Engrossing and thought provoking discussion ! It is always a pleasure to listen to Dr. Sahib - voice of reason in an otherwise polarised irrational and violent environment. Rightly observed, majority has a very skewed perception of corruption I have not seen a single person who is against any corruption or even plain felony which benefits him.
I disagree with many points made by Dr. Pervez. How can he assume that America has no interest to interfere in Pakistan? What about geographical and economics aspects lest political. Do you think Confessions of Economic Hitman are wrong ? We want Pakistan to have economic relations to alleviate poverty and that should come as an independent decision of the state, not dictated by any other country.
What has the US achieved by interfering in Pakistan? I am asking about the alleged recent interference. What has it gained really? Nothing. That answers your question.
@@soheil527 us has achieved what khan has achieved by being a taliban fan boy .May be Ok coming to the point, yes it is possible that the us has it's hands behind in the ouster of Khan but Khan's narrative of "pursuing an independent foreign policy which would first look after the welfare of the masses " is nothing more than a hollow rhetoric which actually resonated with the masses because of anti Americanism :something which pakistanis always had especially after the killing of osama bin laden. The anti Americanism among Pakistanis is not entirely unjustified either ;given the hypocritical nature of relationship it had with Pakistan, us has wronged Pakistan several times in several ways. But rather than those reasons it is owing to culture chauvinism that this sentiment resonates the most. The foreign policy which khan pursued was not that which "looked after the welfare of masses " but rather it looked after the xenophobic, chauvinist sentiments of the masses. And thus by fuelling jingoism, irrationality it is very easy to throw away the main issues in the bin and comfortably sit on pm chair undisturbed and uninterrupted for years. Correct me if I am wrong
@@LearnArabicwithTahir by installing their puppet government, Russian and Chinese projects will be hampered in pakistan ,which is not in interest of pakistan both in short and long run.
Pakistan badly needs Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy and people of his caliber, integrity and education to lead Pakistan for a very long time to make this country livable and proud.
@@islam-lightindark4048 kaha hai free.will pakistan mai ya islam mai?? Apostasy krne pe jail hoti hai aur logo ko pta chla tum mulhid tu zinda jla denge..
I saw his (IK) latest interview with Muzamil, Junaid and these guys asked beautiful and relevant questions but the answer were - religion, foreign policy, and Masiah complex and no counter questions. Hard time for Pakistan ahead coz both parties are worst.
@@fahadullahkhan6967 Yes they were linked that'why been asked, answer can still be given in shuttle manner irrespective avoiding them and giving irrational answers.
@@GG-ur4km IK didn't like those questions lol, the "leaked video" prior to overseas speech must have been a good lesson for Hum TV, Shan, Muzzamil and Junaid 😂😂😂
I actually thought they were very soft questions and obviously if they were to ask tough questions it was very easy for IK to say no, coz who wants to take an exam when they know they are going to fail. For Junaid and muzzamil it was an easy way to grow their own channels so why take the risk of asking tough questions, and i do not begrudge them for it.
I wouldn't make a big deal of it, I think that tends to happen with politicians especially a populist like IK, plus our people need to be told the same things many times in simple terms to make them think about them sort of like hashtags.
The basic premise in the discussion is faulty. Why does he think that America cannot interfere in our politics? If Americans have had interest in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, etc. why can't they have the same interest in Pakistan? I think the whole discussion becomes useless.
America is definitely intrested in Pakistan Because Pakistan has a on sale begairat army. Imran khan is also incompetent and useless But the worst problem is Pakistani public is jahil and religious and emotional ......Especially youthisa
Pakistan is biggest economy and world power America is facing direct threat and interfere. Every nation works for their own interest. Pakistani Muslims also try to influence elections where their number become slightly higher. They do same example Canada
@@Littlesparrow988 medam apko sach main lagata hai apke country ke baki leader USA ke sath mil gaye hai ? Kyonki imran khan russia gaya tha ? 1. Ye imran khan ullu bana raha hai , agar ges or oil chaie saste main to russia jane ki jarurat nahi thi , pass main iran ke pass she le lete jese , bharat leta tha 2018 she pahale saste main. 2. Agar ye baki mile hue hai to imran khan inke sath election kyo chahta hai ? 3. Imran khan khud currpted hai tosakhana le lie .
Suzuki GSXFA Exactly...Iss mulk mai insaan ki qadar tab ki jati hai...jab woh insaan marr jata hai...Imran Khan ki qadar tab aye gi jab woh iss duniya mai nahi rahay ga...
