Low-carb vs. High-carb: Which Diet Is Better? I Simon Hill x Rich Roll

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 65

  • @jansmith3158
    @jansmith3158 2 роки тому +3

    Just watch yt Dr Berg, Dr Eckberg, Dr Mindy Pelz, Dr Ken Berry about keto and why you should not worry about Cholesterol. Watch also their vids on health fats and butter. Read the comments on their keto and carnivore diet vids.

    • @pearljam_1
      @pearljam_1 5 місяців тому +3

      Berg 😂. A chiropractor… ya let’s not worry about thousands of studies that link LDL with CVD. Keep watching quacks like that and see what happens to your body in 10 years.

    • @timothykowalewski3943
      @timothykowalewski3943 2 місяці тому

      Charlatans, all of em. No thanks

  • @khampafitness
    @khampafitness 2 роки тому

    What’s your opinion of Bruce Kimball now?

  • @qrockz007
    @qrockz007 2 роки тому +14

    why does rich roll not invite paul saladino and have a discussion? seems like rich does only invite ppl with the same perspective

    • @TenTempeh
      @TenTempeh 2 роки тому +9

      Saladino is kind of delusional. Carnivore Diet is nonsense as a lifestyle. From what I've seen of him, he isn't really bright so I would have no interest in inviting him. Let him go to Rogan's podcast, its more suited to him.

    • @qrockz007
      @qrockz007 2 роки тому +3

      @@TenTempeh lol, just ur opinion and no arguments.

    • @TenTempeh
      @TenTempeh 2 роки тому +1

      @@qrockz007 ok bro, believe what you want. I have plenty of arguments. But it's pretty obvious, so...

    • @pippilotta3511
      @pippilotta3511 2 роки тому +3

      Saladino isn’t a good example of the carnivore diet because he adds carbs - fruit and honey. He also changes his mind a lot and isn’t really a reliable source of information since he’s only experimenting on himself. There are some great doctors though who’d be interesting guests for this podcast like Dr. Chaffee (who’s about the same age as Rich Roll and looks two decades younger) or Nina Teicholz (a journalist) or Gary Taubes, Tim Noaks etc. Those are the most interesting conversations rather than being in an echo chamber at all times about nutrition. In my opinion the one thing that Rich Roll doesn’t get quite right. He’s amazing every other way (that I know of).

    • @yl1487
      @yl1487 2 роки тому +2

      Yes. Agreed. Second that, Rich has been happy to generate an echo chamber around himself, with what I hope may simply be an unintentional tendency to unconsciously skirt around any voices of dissent ... or otherwise what might be divergent thinking - at least from his perspective. Good thing to encourage him to remain open, curious, broaden his intellectual horizons rather than entrap himself in a deep dogmatic dungeon.
      If you might please let me add Peter Dobromylskyj (of Hyperlipid renown) to this discussion idea. Peace.

  • @pippilotta3511
    @pippilotta3511 2 роки тому +12

    Statins don’t help overall longevity. High cholesterol is a good thing. The higher the cholesterol the lower the all cause mortality. They got this one upside down. Fat is good for us. Sugar is bad - it raises triglycerides and causes inflammation in the body. Any carb is turned into sugar in your body.
    You won’t get a heart attack with low triglycerides. Whoever is worried about their risk for heart disease should have a calcium scan. I’ve been eating an animal based diet for the most part of my life. Keto and low carb. My calcium scan is zero and my triglycerides low. There’s literally no chance I will get a heart attack anytime soon. And I am 52 years old.

    • @yl1487
      @yl1487 2 роки тому +2

      Brings up my memory of David Diamond's admission of his own hypertriglyceridemia ... even that dealt with effectively by a low carbohydrate approach.
      Let's appreciate the fact that the significance of Philip Randle's work is revealed in multiple, surprisingly contrasting contexts - Cyrus, with an autoimmune constellation including type I diabetes, has some success living in a sunny climate relying on glucose and fructose rich fruit in the absence of ingestion of fat - alas, a strategy that may be suspect in the long term (yes I too have a bias towards saturated lipid as a predominant energy substrate) however, nevertheless illustrating fundamental principles from Randle at play.
      Go well.
      P. S. Much to enjoy in Peter Dobromylskyj's thoughts too ... Peace.

