Frank saying "please" really tears me up here because i think it's the first time he ever properly realised what Monica really was but didn't want to hear it because despite the pain he still loved her .
My heart always gets tugged at when Fiona shouts "I was NINE!" It's filled with such desperate exhaustion and frustration. And of course, that small trembling "Please" from Frank really strikes a chord. All in all, it's such a powerful performance from both of them.
I was eleven, when pretty much the same happend, I "only" have 3 younger siblings though, but this really is like listening to my younger self arguing and being angry/frustrated..
Those kids can say shit about Fiona, and think that Fiona is not worthy, but one thing for sure is that she is their mom, maybe not to Lip and Ian that much, but for the rest, and I hate how all of them, Debbie the most, gives her shit about the mistakes she has made, and not once think "Fiona did all she could for us, she put her life on stop so she could find multiple jobs to put food on the table, maybe she deserves a little respect" Edit. Im so glad 2K people think the same
@@no1reveluv when she was trying to become their legal guardian, she said the first time Monica and frank left her alone to go get drugs, with lip and ian and she had to walk 6 miles by foot holding both babies in her arms because ian had a fever. She was 6.
The fact that the amount of respect she has is so little. Why don’t she ever get “a good job Fiona , you did great” sentence. She deserves more thank she did for them
Yeah I dont understand how all of them can stand there listening to what Fiona did for them especially at such a young age and still treat her the way they did.
In real life, it really does. We the eldest who put our life on stop, get our childhood taken away, so we can help our parents or making sure our siblings can have a better life, not worrying about anything, not knowing what harms the family…… this child will never get the respect she deserve. I am that child. No matter how much I did, nobody will appreciate me. I understand Fiona. And I hope all children whom their childhood get taken away, will get the life they deserve.
Frank's defeated "please" might be one of the realest moments in the whole series. He's deeply hurt, and he doesn't want to hear anymore because he knows Fiona is 100% right about everything.
My dad grew up in a family where you didn't just leave, you ran...I have an uncle who moved to California & the family merely communicated through letters...my uncle even went as far as to say if any of them came to visit him, he wouldn't answer the door...he died about four years ago & my cousin found that out by accidently stumbling across his obituary online...we never even met him
I feel so bad for Frank. I mean he is finally realizing how much Monica fucked with him and how terrible she was to their kids. And Fiona, no words need to be said for her.
“ I’m glad she’s dead “ … when someone has really betrayed you you’re entire life , it’s a relief to know that they can no longer be around to do it . That’s the part I felt the most .. not bc u hate them but bc they are fucking dangerous to your soul . Loving them is a problem. When they die it’s the most disturbing and vile liberation u will ever feel in your life . I’ve been there .
Fiona never had a chance. Imagine someone being 9 years old and raising their siblings and taking care of their deadbeat father who never once helped them. If anything, he made their lives so much worse. She was never going to grow up into a well adjusted adult who made good choices. She needed serious help and instead she had to fight every single day to keep her and her family safe, alive, and loved (im excluding Frank from that). Her character is so well written and emotional and has so many layers to her personality.
“She was never here, She was never fuckin here! She left!” Gosh this scene hits so hard. She did absolutely amazing and all of the brothers and Debbie standing behind her watching. They’re all they had. This scene gets me every time I watch it. 🖤
Honestly, this is the defining scene of the entire series for me. There are great performances all throughout, but this gave the two pillars of the show the opportunity to just absolutely let it rip with their core motivations. No holds barred, just visceral, honest, ugly. Bravo.
The raw emotion is amazing but what gets me is when the mask comes back up to be the strong woman she had to craft herself into. “She didn’t love me and she didn’t love you.”