After starting to watch Mr. Hoodbhoy, I so badly want to learn Urdu to understand his every word. Fortunately I understand Hindi, so because of the contextual understanding I extrapolate to understand the full message.
Ignorance among bigoted religious extremists is understandable, but not unforgivable. *But ignorance, hatred of one's own history and bigotry among the intellectuals among Pakistani intellectuals is not understandable.* Even a good intellectual like Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy never mentions the historical, literary, linguistic, scientific and philosophical achievements of India, which includes current Pakistan. *Pakistan should stop suppressing its own languages and heritage.*
بھائی صاحب معزرت کے ساتھ آخر تک میزبان صاحب کے سوالات سن کر سمجھ نہیں آئی کہ یہ پروگرام انگلش میں تھا یا اردو میں؟ پتہ نہیں یہ محکومیت بھرا رویہ کب ھماری جان چھوڑے گا
@@emue229 i am talking about this particular conversation. If you have listened this whole convo, come up with one point that was logical. He, himself is contradicting his own statements.
Freedom of speech and expression is what is why they prefer to stay living in the Western World I'm As a Senior Citizen of Pakistan Fail to understand what makes Professor Pervaiz Hoodboy to think that IMRAN KHAN LEADER WITH A HEART AND AVISION is guilty of calling riyasat medina but As I know him he is a humble servant of God and believe in fundamental Right of human values and democratic norms he has cofessedtohave failed in Established rule of Law and then the social justice which are the prerequisite for the democracy and uphold of the Constitution of Pakistan but still struggling to carry forward his project from his first tenure
I really respect and value Dr. Hoodbhoy. But on this I disagree with him. I support IK because I think he is honest with Pakistan as well. Though he has made a lot of mistakes and became more religious than I thought he would but still he is the only genuine option for Pakistan. Others are not even an option
JUDGE GENERAL -JAHILIYYA are the Magic words behind the failure of today's Pakistan systematically reduced to a banana republic and it's no other than the present unpopular and inhuman regime of today's Pakistan
This would suggest that dr Pervaiz Hoodboy feeling comfortable with the property tycoons who are living in their comfort zones with out feeling concerned about the man on the streets of Pakistan
SikanderG I know about her...you don't need to tell me that...she’s the daughter of Sita White and a British Film director...she’s not IK’s daughter...
🎉 Don't Pervaiz Hood Bhoy think whatever happening in Gaza is not oppression and State of Israe is on the wrong side of history.. Very Right whhen Dr condemned Corruption & Mismanagement . Jinnah sb saying in his last days in Ziyarat when asked about his death he simply remarked I'll be happy if God Almighty say to Well Done Jinnah..
Meny Parvez hoodbhoy sahb ko boht goor k sath suna ovr ab me es nateejy pr puhcha k sir ko khan sahb sy koi koi zaaatii jalan hai jis ki buniyaad pr es trh sy bat kr rahy hain. Sir app ko pataa hoga k jahaan law k merits hain to sath me demrits b hain. Khan sahb insaan hain zaroor un me khamiyaaan hongi lekin app khoobiyoun ko q mis kr jaty hain.? App ny ek baat ki k Imran khan play boy rahy hain to sir kia insaan hamesha ek jesa rehta hai?? Kia us me wakt k sath badlao nh aaata??
ڈاکٹر صاحب، مان لیا کہ سیاستدان کرپٹ ہیں۔ لیکن اس سسٹم میں رہتے ہوئے ہمیں ان کو تسلیم کرنا ہو گا۔ اگر سسٹم کو چھوڑنا ہے تو پھر متبادل کیا ہے؟؟ تو لوگوں کو سسٹم کے اندر رہ کر کوشش کرنی چاہیے اور آئین کی سربلندی ماننی چاہیے۔ ساتھ ساتھ ووٹ کے ذریعے صفائی کریں۔ شکریہ
As for as my knowledge is concerned, Bhutto changed a little bit at the bottom level such as private companies’ sector and land were custodies under Government but he couldn't succeed because of mindset, we are brainwashed due to a lack of education.
Parvez Sahab, Aap Jaise motabar log bhi Kitani bhi Koshish kar Len, jis Islamic jahalat Ki ibadat Har khas O aam kar rahaa Hai usaka nateejaa Kisi haal Nahin Badal sakta. Jab tak Pakistan kee maassom awaam Ko Islam Ki khudkush jahalat se baahar nahin nikala jaegaa, is masle ka koi hal Nahin, kaum ka koi mustaqbil Nahin.
