARIOUS considering ever since John’s death he’s inserted himself in songs and things he doesn’t belong or are beyond relevance. Than there is this “list” - what? Show me where he said this would be the supergroup he would make even as a fantasy? These guys are so NOT a potential group what utter BS. Macca and his massive ego has picked guys that have complimented him or he’s worked with with NO REGARD to whether they could play, what they would play together. We have to stop these Bot sites now.
I agree 100% about the first part. When John's songs became the coolest songs of all the Beatle's output Macca suddenly put himself into the process, which was a process he denied even 30 years after John died. But not anymore, now he was part of writing everything with John, which is of course utter BS because when you look at the distinction between what Lennon originally created and Macca did they are world's apart. And hardly a hint of anything "Lennon" in Macca's over 50 years of solo output. Macca was interviewed extensively in the late 70's about his role in John's songs - like how many did he really take part in. His answer? THREE. Now it's practically all of them. And John's not here to defend it nor George, who are both known to speak their minds. Ringo just plays along because that's his style.
The dream suprgroup has already been. Each the greatest, it's called Led Zeppelin! Greatest singer in a group, greatest guitarist, greatest bassist / multi instrument, greatest drummer! Greatest song ever! Boom, the chemistry definitely worked!
Great players sure but I'd bet they'd make a horrible group. It's like a bunch of individual star (soccer) football players making a terrible World Cup team.
Otis Blackwell was the real Elvis Presley. Elvis actually took his style and voice. Google him. I couldn’t believe it. Then again, Elvis didn’t write songs, meaning not one. So what is Paul talking about?
@jcjcviews: Otis first wrote "Dont Be Cruel" and made a demo for it - this was followed by Elvis, which was also in the spirit of the composer: "I thought they did justice to the songs. They put the kind of feeling into it that I felt'". But Elvis was already well known before this hit and didn't need otis to learn to sing! In addition, Otis earned a lot from the success that Elvis achieved with his compositions!
@kin_the_t We may have seen different videos. But for me, having grown up in Charleston and Yazoo City, my relatives were in the juke joint business. So there’s that. In the video I saw, one has to pick. Did Elvis sound like this first, or was it Blackwell? To me, the two sound almost identical. Happenstance? As for Rock and Roll and who made the money, if that’s what you mean by “success,” Keith Richards of the Rolling Stones is worth half a billion dollars. Keith Richards! But then there are the Beatles, Led Zepplin, and countless others living fat. No, I think having some compositions, compared to the output of the unrecognized and unpaid for me, just doesn’t cut it. The “loot” is a great robbery and should be shared. Not an Elvis hater. Thanks for the feedback. jcjcviews. Happy Holidays
Who is narrating this thing? Is the flat banal voice devoid of anything remotely resembling inflection supposed to add something to the subject material?
McCartney was already in the Supergroup. It don't get any better than the Beatles.
Spot on.
All of the players named are super. I'm not sure together, in one band, they'd be super. You need chemistry. I can't imagine Elvis in the same group as Hendrix. As far as a super group goes, I'll take The Beatles.
Travelling Wilburys for me
I thought that when looking at this, he's played live with Gilmour before and I think he would be a better choice in this.
That is so true. I do not think this would be a supergroup. Actually, too many virtuosos would spoil it. They would be vying for attention. Will there ever be another Beatles? I don't think so. The combination of voices and writing skill was unique. Add in their masterful playing which served the song, rather than ego, and the production talent of George Martin, and you have something very hard to replicate. Think how many top rate songs they wrote and put out. You've even got masterpieces that were never played live or put out as singles!
@@richardmortimer8147 They could probably do it for a couple of songs one night just like the humongous group of musicians that get on stage together at the Hall of Fame induction ceremonies every year.
If you replaced Ringo with Bonham, The Beatles wouldn't have worked. If you replaced George with Jimi, The Beatles wouldn't have worked. Paul knows more than all of us that a group needs many things to thrive, and chemistry is a major factor.
Great musicians are great musicians. They do have to get along though.
He’s referring Bonham not to the Beatles, but to his Wings.
Supergroup - The Travelling Wilburys, they gelled well, no over powering egos, just 4 guys having fun making music
There were 5 guys in the Travelling Wilburys
@@johnpearce3033there were four guys, and then there was Roy Orbison.
@@Sherwoody The other four were in awe of Roy Orbison.
