Taking Relief from the Cart Path - USGA Rule 16.1a Explained

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 120

  • @htchen77
    @htchen77 Рік тому +8

    In the 2nd scenario, in the rocks is nearest point of relief, but didn’t you forget the 2nd part of the rule? One club length from the rocks?

  • @yolo7630
    @yolo7630 Рік тому +2

    Very clear explanation on which club to use for the relief and how to measure the nearest point of relief! Shared with my friends. Thank you!

  • @richardgenobles4393
    @richardgenobles4393 3 місяці тому +1

    Best ifo I seen so far. straight to the point,

  • @peterbanton9155
    @peterbanton9155 2 роки тому +3

    I have watched other UA-cam videos that demonstrate when finding your nearest point of complete relief from a cart path complete relief must be determined with the club you intend to use for the next shot once the ball has been dropped. After the nearest point of relief is found and marked a drop area is then measured and marked by using your longest club that is not a putter. You found your nearest point of relief with your driver not the club you intend to use for your next shot. Is using your driver correct?

    • @KetilSunde
      @KetilSunde Рік тому

      It shuld be the intend club, not the longest which he explained saved time.

    • @africanbuffet614
      @africanbuffet614 Рік тому +1

      @@KetilSunde Where did he explain that it saved time ? Saved time for the purpose of the video or what exactly?

  • @edithrobert-casanova7545
    @edithrobert-casanova7545 3 роки тому +3

    Hi, Andy, very useful. Thanks.

    • @Wolfie565
      @Wolfie565 2 дні тому

      Useful but your club selection must be the club you would have been taken had it not been on a path!!

  • @petersydney5527
    @petersydney5527 Рік тому +1

    Great tips and I agree with you re the need to know more rules😀

  • @user-wz4dd6vz8x
    @user-wz4dd6vz8x Рік тому

    thank you so much for this. Rules, rules, I wish they'd stop changing. This was great. I 'ook forward for the next video.

  • @pedroduisberg8788
    @pedroduisberg8788 2 роки тому +1

    Great explanation , clear and slow Thanks

  • @danielfrancoeur8345
    @danielfrancoeur8345 3 роки тому +11

    Great explanations. However, you could have added the scenario where the ball is on fair ground but feet are on the cart path.
    I know you are allowed relief but not clear for everyone.
    Thanks

    • @TheGoldenriff
      @TheGoldenriff Рік тому +1

      I think you would do the same exact thing in that case. Find the nearest point of relief and take a club length and make your drop.

    • @timgrover3226
      @timgrover3226 10 місяців тому

      I disagree with Daniel...the path would have to physically interfere with one's stance. In this case standing on the path would in no way interfere with one's stance- so no free relief.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Місяць тому

      ​@timgrover3226 Standing on anything that qualifies as ACC entitles the Player to complete Relief.
      NO one has to stand on a Cart Path to make a Swing.

  • @HaccasDave
    @HaccasDave 4 місяці тому

    Thank you. Very well explained.

  • @JackRainfield
    @JackRainfield Рік тому

    Awesome! One would think the USGA rules would try to be as clear as this is.

  • @tracymoore7058
    @tracymoore7058 Рік тому +1

    Thank you very much!!!

  • @geoffreyprentice7356
    @geoffreyprentice7356 2 роки тому +1

    Great demo, it appears to me that there are a variance of interpretation in these rules,because of different situations.Maybe a cover statement or explanation of this would enhance your demo?

  • @richardfrommer1535
    @richardfrommer1535 4 місяці тому

    Hi Andy, I have a question based on your scenario in which you took relief from the sand after the cart path relief. What if, after you found your NPR from the cart path and then the sand, you then took your club one length relief area from NPR, AND THEN found another obstruction such as a sprinkler head, than didn't interfere from your NPR BEFORE taking your one club length relief area. The question is would you then get ever further relief from that sprinkler head? I don't think that you would because you have found your NPR from the original obstruction(s). If they did get further relief, the player would be hopping across the course from one obstruction to another. It's not real clear in the rules or definitions, but a cause of heated debates.

  • @jerrywilliamssr.2358
    @jerrywilliamssr.2358 Рік тому +1

    Thanks, that helped

  • @Wolfie565
    @Wolfie565 2 дні тому

    Let's say you hit your drive to the right and end up on a cart path. Your nearest point of relief will be the spot on the golf course nearest to where your ball lies is that is not nearer to the hole and that gives you complete relief from the cart path. To determine that spot, you should use the club that you would have used if the cart path was not there.
    So if your ball on the cart path is 150 yards from the hole and you would normally hit a 7-iron, that is the club that you should use to determine your nearest point of relief

  • @ft6755
    @ft6755 2 роки тому

    Great video thank you

  • @ashokdabir2158
    @ashokdabir2158 Рік тому

    Well explained!

