Helle Harding knife, first look and problems.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 66

  • @kameelelian6044
    @kameelelian6044 2 роки тому +5

    I love helle knives I have two and they were both perfect. The shop you purchased this from is to blame , they should be checking these things before they go out I'm sure it was damaged either at the place you purchased it at or the damage was caused during shipping. Knives like this don't leave the helle factory.

    • @Herr_Gamer
      @Herr_Gamer 2 роки тому

      I wonder what the american shopkeepers do to their stock because the only tiles I see people have issues with Helle knives is when they’re bought in America

    • @brianlash154
      @brianlash154 2 роки тому

      @@Herr_Gamer try not to group up every single American retailer like that. I'd expect issues from knife center but dlt does it right each and every time

    • @howardvarley8795
      @howardvarley8795 5 місяців тому

      Yes they do!!!

  • @nunayoorbidnez2119
    @nunayoorbidnez2119 3 роки тому +3

    My Helle Harding arrived today with a badly aligned blade. Very disappointing considering how expensive these knives are.

  • @MB_OutdoorsMT
    @MB_OutdoorsMT 3 роки тому +1

    I have several Moras and I was tempted to buy a Helle. I'm having second thoughts now.

    • @Herr_Gamer
      @Herr_Gamer 2 роки тому

      This is very rare and I’m surprised to see it. I myself have owned many, most of my friends and family own at least one and the only issue I’ve seen is one had a slight discolouration of the leather spacers

    • @kameelelian6044
      @kameelelian6044 2 роки тому

      This didn't leave the helle factory like that

    • @howardvarley8795
      @howardvarley8795 5 місяців тому

      @@kameelelian6044mine Did!! Twice!!!

  • @davidcooper6704
    @davidcooper6704 7 років тому +2

    I would have sent this one back. I have the same knife, supplied by Heinnie Haynes and it is spot on with no issues at all. May I ask why you accepted an knife that should not have passed inspection/quality control at the factory. I am sure if you return it to the retailer or the factory they will almost certainly replace it.

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  6 років тому +1

      I purchased it online so I did not get a chance to choose a good one. The shop took it back and gave me a refund.

  • @joycarroll568
    @joycarroll568 6 років тому +1

    I could live with two of the issues and chalk them up to rustic handmade charm but NOT the lopsided mounting that’s when it would have gone back. No doubt in my mind.
    The problem I think is we are getting used to seeing perfect machined knives and a cosmetic issue can seem a big deal
    As I’ve already said it would have gone back if it was mine because of the wonky mounting, but that aside is it for looking at or using? If it’s the latter I say use it, and use it well. Form a bond with it over several years and then just sand and polish it back to as was. I’m sure the knife is well up to that

  • @hh227
    @hh227 3 роки тому +1

    Jesus dude, send it back. How much did it cost? And what’s wrong with Mora?

    • @ilijabosnjak76
      @ilijabosnjak76 3 роки тому

      I was thinking the same,Mora Robust is indescribable 😂…Some people are just Stupid my friend…

    • @howardvarley8795
      @howardvarley8795 5 місяців тому

      @@ilijabosnjak76and some people are just pig ignorant!

  • @recycled3654
    @recycled3654 3 роки тому +1

    Sometimes I wonder if maybe these retailers aren't buying factory seconds and selling them as is. I noticed a lot of bent or warped blades over the last few years, I find it hard to believe QC has become common place everywhere. Never know though.

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  3 роки тому

      I would have kept the knife if it wasn't for the somewhat crooked blade. That was the thing that put me off. I would have ignored the other small niggles.

    • @nunayoorbidnez2119
      @nunayoorbidnez2119 3 роки тому +1

      Made me wonder that too. I'm surprised that Helle is willing to risk the loss to their reputation. When a product is billed as "hand crafted", I assume that even MORE attention has been payed to product quality.

  • @mums1son
    @mums1son 2 роки тому

    Yeah I went and purchased a Helle Utvaer, It’s a work of art. But I drove over a hour away just to put my hands on it before dropping that kind of money.

  • @fv7594
    @fv7594 3 роки тому +3

    Handmade or not this is not acceptable its too expensive to have these inperfections. Also they advertise their knifes as quality handmade knifes.

  • @Cid_1
    @Cid_1 2 роки тому +1

    Helle got great customer service. I'm sure the shop you bought it from did refund you or send you a new Harding without any issues.

  • @roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
    @roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 2 роки тому +2

    It's not a museum piece. It's made to use. Stop nit picking.

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  2 роки тому +2

      I don't understand why people think this is me being nit picky. I paid over £100 for a knife and I expect the blade to be straight. Simple as that. If I bought a golf club I'd expect the shaft to be straight. It's not that unreasonable.

    • @loboptlu
      @loboptlu Рік тому

      ⁠@@alexrudavin540only 100 pound for a harding ? The retailer clearly did something to sell it that cheap.
      Had it too twice with a marttiini and in the end it was the retailer who thought he had to inspect the knives and no idea what he did , but the knives where trashed .
      I order from marttiini ,helle and morakniv directly now , always perfect and mora and marttiini let me put my initials on it , free for marttiini and 7,5€ for mora.

  • @theadventureexpedition3619
    @theadventureexpedition3619 6 років тому +3

    They have a lifetime warrenty

  • @bosse641
    @bosse641 5 років тому +4

    Obviously no pride of workmanship among some of their makers. Not smart business.

  • @asplendidaffair
    @asplendidaffair 7 років тому +2

    I have the same knife with the same blade problem.