Not agreeing with you sir. He may be a clever politician but he atleast tried to solve the problems which many politicians ignored for many years. May he come with two 3rd majority and solve the problems which he coulnd't in allied govt.
Na sirf upper class or middle class but lower class b Khan sahb k sath khary hwy hain.. Khaan sahb ek sacha leader hai. Ye mulk agr peechhy rah gayaa to reason sirf fooj hai. Es mulk ko fooj ny jakraa huwa hai ovr fooj ko America control krta hai. nijaaat agr dilwani hai to sirf fooj sy dilwao..
Sir, you are my idol and i want people like you in india, in league with APJ Kalam, our former president who wanted indian children to get Modern science and technology. Sir, I think that Pakistan needs you more than india. Sir keep your good work going. I am a Post graduate doctor Medicine 💊💉 and will be happy to meet you personally in Pakistan if I came to Pakistan.
Not that uncommon banning book always makes them more popular. I've met quite a few Pakistanis in Islamabad and Karachi who have translated or english copies of the Satanic Verses.
While I like Hoodbhoy, I am unsure how much weight to give his political analysis, especially when Imran Khan is incorrectly lumped together with all the other proven crooks of Pakistani politics. Sure, Imran is too Islamic and in the long run this will be bad for Pakistan, but might be better than the mess that has existed for decades. Imran does have “established” politicians in his party. At the same time, Imran Khan is also less corrupt and more willing to stand up to the corruption and tyranny of the establishment. Whether one agrees with his politics or tactics, we have to acknowledge that he is less corrupt and willing to fight for what he believes in. We should not lump him together with others.
Brilliant and thought provoking analysis, Dr Hoodbhoy is a living legend, full of wisdom and a Great Intellectual! Alas people of Pakistan don't recognize his worth.
Posts of Arabic teachers were created but no recruitment has taken place. These teachers will not be madrasa students but at least BA Bed with Arabic as major.
USA trled its best to convert Afghanistan into a peaceful and democratic country. When Imran Khan was the PM, Pakistan used to give shelter to the Taliban. When the Americans withdrew from Afghanisthan, the Pakistan army helped the Taliban to conquer Afghanistan. Imran Khan thought that the Taliban will help Pakistan and attack Kashmir This did nit happen and the Taliban turned against Pakistan. Imran's policy failed compketely so the army stopped supporting Iman. Imran had been made PM by the army through the back door. Hence when he followed tge wrong policies tge army got rid if Imran.
Exactly...Iss mulk mai insaan ki qadar tab ki jati hai...jab woh insaan marr jata hai...Imran Khan ki qadar tab aye gi jab woh iss duniya mai nahi rahay ga...
Main problems of Pakistan 1 70 percent black economy 2 very little tax collection 3 not following fundamental principles of Islam like living simple life, being good human 4 corruption 5 poor education system. 6 intolerance 7 bad mental and physical health 8 multiple wrong ideologies 9 secretarinam, provincialism. 10 interference of departments in affairs of other departments 11 might is right and no rule of law 12 lack of personality development, grooming
Why do Pakistani academics have to comment on subjects they know nothing about, they should stay out of politics and concentrate on their speciality, perhaps they will achieve some international recognition.
ASA Pakistani intellectual, professor, and highly educated person, he has every right to express his opinions. Instead of criticising him, you could have expressed your opinion also, instead of blatantly condemning him. We would also paid attention to you. We like Hoodbhoy and he is a fountain of knowledge and wisdom.
@@malikahmad8170 He has a right to his views but he has to decide if he is a political commentator or an academic. You cannot mix quantum mechanics with politics. There is a YT video of him circulating where is giving his views to a Turkish TV channel as a 'security expert' on PK!
@@rmzk1783 who makes such determination? You? The faugis, the mullas, the bureaucrats, businessmen, and the illiterate landlord, who never tilled a piece of land--all can discuss and join politics, but a professor cannot join? Great judgement?
@@soheil527 I am sure you have a sound basis for your opposition, which I would request to give details instead of just generalised “Hindu-Shia interest”. We would wait for such details.
I agree with everything Hoodhboy is saying here except the socialism/communism thing. I think socialism/communism has been actively harmful in Pakistan.
Sir please read the books : Hasis Adaray..... Butto Zia Aur Mein... Aur Line Cut Gai... But America has had influenced Pakistan in a variety of ways...
Doctor Shb khan ny American k sath country to country level per eqaul level ki baat krta hy na k unki batain maan kr unki policey ko apny country k liay adopt krain
Engrossing and thought provoking discussion ! It is always a pleasure to listen to Dr. Sahib - voice of reason in an otherwise polarised irrational and violent environment. Rightly observed, majority has a very skewed perception of corruption
I have not seen a single person who is against any corruption or even plain felony which benefits him.