  • @donmiles724
    @donmiles724 4 місяці тому +1

    Nice job. Does it matter if your nearest point of relief is closer to the hole or not? For instance, what about a ball on the cart to the side of the green. One side would be closer.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Місяць тому

      One of the provisions of the Nearest Point of Complete Relief is it be NO Closer to the Hole. So if you had a Cart Path near a Green, most likely you would have to Drop on the Far side of the Path and then Chip/Pitch over the Path.
      There could be a geometric Point of Complete Relief between the Path and the Hole.
      The Deciding Factor would be Point of Complete Relief CANNOT be closer to the Hole than where the Ball sits on or near the ACC.

  • @SallyJaynes
    @SallyJaynes Місяць тому +1

    My ball was in a bush a foot from cartpath, an official said first step is to drop on the cart path, then from there drop to the nearest point of relief...I argued that no where in the rules of golf does it have you dropping in a concrete cart path.. what's right?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  Місяць тому

      You take relief from one thing at a time. First the bush - if that nearest point is on the path then that is where you would drop and then you would take relief from the path after you dropped it there.

  • @007Veeman
    @007Veeman 8 місяців тому

    What happens if your ball lands passes the green, lands on a cart path, but in-between two out of bound? And the only clean relief in bounds is closer to the hole?

  • @phidip2328
    @phidip2328 3 роки тому +4

    What about when the cart path is going perpendicular to the fairway (crossing it)? Can you still drop on either side, even if one side is clearly much closer to the hole?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому +1

      Your drop must be no closer to the hole so in that case you would only have one direction to go.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Рік тому

      Because of "No Closer to the Hole", you will always be off the 'Away Side' of a crossing Cart Path. Your "Nearest Point of Complete Relief" will be at least a foot behind the Cart Path because your Front Foot CAN'T be on the Cart Path.

  • @gnarbucklar
    @gnarbucklar 3 роки тому +4

    When the closest relief was under the tree and in rocks, couldn’t you take that and use the club length arc to back away from the rocks?

    • @1pierrr
      @1pierrr 3 роки тому +2

      yes. Also move it back towards the path a little would have helped too, but not so far that you are standing on it to play your shot. A shorter iron would have been helpful.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 2 роки тому +1

      That would depend upon how large the rocky area is. You are allowed to drop anywhere in your Arc, but you have to drop again if the First Drop had you standing on the Path again.

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому +1

      You can as long as you get it out of the rocks and you are getting relief from the path

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 2 роки тому

      @@1pierrr your Reference Point for determining Nearest Point of Complete Relief is determined by the Club you intend to use to play the upcoming Shot.
      The SIZE of the Relief Area is determined with Driver usually.

    • @1pierrr
      @1pierrr 2 роки тому +1

      @@apaulmcdonough2170 I assume you are noting my “a shorter iron”…. this was for hitting the golf ball so you stand closer to the ball so your feet aren’t on the path and so you aren’t in the rocks or behind the tree…. not used for measuring the relief area.

  • @Unplugged704
    @Unplugged704 2 роки тому +2

    Great examples!
    Question - in your 3rd example, you dropped on the sand, then remeasured/dropped. Just curious why you just wouldn't drop outside the sand as per your measure, the grass was still within the driver club length?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому +1

      If that was an option you should definitely do that. I was mainly just showing that as an example as to if there was no grass.

    • @nathansmith762
      @nathansmith762 2 роки тому

      you can also use it to your advantage. If the nearest point of relief is behind an obstacle and there is a free drop location within that one club length that isn't the same thing your already taking relief from it can hep you get out from behind the obstacle

  • @thomasrichardson-ev1wp
    @thomasrichardson-ev1wp 4 місяці тому

    Would abnormal ground conditions include a muddy area without water and the rest of the course is dry

  • @ericfermin8347
    @ericfermin8347 2 роки тому +1

    In scenario #2 why didn't you mark one club length from the tee in the ground like you did in scenario #1?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому

      Because I was just determining the reference point to decide which spot was the nearest.

  • @wesbilly
    @wesbilly 2 роки тому +1

    But why couldn’t I just have taken relief to the right of the rocks one club length?

  • @daviddelong6882
    @daviddelong6882 2 роки тому +1

    With regard to scenario 2, can you drop just off the path? Does your one club length have to further from the path. In a nutshell, must you take complete relief or can you take partial relief.