    • @toms8879
      @toms8879 Рік тому

      incorrect for many. just look here on youtube. many high meat dieters have gotten a heart attack. where do you get the the higher cholesterol the lower all cause mortality. that is just not the case.

    • @veniqe
      @veniqe Рік тому

      I've been eating 80g+ of pure, raw kidney fat a day since at least February this year. My total cholesterol is a measly 3.9mmol/L. My LDL is a puny 1.7mmol/L. I just can't seem to increase my cholesterol to the sky high levels of some pure-blooded carnivores. My theory is that all the kidney fat I eat lowers my body's need for making endogenous cholesterol.

    • @IgnoreMeImWrong
      @IgnoreMeImWrong Рік тому

      Dietary doesn't raise total Cholesterol. You've done fuck all. lol@@veniqe

    • @classicgameplay10
      @classicgameplay10 10 місяців тому

      Sugar doesnt raise tryglicerides... I dont know where people get this idea. There was a study recent showing that even oreos lower tryglicerides and cholesterol. Its saturated fat that rises tryglicerides. But fats overall.

  • @lakid9749
    @lakid9749 Рік тому +2

    Ummmm
    Cause everybody is different and health is not a blanket ??!!?
    Come on

  • @downtownjb100
    @downtownjb100 3 роки тому +1

    I aim for plant based keto

    • @daltonvanhorn5167
      @daltonvanhorn5167 10 місяців тому

      you can probably just eat plant based and not worry about putting your body into ketosis

    • @edithsmith1524
      @edithsmith1524 21 день тому

      Be careful, I tried that, and I look twenty years older than I am...

  • @PepeCoinMania
    @PepeCoinMania 5 місяців тому +2

    I don’t take seriously any vegan

    • @pearljam_1
      @pearljam_1 5 місяців тому

      Well that vegan will wave at you through the window of your nursing home room.

    • @todd92371
      @todd92371 5 місяців тому +2

      Have you studied the "Blue Zones"

    • @IconIcon-p9j
      @IconIcon-p9j 4 місяці тому +2

      @@todd92371I’ve been to 2 of the zones and they eat meat there…
      It’s usually more veggies, fruits, nuts, ect but there is meat. Usually for lunch/dinner…

    • @todd92371
      @todd92371 4 місяці тому

      @@IconIcon-p9j which areas?

    • @IconIcon-p9j
      @IconIcon-p9j 4 місяці тому

      @@todd92371 Okinawa and Sardinia

  • @reubenoneill2720
    @reubenoneill2720 2 роки тому +3

    Yea cause nuts and seeds are so available through the whole of evolution. The body must be smart enough to change its ways in 100 years once we have machines 😂

    • @toms8879
      @toms8879 Рік тому

      every couple of generation changes have happened. but who cares what we ate in pre historic times. if i throw you back in hsotry you would not surived on the foods they were eating

    • @IgnoreMeImWrong
      @IgnoreMeImWrong Рік тому

      Probably survive longer than you.@@toms8879

    • @pearljam_1
      @pearljam_1 5 місяців тому

      ⁠@@toms8879what are you talking about. Evolution doesn’t work like that. Jesus man pick up a science book.

  • @IgnoreMeImWrong
    @IgnoreMeImWrong Рік тому +1

    So... He's a vegan, that's what I'm hearing.

  • @HufflepuffDaddy
    @HufflepuffDaddy 3 роки тому +1

    The difference is probably between Diabetics vs pre- and non-Diabetics test subjects on either diet. If that isn't a controlled factor in testing then you'll get waffling results like this guy.

    • @HufflepuffDaddy
      @HufflepuffDaddy 3 роки тому +1

      @@TheProofWithSimonHill low carbs as a variable could mean 50-150 carbs a day to as little as 20 carbs or less per day depending on the definition of "low" used in the study. A variable that fluctuates that much in value would give wildly differing results.

    • @panes840
      @panes840 3 роки тому +3

      @@HufflepuffDaddy I suggest you read the study itself. Otherwise you can't come to any sensible conclusion. I didn't take Simon as waffling, he was saying how it actually is. Read the study itself then.

    • @HufflepuffDaddy
      @HufflepuffDaddy 3 роки тому

      @@panes840 this debate is "Low Carb vs High Carb" and I don't see how the randomized DIETFITS study of HLF (healthy low fat) vs HLC (healthy low carb) proves or disproves the specific relationship of Low Carb vs High Carb unless you can point it out for interested parties.