I disagree with many points made by Dr. Pervez. How can he assume that America has no interest to interfere in Pakistan? What about geographical and economics aspects lest political. Do you think Confessions of Economic Hitman are wrong ? We want Pakistan to have economic relations to alleviate poverty and that should come as an independent decision of the state, not dictated by any other country.
What has the US achieved by interfering in Pakistan? I am asking about the alleged recent interference. What has it gained really? Nothing. That answers your question.
@@LearnArabicwithTahir What has the US achieved by interfering in afghanistan, iraq or in ukraine? are you trolling or just acting smart?
@@soheil527 us has achieved what khan has achieved by being a taliban fan boy .May be
Ok coming to the point, yes it is possible that the us has it's hands behind in the ouster of Khan but Khan's narrative of "pursuing an independent foreign policy which would first look after the welfare of the masses " is nothing more than a hollow rhetoric which actually resonated with the masses because of anti Americanism :something which pakistanis always
had especially after the killing of osama bin laden. The anti Americanism among Pakistanis is not entirely unjustified either ;given the hypocritical nature of relationship it had with Pakistan, us has wronged Pakistan several times in several ways.
But rather than those reasons it is owing to culture chauvinism that this sentiment resonates the most. The foreign policy which khan pursued was not that which "looked after the welfare of masses " but rather it looked after the xenophobic, chauvinist sentiments of the masses. And thus by fuelling jingoism, irrationality it is very easy to throw away the main issues in the bin and comfortably sit on pm chair undisturbed and uninterrupted for years.
Correct me if I am wrong
@@LearnArabicwithTahir by installing their puppet government, Russian and Chinese projects will be hampered in pakistan ,which is not in interest of pakistan both in short and long run.
@@aimgoal2453 now that the puppet govt (as you seem to think) is in power? Has the chinese CPEC project been hampered? A big No.
Pakistan badly needs Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy and people of his caliber, integrity and education to lead Pakistan for a very long time to make this country livable and proud.
unless islam remains the identity and priority of pakistan, people like dr hoodboy will be a critically endangered species..
@@byron-ih2ge bilkul thik kaha is liye mai ne islam apni Zindagi se nikal diya
@@huzaifa2369 😂Acha yeh kehne ki zarorat nahi .Aphki free will hai
@@huzaifa2369 best decison ever
@@islam-lightindark4048 kaha hai free.will pakistan mai ya islam mai?? Apostasy krne pe jail hoti hai aur logo ko pta chla tum mulhid tu zinda jla denge..
What a great man. Full of wisdom. One of the very few sane voices in Pakistan
I saw his (IK) latest interview with Muzamil, Junaid and these guys asked beautiful and relevant questions but the answer were - religion, foreign policy, and Masiah complex and no counter questions. Hard time for Pakistan ahead coz both parties are worst.
@@fahadullahkhan6967 Yes they were linked that'why been asked, answer can still be given in shuttle manner irrespective avoiding them and giving irrational answers.
@@GG-ur4km IK didn't like those questions lol, the "leaked video" prior to overseas speech must have been a good lesson for Hum TV, Shan, Muzzamil and Junaid 😂😂😂
I actually thought they were very soft questions and obviously if they were to ask tough questions it was very easy for IK to say no, coz who wants to take an exam when they know they are going to fail. For Junaid and muzzamil it was an easy way to grow their own channels so why take the risk of asking tough questions, and i do not begrudge them for it.
I wouldn't make a big deal of it, I think that tends to happen with politicians especially a populist like IK, plus our people need to be told the same things many times in simple terms to make them think about them sort of like hashtags.
آپ کی بہت مہربانی کہ ہمیں عمران خان کی اصلیت بتا دی. لیکن ہم کیا کریں ہم پھر بھی عمران کہ سپورٹر ہیں.
Finally sir you have come to discuss .. thanks 😊.. If possible sir , I want to meet you Dr. Hoodbhoy.. love u ❤ from 🇮🇳
Don't worry he will finally return o his beloved country India once he is done with the task given to him by RAW.
@@subwaymirdif what a nonsense comment... everything is not possible from religion in this world. Try to accept this reality.
आसमानी किताब वाले कभी नही सुधरेंगे
@@subwaymirdif such an ignorant comment
@@sayandevchowdhury3684
RAW should understand this.