    • @ztheg_
      @ztheg_ Рік тому

      you must take full relief. no part of you or the ball may be affected by the cart path after you take relief

  • @bruceaugustine6486
    @bruceaugustine6486 3 роки тому +2

    So because the nearest point is in the rocks or roots, you still have the arc of the club to drop your ball, correct?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому

      Basically yes. It gives you a little room there within that arc

  • @johngrimm5927
    @johngrimm5927 3 роки тому +2

    Great Video. I don't understand Scenario #3 where relief if secondarily taken from the sand. It is not a bunker and is not marked as ground under repair, so I don't get why you are able to take relief from that area. I don't see it as being qualified as an Abnormal Course Condition.

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому +2

      One of the Abnormal Ground Conditions allowed for is Ground Under Repair under which an a hole is made by the maintenance crew for maintaining the course (such as a hole made in removing turf or a tree stump or laying pipelines, but not including aeration holes) would classify until it were brought up to the standard of the course (i.e. sod replaced over the hole). It basically comes down to the common practices at that course. If they typically bring an area like that up to their standard of sod then you would get relief under that definition; however if they typically leave areas like that and consider it repaired then you would be correct in saying that no relief would be given. Sorry for the long response, but I hope that helps clear it up.

    • @alallen694
      @alallen694 2 роки тому

      Hate to sound picky, but the proper terminology is Abnormal Course Condition (ACC). Not Abnormal Ground Condition. Ground under repair (GUR) is all part of ACC. Ground under repair are typically designated and marked by the committee. If a Player encounter an area he thinks is GUR, and no Rules Referee is around, he should play two balls under Rule 20.1c(3). One playing the ball as it lie, and one taking relief from the area.

  • @cruzcontreras2391
    @cruzcontreras2391 2 роки тому +2

    Good video! Thanks. Question: What if the ball is on the left side of the cart path and left of the cart path is OB. Would you still be allowed relief on that side or would you go on the right side, or not get relief at all?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому +2

      Your relief must be on a playable part of the golf course so you would not have to drop it out of bounds you could drop on the other side because that would be the nearest point of relief.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Місяць тому

      ​@@AndyWeissingerIf there was a Penalty Area near the ACC would I be required to drop in the General Area that also had my Stance inside a Penalty Area?
      Or would my NPCR be on the opposite side so my Stance would be in the General Area?

  • @marshallviliesis
    @marshallviliesis 2 роки тому +4

    The problem with the rules of golf is this is a 7 minute video

  • @m8j64
    @m8j64 Рік тому +1

    My buddy David, says that a bare spot on the fairway, no grass just dirt, is an abnormal course condition. But outside the fairway must be played as is. True?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  Рік тому +1

      Your buddy David would be wrong. Have him look at the definition of abnormal course condition

  • @kpxkrnkidx
    @kpxkrnkidx 6 місяців тому

    In scenario 2, is there a rule that prohibits you from dropping your ball closer to the very path within the driver length whilst standing on the cart path?

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Місяць тому

      You aren't required to Stand in the Relief Area to perform your Drop(s). The Ball must land inside the Relief Area.

  • @mwelasemazibuko5357
    @mwelasemazibuko5357 2 роки тому +1

    Taking a relief isn't that u must take it till you at good conditions of ground to play?eg relief on the watered green?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому

      Relief is taken from one thing at at time and you measure from the edge of whatever you are taking relief from if it something marked or obvious (like the edge of the cart path)

  • @grantkeller7945
    @grantkeller7945 3 роки тому +1

    How is abnormal defined? Is it defined by the official in tournament play and by the player in casual play? Could it be a dead patch of grass that a “to-the-rules player” can deem as abnormal in that scenario?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому +1

      The rules clearly define what Abnormal is and goes into detail on the four categories of abnormal in order to rule out a scenario like you describe from someone just declaring something as abnormal.

  • @br5448
    @br5448 2 роки тому +1

    helpful - in the case where the nearest point is on the roots, can one simply drop it closer to the cart path on that line? Although one's feet may be on the cart path?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому

      If you are going to take relief the relief has to be complete, so if it was on roots you may not want to take relief and just stand on the cart path. You will even see players choose to hit the ball off of a cart path at times.

    • @br5448
      @br5448 2 роки тому

      @@AndyWeissinger Got it, the 'complete' part is key. Thank you for answering.

  • @jmoro1242
    @jmoro1242 3 роки тому

    So you can use any club for nearest relief? As choosing a shorter club in some situations can determine which side of the cart path is the nearest relief. If so does it have to be the club you intend to use for the shot after relief? You used a driver in the first intense, which put you in the rocks.