I'd be happy with McCartney on bass
Bonham's version is absolutely brilliant👍🏻i think it's cool he took time off for a minute from zep to work with Paul. Brilliant. And Billy Preston is another uncanny musician 🙏🏻 rest easy mates.
McCartney died in 1966. This man is William Campbell.
I would put in another super singer of all times. Steve Marriot of the Small Faces. BUT: Putting in musicians as members of a virtual super group is not putting a super group together. Maybe, they don't harmonize, personally. So the Beatles, the Rolling Stones, the Kinks, the Who, U2, Led Zeppelin were (are) supergroups as they were (are) musicians standing up and working together as a unit of musical friends.
Drums: John Bonham (Led Zeppelin)
Keyboards: Billy Preston
Bass: John Entwistle (The Who)
Guitar: Jimi Hendrix
Vocals: Elvis Presley
Look, I’m not gonna argue with Paul McCartney. The only thing I can say is look at a lot of the super groups that got together and didn’t last very long……. I mean, the one that really comes to mind is blind faith, and they lasted one album… Even cream did it last that long….. It’s not easy
It is amazing that Cream lasted as long as they did. Baker was a violent sociopath and Bruce was a tough Glaswegian, who wouldn't put up with any nonsense. The brawling between Baker and Bruce backstage regularly reduced Clapton to tears. It is a wonder how they ever managed to get on stage together!
Thank god Paul is a fan of music and isn’t jaded enough not to answer this as a music geek.✌️
Based on singing, playing, songwriting, performing,
UK Band
Bass: Paul McCartney
Guitar: John Lennon
Drums: Phil Collins
Keyboards: Elton John
Lead Guitar: Jimmy Page/Eric Clapton/Pete Townsend
Singer: Mick Jagger/Freddie Mercury
US Band
Bass: Brian Wilson
Guitar: Bob Dylan/Paul Simon
Drums: Don Henley
Keyboards: Stevie Wonder/Billy Joel
Lead Guitar: Jimi Hendrix
Singer: Elvis Presley/Michael Jackson
The categories with the slash are very close and could be either one on any given day
I totally agree, super musicians of totally different styles don't make a super group, as you say, it's a chemistry, can you imagine Hendrix playing Guitar for Elvis, Scotty would turn in his grave
It's funny that Billy Preston worked with John, George and Ringo on solo albums and even toured with George but never worked with Paul after the Beatles.
Lee Sklar, Rick Wakeman, Alan White, Trevor Rabin, Greg Lake
I would've picked Chris Squire for bass.
Great choices. Thanks Paul.
A Hall of Fame All Star Rock 'n Roll Band... WHOA!!!
I would lean more towards songwriters/collaborators over virtuosity (though I love those guys as much as anybody does). I also think that backup vocal ability is huge, as is versatility, different influences, creative backgrounds and uniqueness. I expanded it from five because... well I could... but I tried to get everybody in that belonged.
- Lead Vox: Ann Wilson - monster vocalist, good songwriter (adds a flute option and gets a female influence in here also).
- Lead/rhythm guitars (swap back and forth): Jimmy Page - THE best combinatiion of songwriter, versatile musician and band leader. David Gilmour - songwriter, versatility, backing vox.
- Bass: Chris Squire - unique, distinctive bass playing, songwriter, great backing vocalist.
- Acoustic guitar: Paul McCartney - had to work him in because of the songwriting and vocals.
- Piano: Elton John - songwriting and vocals again.
- Keys: Keith Emerson - THE electronic virtuoso of virtuosos. Good songwriter, great classical interpreter.
- Drums: Alan White - rocks great but more versatile than Bonham while adding backing vox and some songwriting.
- Percussion - Ray Cooper: THE maestro of ALL percussion maestros.
- Lyrics - Bernie Taupin: nobody else even remotely close (not Dylan, not the Fab Four even if all are combined)
He's got a Hell of a Band!
What I would give to have an album from a creative session of these giants of music history!! And with Paul McCartney’s endorsement, the gold becomes platinum within nanoseconds!!! Just the thought brings joy to the soul!!!
A mega supergroup. You can't go wrong with any of the choices. Thanks for the video.
Well, being alive would be a plus, wouldn't it?
@@rmongiovi He did say All-Time and not living. That's why the title of this video is HIS DREAM SUPERGROUP.
I also don't know why the h-e-double toothpicks you replied to me and said that comment.