The basic premise in the discussion is faulty. Why does he think that America cannot interfere in our politics? If Americans have had interest in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, etc. why can't they have the same interest in Pakistan?
I think the whole discussion becomes useless.
America is definitely intrested in Pakistan
Because Pakistan has a on sale begairat army.
Imran khan is also incompetent and useless
But the worst problem is
Pakistani public is jahil and religious and emotional
......Especially youthisa
They interfare by direct attack and not by other politician .
Pakistan is biggest economy and world power America is facing direct threat and interfere. Every nation works for their own interest. Pakistani Muslims also try to influence elections where their number become slightly higher. They do same example Canada
@@audiblebooksvideo7340 Nuclear Powers cannot fight directly now. Read The Confessions of Economic Hitman to catch real facts
@@Littlesparrow988 medam apko sach main lagata hai apke country ke baki leader USA ke sath mil gaye hai ? Kyonki imran khan russia gaya tha ?
1. Ye imran khan ullu bana raha hai , agar ges or oil chaie saste main to russia jane ki jarurat nahi thi , pass main iran ke pass she le lete jese , bharat leta tha 2018 she pahale saste main.
2. Agar ye baki mile hue hai to imran khan inke sath election kyo chahta hai ?
3. Imran khan khud currpted hai tosakhana le lie .
یہ بات پریشان کن ہے کہ ایک ایسے فسطائی دور کا آغاز ہو جسکا ختم ہونا ممکن نہ رہے۔
P.Hoodhbhoy is right on track and insightful to point out that IK is the most dangerous person for Pakistan.
He is dangerous because he tells the truth
Suzuki GSXFA Exactly...Iss mulk mai insaan ki qadar tab ki jati hai...jab woh insaan marr jata hai...Imran Khan ki qadar tab aye gi jab woh iss duniya mai nahi rahay ga...
@@anoushamudassar7001 easy tiger 🐅 you sound like you're threatening him. My statement was from a U2 song 🎵
Are you able to find those references Hoodbhoy gave? Specifically where IK and his opinion on Pakistani Christians?
Such an insightful discussion
Thank you professor and thank you
Nawfal
After starting to watch Mr. Hoodbhoy, I so badly want to learn Urdu to understand his every word. Fortunately I understand Hindi, so because of the contextual understanding I extrapolate to understand the full message.
Imran Khan is not a politician... he is a revolutionary
He is zero in everything.
From where Revolutionary? Please explain. Tks
Ignorance among bigoted religious extremists is understandable, but not unforgivable. *But ignorance, hatred of one's own history and bigotry among the intellectuals among Pakistani intellectuals is not understandable.* Even a good intellectual like Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy never mentions the historical, literary, linguistic, scientific and philosophical achievements of India, which includes current Pakistan. *Pakistan should stop suppressing its own languages and heritage.*
بھائی صاحب معزرت کے ساتھ آخر تک میزبان صاحب کے سوالات سن کر سمجھ نہیں آئی کہ یہ پروگرام انگلش میں تھا یا اردو میں؟
پتہ نہیں یہ محکومیت بھرا رویہ کب ھماری جان چھوڑے گا
The nation is blessed with an honest leader, we must try not to lose him.
One of the most sensible Pakistani citizen, Dr. Hoodbhoy and the enlightened host..
He surely is but sorry to say in this sitting all his arguments are vague and illogical.
@@knownstranger999 Hoodbhoy is always logical. The only Pakistani with sane brain
@@emue229 i am talking about this particular conversation. If you have listened this whole convo, come up with one point that was logical. He, himself is contradicting his own statements.
Ayega imran lootega poora pakistan Somalia banega pakistan.
Pehle doller 250 paar inshallah
We love you imran Khan from india
Freedom of speech and expression is what is why they prefer to stay living in the Western World I'm As a Senior Citizen of Pakistan Fail to understand what makes Professor Pervaiz Hoodboy to think that IMRAN KHAN LEADER WITH A HEART AND AVISION is guilty of calling riyasat medina but As I know him he is a humble servant of God and believe in fundamental Right of human values and democratic norms he has cofessedtohave failed in Established rule of Law and then the social justice which are the prerequisite for the democracy and uphold of the Constitution of Pakistan but still struggling to carry forward his project from his first tenure
Good insights about governance. Again my fav professor
25:40 just a correction , tosha khane wale case m corruption sabit nhi h, usne tosha khane se legally liye h, 15% price day k legally buy kiye h
I really respect and value Dr. Hoodbhoy. But on this I disagree with him. I support IK because I think he is honest with Pakistan as well. Though he has made a lot of mistakes and became more religious than I thought he would but still he is the only genuine option for Pakistan. Others are not even an option
JUDGE GENERAL -JAHILIYYA are the Magic words behind the failure of today's Pakistan systematically reduced to a banana republic and it's no other than the present unpopular and inhuman regime of today's Pakistan
Dr Saab love your sense of humor...