"If she loved us so much, why wasn't she here?" That hits hard considering that my egg donor(she doesn't deserve to be called a mother) abandoned me. She steadily did the same thing to my younger sibling after she divorced my sibling's dad, but my sibling still has contact with her. I refuse to reach out anymore because she can't own up to her mistakes. She abandoned me after I was two. I didn't even know or meet her until I was eleven. Didn't start fully seeing her again until I was thirteen and it was always ME having to ask when/if she was getting me for the weekend because sometimes she "didn't have enough gas money", but that was because she'd either get a new tattoo or party with her friends that same weekend. She tried manipulating me into thinking my dad was a monster who took me away from her. She didn't take me to my sister's funeral(step sibling) or at the very least tell me when it was. She let my other stepsister beat me up(I was fifteen and stepsister was in her early twenties). I was sexually harrassed at sixteen because she threw a party on one of the weekends I was there. She left to go to a bar with everyone and left me alone with two people around my age and a dude in his forties, who would not leave me alone and kept following me into every room. After her divorce, at her new house, she made me sleep in the living room so her and her new bf's friend could have the spare bedroom. I first broke contact at eighteen, but I reached out after getting pregnant at nineteen because I thought maybe she could change. I had a miscarriage and she never showed up to comfort me ONCE. So I broke contact again and she somehow found my number. She sent me a picture of a tattoo she got representing MY child without my or my fiance's permission nonetheless. I blocked her, but ended up unblocking her after getting drunk one night to send a drunk text, letting out everything I felt. Next day she had texted me back and was pissed. I apologized for texting her, but refused to apologize for what I had said because it was how I felt. Haven't heard from her since and I prefer to keep it that way because everytime she came back into my life, my mental and emotional health paid the price.
What always breaks my heart is even with all the fucked up shit Frank does he was and still is the better parent, like he was really messed up but he never left them and he did help them in his own little way
You can see it in Franks eyes that he was broken...once I heard him say "please" it broke me. He noticed how much Fiona does for him and everyone else...I have a feeling Frank didn't want to believe that Monica died...I've always felt bad for Frank
Frank knew that what Fiona was saying was the truth but he didn't wanna face it because he was so in love with Monica or at least his idea of her. Love can blind you ones many flaws to which Monica had. Took this moment to finally make Frank realise what Monica was. A selfish woman that walked out on him and their kids and left a nine year old Fiona to pick up the pieces. That being said, it was somewhat satisfying to see someone finally get to Frank considering his part to play in the deterioration of his family.
When frank said “please” rlly made my heart shatter because he knew it was true but he didn’t want to say it because he was still in love with her frank I’d the best person ever when Fiona was drunk and fighting with lip when frank said “I couldn’t have done it without her” shoes that frank cares about Fiona also what’s the song for this
I really do sympathise with both of them in this because he lost the love of his life, sure they were fucked up but they loved each other in their own messed up way he needed to hear what fiona was telling him but it was still really painful
My friend recommended me this show, as I needed a new comedy show to binge and this is was not what I was expecting at all, the show is fantastic and the family dynamic is both beautiful and heartbreaking.
After a few episodes I had to watch this w/o my S.O. cuz of the EXACT same issues he had growing up...to him...wasnt funny,....serious, he would go door 2 door, 2 get food 4 him & 3 bros. Wish this wasnt true. Emmy is FU(¥A₩SOME!!!!!) she deserves an EMMY, & ACADEMY!!!!.
![Shameless 712 [Season 7] Fiona & Frank about Monica](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SRAYA45aoGs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Shameless 712 [Season 7] Fiona & Frank about Monica](/img/tr.png)
Frank saying "please" really tears me up here because i think it's the first time he ever properly realised what Monica really was but didn't want to hear it because despite the pain he still loved her .
ikr :( omg
What wat episode was it on I didn’t see it?
@@april.ydd16 season 8 episode 1
@@cjbbbb07 i thought it was season 7 finale?
Her saying “I was nine made me” cried
“Not Mónica, ME” oh my God best scene ever
THE BEST ACTOR I KNOW
@@davidsolorio6983 YES😭
It is so unfair. Nine years old Fiona was the only one who had to dealt with the absence of Monica in an adult manner.
What season and episode is this
Or when she was 6 taking care of lip and ian
@@baddestair1213 season 7 ep 12
when Fiona says SHE LEFT my heart breaks to pieces
"I was 9"....
"Taking care of all of us"
"Dragging your ass in from the yard"
"So you wouldn't freeze to death"
“Staying up all night with Ian when he had chickenpox”
My heart always gets tugged at when Fiona shouts "I was NINE!" It's filled with such desperate exhaustion and frustration. And of course, that small trembling "Please" from Frank really strikes a chord. All in all, it's such a powerful performance from both of them.
I was eleven, when pretty much the same happend, I "only" have 3 younger siblings though, but this really is like listening to my younger self arguing and being angry/frustrated..
I,am Chinese,it's real will happen in USA where is such great country,will really exist family like this ?