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  7 років тому

      Barry White I sent it back to the shop where I bought it from and they gave me a refund. I asked if they had the same knife in stock but without the problems but they said no, saying that the knives are handmade which is fair.

  • @ilijabosnjak76
    @ilijabosnjak76 3 роки тому +1

    I don’t know about you or how much you paid for the knife but I would challenge you with my Mora Robust…

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  3 роки тому

      Someone else mentioned Mora in comments. Might look at their knives at some point.

  • @talknroll6499
    @talknroll6499 3 роки тому +2

    Same thing with my Helle Eggen. 👎

  • @markstr8309
    @markstr8309 6 років тому +4

    Helle knives are very expensive they need to put out quality or they will be massacred on youtube and rightly so.

  • @brianlash154
    @brianlash154 2 роки тому +1

    These knives are completely handmade, tooling marks, "imperfections" are and should be expected and anticipated. Only collectors gripe about knives that are anything short of a perfect specimen.
    Like people have done for 40 thousand plus years, use your knife until is literally breaks on you. Try not to focus on something unless it poses a safety hazard

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  2 роки тому +1

      Everyone can decide what is acceptable for them as a customer. I can live with "imperfections" but a blade that is mounted clearly off axis isn't an "imperfection" in my opinion.

    • @brianlash154
      @brianlash154 2 роки тому

      @@alexrudavin540 the knife appears to be a stick tang, maybe I'm not understanding what you mean by mounted off axis, they do make full'er' tang knives like the temagami in 14C28N
      Maybe that will be better for you

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  2 роки тому

      @@brianlash154 when looking down the spine of the knife, the handle and the blade were not in line. Essentially the blade was off at an angle. Which was the main reason I returned it. The other little issues were negligible.

    • @brianlash154
      @brianlash154 2 роки тому

      @@alexrudavin540 did you ask for a replacement?

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  2 роки тому +1

      @@brianlash154 I decided that if spending this much, I'd rather see the knife first hand but there was no stock nearby. I ended up buying an Opinel no.08 which for the money is absolutely fantastic!

  • @howardvarley8795
    @howardvarley8795 5 місяців тому

    I have exactly the same problem with my helle Harding - unfortunately ‘hand made’ is Not an excuse for Sloppy Manufacture, and poor quality control,.. I also have a Temagami where the metal tang Doesn’t fit in the handle properly, I had to cut a wedge to glue in between the two. I will never buy a Helle knife again.

  • @Владимир-я2й4ь
    @Владимир-я2й4ь 10 місяців тому

    Ножи helle лучшие в мире ламинаты и в работе они супер.

  • @artem8032
    @artem8032 7 років тому

    у тебя новая пассия? )

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  7 років тому

      Артём Козлов нет, просто давно хотел купить хороший нож, но этот немного разочаровал

  • @bubbasdually
    @bubbasdually 5 років тому +3

    Looks good to me, its made to cut, put down your purse and put it to work.

    • @fv7594
      @fv7594 3 роки тому

      Yes it works but its not what he paid for.
      Little things like this annoys me so much id send this one back.

    • @brianlash154
      @brianlash154 2 роки тому

      @@fv7594 you must be a collector

  • @100BearPaw
    @100BearPaw Місяць тому

    Hand made by someone on a Friday at the end of the day on a holiday weekend!! By someone who hated his life already! Not capable of caring about quality.

  • @michelpoels
    @michelpoels 3 роки тому

    Contact Hellen and see what they do, don't put this on you tube, give theme a chance.

  • @zdrahar8977
    @zdrahar8977 6 років тому

    Жаль что не на русском... Ножи красивые если разглядывать издалека)) а как сталь??

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  6 років тому +1

      Да сам не знал, то ли на русском, то ли на английском записать)) В принципе нож хороший. Я его вернул только из-за криво закреплённого клинка. Может быть попробую ещё один купить)

    • @zdrahar8977
      @zdrahar8977 6 років тому

      Alex Rudavin если на Украине живёшь в ибисе на них хорошие скидки

  • @bluejeans8001
    @bluejeans8001 6 років тому +7

    If you want perfection buy a knife made by a computer, if you want “hand made” then expect human imperfections.

  • @dalebrooks9123
    @dalebrooks9123 5 років тому

    It’s a handmade knife! You know by people go try to make one in your garage then try complaining or even just put a new handle on that one. Stick to robot china junk if you can’t deal with imperfections that come with handmade products of any kind

    • @alexrudavin540
      @alexrudavin540  5 років тому +5

      If you bought a handmade guitar, would you be happy if the neck was not mounted straight? I didn't say it's a bad knife. I just wasn't happy with that particular one.

    • @nunayoorbidnez2119
      @nunayoorbidnez2119 3 роки тому

      If you paid $$$ for a knife that arrived with a poorly aligned blade, and you accepted it as-is, I have a car to sell you.

    • @B61Mod12
      @B61Mod12 3 роки тому

      Dale you are a complete dickhead. Helle literally advertise "perfection".
      ua-cam.com/video/1cuYnbWmEMY/v-deo.html

    • @lesarr8606
      @lesarr8606 2 роки тому

      Robot china junk??? They make much better knives than most well known american brand. Bark river knives is an exception.

    • @shawnpepin7890
      @shawnpepin7890 Рік тому

      Helle is far from handmade… many automatic processes and machines. Hand finished yes, but blade alignment, handle shaping (90%) and sheathing is automated