Anyway he is the King of the blind
You mean andho main kana raja? Righty said
This would suggest that dr Pervaiz Hoodboy feeling comfortable with the property tycoons who are living in their comfort zones with out feeling concerned about the man on the streets of Pakistan
Lol. Kush hamdeed. Indeed. Just because you don't believe in God you cannot bring yourself to wish someone peace
Thanks Dr. Sahib for highlighting truth about a crook like Imran Niazi.
You are most likely corrupt supporting corrupt !!
Perwaz Hood Bhaai RABBUL izzat aapko shaad abaad rakkhe.
Dr Pervez Sir, I agree with you and progressive minds like you on both sides are needed.
Jai Jhulelal Sain 🌹
Sir, IMRAN KHAN is not rigid or religion fantastic
Pervez Hoodboy is one of the few sane voices in the Indian subcontinent.
is he better than your hindu dharmgurus who preach to rape muslim girls?
Ew
He is Pakistani
@@farazlaghari3785 Pakistan is in Indian subcontinent. Haha 😂
@@ankitsen1998 oh yeah that was mostly ruled by muslims
Imran khan, during his reign played religion card and american card and did nothing.
Facts
Straight forward person i respect you
No this piece is not straight forward.
I have been left with many unanswered questions... Giving it a thumbs down. 👎👎
@@0786AHA it is upto you. i always respect regarding his clear and logical opinion about our real problem so i cant thumb down
@@0786AHA his opinion is unbiased.
@@0786AHA listen his ending notes.
I can't get over the fact that IK has an illegitimate child whom he abandoned. This has affected me somehow.
It may be more you may find more in his family as well.
Lol...he doesn't have an illegitimate child...woh case jeet chuka tha...
@@anoushamudassar7001 He does. Tyrian White. Look it up.
SikanderG I know about her...you don't need to tell me that...she’s the daughter of Sita White and a British Film director...she’s not IK’s daughter...
@@anoushamudassar7001 The court in U. S. declared IK as father of Seeta white's daughter. Please don't act as an Ostrich.
I wanted to hear from Mr. Hoodbhoy but I must say audio was not up to the mark.
Yes I was waiting for this! Good to see you again professor
🎉 Don't Pervaiz Hood Bhoy think whatever happening in Gaza is not oppression and State of Israe is on the wrong side of history.. Very Right whhen Dr condemned Corruption & Mismanagement . Jinnah sb saying in his last days in Ziyarat when asked about his death he simply remarked I'll be happy if God Almighty say to Well Done Jinnah..
Dr Parvez Hoodbhoy zindabad
"Buying an Election" isn't that a well-defined problem, he picked the issues that give most votes for least effort.
Absolutely right
Sir
Dr Hoodhoy is wise, insightful and humorous as well.
Pervez Hoodhbhoy sahib, I am your fan. You are one of the bests.
Iss mulk mai insaan ki qadar tab ki jati hai...jab woh insaan marr jata hai...Imran Khan ki qadar tab aye gi jab woh iss duniya mai nahi rahay ga...
Meny Parvez hoodbhoy sahb ko boht goor k sath suna ovr ab me es nateejy pr puhcha k sir ko khan sahb sy koi koi zaaatii jalan hai jis ki buniyaad pr es trh sy bat kr rahy hain.
Sir app ko pataa hoga k jahaan law k merits hain to sath me demrits b hain. Khan sahb insaan hain zaroor un me khamiyaaan hongi lekin app khoobiyoun ko q mis kr jaty hain.?
App ny ek baat ki k Imran khan play boy rahy hain to sir kia insaan hamesha ek jesa rehta hai?? Kia us me wakt k sath badlao nh aaata??
SIR YOU ARE RIGHT BUT YA SOCIETY ITNA SACH NHI SUN SAKTI GREAT GREAT GREAT WORK, BIG FAN OF YOURS!
Proud of you sir!