“If she loved us so much why isn’t she here?” That hits hard
Especially when you had someone like that Is like that
I watched this over and over and it made me cry we d
Those kids can say shit about Fiona, and think that Fiona is not worthy, but one thing for sure is that she is their mom, maybe not to Lip and Ian that much, but for the rest, and I hate how all of them, Debbie the most, gives her shit about the mistakes she has made, and not once think "Fiona did all she could for us, she put her life on stop so she could find multiple jobs to put food on the table, maybe she deserves a little respect"
Edit. Im so glad 2K people think the same
Victoria Sandia i fucking hate Debbie so much it physically hurts
Victoria Sandia exactly I mean a nine year old raising a family. There’s no way this will turn out perfect but boy did she do the best she could.
She was 6. 6 when she became an adult. Fiona didnt sign up to be a mother for 5 kids.
@@elizabethsunderland447 no she was 9
@@no1reveluv when she was trying to become their legal guardian, she said the first time Monica and frank left her alone to go get drugs, with lip and ian and she had to walk 6 miles by foot holding both babies in her arms because ian had a fever. She was 6.
Frank saying ‘please’ broke my heart because he knows it’s true he just doesn’t want to believe because he loves her🥺🥺
@ELI BEHNKEN yea but he’s our piece of shit🥺
Don’t be an apologist please. He’s dismissing her pain and that’s horrible.
@ELI BEHNKEN exactly.
@@Asterix_Angel33 he’s not. He’s the one who was fucked up THE MOST by Monica.
@@Asterix_Angel33 dont dismiss his emontional pain
The fact that the amount of respect she has is so little. Why don’t she ever get “a good job Fiona , you did great” sentence. She deserves more thank she did for them
Yeah I dont understand how all of them can stand there listening to what Fiona did for them especially at such a young age and still treat her the way they did.
Fr-
That's life. The greatest heros take on thankless jobs.
In real life, it really does. We the eldest who put our life on stop, get our childhood taken away, so we can help our parents or making sure our siblings can have a better life, not worrying about anything, not knowing what harms the family…… this child will never get the respect she deserve. I am that child. No matter how much I did, nobody will appreciate me. I understand Fiona. And I hope all children whom their childhood get taken away, will get the life they deserve.
She did get a "good job Fiona" before she left :)
Frank's defeated "please" might be one of the realest moments in the whole series. He's deeply hurt, and he doesn't want to hear anymore because he knows Fiona is 100% right about everything.
Frank was the worst but he wasn’t stupid.
"She wasnt here, she was never fucking here. She left. I was nine. Nine. And taking care of you. Taking care of all of us."
I don't know if that's the song or their unbelievable acting, but I got chills fucking everywhere.
What's the song
Gracie Cooper part 3
@@nerdterritory1997 I think it’s more intense and emotional without the song.
@Sarah Taylor
« kill yourself » part III by suicideboy
It always breaks my heart when Frank says please. Emmy and William are awesome in this scene.
It’s Emmy not Emily
I'm so glad Fiona cut all ties/losses and ran. She deserved a fresh start more than any of them.
My dad grew up in a family where you didn't just leave, you ran...I have an uncle who moved to California & the family merely communicated through letters...my uncle even went as far as to say if any of them came to visit him, he wouldn't answer the door...he died about four years ago & my cousin found that out by accidently stumbling across his obituary online...we never even met him
God this is so heartbreaking. The scene is horribly tragic without the music but with it ... Oh man poor Fiona. I always feels so so bad for Fiona.
This shit is intense 😳 emmy's acting is fucking flawless!
“I was nine,nine, and taking care of you!” That hits hard.🥺
The more often I see the video the better the acting gets
I feel so bad for Frank. I mean he is finally realizing how much Monica fucked with him and how terrible she was to their kids. And Fiona, no words need to be said for her.
One of the best moments in the series
The acting was unbelievably realistic and you could hear the raw emotion in both of them
“ I’m glad she’s dead “ … when someone has really betrayed you you’re entire life , it’s a relief to know that they can no longer be around to do it . That’s the part I felt the most .. not bc u hate them but bc they are fucking dangerous to your soul . Loving them is a problem. When they die it’s the most disturbing and vile liberation u will ever feel in your life . I’ve been there .
Where is emmys Oscar award bc she’s amazing
God damn she is one hell of an actress, I literally cry EVERY time.
i never thought that Fiona's "YOU'RE MY MOTHER TOO!" I fucking bawled like baby, then this.