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому

      You are able to use any club you have during the round except your putter.

    • @JayRobertsGolf
      @JayRobertsGolf 3 роки тому +9

      @@AndyWeissinger Andy, great video. What are your thoughts about the fact that per the definition of Nearest Point of Relief it states that, "Estimating the nearest point of relief requires the player to identify the choice of club, stance, swing, and line of play he or she would have used for the stroke". Does that not require the player to use the club they are most likely going to use for the next stroke and thus prevent the player from using any club that they'd like?

    • @davidverity9576
      @davidverity9576 2 роки тому +2

      @@AndyWeissinger Jay & Modest are right Andy;-a player could only use driver for establishing the NPCR if that was to be the club he or she would have used to play the shot if the abnormal course condition did not exist. The longest club in the bag is used to measure the one-club length from the reference point. Dave

  • @the_laybacks
    @the_laybacks Рік тому +1

    I've been away from golf for the past few years. A new thing for me is taking drops from knee height, rather than shoulder height. Personally, I think bending down and dropping it from the knee looks kind of gay. I still drop from shoulder height. Am I allowed to do that, or does it absolutely HAVE to be from the knee?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  Рік тому

      Agreed. Unfortunately you do have to drop from knee height.

  • @kpxkrnkidx
    @kpxkrnkidx 6 місяців тому

    Can I putt my ball and ride the cart path if it is deemed advantageous to do a without penalty?

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Місяць тому

      Yes, you could. Other than a Ball Out of Bounds or a Ball in a NO Play Zone, you always have the choice of Playing the Ball "as it lies".

  • @urstandingonmyfoot
    @urstandingonmyfoot 2 місяці тому

    if the ball is laying on rocks underneath and close to the tree, wouldn't you consider that an "unplayable lie" ?

  • @pdub7562
    @pdub7562 3 роки тому +1

    Does no nearer to the hole factor into the decision? In the first scenario say the green is 10yrds to your left you would be dropping it nearer to the hole. Is that allowed?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому

      Yes - no closer to the hole is always a consideration when taking a drop of any kind. If that were closer to the hole you would not be able to drop in that direction.

    • @pdub7562
      @pdub7562 3 роки тому

      @@AndyWeissinger So even if the nearest point of relief is closer to the hole but a drop within one club lengths of that point is not closer then thats ok?

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  3 роки тому

      @@pdub7562 If the nearest point is closer than you cannot use it. Think of it as two qualifiers: 1. No closer to the hole 2. Nearest point of relief - i.e. Nearest point of relief that is no closer to the hole

    • @pdub7562
      @pdub7562 3 роки тому +1

      @@AndyWeissinger Thanks

  • @user-ik2oi8cj4c
    @user-ik2oi8cj4c Рік тому +1

    Sorry, but Andy is wrong at 2:15 where he says to use the longest club. The definition of Nearest Point of Complete Relief is determined by using the club they would normally use at that location. "Estimating this reference point requires the player to identify the choice of club, stance, swing and line of play they would have used for that stroke."

    • @Wolfie565
      @Wolfie565 2 дні тому

      Yep that is correct! That is what the rule states!

  • @jeremyguitarm1
    @jeremyguitarm1 11 місяців тому

    Does your body have to stay within the “arch” area when dropping?

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Місяць тому

      NO. The only requirement is the Ball must strike the Ground inside the Relief Area.

  • @user-xt1uz5qn4d
    @user-xt1uz5qn4d Рік тому

    If you’re going to pass yourself off as a rules authority you should get the rule right.
    Establishing to point of complete relief from abnormal must be done with intended club and swing path of next shot. You CANNOT use “any club in your bag” to establish a reference point
    for nearest point of complete relief.

  • @maaduece5132
    @maaduece5132 2 роки тому +1

    Why does tiger never take free relief when he tore up his knee trying to hit off the car path

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  2 роки тому

      Relief is an option. There are times when our nearest point of relief puts us in a worse position and the best option may be to hit it off the cart path.

  • @jimdomiano4552
    @jimdomiano4552 Рік тому

    I usually us my foot wedge😉

  • @danherold8132
    @danherold8132 3 роки тому +1

    scenario 2: couldn't you use a shorter club?

  • @Jeremy-vf7su
    @Jeremy-vf7su Місяць тому +1

    I never want to play with someone who makes me measure my free relief.

  • @andrewallen3210
    @andrewallen3210 2 роки тому

    I thought you should mark your ball on the path before picking it up?

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Рік тому

      Once you lift the Ball you are Committed to taking Relief.
      First find the NEAREST Point of Complete Relief, and then Decide if you really want to Take the Relief, if Yes, only then Lift the Ball.