Excellent analysis 👏 👍
ڈاکٹر صاحب، مان لیا کہ سیاستدان کرپٹ ہیں۔ لیکن اس سسٹم میں رہتے ہوئے ہمیں ان کو تسلیم کرنا ہو گا۔ اگر سسٹم کو چھوڑنا ہے تو پھر متبادل کیا ہے؟؟ تو لوگوں کو سسٹم کے اندر رہ کر کوشش کرنی چاہیے اور آئین کی سربلندی ماننی چاہیے۔ ساتھ ساتھ ووٹ کے ذریعے صفائی کریں۔ شکریہ
Sir please voice quality theek Kar lain, mic 🎤 qareeb Kar ke lagaein. Awaz bohat halki aa rahi ha
Excellent analysis
Would a Secular society accept the freedom of speech and expression and religious beliefs
Imran khan himself didn't give position to an Ahmadi economis because Mullahs made a huge hue and cry.
As for as my knowledge is concerned, Bhutto changed a little bit at the bottom level such as private companies’ sector and land were custodies under Government but he couldn't succeed because of mindset, we are brainwashed due to a lack of education.
For the benefit of those outside pakistan please post the references for the points on which Dr Hoodbhoy bases his conclusions on Imran Khan.
Hypocrisy of imran khan is another level...
I really love Hoodbhoy saahab, he is the true scientist of our country. I feel proud of him. God bless you sir
pakistan k ley socho for great cause.imran khan ka muksad great hy
Any one whose Roots are among the public
Imran Khan Niyazi is alone enough to destroy Pakistan.
You are very great Sir.
Parvez Sahab,
Aap Jaise motabar log bhi Kitani bhi Koshish kar Len, jis Islamic jahalat Ki ibadat Har khas O aam kar rahaa Hai usaka nateejaa Kisi haal Nahin Badal sakta.
Jab tak Pakistan kee maassom awaam Ko Islam Ki khudkush jahalat se baahar nahin nikala jaegaa, is masle ka koi hal Nahin, kaum ka koi mustaqbil Nahin.
Yes . As he has leda zigzag life himself with lies in abundance, he misleads all .
Not agreeing with you sir. He may be a clever politician but he atleast tried to solve the problems which many politicians ignored for many years. May he come with two 3rd majority and solve the problems which he coulnd't in allied govt.
Na sirf upper class or middle class but lower class b Khan sahb k sath khary hwy hain..
Khaan sahb ek sacha leader hai. Ye mulk agr peechhy rah gayaa to reason sirf fooj hai. Es mulk ko fooj ny jakraa huwa hai ovr fooj ko America control krta hai. nijaaat agr dilwani hai to sirf fooj sy dilwao..
So what is the alternative to IK? The Shareef brothers? Or zardari ?
Sir, you are my idol and i want people like you in india, in league with APJ Kalam, our former president who
wanted indian children to get
Modern science and technology.
Sir, I think that Pakistan needs you more than india. Sir keep your good work going. I am a Post graduate doctor Medicine 💊💉 and will be happy to meet you personally in
Pakistan if I came to Pakistan.
Sir what is wrong if Imran Khan advocates that Pakistan should take its decision independently and in the best country's interest.
First you debit than ask about free policy 🙂
In my opinion IK advocate Progressive Islam in that ALL non Muslim should be allowed to live As per their Culture an religious beliefs
Excellent subject
Great Analysis Sir 👍
Good to see you Professor
Start watching this interview from 8:06
Then you will find out why he has this point of view.
Nice to see a book by Richard Dawkins on the shelf. God Delusion maybe? But also surprised because I thought such books would be banned in Pakistan .
Not that uncommon banning book always makes them more popular. I've met quite a few Pakistanis in Islamabad and Karachi who have translated or english copies of the Satanic Verses.
@@Fahimkhan-wr7qs do u wana get lynched lol??
@@Fahimkhan-wr7qs can download it for free on internet in pdf form. its also alavaible in audio book form on youtube in urdu language.
@@o........8793 I think you mean pdf form.....typographical error it seems.
@@anujay81 yes i correct it :)
While I like Hoodbhoy, I am unsure how much weight to give his political analysis, especially when Imran Khan is incorrectly lumped together with all the other proven crooks of Pakistani politics. Sure, Imran is too Islamic and in the long run this will be bad for Pakistan, but might be better than the mess that has existed for decades. Imran does have “established” politicians in his party. At the same time, Imran Khan is also less corrupt and more willing to stand up to the corruption and tyranny of the establishment. Whether one agrees with his politics or tactics, we have to acknowledge that he is less corrupt and willing to fight for what he believes in. We should not lump him together with others.
Brilliant and thought provoking analysis, Dr Hoodbhoy is a living legend, full of wisdom and a Great Intellectual! Alas people of Pakistan don't recognize his worth.
Plz don't be too emotional .