There’s only one bass player I’d put before McCartney & his name is Herbie Flowers. He was the biggest session player in Britain & also formed “ Blue Mink”. Played that bass line on “ Take a walk on the wild side” & played on so many great records it’s not funny. Including the best tracks on Elton John’s “ Tumbleweed Connection” album. Have a listen to his bass playing on Elton’s “ Country Comfort”, it’s mind blowing & not unlike McCartney’s own bass playing. Full of the melody & tastefulness!
Absolutely!!!! Paul McCartney is the melody bassist of all time, John Entwhistle is the killer bassist technically of all time (excluding the slapping community). He did BASS like classical guitar!!!
Drums: John Bonham
Keys: Billy Preston
Bass: John Entwistle
Guitar: Jimi Hendrix
Vox: Elvis Presley
For keys I would tap Jon Lord, and for the voice... Elvis would be a hell of a frontman, but I gotta go with Paul McCartney himself. He can do tender ballads, goofy sing-a-longs, and hard Rock anthems. Throw on Golden Slumbers and he goes from one extreme to another in a single line. The kid's got talent. As for Bonzo, The Ox, and Jimi, hell yeah!
Yes, all the picks for his dream supergroup are perfectly logical; the trick, however, would be to do the arrangements so that they could play together *as a cohesive band* (not just everyone simultaneously soloing)
To experience (no pun intended) what sort of original material they could come up with. . . that would be the aforementioned "dream"
Spot on, totally agree!
Five indisputably great musicians, pretty sure they would absolutely suck as a band
Entwistle, Hendrix and Bonham could be a killer trio, though, and I'm pretty sure a Presley/Preston collab would be pretty happening, too
Growing up a fan of sports in America you get used to looking at year-end All pro teams, All Star games and the like. About twenty years ago, after realizing the eraa of Rock n' Roll had passed, I made an All Star lineup involving positions
I must have missed the memo about the passing of Rock 'n' Roll... Never mind.
Bonzo and The Ox were both considered as early members of Jimmy Page's "new Yardbirds" group that became Led Zeppelin. In fact that name was first proposed by Entwistle.
I guess I heard the wrong rumor. I always thought that their name came from a quip by Keith Moon: That will go over like a lead balloon.
I knew he would pick Hendrix. You'd get a ton of controversy no matter who you named best guitarist all time, but you'd get the least with Hendrix.
Macca and The Ox are neck and neck in my eyes as the greatest bass players I have ever heard in Rock. Elvis,although great is of a different style than the rest and I do not know how well he would fit.
I agree with Sir Paul on everything! Cool.😊
that for me would be the perfic band, loved the vid, most excellent.
Cream was a supergroup that made great music and despised each other.
What a killer line-up would've been. I agree 100%. Unfortunately all those guys have passed away. One could only image what could've been
AI one day?
I wonder is it possible to put their talents together using AI.
@@Muller-s5f The TCB band did a tour a bunch of years ago and performed with a hologram of Elvis so why not try AI.
I will say it now, electric ladyland is one of the best albums ever. In concept and in playing
Two hypothetical supergroups I’d like to see, with living members, would be Paul and Ringo with the current Rolling Stones lineup, and/or Paul and Ringo with Jeff Lyne and Todd Rundgren, playing Beatles songs.
Jeff Buckley on vocals, Chris Squire on bass would be contenders as well.
Much as I would hate to argue with Paul McCartney on his selection, the one I would dispute is Elvis. In his place, I would put Roy Orbison.
It's funny to learn after all these years that Paul was a Zeppelin fan and ranked Bonzo as the best.
They did a super group of 5 when Billy joined the Beatles in the Get Back sections.
Billy Shepherd--the spitting image of Phil Ackrill of Denny Laine And The Diplomats. Also looks just like Vivian Stanshall. Silly Willy with the Philly Band. Ooo-Wee!
Individually brilliant but as a band, a holy mess.
I was thinking exactly the same!
Would love to see someone with great A-I chops piece together that group doing "Suspicious Minds."
Pretty soon, we will have musical AI tools that will be able to emulate that supergroup playing together.
I would have liked to see that band play.
I wish he only used current musicians in this exercise. Personally I would go with his own Abe Laborial Jr. as the drummer. He is a powerful and mighty drummer. Entwistle hell yes. Total agreement there. Torn on the rest of the band.
The whole Laborial family are fabulous musicians!