This will always be my favorite scene from shameless
His acting skills oh my god
Fiona never had a chance. Imagine someone being 9 years old and raising their siblings and taking care of their deadbeat father who never once helped them. If anything, he made their lives so much worse. She was never going to grow up into a well adjusted adult who made good choices. She needed serious help and instead she had to fight every single day to keep her and her family safe, alive, and loved (im excluding Frank from that). Her character is so well written and emotional and has so many layers to her personality.
she's so fucking gorgerous
“She was never here, She was never fuckin here! She left!” Gosh this scene hits so hard. She did absolutely amazing and all of the brothers and Debbie standing behind her watching. They’re all they had. This scene gets me every time I watch it. 🖤
Carl was the only one who was truly greatful for Fiona
Carl. Never ever ever lip
@@chanelguilty yeah sorry its just been awhile since ive watched the show😅
And i think also liam
Forrealll
Can I just say, they are FANTASTIC actors, like really...
Honestly, this is the defining scene of the entire series for me. There are great performances all throughout, but this gave the two pillars of the show the opportunity to just absolutely let it rip with their core motivations. No holds barred, just visceral, honest, ugly. Bravo.
I hate that he didn’t really give her the goodbye she deserved when she left their home ;-;
No a ir
Qoiepmi
Dp
Isń_8$
I felt like his goodbye meant a lot it was in his own messed up words she understood
Shameless breaks my heart, this show is such a tragedy in every fucking way possible. In its own sense it’s masterpiece.
With one word. William h. Macy is such a great actor. "Please". And everybody knows what a deep love he had for her.
the amount of times i re-watched this scene-
Lol that's all I'm doing and I havent even gotten to this ep! Lol I'm only on S3
@@UrFavReader i have not watched shamless yet XD lol
The funny thing is that these too actors are really close😂
This show still wrecks me to my core and also is my comfort show at the same time.
I never watched this show, but Emmy Rossum is such a good actress.
the way frank says please 🥹💔
“Enough” Im gonna sit here and cry, Goodbye-
Frank tearing up saying please is what really broke me I cry over this for days
Frank truly loved her this was the moment he realized what kind of person she was 💔
How has she not gotten an award
The raw emotion is amazing but what gets me is when the mask comes back up to be the strong woman she had to craft herself into.
“She didn’t love me and she didn’t love you.”
"If she loved us so much, why wasn't she here?"
That hits hard considering that my egg donor(she doesn't deserve to be called a mother) abandoned me. She steadily did the same thing to my younger sibling after she divorced my sibling's dad, but my sibling still has contact with her.
I refuse to reach out anymore because she can't own up to her mistakes. She abandoned me after I was two. I didn't even know or meet her until I was eleven. Didn't start fully seeing her again until I was thirteen and it was always ME having to ask when/if she was getting me for the weekend because sometimes she "didn't have enough gas money", but that was because she'd either get a new tattoo or party with her friends that same weekend.
She tried manipulating me into thinking my dad was a monster who took me away from her. She didn't take me to my sister's funeral(step sibling) or at the very least tell me when it was. She let my other stepsister beat me up(I was fifteen and stepsister was in her early twenties).
I was sexually harrassed at sixteen because she threw a party on one of the weekends I was there. She left to go to a bar with everyone and left me alone with two people around my age and a dude in his forties, who would not leave me alone and kept following me into every room.
After her divorce, at her new house, she made me sleep in the living room so her and her new bf's friend could have the spare bedroom.
I first broke contact at eighteen, but I reached out after getting pregnant at nineteen because I thought maybe she could change. I had a miscarriage and she never showed up to comfort me ONCE.
So I broke contact again and she somehow found my number. She sent me a picture of a tattoo she got representing MY child without my or my fiance's permission nonetheless.
I blocked her, but ended up unblocking her after getting drunk one night to send a drunk text, letting out everything I felt. Next day she had texted me back and was pissed. I apologized for texting her, but refused to apologize for what I had said because it was how I felt. Haven't heard from her since and I prefer to keep it that way because everytime she came back into my life, my mental and emotional health paid the price.
I'm so sorry thats happened to you ❤
What always breaks my heart is even with all the fucked up shit Frank does he was and still is the better parent, like he was really messed up but he never left them and he did help them in his own little way
This is too strong, I cant, You tell him Fiona!
0:25 I cry SO MUCH.
this hits closer to home than it should of.
no offence but i watched this last night when i was drunk and cried so fucking hard
I am offended.
Sydney P why would that be offensive?