Governing System what really matter
No sir he may have flaws but he is the only hope for Pakistan
Don't talk about what imran was talk about what he is.
Posts of Arabic teachers were created but no recruitment has taken place. These teachers will not be madrasa students but at least BA Bed with Arabic as major.
i know very well how these teachers are going to be well versed in Arabic 😂😂🤣🤣.
@@anordinaryman3885 even if they what will they achieve.
@@GG-ur4km not much ,teaching modern Arabic in Pakistan for masses(most of us r not even interested ) is next to impossible.
You should have ended on an optimistic note. There is hope IMO. In fact I know things will get better.
They every now and then optimistic word using “inshalla”, according to Hindu if any Muslims used this word that never going to happen.😬
USA trled its best to convert Afghanistan into a peaceful and democratic country. When Imran Khan was the PM, Pakistan used to give shelter to the Taliban. When the Americans withdrew from Afghanisthan, the Pakistan army helped the Taliban to conquer Afghanistan. Imran Khan thought that the Taliban will help Pakistan and attack Kashmir This did nit happen and the Taliban turned against Pakistan. Imran's policy failed compketely so the army stopped supporting Iman. Imran had been made PM by the army through the back door. Hence when he followed tge wrong policies tge army got rid if Imran.
P.Hoodbhoy is physics scientist as well as good political scientist also.😊😊.
If this is misleading then V Want To be More Misleading ....
He is Love ...
My Captain ❣️❣️
Hail Captain U-Turn. Support U-Turn. When you go out to vote take a U-Turn.
Begairat youthia burger
سبحان اللہ مطمئن ۔۔۔۔۔۔
Exactly...Iss mulk mai insaan ki qadar tab ki jati hai...jab woh insaan marr jata hai...Imran Khan ki qadar tab aye gi jab woh iss duniya mai nahi rahay ga...
@@anoushamudassar7001 Please ask him to leave so that you can respect him.
Main problems of Pakistan 1 70 percent black economy 2 very little tax collection 3 not following fundamental principles of Islam like living simple life, being good human 4 corruption 5 poor education system. 6 intolerance 7 bad mental and physical health 8 multiple wrong ideologies 9 secretarinam, provincialism. 10 interference of departments in affairs of other departments 11 might is right and no rule of law 12 lack of personality development, grooming
Good effort of our dear bro and scientist
Great analysis!
Why do Pakistani academics have to comment on subjects they know nothing about, they should stay out of politics and concentrate on their speciality, perhaps they will achieve some international recognition.
ASA Pakistani intellectual, professor, and highly educated person, he has every right to express his opinions. Instead of criticising him, you could have expressed your opinion also, instead of blatantly condemning him. We would also paid attention to you. We like Hoodbhoy and he is a fountain of knowledge and wisdom.
@@malikahmad8170 He has a right to his views but he has to decide if he is a political commentator or an academic. You cannot mix quantum mechanics with politics. There is a YT video of him circulating where is giving his views to a Turkish TV channel as a 'security expert' on PK!
@@rmzk1783 who makes such determination? You? The faugis, the mullas, the bureaucrats, businessmen, and the illiterate landlord, who never tilled a piece of land--all can discuss and join politics, but a professor cannot join? Great judgement?
he is good for nothing professor acting as an intellectual promoted by hindu- shias interests
@@soheil527 I am sure you have a sound basis for your opposition, which I would request to give details instead of just generalised “Hindu-Shia interest”. We would wait for such details.
Imran Khan is great leader
Public knows you too well hoodbhoy, keep trying.
I agree with everything Hoodhboy is saying here except the socialism/communism thing. I think socialism/communism has been actively harmful in Pakistan.
He also condemned it, you did not pay attention.
He also condemned it bro
Asking a doctor to build a bridge because he is educated..
Perfect......Imram is a cricketer.....usko PM bana diya.....too much fun
Unhe jana unhe mana na rahaka ger se kam lillahil hamd me dünya se musalman veya💖🌹
Great sir
🖤🖤🖤
Sir please read the books : Hasis Adaray..... Butto Zia Aur Mein... Aur Line Cut Gai...
But America has had influenced Pakistan in a variety of ways...
Governance is not a game of cricket:Col. Sato; camp commander in the Bridge on the River Kiwaii.
How to get rid of Fitnah Khan?
👍
Doctor Shb khan ny American k sath country to country level per eqaul level ki baat krta hy na k unki batain maan kr unki policey ko apny country k liay adopt krain
Doctor Shb total farigh bandy hn in ki as science teacher hun respect krty hn