  • @murphaa9564
    @murphaa9564 Рік тому

    Why can’t I identify as a righty or a lefty at anytime on the course? Serious?

  • @beatiger9361
    @beatiger9361 2 роки тому

    Pls answer the comment below mine. Thanks

  • @mkwy8782
    @mkwy8782 9 місяців тому +1

    Sometimes the rules are mindbogglingly silly. How about we employ the principles of common sense and fair play and call it good?

  • @MichealBacon
    @MichealBacon Рік тому

    You must use the intended club to determine distance for cart path relief (immovable obstruction under Abnormal Course Conditions). You cannot use a driver length (and not use it) simply to benefit or improve your relief area, again in THIS scenario. You will be denied under Rule 16.1in the PGA due this act being "unreasonable stroke" - already tried and been ruled on. Other than that, great stuff.

    • @MichealBacon
      @MichealBacon Рік тому

      To be clear, you cannot measure with driver then use 7iron or 6 or 8..ect when taking FREE relief. You can however use the driver length to maximize relief area from a HAZARD or anytime when taking a general penalty and a drop.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Рік тому

      ​@@MichealBaconI highly recommend you find the USGA/R&A Definition of "Club-Length" which will explain to you how you are Incorrect.
      You can use any Club to determine the Nearest Point of Complete Relief, which becomes the "Reference Point" that the One "Club-Length" is measured from.

  • @sampozzi2746
    @sampozzi2746 Рік тому

    This is why rounds now take 6 hours.

  • @thesouthwillfallagain3803
    @thesouthwillfallagain3803 Рік тому +2

    Golfing with the boys Rule 69.420: use the foot wedge and put the ball wherever you want.

  • @jonathonreedg
    @jonathonreedg 2 роки тому

    We all suck. Just move it over and keep it going.

    • @ccrider-
      @ccrider- Рік тому

      I wish you were wrong...

  • @AdrianArthurBray
    @AdrianArthurBray 2 роки тому

    Unclear why he did not drop the ball of the path, away from the rocks, but stand on the path to hit it.

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Рік тому

      Because you are required to take COMPLETE Relief - Ball, Area of Intended Swing, AND Stance.

  • @reginaldgraves1684
    @reginaldgraves1684 3 роки тому

    Chance is what justifies calling golf a game rather than a sport. Over the years every rules have been introduced to reduce the element of luck in golf which has changed the nature of the "game". For example; The Drop has gone from behind the player over the shoulder to a curtsy in order to remove the chance of a bad lie, originally there was probably no relief at all. It is debatable whether concrete is a bad lie. Relief from GUR should be "required" for protection of the area not to enable the golfer to obtain a better lie.

  • @iron1215
    @iron1215 Рік тому

    i just give my ball a swift kick...

  • @benlife340
    @benlife340 Рік тому

    why waste time ... chose relief point considering all conditions...and take a relief simple ....

  • @alize43m
    @alize43m Рік тому

    We wonder why their slow 🐌 play lol .

  • @bigdogpete43
    @bigdogpete43 4 місяці тому

    You are on a course by yourself. Kick it over and play your shot.

  • @popscyclep8084
    @popscyclep8084 2 роки тому

    No help

  • @Jimsranch
    @Jimsranch Рік тому +1

    ??? stand on cart path - ball on turf OK??

    • @AndyWeissinger
      @AndyWeissinger  Рік тому

      You would be able to drop if ball was on the turf and you were standing on the cart path

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Рік тому

      IF your Ball is in the Grass, but you would be Standing on the Path you can choose to "Play It as It Lies".
      IF you Choose to Take Relief, you MUST be Standing OFF the Path to play your Stroke.

  • @rodbacon9489
    @rodbacon9489 2 роки тому

    Have seen this explained much better elsewhere. Keep trying.

  • @youtubechangemynamewhy
    @youtubechangemynamewhy 2 роки тому

    Too slow sir, speed up

  • @ericschorsch
    @ericschorsch 2 роки тому

    Take this video down - it is wrong! You must use the club you would expect to use to make the stroke - NOT THE DRIVER!

    • @apaulmcdonough2170
      @apaulmcdonough2170 Рік тому

      For a Right Handed Player It doesn't matter what Club you use to determine PCR to the Left Side of an ACC, because off the Left Side the Intended Direction of Swing puts the Reference Point about 6 inches off the ACC. For Right Side Reference Point the Choice of Club Makes a difference in determining the NEAREST Point of Complete Relief.
      Then It's usually a Driver used to measure the Relief Area.