Always watching shameless when I'm drunk and crying
@@desiree5916 they’re being sarcastic because there’s nothing offensive in the comment yet the commenter said “no offense”
This is heartbreaking, really !!
This was 2 years ago and Im still watching. This soooooo AWESOME SHAMELESS😳
I swear we need a mini-season with flashbacks of young Fiona and everyone and have the scene audio in the background showing us what happened.
this scene is really painful because i think it was the first time frank really realized who monica was, he was just too hurt to accept it
You can see it in Franks eyes that he was broken...once I heard him say "please" it broke me. He noticed how much Fiona does for him and everyone else...I have a feeling Frank didn't want to believe that Monica died...I've always felt bad for Frank
They had a lot of real moments on the show but for me this is #1
this scene is so sad i literally tear up everytime I watch it
Frank knew that what Fiona was saying was the truth but he didn't wanna face it because he was so in love with Monica or at least his idea of her. Love can blind you ones many flaws to which Monica had. Took this moment to finally make Frank realise what Monica was. A selfish woman that walked out on him and their kids and left a nine year old Fiona to pick up the pieces. That being said, it was somewhat satisfying to see someone finally get to Frank considering his part to play in the deterioration of his family.
When frank said “please” rlly made my heart shatter because he knew it was true but he didn’t want to say it because he was still in love with her frank I’d the best person ever when Fiona was drunk and fighting with lip when frank said “I couldn’t have done it without her” shoes that frank cares about Fiona also what’s the song for this
I really do sympathise with both of them in this because he lost the love of his life, sure they were fucked up but they loved each other in their own messed up way he needed to hear what fiona was telling him but it was still really painful
My friend recommended me this show, as I needed a new comedy show to binge and this is was not what I was expecting at all, the show is fantastic and the family dynamic is both beautiful and heartbreaking.
He knew Monica was horrible but he loved her he held on to that illusion
It is crazy how the gallagher family hated Frank. But despised Monica for everything that she did.
Sometimes I don't understand why people hate Fiona she tried so hard
I really wish Emmy returned in the last episode when frank was talking about all his kids they could’ve shown how Fiona’s doing now
STOP IM NOT EVEN AT THAT EPISODE YET AND IM CRYINGG
"She was a juncky and a drunk"
And this was 2 year's ago god OoO
This is the reality of our lives. We live in anger and hatred each day. We are hypocrite of our feelings
So heartbreaking ... the acting it's so good, touch my little black heart D:
I said the same about my own mom. I was glad she was gone. At least the BS was over. The drama and trauma was done. She couldn't hurt us anymore.
This song should’ve been apart of this scene it’s way more intense this way I only acknowledge this video
Agreed.
“She didnt love me. She didnt love u👁👄👁”
😂😂🤣🤣 feel bad for frank
u know what every child deserves parents but not every parent deserves a child
Fr imma just sit here and act like he didn’t say “She was a beautiful fragile woman”
Best acting from Emmy Rossum.
👏👏👏👏👏
Fiona gave so much of herself and got so little in return
Gotta feel bad for Frank. Had a mom that was screwed up, managed to straighten up his life for a bit but then Monica comes and threw it out of whack
1:28 the pain in her eyes 😭😭
my heart is broken💔
I fucking feel this pain man
Fiona deserve more then she could ever asked for I felt really bad when plip turn on her for a while after her spiral
She didn't love fiona or any of the kids . It was only guilt .
Superb piece of acting.
She should’ve got an Emmy.
Emmy Rossum’s acting was sublime on this show.
First time frank shown deep emotion
This seen makes me cry because I’ve had this exact conversation with my dad about himself.
I started crying listing to this it reminded me of my family but I got hurt not just taking care of my family 😥😖💔
I am so sorry
When frank say "please"..
Pain in her voice just making me sad :
What episode is This?
The acting in this scene is amazing
i think its 7x12
Omg. That show was so real. Wow.
frank really loved monica
Best scene ever.....
I was waiting for the beat to drop
After a few episodes I had to watch this w/o my S.O. cuz of the EXACT same issues he had growing up...to him...wasnt funny,....serious, he would go door 2 door, 2 get food 4 him & 3 bros. Wish this wasnt true. Emmy is FU(¥A₩SOME!!!!!) she deserves an EMMY, & ACADEMY!!!!.
Frank was in denial so bad
YES I live for this scene:O
i can relate to this becuase my mom left me when I was 6 and I was berley year 2 taking care of my siblings