@ Indeed!
please level all the volume of the voices .... or use a compressor please NICE VIDEO ANYWAY !!!! :)
And my comment got added when I wasn't finished. It was about the SIX positions in my All Time Band based on everything they did, and not how they would play together. The sixth position is the 2nd guitarist which was both fairly common, but also just a blaay to get one more
would have loved to seen what the Beatles with Dave Clark and Brian Wilson in the band could produce,
today's ultra super group; Paul McCartney, Bill Bailey, Buckethead, El Estepario Siberiano
In ten years, when Paul has passed on, AI will deliver us an original song performed by Paul's super group.
While all his choices are exceptional, I'm disappointed he didn't choose any of his old mates from Liverpool. You can't possibly have a more "SuperGroup" then The Beatles. To me, it's as if he dismissed them as inferior.
AI will probably do this at some point in the future.
Hendrix would have never blended into a real band. His style was up front and in your face on everything. Hendrix was just a pure solo player.
tom petty singer, ric ocasek rhythm guitar, satriani lead, howard jones keyboards, drums bonham
Let's start with Enswhistle and Bonham, and find other suitable musicians.
They'd need another guy, though, because there are five killer performers, but no killer songwriter.
They'd need Paul - rhythm guitar, piano, and bass when John was playing horns.
I would have picked Don Barnes of .38 Special, instead of Elvis, but that's just me.
This Super Group could happen if we can just Time travel back to 1969 or 1970.
I agree on all of Paul's choices except for lead singer, which should go to Freddie Mercury.
A.I .will bring it to life. But be care full
One day soon, AI will be making songs from his supergroup.
Is it me or does Paul look like Brian Wilson in this shot?
I was totally onboard with this band idea ... until the vocalist was revealed. You'd need someone better-versed in Experimental Rock and Rock Fusion, IMO. Because - I think - that sort of music is probably what would work best for this combination of talent.
I will take the Traveling Wilburys over this any day
The same dude that the media reported as deceased for two weeks straight, which then suddenly reverted, claiming he was brought back to life. I'm sure the same media have beachfront property for sale in Nebraska as well 😂
With AI you could hear this supergroup
Wow, a lot of famous people! But it wouldn't have been my choice.
... and I wonder what songs this supergroup would have played ... and what role Paul would have taken ... (only composer?)
"I Saw Her Standing There" was the first one that came to mind. It's been done a lot of times involving Paul in one shape or another. I can imagine Elvis giving it a try.
Hm. I think Fogerty, Stills, McCartney, Winwood, would have been great.
I’ve heard Paul say Bonham was great but he didn’t always keep in time when live with Zeppelin.
Bonzo was overrated.
Saw led twice their records better than live
@@robertkelly6282 Zep great studio albums, but live shows, not very good.
Paul must have always wanted some non wimp cred to be in an acid rock, hard rock, pioneers of metal with blues traits kinda band. He coulda easily picked Joe Walsh or Rick Derringer guitar , Geddy Lee Bass, Richard Carpenter or Edgar Winter keys Brad Delp or Karen Carpenter Vocals and the awesome Dino Danelli on Drums.,.. sounds like people who would never get togther for the most part but this lineup woulda written some unreal songs and played em like a huirricaine live. He coulda named another band with Carol Kaye, Brian Wilson and Glenn Campbell, Billy Joel or Elton John for starters as well. I'm sure Paul respects all these people.
He definitely respects Brian Wilson
Paul has already had some experience with those music genres with one band. Songs like:
acid rock: Tomorrow Never Knows
hard rock: Revolution
metal: Helter Skelter
I'm pretty sure that The Beatles did some blues as well.
He's even done disco with another band. (Wings' "Goodnight Tonight")
Paul is a fan of all types of music. He's even done a couple of songs with Kanye West.
@@LouisSpeciale-vp9sl It was Brian Wilson who suggested that Paul write "Back in the USSR" like the Beach Boys did in "California Girls".
We don't really see and hear Paul stating it, thus it maybe the narrator's fantasy.
John Bonham
Rick Wright
Flea
Jimi Hendrix
Elvis Presley
there already was a dream supergroup, led zeppelin!
Another super group, just add Ritchie Blackmore to The Who.
Typical McCartney response. smh. He should have said the Beatles.
Ginger Baker on drums
Great drummer, horrible person. He would be brawling with the other members of the band backstage!
When He stood outside that curtain at the Paladium and sang his song all by himself he showed what a shit he was internally. Nothing has changed, he is still a good front man for what ever story he wants to tell.
Who? Tell us more.
@@007EnglishAcademy Clearly it happened before your time on this planet else you would know.
Some how I can't see Elvis and Hendrix.
As soon as I hear that stupid AI voice I exit out of the clip.
Hope you all enjoyed it
8:58 it's "ommazh" or "hommidge" - don't combine them
I find it interesting that most members of this supergroup died of drugs or alcohol poisoning. Is that the cost of pushing yourself to be at the top of your craft?
Characteristic humility??? Are you serious? Paul is the biggest egomaniac of all time.
He's a lot more humble than he needs to be.
@ yes.,worship at the feet of the great McCartney.
Stop being a fanboy and open your eyes. Just because he’s a unique talent doesn’t mean he’s not a dick.
He’s a liar and a pathetic rewriter of history. He took credit for stuff he didn’t do but only after John and George were dead. He’s a coward. But you feel free to kneel before him.
Are computers capable of making what is stated here?
II don’t know who comes up with this BOT garbage but the idea Macca was ever humble is HILARIOUS considering ever since John’s death he’s inserted himself in songs and things he doesn’t belong or are beyond relevance. Than there is this “list” - what? Show me where he said this would be the supergroup he would make even as a fantasy? These guys are so NOT a potential group what utter BS. Macca and his massive ego has picked guys that have complimented him or he’s worked with with NO REGARD to whether they could play, what they would play together. We have to stop these Bot sites now.
I agree 100% about the first part. When John's songs became the coolest songs of all the Beatle's output Macca suddenly put himself into the process, which was a process he denied even 30 years after John died. But not anymore, now he was part of writing everything with John, which is of course utter BS because when you look at the distinction between what Lennon originally created and Macca did they are world's apart. And hardly a hint of anything "Lennon" in Macca's over 50 years of solo output. Macca was interviewed extensively in the late 70's about his role in John's songs - like how many did he really take part in. His answer? THREE. Now it's practically all of them. And John's not here to defend it nor George, who are both known to speak their minds. Ringo just plays along because that's his style.
The dream suprgroup has already been. Each the greatest, it's called Led Zeppelin! Greatest singer in a group, greatest guitarist, greatest bassist / multi instrument, greatest drummer! Greatest song ever! Boom, the chemistry definitely worked!
Humility ??? McCartney. ? You have to be joking 🤣
Considering his position in the music world, he is still pretty down to earth talking to people.
@@stevebarlow3154 My brother met Paul a couple of months before the pandemic and would say the same thing.
Could this narrator sound less interested in his subject?
Jon Lord was better on Keys.
The only truly immortal vocalist is Freddie Mercury - Sir Paul should have chosen him instead of overrated Elvis.
Wasn't wings a super group???
Great players sure but I'd bet they'd make a horrible group. It's like a bunch of individual star (soccer) football players making a terrible World Cup team.
That is some group, can we get them together please 😁👍
My five: Neil Peart, Rick Wakeman, John Entwistle, Edward Van Halen, Robert Plant.
Otis Blackwell was the real Elvis Presley. Elvis actually took his style and voice. Google him. I couldn’t believe it. Then again, Elvis didn’t write songs, meaning not one. So what is Paul talking about?
@jcjcviews: Otis first wrote "Dont Be Cruel" and made a demo for it - this was followed by Elvis, which was also in the spirit of the composer: "I thought they did justice to the songs. They put the kind of feeling into it that I felt'". But Elvis was already well known before this hit and didn't need otis to learn to sing! In addition, Otis earned a lot from the success that Elvis achieved with his compositions!
@kin_the_t We may have seen different videos. But for me, having grown up in Charleston and Yazoo City, my relatives were in the juke joint business. So there’s that.
In the video I saw, one has to pick. Did Elvis sound like this first, or was it Blackwell? To me, the two sound almost identical. Happenstance?
As for Rock and Roll and who made the money, if that’s what you mean by “success,” Keith Richards of the Rolling Stones is worth half a billion dollars. Keith Richards!
But then there are the Beatles, Led Zepplin, and countless others living fat.
No, I think having some compositions, compared to the output of the unrecognized and unpaid for me, just doesn’t cut it.
The “loot” is a great robbery and should be shared.
Not an Elvis hater. Thanks for the feedback. jcjcviews. Happy Holidays
And here's Elvis and Bonham together. ua-cam.com/video/u5rHrD9eja0/v-deo.html
What a waste of time. Is this AI?
It would be Elvis and his backup band.
Who is narrating this thing? Is the flat banal voice devoid of anything remotely resembling inflection supposed to add something to the subject material?
1) AI.
2) No, but unlike voiceover work done by a human, it's free.
@@alanedmonds4272 You get what you pay for, and AI narrated clips should be disallowed.